GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

17

Transcript of GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Page 1: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game
Page 2: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game
Page 3: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Measuring Collaboration in a Multiplayer Game

Deirdre Kerr & Jessica Andrews Educational Testing Service

12/10/2015

Page 4: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

What We Do

Awesome!

Learning Sciences Data Mining

StatisticsBehavioral Analytics

Page 5: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Goals Develop a methodology for scaling

qualitative analytics Interpretable, actionable information About individual behavior Without requiring in-person observations

Define collaborative behavior Often defined as team performance Different definitions in different contexts

Develop a measure of collaboration Based on behaviors Independent of performance

Page 6: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Why Collaboration? Traditionally qualitative

Reflected in problem solving process (not result) Not measurable outside behaviors

Worthwhile problem Of concern to employers Unclear impact on performance No good preexisting measures

Actionable information Remediation Incentives Accurate scoring of individuals in a group

Page 7: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Example Environment

Page 8: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Generate an Ontology

Page 9: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Expand to a Behavioral Ontology

Page 10: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

LegendNode ShapesOvals = latent or calculated variablesRounded Rectangles = inferred actionsRectangles = observed actions

Node ColorsLight Gray = task independentDark Gray = task dependent

Expand to a Cognitively Enhanced Ontology

Page 11: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Extract Features

Page 12: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Create Chains-of-Evidence

Page 13: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Action Set Label

Action Set Label

I-TAF FrameworkOverview

Page 14: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Bayesian Networks

Action Set Label FrequencyFrequentAverageRare

Collaborative SkillExcellentGoodFairPoor

Action Set Label OccurrencePresentAbsent

Learned

Predicted/Measured

Calculated

Page 15: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Using I-TAF with a Different Game Use the same ontology & behavioral

ontology Update dark gray nodes in the cognitively

enhanced ontology To represent different affordances in the new

game Update features Update chains-of-evidence

To extract the SAME action set labels Use the same model (Bayesian Network)

Page 16: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

Thank You!

Deirdre [email protected]

Jessica [email protected]

Page 17: GIAF USA Winter 2015 - Measuring collaboration in a multiplayer game

JOIN IN THE CONVERSATION PARTICIPATE IN THE NEXT GIAF

GIAF on LinkedIn www.deltadna.com/[email protected]