Genomic ‘dark matter’ in the heart A clinical treasure trove Samir Ounzain, Ph.D CGRM Seminar...
-
Upload
frederick-carroll -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of Genomic ‘dark matter’ in the heart A clinical treasure trove Samir Ounzain, Ph.D CGRM Seminar...
Genomic ‘dark matter’ in the heart
A clinical treasure trove
Samir Ounzain, Ph.DCGRM Seminar Series, Maastricht – 5th December 2014
Pedrazzini LabDepartment of Medicine
Experimental Cardiology UnitUniversity of Lausanne Medical School
Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois (CHUV)Lausanne, Switzerland
@ispiyou about.me/ounzainsamir Samir Ounzain, 2014
Cardiovascular disease and heart failure – Heartbreaking statistics
Bill Cannon, Outlook - Heart Health, Nature, 31st January 2013
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Cardiovascular disease and heart failure – More heart disease ahead
Bill Cannon, Outlook - Heart Health, Nature, 31st January 2013
the projected annual number of worldwide
deaths from cardiovascular disease in 2030 23.6M
global deaths per minute from cardiovascular
disease in 2008 33
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Cardiovascular disease and heart failure – Global burden
Bill Cannon, Outlook - Heart Health, Nature, 31st January 2013
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Response to biomechanical stress in the adult heart
Compensated FailingNormal
Biomechanical StressMyocardial InfarctionHypertension
Cardiomyocyte hypertrophy
Gradual loss of cardiomyocytes
Fibroblast proliferation
Massive loss of myocytes
Fibrosis
Electro-mechanicalRemodeling
Mobilization of immature cardiomyocytesand cardiac stem cells
Regeneration
What we have: Fewer myocytes
More fibrosis
What we want: More myocytes
Less fibrosis
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Cardiac gene regulatory networks
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Long non-coding RNAs – Characteristics and mechanisms of action
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Hu, W et al (2012) Regulation of mammalian cell differentiation by long non-coding RNAs. EMBO Reports
Typically (A) >200bp (B) lack coding potential (C) PolyA(+) (D) Pol2 transcribed (E) multi-exonicHighly tissue/context specific – Thousands likely exist
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Long non-coding RNAs – Characteristics and mechanisms of action
Functions in the heart are poorly characterized
Rinn, J and Chang, H al (2012) Genome regulation by long non-coding RNAs. AnnuRev-Biochem
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Jerome DauvillierFrederic BurdetMark IbbersonIoannis Xenarios
Rory JohnsonRoderic Guigo
Blanche SchroenStephane Heymans
Alexandre Sarre
Keith Harshman
Rudi, Tal, Miki, Iole, Moh
Characterising the mouse long non-coding (lncRNA) transcriptome
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Humanortholog identification
1110 lncRNAsMouse model
Human heart disease
Myocardialinfarction
14 d.
Borderzone
Poly A(+) RNA-Sequencing
ab initio reconstruction
Association with specific chromatin state
transitions
Heart specificity
UC
SC
ln
cRN
As
mR
NA
s
Nov
el ln
cRN
As
Correlation with cardiac physiology
Functional roles as Enhancer derived ncRNAs
p300
H3K4me1
H3K4me3
H3K27Ac
H3K27me3
Mouse enhancer
LVLA
RA
RV
UCSC mRNA UCSC lncRNA
Novel lncRNA
8.7% (1521)5.6%
85.7%
Novel lncRNA identification and characterisation
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Den
sity
0 20 40 60 80
Coding potential (Gene ID score)
UCSC mRNAs UCSC lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs
UCSC mRNA UCSC lncRNA
Novel lncRNA
8.7% (1521)5.6%
85.7%
Exons Introns Promoters
Den
sity
0.0-0.5-1.0-1.5-2.0 0.0-0.5-1.0-1.5-2.0 0.0-0.5-1.0-1.5-2.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
PhastCons (Normalized by size)
UCSC lncRNA
Novel lncRNA
UCSC mRNA
Random intergenic
Overlapping antisense
Overlapping sense
Intronic antisense
Intronic sense
Exonic sense
Divergent
Convergent
Same strand
UCSC lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs
Transcript number
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Den
sity
1 10 100 10000.10.01
Mean transcription (FPKM)
UCSC mRNAs UCSC lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs
Response of the transcriptome to stress – 14 days post MI
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Sham MI
NppaNppbMyh6Myh7Col1a1PostnTgfb1XLOC_007752XLOC_012723XLOC_010855XLOC_001225XLOC_007565XLOC_007852
Sham MI
UCSC mRNAs
1338 do
wn
2204 up
Sham MI
UCSC lncRNAs
67 up
66 do
wn
Sham MI
Novel lncRNAs
86 up
225 do
wn
Canonical Markers
Sham MI
Sh
am
MI
UCSC mRNAs
Sham MI
Sh
am
MI
UCSC lncRNAs
Sham MI
Sh
am
MI
Novel lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs exhibit significant cardiac specific expression
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
All transcriptsH
eart
sp
ecif
icit
yH
eart
sp
ecif
icit
yH
eart
sp
ecif
icit
y
15075 UC
SC
mR
NA
s988 U
CS
C ln
cRN
As
1521 No
vel lncR
NA
s
Hea
rt
ShamHeart
MIHeart
17 non cardiac tissues
Cu
ffli
nks
Pre
dic
tio
ns
+
-
+
-
+
-
+
-
Heart
Testis
Kidney
Liver
Str
and
sp
ecif
ic
tran
scri
pti
on
Lung
Stomach
PhastConsVertebrates
+
-
+
-
Novlnc6
Proximal coding genes are heart specific and implicated in cardiac biology
P value (-log 10)
Heart specific transcripts (%)
Correlation score = 0.995
Cufflinks predictions
UCSC annotations
+-
ENCODE Heart
Sham
MI
PolyA(+)RNA-Seq
278 lncRNA/mRNA pairs with correlations > 0.9
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Novel lncRNAs exhibit significant cell and sub-cellular specificity
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Novlnc333
Novlnc174
Novlnc95
Novlnc86
Novlnc44
Novlnc90
Novlnc103
Novlnc96
Novlnc49
Novlnc11
Novlnc15
Novlnc32
Novlnc76
Novlnc61
Novlnc6
Novlnc35
Novlnc23
CMFibr.
0 0.05 0.10 0.15-0.05-0.10-0.15
Novlnc11
Novlnc95
Novlnc49
Novlnc76
Novlnc86
Novlnc44
Novlnc96
Novlnc90
Novlnc15
Novlnc6
Novlnc35
Novlnc333
Novlnc61
Novlnc174
Novlnc103
Novlnc32
Novlnc23
CMFibr.
0 2 4-2-4
Delta Fold Change Nuc. Cyto.Cyto/Nuc Ratio
Novel lncRNAs are highly correlated with cardiac physiological traits
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
LV
mas
s / B
WL
V m
ass
IVR
TS
A M
I tra
ceS
A L
V a
rea;
dL
A M
I tra
ceL
A L
V a
rea;
d
LV
ID;
sL
V v
olu
me;
sL
VID
; d
LV
vo
lum
e; d
LV
PW
; d
LV
PW
; s
EF
FS
IVS
; s
IVS
; d
Bo
dy
wei
gh
tH
eart
rat
e
LA
LV
are
a; s
Echocardiography derived traits
1.
2.
3.
4.
No
vel l
ncR
NA
s
Correlation
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00
Den
sity
EF2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00
Correlation
Den
sity
MI Trace
UCSC lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs0 0.5 1.0-1.0 -0.5
Correlation
Heart specific transcripts (%)
EF
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00
1
2
3
4
5
Den
sit
y
Correlation
Cluster 1
Cluster 2
Cluster 3
Cluster 4
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Novlnc35
mhy7
Novlnc6Novlnc15
Novlnc76
Novlnc61
Novlnc103
Novlnc174
Novlnc23
Novlnc333
Novlnc32
Novlnc49
Novlnc11
Novlnc95
Novlnc90
Novlnc86
Novlnc96
Novlnc44
col1actgfnppatgfb2
LV m
ass
/ B
W
LA M
I tr
ace
SA
MI
trac
e
LV m
ass
SA
LV
are
a; d
LA L
V a
rea;
d
LA L
V a
rea;
s
LVID
; s
LV v
olum
e; s
LVID
; d
LV v
olum
e; d
Hea
rt r
ate
Bod
y w
eigh
t
IVS
; s
LVP
W;
s
EF
FS
LVP
W;
d
IVS
; d
0 0.5-0.5
Border Zone
70
50
30
10
0-1-2-3
Novlnc6
EF
(%
)
R=0.785
70
50
30
10
0-1-2-3-4
Novlnc15
R=0.811
70
50
30
10
0-1-2-3 1
Novlnc95
R=0.785
Fold change over Sham
70
50
30
10
10 21
Novlnc174
R=-0.538
Fold change over Sham
70
50
30
10
321-1 0
Myh7
R=-0.426
70
50
30
10
210-2 -1
Col1a
R=-0.484
70
50
30
10
210-1
Nppa
R=-0.788E
F (
%)
Novel lncRNAs Cardiac markers
Myocardialinfarction
BorderZone
1, 7 and 14 days
Novel lncRNAs are highly correlated with cardiac physiological traits
Novel lncRNAs are associated with cardiac specific active enhancers
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
H3K4me3+H3K27me3 bivalent/poised promoterH3K4me3+H3K27ac active/initiating promoterH3K4me3 initiating promoterH3K27me3+H3K4me1 poised developmental enhancerH3K4me1 poised enhancerH3K27ac+H3K4me1 active enhancer H3K27me3 Polycomb repressed
ENCODE Data SetsChIP-Seq data sets from 5 mouse whole tissues
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Kidney Liver SpleenHeart Testis
1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
1
2
3
Down
None
Up
H3K4me3+H3K27me3 bivalent/poised promoterH3K4me3+H3K27ac active/initiating promoterH3K4me3 initiating promoterH3K27me3+H3K4me1 poised developmental enhancerH3K4me1 poised enhancerH3K27ac+H3K4me1 active enhancer H3K27me3 Polycomb repressed
ENCODE Data SetsChIP-Seq data sets from 5 mouse whole tissues
No
vel l
ncR
NA
s
No
vel l
ncR
NA
s
Novel lncRNAs are associated with cardiac specific active enhancers
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
H3K
4me1
H3K
4me3
H3K
27A
cH
3K27
me3
PhastConsVertebrates
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Spleen
Testis
Cu
fflin
ksP
red
icti
on
s
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Spleen
Testis
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Spleen
Testis
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Spleen
Testis
Novlnc6
Enhancer
Novel lncRNAs are associated with cardiac specific active enhancers
Mouse embryonic stem cell cardiac differentiation
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Oct4Nanog
EomesBrachyury T
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5
Cardiac genes(-MHC; -MHC)
d0 d2-3 d3 d3-d6 d6-12 d>12
Organizedsarcomeres
mES MES CPC CM
Integration of ChIP-sequencing data from Wamstad J.A. et al. 2012. Cell.
Embryonicstem cells
Mesodermalprecursors
Cardiacmesodermalprecursors
Cardiacprecursors
Immaturecardiomyocytes
Maturecardiomyocytes
Spontaneously beatingSpontaneously beatingcardiomyocytescardiomyocytes
Hanging dropsHanging drops Suspension cultureSuspension culture Adherent cultureAdherent culture
Embryoid bodiesEmbryoid bodies DifferentiatingDifferentiatingembryoid bodiesembryoid bodies
d0 d3-6 d6-9 d9-12
UndifferentiatedUndifferentiatedembryonic stem cellsembryonic stem cells
Embryonic stem cellEmbryonic stem cellcoloniescolonies
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
MES CPC CMES
A
B
C
D
H3K27me3
H3K4me1 & H3K27Ac
H3K4me1
H3K4me1 & H3K27me3
H3K4me3
H3K4me3 & H3K27Ac H3K4me3 & H3K27me3
1
2
3
USCC mRNAs
USCS lncRNAs
Novel lncRNAs
MES CPC CMES
1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 30
5
10
15
20
25
%
Cluster A Cluster B Cluster C Cluster D
%Heart specificy
Oct4Nanog
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5 -MHC; -MHC
Novel lncRNAs are associated with cardiac specific active enhancers
Novel lncRNA expression correlates with chromatin state
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Novlnc6
Novlnc11
Novlnc15
Novlnc23
Novlnc32
Novlnc35Novlnc44Novlnc49
Novlnc61
Novlnc76Novlnc86Novlnc90
Novlnc95Novlnc96
Novlnc103
Novlnc174
Novlnc333
ES
ME
SC
PC
CM
H3K4me3 H3K27me3E
SM
ES
CP
CC
M
H3K4me1
ES
ME
SC
PC
CM
H3K27ac
ES
ME
SC
PC
CM
Fol
d ch
ange
ove
r d0
Novlnc61 Novlnc23 Novlnc49 Novlnc44
ES cell differentiation
Fol
d ch
ange
ove
r d0
ES cell differentiation
Novlnc11 Novlnc32 Novlnc41 Novlnc95 Novlnc333
MES CPC CMES
Oct4Nanog
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5 -MHC; -MHC
d3 d6 d12d0
Inferring functions for novel lncRNAs based on chromatin state transitions
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Embryonicstem cells
Mesodermalprecursors
Cardiacprecursors
Cardiomyocytes
Exp
ress
ion
Genes
Lineage-specific gene expression
Stages of differentiation
x y z x y z x y z x y z
Based on Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Embryonicstem cells
Mesodermalprecursors
Cardiacprecursors
Cardiomyocytes
Exp
ress
ion
En
rich
men
tE
nri
chm
ent
En
rich
men
tE
nri
chm
ent
H3K4me3
H3K27me3
H3K4me1
H3K27Ac
Genes
Lineage-specific gene expression
Functional inference
Stages of differentiation
x y z x y z x y z x y z
Ch
rom
atin
e st
ate
tran
siti
on
Based on Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
Inferring functions for novel lncRNAs based on chromatin state transitions
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
1st pattern
2nd pattern
3rd pattern
Cluster 1(gene x, plus other geneswith similar pattern)
34 Patterns / Clusters
Cluster 2(gene y, plus other geneswith similar pattern)
Cluster 3(gene z, plus other geneswith similar pattern)
Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
Inferred function based on top
GO terms
Cluster
1 House keeping
2 House keeping
3 House keeping
4 Cellular homeostasis
5 Pluripotency, Metabolic process
6 Metabolic process, Transport
7 Cellular homeostasis, Matrix
8 Channel activity, Signaling
9 Development
10 Vascular homeostasis
11 Pluripotency, Development
12 Renal homeostasis
13 Catabolic process
14 Metabolic process
15 Enzymatic activity
16 Inflammatory response
17 Metabolic process
18 Inflammatory response
19 Inflammatory response
20 Contraction, Heart development
21 G-protein coupled receptors
22 G-protein coupled receptors
23 Contraction, Heart development
24 Contraction, Heart development
25 Contraction, Heart development
26 Contraction, Heart development
27 Contraction, Heart development
28 G-protein coupled receptors
29 House keeping
30 Contraction
31 Transcription, Translation
32 Mitochondrial activity
33 Translation
34 Translation
Inferring functions for novel lncRNAs based on chromatin state transitions
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
1
3
18
25 2623 24
28
USCS mRNAs
20
27
2
Novel lncRNAs
1
3
18
28
26
24
23
20
27
25
2
Definition of 34 clusters corresponding to 34 groupsof genes that are functionally related
E.g.: Cluster 1, 2, 3: House keeping function Cluster 18: Immune/Inflammatory response Cluster 20, 23-27: Cardiac development, muscle contraction Cluster 28: Calcium homeostasis, GPCR signaling
Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
- 5.70
- 4.00
- 2.00
0.00
2.00
4.00
7.25
Pearsonresidual
Down Unchanged Up
1
3
23
24
28
18
20
27
2
2526
Sham vs. MI
Cluster-associated novel lncRNAs are enriched in –up/-down regulated lncRNAs
Inferring functions for novel lncRNAs based on chromatin state transitions
Candidate cardiac enhancer derived lncRNA – Novlnc6
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
p300
H3K4me1
H3K4me3
H3K27Ac
H3K27me3
PhastConsVertebrates
Mouse enhancer
LVLA
RA
RV
Novlnc6 Nkx2.5
Scrambled
Novlnc6 Gapmer 1
Bmp10 Gata4 Tbx20 Myh6 Myh7
Fol
d ch
ange
ove
r S
cram
ble
Novlnc6 Gapmer 2
** *** * * *
Remote ZoneBorder Zone
d1 d7
*
d1 d7
* *
Fol
d ch
ange
over
Sha
m d
1
Novlnc6
d1 d7
*
Nppa
Fol
d ch
ange
over
Sha
m d
1
*
d1 d7
*Col1a
d1 d7
*
EF
*
%
Novel lncRNAsChromatin State Clusters
1
3
18
28
26
24
23
20
27
252
Novlnc6
Bmp10
Cardiomyocytes
Novlnc6Gapmers
70
50
30
10
210-1
Nppa70
50
30
10
0-1-2-3
Novlnc6
EF
(%
)
R=0.785
R=-0.788
Nkx2.5
Sham MI
Novlnc6 is modulated in Human heart disease
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Hs Novlnc6
p < 0.001
Nkx2.5 Nppa Col1a
p < 0.05 p < 0.001 p < 0.001
p < 0.01 p < 0.01
TransMapped Human Orthologs
PhastConsVertebrates
Mammalian Basewise PhyloP
Hs Novlnc6
p < 0.001
EF
p < 0.001
PW thickness
Dilated cardiomyopathy
Aortic stenosis
1100 human orthologs identified
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Summary
Identified 1500 novel lncRNAs in the infarcted mouse heart
Novel lncRNAs are heart specific
Novel lncRNAs are highly correlated with physiological traits
Novel lncRNAs are enriched at heart specific active enhancers
Inferred novel lncRNA functions based on chromatin states
Conserved novel lncRNAs are modulated in human disease
Unique characteristics of novel lncRNAs render them ideal tissue specific therapeutic targets and biomarker candidates
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Jerome DauvillierFrederic Burdet
Rory Johnson
Matthew BlowDalit MayLen Pennacchio
Alexandre Sarre
Keith Harshman
Rudi, Miki, Iole, Razan, Christine, Moh
Enhancers – Key information processing units within genome
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Approx 1 million enhancers in all human cells (number increasing)Deregulation of enhancers = Disease
Most disease associated genetic variation occurs within them
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Enhancer associated lncRNAs are emerging as integral functional components
Modulate chromatin loops/genome topology
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Enhancer associated lncRNAs are emerging as integral functional components
Collaborate with transcriptional activators
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Enhancer associated lncRNAs are emerging as integral functional components
Evict transcriptional repressors – Promoter pause release
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
-cis vs –trans activity of enhancer associated lncRNAs
Enhancer associated lncRNAs diversify enhancer function
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Identification of bona fide developmental cardiac enhancers
• 3,000 candidate cardiac enhancers were identified in the embryonic heart at E11.5
• 130 were tested in a transgenic reporter assay in vivo (E11.5)
• 63% of these enhancers drive reproducible reporter gene expression in the developing heart
• We selected 7 bona-fide cardiac enhancers proximal to important cardiac genes
Matthew BlowDalit MayLen Pennacchio
Developmental cardiac enhancers produce ncRNA
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
mm67 mm77 mm85 mm104 mm130 mm132 mm172
Forebrain p300
Midbrain p300
Limbs p300
Conservation
Heart p300
Enhancer region
Enr
ichm
ent
302302302302302
+RT -RT +RT -RT +RT -RTNkx2.5EpiprofinHesx1mm67mm77mm85mm104mm130mm132mm172
Forebrain Limbs Heart
Forebrain Limbs Heart
RNARNA RNA
E11.5 Micep300 ChIP-Seq
Developmental cardiac enhancers produce ncRNA
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
mm67 mm77 mm85 mm104 mm130 mm132 mm172
Forebrain p300
Midbrain p300
Limbs p300
Conservation
Heart p300
Enhancer region
Enr
ichm
ent
302302302302302
+RT -RT +RT -RT +RT -RTNkx2.5EpiprofinHesx1mm67mm77mm85mm104mm130mm132mm172
Forebrain Limbs Heart
Forebrain Limbs Heart
RNARNA RNA
E11.5 Micep300 ChIP-Seq
Enhancer associated ncRNAs are dynamically expressed
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er E
9.5)
mm67
*
* * *
*
mm85
* *
Myocardin
** * *
** * *
mm67 mm85 Myocd
d0 d3 d6 d9 d12 d0 d3 d6 d9 d12 d0 d3 d6 d9 d12Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fo
ld o
ver
d0
)
Oct4Nanog
EomesBrachyury T
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5
Cardiac genes(-MHC; -MHC)
d0 d2-3 d3 d3-d6 d6-12 d>12
Organizedsarcomeres
Embryonicstem cells
Mesodermalprecursors
Cardiacmesodermalprecursors
Cardiacprecursors
Immaturecardiomyocytes
Maturecardiomyocytes
Enhancer associated ncRNA expression correlates with enhancer activity
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
mm67
AnnotationUCSC Genes
Enhancer
Phospho-Ser5RNA Pol II
PhastConsVertebrates
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
H3K4me3
H3K4me1
H3K36me3
H3K27Ac
H3K27me3
Based on Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
mm67
d0 d3d6 d9d12
MES CPC CMES
Oct4Nanog
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5 -MHC; -MHC
d3 d6 d12d0
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
mm85
AnnotationUCSC Genes
Enhancer
Phospho-Ser5RNA Pol II
PhastConsVertebrates
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
mES
MES
CPCCM
H3K4me3
H3K4me1
H3K36me3
H3K27Ac
H3K27me3
Based on Wamstad JA et al. 2012. Cell 151: 206
Enhancer associated ncRNA expression correlates with enhancer activity
MES CPC CMES
Oct4Nanog
Mesp1 GATA4Nkx2.5 -MHC; -MHC
d3 d6 d12d0
mm85
d0 d3d6 d9d12
Enhancer associated ncRNAs are enriched in cardiac progenitor cells
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
101 102 103 104 105
EmGFP Intensity (a.u.)
1%
d0
SS
C
101 102 103 104 105
EmGFP Intensity (a.u.)
29%
d6
SS
C
101 102 103 104 105
EmGFP Intensity (a.u.)
23%
d10
SS
C
d0 d6 d10
%* *
Nkx2.5-positivecardiac progenitors
Nkx2.5-positivecardiomyocytes
UndifferentiatedES cells
Specification Differentiation
d6 d10
ES14 RP11-88L12
Nkx2.5 promoter GFP
GFP-positiveGFP-negative
mm67 Myocdmm85
***
**
*
mm67 Myocdmm85Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er G
FP
-neg
ativ
e) Day 6 Day 10
Orthologous human enhancers are transcribed and functional
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Conservation
Fetal heart
Human orthologof mm67
Adult heart
Human orthologof mm85
Human orthologof mm130
Enr
ichm
ent30
230
2
Enhancer region
p300
Human orthologof mm130
Fetal heart
s
mm67
mm85
mm130
Human orthologsof
s
Adult & Fetal Human Left Ventriclep300 ChIP-Seq
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Human fetal heart
(12 weeks of gestation)
Enzymaticdissociation
Differentialplating
Control
Differentiation
Cardiacprecursors
Cardiomyocytes
d7 and d14
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er d
0)
*
*
d0 7 14
Myh6Mesp1
*
*
d0 7 14
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er d
0)mm67 ortholog
**
mm85 ortholog Myocardin
**
d0 7 14d0 7 14 d0 7 14
Orthologous human enhancers are transcribed and functional CPCs
tissue
Gata4Nkx2.5Mef2C
Cx43-MHC-MHC
GAPDHTroponin I
-actinin Nkx2.5
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Oct4+
Nanog+
GATA4+
Nkx2.5+
d6ESC CPC
Paired-end RNA-seqpolyA+ RNA; 400-500 x 106 PE reads per
sample
Map reads to mouse genome (mm9)(Tophat)
Ab inition reconstruction(Cufflinks)
Filtering: >200 nucleotides; multiexonic
UCSC mRNAs UCSC lncRNAs Novel lncRNAs
elncRNAs plncRNAs
13.9 %(2608)
8.4 %(1537)
77.7 %(14376)
UCSC mRNA UCSC lncRNA Novel lncRNA
100
102
104
10-2
10-4
FPKM
H3K4me1 H3K27Ac (elncRNAs)
H3K4me3 (plncRNAs)
Novel lncRNA
UCSC lncRNA
236
442
630
477
Global discovery of enhancer-associated lncRNAs during cardiac differentiation
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
ES MES CPC
H3K4me1 H3K27Ac
H3K4me3 PhastConsVertebrates
ESC
MES
CPC
ESC
MES
CPC
ESC
MES
CPC
Cufflinks Predictionsand enhancer
H3
K27
Ac
H3
K4m
e1
H3
K4m
e3
Ch
rom
atin
5 Kb
mm85
Chr. 11 65460157 - 65466563
UCSC mRNA
3222 up
2881 do
wn
d0 d6
UCSC lncRNA
244 up
297 do
wn
d0 d6
Novel lncRNA
311 up
806 do
wn
d0 d6
0+
1+
2-1
-2
Global discovery of enhancer-associated lncRNAs during cardiac differentiation
Mm85 – Poly(A)+, multi-exonic lncRNA expressed in adult heart
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Lung
Small Intestine
Spleen
Stomach
PhastConsVertebrates
Cu
ffli
nks
Pre
dic
tio
ns
Str
an
d s
pe
cif
ic
tran
sc
rip
tio
n
+
-
+-
+
-
+-
+
-
+
-
+
-
mm85
Mm85 lncRNA is required for transcription of target gene
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
mm85mm67 Myocardin Map2k4 Gene / Enhancer ID
Genomic loci
sh mm85-1; sh mm85-2
MM85-Promoter distance381 kbp 138 kbp
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er s
hCon
)mm85 Myocardin Map2k4
* ** *
P19CL6
mm85shRNAi
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er s
hCon
)
mm85 Myocardin Map2k4
**
Cardiomyocytes
mm85Gapmers
mm85mm67 Myocardin Map2k4 Gene / Enhancer ID
Genomic loci
Mm85 GapmeR
MM85-Promoter distance381 kbp 138 kbp
Mm85 lncRNA is required for transcription of target gene
SMAD7-enhancer associated lncRNA is required for its transcription
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Heart
Kidney
Liver
Lung
Small Intestine
Spleen
Stomach
Str
and
sp
ecif
ic
tran
scri
pti
on
PhastConsVertebrates
+-
+-
+-
+-
+-
+-
+
-
Cu
ffli
nks
Pre
dic
tio
ns
SMAD7-lncRNA
SMAD7
ES MES CPC
H3K4me1 H3K27Ac
H3K4me3
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Rel
ativ
e R
NA
exp
ress
ion
(fol
d ov
er C
on G
apm
eR)
SMAD7-lncRNA SMAD7
**
SMAD7-lnc SMAD7 Gene / Enhancer ID
Genomic loci
SMAD7-lncRNA GapmeR
SMAD7-lnc-Promoter distance<1 kbp
Cardiac Fibroblasts
SMAD7-lncGapmers
SMAD7-enhancer associated lncRNA is required for its transcription
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Summary
Developmental cardiac enhancers generate ncRNAs
Enhancer ncRNA expression correlates with enhancer activity
Enhancer ncRNA expression is conserved in Humans
Identified 630 novel Poly(A)+ and multi-exonic elncRNAs
elncRNA is specifically required for target gene expression
Developmental elncRNAs could represent interesting therapeutic targets for modulating cardiac GRN activity and
providing insight in state of GRN
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Nu
mb
er o
f n
ove
l ln
cRN
As
dis
cove
red
Average number of paired-end readsSequencing depth per sample
Ounzain S et al, EHJ, 2014
Ounzain S et al, JMCC, 2014
Why you need to sequence very deep to discover novel lncRNAs...........Typical sequencing depth of most studies in the heart
(50million PE-reads per sample)We sequenced to a depth of at least 300 million PE-reads per sample
(Identified 100s of novel cardiac specific lncRNAs with unique characteristics)
Missed novel lncRNAs at 50mil PE-reads
Detected novel lncRNAs at 50mil PE-reads
Jerome DauvillierFrederic BurdetMark IbbersonIoannis Xenarios
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Future therapeutic approaches for repair
Differentiation
Reprogramming
iPSC
ESC
CPC
CM
Fibroblasts
DirectReprogramming
CPC
lncRNAs
lncRNAs
lncRNAs
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
CM
Fibroblasts
DirectReprogramming
2
LncRNA cocktail
CM
CPC
CPC MobilizationCM Proliferation
1
Future therapeutic approaches for repair
about.me/ounzainsamir @ispiyou
Rudi MichelettiTal BeckmannMichael AlexanianIole PezzutoMohamed NemirPedrazzini Lab
@ispiyou@CardiolncRNA
Jerome DauvillierFrederic BurdetMark IbbersonIoannis Xenarios
Rory JohnsonRoderic Guigo
Blanche SchroenStephane Heymans
Alexandre Sarre Keith Harshman
Matthew BlowDalit MayLen Pennacchio