Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September...

15
Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata When : 23-27 September 2013 Where : Exactly here Are LGRBs biased tracers of SFR? Clues from a complete sample of z<1 LGRB hosts S.D. Vergani (CNRS, Paris Observatory - INAF, Milan Observatory) & many collaborators

Transcript of Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September...

Page 1: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata When : 23-27 September 2013 Where :

Exac

tly h

ere

Are LGRBs biased tracers of SFR? Clues from a complete sample of z<1 LGRB hosts S.D. Vergani (CNRS, Paris Observatory - INAF, Milan Observatory) & many collaborators

Page 2: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Assessing the BiasBoissier et al. 2013

• quantify the dipendence with SFR and Stellar Mass by comparison with Star Forming Galaxies (SFG z<1.1; Boissier et al. 2010)

• Connect to a more physical depencence on Metallicity

GRBrate = bias x SFR bias = b(z)

Page 3: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Assessing the BiasBoissier et al. 2013

SFR

Mstars

Metallicity

Page 4: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Predictions from the MilleniumCampisi et al. 2009 on

• LGRBs originate from death of massive stars

• putting metallicity constraints on the progenitor

Properties of LGRB hostsand their distribution

Page 5: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

The BAT6 sampleSalvaterra et al. 2012 + others

• Observing condition criteria (see TOUGH)

• cut on the BAT brightness

• 58 LGRBs

• 95% redshift completeness

Nava+ 2012; D’avanzo+ 2012; Campana+ 2012; Melandri+ 2012; Covino+2013; Ghirlanda+2013; +++

Page 6: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

The z<1 BAT6 hosts

• 14 hosts

• Data in the literature

• SFR, Stellar Masses, MB

• VLT, GTC, OPTICON + available data

• Metallicity

Page 7: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Eiso & Liso vs Mstar

Eiso vs Mstars Liso vs Mstars

Page 8: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Boissier’s bias test

Page 9: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Boissier’s bias test

Page 10: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

SFR distributionNo Z cut

Z<0.3Zsun

Z<0.5Zsun

Page 11: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

MB distributionNo Z cut

Z<0.3Zsun

Z<0.5Zsun

Page 12: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Stellar Mass distributionNo Z cut

Z<0.3Zsun

Z<0.5Zsun

Page 13: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013

Conclusions

• there is a bias, decreasing with Mstars and SFR

• probably linked to the metallicity

• sample metallicity distribution to come

• extending the study to z=1.5

Page 14: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •

THANKS!

Page 15: Galaxies meet GRBs at Cabo de Gata · S.D. Vergani : GRBs meet Galaxies @ Cabo de Gata - September 23 - 27 2013 Conclusions • there is a bias, decreasing with M stars and SFR •