Future of CAE and Implication on Engineering Education · PDF fileFuture of CAE and...
Transcript of Future of CAE and Implication on Engineering Education · PDF fileFuture of CAE and...
Seung-Hyun Yoo
University of Maryland
On leave from Ajou University,
Suwon, Korea
Future of CAE and Implication
on Engineering Education
2007. 10. 08
2nd IFIP Conference on CAI
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
Ajou University
• 30 Km south from Seoul
• Private university with
Medical school, Hospital
• Founded in 1973
• Daewoo Education
• Strong Engineering Prog.
www.ajou.ac.kr
Ajou University
Neighbor of the
2002 Soccer
World Cup
Suwon Stadium
Home of
Samsung
Electronics,
Semiconductors
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
• 2003 IRI
• New to the world
• 5-10 times productivity
• 30 ~ 50% cost reduction
• More than 6 Sigma
Radical Innovation
• Industrial Revolution
– Energy
– 18C – 19C
• Information Revolution
– Information
– Now
– Knowledge
• NT, BT
Paradigm Change
From Tools to Subjects
Slide rules Calculator, Computer
HEMMI
Computation
From Tools to Subjects
Numerical
Symbolic
SW : Mathematica, Matlab, Macsyma
Cxdxx
dxx
32
1
0
2
3
1
333.0
Extinct of Mechanical Engineering ?
ASME : Mech. Eng.
Magazine
125th Anniversary
Cover Story :
„Future Shock‟
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
VPD
Concept
Development
Product
Definition
Simulation
Prototype
Testing Manufacturing
Planning
Product &
Simulation Data
Management
Product
Support &
Service
(release
Manufacturing)
Production
Planning
Inventory
Management
Plant
Maintenance
Salse &
Distribution
Order
Processing&
Control
ERPPLM
Knowledge
System
Transverse
System
Sourcing
SCM
“Extended
Systems”xx
xxx
xxxx
Virtual Product Development as Part
of the Digital Enterprise
Product development and MDAprocesses are changing
Product Data Management(Doc., Spec, BOM, Etc.) (PDM)
TIME
Manufacturing(CAM)
Analysis/Evaluation(CAE)
Detail Design(CAD)
Concept Design(CAID)
Product Development
- Reduce costs,
- Reduce time-to-market,
- Assure integrated quality
- Reliability
customers
andmarkets
product
concept
design
engineeringdrafting
process
planning
production
schedulingproduction
quality
control
order new
equipmentand tooling
Computer-
AidedDesign
Computer-
automated draftingand documentation
Computer-
aided processplanning
Computer scheduling,
material requirements planning,shop floor control
Computer-controlled
robots,machines, etc.
Computer-
aided qualitycontrol
FEM
FEM in CAE
Mechanics follows industry
• Beam : Railroad (Beam on elastic foundation)
• Plates : Ship industry
• Shell : Pressure vessel, Aerospace
• Composites : Aerospace
• Crashworthiness : Auto
• Multiphysics : Electronics
• Biomechanics : BT
• Nanomechanics : NT
My concern on solid mechanics
• Thinness- membrane
- plate
- shell
• Discontinuity- joint
- crack
- etc
• Biomechanics- human body
- cell
- bone
- soft tissue
Mathematical system
• Elliptic
• Parabolic
• Hyperbolic
Problem Type
IVP(Initial Value Problem)
BVP(Boundary Value Problem)
Physical Condition
Boundary Condition
Governing Equation
PDE
Solutions
• Analytical solutions
• Approximate solutions
– Variational methods
– Discretization methods
• FDM (Finite Difference Method)
• FEM (Finite Element Method)
“Divide and Conquer”
Evolution of computational structural analysis
• 1970‟s– Linear statics, Buckling, Modal analysis
– 5,000 grids, 3,000 elements, 25,000 DOF
– 2,000 CPU sec, 1 Elapsed hr, 8MB mem, 300 MB disk
• 1980‟s– Nonlinear, Dynamics, Superelements, Direct methods
– 50,000 Grids, 60,000 Elements, 250,000 DOF
– 2,000 CPU sec, 1 Elapsed hr, 480 MB mem, 1GB disk
• 1990‟s– Adaptivitiy, Optimization, Coupled analysis
– 150,000 Grids, 200,000 Elements, 1.5M DOF,
– 6,500 CPU sec, 2 Elapsed hr, 1GB mem, 100GB disk
• 2000‟s– Probabilistic, CAD integration, AI
– No limit (Hardware allowed )
History of FEM
• Mid-1800s – basic concepts
• 1920‟s : On Truss and Frame Analysis
• 1960 : Clough - first paper published
using term “Finite Element Method”
• 1965 : First conference on finite elements.
Application trends of FEM
• Discrete Structures
• Continuum – Elliptic PDE
• Thinness (Membrane, Plates, Shells)
• Wave Propagation – Hyperbolic PDE
• Heat Transfer – Parabolic PDE
• Mass Transfer
• Electro Magnetic Field
FEM and TRIZ (MATChEM)
1. M : Mechanical : Structural Analysis
2. A : Acoustical : Wave Propagation
3. T : Thermal : Heat Transfer
4. Ch : Chemical : Chemical Engineering
5. EM : Electro Magnetical : Electronics
FEM also followed evolution pattern !
Research directions of
computational mechanics
• Virtual design
• Multi-discipline analysis
• Multi-scale phenomena
• Modal selection and adaptation
• Very large-scale parallel computing
• Biomedical applications
• Controlling uncertainty : probabilistic methods
Laws of Creation of Technology System (TS):
Laws of Development of TS:
Law of System Completeness.
Law of Energy Conductivity in System.
Law of Harmonization.
Law of Increasing Ideality of Technical Systems
Law of Uneven Development of Parts
Law of Transition to the Super-System.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Law of Transition From Macro-Level to the Micro-Level.
Law of Increasing the Degree of Substance-Field Interactions.
Time
TSn
TS0
Main
parameter
TS1
TS2
TS3
9 Law of Increasing the Degree of Dynamization
FEM followed Evolution Pattern Rule
Future of CAE & FEM
From “Ideality”
• CAE will simulate from the bottom (Nano)
• CAE can simulate real behavior
• CAE will free engineers from “analysis” burden
Engineers can concentrate on
“Creative Work”, using CAI tools
including TRIZ !
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
Engineering Design (ABET)
Engineering design is the process of devising a system, component, or
process to meet desired needs. It is a decision making process (often
iterative), in which the basic science, mathematics, and engineering
science are applied to convert resources optimally to meet a stated
objective. Among the fundamental elements of the design process are
the establishment of objectives and criteria, synthesis, analysis,
construction, testing and evaluation. The engineering design component
of a curriculum must include most of the following features:
development of student creativity, use of open ended problems,
development and use of modern design theory and methodology,
formulation of design problem statements and specifications,
consideration of alternative solutions, feasibility considerations,
production processes, concurrent engineering design, and detailed
system descriptions. Further, it is essential to include a variety of
realistic constraints such as economic factors, safety, reliability,
aesthetics, ethics, and social impact.
Engineering Design (ABET)
System, Component, Process, Concept
Resources, Constraint
Decision making
Optimization
Creativity
Two Designs
Everyday design
Incremental design,
Routine design,
Improvement,
Optimization,
Compromise,
CAE
Creative design Creative design
Innovative design
TRIZ & Design for assembly
• TRIZ : 40 Principles
No. 4 : Use Asymmetry
• Design for Assembly
Use “Symmetry ”
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
2004 ASEE Conference
• Annual ASEE Conference
• 2004. 6. 20-23, Salt Lake City, Utah
• 3000 attended
• “Engineering education reaches new
heights”
• 2005. 6. 12-15, Portland, Oregon
Main Plenary
• 6. 21(Monday) 8:30 – 10:15 am
• Prof. Woodie Flowers (Mechanical
Eng., MIT)
• China and India Student Video
“Are we smarter, more hard working, more
ambitious?” “NO!”-> Outsourcing
But not Leadership.
Then, “Informed creative thinking”
• From Engineering Science to Engineering
Engineering Science
• 50th Anniversary of Sputnik
• 1957, Oct. 9
• After this, science
education reform
in USA
• Engineering science
became important from
then.
PRISM
• Monthly magazine of ASEE
• 2004 Summer Issue
• Expanding the Mind
– pp. 30 – 36 (Scanned file)
– Covered “Engineer‟s creativity‟
• So far relied on „Serendipity‟
• TRIZ is a new light.
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
Engineering Mechanics at Stanford
S. P. Timoshenko (1878~1972)
- Father of Engineering Mechanics
W. Flügge
- “Stresses in shells”
C. R. Steele (ME & AA)
- Editor, Int. J. of Solids & Structures
S. H. Yoo
at Ajou Univ.
Courses taught at Ajou Univ.
Undergraduate
• Numerical methods
• Statics, Dynamics
• CAE
• Solid mechanics
• Vibration
• Introduction to Design
• Creative problem
solving
• New product
development
Graduate
• Elasticity
• Continuum mechanics
• Advanced mathematics
• Fracture mechanics
• Plate and shells
• Wave propagation in solids
• Finite Element Method
• Biomechanics
• TRIZ
My current researches• Structural Mechanics
• Thinness
• Beams, membrane, plates, shells
• MEMS, Thin film
• Discontinuity
• Design• Practical design
• Design theory
• BME• Bio Medical Engineering
• Bio Mechanical Engineering
• TRIZ -> CAI
From
Mechanics,
CAE
(Engineering
Science)
to
CAI / TRIZ
(Engineering)
Common Russian origin for me
S. P. Timoshenko(1878~1972)
Father of Engineering
Mechanics
G. S. Altshuller(1926~1998)
Father of TRIZ
4C
CAD CAE CAM
FEA
• ABAQUS
• ANSYS
• NASTRAN
• Intuitive FEM
Dynamic
Analysis
• DADS
• ADAMS
• ADAS
Dynamic
Loading
Elements
1. Geometry
2. Physical Properties
3. Boundary Condition
4. Loading
CAT
Serendipity
1. The faculty of making fortunate
discoveries by accident.
2. The fact or occurrence of such
discoveries.
3. An instance of making such a
discovery.
Various views on TRIZ
• From Knowledge Management
• From 6 Sigma
• From Engineering Design
• From Innovation
• From Creativity
• From R&D
• etc…
Future of TRIZ
1. Automatic more inventions check
• Currently 3 Million patents covered
2. SW (Goldfire, IWB,CREAX)
3. Application to other fields like Business
4. Expanding to lower grade, High schools
5. Variations, Simplifications of TRIZ
- ASIT, USIT, etc…
New Approach for Design Course
• Team building : MBTI
• Sketch
• Draw on the right side of brain
• Various creativity enhancing
method
• Zen
• Systematic Innovation
• TRIZ SW
Outcome
• Before : No practical output from
students of design course
• After : Motivation,
Confidence
Patents and utility models
every year.
Engineering Education Reform
• Accelerometer
– Important for many applications
– As sensors such as in Airbag
– Now in MEMS
– Main part is Cantilever Beam
Example : Cantilever Beam
Cantilever Beam
•To measure
• Acceleration
• by Elasticity
• Look up
• Cantilever
Science for Designers• What to do is known; but how to do?
• Use the Pointer to physical effects and
phenomena
to move solid body
to change densityto separate gas and
liquid
to detect gas flow
Magnetostriction
Archimedes forceThermal expansion
Piezoeffect
……..
Effects
From Discipline based knowledge
To Need based knowledge !
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
• Quantitative analysis to identify most
important parameter. So far TRIZ sw.
• NPD course to regular course
• AUCSE (Ajou University Consortium
for Staff Enrichment)
• Elaboration of “Engineering Activities”
as Functions in Effects module for
engineering education
Further Study
NSF CreativeIT
• Required Advances
– New theoretical models
– New modes of research
– Innovative educational approach
– Creativity enhancing tools
NSF CreativeIT
• Research Areas
– Understanding creative cognition and
computation
– Creativity to stimulate breakthrough in
science and engineering
– Educational approaches that encourage
creativity
– Supporting creativity with IT
NSF CDI
• 3 Theme Areas
– From data to knowledge
– Understanding complexity in natural,
built, and social systems
– Building virtual organizations
• Innovation is needed everywhere
• FEM in CAE
• Engineering Design
• Engineering Education
• My Experiences
• Further Study
• TRIZ in Korea
Contents
• Producing results
– Patents
– Publications
• From translation to Korean authorship
• Moving 3rd generation of TRIZ in Korea
• Research on
– Theory of CAI and TRIZ
– Direct application to practical problems
– High interests in industry, government and
also universities
CAI &TRIZ in Korea
• Ph. D. Thesis on TRIZ (2006)
• “Research on determinants for learning
effect and knowledge creation
performance of TRIZ”
• School of Business Adminstration
• Ewha University, Seoul, Korea
An examples of research