FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND%...

18
FORT PORTAL OBSTETRIC AND NEONATAL EMERGENCIES TRAINING DAYS 11 TH AND 12 TH NOVEMBER, 2014 INTRODUCTION The 2011 Ugandan Demographic Health surveys (UDHS) (Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS) and ICF International Inc, 2012) puts Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) at 438 per 100,000 live births and infant mortality rate at 79 per 1000 live births. Access to quality Basic Emergency Obstetric and Neonatal Care (BEmONC) and Comprehensive Emergency Obstetric and Neonatal Care (CEmONC) services, which could address some of the direct obstetric causes of maternal death, is available in only a limited number of facilities in Uganda. Uganda’s Ministry of Health acknowledges “HRH [Human Resource for Health] are in short supply, both in numbers and in skills mix, to effectively respond to the health needs in Uganda” (Ministry of Health, Government of Uganda, 2010). It is reasonable to assume that if the overall number of health care workers and their skill mix increased we could, in turn, increase the skilled birth attendance rate and thereby decrease the maternal and newborn mortality and morbidity. Although neither the LiverpoolMulago Partnership (LMP) or the Sustainable Volunteering Project (SVP) obviously can increase the number of health care workers it is reasonable to assume that with some appropriate training we may be able to increase the skill mix. A core objective of the SVP, since its inception, includes training in emergency obstetric skills. The overall aim of the project is real sustainable change, and we hope teaching improved skills is one way to achieve this. Many volunteers all across Uganda, whether connected to the SVP, other projects, or having travelled to Uganda independently, have realised that this is the case and have given their time to teaching. However this approach has lead to various courses being taught, in different styles and often with different messages. This can be confusing for participants, and often the content of study days and courses is not actually appropriate to the environment in Uganda. This year LMP has tried to coordinate the teaching it offers to deliver a consistent, safe and appropriate message. In May 2014, Dr Helen Allot, Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist at Royal Berkshire NHS Foundation Trust, and Obstetric lead of the Reading Kisiizi partnership, ran a practical course on obstetric emergencies in Kampala. Shortly after this a similar course was run in Hoima, but updated for the more rural setting where the highest level of care in the area is a regional referral hospital rather than a national referral hospital. Many of the team who were involved in the running of this training day in Hoima were actually based in Fort Portal and this report describes the evolution of that work and training to run two similar training days in Fort Portal at the beginning of November 2014.

Transcript of FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND%...

Page 1: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

FORT  PORTAL  OBSTETR IC  AND  NEONATAL  EMERGENCIES  TRA IN ING  

DAYS  

11TH  AND  12TH  NOVEMBER ,  2014  

INTRODUCTION  

The  2011  Ugandan  Demographic  Health  surveys  (UDHS)  (Uganda  Bureau  of  Statistics  (UBOS)  and  ICF  International  Inc,  2012)  puts  Maternal  Mortality  Ratio  (MMR)  at  438  per  100,000  live  births  and  infant  mortality  rate  at  79  per  1000  live  births.    Access  to  quality  Basic  Emergency  Obstetric  and  Neonatal  Care  (BEmONC)  and  Comprehensive  Emergency  Obstetric  and  Neonatal  Care  (CEmONC)  services,  which  could  address  some  of  the  direct  obstetric  causes  of  maternal  death,  is  available  in  only  a  limited  number  of  facilities  in  Uganda.    Uganda’s  Ministry  of  Health  acknowledges  “HRH  [Human  Resource  for  Health]  are  in  short  supply,  both  in  numbers  and  in  skills  mix,  to  effectively  respond  to  the  health  needs  in  Uganda”  (Ministry  of  Health,  Government  of  Uganda,  2010).    It  is  reasonable  to  assume  that  if  the  overall  number  of  health  care  workers  and  their  skill  mix  increased  we  could,  in  turn,  increase  the  skilled  birth  attendance  rate  and  thereby  decrease  the  maternal  and  newborn  mortality  and  morbidity.    Although  neither  the  Liverpool-­‐Mulago  Partnership  (LMP)  or  the  Sustainable  Volunteering  Project  (SVP)  obviously  can  increase  the  number  of  health  care  workers  it  is  reasonable  to  assume  that  with  some  appropriate  training  we  may  be  able  to  increase  the  skill  mix.      

A  core  objective  of  the  SVP,  since  its  inception,  includes  training  in  emergency  obstetric  skills.  The  overall  aim  of  the  project  is  real  sustainable  change,  and  we  hope  teaching  improved  skills  is  one  way  to  achieve  this.    Many  volunteers  all  across  Uganda,  whether  connected  to  the  SVP,  other  projects,  or  having  travelled  to  Uganda  independently,  have  realised  that  this  is  the  case  and  have  given  their  time  to  teaching.    However  this  approach  has  lead  to  various  courses  being  taught,  in  different  styles  and  often  with  different  messages.  This  can  be  confusing  for  participants,  and  often  the  content  of  study  days  and  courses  is  not  actually  appropriate  to  the  environment  in  Uganda.    

This  year  LMP  has  tried  to  co-­‐ordinate  the  teaching  it  offers  to  deliver  a  consistent,  safe  and  appropriate  message.  In  May  2014,  Dr  Helen  Allot,  Consultant  Obstetrician  and  Gynaecologist  at  Royal  Berkshire  NHS  Foundation  Trust,  and  Obstetric  lead  of  the  Reading  Kisiizi  partnership,  ran  a  practical  course  on  obstetric  emergencies  in  Kampala.    Shortly  after  this  a  similar  course  was  run  in  Hoima,  but  updated  for  the  more  rural  setting  where  the  highest  level  of  care  in  the  area  is  a  regional  referral  hospital  rather  than  a  national  referral  hospital.    Many  of  the  team  who  were  involved  in  the  running  of  this  training  day  in  Hoima  were  actually  based  in  Fort  Portal  and  this  report  describes  the  evolution  of  that  work  and  training  to  run  two  similar  training  days  in  Fort  Portal  at  the  beginning  of  November  2014.      

Page 2: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

THE  FORT  PORTAL  OBSTETRIC  AND  NEONATAL  EMERGENCIES  TRAINING  DAYS,  NOVEMBER  2014  

The  course  was  designed  to  take  participants  through  a  structured  approach  to  the  management  of  obstetric  and  neonatal  emergencies.    These  are  areas  identified  as  a  priority  in  Uganda.    It  was  designed  with  a  knowledge  and  understanding  of  working  in  a  challenging  and  low  resource  setting.      

A  2006  study  in  the  Lancet  raised  concerns  over  the  ability  of  health  facilities  to  recognise  and  treat  life-­‐threatening  complications  and  that  substandard  practices  contribute  directly  to  maternal  deaths,  acknowledging  that  Sub-­‐Saharan  Africa  has  the  worst  death  figures  (Ronsmans,  2006).  With  this  in  mind,  the  Obstetric  and  Neonatal  Emergencies  Training  Day  aimed  to  train  multi-­‐disciplinary  staff  from  multiple  cadres  and  settings  including  Health  Centres  and  the  Regional  Referral  Hospital.    It  was  hoped  that  if  the  day  was  successful  and  showed  meaningful  change  it  may  be  run  in  other  locations  around  the  Kabarole  district  including  health  centres  and  possibly  some  private  hospitals  to  increase  skills  across  the  region.      

FACULTY  

The  course  was  arranged  by:  Dr  Andrew  Mullett  (Specialist  Registrar  in  Paediatrics),  Dr  Lesley  Milne  (Specialist  Trainee  in  Anaesthetics)  and  Dr  Jon  Nelson  (Specialist  Registrar  in  Obstetrics  and  Gynaecology).    They  were  helped  with  organisation  and  teaching  by:  Jean  Skeen  (Senior  Midwife),  Mary  Doyle  (Volunteer  Midwife  from  Better  Birth  Uganda  Charity)  and  Nice  Bashabire  (Midwife  and  Coordinator  of  School  of  Nursing  at  Mountains  of  the  Moon  University  (MMU),  Fort  Portal).    Natalie  Tate  and  Professor  Louise  Ackers  performed  post  course  data  entry  and  analysis.    

TRAIN  THE  TRAINERS?  

One  of  the  faculty  members  was  Nice  Bashabire  who  works  at  MMU  and  has  previously  been  involved  in  teaching  on  these  days.    It  was  hoped  that  by  continuing  to  use  Ugandan  faculty  we  would  be  in  essence  “training  the  trainers”,  by  which  we  mean  that  the  by  continuing  to  practice  these  teaching  skills  and  styles  they  may  start  to  utilise  them  increasingly  in  their  own  teaching  within  Uganda.      

It  has  initially  been  the  hope  of  this  course’s  organisers  to  involve  several  other  Ugandan  trainers  from  other  facilities  in  the  country  including  several  from  Mulago  who  had  participated  in  the  original  Kampala  training  day  run  in  May  2014.    Unfortunately,  though,  these  individuals  felt  the  remuneration  offered  to  attend  and  teach  on  this  course  was  not  sufficient  and  declined  to  attend.    It  was  the  feeling  of  the  organisers  of  this  course  and  SVP  staff  that  the  remuneration  being  offered  was  acceptable  and  so  no  increase  was  offered.      

PARTNERSHIP  

The  course  was  run  in  partnership  between  the  SVP  and  MMU,  and  was  targeted  at  staff  from  Fort  Portal  Regional  Referral  Hospital  (FPRRH),  students  from  MMU  and  was  also  offered  to  staff  from  Bukuuku  Health  Centre  IV  (although  none  were  able  to  attend).      

Page 3: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

COURSE  DESCRIPTION  

This  one  day  course  was  held  over  two  consecutive  days  to  try  and  allow  as  many  staff  members  from  FPRRH  to  attend  as  possible  by  allowing  them  to  cross  cover  each  other.      

In  the  morning  the  candidates  were  given  a  series  of  six  lectures  and  tea  was  provided  halfway  through.    After  lunch,  also  provided,  the  candidates  were  divided  into  five  groups  and  five  practical  sessions  were  run  simultaneously  with  the  students  rotating  every  25mins.      

CURRICULUM  

The  maternal  mortality  ratio  (MMR)  for  Uganda  remains  high  with  the  leading  direct  causes  of  these  deaths  being:  haemorrhage  (26%),  sepsis  (22%),  obstructed  labour  (13%),  unsafe  abortion  (8%)  and  hypertensive  disorders  in  pregnancy  (6%)  (Ministry  of  Health,  Government  of  Uganda,  2010).      

These  following  topics  were  chosen  as  they  represent  complications  of  childbirth  that  are  life-­‐threatening  to  mothers  and  babies,  and  are  often  managed  inappropriately  or  without  thought  for  potentially  devastating  consequences.  The  problems  covered  are  faced  daily  in  all  of  Uganda,  including  at  FPRRH.      

In  light  of  the  current  global  Ebola  epidemic  and  the  fact  that  in  the  weeks  prior  to  the  course  Uganda  had  a  confirmed  case  of  Marburg  it  was  also  felt  that  the  day  should  have  an  overarching  theme  of  good  hygiene.    To  this  end  the  training  day  facilitators  performed  a  ‘hand  washing  dance’  at  several  points  throughout  the  day  getting  the  candidates  to  join  in  reminding  them  of  the  ‘six  steps  of  hand  hygiene’  (i.e.  the  correct  way  to  wash  your  hands  for  maximal  pathogen  clearance).    Faculty  also  observed  and  encouraged  hand  washing  during  the  tea  and  lunch  breaks.      

The  course  focused  on  practical  management  of  six  of  the  most  important  Obstetric  and  Neonatal  Emergencies,  with  lectures  being  given  on  each  of  the  following:  

1. Sepsis  (Dr  Lesley  Milne)  2. Hypertensive  Disease  in  Pregnancy  (Dr  Jon  Nelson)  3. Post  partum  haemorrhage  (PPH)  (Midwife  Nice  Bashabire)  4. Breech  birth  (Senior  Midwife  Jean  Skeen)  5. Shoulder  dystocia  (Dr  Jon  Nelson)  6. Neonatal  resuscitation  (Dr  Andrew  Mullett)  

The  afternoon  practical  sessions  were  as  follows:  

1. Hypertensive  Disease  in  Pregnancy  (Midwife  Nice  Bashabire  and  Midwife  Mary  Doyle)  

2. Post  partum  haemorrhage  (PPH)  (Dr  Lesley  Milne)  3. Breech  birth  (Senior  Midwife  Jean  Skeen)  4. Shoulder  dystocia  (Dr  Jon  Nelson)  5. Neonatal  resuscitation  (Dr  Andrew  Mullett)  

With  each  of  the  lectures  we  felt  it  was  important  to  have  a  few  “take  home  messages”  and  these  were  highlighted  at  the  end  of  each  lecture.    The  candidates  were  then  asked  to  

Page 4: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

recount  these  at  the  tea  break  and  lunch  break  to  ensure  they  retained  them.    These  take  home  messages  were  also  reiterated  during  the  afternoon  practical  sessions.      

The  take  home  messages  from  the  various  talks  were  as  follows:  

1. Sepsis  (Dr  Lesley  Milne)  a. Early  recognition    b. Early  antibiotics  and  fluids    c. Hand  washing    

2. Hypertensive  Disease  in  Pregnancy  (Dr  Jon  Nelson)  a. Control  blood  pressure  b. Treat  or  prevent  seizures  c. Fluid  balance  d. Deliver  the  baby  and  placenta    

3. Post  partum  haemorrhage  (PPH)  (Midwife  Nice  Bashabire)  a. Fluid  to  resuscitate  the  mother  b. Rub  the  uterus    

4. Breech  birth  (Senior  Midwife  Jean  Skeen)  a. Call  for  help  and  prepare  b. Hand  off  the  breech  c. Allow  natural  descent  

5. Shoulder  dystocia  (Dr  Jon  Nelson)  a. Call  for  help  b. McRoberts  position    

6. Neonatal  resuscitation  (Dr  Andrew  Mullett)  a. Dry  the  baby    b. Position  the  airway,  and  re-­‐   ���adjust  position  if  required  c. Ventilate  the  baby   ���  

The  team  also  managed  to  do  some  initial  analysis  of  the  pre-­‐course  questionnaires  during  the  morning  session  so  areas  of  particular  weakness  could  be  addressed  in  more  detail  in  the  afternoon.    Similarly,  they  analysis  of  the  post-­‐course  questionnaires  from  day  1  were  used  to  inform  and  alter  the  teaching  for  day  2  to  address  any  unmet  learning  needs.      

METHOD  OF  ASSESSMENT  

The  faculty  created  a  20-­‐question  pre  and  post-­‐course  questionnaire.    This  was  a  modification  of  a  questionnaire  created  by  the  LMP  team  in  Mbarara  for  a  similar  course  that  was  being  run  at  a  similar  time  to  these  courses.    The  modification  was  based  on  covering  the  topics  being  taught  on  our  course  as  well  as  some  comments  the  Mbarara  team  made  on  how  their  questionnaire  had  performed.      

The  same  questionnaire  was  used  both  before  and  after  the  course  to  determine  improvement.    The  questionnaire  consisted  of  true/false  questions  (Appendix  1).      

Around  two  weeks  after  the  course  all  the  candidates  who  had  provided  their  email  addresses  were  emailed  both  their  pre  and  post  course  scores  along  with  an  educational  document  explaining  and  where  appropriate  providing  evidence  of  the  correct  answers  (Appendix  2).    Copies  of  all  of  the  presentations  were  also  sent  out  to  the  candidates  for  future  reference.      

Page 5: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

RESULTS  

The  following  table  shows  the  pre-­‐  and  post-­‐course  scores  as  well  as  the  score  improvement.    There  were  a  total  of  20  true  or  false  questions  in  the  questionnaires.    We  have  subdivided  the  results  by  cadre.    Please  note  that  not  all  candidates  returned  both  questionnaires  and  therefore  have  been  excluded  from  statistical  analysis.    There  were  82  complete  returns  out  of  a  total  85  candidates  over  the  two  days.      

Cadre   Number  of  Candidates  

Pre-­‐course  Score  

Post-­‐course  Score  

Score  Imporvement  

Nursing  Staff   37   11.3   15.6   4.3  Midwives   9   12.0   15.6   3.6  Nursing  Students   25   9.0   13.9   4.9  

Other  Staff   11   12.8   15.4   2.6  Overall   82   10.9   15.0   4.1  Rounded  to  1  decimal  place.  

Paired  student  T-­‐tests  were  run  and  were  significant  for  all  individual  cadres  (p<0.05)  as  well  as  the  overall  rating  (p<0.01).  

The  other  staff  were  made  up  of  2  anaesthetic  officers,  1  intern  doctor  and  the  rest  did  not  list  a  cadre.      

COURSE  FEEDBACK  

A  post  course  feedback  form  was  also  attached  to  the  post-­‐course  questionnaire  and  this  was  analysed  by  Professor  Louise  Ackers  (LMP  Trustee)  and  Natalie  Tate  (LMP  project  evaluator)  (Appendix  3).  

The  candidates  graded  all  of  the  lectures  and  practical  sessions  on  a  scale  of  usefulness  (Not  Useful,  Useful,  Very  Useful).    These  are  the  results:  

Lecture  Topic   Not  Useful   Useful   Very  Useful  Sepsis   2%   24%   74%  Hypertensive  disease  in  pregnancy   1%   16%   82%  Post-­‐partum  Haemorrhage   2%   16%   82%  Breech   2%   19%   79%  Shoulder  Dystocia   1%   18%   80%  Neonatal  Resuscitation   0%   14%   86%  Overall   2%   18%   80%  Rounded  to  nearest  whole  percentage.      

Lecture  Topic   Not  Useful   Useful   Very  Useful  Hypertensive  disease  in  pregnancy   0%   19%   81%  Post-­‐partum  Haemorrhage   1%   18%   81%  Breech   0%   15%   85%  Shoulder  Dystocia   0%   12%   88%  Neonatal  Resuscitation   0%   5%   95%  Overall   0%   14%   86%  

Page 6: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

Rounded  to  nearest  whole  percentage.  

After  the  subject  specific  feedback  we  also  asked  three  specific  questions.    Some  of  the  responses  are  listed  below:  

Are  there  any  other  topics  that  you  feel  were  missing  from  this  Emergencies  in  Obstetrics  and  Newborn  Care  day  that  you  would  have  liked  to  have  been  covered?    

The  most  common  response  was  Antepartum  Haemorrhage  (APH).  

The  next  most  common  responses  were  variously  related  to  management  of  neonatal  complications,  followed  by  cord  prolapse.      

What  barriers  do  you  foresee  that  might  prevent  you  from  implementing  the  skills  taught  today  in  your  everyday  practice?    

The  most  common  responses  were  related  to  staffing  levels,  provision  of  equipment  and  workload  of  the  health  care  provider.      

Do  you  have  any  other  comments  or  feedback  on  the  day  to  help  us  improve  it  for  next  time?    

The  following  is  a  selection  of  the  comments  received:  

“Keep  it  up  

“Thumbs  up”  

“Excellent”  

“Well  done”  

“It  has  been  so  good,  I  have  benefited  a  lot.”  

“Time  was  very  short,  needs  5  days.”  

“Maybe  to  train  other  health  workers  in  other  districts.”  

“I  liked  the  mode  of  teaching”  

“An  excellent  mode  of  delivery  combining  theory  and  practicals.”  

All  candidates  were  given  a  certificate  of  attendance  at  the  end  of  the  day  (Appendix  4).  

LOGISTICS  AND  COSTINGS  

Due  to  the  University  of  Salford’s  support  for  development  of  facilities  at  MMU’s  School  of  Health  Sciences  skills  laboratory  including  the  donation  of  many  obstetric  mannequins  it  was  felt  appropriate  to  hold  the  training  days  in  the  facilities  at  MMU.    This  was  further  emphasised  by  LMP’s  continued  partnership  with  the  university  and  the  inclusion  of  MMU  staff  members  in  the  faculty.    However,  the  health  sciences  campus  is  located  at  Lake  Saaka  approximately  7km  from  FPRRH.      

Page 7: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

The  course  was  offered  to  all  staff  working  within  maternity  or  neonatology  at  FPRRH  via  word  of  mouth  and  posters.    We  approached  senior  staff  members  at  the  hospital  including  heads  of  department  and  the  hospital  director  to  get  permission  to  take  staff  away  from  their  daily  duties.    The  students  at  MMU  were  offered  the  course  via  means  of  phone  calls  and  in  class  announcements  via  the  MMU  staff  on  the  faculty.    The  staff  at  Bukuuku  Health  Centre  IV  were  offered  the  course  via  informing  of  the  Doctor  In-­‐Charge  and  provision  of  a  poster.      

Due  to  the  distance  it  was  felt  important  to  provide  transport  to  and  from  the  facility  for  hospital  staff.    The  university  student  bus  was  arranged  to  pick  up  candidates  from  FPRRH  at  0830  each  day.    However,  on  both  days  the  bus  was  around  45mins  late.    This  did  unfortunately  have  a  significant  impact  on  the  running  of  the  day  as  well  as  the  moral  of  the  candidates  attending.    It  was  also  noticed  by  the  faculty  waiting  at  the  hospital  that  some  of  the  prospective  candidates  did  not  wait  and  left  prior  to  the  buses  arrival.      

It  was  felt  from  previous  experience  and  the  local  faculty  members  that  in  order  to  ensure  attendance  it  would  be  important  to  provide  lunch  and  refreshments  to  the  candidates.    Arrangements  were  therefore  made  for  this  via  the  university’s  usual  caterers.      

Approximate  costs  to  run  the  two  training  days  were  as  follows:  

Provision   Cost  Location  Hire   0.00  UGX  Transport   80,000  UGX  Catering   1,200,000  UGX  Course  materials   50,000  UGX  Total   1,330,000  UGX  (~£340  GBP)  

FUTURE  WORK  

POST  COURSE  MENTORING  

Dr  Andy  Mullett,  Dr  Lesley  Milne  and  Dr  Jon  Nelson  are  all  continuing  to  work  within  FPRRH  and  are  using  a  co-­‐presence  principle  of  working  alongside  local  staff  members  to  reiterate  the  principles  and  practice  taught  on  the  training  days.    Midwife  Jean  Skeen  is  continuing  to  work  in  a  local  health  centre  three  and  is  hoping  to  start  working  in  other  local  health  centres  shortly  alongside  local  staff.    Nice  Bashabire  continues  to  work  within  the  School  of  Health  Sciences  teaching  the  nursing  students.      

LONGITUDINAL  FOLLOW  UP  OF  KNOWLEDGE  TRANSFER  

The  faculty  plan  to  email  the  questionnaire  to  all  candidates  who  provided  a  valid  email  address  3  months  after  the  course  to  try  and  obtain  a  longer-­‐term  picture  of  retention  knowledge.    It  will  be  specifically  requested  that  they  do  not  refer  to  the  answers  provided  although  the  faculty  acknowledge  that  this  is  a  risk  and  may  skew  the  responses.    They  will  also  hand  out  hard  copies  to  those  staff  members  who  they  are  working  alongside  who  attended  the  course  to  try  to  prevent  where  possible  reference  back  to  the  answers  provided  and  to  ensure  completion.      

Page 8: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

FUTURE  TRAINING  DAYS  

The  faculty  hope  to  be  able  to  arrange  similar  training  days  at  some  of  the  local  larger  health  centres  in  the  district  in  the  New  Year,  at  which  staff  from  smaller  local  health  centres  would  also  be  invited.    They  also  hope  to  run  one  at  FPRRH  to  try  and  encourage  more  doctors  to  attend.    It  should  be  noted  that  the  intern  doctors  were  unfortunately  on  strike  over  pay  on  the  days  of  the  course  and  this  may  have  affected  attendance.      

The  faculty  continue  to  try  to  identify  local  staff  members  who  would  be  suitable  to  be  part  of  the  faculty  in  future  and  possibly  run  similar  training  days  without  the  aid  of  LMP  volunteers.      

   

Page 9: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

BIBLIOGRAPHY  

Aldrich,  E.  (2014).  Policy  Brief:  Translating  evidence  from  a  study  on  the  relationship  between  transport  for  emergency  obstetric  care  and  maternal  health  and  well-­‐being.  The  Sustainable  Volunteering  Project  &  University  of  Salford.  Salford:  University  of  Salford.  

Ministry  of  Health,  Government  of  Uganda.  (2010).  Health  Sector  Strategiv  Plan  III  2010/11  -­‐  2014/15.  Government  of  Uganda,  Ministry  of  Health.  Ministry  of  Health,  Government  of  Uganda.  

Ronsmans,  C.  G.  (2006).  Maternal  Mortality:  who,  when,  where  and  why?  The  Lancet  ,  368,  1195-­‐1196.  

Uganda  Bureau  of  Statistics  (UBOS)  and  ICF  International  Inc.  (2012).  Uganda  Demographic  and  Health  Survey  2011.  Kampala,  Uganda:  UBOS  and  Calverton,  Maryland:  ICF  International  Inc.  

 

   

Page 10: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

APPENDIX  1  

   

Candidate Number:

Pre and Post Course Assessments

Please indicate your cadre here:

If you would like to know your pre & post course results please print your email address here:

Question TRUE FALSE Dont Know

Low blood pressure is an early sign in haemorrhage.

Intravenous fluid should be given at a rate of 1 litre every 2 hours in hypovolaemic shock.

Raised respiratory rate is a sensitive measure in shock.

In septic shock patients should be given fluids early and rapidly.

We should be more worried about a patient who responds to voice than one who responds to pain.

Eclamptic fits can only happen before the delivery of the baby.

The correct management with eclampsia is to perform a caesarean section immediately.

In haemorrhage raised heart rate is an early sign.

The majority of cases of shoulder dystocia will resolve with McRoberts’ position alone.

In eclampsia a urine output of more than 30 mls per hour is reassuring.

An unconscious but breathing patient should be kept in the recovery position.

Magnesium sulphate is the drug of choice in prevention of eclampsia.

The most common cause of post partum haemorrhage is vaginal trauma.

You know if a patient is in septic shock because the temperature is always high.

Drying the baby is an important early step in neonatal resuscitation.

Suctioning is a routine part of neonatal resuscitation.

The correct airway position for neonatal resuscitation is the ‘neutral position’.

A single health care worker can successfully manage shoulder dystocia alone.

In breech delivery a “hands off” approach should be used until delivery of the head.

In breech, active pushing should be discouraged until the cervix is fully dilated.

Page 11: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

APPENDIX  2  

Answers  and  explanations  to  pre  and  post  course  questionnaires  from  Obstetric  and  Neonatal  Emergencies  Training  Day  

1.  Low  blood  pressure  is  an  early  sign  in  haemorrhage.  False  Low blood pressure is a late sign of haemorrhage. The earliest sign is tachycardia. Early in haemorrhage the body compensates for blood loss by increasing the heart rate and systemic vascular resistance in order to maintain blood pressure and hence the tissue perfusion pressure. Eventually, these compensatory mechanisms will fail and only then will blood pressure start to fall. The table below shows the signs that occur during progressive haemorrhage. This is known colloquially as the Tennis Rules due to the % blood loss being the same as the tennis scoring system which can help to remember the percentages.

You can see clearly from here why it is important to try and estimate blood loss accurately. The bodies total circulating blood volume is approximately 5-6L. Therefore, a loss of 2L = 33% and is potentially life threatening.

2.  Intravenous  fluid  should  be  given  at  a  rate  of  1  litre  every  2  hours  in  hypovolaemic  shock.    False  There is no correct rate to give fluids in hypovolaemic shock. Fluids should be given as quickly as possible to restore the circulating volume and restore tissue perfusion. Two large bore cannula’s should be placed in large central veins (normally the antecubital fossa’s), and fluids should be run as quickly as possible. When infusing

Page 12: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

large volumes of fluids it is preferable if these are warmed, however delivery of fluids should not be delayed waiting for them to be warmed. Get the next bag warming whilst the first is running in.

3.  Raised  respiratory  rate  is  a  sensitive  measure  in  septic  shock.    True  A raised respiratory rate is a sensitive sign in shock of any type. In septic shock in particular it is one of the diagnostic criteria for the Systemic Inflammatory Response Syndrome (SIRS).

Remember that sepsis is defined by the presence of the SIRS response plus a source of infection. Septic shock is defined as sepsis induced hypotension (despite adequate fluid resuscitation) plus end organ perfusion abnormalities.

4.  In  septic  shock  patients  should  be  given  fluids  early  and  rapidly.    True  As you can see from the above answer it is important to fluid resuscitate early and aggressively to maintain tissue perfusion pressures. There is good evidence to show that this can significantly reduce morbidity and mortality (Early goal-directed therapy was introduced by Emanuel P. Rivers, MD, MPH in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2001.)

5.  We  should  be  more  worried  about  a  patient  who  responds  to  voice  than  one  who  responds  to  pain.    False  The AVPU scale is a very simple and quick way of scoring patients conscious level. The Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) is still the gold standard but can be lengthy to perform in the emergency situation. It is, therefore, now widely accepted that the AVPU is acceptable in emergencies. To remind you AVPU stands for:

Sepsis and Septic ShockDr Lesley Milne

Fort Portal Regional Referral Hospital

UK Maternal Mortality from Sepsis

2003 - 2005: 0.85 deaths per 100,000 maternities from sepsis

2006 - 2008: 1.13 deaths in 2006–2008 from sepsis

Sepsis is now the most common cause of Direct maternal death.

The Eighth Report of the Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom

Ugandan Maternal Mortality from Sepsis

Pregnancy related sepsis 10%

Infections not related to pregnancy 11%

Total 21%

2nd National Maternal and Perinatal Death Review (MPDR), Ugandan Ministry of Health 2012/2013:

Comparing sepsis globally

American College of Chest Physicians and Society of Critical Care Medicine met in 1991 to reach a consensus on the diagnosis of sepsis and its sequelae.

These definitions have provided a foundation for the common reporting and discussion of sepsis, its complications and treatment.

SIRS: Systemic Inflammatory Response Syndrome

Manifest by two or more of the following conditions:

1. A temperature >38oC or <36oC

2. An heart rate >90 beats per minute

3. A respiratory rate >20 breaths per minute or a PaCO2 <32 mmHg

4. A white blood cell count >12,000/mm3 or <4000/mm3, or the presence of >10% immature forms.

Definitions

Sepsis (Simple):

The systemic response to infection (SIRS)

plus

an infection.

Page 13: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

A Alert V Responsive to Voice P Responsive to Pain U Unconscious This indicates a decreasing level of consciousness as you move down the table, the more the conscious level is depressed the more worried you should be.

6.  Eclamptic  fits  can  only  happen  before  the  delivery  of  the  baby.    False  Eclamptic fits can happen up to one week post partum. One study found that 44% fits occur postnatally, 38% antepartum and 18% intrapartum (Douglas KA, Redman CWG (1994) Eclampsia in the United Kingdom. BMJ 309:1395–1400)

7.  The  correct  management  with  eclampsia  is  to  perform  a  caesarean  section  immediately.    False  The decision to perform a caesarean section is based on a number of different factors. The first priority is to stabilise the mother. Delivery is likely to be indicated over the coming hours to days, however vaginal delivery is still the preferred method of delivery unless caesarean is otherwise indicated.

8.  In  haemorrhage  raised  heart  rate  is  an  early  sign.  True  See answer to question 1.

9.  The  majority  of  cases  of  shoulder  dystocia  will  resolve  with  McRoberts’  position  alone.  True  A majority of cases of shoulder dystocia will resolve with the McRoberts’ position, with success rates of up to 90% reported (McFarland MB et al. Perinatal outcome and the type and number of maneuvers in shoulder dystocia. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 1996;55:219–24).

10.  In  eclampsia  an  urine  output  of  more  than  30  mls  per  hour  is  reassuring.  True  A urine output of 0.5ml/kg/hour is considered to be evidence that renal function is maintained, and this is approximate equivalent to 30ml/hour in most patients. It is also reassuring when using magnesium sulphate as it is excreted renally and therefore is unlikely to be accumulating and causing serious side effects like respiratory or neurological depression.

Page 14: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

11.  An  unconscious  but  breathing  patient  should  be  kept  in  the  recovery  position.  True  This will reduce the risk of aspiration of vomit or other secretions and help maintain patency of the airway.

12.  Magnesium  sulphate  is  the  drug  of  choice  in  prevention  of  eclampsia.  True  There is good evidence that eclamptic seizures are more likely to stop with magnesium sulphate administration and also that further seizures will be prevented. This is compared to other anti-seizure drugs e.g benzodiazepines or sodium valproate.

13.  The  most  common  cause  of  post  partum  haemorrhage  is  vaginal  trauma.  False  It widely accepted that the most common cause is uterine atony, hence why initial management focuses on atony, although all causes should be considered and managed appropriately (FIGO Guidelines: Prevention and treatment of postpartum hemorrhage in low-resource settings; International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 117 (2012) 108–118).

14.  You  know  if  a  patient  is  in  septic  shock  because  the  temperature  is  always  high.  False  As part of the SIRS response temperature can be high (>38oC) or low (<36oC) (see question 3).

15.  Drying  the  baby  is  an  important  early  step  in  neonatal  resuscitation.  True  Babies have a larger surface area to volume ration than older children or adults. When wet they will loose heat very quickly via evaporation dropping their temperature and hindering resuscitation. Hypothermia is a known killer of neonates.

16.  Suctioning  is  a  routine  part  of  neonatal  resuscitation.  False  Suctioning is no longer a routine part of neonatal resuscitation. There is now good evidence that its routine use may in fact be detrimental to resuscitation efforts. That is not to say that it may not still occasionally be required, but its use should be saved only for incidences when a something can be seen that may be occluding the airway, such as a blood clot or thick meconium. This can then be removed under direct vision (meaning you can see what you are suctioning). Thin secretions do not need to be suctioned. It may be considered again at the point of using airway adjuncts if you are struggling to get air entry.

Page 15: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

17.  The  correct  airway  position  for  neonatal  resuscitation  is  the  ‘neutral  position’  True  The neonate has a number of differences anatomically that impact on the airway. The occiput is larger comparative to the adult and this will tend to flex the head forward and occlude the airway. The tongue is relatively larger in the mouth than in adults. The larynx is more anterior. The neonate that required resuscitation is also likely to have poor muscle tone initially, which will effect the upper airway tone. If the airway is either over or under extended it may therefore occlude. The easiest position to achieve a patent airway and good air entry is therefore the neutral position, which means that the face is parallel to the bed.

18.  A  single  health  care  worker  can  successfully  manage  shoulder  dystocia  alone.  False  Whilst there maybe situations where you maybe the only person present at a shoulder dystocia, it is a very difficult emergency to manage alone, hence why your first action should be to call for help.

19.  In  breech  delivery  a  “hands  off”  approach  should  be  used  until  delivery  of  the  head.  True  Unless a breech extraction is being performed for the second twin, most breech deliveries will occur spontaneous up to delivery of the head. Excessive handling of the baby prior to this point can cause trauma and other complications such as a nuchal arm. However, controlled delivery of the head is recommended to aid flexion and prevent sudden delivery and decompression injuries.

Page 16: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

20.  In  breech,  active  pushing  should  be  discouraged  until  the  cervix  is  fully  dilated.  True  This is true for any delivery, but particularly in breech to ensure the presenting part does not slip through a incompletely dilated cervix and then cause entrapment of the after coming head.    

Page 17: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

APPENDIX  3  

   

Candidate Number:

Are there any other topics that you feel were missing from this Emergencies in Obstetrics and Newborn Care day that you would have liked to have been covered?

What barriers do you foresee that might prevent you from implementing the skills taught today in your everyday practice?

Do you have any other comments or feedback on the day to help us improve it for next time?

How useful did you find the following lectures?

Not Very Useful Useful Very Useful

Sepsis and Septic Shock

Hypertensive Disease in Pregnancy

Post Partum Haemorrhage

Breech

Shoulder Dystocia

Neonatal Resuscitation

How useful did you find the following scenarios?

Not Very Useful Useful Very Useful

Hypertensive Disease in Pregnancy

Post Partum Haemorrhage

Breech

Shoulder Dystocia

Neonatal Resuscitation

Was there anything else you would have liked to have been covered within these lectures?

Sepsis and Septic Shock

Hypertensive Disease in Pregnancy

Post Partum Haemorrhage

Breech

Shoulder Dystocia

Neonatal Resuscitation

Page 18: FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES… · FORTPORTALOBSTETRICAND% NEONATAL%EMERGENCIES%TRAINING% DAYS% 11TH%AND%12TH%NOVEMBER,%2014% INTRODUCTION% The%2011Ugandan%Demographic%Health%surveys%(UDHS)%(Uganda

APPENDIX  4  

 

EMERGENCY OBSTETRIC AND NEWBORN care

This is to certify that

____________________ COMPLETED A ONE DAY TRAINING WORSHOP ON

November 2014

Professor LOUISE ACKERS – TRUSTEE OF the Liverpool-

mulago partnership

Dr. Edmond Kagambe – deputy

vice chancellor OF MOUNTAINS OF THE MOON

UNIVERSITY