Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\...

7
L..-_ c, { -- -'s<' a_ S U e) ei \ L bO q) o qJ a. r1 F. z o 6^ F.l (-) z o z o ,d N o bo o .o o o a .o F rrl (h o- ;,i r! 7d Trl] t.l-{ ,r [.] an l,J-l trl fi- (D '- 2,1 tlI Pi cn- ArI] ad rr.t = {< rq F-{ z o l-.{ F-+^ )-{ o z o U trl z (, z t-{ Fr z rrl & Fr T

Transcript of Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\...

Page 1: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

L..-_

c, { --

-'s<'

a_SUe)ei\LbO

q)oqJ

a.

r1

F.

zo6^F.l

(-)

zozo,dNoboo.oooa.oF

rrl(ho-;,i r!7dT

rl]t.l-{

,r[.]an

l,J-ltrl

fi-(D

'-2,1tlIP

i cn-

ArI]

adrr.t ={<rq

F-{

zol-.{F

-+^

)-{

ozoUtrlz

(,zt-{F

rzrrl&F

r

T

Page 2: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

oO@

riO\

ON

Ln\ot-l

t-l F

l r-t

It- N

ca

OO

O

\ t-r

ririN

0)*6!oo

-ou)-

t-!aOZ

(J

+J0)

O.

trbo(d(r^q.)

(gIaq)U)

(-)

:!^

.!l

Z:E

'f.'<

-.:5i:

()

L-/(EA

\-/5HJ!r!i

lV

OiX

!;;Lrtrr\ :r

n\J,i

P\3L.1a

ii u

-\-/!M

E](g

tqF.O

.Irq

q q)

^dtLIJ

tH

cn -=.i

UO

\ F

r (h

#--5t4-:

I9X.S

IT

I

O.O

.=(ld(dA

,{Fr

zI-{-

zUrI]zr!t+

t

#l-)O.

(g(,

FzF-r-

zUEqz

roco\or-oooN

ltll:l:::::::

-::d:::::::.

.::::

_: H

:

i i

i D

:F)::::-l

i4::::Di1r!::cr)iY;Y

&F

l:lri N

.Ai;*rrto:U

=tr

:E

ZI

E 9 X

2z=

r_j^r-q))4EJ

iAf-1

7.o-(nJn

i8 Z g H

p'fr 3i

.n a^

rrl F

i i;

Tr..!

.\-/tso-,,/-v-l

:=

P P

=:

* E

:A(zzH

u:H

t,s3EZ

Z:3,3X

A .E

UB

,q)X

J

c.i cd +

,-?i \ij

Nvv

- H

H

i

'jJJ)]

EaooO

OO

o!!!

v.H.-.!-!

i-1 +

Q

. O

. O

. O

. O

. ii.

-d-a_a(d(ddfu'F-

EU

UU

UO

UU

azto_fO

Page 3: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

+t=

-ri i =

EtgI-+

E yZ

,1 {'-=n!:?=

! = i

=+

t ==

=

=*=

li7 =

3-z1 1 Y ;ii

i*=iE

i El=

; a, ="_ :

=;2;; :,1:z=

=;i=

==

:: s: =1-, :17 =

-:=

; =:f i: i:=

i:==

1E +

i;! ? = E

i; =, ilj

=r_ =

=_:i; zt=

,4;=1!y

=;iloxE

i': E

uk =

;21't .r:i;.1-;1.

Zn =

.;=)i i,;y):iT

:; EE

iEiiiii Z

iiEE

Z=

=.=

=Z

:! Lt:7y<7-=

i ;*ZiE

EV

;= ?riail=

; 2 1,r?;Ez;i=

Z=

;sz: iEE

ii,-1;?i i=,i::

E 8 : ri E

eEil=

iEE

i{iE?ii,=

1?:+E

Ei'=

iEi

p

.$ ? :+g|ii1iiE

ii"zli=iiiiE

r;i; $E

iE ii

=- fr ,;1 E

t',:,Eip 5 ! iiii:+

iia /=E

i,, i:Ei. iz

tr :i;=i=

=i=

1ilZ=

1 =Z

a r;-e"I= i i

;_= i

? i ti ; = -=

7e 7.4 = -=

5- 1 y. 1=-=

E yE

.= =

: = =

= ;1:,:

:'2 7'; ;EjI?=

=i-*._:'{7;=

a:s uE.ii'1,- =

'+ i. yE

=e=

?i i=i jia,=

iZ=

=

i * =4izii=

, i: ,:i:? =

s E: ?,=

2= :, =

7 = =

= =

==

i=,=

==

a==

= =

4, ;a :,i 1=

7

i:=-=

--_--::=

_ t.=

-=--=

=

=-,^:

-

Eu: E

E,*,I 1i E

,EIE

s;t E

s",SN

gi q=':E

rg? iulEfr iE

HH

3*; :3,=

,s:aE *;iti

eis :=

flli *8 -il:T

,=E

ei gieEH

E E

:^8"4,

E;i ggj=

Ei *siiE

?j-[ 5iIgE€*sE

I'i *S

E r, fi; E

f E * P

; F a t

u

I}IBF

F?E

i 3EE

E€ $E

u'c c r'u uo E,3,;.IE

=:;*

,+H

;i;Es H

q+ rr$iE

B,E

:€ E

.E-E

q E E

g,:; ; E E

g E;1

8'lsPJU

US

*E!'=

deb'E

.i; ; fg ?FE

* Egi [+

E E

3'3qE E

8.EE

ut" EH

.'s8

Page 4: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

: -.:/7

='rri3i;

i,.y=_.-t-i9

7o+,;--(6 trtr1

.:u- ' L---.u'i

s ,j=

=

z=E

_1Vi=

:7=-],,_

==

),,)=?i7Z

i 'i.7iaiii7r=:

=*.nl

:.2=1-->

", a-y=

=e':

,=i''=

-=:::i

3tiL.-=14!

: =

=!r =

,4Ia;=+

Z:=

1i? i,=i;*li4t i;2i;:=

i:.:

=-+

s E

y==

'e:3. 1=

=n-)

-'J\-i.=?'7iq

'.d-i...i 7.'z

_u=

=: +

:i : :tEE

==

i ;=r ;; *=

i1i.=Z

lzZ=

+! =

3: =! ;.

-t2''- -,--

Z_'i; !.

,E'=

6i.,* =2=

:.'.- i.a.r,tr; y

,=1i7=

=

?9€:_:=

.i a.i=

,77..4i =

>=

z:=i1=

y'qi'-='=

]:i.=

'o o is';', i-;-

-:t

= -=

'c;? ; =

*'=,8'Z

; i. .,

tr r,tr E .. i,!; p y'd fi :A

7 :, =

iZ+

:;

=-!

r - =

:a,! ! +=

=

= - i:t '' ?, an iZ

,iZ ? i,=

ii r:a *E

; e

ii_l= iE

=rz-1 =

=7i v::+

E

= F

i; : s='2 2e2€ *pE

',FI

=,....7..9

t ea t.d

'..' .J

.r L? i2

Z-=

*=

ZZ

-,.,:

r.=.t,2.7j-=

qF

_!

:r

;.i.==

F

.=f i s) ?

::=-=

-t.a.7,s,!.=

{ tr.;'=.=

--,: :3.2: =

.r,.=.=

, ^j e€-o =

,I =

p,. r _ .1\ZZ

''i=-. E

iZ1=

,=-=

=:=

.)77,;,*'iEii i i€ =

.31 a

= i ?7;t

=" i iaa;

xlil=-.,2.1f i?'=

i*Zt=

1i81-El;

= : ! ai

e

1r=i7'Z

ii=i i:

i;_i "i!: 1,;22:.:a??;7 ;ii :2ltr :

='!.=

i==

i'1=<

=

/'-= =

="-a e ?;E

;'|.= z =

=- =

L+'Z

n t''a2-i:

= =

*F i;

u -'ir e. =:a ri j i =

y | 2*==

Z.iE

.a = >

;9; !i z r i

:i'ti'ezy_?:=nti_ E

=_1:i=

=iia: v u.:,6a=

Ei s,-7 I s =

Ez?

:-=''

t7 i-.1,=

--:- =

=

- * =1

a.Z:/

--L I - ? -- =

-.- =.- .-i,,.-.,'7=

J.2 ?,,3,:7 a,;-l-t:=

!"L= ,J,-.-=

==

Z 7.-. i-

= ;;

)- - -'J =

= t ! '!=

<3 2r-',ii L{

?, l rzEii ii=

1'.l \181 ?iz-l46.-!",U

Ea_,L_li,-=

1=o-aj=

z -= - =

- - E.ri'.. 2; : -i_ =

E : =

,i.rE*itiiT

.gEix?!,=

,u-,| =

.=,=

=

= =

,2 4='i

.i=,

= ? t-

ja-=

.--.-'. =

=,-':,

-.!'-;:. ),a,1

- ) 3;:.S-

:=,r

?Q.=

; iZ

.J V

." j. _*.!gi_ -; =

.. : i i.,_ !==

'-,E,_Z

'1 2=a

-7 ai ) a ='; z E

a = ; t ] ;:=

= a =

i z t=

_ l, =

i : 1; =1 :a=

'a, : ='

=_ :

7 2 ; :7= a=

7=; =

- 2 =:

=- 1.j j -; - :

=

- -

- -

- a

-- -

- =

=

- ;'-

. =

=

=

- .-

'- =

7

- -

- -

'- - =

=

-=

-- -:

r --

:=-

: -

I _

- :

- _

=

=

. :-

_ =

:

=

- =

_

11 --

I :-:

. :

- =

.

- :

: =

: :

. =

: -

-. a

_ _

- -

- =

!Ef*E

t* ;:E.aE

[?E '' =

:*a:=: E

&sB

E E

*+B

glEIffE

iiEE

igE$E

ggiigt eE IE

tEg i iH

ii

itiggiiilgggEiig+

iligiiii iiiggg + iigi

gigliIigEiigitlitiitiggii iilE

il I +iig

q€E.fligg:iIE

EE

SI i$E

iE i;E

BE

=gi$E

g E E

EE

E

Page 5: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

: =

-;.=iy

99i *

E 3 i'3

= i

j'3 E

i e'5 f E

i: U

e,='ti

o,Z L2 !.=

-: =

.- '-

(J d tr

s =

'= -; ; =

3 g + i5 ; E

iZ i, ye ;, Z

E =

i i 221:i2=*.=

!=Z

i =

fE 3:.=

i i=

a= a=

L+,-i-=

11s

--2:1 .=

- rr; E

:;2;E

;,-Z) ?C

di io;X

9E,ill.=

'a2;!r

iL;: F

,=.=

i: i4-r,ai " i-:;:

tZ

n9 ii7==

E

ET

E L t

Zu'n 2 ?:

a 1' a

J 2'i .^= ?

iE

i:,= =

*- P,

! 9 = =

,',2 = i,;

i Z

-* 7 = j.

: s'E 1=

1 iE7 * !;

= !E

yi2z._ii : ; :+€

= i;22:

x=2 t

E E

E.H

AE

! =€ ;i-tii=

-Li?=:=

il !==

eli= ;=

iE iii€=

,Ei+

iap=

, i.i E E

t I - "-E

; u_: : l1=

ii,i=

;E=

=,i =

z z.=<

iz?2 =

<, ''r

?. -= \z'

.s.= i -F

't 4 =

-3 < E

g q ,g .bs:

J,o * E

o,so 2-9 _:,rE

Z:,E

EiA

:, E1; i=

. =

-7,,ia u : *E

itz_i?=? =

,t; v y=

E:,? >

i =

'i y ''32- t= v 5€ I i

!€s 1ili*?1 v,.;Z

L:i=

7t-" aEiI =

;42?4 :e E E

E.^, i i-

= - i.E

;ae{iin,=*r*=

i =A

- =. =

, = =

,s,ti .: V

, =

. =r,E

=.

;? t = =

:!;ij,dE

;ai,; I:,s=

4i zy>

=_iZ

= JiE

,=?"'7nii'i?*-. 1

:ii'aE

lirE f =

E .2i E

EE

:',;i ctigili+ia;i;=

t'---&

=>

a! = ?.2 - =

d: &;

Z yi:: i * :, ?Z

I,=--- ,=

i j,7.= i:.!i,i;'

'3 g U ,

mE

,;rE=

eE=

p; zE=

: s g ;.:Es:E

:iEI ! E

?=iE

liiliiEy=

; ; : Ez?E

,7 Zii: !i ;sE

: iE E

iii !: i.=i;:z?i,E

*=:'2-a;"'!'-t7

?'i'i 3;:=

?"'=

7'?t.

=3 !'a

l {.

ii,,==

)

)i": .-';::i'}

-*z = i=

.,72''t-J:t Qt# =

:.i." --*.: c =

i.iQ

'=,-. d-'i'y. 1

o 2 z=,,8=

-Z!!L; a:

E i

= =

i.,r.=,!'=

=:1i:: ; =

:i =7;{z=

i: g [; ??y-E

i,.it : i i E i: I : E

iE

Ea_r_,:

==

i -.i : : . : =

= 1 =

=- . il=

,=._1 i a :=

: : ==

1 1==

r,1,1i ==

s'i';ii 1gig;igil1i=igif}iiii,lii* iE

isEE

fi !iEE

fuIH'*E

ggE E

II};gE E

EE

Egi E

igE :i eIE

Ee$i ;

i E iiiB

E gE

E E

E E

ii iI igriEi E

iE gE

iiii iiiilgiiiigggggl I ii IiaE

gi Egt sgttI ii

l E ai ggl e i:gii

Page 6: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

7 - -: - 1-'j::i.

j g= =

- =

y.=;

it,!'='v=

S

Zyiy,.=

2,L i,=

r:,1:i-i

=r =

=_::Z

Zi:t-i,A

=4.':i_iiT

LzE=

i-=

.= s:,T

eri =

2tr=,

: +

;= i12=

=1 ii =

iZL; L- =

,.2= i=

==

::?=;i=

, ;x;i : +

i iitiEitiizE

+tE

;:*rEa =

iiliTF

,1?+zE

_i-=i

, ^

- C

-C,

: =

t;=i=

1tj7,'1,?i

t.". --.v,..=

r,., -. - =

.-- -,= - :,=

.=+

='t2

';. ?:: t ia'v.=

'3,eit::a=-+

?,+

= =

': .=

':i?.a -iZ=

!"-.r_!=uZ

- 7 =

:ii;t;,.ii=i?.:=

, d !-g ,--.i

1=';z':.2=

?4,+:':i3,

I -.

? i,-. i

l-clli -,-

5- ?z,a F

=

J a q 1,5's

C 6'=

= at !'t

22 t

i -

i -. i Z iC

= E

: t y=, =

:?!= E

E +

4 E 7a liE

a !:;i= iE

!, Ei

z= Z

z; re ie i=4.i=

i =i =

f ,i,: i=: i=

rg:=;a =

:_1=r!

=.E

a 6F, -

t !"

i ;E E

Z i Ii ii,3 !7 2 2;i ? z=

i *' +

-,; ; :, e i *i 1 i7 =

;= i

E2 -* ' -xE

: E =

i" e E: =

= 1_€ E

,l 17;zbE=

\:ii2-e?E;iliaE

=i

q

=i;2?ii=

i'E=

=z<

;i!==

=-?;;=

\:a=

A=

1=yi ry E

j F

=i a;-*l=

i=,-'r=

e- ni = E

= i z=

i=E

1,9 =1'.+

:?=?,=

1 :7 :1"7 zi := : 1a, y =

yI r: i z=,

:ay,E:o?P

i=Lv=

iiia=- ilr;E

,. I rbEaI ; 1 t- =

i ! i' t's-= s z-. z t

= =

= 1., =

i., lE =

z ?-"ii iE=

Z?=

lE+

r if,-.;,iii ?i?il,-;iii'11 t=

E i, |-iz=

+=

= z-,,i1i:',ai=

ii:'1 i ,: '= =

4 = '; 1 : e'-=

? !tz ; ; z \iE

=, ;l}E

;ir; { i'i,lriEi1 E

EI*1;E

f € E;Iii-i *

=

'.-iZlz

= r=

': iZ =

i =+

tr-: Z i1+

'2 != z 1':=

i't1 i==

_ =: =

ii =

=;'-

S ;

.: - --: =

J=-

=:=

7'i::_,

= =

4 =

=

--='-',

t =.=

= =

='.

a' =

==

- 1-,::. | =

-;=._=

r r -=

-:= :.:1

;-_ ==

==

= _ _=

=-:

a_. =

=i

, :

= ;

=_t

= ,

: ;

- - . =

.'-,

_ ; -

_- : -

_ :

- -

= -

_ ; =

. .

.

EF

IEff gE

IEE

E E

iEE

iEE

EiE

f,IEE

iiBiE

BgiE

EB

€E E

s:=

E E

giiiiigitit E

EE

i}EE

EtgiiiE

EiB

g3: iItBiE

iiiiiE{iIii IffE

[iE gi iiiB

f,iB$

EE

iEE

iffiSE

EE

EE

iEB

EE

i EB

iEiE

EE

iEgiE

Bii 1g

E*; ss *€iE

€ i:t utl,ggE$, *f*qrE

{r;,iEE

i{iE*:

,iIgig[IEi;tif [iif!E

s s,[a*;EE

Ei sagis;t sn

Page 7: Fr rrl Fr (, U F-+^ neconditionat - Alfie Kohn.pdf · oO@riO\ ONLn\o t-l t-l Fl r-t It- N ca OO O\ t-r ririN 0) * 6! oo-o u)-t-! a O Z (J +J 0) O. tr bo (d (r^ q.) (g I a q) U) (-):!

_oclr9lo-@

H :

q.=* E

=-iE

giitr=

oo:lougA

E

E9

E:A

E3*

*'O

o X

=

' ..e

aub6*I

:o o

-6u

*5 6

iEY

=ro

=

Gl!

A

a.=

oinhu^

,a !

- +

o}\

\€ G

E

C

f N

+i

F

o';!?ool,t

'6 ao

Qo6

.-ooJ=

e O

ai^

;i G

9 G

;;!

,oh ,oE

tr >

: >

.=O

.E

tr E

.:oo=

o'xi=e

o.- o

g (,)

o o

I O

.r=

qoo=

o.L_zo

o in

o.lj .=

tho-=o-.:a

S

i=:aE

; =

i,?=t.-sg''s

=i

,=:=

:=;

ie:=?iitIt_y

:=

-:a?8,=

j ;'ii'E

-*=1t):J

2?'tr=

iV=

a,: p 13 3=.=

? :': =

i=2,,::

i=7ir*8..=

.1 =

.

;==

;Ei 3 =

bai LE ry T

:; i

=i2zi=

,;'':=i:ar1=

i i.=

=-'=

a,2.! 4i'i it<

'7t;i =

=i=

?=rE

;7 ==

'aE "1-:tr,i

a; ; e ;: a ,=

* li a? E

" ?-* e

yJa:p:ed=; a=

ii igas=;

i=

tVE

+,i:E

?==

i'i,-L;;ii E

u = ? li.=

=

.-u = L=

_.7'i =:a.=

z

'v?i s-i; tf ;='i:al9 na:

Ei i;=

!:i-;:Z*Z

'ii " =

s U -

=Q

:=:t;iiE

i==

17 !a=

=

u

;-n"{3a7,==

i =t,' gr,Z

!-; s

!qy !,=+

T! E

i.j,. g, B.=

i.? ", F

,=ii; ! E

;aE1?=

xE=

;?1'*i ;i=

=E

La,=:2.-!V

=72 ! "E

"i: =

1= *J v'u i 2, Z

=; ic =

?,==

- z =

: j :

- -

-:. 1 --. a .=

'. =

-a ! .:=

r := t'r

=

t: -

:: >

_:

=--

-

= _ =

=- i=

--.-.=.

-.1 ,.i:

i

EiffiiE

E?iliE

Er iiiiiiE

ii iilgHii gi* E

'iB*

lEtE

HE

iiEIE

iEE

iiEiiE

E E

i i$iEE

iiiiiiiggigtE

E $i;s;E

fiEgE

[B{E

g EE

E E

iB€rlrE

E : e ;t€ E

nEE

e

:iEiaE

EE

,s t rE g, i;B

iE [*ggE

i ggE{E

tiritBii

N