7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

1/28

$UWDVD&XOWXUDO6\VWHP

$XWKRUV&OLIIRUG*HHUW]5HYLHZHGZRUNV6RXUFH0/19RO1R&RPSDUDWLYH/LWHUDWXUH'HFSS3XEOLVKHGE\The Johns Hopkins University Press6WDEOH85/http://www.jstor.org/stable/2907147 .

$FFHVVHG

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms

of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

.

The Johns Hopkins University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to

MLN.

http://www.jstor.org

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=jhuphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/2907147?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/2907147?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=jhup

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

2/28

$ 57$6$&8/785$/ 6

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

3/28

&/,))25' *((57=

WDONZKHUHRIQHFDQQRWVSHDNWKHUHRIQHPXVWEHVLOHQWHHPVOLNHYHU\DWWUDFWLYHRFWULQH%XWRIFRXUVHKDUGO\Q\RQHVDYHWKHWUXO\QGLIIHUHQWVWKXVVLOHQWUWLVWVQFOXGHG2QWKHFRQWUDU\KHSHUFHSWLRQRIVRPHWKLQJPSRUWDQWQHLWKHUSDUWLFXODUZRUNVRULQWKHDUWVJHQHUDOO\PRYHVSHRSOHWRWDONDQGZULWHERXWWKHPQFHVVDQWO\RPHWKLQJWKDWPHDQLQJIXORXVFDQQRWEHOHIWXVWWRVLWWKHUHEDWKHGLQSXUHVLJQLILFDQFHQGVRZHGHVFULEHDQDO\VHFRPSDUHXGJHFODVVLI\ZHHUHFWWKHRULHVDERXWFUHDWLYLW\RUPSHUFHSWLRQVRFLDOIXQFWLRQZHFKDUDFWHUL]HUWDVDODQJXDJHDVWUXFWXUHV\VWHPQDFWDV\PEROSDWWHUQRIIHHOLQJZHUHDFKIRUVFLHQWLILFPHWDSKRUVVSLULWXDOQHVWHFKQRORJLFDOQHVSROLWLFDORQHVDQGLIDOOHOVHIDLOVZHVWULQJDUNVD\LQJVRJHWKHUQGKRSHVRPHRQHHOVHZLOOOXGLFDWHWKHPIRUXV7KH VXUIDFHERRWOHVVQHVVRIWDONLQJDERXWDUWVHHPVPDWFKHGE\DGHSWKQHFHVVLW\RWDONERXWLWHQGOHVVO\$QGLWVWKLVSHFXOLDUVWDWHIDIIDLUVKDWZDQWKHUHWRSUREHQSDUWWRH[SODLQWEXWHYHQPRUHWRGHWHUPLQHZKDWGLIIHUHQFHWPDNHV7RVRPHGHJUHHDUWLVHYHU\ZKHUHDONHGDERXWLQZKDWPD\EHFDOOHGFUDIWHUPVLQWHUPVRIWRQDOSURJUHVVLRQVRORUUHODWLRQVRUSURVRGLFVKDSHV7KLVLVHVSHFLDOO\WUXHLQWKH:HVWZKHUHVXEMHFWVOLNHKDUPRQ\USLFWRULDORPSRVLWLRQKDYHEHHQGHYHORSHGWRWKHSRLQWRIPLQRUFLHQFHVQGWKHPRGHUQPRYHWRZDUGHVWKHWLFIRUPDOLVPEHVWUHSUHVHQWHGULJKWQRZE\VWUXFWXUDOLVPQGE\WKRVHYDULHWLHVRIVHPLRWLFVZKLFKVHHNWRIROORZWVHDGLVEXWDQDWWHPSWRJHQHUDOL]HWKLVDSSURDFKLQWRDFRPSUHKHQVLYHRQHWRFUHDWHDWHFKQLFDODQJXDJHFDSDEOHRIUHSUHVHQWLQJWKHLQWHUQDOUHODWLRQVRIP\WKVRHPVGDQFHVRUPHORGLHVLQDEVWUDFWUDQVSRVDEOHWHUPV%XWWKHFUDIWSSURDFKWRDUWWDONVKDUGO\RQILQHGWRHLWKHUWKH:HVWRUWKHPRGHUQDJHDVWKHHODERUDWHWKHRULHVRI,QGLDQPXVLFRORJ\DYDQHVHFKRUHRJUDSK\$UDELFYHUVLILFDWLRQU

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

4/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

5/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

6/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

7/28

&/,))25' *((57=

7KH LQWHQVHFRQFHUQRIWKH

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

8/28

0/ 1 7RGHYHORSWKHSRLQWPRUHFRQFUHWHO\QGWRGLVVLSDWHDQ\QWHOOHFWXDOLVWUOLWHUDU\XUDVXFKZRUGVDVLGHDWLRQDODQGFRQFHS

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

9/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

10/28

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

$FRPPRQUHVSRQVHWRWKLVVRUWRIDUJXPHQWVSHFLDOO\ZKHQLWFRPHVIURPWKHVLGHRIDQWKURSRORJLVWVVWRVD\WKDWPD\EHDOOZHOODQGJRRGIRUSULPLWLYHVZKRFRQIXVHWKHUHDOPVRIWKHLUH[SHULHQFHLQWRRQHODUJHXQUHIOHFWLYHZKROHEXWLWGRHVQWDSSO\WR

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

11/28

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

,ELGS,ELGS

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

12/28

0/ 1 GHHSHQKXPDQDZDUHQHVVRIWKHVSLULWXDOGLPHQVLRQVRIH[LVWHQFHWKH\ZHUHYLVXDOQYLWDWLRQVRUHIOHFWLRQVQWKHWUXWKVI&KULVWLDQLW\)DFHGZLWKDQDUUHVWLQJPDJHRI7KH$QQXQFLDWLRQ7KH$VVXPSWLRQIWKH9LUJLQ7KH$GRUDWLRQRIWKH0DJL7KH&KDUJHWR6W3HWHUU7KH3DVVLRQWKHEHKROGHUZDVWRFRPSOHWHWE\UHIOHFWLQJRQWKHHYHQWDVKHNQHZLWDQGRQKLVSHUVRQDOUHODWLRQVKLSRWKHP\VWHULHVWUHFRUGHG)RULWVRQHWKLQJWRDGRUHDSDLQWLQJDVD'RPLQLFDQSUHDFKHUGHIHQGLQJWKHYLUWXRXVQHVVIDUWSXWLWEXWLWLVTXLWHDQRWKHUWROHDUQIURPDSDLQWHGQDUUDWLYHZKDWWRDGRUH

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

13/28

&/,))25' *((57=

IRUWKKHW\SHVRIDWWLWXGHGLVTXLHWUHIOHFWLRQQTXLU\KXPLOLW\GLJQLW\GPLUDWLRQDSSURSULDWHWRHDFKDVZHOODVRIIHULQJLFWDDVWRKRZVXFKPDWWHUVZHUHUHSUHVHQWHGYLVXDOO\ZHUHSUREDEO\WKHPRVWPSRUWDQW3RSXODUSUHDFKHUV GULOOHGWKHLURQJUHJDWLRQVLQD VHWRILQWHUSUHWLYHVNLOOVULJKWDWWKHFHQWUHRIWKHILIWHHQWKFHQWXU\HVSRQVHWRSDLQWLQJHVWXUHVZHUHFODVVLILHGSK\VLRJQRPLHVW\SHGFRORUVV\PERORJL]HGQGWKHSK\VLFDODSSHDUDQFHRIFHQWUDOILJXUHVGLVFXVVHGZLWKDSRORJHWLFDOFDUH

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

14/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

15/28

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

WLRQVRIVLPSOHUPRUHUHJXODUDQGPRUHFRPSUHKHQVLEOHRQHV,ELGS ,ELG

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

16/28

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

,ELGSS0%D[DQGDOO*LRWWRQGWKH2UDWRUV2[IRUG

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

17/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

7KHUHLVKDUGO\EHWWHU[DPSOHRIWKHIDFWWKDWDQDUWLVWZRUNVZLWKVLJQVZKLFKKDYHDSODFHLQVHPLRWLFV\VWHPV[WHQGLQJIDUEH\RQGWKHFUDIWKHSUDFWLFHVWKDQWKHSRHWLQ,VODP$0XVOLPPDNLQJYHUVHVIDFHVD VHWRIFXOWXUDOUHDOLWLHVDVREMHFWLYHWRKLVLQWHQWLRQVVURFNVRUUDLQIDOOQROHVVVXEVWDQWLDOIRUEHLQJQRQ

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

18/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

19/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

20/28

0/ 1 UHLQIRUFHGE\WKHZKROHSDWWHUQRIWUDGLWLRQDO0XVOLPLIH$OPRVWHYHU\ER\DQGPRUHUHFHQWO\PDQ\JLUOVDVZHOOJRHVWRDGULOOVFKRROZKHUHKHOHDUQVWRUHFLWHDQGPHPRUL]HYHUVHVIURPWKH4XUDQ,IKHLVDGHSWDQGGLOLJHQWKHPD\JHWWKHZKROHRUVRE\KHDUWDQGEHFRPHDKDIL]PHPRUL]HUQGEULQJDFHUWDLQFHOHEULW\RKLVSDUHQWVIVLVPRUHOLNHO\HLVQRWKHZLOODWOHDVWOHDUQHQRXJKWRFRQGXFWKLVSUD\HUVXWFKHUFKLFNHQVQGIROORZVHUPRQVIKHLVHVSHFLDOO\SLRXVKHPD\HYHQJRWRDKLJKHUFKRROLQVRPHXUEDQFHQWHUOLNH)H]RU0DUUDNHFKDQGREWDLQDPRUHH[DFWVHQVHRIWKHPHDQLQJRIZKDWKHKDVPHPRUL]HG%XWZKHWKHUDPDQFRPHVDZD\ZLWKKDQGIXORIKDOIXQGHUVWRRGHUVHVRUWKHHQWLUHFROOHFWLRQUHDVRQDEO\FRPSUHKHQGHGWKHPDLQVWUHVVVDOZD\VRQUHFLWDWLRQQGRQWKHURWHOHDUQLQJQHFHVVDU\WRLW:KDW+RGJVRQKDVVDLGRIPHGLHYDO,VODPWKDWDOOVWDWHPHQWVZHUHVHHQDVHLWKHUWUXHRUIDOVHWKDWWKHVXPRIDOOWUXHVWDWHPHQWVIL[HGFRUSXVUDGLDWLQJIURPKH4XUDQZKLFKWHDVWPSOLFLWO\RQWDLQHGWKHPDOOZDVNQRZOHGJHDQGWKDWWKHZD\WRREWDLQNQRZOHGJHZDVWRFRPPLWWRPHPRU\WKHSKUDVHVLWZDVVWDWHGLQFRXOG EHVDLGWRGD\IRUWKHJUHDWHUSDUWRI0RURFFRZKHUHZKDWHYHUZHDNHQLQJIDLWKKDVH[SHULHQFHGLWKDV\HWWRUHOD[LWVSDVVLRQIRUUHFLWDEOHWUXWK6XFKDWWLWXGHVDQG VXFKWUDLQLQJHDGWRHYHU\GD\OLIHEHLQJSXQFWXDWHGE\LQHVIURPKH4XUDQDQGRWKHUFODVVLFDOWDJV$VLGHIURPKHVSHFLILFDOO\HOLJLRXVFRQWH[WVWKHGDLO\SUD\HUVKH)ULGD\ZRUVKLSKHPRVTXHVHUPRQVKHEHDGWHOOLQJDQWDWLRQVQWKHP\VWLFDOEURWKHUKRRGVWKHUHFLWDORIWKHZKROHERRNRQVSHFLDORFFDVLRQVVXFKDVWKH)DVWPRQWKKHRIIHULQJIYHUVHVDWIXQHUDOVZHGGLQJVDQGFLUFXPFLVLRQVRUGLQDU\FRQYHUVDWLRQVODFHGZLWK4XUDQLFIRUPXODHWRWKHSRLQWZKHUHHYHQWKHPRVWPXQGDQHVXEMHFWVVHHPVHWLQD VDFUHGIUDPH7KH PRVWLPSRUWDQWSXEOLFVSHHFKHVWKRVH IURPWKHWKURQHIRUH[DPSOHDUH FDVWLQDQ$UDELFVRFODVVLFL]HGWKDWPRVWZKRKHDUWKHPEXWYDJXHO\XQGHUVWDQGWKHP$UDELFQHZVSDSHUVPDJD]LQHVQGERRNVDUHZULWWHQQDVLPLODUPDQQHUZLWKKHUHVXOWKDWKHQXPEHURISHRSOHZKRFDQUHDGWKHPVVPDOO7KHFU\RI$UDEL]DWLRQWKHSRSXODUGHPDQGVZHSWIRUZDUGE\UHOLJLRXVSDVVLRQVIRUFRQGXFWLQJHGXFDWLRQLQFODVVLFDO$UDELFDQGXVLQJWQJRYHUQPHQWQGDGPLQLVWUDWLRQLVDSRWHQWGHRORJLFDOIRUFHHDGLQJWRDJUHDWGHDORIOLQJXLVWLF\SRF

,ELG9RO,,S

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

21/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

22/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

23/28

&/,))25' *((57=

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

$VWLQJ\KRVWIDUHVQREHWWHU$VIRUKLPZKRVVWLQJ\QGZHDNKHXVWVLWVKHUHDQGGRHVQWDUHVD\Q\WKLQJ7KH\ZKRFDPHIRUGLQQHUZHUHVLQDSULVRQWKHIRRGZDVVREDG@7KHSHRSOHZHUHKXQJU\OOQLJKWQGQHYHUDWLVILHG7KHKRVWVZLIHSHQWKHHYHQLQJRLQJVVKHSOHDVHG%\*RGVKHGLGQWYHQZDQWRJHWXSDQGJHWWKHFRIIHHUHDG\

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

24/28

0/ 1 $QGDFXUHUDIRUPHUIULHQGZLWKZKRPWKHSRHWKDVIDOOHQRXWJHWVWKLUW\LQHVRIWKHIROORZLQJRUWRIWKLQJ2KWKHFXUHUVQRORQJHUUHDVRQDEOHPDQ+HIROORZHGKHURDGWREHFRPHSRZHUIXO$QGFKDQJHGQWRPDGEHWUD\HU+HIROORZHGWUDGHIWKHGHYLOKHVDLGKHZDVVXFFHVVIXOXWGRQWEHOLHYHW$QGVRRQ1RULVLWPHUHO\QGLYLGXDOVWKHSRHWFULWLFLVHVRUFDQEHSDLGWRFULWLFLVHRUPRVWRIWKHVHYHUEDODVVDVVLQDWLRQVUHFRQWUDFWREVWKHLQKDELWDQWVIDULYDOYLOODJHRUIDFWLRQUIDPLO\

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

25/28

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

26/28

0/ 1 ,Q VKRUWQVSHHFKWHUPVRUPRUHH[DFWO\VSHHFKDFWWHUPVSRHWU\LHVLQEHWZHHQWKHGLYLQHPSHUDWLYHVIWKH4XUDQDQGWKH

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

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

27/28

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

1*RRGPDQ/DQJXDJHVRI$UW,QGLDQDSROLVS-0DTXHW,QWURGXFWLRQWR$HVWKHWLF$QWKURSRORJ\0DFDOHE0RGXOHQ$QWKURSRORJ\5HDGLQJ0DVVS

7/30/2019 Geertz_76_Art as a Cultural System.pdf

28/28

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