Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
-
Upload
kesavanmohanadas -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
1/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme Projectat Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
GEOTECHNICAL ASSESSMENT REPORT
ON
CRACKS ON HOUSES IN ZONE A
(Preliminary)
Submitted on
8th
July 2013
by
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
2/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
GEOTECHNICAL ASSESSMENT REPORTON CRACKS ON HOUSES IN ZONE A
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ............................................................................................................. i
1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1
2 Original Ground Level of Affected Area ..................................................................... 5
3 Soil Condition of Affected Area .................................................................................. 6
3.1 Borehole data ..................................................................................................................... 6
3.2 Possible localised loose soil materials .............................................................................. 14
3.3 Possible Fault Lines ......................................................................................................... 16
4 Preliminary Conclusions & Recommendations ....................................................... 17
4.1 Preliminary Conclusions ................................................................................................... 17
4.2 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 18
Appendix-1: Original topography of affected housing platform
Appendix-2: Photos of cracked houses
a) ZA-B528 unit no.2 Ground Floor ...................................................................................... 1
b) ZA-B528 unit no.2 1st
Floor .............................................................................................. 3
c) ZA-B553 unit no.2 Ground Floor ...................................................................................... 3
d) ZA-B553 unit no.2 1st
Floor .............................................................................................. 5
e) ZA-B554 unit no.3 Ground Floor ...................................................................................... 6
f) ZA-B555 unit no.3 Ground Floor Back Yard ..................................................................... 9
g) ZA-B555 unit no.4 Ground Floor Back Yard ................................................................... 10
h) ZA-B555 unit no.4 Ground Floor .................................................................................... 11
i) ZA-B555 unit no.4 1st
Floor .............................................................................................. 7
j) ZA-B556 unit no.4 Ground Floor Apron Slab .................................................................... 9
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
3/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
i
Executive Summary
This report will describe the process of observation, preliminary assessment of geotechnical
condition and recommendation for further investigation on the ground behaviour in order to
suggest possible remedial works.
Sometime in November 2012, SIC was notified that several houses in zone A were affected
with cracks on the wall. The houses were constructed on cut platform. Based on the existing
available borehole data, topographical survey plan, geological survey map and ground
settlement monitoring data, it is found that the soil condition of the cut platform where the
affected houses are located is considerably good and our opinion was unlikely that the
settlement is due to poor soil quality.
However, more houses were found with cracks on the wall and other places and based on
the alignment of the affected houses; it could be possible that localised loose soil materialexist along that axis. This could only be verified if further soil investigation is carried out.
This condition may pose a potential for temporary ground subsidence when excavation is
carried out in the vicinity. The temporary ground subsidence could be aggravated when the
groundwater washes the localised loose soil material during excavation works. However it
does not seem to be the case for other areas which may suggest the absence of loose
material. The cracks on the houses could be due to temporary aggravated soil subsidence
when this unforeseen localised loose soil material was being washed out from the soil layer
during excavation in the vicinity.
As the nearest fault line indicated in the Geological Survey Map is more than 1 km from the
affected houses, it is unlikely that the settlement is due to the fault lines.
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
4/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 1 of 20
1 Introduction
In November 2012, some cracks were observed on 5 rows of terrace houses in Zone-A,
platforms ZA-B526, ZA-B528, ZA-B553, ZA-B554 and ZA-B557 (refer to Figure 1).
Figure 1:Platforms with cracks observed on houses (Nov 2012)
As these platforms were constructed on cut grounds of substantial depth between 10 and
25m, and the borehole data showed that the soil condition there was good (with SPT > 50), it
was suspected then that the cracks on the houses may be caused by structural movement.This was especially so as the cracks initially appeared on the brick walls and precast joints
and not on the ground slabs. A structural investigation was carried out and reported
separately.
However, as the cracks reappeared after repair works were carried out, and more cracks
were observed in the neighbouring platforms, it was decided that more extensive settlement
markers monitoring was to be carried out.
Settlement markers were also installed on the affected platforms to monitor whether there
was any ground settlement. In total, 8 sets of readings were taken between 9
th
Nov and 29
th
Dec 2012, and there seemed to be insignificant ground settlement except for some
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
5/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 2 of 20
Ta
ble1:Settlementreadingsfrom9
Novto29
anomalies (refer to Table-1). As such, a fresh set of level monitoring will be initiated prior to
further analysis.
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
6/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 3 of 20
The proposed additional settlement monitoring shall be carried out on the 14 platforms as
shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2:Platforms for further settlement monitoring
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
7/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 4 of 20
For each platform, 12 settlement markers will be installed at the locations as shown in Figure
3.
Figure
3:Locationsofsettle
mentmarkersforeachhousingplatform
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
8/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 5 of 20
2 Original Ground Level of Affected Area
The affected housing platforms are between PL.53.0m to PL.56.0m (refer to Figure 4),whereas the original ground level in that area ranges from about 54 to 100m as shown inAppendix-1. With this 15 to 40m thick layer of earth removed and the overburden pressure
relieved, it is unlikely that the load from the houses would cause any further consolidationsettlement.
Figure 4:Platform levels of cracked houses
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
9/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 6 of 20
3 Soil Condition of Affected Area
3.1 Borehole data
The soil condition of the affected area is analysed from the nearby 4 boreholes, i.e., BH-02,
BH-04, ABH5 and ABH6 as shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5:Boreholes around affected area
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
10/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 7 of 20
BH-02 was carried out at original ground level of 74.58m and terminated at 63.85m (refer toFigure 6). At depth 67.11m and below, the SPT N value reaches 50, and the soil isdescribed as Hard dark grey CLAY with traces of silt. Therefore, it is very possible that thecut ground at about PL.55m to be of similar good soil condition. The groundwater tablevaries between 1.24 to 2.29m below the original ground level, i.e. WL = 72.29 to 73.34m.The relatively high groundwater table will be lowered with time after the original ground hasbeen cut down to the proposed platform level. The rate of groundwater table loweringdepends on factors such as soil porosity, rainfall intensity, site conditions, etc.
Figure 6:Borehole data BH-02
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
11/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 8 of 20
ABH6 is another borehole nearest to the affected area. It was carried out at a partially filledground level of 49.5m (although the original ground level was 46.2m) and terminated at level37.365m with a borehole depth of 12.135m (refer to Figure 7). The original soil condition
shows a minimum SPT N value of 7. It increases to a value of 16 at level 43.5m, and closeto 50 at 42.0m and below. Again, it confirms that the surrounding soil condition of theaffected area is of reasonable quality and strength. The recorded groundwater depth is0.51m from the borehole top level, i.e. WL = 49.0m, which is below the proposed platformlevel.
Figure 7:Borehole data ABH6
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
12/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 9 of 20
ABH5 was carried out at original ground level of 96.2m and terminated at 46.87m. At depth85m and below, the SPT N value reaches 50, and the soil layers close to the housingplatform level are described as Hard dark grey CLAY with traces of silt and Very densebrownish grey silty fine SAND (refer to Figures 8a-8d). The recorded groundwater tablevaries from 23.35 to 25.68m below the original ground level, i.e. WL = 70.52 to 72.85m. Therelatively high groundwater table will be lowered with time after the original ground has beencut down to the proposed platform level. The rate of groundwater table lowering depends onfactors such as soil porosity, rainfall intensity, site conditions, etc.
Figu re 8(a):Borehole data ABH5
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
13/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 10 of 20
Figu re 8(b):Borehole data ABH5
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
14/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 11 of 20
Figu re 8(c):Borehole data ABH5
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
15/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 12 of 20
Figu re 8(d):Borehole data ABH5
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
16/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 13 of 20
BH-04 was carried out at original ground level of 67.04m and terminated at 56.14m. At depthof about 59m and below, the SPT N value reaches 50, and the soil layer is descri bed asHard dark grey CLAY with traces of silt (refer to Figure 9). The recorded groundwater table
varies from 2.88 to 3.67m below the original round level, i.e. WL = 63.37 to 64.16m. Therelatively high groundwater table will be lowered with time after the original ground has beencut down to the proposed platform level. The rate of groundwater table lowering depends onfactors such as soil porosity, rainfall intensity, site conditions, etc.
Figure 9:Borehole data BH-04
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
17/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 14 of 20
3.2 Possible localised loose soil materials
From the alignment of the affected houses (refer to Figure 11), it seems that although theground condition in that area is generally good, there could be a possibility that localisedloose soil materials exist along that alignment. During excavation, such localised loose soilmaterials could be washed out from the soil layer by the groundwater, thus aggravating thetemporary subsidence of the surrounding ground, which may have led to the cracks on thehouses. The existence of the localised loose soil materials could be verified by further soilinvestigation along the alignment of the affected houses.
The borehole data shows that the original groundwater table was higher than the cutplatform. The hill to the northwest of the affected houses is about 40m above the platformlevel as shown in Figure 10.
Figure 10:Hill northwest of affected houses
Borehole ABH5 shows that the groundwater table there is about 20m higher than theaffected housing platform level. In normal circumstance, the higher groundwater table will belowered with time to reach equilibrium with the groundwater table at the cut platform. This
natural process will take a long time and is often unnoticeable. However, it is inevitable thatduring construction when excavation is carried out groundwater will be released from theexcavation, causing the surrounding groundwater table to lower and possible temporaryminor subsidence to the surrounding ground.
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
18/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 15 of 20
Figure 11:Alignment of affected houses
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
19/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 16 of 20
3.3 Possible Fault Lines
The Geological Survey Map from the Geological Survey Department, British Territories inBorneo shows 3 fault lines in the Muara Area close to the development site (refer to Figure12). As the fault lines are far from the affected houses, it is highly unlikely that the cracks
were caused by this condition.
Figure
12:FaultlinesinMuara
area
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
20/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 17 of 20
4 Preliminary Conclusions & Recommendations
4.1 Preliminary Conclusions
Based on the existing available borehole data, topographical survey plan, geological survey
map and ground settlement monitoring data, the following preliminary conclusions are drawn:
The soil condition of the cut platform where the affected houses are located isconsiderably good. It is Hard dark grey CLAY with traces of silt with SPT N value of50 at the cut platform level. Therefore, it is unlikely that the settlement is due to poor soilquality.
However, based on the alignment of the affected houses, it could be possible thatlocalised loose soil material exist along that axis. This could only be verified if furthersoil investigation is carried out.
The groundwater table around the cut platform where the affected houses are located is
significantly higher than the house platform, especially at the hill to the northwest of theaffected houses. This poses a potential for temporary ground subsidence whenexcavation is carried out in the vicinity. The temporary ground subsidence could beaggravated when the groundwater washes the localised loose soil material into theexcavated ground.
The cracks on the houses could be due to temporary aggravated soil subsidence whenthe unforeseen localised loose soil material was being washed out from the soil layerduring excavation in the vicinity.
As the nearest fault line indicated in the Geological Survey Map is more than 1 km fromthe affected houses, it is unlikely that the settlement is due to the fault lines.
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
21/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 18 of 20
4.2 Recommendations
Based on the preliminary conclusions, the following course of actions is recommended:
If the cracks on the houses were due to temporary soil subsidence caused by localised loosesoil material being washed out from the surrounding soil layer by the groundwater duringexcavation in the vicinity, the settlement will diminish with time after the excavation has beenbackfilled. To determine when the settlement has stabilised and is safe to carry out thestructural repair works, the following monitoring programme should be implemented:
Ground settlement monitoring of the 28 affected house platforms at an interval of 3days for a reasonable duration until no significant settlement is observed. If thesettlement readings show incremental settlement of less than 2mm in 3 consecutivereadings, it is likely that the temporary soil subsidence has stabilised and issufficiently safe to carry out the structural repair works. Ground settlement monitoringshould continue during the repair works, but reduced to only weekly monitoring.
Install 15 nos. of water standpipes at the proposed locations as indicated in Figure14. This is to monitor the surrounding groundwater table to detect if the drawdownrate is significant enough to cause further soil subsidence.
Carry out further soil investigation along the alignment of the cracked houses todetermine if there are localised pockets of loose soil material which could have beenwashed out by the groundwater during excavation, thus causing the groundsubsidence along that axis. 9 nos. of additional boreholes are proposed, and thelocations are as indicated in Figure 15.
To monitor the length and width of the existing cracks on the houses and see if theyare propagating further before carrying out any structural repair works.
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
22/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 19 of 20
Figure 14:Indicative locations of proposed water standpipes
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
23/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Page 20 of 20
Figure 15:Indicative locations of proposed additional boreholes
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
24/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix-1
Appendix-1: Original topography of affected housing platform
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
25/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-1
Appendix-2: Photos of cracked houses
a) ZA-B528 unit no.2 Ground Floor
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
26/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-2
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
27/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-3
b) ZA-B528 unit no.2 1st Floor
c) ZA-B553 unit no.3 Ground Floor
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
28/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-4
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
29/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-5
d) ZA-B553 unit no.3 1st Floor
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
30/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-6
e) ZA-B554 unit no.3 Ground Floor
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
31/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-7
f) ZA-B555 unit no.4 1st Floor
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
32/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-8
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
33/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-9
g) ZA-B556 unit no.4 Ground Floor Apron Slab
h) ZA-B556 unit no.2 Ground Floor Back Yard
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
34/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
Appendix 2-10
i) ZA-B557 unit no.4 Ground Floor Back Yard
-
7/29/2019 Geotechnical Assessment Report on Zone-A Settlement (2013!07!08) - Rev.03-1 Correction
35/35
Brunei 4000-Unit National Housing Scheme ProjectAt Menkabau, Kampong Mentiri, Bandar Seri Begawan
j) ZA-B557 unit no.4 Ground Floor