Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we...

49
Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University of Houston UH Law School October 16 th , 2019

Transcript of Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we...

Page 1: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Glacial Change in Antarctica:How we know and what we might

do about it

Julia Wellner

Earth & Atmospheric Sciences

University of Houston

UH Law School October 16th, 2019

Page 2: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Plan

• Antarctic basics

• Who am I and what do I do?

• Thwaites Glacier– How it’s changing

– How do we know

• Geo-Engineering of ice sheets

Page 3: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

3

Page 4: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Sea level would rise about 70 m

– many of the world's large population centers would be flooded

What would happen if all glaciers melted?

Page 5: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Where is all that ice?

~65 m is in

Antarctica

Page 6: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

~65 m is in

Antarctica

Where is all that ice?

Page 7: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Antarctica: Highest Continent

Page 8: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Antarctica: Highest Continent

Page 9: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Antarctic Temperature Change

Page 10: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Mass balance is what counts, not temperature anyway

Rignot et al., 2008

Measurements

from:

•SAR

Interferometry

•GRACE

Page 11: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Ice Behavior is Controlled by Water (2 of 3 ways in Antarctica)

11

Page 12: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

The WAIS, and Peninsula Ice Cap, are:

•Grounded below sea level

•On a Foredeepened shelf

•Many areas have ice shelves

Marine-based Ice

Page 13: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Plan

• Antarctic basics

• Who am I and what do I do?

• Thwaites Glacier– How it’s changing

– How do we know

• Geo-Engineering of ice sheets

Page 14: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Quickly: What do I do?

R/V Mishipeshu University of Houston

Page 15: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

15Different Scale

Page 16: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do?

16

Page 17: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Core on sunny days

17Photo by Y. Muñoz (2010)

Page 18: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Core on cold days

18

Photo by K. Gavahan (2012)

Page 19: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Core Repository

19

Page 20: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Seismic

20

(2005)

Page 21: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Multibeam Swath Bathymetry

21

(2002)

Page 22: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Collaborate with ocean and bio teams

22CTD Photo by Y. Muñoz (2010)

Kimberly Mead

Yuribia Muñoz with Amy Leventer

Page 23: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? GPS (rebound)

23Photos by Y. Muñoz (2010)

Page 24: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Go Ashore in Small Boats (cheaper than helo)

24

(2012)

(1998)

Page 25: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Date Sediments

25

Gamma-ray spectrometry to measure 210Pb, 137Cs, other

Page 26: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

What do we do? Sediment size, shape, texture

26

Small conchoidalfractures

Dish-shaped concavitity

Page 27: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Geology, but highly interdisciplinaryW

elln

er, e

t al

., 2

01

9

Page 28: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

28

Page 29: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Plan

• Antarctic basics

• Who am I and what do I do?

• Thwaites Glacier– How it’s changing

– How do we know

• Geo-Engineering of ice sheets

Page 30: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

• Antarctica may contribute up to 1meter to global mean sea level (GMSL) in this century*.

• More data is required from Thwaites Glacier to improve predictive climate models.

30* Based on DeConto and Pollard, 2016

Future of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet

Modeled Scenarios of Antarctic Contribution to GMSL

EAIS

WAISAmundsen

Sea

Ross Sea

Weddell Sea

WAIS: West Antarctic Ice SheetEAIS: East Antarctic Ice Sheet

1000 km

Page 31: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

31* Based on DeConto and Pollard, 2016

Future of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet

Ross Sea

Weddell Sea

Amundsen Sea

• Antarctica may contribute up to 1meter to global mean sea level (GMSL) in this century*.

• More data is required from Thwaites Glacier to improve predictive climate models.

Modeled Scenarios of Antarctic Contribution to GMSL

EAIS

WAIS: West Antarctic Ice SheetEAIS: East Antarctic Ice Sheet

Thwaites Glacier Catchment

1000 km

Page 32: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Marine Ice Sheets, Stability, Instability, and Sediments

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 33: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Thwaites Glacier

Amundsen Sea

https://thwaitesglacieroffshoreresearch.org/

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

THwaites Offshore Research

Page 34: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Stability is dependent on…•Atmospheric conditions

•Oceanographic changes

•Bed topography

Warm, saline Circumpolar Deep Water

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 35: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Need to reconstruct glacier position using sedimentary facies and age modeling.

Warm, saline Circumpolar Deep Water

When did Thwaites lift off pinning points?

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 36: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Glacial Marine Depositional Model

Model adapted from Kirshner et al., 2012; Hillenbrand et al., 2013; Smith et al., 2017

Coarse-grained,Poorly sorted ornormal grading

Grounding ZoneProximal

1

Seasonally Open Marine

Diatomaceous, silty clayLarger clasts (ice rafting)

3

Sub-Ice Shelf

Laminated silty clay

2

12 3

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 37: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

2019 Field Season in the Amundsen Sea

Research Vessel/Ice BreakerNathaniel B. Palmer

Map of ship track, ice imagery, & preexisting bathymetry near Thwaites Glacier.

Ship Track

Thwaites Ice Shelf

Amundsen Sea

Thwaites

Ph

oto

: Jam

es K

irkh

am

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 38: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Rugged Seafloor Near Thwaites Glacier

Cored on two bathymetric highs that are possible pinning points in the past.

Amundsen Sea

ThwaitesNew bathymetry data and core sites around Thwaites Glacier

Thwaites Ice Shelf

Modern

Pinning Point

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 39: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Preliminary Interpretation - KC04

Clay laminations and sand lenses with sparse gravel

Sandy mud with some gravel

Pebbly sandy mud with cobbles, high shear strength at base

Sandy mud, no gravel

km

Amundsen Sea

KC04

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 40: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Unpinning of Thwaites Ice Shelf

12 3

km

Amundsen Sea

KC04

Grounded Ice Extent

Proximal to grounded ice

Subglacial till?1

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 41: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Unpinning of Thwaites Ice Shelf

1

1

12 3

Gradually less proximal

km

Amundsen Sea

KC04

Grounded Ice Extent

Proximal to grounded ice

Subglacial till?

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 42: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Unpinning of Thwaites Ice Shelf

1

Transitional facies

km

Amundsen Sea

KC04

Grounded Ice Extent

Proximal to grounded ice

Subglacial till?

Gradually less proximal

2

12 3

1

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 43: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Unpinning of Thwaites Ice Shelf

1

3

12 3

Seasonally open marine

Transitional facies

km

Amundsen Sea

KC04

Modern Ice Shelf Margin

Proximal to grounded ice

Subglacial till?

Gradually less proximal

2

1

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 44: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Ongoing Work

Dates imminent

Back to field in January

Thwaites Ice Shelf

Paleo Pinning Point #2

Modern Pinning Point

Paleo Pinning Point #1

Introduction Ice Extent Dating Amundsen Sea

Page 45: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Plan• Antarctic basics

• Who am I and what do I do?

• Thwaites Glacier

– How it’s changing

– How do we know

• Geo-Engineering of ice sheets

Page 46: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Control water flow: Can’t even do that in warm waters

Page 47: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Build a pinning point: What about surface melt?

Page 48: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Make snow: Never ending battle

Page 49: Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we ... · Glacial Change in Antarctica: How we know and what we might do about it Julia Wellner Earth & Atmospheric Sciences University

Manique Talia-Murray

Thanks, questions?