Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black...

64
Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black hole Joss Bland-Hawthorn University of Sydney @jossblandhawtho

Transcript of Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black...

Page 1: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Front-row seat on the daily life !of a supermassive black hole

Joss Bland-HawthornUniversity of Sydney

@jossblandhawtho

Page 2: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

22

The original astronomers

Page 3: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

3

Milky Way’s centre exploded 3.5 Myr ago

Page 4: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

4

So what holds the moon in orbit?

There’s nothing obvious about gravity.

Page 5: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

5

The ball orbits because of the string

Page 6: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

6

The bee orbits because of its internal energy

Page 7: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

7

Isaac Newton (1642-1727)

Page 8: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

8

Isaac Newton (1642-1727)

Page 9: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

9

Isaac Newton (1642-1727)

I will limit this talk to a couple of equations

Page 10: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

1783: Sir Joseph Banks“A Proposal for Establishing a Settlement in NSW”

1783: John Mitchell first discussed idea of black holes

Page 11: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

11

1916: Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity

Gravity maintained by waves propagating through space-time

Einstein was unsure about "gravitational waves" but a colleague encouraged him to stick with it.

Page 12: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

12

1916: Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity

1919: total eclipse of the Sun

1939: Einstein claimed black holes may not exist; Oppenheimer andChandrasekhar thought they would.

Page 13: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

13

1958: no evidence yet for black holes but Finkelstein found they probably exist and have this structure, i.e. one-way membrane:

Page 14: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

14

Arguably,DennisSciama(Oxford,Trieste)hadthestrongestinfluenceonthedevelopmentofblackholetheory…

Page 15: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

15

1963: black holes rotate !

Roy Kerr2016 Crafoord Prize: Roy Kerr & Roger Blandford

2009 biography: Cracking the Einstein code, F. Melia

Page 16: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

16

1963: a golden year for Australian-US astronomy

Lunar occultation of “radio star” 3C273using Parkes telescope

The discovery of quasars:galaxies in the early universe powered bysupermassive black holes at their cores

2008 Kavli Prize

Page 17: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

17

Page 18: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

18

Who is this ?1920: born in Wisconsin

1941: graduates in physics & chemistry

1942: joins US navy

1946: gets pilot’s license

1972: first woman elected to National Press Club

2010: dies aged 89

Page 19: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

19

Ann Ewing1920: born in Wisconsin

1941: graduates in physics & chemistry

1942: joins US navy

1946: gets pilot’s license

1964: coins term “black hole”

1972: first woman elected to National Press Club

2010: dies aged 89

Page 20: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

20

Page 21: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s
Page 22: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

For non-rotating black holes:

- event horizon is at RS = 2GM/c2

- inner edge of the disk is at 3 RS

For maximally rotating black holes:

- event horizon is at ½ RS

- inner edge of the disk is at ½ RS

Our expectation is that black holes do rotate

Page 23: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

If the Earth collapsed, it could !form a black hole.

23

How big would it be?

Page 24: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

24

"Empty space" is full of energy waves

Page 25: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

25

Black hole weighing 200 tons evaporates in 1 second !

1974: Hawking’s bombshell – black holes evaporate!

Page 26: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

26

John’s search for evaporating black holes led directly to the invention of WiFi

Page 27: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

27

Accretion disk spinning around a black hole

This is how we are able to “see” where black holes are hiding

Page 28: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Black holes were far more energetic in the past – that’s when they did most of their growing up

12.6 billion yearsAbout 95% of time back to the Big Bang

Page 29: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

29Hercules A

Are black holes still active today?

Page 30: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

30Centaurus A

Are black holes still active today?

Page 31: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

We now believe that all galaxies have black holes at their centres, the most ancient part of the galaxy.

1998: An amazing discovery is that the black hole knows about the galaxy around it.

Page 32: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

32

CDM paradigm:

The growth of a supermassive black hole over cosmic time

Black holes are seeded by the first stars

TK, VB, JBH Rev Mod Phys 2013

Page 33: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

33

Page 34: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

34Australian Physics, Nov-Dec 2014

Page 35: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

35

Dover Heights

Page 36: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

36

Constellation of Sagittarius (Sgr)

Page 37: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

USyd/AAO 2013

Page 38: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

38

Page 39: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

39

Sgr A*

Star motions show the black hole is 4 million times the mass of the Sun

Page 40: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Now we move to degree scales

40

Page 41: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

1974: Our first clue of something weird in Sgr A* − a plume of antimatter streaming out of the region

Milky Way disk

2005: INTEGRAL satellite

Page 42: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

The Galaxy’s bipolar wind seen on 10 kpc scales…

What powers it ?

ROSAT 1.5 keV (diffuse) Estimated energy ~ 1055 erg JBH & Cohen (2003)

MSO 2014

Page 43: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

2010: big NASA discovery

2014 Rossi Prize EsCmatedenergy>1056erg

Page 44: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

44

You’re the first audience to see this composite…

Page 45: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

USyd/AAO 2013

Claims for a jet not convincing

Page 46: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

MSO 2014

30 or more nearby Seyfert examples: 0313-192 NGC 1068 NGC 2992 NGC 3079 NGC 3801 NGC 5506 NGC 6764 Circinus Markarian 6 M51 …

Page 47: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

So when did all this happen?

Until recently, there was no corroborating evidence for when the Galactic nucleus exploded.

MSO 2014

Page 48: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

The mystery of the Magellanic Stream’s ionization

MSO 2014

Page 49: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

MSO 2014

The Magellanic HI Stream

Page 50: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Radiation field restricted by the surrounding galaxy is often seen from low power AGNs (Seyferts)

Page 51: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Seyfert ionizes gas streams at up to ~ 35 kpc

Page 52: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

The Magellanic Stream was lit up by Sgr A* only a few million years ago

USyd/AAO 2013

Sgr A* was ten million times more powerful than today

Page 53: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

D. Mukherjee, ANU

Page 54: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

MSO 2014

What was the “event” ?

Page 55: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

55

The “event” was not an infalling star, too rare, too little mass.

2016: simulation of a star being stretched by a factor 300 as it falls into a massive black hole

Page 56: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

56

The “event” was likely due to a gas cloud ~ 10,000 solar masses.

Page 57: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Singular event – formation of young inner disk

T = 4-6 Myr R = 0.04 – 4 pc

Fermi bubbles are AGN jet-driven, arguing for event at T0 ~ 2-5 Myr

and burst time TB ~ 0.5-1 Myr (e.g. Guo & Mathews 2012).

Associated with central hole of young disk ?

Page 58: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

Are we in any danger?

ESO Gravity instrument says accretion disk is pointing at Earth now.

Page 59: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

MSO 2014

Looking to the future

Page 60: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

60

IceCube Neutrino Observatory, South Pole

Page 61: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

61

Page 62: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

62

Einstein’s General Relativity predicts mysterious shadows and rings around an event horizon

Page 63: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

63

Laser Interferometry Gravity-Wave Observatory (LIGO):

in search of black holes behaving badly…

Page 64: Front-row seat on the daily life of a supermassive black holephysics.usyd.edu.au/~helenj/Quarks/jbh.pdf · 1941: graduates in physics & chemistry 1942: joins US navy 1946: gets pilot’s

.

Expect great advances in the decades ahead – Sgr A* research guarantees longevity for astrophysics

I predict that Galactic Centre research will become a distinct field of physics