Paul M. Sotkiewicz, Ph.D. Chief Economist PJM Interconnection ICC November 8, 2011
Generation Interconnection Facilities Study Report for PJM ...
Transcript of Generation Interconnection Facilities Study Report for PJM ...
1
Generation Interconnection
Facilities Study Report
for
PJM Generation Interconnection Request
Queue Position X1-096
“Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV”
July 2014
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
2
Table of Contents
A. Transmission Owner Facilities Study Summary ............................................................................... 3
1. Description of Project ..................................................................................................................... 3
2. Amendments to the System Impact Study or System Impact Study Results ................................. 3
3. Interconnection Customer’s Milestone Schedule ........................................................................... 3
4. Customer’s Scope of Work ............................................................................................................ 3
5. Description of Facilities Included in the Facilities Study (DPL’s Scope of Work) ....................... 5
6. Total Cost of Transmission Owner Facilities Included in the Facilities Study .............................. 5
7. Summary of the Schedule for Completion of Work for the Facilities Study ................................. 6
B. Transmission Owner Facilities Study Results ................................................................................... 7
1. Transmission Lines – New (Attachment Facilities) ....................................................................... 7
2. Transmission Line – Upgrades ....................................................................................................... 7
3. Substation/Switchyard Facilities (Attachment Facilities) .............................................................. 7
4. Upgrades to Substation/Switchyard Facilities ............................................................................... 9
5. Metering & Communications ........................................................................................................ 9
6. Environmental, Real Estate and Permitting Issues ...................................................................... 10
7. Summary of Results of Study ....................................................................................................... 12
8. Schedules and Assumptions ......................................................................................................... 13
9. Other (Light Load Analysis) ........................................................................................................ 14
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
3
A. Transmission Owner Facilities Study Summary
1. Description of Project
Great Bay Wind I, LLC, the Interconnection Customer (IC), has proposed a 150 MWE (19.5 MWC;
150 MW MFO) wind powered generating facility to be located in Somerset County, Maryland. PJM
studied X1-096 as a 150 MW injection into the Delmarva Power and Light (DPL) system at the Kings
Creek 138 kV substation and evaluated the project for compliance with reliability criteria for summer
peak conditions in 2015. The planned in-service date, as originally stated in the Attachment N, is October
10, 2014.
2. Amendments to the System Impact Study or System Impact Study Results
The scope of the project as stated in the revised Impact Study, submitted on April 2013, has remained
relatively unchanged. However, the estimates herein provided were performed in more detail than those
provided in the Impact Study.
The DPL portion of the project is projected to be completed approximately 20-24 months following
an executed Interconnection Service Agreement (ISA) and Construction Service Agreement (CSA). This
is assuming a normal land use and environmental permitting and approval process.
3. Interconnection Customer’s Milestone Schedule
The IC revised the planned in-service date for the X1-096 project to December 31, 2016. The DPL
schedule is supportive of the revised in-service date.
4. Customer’s Scope of Work
The IC proposes the construction of a 150 MWE (19.5 MWC; 150 MW MFO) wind powered
generating facility to be located in Somerset County, Maryland.
The IC assumes full responsibility for design, permitting and construction of all facilities associated
with the X1-096 generating station on their side of the Point of Interconnection (POI.) X1-096 will
interconnect with the Delmarva Power and Light (DPL) transmission system at the existing Kings
Creek 138 kV substation. The Point of Interconnection (POI) will be located at a disconnect switch
just beyond the fence line of the new substation (see Attachment 1).
The IC is responsible for all design and construction related activities on their side of the Point of
Interconnection. Site preparation, including grading and an access road, as necessary, is assumed to be by
the IC. Route selection, line design, right-of-way acquisition and construction of the direct connect
facilities is not included in this report and is the responsibility of the IC. The IC is required to construct a
138 kV breaker, which it will own, no more than 500 feet from the tap point. Information detailing the
interconnection to DPL facilities is outlined in the “Technical Considerations Covering Parallel
Operations of Customer Owned Generation of One (1) Megawatt or Greater and Interconnected with the
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
4
PHI Power Delivery System.” The costs outlined in this study do not include construction of the 138 kV
equipment from the generating facility to the tap structure.
The IC shall also incorporate DPL’s scope of work into their CPCN application for filing as a single
project. DPL will coordinate with the IC to prepare, develop and file the required documentation for the
CPCN.
The IC shall supply adequate, buildable high land with access roads for the installation of the DPL
facilities at no cost to the Company. All applicable permitting, zoning and land use approvals will be
obtained by the developer for DPL’s proposed facilities. DPL will apply for its own building permit for
the facilities within its substation fence.
The IC is responsible for obtaining all rights necessary for their facilities, up to and including any
usage of property in which Pepco Holdings, Inc. may have real property interests. As part of this process,
the IC shall provide, for PHI review, surveyed site plans that delineate their intended facilities, and clearly
define the facilities relationship to existing rights of way and the electrical facilities contained therein.
PHI will provide the IC with the appropriate legal instrument affording the IC the right to use PHI real
property, if necessary, upon review, subsequent approval, and associated compensation.
DPL will require the capability to remotely disconnect the generator from the grid by communication
from its System Operations facility. Such disconnection may be facilitated by a generator breaker, a line
recloser, or other method depending upon the specific circumstances and the evaluation of PHI. The IC is
responsible for construction of single mode fiber optic cable from the generating site to the POI.
Reactive Power and Grid Support Requirements
This section contains setting requirements for the operation of the Interconnection Customer’s
proposed equipment.
The wind turbine selected for this project must have the follow capabilities:
Dynamic VAR response
Ramp rate control
SCADA communications
Curtailment
Low voltage ride through and a configurable frequency ride through
Ability to receive and respond to a transfer trip or SCADA signal
Each individual turbine in the wind generator’s facility shall have the ability to shut down separately
at maximum output to avoid the turbines from shutting down simultaneously due to over speed during
high wind conditions.
The X1-096 generating facility will be required to maintain a power factor at the Point of
Interconnection between 0.95 leading (absorbing VARs) and 0.95 lagging (producing VARs).
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
5
5. Description of Facilities Included in the Facilities Study (DPL’s Scope of Work)
This report describes the electrical interconnection facilities and upgrades to existing DPL facilities
necessary to support the IC’s generation. The IC’s interconnection circuit construction and the IC’s
generation facilities are not included in this study.
Attachment Facilities – PJM Network Upgrade Number n3732 (Substation)
Design and construct a new 138 kV bus position at Kings Creek substation. This substation
expansion will be built to the Company’s (the “Company” referring to ACE, DPL, or
PEPCO) specifications for a transmission substation and be owned and operated by the
Company. An additional 138 kV line terminal, upgraded bus and associated relaying,
communications equipment and a control house will be installed. DPL will obtain the
necessary permitting for all work within the substation fence.
Attachment Facilities – PJM Network Upgrade Number n3733 (Transmission)
Install a self-supporting 138 kV steel structure to accommodate motor operated disconnect
switches and a span to the DPL Kings Creek 138 kV substation.
Upgraded Facilities (DPL Transmission/Telecommunications)
The following work was identified by DPL as required in order to provide with the communication
path necessary for the interconnection of X1-096.
Install OPGW on circuit 13713 Loretto to Kings Creek.
DPL reserves the right to review the electrical protection design and relay settings for interconnecting
customer facilities to ensure that the protective relaying equipment will be compatible with that installed
at the remote substations. DPL personnel must be present at the time of commissioning to witness proper
function of the protection scheme and related coordination.
A three phase 138 kV revenue metering point needs to be established on the IC side of the disconnect
switch at the POI. See Section B.5 of this report for IC’s scope of work.
6. Total Cost of Transmission Owner Facilities Included in the Facilities Study
Item Total Cost
Attachment Facilities $2,096,927
Attachment Facilities with Contingency 15% $2,411,466
Upgrade Facilities $1,439,358
Upgrade Facilities with 15% Contingency $1,655,261
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
6
7. Summary of the Schedule for Completion of Work for the Facilities Study
The overall estimated timeline for this project, including upgrades, is approximately 20-24 months
from the date of the PJM release for design/construction. This timeline may be able to be improved with
preferred system outages.
Attachment Facility Timeframe
Substation Design, Procurement and Construction 20-24 months
Transmission Engineering, Procurement and Construction 20-24 months
Environmental Permitting 18 months
Outside Plant Comm. Design, Procurement and Construction 12-18 months
Metering 6 months
Real Estate 18-24 months
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
7
B. Transmission Owner Facilities Study Results
This section describes facilities identified to be installed (attachment facilities), replaced, and/or
upgraded (upgrade facilities) by DPL to accommodate the project. During detailed design and analysis
other components may be identified for installation or replacement due to this interconnection.
1. Transmission Lines – New (Attachment Facilities)
PJM Network Upgrade Number n3733
New transmission facilities will be designed and constructed to accommodate the new
interconnection as follows:
Steel pole with a drilled pier concrete foundation.
Insulators and associated hardware.
1 138 kV pole mounted disconnect switch with a rating of 2000 amps.
Motor operators and communication devices (RTU).
Multi-vacuum interrupting devices.
Two (2) spans of wire (3 phases each) from the proposed station to the POI.
2. Transmission Line – Upgrades
Upgrade Facilities (DPL Transmission/Telecommunications)-Kings Creek-Loretto OPGW
The installation of OPGW on circuit Loretto to Kings Creek (existing circuit 13713) includes the
following work:
Replace 7.2 miles of the static wire with Optical-Ground Wire (OPGW) on the existing Kings
Creek-Loretto 138 kV line.
Replace approximately 15 structures to accommodate the new OPGW installation (exact
quantity to be determined upon the completion of a detailed structural analysis; the total
structures count is 54).
3. Substation/Switchyard Facilities (Attachment Facilities)
PJM Network Upgrade Number n3732
At Kings Creek Substation, a new circuit breaker (called CB 135) will be installed between
breakers 130 and 131. This results in the IC’s terminal being between CB’s 130 and 135 and AT1
being between CB’s 131 and 135. Additionally, it is necessary to bring the station’s 138 kV bus up to
present standards; this involves removing two (2) dead end wood poles with guy wires, three (3) H-
frame strain bus structures (along with their foundations), and all associated 954 ACSR strain bus and
then replacing all of the strain bus with new rigid bus and structures. Additionally, single phase
voltage transformer “CCP8” is associated with AT1’s schemes and will become separated from
AT1’s bus position once new CB 135 is added, so it is necessary to install CCP8 in a new physical
location. A new switch and switch structure will be needed for the high side of AT1 as well since its
strain bus H-frame (which presently houses its high side disconnect) will be removed. The IC’s
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
8
terminal is assumed to consist of an aerial transmission take-off H-frame structure. A three-phase
bank of CVT’s, a disconnect switch, and a set of surge arresters will be included at this terminal.
The relaying for the IC’s new bus terminal will consist of two sets of differential bus
protection. Additionally, DPL will install a new Orion LX communications processor and Ethernet
switch to support this project. All relaying will be designed and installed per DPL’s standards.
At Kings Creek Substation, the work includes the following items:
One (1) 138 kV, 2000 A, 40 kA circuit breaker
Five (5) 138 kV, 2000 A vertical break disconnect switches
Two (2) 138 kV, 1200 A vertical break disconnect switches with quick-break whips
Four (4) 138 kV class CVT’s
Three (3) 138 kV station class surge arresters
Four (4) low switch stands (steel)
Four (4) high switch stands (steel)
One (1) low 3-phase CVT stand (steel)
One (1) high 1-phase CVT stand (steel)
Two (2) high-low diagonal bus support stands (steel)
Three (3) 3-phase high bus support stands (steel)
Two (2) 3-phase low bus support stands (steel)
Three (3) 1-phase high bus support stands (steel)
One (1) aerial transmission line take-off tower (steel, H-frame)
Lot of 4” SPS aluminum bus, 954 ACSR 45/7 conductor, connectors, insulators, and misc.
hardware
Two (2) breaker control / breaker failure relay panels
One (1) front-line & back-up bus protection panel
One (1) DRTU Panel with Orion LX, Ethernet Switch, and GPS Clock
One (1) new DC Cabinet for the control house
One (1) new AC Cabinet for the control house
One (1) lot of precast cable trench
Lot of secondary control and power cables, meter boxes, junction boxes, yard lights, etc.
Lot of site stone for site restoration after completion of work
Lot of required foundations (drilled piers and slabs)
Lot of required conduit (above and below grade)
Lot of required station ground conductors and connectors (above and below grade)
Removal of existing strain bus (two poles with guys, three H-frame strain structures including
their foundations, and associated conductors)
Reconfiguration of the relay and control schemes associated with AT1 and CB’s 130 and 131 to
accommodate its new connection point between CB’s 131 and 135.
The work required for the substation expansion also includes the following:
Engineering design and drafting, preparation of all plans, layouts, details, schematic and wiring
diagrams, with equipment purchasing and installation specifications
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
9
Field construction management and all other field construction resources
Design of storm water management and erosion and sediment control facilities, with reports
and drawings to be used by the Customer for permitting the site
Clearing/grading of site with installation of roadway, fence, stoning, and storm water and
erosion and sediment control facilities
Testing and commissioning for all new equipment and systems
It is DPL practice to use separate contractors for the installation of foundations, all primary and
relaying work and testing and commissioning.
Drawing Review and Relay Test
DPL will review the IPR cabinet drawing PRIOR TO THE PURCHASE OF EQUIPMENT then test
for proper relay operation after installation of the required protection equipment at IC site.
4. Upgrades to Substation/Switchyard Facilities
No substation upgrade work required for X1-096 other than the work detailed in the
attachments above.
5. Metering & Communications
Metering
A three phase 138 kV revenue metering point needs to be established on the IC’s side of the
disconnect switch at the POI.
The metering instrument transformers will be specified by DPL but all equipment and labor
will be supplied by the IC. The DPL scope would include the programming and installation of the
meters, both primary and backup, and all required wiring work needed to connect the secondary
wiring conductors at the metering enclosure. The materials that the Meter Department provides
would be the meter enclosures, control cable, the meters, the output devices, and miscellaneous
material at the cabinet.
The IC will purchase and install all metering instrument transformers as well as construct a
metering structure per DPL's specifications. The secondary wiring connections at the instrument
transformers will be completed by the interconnection customer's contractors and inspected by
DPL, while the secondary wiring work at the metering enclosure will be completed by DPL's Meter
technicians. The metering control cable and meter cabinets will be supplied by DPL and installed
by the interconnection customer's contractors. DPL's meter technicians will program and install
two solid state multi-function meters (Primary & Backup) for the new metering position. Each
meter will be equipped with load profile, telemetry, and DNP outputs. The IC will be provided
with one meter DNP output.
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
10
The IC will be required to make provisions for a voice quality phone line within approximately
3 feet of each Company metering position to facilitate remote interrogation and data collection.
Telemetry
It is the IC’s responsibility to send the data that PJM and the Company requires directly to PJM.
The IC will grant permission for PJM to send the Company the following telemetry that the
Interconnection Customer sends to PJM: real time MW, MVAR, volts, amperes, generator status,
and interval MWH and MVARH.
6. Environmental, Real Estate and Permitting Issues
Environmental
It can be assumed that this project in entirety would need a CPCN license and/or waiver, which
would be the responsibility of the customer who is designing, route siting, acquiring ROW and
constructing the line to the point of interconnection. DPL would require that the customer include
the new steel pole and span outside of the Kings Creek substation to the point of interconnection in
their CPCN or waiver. The IC would be required to include this work in the CPCN application,
making this a single and complete project covered by one application. DPL Environmental Planning
would take responsibility for any necessary studies for the additional steel pole outside of the
substation and for the environmental permitting covering the work inside the substation.
DPL’s Environmental Planning Department has reviewed the available public sector data for all
of the project areas and the work involved in permitting the projects is as follows:
Wetlands and Water Bodies
• No wetlands or water bodies appear within the transmission study area or substation in public
sector data. It is assumed that the OPGW installation would include several pole
replacements which could potentially affect wetlands and waterways. Field surveys would be
necessary to delineate any wetlands occurring within the overall project area. Tidal and non-
tidal wetlands exist within one (1) mile of the project area. The project area is also within a
mile of Kings Creek, the 100 year flood plain, and it is within the Chesapeake Bay Critical
Area. Since the substation expansion and transmission pole will increase the impervious
cover within 1,000 ft. of a tidal watercourse (Kings Creek), coordination and review by the
Critical Area commission is required. While impact numbers in the Critical Area are
unquantified at this time, it is assumed that all subsequent permitting and possible mitigation
will be necessary at some degree depending on agency consultation. These consultations and
approvals are included in the Cost Estimate below. Potential mitigation costs are unknown at
this time.
Rare, Threatened and Endangered Species
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
11
• Dependent on agency consultation. However, public sector data indicates that there is known
RTE habitat within the project footprint and within the OPGW study area. The project area is
within Maryland Sensitive Species Land and Water. A habitat suitability assessment would
be necessary in the field, along with agency consultation. It is possible that additional
targeted species studies may be required.
Cultural Resources
• Formal agency consultation should occur with regards to cultural resources. Based on public
sector data, the project area may have the following concerns regarding cultural resources: a
National Register of Historic Places property, Maryland Inventory of Historic Properties
within one (1) mile, and a Maryland Historical Trust Preservation Easement is within one (1)
mile of the project. Public sector data also indicates that the project is within one (1) mile of
Chesapeake Forest Lands. A visual effects assessment may be required at an additional cost.
Resource Studies (preliminary list):
• Wetland and waters of the U.S. delineation
• Critical Area Commission Review
• Habitat Suitability Assessment (based on agency consultation)
• Potential Targeted Rare, Threatened and Endangered Species (RTE) Species Surveys (based
on agency consultation)
• Visual Effects Assessment (given presence of NRHP in vicinity)
• Phase 1A Archaeological Assessment (the reconfiguration within new ROW)
• NEPA review (dependent on funding source/Federal stakeholders, etc.)
Real Estate
DPL will research the property rights for the existing transmission circuits ROW and the
specific pole locations and obtain any required road crossing permits and associated work.
The IC is to provide easements into the facility for DPL facilities at no expense to DPL prior to
construction.
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
12
7. Summary of Results of Study
Project Name: X1-096 Loretto- Kings Creek
138 kV Indirect Direct
TOTAL
($) Attachment Facilities n3732– New 138 kV
Position at Kings Creek Substation. Material Labor Material Labor
System Planning
105 1,500 1,605
Project Management & Special Billing
840 12,000 12,840
Outside Plant Communications
14 200 214
System Protection
350 5,000 5,350
Interconnection Arrangements
140 2,000 2,140
System Operations
105 1,500 1,605
Real Estate
350 5,000 5,350
Metering 388.5 210 5,550 3,000 9,149
Environmental Permitting
7490 107,000 114,490
Transmission Engineering & Construction
42 600 642
Substation Engineering & Construction $37,730 $46,100 539,000 922,000 1,544,830
TOTAL COST 38,119 55,746 544,550 1,059,800 1,698,215
15% Contingency 5,718 8,362 81,683 158,970 254,732
GRAND TOTAL 43,836 64,108 626,233 1,218,770 1,952,947
Project Name: X1-096 Loretto- Kings Creek
138 kV Indirect Direct
TOTAL ($) Attachment Facilities n3733– New
Transmission Switch Structure and Tap to
POI
Material Labor Material Labor
System Planning 28
400 428
Project Management & Special Billing 140
2,000 2,140
Outside Plant Communications 105 4683.6 1,500 66,908 73,197
System Protection 35
500 535
Interconnection Arrangements 14
200 214
System Operations 28
400 428
Real Estate 28
400 428
Environmental Permitting 42
600 642
Transmission Engineering & Construction 9,293 11,618 132,755 165,965 319,630
Substation Engineering & Construction 70 1,000 1,070
TOTAL COST 9,398 16,686 134,255 238,373 398,712
15% Contingency 1,410 2,503 20,138 35,756 59,807
GRAND TOTAL 10,808 19,189 154,393 274,129 458,519
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
13
Project Name: X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek
138 kV Indirect Direct
TOTAL ($)
Upgrade Facilities -Install OPGW on Ckt.
13713 Kings Creek to Loretto. Material Labor Material Labor
System Planning
42
600 642
Project Management & Special Billing
560
8,000 8,560
Outside Plant Communications 2,380 7,322 34,000 104,604 148,306
System Protection
56
800 856
Interconnection Arrangements
14
200 214
System Operations
105
1,500 1,605
Real Estate
700
10,000 10,700
Environmental Permitting
8,540
122,000 130,540
Transmission Engineering & Construction 16,100 58,309 230,000 832,990 1,137,399
Substation Engineering & Construction 35 500 535
TOTAL COST 18,480 75,684 264,000 1,081,194 1,439,358
15% Contingency 2,772 11,353 39,600 162,179 215,904
GRAND TOTAL 21,252 87,036 303,600 1,243,373 1,655,261
Generation projects meeting IRS "Safe Harbor" provisions generally do not incur
"CIAC"(Contribution in Aid to Construction), a tax collected by the utility for the state or federal
government. DPL does not expect to collect CIAC for this project. If for any reason, "CIAC" would be
required for this project, it would be the responsibility of the party owning the generator to pay this cost.
DPL reserves the right to charge the Interconnection Customer operation and maintenance expenses
to maintain the Interconnection Customer attachment facilities, including metering facilities, owned by
DPL.
8. Schedules and Assumptions
The DPL schedule is based on a 20-24 months lead-time from start of engineering to in-service date,
including the assumption that it would not be impacted by storm damage and restoration, time of year
limitations, permitting issues, outage scheduling, system emergencies, and contractor and equipment
availability.
It is important to note that this project will be incorporated into the existing project work load at DPL
at the time of contract execution. If the workload of existing projects is extensive, resource constraints
may cause this project to be delayed beyond the projected in-service date.
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
14
9. Other (Light Load Analysis)
Light Load analysis has been completed and no violations were found.
© PJM Interconnection 2014. All rights reserved. X1-096 Loretto-Kings Creek 138 kV
15
ATTACHMENT 1
X1 – 096
Kings Creek 138 kV
Pocomoke
138kV
Loretto
138kV
AT1
138/69kV
134
133130
NEW
131
132
T1
25kV
T2
25kV
Meter owned
By DPLPOI M
X1 - 096
If location of generator is
greater than 500 feet
from substation,
additional developer
circuit breaker will be
required.
DPL
Interconnection
Customer
POI Point of Interconnection