Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

35
Fracking - Why the Oil and Gas Industry received an exemption to the Clean Water Act ECO Green Group Thursday April 7, 2016 by Tony Green

Transcript of Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Page 1: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Fracking - Why the Oil and Gas Industry received an exemption to the Clean

Water Act

ECO Green Group Thursday April 7, 2016by

Tony Green

Page 2: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Agenda The result of methane in your water

Fracking is….

About that Shale

Why? – The Demand for Natural Gas

The Halliburton Exemption

Overview of Fracking Chemicals

The Secretive Additives

In Closing

Questions and Answers

Page 3: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

http://www.hulu.com/watch/708712

Would you find this problematic?

Page 4: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Would you find this problematic?

www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~aubrecht/SD-fracking%20101-22.4.12.ppt

Page 5: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Fracking is short for “hydraulic fracturing.” This

is an old technique for increasing oil production

from worked-out oil wells, but a new

technique for obtaining methane (natural gas).

Source : Fracking 101 www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~aubrecht/SD-fracking%20101-22.4.12.ppt

What is Fracking?

the whole process in a nut the whole process in a nut shell is to artificially enhance the permeability of a formation

Sources: http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic1061062.files/HydraulicFracturing2_ppt.pdf

Page 6: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

What is Fracking?

www.ncel.net/news_uploads/243/Fracking%20PowerPoint%20final.ppt

Page 7: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Gas shale rock has characteristically small pores that are relatively impermeable to natural gas flow unless they are naturally or artificially fractured to create channels connecting the pores

Source : http://naturalgas.org/shale/

About that Shale

Shale is a clastic sedimentary rock that is made up of clay-size weathering debris. which breaks up into thin flat pieces.

Source : http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic1061062.files/HydraulicFracturing2_ppt.pdf

Page 8: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

About that Shale

Geologists have known of the presence of natural gas in shale rock for years, but until recently, could not cost-effectively extract it

Two factors came together in recent years to make shale gas production economically viable: (1) advances in horizontal drilling; and (2) advances in hydraulic fracturing

Source: http://naturalgas.org/shale/

Page 9: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

Natural gas is a combustible mixture of hydrocarbon gases. While natural gas is formed primarily of methane, it can also include ethane, propane, butane and pentane

http://naturalgas.org/overview/background/

Page 10: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

Colorless, shapeless, and odorless in its pure form

One of the cleanest, safest, and most useful of all energy sources, gives off a great deal of energy with fewer emissions than many other sources

http://naturalgas.org/overview/background/

Page 11: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

The distinctive “rotten egg” smell that we often associate with natural gas is actually an odorant called mercaptan.

Found in reservoirs underneath the earth, natural gas is often associated with oil deposits.

http://naturalgas.org/overview/background/

Page 12: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

22 percent of the world's energy consumption

28 percent of U.S. energy demand (as of 2012).

Heats 51 percent of U.S. households. It also cools many homes and provides fuel for cooking

There are approximately 142,000 natural gas vehicles operating on American roads.

http://www.api.org/Oil-and-Natural-Gas-Overview/Exploration-and-Production/Natural-Gas/Natural-Gas-Uses

Page 13: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

Where do we get our energy?

other renewables

2%nuclear

8%

hydropower3%

natural gas26%

coal20%biomass

5%

petroleum36%

http://www.rochester.edu/sustainability/hyrdrofracking-korfmacher.ppt

How do we use natural gas?

31%

19%13%

34%

3%

Electricity

Residential

Commercial

Industrial

Transportation

Page 14: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Why? Demand for Natural Gas

http://www.argus.com Article: Natural Gas Leads Pack for U.S. Power Generation

Natural gas-fired generation will remain the dominant source of power generation

.

Low gas prices

Tougher emissions standards

Aging fleet of coal-fired plants.

Page 15: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

The Halliburton Exemption

www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~aubrecht/SD-fracking%20101-22.4.12.ppt

Page 16: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

The Halliburton Exemption

http://ecowatch.com/2015/08/11/halliburton-loophole-fracking/

Page 17: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

The Halliburton Exemption violated

Clean Water Act Safe Drinking Water Act

Clean Air Act

http://cleanwater.org/page/frackinglawsandloopholes

Page 18: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Source : Hydraulic Fracturing in Shale Reservoirs by Stephen Holdtlisch AICHE Webinar Slide 12

Page 19: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Water Proppant Additives

Page 20: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Sources of Water for “Fracking”

Water sources may come from ground or surface waterMillions of gallons of water used per production wellStorage of water on-site in 20,000 gallon tanks, on-site

impoundments, or centralized impoundments serving multiple sites

Recycling “Flow back” water produced in fracturing process, ranging from 25 to 75 percent recovery

Flow back may contain both naturally occurring contaminants, chemical additives, VOCs, radionuclides, ions and high TDS values, and is not biodegradable

Source: Hydraulic Fracturing www.spencerfarlane.com

Page 21: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Water use for fracking operations

Source: facstaff.uww.edu/bhattacj/envt_geol_2_29.pp

Typically 4 to 6 million gallons per well

EPA estimated that if 35,000 wells are hydraulically fractured annually in the US, the amount of water consumed would be equivalent to that used by 5 million people.”

Source of water used from fracking operations varies, and is not well documented or monitored

Page 22: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Source : Hydraulic Fracturing in Shale Reservoirs by Stephen Holdtlisch AICHE Webinar Slide 25

Page 23: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Page 24: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Source : Hydraulic Fracturing in Shale Reservoirs by Stephen Holdtlisch AICHE Webinar Slide 26

Page 25: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Acid

Dissolves the minerals in the rock, soil and sand below the ground.

,Dissolves parts of the rock to initiate cracking

Example: Hydrochloric Acid (HCL) and Acetic Acid (Vinegar)

Source: https://www.chemservice.com/news/2014/06/chemicalsandfrackingwhatmakesupfrackingfluid/

Page 26: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

BiocideEliminates bacteria in the water that produces corrosive by-products

Example : Glutaraldehyde

Prevent formation of dangerous gasses

Page 27: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Corrosion Inhibitor

Example: Pharmaceuticals, acrylic fibers and plastics

Protects casing from corrosion.

Page 28: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Cross linker

Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases

Source: www.fracfocus.org

Example: Laundry detergents,hand soaps, cosmetics

Page 29: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Scale Inhibitors

Keeps scale deposits from developing inside of the pipes.

Source: https://www.chemservice.com/news/2014/06/chemicalsandfrackingwhatmakesupfrackingfluid/

Example: Household cleaners, deiicers,Paint, Ethylene Glycol – anti-freeze

Page 30: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Source: www.fracfocus.org and http://setxind.com/upstream/the-hydraulic-fracking-process-and-how-it-works/

Friction Reducer“Slicks” the water to minimize friction

Example: Cosmetics, make-up, nail and skin products

Allows the fluids to flow more efficiently through the pipes and enables the fracking pumps to pump at a higher rate without having to increase pressure

Page 31: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Surfactant

Used to increase the viscosity of the fracture fluid

Example: Glass cleaner, multi-surfacecleaner, antiperspirant,deodorants, hair-color

Page 32: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

So what is in Fracking Fluid anyway?

Guar Gum

Source: Oerb What is in our Fracturing Fluid and http://setxind.com/upstream/the-hydraulic-fracking-process-and-how-it-works/

Thickens the water to suspend the sand

Example: used in Ice cream

Increases the viscosity of the fracking fluids and aid in more efficient delivery of proppants into the fractures

Page 33: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

All Common Items – But do you want these in your water?

This is where the

idea for the

exemption came from

!!Pool - Diluted Acid

Cosmetics – Friction Reducer Glass Cleaner - Surfactants

Medical Devices - Biocides

Page 34: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

In closing

Fracking here to stay.

The Oil and Gas Industry

working on green solutions for

chemicals.

Remember with Fracking, like

sustainability, there is a price to

be paid for everything.

Page 35: Fracking why the oil and gas got an exemption to clean water act presentation egg 04072016 final

Questions & Answers