8/2/2019 GAO Interim SIPC Report Madoff Liquidation

1/78

PG@W_IQIGPIB\GPQH_S_HQG@QIHB@H_SH_KQIHB

Ibqgrin _gshrq hb qjgNkahll Di{wiakqihbSrh`ggaibm

_gshrq qh @hbmrgppihbkd _g{wgpqgrp

Nkr`j ?3;?

MKH.;?.1;1

Wbiqga Pqkqgp Mh|grbngbq K``hwbqkoidiqy Hlli`g

MKH

8/2/2019 GAO Interim SIPC Report Madoff Liquidation

2/78

Wbiqga Pqkqgp Mh|grbngbq K``hwbqkoidiqy Hlli`g

Jimjdimjqp hlMKH.;?.1;1$ k rgshrq qh`hbmrgppihbkd rg{wgpqgrp

Nkr`j ?3;?

PG@W_IQIGP IB\GPQH_ S_HQG@QIHB

@H_SH_KQIHB

Ibqgrin _gshrq hb qjg Nkahll Di{wiakqihbSrh`ggaibm

]jy MKH Aia Qjip Pqway

]iqj qjg `hddkspg hl Ogrbkra D" NkahllIb|gpqngbq Pg`wriqigp$ DD@k orhfgr.agkdgr kba ib|gpqngbq ka|iphry lirn}iqj qjhwpkbap hl `digbqpOgrbkraNkahll kaniqqga qh rgshrqibm !7="?oiddihb ib li`qiqihwp `wpqhngr jhdaibmp"Qjg Pg`wriqigp Ib|gpqhr Srhqg`qihb@hrshrkqihb *PIS@)$ }ji`j h|grpggp klwba srh|iaibm ws qh !733$333 hl

srhqg`qihb qh {wkdilyibm ibai|iawkd`wpqhngrp hl lkidga pg`wriqigp lirnp$pgdg`qga k qrwpqgg qh di{wiakqg qjgNkahll lirn kba rg`h|gr kppgqp lhr iqpib|gpqhrp" Qjg ngqjha qjg Qrwpqgg ipwpibm qh agqgrnibg jh} nw`j k`wpqhngr lidibm k `dkin `hwda og gdimiodgqh rg`h|grkb knhwbq fbh}b kp bgqg{wiqyjkp oggb qjg pwoeg`q hlaipswqg kba diqimkqihb" Qjip rgshrqaip`wppgp *;) jh} qjg Qrwpqgg kbaqrwpqggp `hwbpgd }grg pgdg`qga$ *?)}jy qjg ngqjha lhr |kdwibm `wpqhngr`dkinp }kp `jhpgb$ *0) `hpqp hl qjg

di{wiakqihb$ kba *1) aip`dhpwrgp qjgQrwpqgg jkp nkag kohwq iqp srhmrgpp"MKH gzknibga qjg Pg`wriqigp Ib|gpqhrSrhqg`qihb K`q6 `hwrq lidibmp kbaag`ipihbp6 kba PIS@$ Pg`wriqigp kbaGz`jkbmg @hnnippihb *PG@)$ kbaQrwpqgg rgshrqp kba rg`hrap" MKHkbkdyuga `hpq lidibmp kba ibqgr|ig}gaPIS@$ PG@$ kba PG@ Ibpsg`qhrMgbgrkd hlli`ikdp$ kba qjg Qrwpqgg kbajip `hwbpgd"

]jkq MKH _g`hnngbap

PG@ pjhwda ka|ipg PIS@ qh

*;) ah`wngbq iqp srh`gawrgp lhriagbqilyibm `kbaiakqgp lhr qrwpqgg hrqrwpqggp `hwbpgd$ kba ib ph ahibm$ qhkppgpp }jgqjgr kaaiqihbkd hwqrgk`jgllhrqp pjhwda og ib`hrshrkqga$ kba*?) ah`wngbq k srh`gpp kba `riqgrik lhrksshibqngbq hl k qrwpqgg kba qrwpqggp`hwbpgd" PG@ kba PIS@ `hb`wrrga }iqjhwr rg`hnngbakqihbp"

]jkq MKH Lhwba

Qjg Pg`wriqigp Ib|gpqhr Srhqg`qihb @hrshrkqihb *PIS@) mgbgrkddy lhddh}ga iqp skpqsrk`qi`gp ib pgdg`qibm qjg qrwpqgg lhr qjg Nkahll di{wiakqihb" PIS@ nkibqkibp k lidghl qrwpqgg `kbaiakqgp lrhn k`rhpp qjg `hwbqry$ owq mi|gb qjg kbqi`iskqga`hnsdgziqigp hl qjg `kpg$ hlli`ikdp pkia qjg ligda hl shqgbqikd {wkdiliga qrwpqggp }kpdiniqga" PIS@ jkp phdg aip`rgqihb qh ksshibq qrwpqggp kba$ }kbqibm qh k`q {wi`fdy$PIS@ pgbihr nkbkmgngbq `hbpiagrga lhwr qrwpqgg `kbaiakqgp" Klqgr qjrgg hl qjglhwr `kbaiakqgp }grg gdinibkqga lhr rgkphbp ib`dwaibm jk|ibm k `hbldi`q hl ibqgrgpqhr hbmhibm }hrf hb k dkrmg libkb`ikd lirn lkidwrg$ PIS@ pgdg`qga Ir|ibm J" Si`kra$}jh jkp `hbpiagrkodg pg`wriqigp kba qrwpqgg gzsgrigb`g" Jh}g|gr$ PIS@ jkp bhq

ah`wngbqga k lhrnkd hwqrgk`j srh`gawrg lhr iagbqilyibm `kbaiakqgp lhr qrwpqggkba qrwpqggp `hwbpgd$ hr ah`wngbqga iqp srh`gawrgp kba `riqgrik lhr pgdg`qibmsgrphbp lhr skrqi`wdkr `kpgp$ kp ibqgrbkd `hbqrhd pqkbakrap rg`hnngba" Jk|ibmpw`j ah`wngbqga srh`gawrgp `hwda kddh} PIS@ qh ogqqgr kppgpp }jgqjgr iq jkpiagbqiliga kb hsqinkd shhd hl `kbaiakqgp$ kba qh gbjkb`g qjg qrkbpskrgb`y hl iqppgdg`qihb ag`ipihbp"

K fgy mhkd hl orhfgr.agkdgr di{wiakqihbp ip qh srh|iag `wpqhngrp }iqj qjgpg`wriqigp hr `kpj qjgy jka ib qjgir k``hwbqp" Jh}g|gr$ og`kwpg qjg Qrwpqggagqgrnibga qjkq knhwbqp pjh}b hb Nkahll `wpqhngrp pqkqgngbqp rgldg`qgaygkrp hl li`qiqihwp ib|gpqngbqp kba srhliqp$ jg `jhpg qh agqgrnibg `wpqhngrp bgqg{wiqy wpibm qjg bgq ib|gpqngbq ngqjha *BIN)$ }ji`j |kdwgp `wpqhngr `dkinpokpga hb knhwbqp ib|gpqga$ dgpp knhwbqp }iqjark}b" PIS@ pgbihr nkbkmgngbqkba hlli`ikdp hl qjg Pg`wriqigp kba Gz`jkbmg @hnnippihb *PG@)}ji`jh|grpggp PIS@ibiqikddy kmrgga hb qjg kssrhsrikqgbgpp hl BIN" H|gr qjg `hwrpghl ?339$ jh}g|gr$ PG@ hlli`ikdp `hbqibwga qh `hbpiagr kdqgrbkqi|g kssrhk`jgp lhrrginowrpibm `wpqhngrp" Kdqjhwmj phng `wpqhngrp jk|g jkddgbmga qjgQrwpqggp wpg hl BIN$ q}h `hwrqp jk|g jgda qjkq qjg Qrwpqggp kssrhk`j ip`hbpipqgbq }iqj qjg dk} kba }iqj skpq `kpgp$ }iqj ohqj `hwrqp ibai`kqibm qjkq wpibmqjg |kdwgp pjh}b hb `wpqhngrp libkd pqkqgngbqp }hwda gllg`qi|gdy pkb`qihb qjgNkahll lrkwa kba srhaw`g kopwra rgpwdqp" Ib Bh|gnogr ?339$ PG@`hnnippihbgrp |hqga qh pwsshrq qjg wpg hl BIN$ owq }iqj kb kaewpqngbq lhribldkqihb$ ib kb kssrhk`j fbh}b kp qjg `hbpqkbq ahddkr ngqjha" Jh}g|gr$ klqgrkb PG@ hlli`ikdp `hbldi`q hl ibqgrgpq }kp nkag swodi` ib Lgorwkry ?3;;$ qjg PG@@jkirnkb airg`qga PG@ pqkll qh rg|ig} }jgqjgr qjg `hnnippihb pjhwda rg|hqg hbqjg `hbpqkbq ahddkr kssrhk`j" Qjg nkqqgr ip `wrrgbqdy sgbaibm"

Kp hl H`qhogr ?3;;$ `hpqp hl qjg Nkahll di{wiakqihb rgk`jga nhrg qjkb !173niddihb$ kba qjg Qrwpqgg gpqinkqgp qjg qhqkd `hpqp }idd gz`gga !; oiddihb oy ?3;1"Dgmkd `hpqp$ }ji`j ib`dwag `hpqp lhr qjg Qrwpqgg kba qjg qrwpqggp `hwbpgd$ krgqjg dkrmgpq `kqgmhry" ]jidg qjg gpqinkqga qhqkd `hpq lhr qjg Nkahll di{wiakqihb ipahwodg qjg qhqkd lhr kdd `hnsdgqga PIS@ `kpgp qh akqg$ qjg Qrwpqgg$ PIS@$ kbaPG@ bhqg qjkq qjg `hpqp rgldg`q qjg wbsrg`gagbqga piug$ awrkqihb$ kba `hnsdgziqyhl qjg Nkahll lrkwa" PIS@ pgbihr nkbkmgngbq kdph pkia qjg di{wiakqihb `hpqp krgewpqiliga$ kp diqimkqihb qjg qrwpqgg jkp swrpwga jkp srhaw`ga !:"= oiddihb ibrg`h|grigp lhr `wpqhngrp qh akqg" Qjrhwmj |krihwp rgshrqp$ `hwrq lidibmp$ kba k}gopiqg$ qjg Qrwpqgg jkp aip`dhpga iblhrnkqihb kohwq qjg pqkqwp hl qjg di{wiakqihb"PIS@ pgbihr nkbkmgngbq$ PG@ hlli`ikdp$ kba qjg W"P" Okbfrwsq`y @hwrq jk|g`hb`dwaga qjkq qjg Qrwpqggp aip`dhpwrgp pwlli`igbqdy kaargpp qjg rg{wirgngbqp lhraip`dhpwrg wbagr qjg Okbfrwsq`y @hag kba qjg Pg`wriqigp Ib|gpqhr Srhqg`qihb K`q"

\ig}MKH.;?.1;1" Lhr nhrg iblhrnkqihb$`hbqk`q K" Bi`hdg @dh}grp kq *?3?) 7;?.:

8/2/2019 GAO Interim SIPC Report Madoff Liquidation

3/78

Skmg i MKH.;?.1;1 PIS@

Dgqqgr ;

Ok`fmrhwba 0PIS@ Pkyp Iq Lhddh}ga Iqp Bhrnkd Srh`gpp ib Pgdg`qibm qjg Qrwpqgg$

owq Dk`fp Ah`wngbqga Srh`gawrgp kba Lhrnkd Hwqrgk`j 9PIS@ kba PG@ Jk|g Pwsshrqga$ kba @hwrqp Jk|g Kllirnga$ qjg

Qrwpqggp Wpg hl qjg Bgq Ib|gpqngbq Ngqjha ;