Formas Jur_dicas e Mudan_a Social - Marcus Faro de Castro Marcado

www.princexml.comThis document was created with Prince, a great way of getting web content onto paper.

$$&%9-+066;-P$-;69,-5,M:;91)-*):;-

+14-5;6O 65-O )?

P9):I31)

GOIS/TOCANTINS

=5,-7-5,H5+1)O$-;69-96769;6O 65-

O )?

O61D51)

MATO GROSSO DO SUL/MATO GROSSO

#

):;96 )9+

Produo grfica )931#)4714Produo eletrnica #664

KL9 G:J9 AFL=?J9 9 GD=\[G DireitoDesenvolvimento e Justia ;GGJ

+9J9 DAR=L@=)AF9IM=E=ADMEAF9E

Sumrio

Prefcio

Nota dos editores

Nota do autor

1. Introduo

2. Forma e matria: articulaes nafilosofia e na jurisprudentia

K>GJE9KADGKG>A9=G;GFL=PLG

?AL9\h=K

Prefcio

)G =FKAFG BMJ`

A9 9 J=DA?A[G 9 HGD`LA;9 = 9 =;GFGEA9 L9FLG F9 LJ9

Nota dos editores

H9J;=JA9 $- $/* "1.9J9AN9 HM:DA;9 DANJGK

GD=\[G Direito Desenvolvimento eJustia ] 9;9

GD=\[G Direito em Contexto HM:DA;9G:J9K iL=AK X 9LANA

L9FLG G JA?GJ 9;9

Nota do autor

)=KL9 G:J9 ;GE =P;=\[G

1. Introduo

E ME ?J9F

J=KHGKL9 HGJ ME GM

;GEHD=L9E=FL= AF9

HM:DA;9MFGJE9\h=K KG;A9AK 9;=D=J9

;=JL9E=FL= ;GFKLALMA 9 ;@9N= H9J9 9 9\[G=PALGK9

H9H]AK rF=?9LANGs = rHGKALANGs

r;A_F;A9s G IM= KAF9DAR9 9 KM9 NAF;MD9\[G>MF

D=A ;GEG E=J9 KM:KMF\[G

;GFLJA:MA\h=K G>=J=;A

;GF;J=LGK

=KE=J9

>ADGKG>A9 = KM9K =D9:GJ9\h=K

;GFKLALM`J9E G >GJE9DAKEG BMJ`

>9LGK !AF9DE=FL= 9 =D9:GJ9\[G

;GEG 9K L=F

>GJE9 = E9L]JA9 9 ;GEH9J9\[G ]J=N=D9A;9

%G9IMAE )9:M;G ;@9EGM

9FL9KH 1=J HGJ =P=EHDG !=JJ9R %J = AFAR ALL9J = DE=A

2. Forma e matria: articu-laes na filosofia e na

jurisprudentia

2.1 As formas da filosofia e ocontexto da polis

E ME

=FLJ= GK JGE9FGK L=JA9

/9AK A9 F=E >ADGKG>A9 ]MF

J=DA?AGK9K ;=D=:J9

;]M L=JJ9 LJGNh=K 9KLJGK N=FLGK =L;HJGNAF@9

L9E:]E rAEHJ=?F9

9KKAF9D9 1=JF9FL r6G7 IM=

HGKA\h=K HGD`LA;9K F9 ;A

J9Rh=K G KG>AKL9 L9DN=R F[G K=B9 ME HJ9LA;9FL=

;GFN=F\[G FG

=KH=;A9D 9

+GJ ;GFKLALMAJ G >MF

q +D9L[G HGKKA:ADALGM IM= GK ;9EHGK D=P[G J9;AGF9D = KAKL=EWLA;9 KG:J= 9 HGD`LA;9 !ADGKG>A9 +GD`LA;9 = 9 EGJ9D TLA;9>GKK=EAF9M?MJ9

>GJE9K

HD9LfFA;G ] IM= FG HD9FG

HGL_F;A9s AF>GJE= =E ME K=J

IM9D 9 r$

E9K L9E:]E

:=E E9AK L9J

KG;A=9;= ;GE G HJG:D=E9

;GEHD=L9E=FL= = 9 E9J?AF9DAR9J G IM= F[G=J9 >GJE9D GMLJ9 IM=

!ADGKG>A9 +GD`LA;9 HJ=L=F

E9L9E IM9LGJR= >AD@GK

J=?J9K

r9HJ==F

?J9MK ;9

J=HGKALdJAG

9G IM= r;9

F9LMJ9D

GEG KM?=JAA9 ;GE HJ=G;MH9\h=K HJWLA;9K L=F@9 ?=J9A9+GD`LA;9 = 9 TLA;9 =D9 F[G ;@=?GM 9HJG

;GFLJ9HGKA\[G E=J9E=FL= AFL=D=;LM9D =FLJ=9K AGK = G ;GKLME= J=DA?AGKG LJ9

9;GFL=;A9 ;GE GK ?J=?GK GK JGE9FGK AFA;A9DE=FL= H=J;=:A9E G EMF

!GA F9 KM9 >GJE9 =KLGA;9 ;GE GK =K;JALGK

=PLAFLG FG K];MDG $$ 9 EMAL9KIM=KLh=K >A;9N9E KG: 9 dJ:AL9

L=KL9E=FLWJA9 = F[G L=KL9E=FLWJA9G:JA?9\h=K ;GFLJ9LM9AK =

+GJL9FLG ;GEG AF

J=HM:DA;9F9 NWJAGK K=LGJ=K

DM?9J=K Hi:DA;GK =

AEHJdHJAG KM?=JAJ IM= GK JGE9FGK GJE9DAKEGBMJ`

9D?ME9K

+GJ AKKG KMKL=FL9J ;GEG >9R (A?M=D-=9D= IM= G;GJJ=M ME rEAD9?J= JGE9FGs ;GJJ=KHGF

H F r9 BMJAKHJM

K=JNA\G

AFKLJME=FL9DAR9\[G

FGJE9LANGK =KK= >GJE9DAKEG HJ9?EWLA;GK= GHGJW E9AK L9JGJE9DAKEG ;GF;=ALM9DAKL9s L`HA;G

J=DA?A[G AKKG ] 9H=F9K 9 ;MDLMJ9 LJ9

IM= HG=J=;A

HGJ =P=EHDG HGJ AFKLALM;AGF9DAR9J BMJA

+GJL9FLG K= G rBG?9J ;GE 9K >GJE9KsH=JEALA9 9 KMKL=FL9\[G

H=JEALAM =E -GE9 IM= G KL9

NAF;MD9\[G Dd?A;9 ;GE

.G:J= AKKG 9AF

ME9 teoria

IM9D G

;GF>A?MJ9\[G

;GE KA?FA>A;9

)=KK= K=FLAGJE9s = rE9L]JA9s = KM9K AEHDA;9\h=K HGD`LA;9K FG ;9EHG ADGKG>A9

IM= K= HJGB=L9N9 ;GEG EGJ9D mores =AFA9 H9

;GFLJ9HGFLG ;GEH9JWN=D 9G IM= K=HJG

@=D=FAKEG HA;MJAKEG KLGA;AKEG =LA;AKEG HJGH9?GM ME9 HKA;GDG?A9 IM= AEHDA;9N9 FME9 9LALM

9;MEMD9\[G

9DE9 AF

=FLJ= GK ?J=?GK GK E9D=K HJ9LA;9

GMLJ9 E9AK J=D9;AGF9GA AFL=FK9E=FL=GJEMD9\h=K

DM=F;A9J J=DA?AGK9E=FL= G EMF

9FL=JAGJ 9G K];MDG 3$$ F[G =J9E

;DWKKA;G >GJ9E AF;GJHGJ9

LGJFGM G HJAE=AJG J;=:AKHG GA ;JA9

G;MH9J G LJGFG A;9J9 K=E @=J

HdK GK EGKL=AJGK

9KK=E:D=A9

;GEG >GJEMD9

=E=J?_F;A9

>AJE= GHGKA\[G HGD`LA;9 9G J=A J=9\[G GA 9 9

;GEH=L_F;A9 J=9D H9J9

;GF>GJE9\[G

+GJ E=AG

)GJE9F

KMHD9FL9FGJ9E K=F

KALM9\h=K =KH=;`>A;9K

;9J9;L=J`KLA;9

KG:J= >9LGK = ;GF

:9K= FG K=?MF

IM= 9 G>=FK9 =>=LAN9 F[G =J9

"D9FNADD ;GF@=;A9 ;=J;9

commnon law 9L] @GB= >GJE9K BMJ`

+9J9 +G;G;C !GJL=K;M= =J9 ME BMJAKL9 IM==K;J=NA9 KG:J= >ADGKG>A9 GM K=B9 ME BMJAKL9IM= HJG;MJ9N9 J=>D=LAJ >ADGKG>A;9E=FL=KG:J= 9 EM

rEGD=P[G J=;9A KG:J= 9 HJGNAGJLMF9 = 9 NAJLM

9:KGDML9 = F=;=KKWJA9 AR=J9+D9L[G JAKLdL=D=K @9NA9 ;GFLJA:M`GJE9

9 HGD`LA;9 = 9?AJ =E KG;A=

E KM9 :MK;9 HGJ ;JAL]JAGK H9J9 KMH=J9J 9HGKKA:ADA

FG ;GFL=i

rK= =D=

KMHGJL9J[G G L=KL=

J9 F9 KM9 expertise

jurisprudentia 9:KGJN=FGJE9KsGM;9L=?GJA9K

H=D9 ;GFKLJM\[G GAL9E:]E ;GF>GJE= K=JW NAKLG 9:9APG GIM= >AR=J9E GK BMJAKL9K IM= =D9:GJ9J9E G

;GJJ=KHGF

G>=J=;=M E=AGK H9J9 AF;GJHGJ9J XKr>GJE9Ks 9

E K=?MF

;GEHGKLGK

9;=D=J9GJE9\[G L=;FGDd?A;9

KK9 9:=JLMJ9 H9J9 HJGEGN=J 9 reforma

;GFLJ9HGKA\[G X J=DA?A[G HGDAL=`KL9 G A

rH=JE9F=;= G;MDLG = J=IM=J ME9 =PHDA;9\[G 9 L`LMDG A;9

=PLJ9HGD9\[G GJE9 = E9L]JA9 IM= =NGDMAM H9J9 9 NAK[GK=?MF

< 9 lex naturae HG

jurisprudentia E=A;9J9E ;GF@=;A

=;GFfEA;G

;=JL9 E=

E9F=AJ9 A9 ?J=?9 GFLM

+9J9 =FL=F

;GJJ=KHGF

>J=IM=FL=E=FL= J=KN9D9N9 H9J9 9 =PHJ=KK[GHG]LA;9 GA ;9H9R

9JAKLGL]DA;9K HMF@9E E=FGK _F>9K= F9GHGKA\[G =FLJ= r>GJE9s = rE9L]JA9s )G;9EHG A9 +GD`LA;9 ;GEG NAKLGJAKLdL=D=K @9NA9

G>=J=;AMF

J9;AGF9D ;=AL9N9E =E ?=J9D 9 GHGKA\[G9JAKLGL]DA;9 =FLJ= J9;AG;`FAGK 9HG

9JIMAL=LMJ9 KKAE ;GEG F9 >ADGKG>A9 GKJ9;AG;`FAGK =KL9J rN=J

;=JLG = K=F

=D9:GJ9\[G BMJ`=J=FL=K 9KALM9\h=K = ;GF

;GFLJWJAGK ] =NA

=P;=LG GF=LANGL9FLG FGK ;9KGK ;ANAK IM9FLG FGK ;JAEAF9AK 676

;GFN=J?_F;A9

H9JL=K =E IM= G GA GJ?9FAR9

J=;GE=F

AFL=F\[G

GE KM9K 9FWDAK=K = K`FL=K=K ?=J9N9E 9FGL9\h=K ?DGK9K AFL=JDAF=9J=K GM E9J?AF9AKIM= K=JNA9E =J_F;A9K E9AK ?=F]JA;9KGM KAFL]LA;9K

"DGK9 KG:J= J=N=JL=J Ipso jure = 9KKAE=D= L=E 9 =KH];A=

* HJAE=AJG H9KKG =J9 =PHDA;9J ;GEG GK DANJGK 6

=PHDGJ9E >A?MJ9K GJE9AK GJA?AF9

AJJ=>MLWN=D

scripta 9 J9R[G HGJ =K;JALG KL9N9 9`ME9 ;GF;=H\[G

E ;GFLJ9KL= ;GE GK "DGK9

9EHD9 = 9E:A;AGK9

H9J9 G

HJG>MF

AKKG 9L=FL9N9E E9AK H9J9 GK J=>=J=F;A9AKFGJE9LANGK DG;9AK F[G HJGNAF

L];FA;9 HGD`LA;9 )=KK= K=FLAGJ\GK

DGJ=K;=M ;GE NA?GJF9IM=D=EGE=FLG+GJ =KK= = GMLJGK EGLANGK 9 =K;GD9

J9R[G FG LGEAKEG 9 >D=PA:ADA

BMJ`GJ9E ;9H9R=KGJE9\[G

jurisprudentia

L=GDG?A9

>AR=J9E =PH9F

E=KE9K L=F

=D= K=B9

HD9LfFA;G

.G:J= AKKG G:K=JN9 #=A

+D9L[GNH 1=J'GF?H et seq D9F;@]H >.;@MDLRH >/=DD=?=FGMH=JGMKK=\[G .G:J=GKAKL=E9>GJEMD9JN=J2GD>>H >=JE9FH 1=JK=\[G supra >=9J'GK9FGH >=JE9FH 1=J'GH=KH 1=J/=DD=?=FGMH=JMKH >2GD>>H 1=J#=?=DH 1=J#=?=DH et seq. 9L9D@9=-G

2=:=J 9 HJGHh= IM= 9 HKA;GDG?A9

;GFLAF=FL= =MJGH=M E9AK GM E=FGK 9 H9JLAJ

IM= K= IM=AP9

?GN=JF9J HGJ E=AG

9AP9 $

3. Ascenso do formalismojurdico moderno

3.1. Agitaes da retrica e acrtica humanista

GEG NAKLG FG ;9H`LMDG 9FL=JAGJ 9=D9:GJ9\[G GJE9Ks BMJ`

G HJG:D=E9

jurisprudentia ME ;GFBMFLG

HJGHdKALG

=E =K9K J=LdJA;9K = E`KLA;9K ] XIM9D K= GHMF@9E r@=J=KA9Ks

FLJ= =D=K GK IM= G:LAN=J9E E9AGJ _PALGHGD`LA;G >GJ9E GK ;D]JA?GK = 9K ;G9DARh=KEGFWJIMA;G:MJ?M=K9K +GJ]E =KL9K iDLAE9K 9;9:9J9E HGJ KG:J=HMB9J =

=D=E=FLG =KL9N9 =E ?J9F

jus canonum = 9

AEHMDKAGF9F

H9;A>A;9\[G @GMN= NWJA9K ;A

AFA;A9DE=FL=

NARAF@9 KG:J= 9 HMFA\[G

HJ9LA;9

9J?ME=FLG =E >9NGJ GJE9s A?MJ9

rLMEMDLGs q =J9 9 ;9J9;L=J`KLA;9 IM= ;GFLJA:M`9 H9J9 LGJF9J -GE9 ME9 J=Hi:DA;9

KADG?AKEGK AF;GEHD=LGK =FLAE=E9K = L9E:]E HGJ NAK9J 9 ;GEMFA;9\[G ;GE H=KKG9KK=E@9:ADA

* >ADdKG>G KGDALWJAG =E K=M ;9EHG ;A=FL`>A;G H9JLA;MD9J 9HdK AFN=KLA?9J ;MA

AFKLALM;AGF9D

* @ME9FAKEG

EGNAE=FL9\[G

;GFKLJ9F?AE=FLGK

AF;=FLAN9J IM= GK dictatores K=

HDMJ9D E GMLJ9K H9D9NJ9K G =>=ALG

DAL=J9LMJ9 = @AKLdJA9 ;GEG E=AG

GFLJA:M`J9E H9J9 G

E=KE9 =J9 >GJE9

AKKG HGJ 9KKAE

J=LdJA;9 =

AFL=FK9E=FL= GK >GJE9DAKEGK

AF>DM=FL=K =E L=JEGK HGD`LA;GK F[G >GA GIM= D=N9N9 AF=IMANG;9E=FL= 9G J=HM:DA;9FAKEG HDMJ9DAKL9 ;GEG =J9 9 LJ9B=LdJA9 IM=EGLAN9N9 AFL=D=;LM9AK = @GE=FK HJWLA;GK=E ;A

plenitudo potestatis =J9 ME HJAEGJ

= KM9K ;GFK=IM_F;A9K HJWLA;9K )=KK= =KIM=E9 G :=E

HD9LfFA;Gs F9 :9K=

HJAE=AJ9 ;GF

F=;=KKA

K=MK =>=ALGK =;GFfEA;GK = HGD`LA;GK 9 EAKK[GK=JA9E9AKA9GJE9s

K=IM=F;A9D = @A=J9JIMA9 9JIMAL=LfFA;9s BWE=F;AGF9

BMKF9LMJ9DAKL9 IM= K=JW 9:GJ

$EH]JAG =

=>A;A=FL=E=FL= HGJ E=AG

;GEG ?=GE=LJA9 ;GE=\9 ;GE HGFLGK DAF@9KKMH=J>`;A=K=L;sT HJ=;AKG 9L=FL9J H9J9 9 EM=J_F;A9

* IM= AKKG KAF9DAR9N9 =J9 IM= 9 jurispru-dentia FG ;GFLAF=FL= = =E K=?MA

=E IM= HJ=

* LJ9:9D@G

LJ=;@GK ;GFL=F

* IM= ] HJ=;AKG

J9R[G AEHD9FL9

;GF;=ALGK Dd?A;GK ;GEG G

KK9 L=J;=AJ9 >9K=

BMJAKL9K E=

G;GJJA

9KKAE 9 =KK9 >ADGKG>A9 9 ;@9F;=

F=?9N9 9 HGKKA:ADA

.G: 9 !ADGKG>A9 )9LMJ9D MF

A9 )9LMJ9D 9

=D9:GJ9\[G GJE9Ks A9 )9LMJ9D = KM9 J=HJ=K=FL9\[G AFL=D=;LM9D

=P;=\h=K F[G =J=;=J9E 9H=F9K ;GFKAJGMP9E=FL= 9DAF@9N9=J_F;A9 E=L9>`KA;9 :WKA;9 IM= =J9 99DE9 @ME9F9 $KKG =KLW F9K HGJ\h=K

contrato KG;A9D KK= NG;9:MDWJAG >GJF=;=JA9 L=JEGK ;JM;A9AK IM= FG ;9EHG A9 +GD`LA;9 K=JA9E 9D\9

;GFLJ9LG ] ME 9;J]K;AEG E=L9>`KA;G 9KKAE;GEG G EGNAE=FLG G ] =E J=D9\[G XE9L]JA9F9GFLGDG?A9E=;9FA;AKL9*MLJG 9KH=;LG 9

continuo ratiocinationes filo deducere ;GF>=J= 9G

L`HA;G GJEMD9\h=K BMKF9LMJ9DAKL9K IM=F[G K= >9D= E9AK =E r>GJE9Ks

+GJ GMLJG D9

EAF@9 HJAE=AJ9 HJ=G;MH9\[G >GA J=D9;AGF9J 9KHJGN9K

'9?MK IM= 9AF

E J=KMEG FG

JGE9F`KLA;9 = L9E:]E =E GMLJ9K >GFL=K>J=IM=FL=E=FL= G ;GKLME= = HM

H9JLA;MD9J=K F9 K=D=\[G = GJ?9FAR9\[G =J=F;A9AK FGJE9LANGK JGE9FGK = GMLJGKKG:J= GK IM9AK K=

HJGHMK=EGK F=KL= DANJG ] HGJL9FLG HfJ 9K '=AKANAK F9 KM9 GJ

AJ=ALG )9LMJ9D 9 rJ9R[Gs =KH=;MD9LAN9>A;9JA9 =F;9JJ=?9

2A=9;C=J 9 AF>DM_F;A9

!ADGKG>A9

Preussischen Staaten 9L] G CodeCivil des Franais = G AllgemeinesBrgerliches Gesetzbuch fr die deutschenErblnder q G dGJE9K HGE:9DAF9K = 9

>9EGK9 r'=A

AFLJ`FK=;9K = AF9DL=J9N=AKs KK= KA?FA>A;9

l rE9FA>=KL9KMLADA

;GE=J;A9D q >9RA9E FG K=FLA

Fonte: Berman (2003, p. 117)

3.3. Mercados, ordem burguesa,positivismos

(M

GJE9Ks IM= NAF@9E K=

K >GJE9K 9IMA J=>=JA

dispositio = elocutio * =EHJ=?G

=>=ALGK q

E=KEG IM9DIM=J

E=L9>`KA;9K q = =AL9 HGJ E=AGA

AJGFAR9J 9 NA

=;GFGEA;9E=FL= FG HD9FG

r=FIM9FLG GK >ADdKG>GK

IM= 9K 9\h=K L`LMDGK GM ;MHGFK IM=

;GEHD=PG GJE9JA9 9 rHJGHJA=

HJG=EAF_F;A9 X J=F

FAKKG =KL9N9 9>AJE9

HJ=LGJ=K HJ=>=JAJ9E HJ9LA;9J 9 KM9 r:JA;GD9?=Es HGD`LA;9 )=KK= K=FLA

;GFKLJM\[G

;GFLJGN]JKA9 =E LGJFG

GHJ=KK[G 9 rHJGHJA=

=E ?J9F

LGJF9N9K= 9KKAE =E L=K= E9AK DANJ=E=FL=

HJGHJA=

FGN9 9HJ=K=FL9\[G G

-=Hi:DA;9 1=D@9 ;GE K=MK r:9Jh=Ks ] = ;D9KK=K E]

>GD@=LAFK (9K

AF>JAF?_F;A9

Elementorum iurisprudentiae universalislibri duo G

AF;G=J=FL= >A?MJ9

jurisprudentia BMKF9LMJ9DAKL9 2A=9;C=JL9E:]EG:K=JNGM

AE9?=E

K];MDG 31$$$ F9 MJGH9 H9KK9JA9E 9 9KKG;A9J 9K FGN9K ;GF

=;GFfEA;G 9G GJ?9FAR9J

boroughs = ;AJ;MFK;JA\h=K counties IM=J=;=:=M G FGE=

AF?D=K=K =KL9N9E ;GEH=LAF

bureaucracy = 9 ME KAKL=E9 AF9F\9KHi:DA;9K 9DL9E=FL= =>A;9R :9K=9

;GEG L9E:]E

;GEH9J9LAN9K (9K =E LG

transformao

H=JKH=;LAN9K

Acadmie des Sciences H=DG AJ=LdJAG =E.G: 9 FGN9 rDA:=J

AJEGMK=L9E:]E 9 H=J;=H\[G `;AGK HJWLA;GK =A\GWD9!J9F;AK 9;GF 67

$ 31$$$ @9NA9 >GJF=;A

policy L_E IM9DIM=J AF;GEH9LA:ADA

r@=L=JG

,M9FLG 9GK HGKALANAKEGK BMJ`

IM9FGKK=E GJA=FL9

AA 9 :MK;9

=ALG G 0LADAL9JAKEG G>=J=;=JA9r>GJE9Ks HJGKH=;LAN9K GM J=>GJE9K AFKLALM;AGF9AK

E=L9>`KA;9K HGKLMD9ADdKG>GK E9KKAE =E FGJE9K HJG

D=PA:ADAR9\[G

MKLAF >GA K=E

=P=EHDG =E K=M The Concept of a LegalSystem * HGKALANAKEG BMJ`

)G =KK=F;A9D 9 AFL=F\[G = 9 EAKK[G HJAF;AH9D

;GFLJ9 9 ;9K9 AEH=JA9D

=E IM= ;GEG 9HGFL9 -=AE9FF H G

.9NA?FQ >=R >GA r

9 ME HJG?J9E9 BW AFA

9:GJADGKd>A;9 H9KK9 9 IM=J=J

jurisprudentia A;9 GM K=B9 rKAKL=EWLA;9s FG K=FLA

)G =D=E=FLG t>ADGKd>A;Gu

rKAKL=EWLA;9s ;GF>GJE= 9;9:9

9 KM9 =NGDM\[G 9 H9JLAJ

;GEMFA

GJF=;=JA9 E=AGK H9J9KG;A=

67 ME ;9JWL=J

G E=KEG L=EHG H9J9 .9NA?FQ H=JL=F;= 9GK BMJAKL9K q = F[G 9G HGNG q 99HLA

= HGJ =D= DANJ=E=FL= KM:E=LA

GJ?YFA;9 EGKLJ9K= F9 J=D9\[G NAN9 lebendigenZusammenhang

IM= K=

J=HJ=K=FL9\[G AFL=D=;LM9D

9 =D9:GJ9\[G

BMJAKL9 ;9:= 9H=F9K KM:KMEAJ HGJ ME9 GH=J9\[G GJE9D ME9 KALM9\[G ;GF;J=L9 9 ME HJAF;`HAG ;GFKA

L_E J=9DA

>GJEMD9\[G 9H9J=;= FG =K;JALG AFLALMD9A;GKG:J=G

?=J9D L=GJA9 HGJL9FLG HJ=L=FMF

+9J=;=ME= HGJL9FLG K=J HGKK`N=D LGE9J MEJ9EG

J=>=J=FL= 9G

;GF;=ALM9DAKEG = K=M =>=ALG >GKKADAR9FL= GJE9K BMJ`

H9J=FL=E=FL= %@=JAF? 9

;GF;=ALM9DAKL9

J=D9\h=K =FLJ=

* 9L9IM= ;GFLJ9 G AA9 HGKALAN9s IM= (9J;MK= AA;9 =E !JA=

ADGKG>A9 F=?9LAN9 = 9KKAE 9 KM:GJ

ME 9LG TEAD= MJC@=AE

H9ML9JA9 H9J9 9 FGN9

=FfE=FGKKG;A9AK LJ9L9F9LGK =EH`JA;GKG:B=LANGK = 9KKAE ;G?FGK;`N=AK =FL[GHMF@9K= =E HGKA\[G

HJAEGJ

;GFK=IM_F;A9

E=FGK ;GEG ME9 porta entreaberta =E

!J9F\GAK "]FQ F9 !J9F\9 9

jus pertinet vel ad personas, vel ad res, vel ad actiones LG

1=JK=\[G supra 0E J=KMEG

J=>=J_F;A9 9IMA ] 9G ;MJJ`;MDG

#G::=K H 'G;C= H -GMKK=9MH==&9FLH =JE9F H

HJ=K=FL= LJ9:9D@G LGE9

=NGDMAM H9J9 G L=JEG r=;GFGEA9s economy 1=J +GGN=Q H +G;G;C H

alternativas 9 ;JAL]JAGK

+9J9 #=?=D F[G =PAKLAM F=E HG

* KMJ?AE=FLG

0E ?=KLG ;G=J=FL= 9DAWK H9J9 IM=E AFN=KLA9 FG DM;J9LANG;GE]J;AG

@A=J9JIMAR9\[G

rJGE9FLAKEG :AGDd?A;Gs 9 rIM`EA;9 HJG>MF

=P;DMAF

=;GFfEA;G K[G GK +9MDKGF * usus modernus pandectarum >GA ME9 =KH];A=

>GJE9K

BMF@G =ALGK A G >=;@9E=FLG

,M=KLh=K ;GEG =KK9K K[G

* KA?FA>A;9

=PA?_F;A9

4. Democracia e transform-aes do Direito

4.1. Em busca de novasortodoxias

GEG NAKLG 9 GH\[G H=DG 9:9F

;GE:AF9FGJEAKL9= ;GFK=JN9

9FL=;=

BMJAKL9K L9E:]E HJG;MJ9J9E =KLJMLMJ9JL=GJA9K IM= 9HJGPAE9

-M .L9EED=J HGJ =P=EHDG HJGHfK ME9 GJE9s = rE9L]JA9s FG

GE =>=ALG =KLJ9F@9E=FL= &=DK=F 9KKAE ;GEG .9LEED=J =KL=F

AFA9 HGKALAN9s E=F;AGF9GA >GJEMD9GA =D9:GJ9

9F9D`LA;9K KG:J= 9 KG;A=

;9J9;L=JAKLA;9E=FL= :MJ?M_K 9E9D?9E9

GEG K= HG

=J9 =NAGJE= BWKM?=JA9NGJ=;=J9E FME HJAE=AJG EGE=FLG 9 =KL9:ADAR9\[G

= >9LG FG K=?MF

(AJ9:=9M >9R 9 K=?MAFL= H=J?MFL9 J=LdJA;9r)[G ] 69D?G :GE7 >A;9J K=E H9JD9E=FLGKK=E =KL9E=FLGK HJGNAF;A9AK pays dtatK=E ;GJHG ;D=JA;9D K=E HJANAD=?A9

/G;IM=NADD= >9R ME9 ;JM;A9D J=KK9DN9 9GD=ALGJ

(9K 9>9KL=AK H9J9 GK D9J9?E=FLGK

FGN9K J=D9\h=K KG;A9AK 9KK=FL9GJE9Ks BMJ`AFAL9K=E KM9 HGKK`N=D N9JA=

*J9 GK H9JLA

=D=?9FL=E=FL= =EH9;GL9

GJA?AF9D GF

KKAE HGJ =P=EHDG F9 !J9F\9 9HdK 9IM=

:MJ?M=K9s LGJF9N9K= =NA

9:9FAK = 9 =;GFGEA9 HGD`LA;9

:MJG;JWLA;GK F[G BM

infra IM= H9KKGM 9 9

,M9FLG 9G

r>GJE9Ks 9

%=DDAF=Cs KG:J= *LLG (9Q=J = K=M ;DWKKA;G LJ9L9

A;ADE=FL= ;GEHJ==FK`N=AK K=E MDL=JAGJ =PHDA;9\[GA;=QH

GF>GJE= J=KK9DL9

9JE9R]FK = AFKL9D9\h=K GFLJ9JA9E=FL= 9L9AK AFL=J=KK=K 9>AJE9N9EK= GK

HJGHJA=

LAHG =J=F;A9

AEHGF=FL=K ;GEG 9K 9HJ=K=FL9

F9 ]D?A;9 =E AF9M?MJ9J9E ME9FGN9 =J9 FG 9NGJ

H9KK9J 9 LJ9:9D@9J ;GE ME9 ;GF;=H\[G A;9s = 9KKAE LAN=KK= ;@9F;=K A;9RE=FL= F9 =KLJMLMJ9\[G

K=J 9 =PHJ=KK[G

6DMFLK;@DA7 @9NA9 K=?MA

)9 L=GJA9 GJ?YFA;9

AKKG =K;J=N=F

AF;9H9;A

3$3 * IM= K= HGGJE9Ks HJdHJA9K 9G KL9

KGE=FL= 9HdK 9 >ADGKG>A9 ;J`LA;9 =ALGK =K>GJ\GK

9HJGN9

9GK K=MK AFL=J=KK=K F9 E9FML=F\[G

9MLG;GF;=H\[G =FIM9FLG :MJG;J9L9K ;GEGrK=JNA

FG:J=R9 HJGHJA=LWJA9

HGD`LA;9 J9F;9E=FL= @GKLAD 9GKHJGHdKALGK

Hi:DA;GK H9J9 ;GE G Kaiser K= MF;AGF9AK = F[G ;GE :9K= =E D9\GK

DAEAL9N9 L9E:]E 9 9:=JLMJ9

* rE]LG

HD=:AK;ALWJA9 LGJF9N9K= ME AF?J=

J=E=LA

FG H9JD9E=FLG !GA ;GE =KK= LAHG

=KK9 H9KK9N9 HGJ ME HJG;=KKG IM= HMF@9=E K=?MF

EHJ]KLAEGK 69GK KL9

HJGHJA=

HGKALANAKEG

IM= 9;9:9JW ;@9E9F

=E=J?=FL=K

H9JYE=LJGK IM= K= LGJF9J9E =E:D=EWLA;GK

9K >GJEMD9\h=K 9D=E[K

LJA:MF9D ;GFKLALM;AGF9D 9D=E[G 9` K=?MFDM=F;A9J9E ;GFKLALM;AGF9DAKL9K:J9KAD=AJGKGF>GJE= G:K=JN9 &GJAGL@ 9 H

F=GC9FLAKEG C=DK=FA9FG =KK= HGKALANAKEG .E=F< GHfK A

H9JLAJ

;GEG J`?A

GFKLALMA\[G GJE9Ks

GFLMGKK= HJdHJA9 X jurispru-dentia 9K

=E=J?AM =FLJ= GK BM`R=K FGJL=9E=JA;9FGKME EG

F9LMJ9D 67 G ;GFLJWJAG GK BM`R=K H9KK9J9E 9;GF;=:=J G common law ;GEG K=F

;GF;=ALM9DAKL9 +GJL9FLG F9K iDLAE9K

0E9 ;9J9;L=JAR9\[G J=KMEA

>GJ9E AEHGJL9FL=K = >9LG FG 9E:A=FL= AF9AK

%9F 'MC9KA=OA;R $F>DM_F;A9K9RA9EHJ=K=FL=K 9

(GJJAK H q ;GEG K=F

HJ9?EWLA;9K ;GE r>GJE9Ks 9

F?=F@9JA9K

K=JA9E =E L=K= GK J=KMDL9

rAFL=?J9Js AFL=D=;LM9DE=FL= 9K r>GJE9KsHJ=K;JALAN9K J=KMDL9FL=K

K=M 9MLGJ 9 Brandeis Brief ;GEG ME9=KH];A= K`E:GDG

AEHGJL9FL=K H9J9 9 >GJEMD9\[G

FLJ= GK AFN=FLGJ=K

GK 9MLGJ=K

NAKL9 =;GFfEA;G ;GFK9?JGM HGD`LA;9K

9KKAKL_F;A9 9 EMD@=J=K GM ;JA9F\9K =KH9F;9

)GJE9DAR9\[G = ,M9DA

E=KEG HJG;=KKG G;GJJ= F9K BMJAK

AFL=JF9;AGF9D

jurisprudentia L9FLG FG ;GFLAF=FL= =MJGH=M;GEG F9K BMJAK

9FWDAK= HJ=KKMHh= IM= =PAKL=E EMAL9K HGD`LA;9KGM GJ\9 GM H=KG

GMLJGK KAEAD9J=K FG >MLMJG ;GE :9K= =E ME9HGF

Economic Analysis of Law K= LGJF9

LJ9:9D@G ;GE =KK= L`LMDG The nature of thefirm HM:DA;9DM_F;A9 HGJ LJAFL9 GM IM9J=FL99FGKs 9:GJ

9L] @GB= =F

H9KK9E K=J ;GFKA=JJGNA9 H9KK9JA9 9 L=J=FLJ= GK r;MKLGKs D`;ALGK DGJ=KL9KAF;=F

;GFLJGN=JLA

=E K=M HJ=KL`?AG ;GE G 9

LJ9FK9\[Gs G9K= ;=JL9K GMLJ9K A

A?MJ9 E`LA;9 G EG

MKM9DE=FL= G K[G =E :9K=K MLADAL9JAKL9K GM;GFK=IM=F;A9DAKL9K +9J9 OGJCAF HGJL9FLG 9K

0E9 N=JK[G 9D=E[

q HGJ 9MLGJ=K ;GEG )ACD9K 'M@E9FF = 9 rL=GJA9

9?=FL= EGJ9D ;9H9R GJ9

K=H9J9

;GFK=IM_F;A9K HJGB=L9

L9EHGM;G >GJ9E GK BMJAKL9K IM= AF

AF;GFL=KL9

+9J9 .L9EED=J GK r;GF;=ALGK BMJ`MF

%9;G:A K=E HJ=KKMHGJ 9 t;GAK9 =E KAu ;GEG t9D?Gu H=FKWN=D F[G K=HG

9MLGJ=K

AFL=J=KK=K :WKA;GK

1=J =E J=D9\[G X !J9F\9 -AH=JL .=?MF

IM= ;GFLJ9Hh= G rHG

K];MDG 3$3 G Conseil dtat @9NA9 HJG

>"9DARA9 1=JK=\[G supra >.;9LLGD9H )[G F=;=KK9JA9E=FL= HGJ K=MK E]JALGK AFL=D=;LM9AK AFLJ`FK=;GKE9K ;GEG AF

* LJ=;@G GJE9DAKEG GJE9DAKEG

AFKLALMA\h=K

.G:J= 9 9FWDAK= BMJA

;9KG Muller v. Oregon Brandeis Brief ;GFLAF@9 ME9?J9F

)=KK= K=FLA

9MLGJ=K JE=F D;@A9F .L=N=F @=MF? -GF9D< G9K= #9JGDJ=IM=FL=E=FL= D9F\9E E[G

5. Eplogo: pesquisa e re-forma do Direito

E K=M Curso de direito constitucional 9 NA?]KAE9 L=J;=AJ9 =

K=MK 9MLGJ=K 9KKAE ;GEG ;GD=?9K K=MKJ=KH=;LAN9E=FL= AFK=J=EK= =E =J=FL=K;MDLMJ9K HGD`LA;9K ;GE =J=FL=K J=HJ=K=FL9\h=K KG:J= G IM= K[G 9K KM9K AFKLALMA\h=K KG;A9AK =;GFfEA;9K HGD`LA;9K =BMJ`

GJA=FL9\h=K H9J9 9 HJWLA;9

*K BMJAKL9K :J9KAD=AJGK 9:KGJN=J9E 9 ;MDLMJ9 BMJ`

KA?FA>A;9GKK= iLAD 9GK =KLM

KKAE 9D]E

;=JL9E=FL= K= J=?GRAB9JA9E =E N=J IM= K=MLJ9:9D@G AFL=D=;LM9D J=FJMLGK;GHAGK9E=FL=/=F

;9J9;L=JAR9\[G =KLW F9 K=\[G supra= >9LG G rHJG:D=E9

GK >9LGK H=KIMAK9 =EH`JA;9 H9J9

9G E=KEG L=EHG A F[G HJ=L=FA;WN=D HG

J=>D=PGK KG:J= 9 HGKKA:ADA

ME9 N=JL=FL= HJGEAKKGJ9

r;GFK=JN9FLAKEGs 9D9N9 *JD9F

:J9KAD=AJG 9;9AKK[G = 9DA 9;9:9 L=F

-% * AFKLALMLG

Referncias

-)/ . +9MDG Imagens de natureza,imagens de cincia. 9EHAF9K +9HAJMK& -() !J9FC # $)5 -'$)"'AK9 Priceless: GF CFGOAF? L@= HJA;= G>=N=JQL@AF? 9F< L@= N9DM= G> FGL@AF? )=O4GJC)=O+J=KK(. "=GJ?= MJLGF ./ +# ). #(GJK= *J?K Select documents of Englishconstitutional history )=O 4GJC /@=(9;EADD9FGEH9FQ */* %G[G (9MJ`;AG %MJAK

8888888888 * K]JAG = G BG;GKG =E %@=JAF?q ME9 NAK[G J=LdJA;9

2003 9E:JA

Research Review N F H

-- /* /G:A9K Introduo ao estudodo direito: HGD`LA;9 :J9KAD=AJ9 .[G +9MDG'9F

+=FFKQDN9FA9 /@= +=FFKQDN9FA9 .L9L=0FAN=JKALQ+J=KK )/#( %=J=EQ F AFLJG EGJ9DK 9F< D=?AKD9LAGF $F*2-$)" %G@F GGJ< The works ofJeremy Bentham MF9DD9;A=K :=AF? 9F=P9EAF9LAGF G> L@= JA?@LK AKKM=<

companion to philosophy of law and legaltheory (9D

Pensamento medieval .[G +9MDG 'GQGD9H *)1$ . +9MDG Curso de direitoconstitucional =< .[G +9MDG (9D@=AJGK*)) . %MDA=F Lcole delxgse K9

8888888888 )GL9K H9J9 ME9 E=LG

)$1 5 F

Direito Empresarial F BMD

*. -GF9D< /@= F9LMJ= G> L@= >AJEAF>DM=F;= Journal of Law, Economics andOrganizationNFH8888888888 /@= HJG:D=E G> KG;A9D ;GKLJournal of Law and Economics N H*(/ M?MKL= Cours de philosophiepositive+9JAK9;@=DA=JN*)) ' 2ADDA9E % /@= J=HM:DA;9F AD=;LAGFK 9E:JA

$)$5 (9JA9 #=D=F9 Compndio de in-troduo cincia do direito =< .[G+9MDG.9J9AN9* (9MJA;= Theories of value anddistribution since Adam Smith A

8888888888 O individualismo -AG

!-$ %GK]

!$.# - $$$ 2ADDA9E 2 #*-2$/5(GJLGF % - /@GE9K $FLJGGJ< 0FAN=JKALQ+J=KKHPAPN"'$5$ (9JAG +JG>ADA KLGJA;G;GEH9J9LANA

" -($) -9F

8888888888 Razes histricas e sociol-gicas do Cdigo Civil brasileiro .[G+9MDG(9JLAFK!GFL=K8888888888 Escritos menores .[G +9MDG.9J9AN9"-)/

GMLM:JG AKHGF`N=D =E @LLH

OOOL9FF=JD=;LMJ=K ML9@=GJ

8888888888 '9 >AF

J=F=O9D G> D=?9D A

=H9JLE=FL +J=H9J=< :Q %9E=K (GM?@LGF%MF@GGJME >GJ HJ=K=FLAF? D=?AKD9LAN=>9;LK American Journal of Trial AdvocacyNH%*.*) JL@MJ % .#'$)&=JF@9J< $FLJG

seiner Entwicklung JALL=J /@=AD '=AHRA?J=ALCGH>MF

J=HM:DA;9F9 So Paulo em Perspectiva NH&)/ EE9FM=D Critique de la raisonpure =< +9JAK +J=KK=K 0FAN=JKAL9JAJ=K

8888888888 /@= DG?A;9DDQ >GJE9D D=?9D J9LAGF9DALQ GJ (9P 2=:=JuK KG;AGDG?Q AF L@= ?=F=9DG?Q G> L@=;GFL=EHGJ9JQ EG 2=KL=JF D=?9DL@GM?@L Hastings Law Journal N

H8888888888 /@= KLJM;LMJ= G> D9;CKLGF=uKGEE=FL9JA=K Buffalo Law Review N H8888888888 /GO9J D9O D=?9D L@GM?@L SuffolkUniversity Law Review NGD F H&*-$*/# .L=>9F -M .E=F< q $FLJG

0FAN=JKALQ G> 9DA>GJFA9 +J=KK 9 H

8888888888 /@= K@9LL=JAF? G> E=L@G

LG L@= HJ=K=FL =< 9E:JA

' $/ - JA9F $FL=JNA=O 9:GML D=?9DH@ADGKGH@Q /@= 0FAN=JKALQ G> /=P9K.;@GGD G> '9O Public Law and Legal The-ory Research Paper F AKHGF`N=D =E @LLH

KKJF;GE9:KLJ9;L;=KKG=E9:J8888888888 '=?9D J=9DAKE $F+// -.*) =FFAK *J? A compan-ion to philosophy of law and legal theory(9D

'$ -.*#) #9JJQ Fate and utopia inGerman sociology, 1870-1923 9E:JA

'*)" Stoics, Epicureans, Sceptics

=< =JC=D=Q 0FAN=JKALQ G> 9DA>GJFA9+J=KK'*+ . %GK] -=AF9D

9FLAKLJGH@GK L= t

English legal history )=O 4GJC " ++MLF9EuK.GFK() 1$'' =JF9J< The fable of thebees'GF

=< LD9FLA; @A?@D9F #=?=DuK Philosphy of Right 67 $F/0& - - *J? The Marx-Engelsreader )=O 4GJC 22 )GJLGF GEH9FQH8888888888 /@= "=JE9F A>

( -0-* )A;@GD9K ( ( .L=N=" Economics and the law >JGE +GKF=J LGHGKLEG

@LLH

?GOGJ

*-")$5/$*) !*- *)*($ **+ -/$*) ) 1 '*+( )/ In-troductory handbook for undertaking regu-latory impact analysis -$ *;L AKHGF`N=D =E @LLH

OOOG=;AD=K@GOH@H!LALD=

;@9HL=JD9QGML@LED$L=EA

- (4 +@ADAHH= '=K ;ANADAKL=K >J9F\9AKNGFLADK

-*$) ']GF La pense grecque et lesorigines de lesprit scientifique +9JAK T?9F? O caminho da filosofia

-* (9JC % '=?9D GJA?AFK HGDALA;K 9F

Formas Jur_dicas e Mudan_a Social - Marcus Faro de Castro Marcado

Documents

Transcript of Formas Jur_dicas e Mudan_a Social - Marcus Faro de Castro Marcado