GENERAL PETRAEUS AND GENERAL MC CHRYSTAL COMPARED-US VIEWS

7/30/2019 GENERAL PETRAEUS AND GENERAL MC CHRYSTAL COMPARED-US VIEWS

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/general-petraeus-and-general-mc-chrystal-compared-us-views 1/50

ABGBUHD]BSUHRBR\

HGCABGBUHD

KLLNUZ\SHD

LIK]HUBC+PJBQ\ I@ R\ KJDJSHUZ

B^]BUS\



8> niru| hai

CrhgbRgìddiq

Crhgb Lh||jch ‥ Hanh \'$ J ci haubb qjsn snb }ubkj|b i` snb `ju|s husjldb snhs

snb Hkbujlhg kjdjshuz nh| eblikb jglubh|jgadz uhgf si}nbhpz' Crujga kz dh|s

siru jg Hànhgj|shg jg 5=88 hs J\H@ NX$ snbub qbub kiub snhg 0= `rdd lidigbd|

h||jagbc' Snb khoiujsz i` snb|b lidigbd| qbub cijga qiuf giukhddz nhgcdbc ez

Khoiu| hgc Ds Lidigbd|' Qb ci nhpb `hu sii khgz abgbuhd i``jlbu| h| qbdd' Snb

husjldb cjc gis hccub|| hgisnbu j||rb jgpidpjga njanbu uhgfjga i``jlbu|$ snhs

ebjga snb euifbg }uikisjig |z|sbk jg snb Hkbujlhg kjdjshuz' Sni|b i``jlbu|

qni hub hcb}s hs `jddjga snb |xrhub|$ j'b' abssjga snb ujans }i|sjga| hs snb ujans

sjkb hgc khfjga gis qhpb| hub uirsjgbdz }uikisbc' Hgz i``jlbu qni cbpjhsb|

ùik snb %lhubbu suhlf% j| }h||bc ipbu' Qb |nirdc gis eb |ru}uj|bc qnbg khgz

|bgjiu i``jlbu| hub jgb``blsjpb dbhcbu| dhlfjga jkhajghsjig hgc snb hejdjsz si

jg|}jub sni|b snbz hub h||jagbc si likkhgc'

88 niru| hai‥ Rgdjfb

‥ Ub}dz }ujphsbdz

‥ @dha h| jgh}}ui}ujhsb

8

UidhgcRgìddiq

http://www.linkedin.com/groupfollowing?unfollow=&followee=165921670&csrfToken=ajax%3A3073896924217968557&goback=%2Egde_1271127_member_194350920&trk=ufp_l



http://www.linkedin.com/groups?viewMemberFeed=&gid=1271127&memberID=165921670


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?setUnlike=&gid=1271127&type=member&item=194350920&commentID=108456075&csrfToken=ajax%3A3073896924217968557&trk=gde_unlkcmt&goback=%2Egde_1271127_member_194350920



http://www.linkedin.com/groupMsg?displayCreate=&contentType=MEBC&connId=165921670&groupID=1271127&goback=%2Egde_1271127_member_194350920


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?flag=&gid=1271127&type=member&item=194350920&commentID=108456075&flagReason=INA


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?trk=group_item_detail-b-show_lks-cmt


















Abgbuhd ]bsuhbr| hgc Abgbuhd Kl Lnuz|shd Lik}hubc ez h

R\ Jgsbddjabglb ]ui`b||jighddiq+jgsbg|jsz+lig`djls+ubpjbq'edia|}is'lik diq+jgsbg|jsz+lig`djls+

ubpjbq'edia|}is'lik

0 chz| hai

Djfb

Likkbgs

Rg`iddiq

@dha

Kiub

fbpjg ur``gbu$ ]hrd Chdz hgc 8 isnbu djfb snj|

3 likkbgs|

Hanh \nbu|nhn ‥ Snhgf| Fbpjg hgc ]hrd

0 chz| hai

‥ Cbdbsb

\sbpbRg`iddiq

http://www.linkedin.com/news?viewArticle=&articleID=31&gid=104181&type=member&item=194691539&articleURL=http%3A%2F%2Flow-intensity-conflict-review%2Eblogspot%2Ecom%2F2012%2F12%2Fgeneral-petraeus-and-general-mc%2Ehtml&urlhash=uVin&goback=%2Egde_104181_member_194691539


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?setLike=&gid=104181&type=member&item=194691539&csrfToken=ajax%3A2378743506244622633


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?view=&gid=104181&type=member&item=194691539&commentID=-1#lastComment


http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem






http://www.linkedin.com/groups?viewMemberFeed=&gid=104181&memberID=70626852&goback=%2Egde_104181_member_194691539





http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?trk=group_item_detail-b-show_lks-disc





http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?deleteItem=&gid=104181&type=member&item=194691539























\sbpb Orgabu| ‥ Aiic si abs h pjbq i` snb|b kbg ig h }bu|ighd dbpbd$ gis or|s

snb }redjl }bu|igh'

\sbpb

2 chz| hai‥ Rgdjfb

5

fbpjgRgìddiq

fbpjg ur``gbu ‥ Crhgb Lh||jch ‥ Hanh \'$ J ci haubb qjsn snb }ubkj|b i` snb

`ju|s husjldb snhs snb Hkbujlhg kjdjshuz nh| eblikb jglubh|jgadz uhgf si}nbhpz'

Crujga kz dh|s siru jg Hànhgj|shg jg 5=88 hs J\H@ NX$ snbub qbub kiub snhg

0= `rdd lidigbd| h||jagbc' Snb khoiujsz i` snb|b lidigbd| qbub cijga qiuf

giukhddz nhgcdbc ez Khoiu| hgc Ds Lidigbd|' Qb ci nhpb `hu sii khgz abgbuhd

i``jlbu| h| qbdd' Snb husjldb cjc gis hccub|| hgisnbu j||rb jgpidpjga njanbu

uhgfjga i``jlbu|$ snhs ebjga snb euifbg }uikisjig |z|sbk jg snb Hkbujlhg

kjdjshuz' Sni|b i``jlbu| qni hub hcb}s hs `jddjga snb |xrhub|$ j'b' abssjga snb

ujans }i|sjga| hs snb ujans sjkb hgc khfjga gis qhpb| hub uirsjgbdz }uikisbc'

Hgz i``jlbu qni cbpjhsb| ùik snb %lhubbu suhlf% j| }h||bc ipbu' Qb |nirdc gis

eb |ru}uj|bc qnbg khgz |bgjiu i``jlbu| hub jgb``blsjpb dbhcbu| dhlfjga

jkhajghsjig hgc snb hejdjsz si jg|}jub sni|b snbz hub h||jagbc si likkhgc'

88 niru| hai‥ Rgdjfb‥ Ub}dz }ujphsbdz‥ @dha h| jgh}}ui}ujhsb

8

Uidhgc

Rgìddiq

Uidhgc \s' Abukhjg ‥ Crhgb$ J nhpb hd|i |bbg snb Hju @iulb i``jlbu sz}b| qni

qbub kiub liglbugbc heirs snbju gb~s |sh`` h||jagkbgs snhg jg abssjga snb oiecigb' J hk h R\H@ %Kr|shga% qjsn ipbu 8< zbhu| }ujiu |bupjlb h| h Ur||jhg

snbg Lbln djgarj|s .\JAJGS liddblsiu*' J nhpb |bbg i``jlbu| likb hgc ai$ snb





















aiic hgc snb ehc' J nhc igb Ds' Lid sbdd kb nb qh| aijga si khfb %`rdd ejuc%

eh|bc ig snb qiuf J qh| aijga si ci ìu njk' .Nb cjcg!s dh|s sii diga hgc nj|

hssjsrcb qh| qnhs ìulbc njk si ubsjub' Kz dh|s siru i` crsz h| h Lh}shjg qh| hs

snb ]bgshaig qiufjga Jgsbd \r}}ius si BL hgc BQ' Snbub qbub dis| i` Ds' Lid|

hgc Lidigbd| urggjga huirgc suzjga si khfb ghkb| ìu snbk|bdpb|' Hd|i snbub

qbub h grkebu i` Khoiu| jg snb }uikisjig nrgs' H| h Lh}shjg qjsn ipbu 5=

zbhu| i` hlsjpb crsz hgc sii idc si eb lig|jcbubc ìu }uikisjig$ J liglbgsuhsbc

ig kz oie' J nhc ]L\!jga Lidigbd| qhgsjga si shfb kb qjsn snbk si snbju gb~s

h||jagkbgs h| J qh| lh}hedb i` abssjga snb oie cigb b``jljbgsdz hgc liuublsdz' J

hd|i h}}hubgsdz nhc h fghlf i` |bbjga snuiran snb E\ hgc abssjga si snb }ijgs'

Qbdd$ si khfb h diga |siuz |nius$ J haubb ùik `ju|s nhgc ie|buphsjig snhs `jddjga

snb ujans |xrhub| hgc gis sbddjga snb sursn si }iqbub qjdd abs zir }uikisbc'

Niqbpbu$ qnbg snb }uipbuejhd \''' njs| snb `hg$js j| snb cibu| snhs hub lhddbcr}ig ez |bgjiu| si abs snb oie cigb' Jg sjkb| i` luj|j| snbz hub njandz phdrbc'

Snbg h`sbu snb luj|j| snb |z|sbk shfb| ipbu hahjg hgc snb aiic igb| %`hcb

hqhz'%

2 chz| hai‥ Djfb

@iddiq Fjuf Oing

Fjuf Oing Dhu|ig$ KEH$ K]K ‥ H| snhs J hk h ìukbu R\ Hukz kbkebu

hgc lruubgsdz h ligsuhlsiu jg Hànhgj|shg$ J lhg hsb|s snhs snb R\ Hukz j|

bgsbujga h }bujic i` |bpbub suhg|jsjig' Snb ghsrub hgc |surlsrub i` snb R\ Hukz

nh| ebbg |i hdsbubc ez }idjsjl| hgc snb jg`drbglb i` ubsjubb|$ snhs }ui`b||jighddz$

snb R\ Hukz j| gi digabu lh}hedb i` diga sbuk illr}hsjighd iu bgcrujga

likehs i}buhsjig|' Js| ipbuhdd cb}bgcbglb ig ligsuhlsiu| hgc js| jghejdjsz si

h}}dz khg+}iqbu |sj}rdhsb| h |bujir| |repbu|jig i` suhcjsjighd Hukz

i}buhsjig|'

H| hg irs|jcbu$ giq diifjga jg$ J qirdc huarb snhs snb subgc j| h |z|sbkhsjl

cj|khgsdjga i` snb bgdj|sbc uhgf|' Niqbpbu$ snj| subgc hd|i h}}bhu| si eb aubhsdz

http://www.linkedin.com/groupItem?setLike=&gid=104181&type=member&item=194691539&commentID=108574087&csrfToken=ajax%3A2378743506244622633&trk=gde_lkcmt&goback=%2Egde_104181_member_194691539



http://www.linkedin.com/groupfollowing?follow=&followee=39351670&csrfToken=ajax%3A2378743506244622633&goback=%2Egde_104181_member_194691539&trk=fwp_l










Fjuf Oing Dhu|ig$ KEH$ K]K ‥ Snhs j| snb ghsrub i` ub}ub|bgshsjpb |iljbsz'

Snb }bi}db hdqhz| bdbls sni|b qni ub}ub|bgs snb `h|njig i` snb sjkb|' H| snb

sjkb| lnhgab ubdhsjpb si snb ligcjsjig| hgc hssjsrcb|$ snb ub}ub|bgshsjig

lnhgab|'8 chz hai‥ Djfb

@iddiq Kjfb

Kjfb Rkjg|fj ‥ H| h pjbsghk pbsbuhg$ J nidc snb|b eisn Abgbuhd| jg snb

njanb|s b|sbbk$ ers snb db`sj|s kbcjh qjdd hdqhz| sbhug ciqg aiic hgc nigb|s

kjdjshuz khg'8 chz hai‥ Djfb

@iddiq Fjuf Oing

Fjuf Oing Dhu|ig$ KEH$ K]K ‥ Snb kbcjh nh| gi isnbu uidb giq ers si

cb|suiz bpbuzsnjga snb R\ |siic ìu' Si hlnbjpb js| aihd|$ snb R\ kjdjshuz kr|s

eb ubkipbc h| h ìulb h| js j| snb igdz ìulb lh}hedb i` }ub|bupjga snblig|sjsrsjig cb|}jsb js| `hjdrub| jg snb ublbgs }h|s' Iglb snb kjdjshuz ubhdjb| snb

}idjsjlhd ieoblsjpb si cb|siuz snb R\ ùik qjsnjg' Snbg dhq bgìulbkbgs lhg

snbg }uilbbc qjsn bgcjga iru cikb|jsl bgbkjb|' Ers snb cikb|sjl b`ìus j|

lruubgsdz hg bgsjsdbkbgs }uilb|| snhs ìulb| h lnijlb' Bjsnbu snb }bi}db lhg eb

}uisblsbc iu js lhg eb bgoiz snbju bgsjsdbkbgs|' Snhs j| qnbg snb }idjlb |shsb

ebajg|' Snb luj|j| j| snb fbz qnjln kr|s eb nhgcdbc }ui}budz' Snhs luj|j| j| snb

R\ bligikjl `hjdrub hgc snb kjdjshuz j| snb shuabs ìu cb`rgcjga hgc snb R\

snbg `hdd| jgsi h sishdjshujhg |surlsrub qjsn igb }idjsjlhd }husz$ ghkbdz snb

Cbkiluhs|' Snj| j| snb aihd i` snb Cbkiluhs|$ hg igb }husz |z|sbk qjsn hdd}idjljga }iqbu| rgcbu cbkiluhs }husz ligsuid hgc |jglb snb kbcjh j| rgcbu

cbkiluhs ligsuid$ snb suhg|jsjig qjdd eb h ubahucbc h| h ghsruhd }uiaub||jig i`

snb }idjsjlhd }uilb||' Snbg snb cj|idrsjigkbgs i` Ligaub|| hgc snb \shsb






























aipbugkbgs| qnjln bgc| hdd snb bdblsjig| jg snb lirgsuz hgc sni|b jg }iqbu

qjdd ubkhjg jg }iqbu ìubpbu'

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Auir}? Qhusjkb ]ui`b||jighd|℥

Cj|lr||jig? Nh| R\ Hukz| Kjdjshuz Pjusrb Cbsbujiuhsbc 9

Ubsrug si ljulh 5==8 sjkb+ùhkb hgc snb lik}bsbglz i` snb ]iqbddCilsujgb pbu|r| snhs i` Abgbuhd| ]bsuhbr| hgc KlLnuz|shd' J|g!s js sjkbsi hckjs snhs snb dhssbu sqi Abgbuhd| hgc snbju r|b i` \}bljhd I}buhsjig|

.jgldrcjga cuigb|* nhpb ebbg kiub igbuir|9 Giq snhs qb |bb snb Juhxub|rds| qb lhg |rkkhujb ]bsuhbr| h| h `hjdrub jg lik}huj|ig siAbgbuhd Bujl F' \njg|bfj!| h||busjig| heirs Juhx‚| qhu' Qnbg lik}hubcsi Ei|gjh qb khz eb arjdsz i` khgz Qhu Lujkb| jg Juhx hgc Hànhgj|shghgc `rusnbu lik}hubc si h ]iqbdd cilsujgb qnbub qb |nirdc nhpb|bhdbc snb eiucbu| jg Juhx hgc cb}diz iru ìdf| jg kh||jpb grkebu| siedrgs hgz i``bg|jpb qnjdb r|jga iru \}bljhd I}buhsjig| @iulb| kiubb``blsjpbdz9

]i|sbc ez Nbuebus Gbd|ig Ou

++++++++

nss}?))diq+jgsbg|jsz+lig`djls+

ubpjbq'edia|}is'lik)5=88)=3)abgbuhd+}bsuhbr|+nidb+

}rglnbu'nskd

http://www.linkedin.com/e/daf8v8-hax1mu7k-y/vaq/196897586/4244984/109820451/view_disc/?hs=false&tok=2GD-K-U3dLRBw1



http://low-intensity-conflict-review.blogspot.com/2011/04/general-petraeus-hole-puncher.html










Qb cjc eujga irs snb hkejarir|R\ uidb jg H`anhg qhu jg iru eiif}redj|nbc ez Bcqjg Kbddbg ]ub||

Gbq Ziuf'



Snbz `irgc snb R\ Hukz lhubbui``jlbu| }dharbc qjsn ljpjdjhg%khghabujhd% phdrb| hgc cbpijc i` suhcjsjighd kjdjshuz pjusrb| '

@uik qnhs J |hq i` R\ Hukz jgH`anhgj|shg h| h |re ligsuhlsiu i` R\HJC jg Nbdkhgc $Anhgj hgc

Frgcr }uipjglb| snb h||b||kbgsi` Aheujbd hgc \hphab |sjdd |bbk|phdjc'J ub`bu si snb kjc dbpbd hgc

njanbu likkhgcbu|'



http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-u0DgLOw2ZB0/TaFUG_2EFOI/AAAAAAAAGxY/z3D6WdzNA4k/s1600/USACMH.jpg



Snb Shdjehg| kipb qjsn djebuszehlf hgc `iusn snuiran ki|s i` snb 8:== Fk i` snb sishd 53== FkH`anhg ]hfj|shg Eiucbu'

Hdd snj| njgs| hs snb `hls snhs R\}i|jsjig j| hkejarir| hgc js |bb|

Shdjehg h| h aiic `rsrub h||bshahjg|s Juhg $Ur||jh hgc bpbg

Lnjgh h| `hu h| Lnjgb|b \jgafjhgaqnjln R\ snjgfbu| djfb si lhddLnjgb|b Srufb|shg (



http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-lHMoGU8mHVw/TaFWEE9_GsI/AAAAAAAAGxg/uWTF1__Wj3o/s1600/Grand+Strat+Contradictions+Afg-747860.jpg



hgc ]hfj|shg j| h| si qni j| snb

shuabs ( Snb ]hfj|shgj kjdjshuz |bb|snbju Shdjehg h||bs| h| }ui~jb|hahjg|s Jgcjh qnjdb snb R\ qhgs|snb Shdjehg si eb `rsrub R\ h||bs|hahjg|s Juhg $Ur||jh$Ur||jhg

Lbgsuhd H|jhg |hssbddjsb |shsb| hgcheipb hdd Lnjgh (

Gisnjga jg snb dh|s sbg zbhu| njgs|

snhs snb R\H lhkb si cb`bhs snbShdjehg iu Hd Xhbch'

Snb Hd Xhbch nh| |jagj`jlhgsdz

lig|idjchsbc js| eh|b| jg GiusnBh|s H`anhgj|shg 'Ers Abgbuhd

]bsuhbr| qni ldhjk| nb lhg urg

`jpb kjdb| qjsn oirughdj|s| jg snb|h`bsz i` Fherd iu Ehauhk snjgf|

isnbu qj|b (



Snj| j| snb ldh||jl Aheujbd hgc\hphab R\ Hukz abgbuhd `dzjganjan jg nj| likkhgc }dhgb ( Kjdb|hqhz ùik chgabu qnjdb Aheujbd

hgc \hphab |hcdz lik}hubc R\Hukz qjsn Abukhg Hukz qnbubeisn gisbc snhs << " abgbuhd

i``jlbu| cjbc jg ehssdb dbhcjga ùiksnb ùigs (

Nbub qb nhpb snj| aubhs lh}shjg i` qhu qni j| hdd |bs si dbhc snb LJH (

Lbushjgdz igb j| jgldjgbc si haubbqjsn Qbjgbu| eiif ig LJH % SnbH|nb|% '

Js j| lbushjg snhs R\ }idjsjl| h|ki|s }idjsjl| j| heirs |bd` |bupjga



http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-oRqHlAXSfww/TaFYo3B6V4I/AAAAAAAAGxs/Irb38fh5D80/s1600/86768ij7.jpg



/ R\ likkhgcbu |hz| snbub nh|ebbg |ikb b~}diuhsjig ìu}isbgsjhd |h`b nhpbg| jg Gruj|shg$Frghu

/ Lig`juk| si ub}iusbu| nb j|

gbaisjhsjga nj| gb~s oie

FHERD? Snb si} likkhgcbu i` R\

hgc GHSI ìulb| |hjc \hsruchzsnhs qnjdb |ikb hd Xhbch `jansbu|

nhpb ebbg |bhulnjga ìu njcbirs|jg uraabc hubh| i` bh|sbugHànhgj|shg$ nb cib| gis snjgf

snbz hub khfjga h likbehlfjg|jcb snb lirgsuz'

—Snbub j| gi xrb|sjig snhs hd

Xhbch nh| nhc h }ub|bglb jgHànhgj|shg hgc ligsjgrb| si nhpb



h }ub|bglb$‛ Abgbuhd Chpjc

]bsuhbr| sidc ub}iusbu| hs snblihdjsjig’| nbhcxrhusbu| jg snbHànhg lh}jshd'

Ers nb hccbc? —Snbub lbushjgdz nh|ebbg |ikb b~}diuhsjig ìu

}isbgsjhd |h`b nhpbg| iu|hglsrhujb| jg pbuz kirgshjgir|hubh| i` Gruj|shg hgc }hus| i`

Frghu }uipjglb|' Iru jgsbgsjig$qjsn iru Hànhg }husgbu|$ j| sikhjgshjg }ub||rub ig sni|b qnihub |bbfjga si b|shedj|n |h`b

nhpbg|'‛

Bhudjbu snj| qbbf$ Snb Qhdd \subbs

Oirughd ub}iusbc snhs crujga snb}h|s |j~ si bjans kigsn|$ hd Xhbch

`jansbu| nhc ebbg |bssjga r}suhjgjga lhk}|$ njcbirs| hgc



eh|b| hdiga Hànhgj|shg’|

giusnbh|sbug eiucbu qjsn]hfj|shg'

Snb gbq|}h}bu ljsbc R\$ Hànhg

hgc Shdjehg i``jljhd| hgc xrisbc hgrgghkbc |bgjiu R\ kjdjshuz i``jlbu

h| |hzjga ‗hd Xhbch j| likjgaehlf'’

\}bhfjga qjsn ub}iusbu| h`sbu h

`hubqbdd lbubkigz ìu GHSI’| si}

ljpjdjhg ub}ub|bgshsjpb$ Khuf\bcqjdd$ ]bsuhbr| |hjc snb ublbgs

cbhsn| i` |bpbg RG qiufbu| jgKhhu+b+\nhuj` jg giusnbug

Hànhgj|shg qirdc gis h``bls }dhg|

ìu Hànhg |blrujsz ìulb| si |shusshfjga snb dbhc ìu |blrujsz jg snb

}uipjgljhd lh}jshd snj| |rkkbu'

GENERAL PETRAEUS AND GENERAL MC CHRYSTAL COMPARED-US VIEWS

Documents

Transcript of GENERAL PETRAEUS AND GENERAL MC CHRYSTAL COMPARED-US VIEWS