Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
Transcript of Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
1/32
PaulBarber
Forensic Pathology and the Europe
If there is in this world a well-attested account, i tNothing is lacking: official reports affidavitsof
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
2/32
2
Such accounts became common in the eighteenth
attested ofthem, the locus classicw ofvampire storioccurred in the twenties, near Belgrade, when a mandiedanaccidental death, after which several people dhad been traditionally viewed as vampirism. Fort
Paole was exhumed:
[It was found] that he was complete and incorrupfresh blood had flowed from his eyes, ears, and graveclothes were also bloody. The old nails on hiwith the skin, had fallen off, and new oneshad growfrom this that he was a true vampire they drovea
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
3/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
folk-hypothesis that seeks to explain otherwise puz
sociated with death and decomposition-phenom
understood. Viewed as a theory, the vampire loreknow-
quite wrong, but like the Ptolemaic astron
describing events accurately and has predictive valu
ever, it differs from such theories as Ptolemys in th
tion ofa single person and no single Copernicus evit
-
that was donepiecemeal, over centuries
-
so thano longer even understand how and why it came a
To complicate the matter further, while modernbrought about an understanding ofthe phenomena
iti thi d t di i l h t h d
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
4/32
4
bodies. It is just in the telling that they diverge, andof their divergence is based on an ingenious interp
but quite normal phenomenon associated with deat(see below, #4). This is not the reason, however, whmyself with the much-debated typological distinctipire, the revenant, and their other relatives: it prove
cult to talk about the genus revenant without d
time to time, to the technical terms for the various sprather than either qualify my terms endlessly or encompassing term, I shall ask the reader to accept fworking definition of a vampirehevenant: any de
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
5/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
5. The friends and neighbors of the revenant di6. He can be heard in the grave, chewing on his
shroud, especially in times ofplague.167. He is most likely to be about in the winter.8. His body is warm to the touch.109. He has an evil smell.19
10. His body shows no signs of rigor mortis.2011. His hair and nails have continued to grow af12. His principal natural enemies are wolves andIS.The revenant cannot cross waterZ3and must r14 P i l b di d f i
sunrise.2
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
6/32
6
Hungary.42 This idea was given added force whmovie version ofBram Stokers novel chose a Hungplay the part ofCount Dracula, a figure derived froPrince (not a count) of Wallachia (notTransylvamon with the Hungarians the fact that no tradition
in folklore at least-attaches to him.+5111
As noted, any attempt to make sense out ofthe begin with considering the factsofdeath, We shallf ll i t i
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
7/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
from 70 to 100.46The temperature of the ground, surface, is normally well below this ideal temperaturgists, in fact, expect the temperature ofa winecave trenheit. It will be seen from this that a body will no
quickly in a grave at all. It may beaccepted as a genGlaister, that a body decomposes in air twice as qui
eight times as rapidly as in earth.Moreover, under certain conditions bodies may n
Where there are hot, desiccating sands, or currents oftion may take place.4BWhere there is a superabundani d f i i ll d
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
8/32
8
they are inadequately buried, the first two for obviotend to give only limited attention to the niceties o
while suicides ignore them completely
-
the last beics, somany people died that burial was often veryfact, quote one informant who actually defines than unattended dead body: These were dead peop
and had no one there to take care of them.52 Andburg, getting right to the heart of thematter, camevampirism could occur simply because a body
enough.)This is because what is really happening is not t
i t t b t th t th i t th t
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
9/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
#13)and the settling ofthe earth would also presumface of the grave.
3. The body is intact andisbloated. If the body is bing surprising about its preservation, sinceit has beemoisture, maggots, and warmth, the principal agenBut even if i t is lying in theopen a body will sometimlong time, especially in cold weather.
The bloating occurs because the internal organsfirst, produce gases that then have no escape route.the Slavs believed that ein Vampyr ware von dem B
die er ausgesogen, ganz rot und aufgeblaht.59 (Aand swollen from the blood of the people whom h
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
10/32
10
dead body is a more complicated matter than is
brief analysis, because decomposition also change5 . There is blood at the lips and nose. Again, thisposing body. It occurs because the lungs, which arerate after death and are under pressure from the blorgans. A blood-stained fluid is forced out through
It will be seen now why it was believed that the here you have a body that is clearly full of someth
when you buried it-it is bloated-and there are obvthe lips. Furthermore, the gravesite is.disturbed (body) The villagers instead of remarking to one a
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
11/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
Hereford calf that was undergoing this dreadful expof the gases was forcing what is called purge fluidbody. This was very audible, even from some distaheard the body before I saw it. The emission of purgwould seem to account for stories of bodies that arein the grave, are dug up, and are found to be lacera
blood.66 It could be, incidentally, that this belief-heard chewing in their graves
-
reinforced the age-oing the dead with food and drink.
If the swollen body is punctured, of course, the rsuddenand dramatic and this process has been unfo
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
12/32
12
Finally. the reader may protest that the bursting
eventoflimited duration and taking place under thsumably not be easily noticed. This is ofcourse trthat such things tend to happen during epidemicdredsofpeople are being buried, and not very deep aat such times i t would be hardnot to notice such so
people would be frequenting the graveyard more thfolklore is rich in accounts of sounds being emitte8.He is mostlikely to be about in the winter. Her
vampire is characterized, among other. things, by
decayproperly Thedecayof thebody is of coursere
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
13/32
12.His hair and nails have continuedtogrow afthe teeth grow as well, although this is more commovampires than in thoseof folklore. The hair, nails, agrow after death: they merely appear to do so as thEventually two other events take place: the nails faenon known as skin slippage occurs (both these the account ofArnold Paole in Section I).
A recent article in National Geographicshows annomenon of the apparent lengthening of the finger
IS.His principal naturalenemies are wolves aclearly arises out of a misinterpretation ofa comm
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
14/32
14
ble, is no match for a wolf: he [the wolf] bites his l
lugat retreats into his grave and decides to remain It may also account for the origin of storiesin Eurohand reaches out of the grave. Sometimes the hanstruck itsmother,800rit is that of someone who hasupon himself, such as a patricide, a thief, or a punlike that ofour standard revenants.81Here toosignificant than the inadequate burial. Such stor
various degrees ofelaboration, and I do not mean them had its origin in an actual event-only thimprobable as it must seem at first sight
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
15/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN VA
was believed to be responsible for droughts, the practiup the body and throwing it into a lake or stream, assumption that, with a sufficiency of water at its dispothe clouds alone.83
15.Potentialrevenantsmay bedisposed ofinswampbe thrown on this practice merely by askingabout altering aside the hydrotropic character of the soul, which
rationalefor numerous funeraryprocedures,84the possiby the natureoftheprob1e;n. Ifyou wish to dispose of ayou will naturally chooseasite that is away from humacould go into the hills, if there are hills, but it must be
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
16/32
16
earth for that length oftime. As for the actual time become a vampire (which is to say, become swthat is simply incalculable: there are too many var
17. To kil lavampire, youmustpierce him withaa vampire makes a certain kind ofsense when youbeing killed is a bloated corpse. The most directwhat it was is to puncture it.
This puncturing of the body is common even bphylactic measure: should the devil inflate [the s
the air would escape.gOOther examplesofsuch puin the
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
17/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN
implements may have been intended to preventinto the body.100 Frequently thedeterrent effect ofattributed to the magical quality ofiron,l01 and scope of this article to deal with the subject adeqwondering if the weight and sharpness of iron w
significant characteristics (weight for holding thefor puncturing it), especially since there are com
non-ferrous implements being used in this way. Oare told ofsharpened stakes that have been driven ibody might be punctured ifi t tries to come to thedescribes both knives and hawthorn stakes being
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
18/32
18turb the surfaceofthe earth, or even to pop up to theis waterlogged. I have before me a photograph (fro
the Los Angeles Times,dated 11/1/85) that showsflooded graveyard, in Louisiana. According to the cafloated up out of the ground in the floodwaters lefThis particular one was tied to a tree by someone whly, that a dead body could not only leave the grave, u
tions, but could not even be counted on to remain coffins, like bloated bodies, are remarkably buoyan
It must come as no surprise to find that we havarchaeological evidence demonstrating that bodies w
i d i h d d d i d ib
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
19/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN VA
territory, the stake had to bedriven in at one blow. A sthe vampire.I0This is perhaps one of the reasons method ofdisposing of a vampire is always that ofb
While I had no doubt that flames would shoot froming vampire, I thought i t best to get the opinion oasked Dr. Allen about this theory. He offered me a mmation than I could have hoped for, saying that he h
hadacquired thehabitofdramatizingthepresenceofby touching them off with a match when he made hisresulting flame, according to Dr. Allen, shot between the air.
21 When a vampire is hilled in his grave he is apt
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
20/32
20
long since been a literary motif, but not, it seems, a
Finally, note the overkill. The body is behead
into the heart, and the corpse is then burned. The straightforward, but the rather extremeefforts tokil
the climate offear in which the events took place. Thpirism can be seen in Kohlers accounts ofconfliccentury, between citizens and the authorities over wh
potential revenant) was to be buried in the churchwere often resolved by military force.11s
As for the movement of the body, clearly this
attempt to drive a stake through it causes a redistrib
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
21/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN V
well: the fear ofthem was simply the fear ofdeathagents that were known tobe contagious, while thea
contagion was not understood. (Since we do understwe are not afraid to catch our death from a victi
recent experience with the AIDS epidemic has had so
the vampire scares of the past.)23. Vampires and other revenants are frequently
after death, sometimes inthe grave orcoffin. Such stoand they occur over such a wide area,116that I finallythere was something to them, although I could not thexplanation. The evidence remains contradictory: D
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
22/32
22
can attest, by grace of the L.A. Medical Examiners O
a decomposing body (brought about by the swell
striking and unforgettable sight. This is one of the re
in Greece, the mouth is tied shut.120In addition, he gives three terms-&u&ppaxo,
cuorpo-that he finds unintelligible. The second twderived from the root Xaprr-, from which our lampmean, respectively, that which is lit up (abstrwhich lights up (agent form).Lawson would see
obvious etymologies because they do not appear to
that is, one notices that such terms all seem to be re
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
23/32
FORENSIC PATHOLOGY AND THE EUROPEAN
when rigor mortis ends, as it must, gravity may aga
ment, which could account in part for the extreme
bodies being found in a changed position.I*Z(The bofthe body would also change its position, and suchcontribute to the idea that the body had left the
causes considerable movement of the corpse. 124 Ancertainly occur-seemingly at the volition of the co
try toadjust the limbs ofthe body while it was in rigospring back to their original position.
Finally, though, I must acknowledge that I have nclear evidence here to persuade me that I have loca
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
24/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
25/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
26/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
27/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
28/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
29/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
30/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
31/32
-
8/3/2019 Forensic Pathology and the European Vampire - Paul Barber
32/32
92
127.128.129.190.
Trigg has an informative discussion of these: pp
Mercure galant, quoted in Hock,p. 34.See Stana in Section I. Also Arnold Paole in SBurkhart, p. 221; Perkowski, Rom. Folk. Vam
221-22; Richard Beitl,Deutsche Volhshunde (Berlin, 1pp. 261-62.I wouldl iketo thank Professor Felix Oinusfor his valversions of the manuscript off h i sarticle. The referhelpful.