Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
-
Upload
vidovdan9852 -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
1/35Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1920865
Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap The Perception of Accounting Academics.
By Emma Ik Okoye and S C Okaro
Department of Accountancy, Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka, Nigeria.
Working Paper Series
Contact Author: S C Okaro
E Mail: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
This research is about the perception of Accounting Academics on the vexed issue of whether the
injection of Forensic Accounting techniques, on a cost/benefit basis, in an audit is capable of increasing
the ability of the auditor to discover fraud and thus help in bridging the audit expectation gap in Nigeria.
A survey research design approach was adopted for this study. Questionnaire was administered onAccounting Academics of 8 tertiary institutions in the Eastern part of Nigeria. The study reveal , from the
perception of Accounting Academics, that Forensic Accounting techniques injected in an audit and given
cost/benefit considerations is capable of increasing the ability of the Auditor to detect fraud and thus
help bridge the audit expectation gap in Nigeria. This finding has implications for both accounting
education and accounting practice.
Key Words: Forensic Accounting; Audit expectation gap; Perception; Accounting Academics.
1.1 background of Study.
The integration of accounting, auditing and investigative skills results in the special field known as
forensic accounting (Crumbley, 2008). Forensic accountants have been described as experienced
auditors, accountants and investigators of legal and financial documents that are hired to look into
possible suspicions of fraudulent activity within a company; or are hired by a company who may just
want to prevent fraudulent activities from occurring. They also provide services in areas such as
accounting, antitrust, damages, analysis, valuation, and general consulting. Forensic accountants have
also been used in divorces, bankruptcy, insurance claims, personal injury claims, fraudulent claims,
construction, royalty audits, and tracking terrorism by investigating financial records. Many forensic
accountants work closely with law enforcement personnel and lawyers during investigations and often
appear as expert witnesses during trials. Forensic Accounting is an amalgam of forensic science and
accounting. Although the coining of the term Forensic Accounting is said to date back to 1946, the
practice is relatively new in Nigeria (Kasum, 2009). The need for forensic accountant has been ascribed
to the fact that the audit system in an organization had failed to detect certain errors in the managerial
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
2/35Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1920865
system. In particular, the following have been fingered as being responsible for the growth of Forensic
Accounting:
- Failure of internal audit and audit committee to unearth hidden aspects of corporate fraud
- The often compromised method of appointing statutory auditors
- The apparent lack of independence of internal auditors.
The increasing incidence of fraud and fraudulent activities in Nigeria and around the world as a whole
(Okoye & Akamobi, 2009; Owojori & Asaolu, 2009)
Audit expectation gap, on the other hand, is often described as the gap between the auditors actual
standard of performance and the various public expectations of auditors performance. Members of
the public expect that:
- Auditors should accept responsibility for the Financial Statements
- Auditors should vouch for the Financial Statements
- Auditors perform a 100% check instead of sampling check,
- Audit reports should serve as early warning signals of corporate distress
- Auditors should take responsibility for all frauds
Public misperceptions of auditors responsibility are a major part of the expectation gap problem
(Koh & Woo, 1998).
The primary responsibility of an auditor is to verify whether the Financial Statements show a true and
fair view of the business while their secondary responsibility is the prevention and detection of errors
and fraud. The primary duty to detect and prevent errors and fraud lie with those charged withgovernance and the management of an entity. Fraud involves misapplication of resources or distorted
reporting of the availability of resources, so this contradicts the element of round and prudent
management. While the third party emphasize that an auditor must be in a position to detect all kinds
of fraud, the auditors are not so persuaded as they believe that it is not their primary duty to detect
fraud, so there is a gap between auditors and third parties(Salehi & Azary, 2009a)
Performance gap is also the other component of the problem. Performance gap occurs when the
perception of the public about the auditors duty is reasonable but the auditor fails in his performance
of such duty. Empirical Studies have long confirmed the existence of audit expectation gap in many
climes (Abduiqaderai qarni, 2004; Ojo, 2006a). Lack of independence by auditors remains a critical issuein the expectation gap conundrum. The following are at the base of auditors lack of independence:
1 Economic dependence
2 Audit market competition
3 Regulatory Frame work and
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
3/35
4 Provision of non-audit services (Salehi, Mansoury, & Azary, 2009)
Forensic accounting per se is not new. However, the recent accounting scandals including the celebrated
case of Enron, the energy giant that collapsed as a result of monumental fraud has added impetus to the
search for a viable option in dealing with accounting frauds. In Nigeria, the recent accounting scandal
involving the food and beverages giant, Cadbury (Nig) Plc. Has brought to the fore the need for anurgent solution. Conventional audit techniques cannot be guaranteed to detect fraud all the time
because of the limitations inherent in the modern audit process. Hence the need for a more robust
technique to stem the tide of fraud and thus bridge the audit expectation gap caused by the inability of
the accounting profession to satisfactorily grapple with fraud from the perception of users of Financial
Statements. The Forensic Accountant is a blood hound of book keeping as opposed to a watch dog
associated with an auditor. They sniff out fraud and criminal transactions in corporate entities financial
records. They hound for the conclusive evidences. External Auditors find out the deliberate
misstatements only but the Forensic Accountants take a more proactive, skeptical approach to
examining the books of accounting. They make no assumptions of Management integrity, show less
concerns for arithmetical accuracy and have nothing to do with assurance or accounting standards butare kin in exposing fraud (Anwar, 2008)
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Some people believe that the incorporation of modern forensic auditing techniques in an audit in
Nigeria is needed to arm the accounting profession to deal effectively with the problem of unearthing
ingenious fraud schemes arising from audit failure to detect frauds. Studies on forensic accounting and
audit expectation gaps are very few in Nigeria. In climes where the use of forensic accounting
techniques is much more common, experts warn that the cost of such tools could be enormous. This
study, therefore, is aimed at ascertaining, on a cost benefit basis, the perception of accounting
academics on the ability of forensic accounting techniques to discover fraud and thus contribute in
bridging the audit expectation gap.
1.3 Objective of Study
The general objective of this study is to find out the perception of accounting academics as to whether
the wide spread use of forensic accounting techniques in the average audit in Nigeria will on a cost
benefit basis, enhance the chances of fraud discovery and thus help in narrowing the audit expectation
gap. Specific objectives of this research are:
1 to find out the view point of accounting academics as to whether on a cost benefit basis, the
introduction of some forensic accounting techniques in an audit is capable of stemming
the tide of financial fraud and thus bridge the audit expectation gap.
2 to ascertain the opinion of accounting academics on some of the identified skills that will serve
the Forensic Accountant in good stead.
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
4/35
3 deriving from the above, to make recommendations
1.4 Research Questions
The following research questions were formulated for the purpose of this study.
1 To what extent do Accounting Academics agree to the suggestion that the introduction of forensic
accounting techniques in an audit will stem the tide of corporate fraud and thus help in bridging the
Audit expectation gap?
2 What is the perception of Accounting Academics to some identified skills needed to make a success
of forensic accounting career?
1.5 Research Hypotheses.
For the purpose of this study, the following research hypotheses were framed and tested in this study
H1 Accounting Academics in Nigeria agree to the suggestion that, on a cost - benefit basis, the
introduction of forensic accounting techniques in an audit will stem the tide of financial fraud and thus
help in bridging the audit expectation gap.
H2 Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in positive light some identified skills needed by a
forensic accountant.
1.6 Scope and Limitations of the Study
This study is focused on accounting academics in Nigeria. However, for reasons of cost and time,
accounting academics in Eastern geo political zone of Nigeria will be the main target. They will be
sought at in their various universities and polytechnics. In particular, accounting academics will be
targeted from the following institutions:
- Nnamdi Azikiwe university, Awka
- University of Nigeria, Enugu Campus
- Anambra state university, Igbariam campus
- Delta state university
- Federal technical college, Umunze
- Federal polytechnic, Oko
- Auchi Polytechnic and
- Enugu State University
1.7 Significance of the Study
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
5/35
This study will add to the little pool of studies available in this area in Nigeria. Members of the public
(including investors) will be able by reading this work to advance their knowledge of this rather
important but new area in corporate governance in Nigeria. The accounting academic will come to
know the thinking of his colleagues as a group on this matter as well as being equipped for future
curriculum development in the area. NUC as a curriculum developer will also be informed of an
input from an important stakeholder group which will help it fashion out an enduring and relevant
curricula in that area. Regulators like ICAN and ANAN will have an input that will enable them
regulate their members better. The international community will have the benefit of another
research on a subject that has international relevance but this time from Nigerian accounting
academics. The individual universities will be in a position to know whether they need to introduce
forensic accounting as a subject to rejuvenate their accounting discipline and give them competitive
edge over their peers. This study may enable Government determine whether there is critical need
for forensic accountants in the economy and thus enable it plan accordingly. Fellow researchers will
be equipped with a study that will give them a base for further work in this area.
References:
Abduiqaderai qarni, A. (2004).Audit expectation gap in saudi Arabia- perceptions of
auditors,preparers of Financial Statements and users. Dundee, Uk.
Anwar, N. (2008, April 20). Forensic accounting: A dynamic tool for combating corruption. The
Financial Express, 1-1. Dhaka.
Crumbley, D. L. (2008). What is Forensic Accounting?Journal of Forensic Accounting,IX(1),1
Kasum, A. S. (2009). The Relevance of Forensic Accounting to Financial Crimes in Private and
Public Sectors of Third World Economies: A Study from Nigeria. Proceedings of The 1st
International Conference on Governance Fraud Ethics and Social Responsibility, June
(pp. 1113).
Koh, H. C., & Woo, E.-S. (1998).The Expectation Gap in Auditing.Managerial Auditing
Journal, 13(3), 147-154.
Ojo, M. (2006). Eliminating the Audit Expectations Gap: Myth or Reality? Munich Personal
RePEc Archive.
Okoye, E. I., & Akamobi, N. (2009). The Role of Forensic Accounting in Fraud Investigation
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
6/35
and Litigation Support. The Nigerian Academic Forum, 17(1), 39-42.
Owojori, A. A., & Asaolu, T. O. (2009). The Role of Forensic Accounting in Solving the Vexed
Problem of Corporate World.European Journal of Scientific Research, 29(2), 183187.
Salehi, M., & Azary, Z. (2009). Fraud detection and audit expectation gap: Empirical evidence
from Iranian bankers.International Journal of Business and Management, 3(10), P65.
Salehi, M., Mansoury, A., & Azary, Z. (2009). Audit Independence and Expectation Gap:
Empirical Evidences from Iran.International Journal of Economics and Finance, 1(1),
P165.
Chapter 2
2.0 Theoretical Framework and Review of Related Literature
2.1Theoretical Framework
Fraud examination is conducted in order to find where fraud is being perpetrated and by whom.
The concept of the fraud triangle has often been advanced to explain the key elements
underpinning most frauds. These include opportunity, pressure and rationalization. Sometimes,
companies unknowingly give their companies the opportunity to perpetrate fraud because of
poor internal control. While some succumb to such temptations, others are able to resist. The
culprit then rationalizes his action. Forensic accounting is based on fraud examination and fraud
triangle (E. I Okoye & Akenbor, 2009)
Since the beginning of the audit profession, theories were made in order to specify and
determine the audit profession. The agency theory is associated with the conflicting interest of
shareholders and management of a company suggesting that the less informed party
(shareholders) will have a demand for information that monitors the behavior of the better
informed manager. Audits of financial reports will be one form of such information. The
policeman theory posits that auditing is focused on arithmetical accuracy and on prevention and
detection of fraud. Other theories guiding auditing include the lending credibility theory,
moderator of claimants theory, Quasi-judicial theory and theory of inspired confidence (Hayes,
Schilder, Roger, & Philip, 1998). The policeman theory is considered most relevant for this
study.
2.2 Forensic Accounting versus Audit
Serial No Forensic Accounting Audit
1 Forensic Accounting is done in Audit is mandatory
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
7/35
response to an event
2 Forensic Accountants should
possess investigative
mentality
Auditors should possess
professional skepticism
3 Deals with financial
investigations
Measures compliance with
reporting standards4 Findings used as evidence in
court or to resolve disputes
Obtain reasonable assurance
that financial statements are
free of material misstatements
5 A Forensic Accountant may
focus more on seemingly
immaterial transactions
An Auditor basically focuses
on material transactions
6 The coverage of Forensic
Accounting is wider than
Audit dealing with both
financial and non- financial
issues
Audit is mainly concerned on
financial statements and its
related items
Source: Sage Inc.
It should be noted, however, that the divergence between Forensic Accounting and auditing
became more pronounced when Auditors began to reject the notion that a primary duty of an
Audit is discovery of errors and fraud (Gray & Moussalli, 2006; Mazumder, 2011).
2.3 Dimensions of Fraud and Audit Expectation Gap
A material misstatement may occur in two ways- misappropriation of assets and fraudulent
financial reporting. These could further occur in the following ways:
- Misappropriation of assets
- Suppression or omission of the effect of transactions from records or documents
- Recording of transactions without sufficient evidence and
- Misapplication of accounting policy.
Possible reasons for management fraud include
1) Incompetent managers playing a survival game by trying to deceive.
2) Management perks often depend on profits
3) Pressure on management to excel in the market place
4) Excessive risk taking by some managers
Management fraud remains the night mare of Auditors as they are very intractable since
management can easily override internal controls. While third parties believe that auditors should as
a primary responsibility, detect fraud, Auditors believe that their primary duty is to issue a report on
the truth and fairness of the financial statement audited by them. Given this scenario, the audit
expectation gap as a result of failure of modern audit process to guarantee the detection of all
material fraud persists (Salehi & Azary, 2009b)
2.4 Skills Set for the Forensic Accountant
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
8/35
Several studies have sought to chronicle the skills which a Forensic Accountant should have in his kitty
to be effective and remain relevant.
In one study, the following findings were made:
- The market place requires the Forensic Accountant to possess a different skill set from the
traditional Accountant
- Over 60% of the respondents ranked analytical skills, attention to details and ethical orientation
as necessary for success as a Forensic Accountant
- The survey targeted Certified Public Accountants (CPAs), Academicians and Attorneys
(representing users).
- All three groups agreed that analytical skills were the most essential.
- Other skills identified by the three groups, though not ranked the same, include effective oral
communication, ability to simplify information, auditing skills, investigative intuitiveness, ability
to identify key issues and relevant qualifications(Davis, Ramona, & Ogliby, 2009)
In a related research that surveyed Forensic Accounting Practitioners, Accounting practitioners and
attorneys, the following skills were identified although perceptions differed among groups as to the
different rankings of the skill sets:
- Deductive Analysis
- Critical Thinking
- Unstructured problem solving
- Investigative flexibility
- Analytical proficiency
- Oral communication
- Written Communication- Specific legal knowledge and
- Composure(DiGabriele, 2007)
One striking thing is that the outcomes of the two researches have a lot in common although
nomenclature may differ.
Interestingly, a similar study in Nigeria which also pooled Accounting practitioners, Academicians
and users of accounting information arrived at similar conclusions on the skill set that will place the
Forensic Accountant in good stead ( Okoye & Yohanna, 2010)
An extensive review of literature also revealed certain other skills which some writers believe willhelp the Forensic Accountant be at his best. These include:
- Persistence and doggedness
- Knowledge skills in criminology
- Computer skills
- Confidence
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
9/35
- Curiosity
- Creativity
- Discretion
- Prudence
- Secrecy
- Honesty and
- Personal courage
(Crawford, 2010; Kleeyman, 2006; Wells, 2003; Zia, 2010)
2.5 Bridging the Audit Expectation Gap-the role of Forensic Accounting. The introduction of Forensic
accounting techniques in an audit will enhance the chances of fraud detection and thus help bridge the
audit expectation gap. Forensic Accounting has been adjudged to have a positive role in solving the
vexed problems of corporate governance in Nigeria including fraud detection (Owojori & Asaolu, 2009).
Other studies confirmed that forensic accounting was relevant in fraud detection (Chariri, 2007; Kasum,
2009). Researchers have even gone a step further to establish that auditors should develop forensic
mindset in order to enable them assess more accurately the risk of fraud in any engagement so thatthey can take appropriate remedial action and thus enhance audit quality(Chui, 2010). However,
researchers caution that the injection of a Forensic auditing expert in an audit, or/and auditors
developing forensic mindset, cannot completely eliminate the audit expectation gap. The simple reason
is that expectation gap has various components, fraud detection or lack of it on the part of auditors
being only one component (Ojo, 2006b)
2.6 Forensic Accounting A cost/ Benefit Analysis. Introduction of Forensic Accounting techniques in an
audit will certainly increase the cost of an audit. This cost will be more in the nature of professional fees
paid to the Forensic Accountant and reimbursable in cases of litigation arising from fraud discovery.
There are, however, benefits also associated with the any decision to introduce forensic accountingtechniques. The real issue, therefore, is whether such a decision will be justifiable on a net benefit/cost
basis. The benefits of Forensic Accounting include fraud prevention and fraud detection (Pirraglia, 2011).
A good starting point is to investigate the cost of fraud. On a global basis, it has been estimated that
about 2.74trilion British pounds has been lost to fraud as at 2009.(McGinn, 2009). The quantifiable and
the unquantifiable costs of financial statement fraud to the global community following the aftermath of
ENRON have been chronicled as follows:
- Heavy losses suffered by companies. For example, it is estimated that more than 50% of U.S.
Corporations are victims of fraud with losses of more than 500,000 U.S dollars
- Investors, employees and pensioners suffer huge losses in the event of bankruptcy of victimcorporations. Enron, for example, lost about 70billion dollars in market capitalization when it failed.
- Other fraud costs include legal costs, increased insurance costs, loss of productivity, adverse impact
on employee morale, customer goodwill, supplier trust and negative stock market reactions.
- Undermines the reliability, quality, transparency and integrity of the financial reporting process
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
10/35
- Jeopardizes the integrity and objectivity of the auditing profession.
- It diminishes the confidence of the capital market and
- Adversely affects the Nations economic growth.(Quffa, 2011).
2.7 Summary of Theoretical Framework and Review of Related Literature.
Forensic Accounting is not as new as many people think. In the beginning, auditors took
responsibility for detection of fraud and forensic accounting techniques were used in audit. Beginning
from early 1940s auditors and the accounting profession began to redefine the duties of an audit.
Auditors were no longer primarily responsible for fraud detection and that the prime purpose of an
audit is to enable the auditor express an opinion as to whether the Financial Statements of an
organization showed a true and fair view of the entitys transactions. With the strident calls and
pressures on modern audit to once again assume responsibility for fraud, the signs are that Audit and
Forensic Accounting will soon reunite again. Forensic accounting techniques by increasing the
probability of fraud prevention and detection help in bridging the audit expectation gap as it relates to
inability of an audit to detect fraud. The cost of financial statement fraud is enormous and may never
be fully quantified. Forensic accounting techniques on a net cost/benefit basis appear to fully justify
their application in a modern audit. Perception studies have shown that various stakeholder groups
agree on the core skill sets required of the modern Forensic accountant. There is a surfeit of research on
forensic accounting especially on the skill sets required of such a professional. In Nigeria, forensic
Accounting presents a relatively new area of enquiry. To the best of the researchers knowledge, only
very few tertiary institutions (including Nnamdi Azikiwe University) are offering courses in Forensic
Accounting. Correspondingly, few local researches are available in this area going by the extensiveliterature review undertaken by the researcher in the course of this study. As forensic accounting is a
new growth area in Nigeria, it is important that perception studies are done particularly in respect of
accounting academics that will drive the needed change in forensic accounting education. This is the
gap this research will help to fill.
References:
Chariri, A. (2007). The Relevance of Forensic Accounting in Detecting Financial Frauds.
Journal Organisasi dan Manajem, 3(2), 81-88.
Chui, L. (2011).An experimental examination of the effects of fraud specialist and audit
mindsets on fraud risk assessments and on the development of fraud-related problem
representations. University of North Texas.
Crawford, C. J. (2010). CAN FORENSIC ACCOUNTING PROVIDE THE TOOLS TO
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
11/35
RESTORE CONFIDENCE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT REPORTING
PROCESS?Journal of Business and Accounting, 3(1), 125-133.
Davis, C., Ramona, F., & Ogliby, S. (2009). Characteristics and Skills of the Forensic
Accountant(p. 277). US: AICPA.
DiGabriele, J. A. (2007). Fishbowl the Forensic Accountant: Are There Differences in the Views
of the Relevant Skills of a Forensic Accountant Among Practitioners, Academics and
Users of Forensic Accounting Services? Mont clair State University.
Gray, O. R., & Moussalli, S. D. (2006). Forensic Accounting and Auditing United Again: A
Historical Perspective.JOURNAL OF BUSINESS ISSUES _, 2, 15- 25.
Hayes, R. S., Schilder, A., Roger, D., & Philip, W. (1998). Principles of International Auditig.
Auditingtext.com. Retrieved August 17, 2011,
Kasum, A. S. (2009). The Relevance of Forensic Accounting to Financial Crimes in Private and
Public Sectors of Third World Economies: A Study from Nigeria. Proceedings of The 1st
International Conference on Governance Fraud Ethics and Social Responsibility, June
(pp. 1113).
Kleeyman, Y. (2006).A Course in Forensic Accounting. Pace, U.S.
Mazumder, M. (2011). Forensic AccountingAn Investigative Approach of Accounting. SSRN
Electronic Library.
McGinn, J. (2009, November 16). The global financial cost of fraud |. Finance Week. Retrieved
August 20, 2011, from http://www.financeweek.co.uk/topic/global-financial-cost-fraud
Ojo, M. (2006). Eliminating the Audit Expectations Gap: Myth or Reality?
Okoye, E. I, & Akenbor, C. O. (2009). Forensic Accounting in Developing Economies Problems
and Prospects.Advanced Research Journal, (1).
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
12/35
Okoye, Emma I, & Yohanna, J. (2010). An Empirical Investigation of the Relevant Skills of
Forensic Accountants in Nigeria.Journal of Knowledge Management, 1(2). Retrieved
from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1797683
Owojori, A. A., & Asaolu, T. O. (2009). The Role of Forensic Accounting in Solving the Vexed
Problem of Corporate World.European Journal of Scientific Research, 29(2), 183187.
Pirraglia, W. (2011). The Advantages of Having a Forensic Accountant Within an Organization |
eHow.com. eHOW. Retrieved August 20, 2011, from
http://www.ehow.com/list_6292827_advantages-forensic-accountant-within-
organization.html
Quffa, H. C. (2011). Financial Statement Fraud.Hanna Associates.
Salehi, M., & Azary, Z. (2009). Fraud detection and audit expectation gap: Empirical evidence
from Iranian bankers.International Journal of Business and Management, 3(10), P65.
Wells, J. T. (2003). The Fraud Examiner. Sleuthing careers bring CPAs personal and
Professional Satisfaction.Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. Retrieved August
10, 2011, from http://www.acfe.com/resources/view.asp?ArticleID=35&fontsize=lg
Zia, T. A. (2010). Development, Delivery and Dynamics of a Digital Forensics Subject.Digital
Forensics conference (p. 175). Presented at the 8th Australian Digital Forensics
Conference, Cowan University.
CHAPTER THREE
3.0 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1RESEARCH DESIGN
A survey research design was adopted for this study. The choice was predicted on the
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
13/35
fact that it allowed for the collection of data from Accounting Academics in an
economical way. The standardized data in the questionnaire allowed for easy comparison.
The approach was also basically cross-sectional as the opinion of Accounting Academics
in Nigeria was elicited at one point in time.
3.2 NATURE AND SOURCES OF DATA.
This study drew its data from primary and secondary sources. The primary source of data
from the respondents. Section B listed 14 statements about Forensic Accounting and Audit
expectation Gap and Accounting Academics were asked to indicate the extent to which
they agreed with the statements. To this end, the questionnaire was based on the five
point likert scale- strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree and strongly disagree with the
following numerical values correspondingly attached to each state, 5,4,3,2 and 1.The last
part of section B of the questionnaire was unstructured and allowed respondents
unfettered freedom to make general comments as they deemed fit on the subject matter.
The face to face distribution method was adopted to get across the questionnaire to the
various respondents. This study drew copiously from such secondary sources as
textbooks, journals, magazines and internet.
3.3 POPULATION AND SAMPLE SIZE
The population of this study is all Accounting Academics in Nigeria. However, to make the
research manageable given resource constraints, Accounting Academics were targeted
from 8 tertiary institutions in the Eastern and Western Zones of Nigeria. Accounting
Academics are a homogenous group as minimum standards of entry and progression in
the Academic ladder are prescribed. .About 100 questionnaire were administered by hand
delivery on respondents. The researcher was able to enlist the help of fellow lecturers in
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
14/35
the various tertiary institutions who facilitated the delivery and return of the questionnaire
70 of the questionnaire were completed and returned given a response rate of70%.
However, 20 of the questionnaire were invalid as they were not properly filled out. 18 0f
the improperly filled questionnaire came for one tertiary institution suggesting that the
problem was peculiar to the institution and had nothing to do with difficulties associated
with the questionnaire.
3.4 DATA ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES.
Simple percentages were used to analyse the distribution of responses. The two
hypotheses of the study were tested using the Chi- square test statistic at an alpha level of
5%. The justification for use of X test statistic is predicated on the fact that the data of
study were essentially discrete, categorical and non-parametric. As a decision rule, if X
calculated is greater than X tabulated the null hypothesis is rejected and vice versa.
3.5 VALIDATION AND RELIABILITY OF INSTRUMENTS
The project supervisor provided expert validation of the questionnaire. The questions
included in the questionnaire were meticulously chosen to ensure the attainment of the
research objectives. Respondents were given clear and unambiguous instructions as to
what to do. The incidence of non- bias response was reduced by the mode of distribution
and collection of the questionnaire.
CHAPTER 4
4.0 DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
4.1 INTRODUCTION
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
15/35
This chapter is concerned with the presentation and analysis of data gathered from questionnaire
gathered administered on Accounting Academics in Nigerias Universities. Main analysis
of this study was done here and results obtained in line with the objectives of study.the
analysis was carried out in such a way that allowed a smooth flow that enabled
implications to be drawn for policy making.
4.2 PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS.
TABLE 4.1 DISTRIBUTION OF RESPONSES IN RESPECT OF ALL THE STATEMENTS
MADE ON FORENSIC ACCOUNTING AND AUDIT EXPECTATION GAP- THE
PERCEPTION OF ACCOUNTING ACADEMICS
STATEMENT 5 4 3 2 1
% % % % %
Forensic
Accounting is
a relatively
new area of
enquiry
62 36 2 0 0
The Forensic
Accountant is
different from
the traditional
auditor
36 60 0 4 0
While 26 64 8 2 0
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
16/35
auditors
express an
opinion on the
financial
statements
based on their
audit work,
members of
the public
believe that
they certify
the statement
Members of
the public
believe that
auditors
perform a
100%
verification of
amounts in the
financial
statements
while often
28 56 10 6 0
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
17/35
auditors
obtain
evidence for
such amounts
through taking
of samples
The average
investor
expects the
auditor as a
matter of his
duty to
discover all
material fraud
38 52 6 2 2
The auditor,
however,
believes that
his primary
duty is not
fraud
detection
52 42 2 2 2
The Forensic
accountant
52 40 6 2
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
18/35
who is not
affected by the
limitations of
the audit
process is in a
better position
to discover
fraud and thus
bridge the
expectation
gap between
the auditor
and investors
The Forensic
Accountant
should be
analytically
minded and
inquisitive
52 48 0 0 0
He/ She
should be able
to
communicate
46 46 6 2 0
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
19/35
complex
financial
transactions in
a simple and
easy to
understand
manner
He/ She must
possess a
sense of
urgency and
commitment
30 54 10 6 0
The Use of
Forensic
Accountant in
an audit will
increase the
cost of the
audit
22 56 8 12 2
The benefits
of using
Forensic
Accountants ,
32 46 12 6 4
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
20/35
however,
outweigh their
costs
The Forensic
Accountant in
Nigeria is up
to a hard job
because of the
high rate of
dishonesty in
the country
52 40 4 4 0
Inculcation of
whistle
blowing
culture in
Nigeria will
help the
Forensic
Accountant in
his work
24 48 16 8 4
Source: Compiled from Researchers Questionnaire, 2011
Deriving from Table 4.1:
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
21/35
- 98% of respondents agree that Forensic Accounting is a new area of enquiry. 2% did not
express any opinion on the matter
- 96% of respondents believe that the Forensic Accountant is different from the traditional
Auditor. 4% were not so persuaded.
- 90% of respondents agreed with the statement that members of the public believe that
Auditors certify Financial Statements. 8% had no opinion on the matter while 2%
disagreed.
- 84% of the respondents agreed with the suggestion that members of the public believe
that Auditors perform a 100% verification of the amounts in the financial statements.
10% had no opinion on the matter while 6% disagreed
- 90% of respondents agreed with the suggestion that the average investor expects the
Auditor as a matter of his duty to discover all material fraud. 6% did not express any
opinion while 4% disagreed.
- 94% of respondents agreed that Auditors believe that it is not their primary duty to
discover fraud. 2% declined comment on the matter while 4% disagreed.
- 92% of respondents agreed with the suggestion that Forensic Accountants were in a
better position to discover fraud and thus bridge the Audit expectation gap. 6% chose to
be neutral while 2% were persuaded otherwise.
- All respondents without exception agreed that the Forensic Accountant should be
analytically minded and inquisitive.
- 92% believes that the Forensic accountant should be able to communicate complex
financial transactions in a simple and easy to understand manner. 6% declined opinion on
the matter while 2% did not agree.
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
22/35
- 84% of respondents agreed that agreed that Forensic Accountants must possess sense of
urgency and commitment. 10% were neutral while 6% disagreed.
- 78 % of respondents believe that the use of a Forensic Accountant in an Audit will
increase the cost of the Audit. 8% chose not to comment while 14 % disagreed.
- 78% of those sampled believe that the benefits of using Forensic Accountants in Audits
will, however, outweigh their costs. 12% did not offer any opinion on the matter while
10% did not agree.
- 92% of respondents agree that the Forensic Accountant is up to an uphill task in Nigeria
because of the environment of high dishonesty. 4% are neutral while 4% expressed a
dissenting view.
- 72% agreed that the inculcation of the whistle blowing culture in Nigeria will facilitate
the work of the Forensic Accountant, 16% refused to be committed while12% disagreed.
TABLE 2 Survey on Cost/ Benefit of Using a Forensic Accountant in an Audit
S/No Statement Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
Disagree
Total
1 The use of a
forensic
Accountant
in an audit
will increase
the cost of
11 28 4 6 1 50
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
23/35
the audit
2 The Benefits
of using
Forensic
Accountants,
however,
outweigh
their costs
16 23 6 3 2 50
Source: Survey carried out by the Researcher (2011)
Survey on Skill sets required by Forensic Accountants Table 3
S/No Statement Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
Disagree
Total
8 The Forensic
Accountant
should be
analytically
minded and
inquisitive
26 24 0 0 0 50
9 He/ She
should be
23 23 3 1 0 50
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
24/35
able to
communicate
complex
financial
transactions
in a simple
and easy to
understand
manner
10 He or She
must possess
a sense of
urgency and
commitment
15 27 5 3 0 50
Source: Survey Carried out by the Researcher,2011
Hypothesis Testing
1 H1: Accounting Academics in Nigeria agree to the suggestion that on a cost-benefit basis, the
introduction of forensic techniques in an audit will stem the tide of financial fraud and
thus help in bridging the audit expectation gap.
Table 4
Response Observation
(0)
Expected (E) (O-E) ( O-E) /E
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
25/35
Strongly Agree 16 10 36 3.6
Agree 23 10 169 16.9
Neutral 6 10 16 1.6
Disagree 3 10 49 4.9
Strongly
Disagree
2 10 64 6.4
50 50 334 33.4
Source: Survey carried out by the Researcher
Using 5% level of significance
Degree of freedom = (R- 1) (C- 1), where R is number of rows and C is the number of columns.
Df = (5-1) (2-1)= 4
X, df 4 = 9.49
Decision: Accept the alternate hypothesis meaning that Accounting Academics in Nigeria agree to the
suggestion that on a cost/benefit basis, the introduction of Forensic Accounting techniques in an audit
will stem the tide of financial fraud and thus help in bridging the audit expectation gap.
Table 5
Hypothesis 2A: Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in positive light that Forensic Accountants
should be analytically minded and inquisitive.
Response Observed(0) Expected(E) O-E (O-E) (O-E)/E
Strongly Agree 26 10 16 256 25.6
Agree 24 10 14 196 1.96
Neutral 0 10 -10 100 10
Disagree 0 10 -10 100 10
Strongly Agree 0 10 -10 100 10
50 50 752 57.56
Survey carried out by the researcher, 2011
Df= (R-1) (C-1)=(5-1) (2-1) =4
X, df4= 9.49
Decision: Accept the alternate hypothesis that Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in positive light
that Forensic Accountants should have analytical and inquisitive mind
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
26/35
Table 6
Hypothesis 2B Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in positive light that Forensic Accountants
should be able to communicate complex financial transactions in a simple and easy to understand
manner
Response Observed (O ) Expected (E) O- E (O-E) (O-E)/E
Strongly Agree 23 10 13 169 1.69
Agree 23 10 13 169 1.69
Neutral 3 10 -7 49 4.9
Disagree 1 10 -9 81 8.1
Strongly
Disagree
0 10 -10 100 10
50 50 26.38
Source: Survey carried out by the Researcher, 2011
Df =(R-1) (C-1) = (5-1) (2-1) = 4
X, df4 = 9.49
Decision: Accept the alternative hypothesis that Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in good light
that Forensic Accountants should be able to communicate complex financial transactions in a simple and
easy to understand manner.
Table 7 Hypothesis 2C
Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in positive light that Forensic Accountants should possess a
sense of urgency and commitment.
Response Observed (O) Expected (E) O- E (O-E) ( O- E)/E
Strongly Agree 15 10 5 25 2.5
Agree 27 10 17 287 28.7
Neutral 5 10 -5 25 2.5
Disagree 3 10 -7 49 4.9
Strongly
Disagree
0 10 -10 100 10
50 50 48.6
Df = (R-1) (C-1) = (5 -1) (2-1) =4
X, df 4 = 9.49
Decision : Accept the alternative hypothesis that Accounting Academics in Nigeria perceive in good light
that Forensic Accountants should possess a sense of urgency and commitment.
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
27/35
CHAPTER 5
5.0 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
The following findings among others were made in the course of this research work:
1 All the 14 statements made in the questionnaire for the respondents to comment received their
endorsement
2The respondents endorsed 100% the assertion that the Forensic Accountant should be analytically
minded and inquisitive.
3 The most Controversial of the assertions was the one that stated that the inculcation of the whistle
blowing culture in Nigeria will help the Forensic Accountant in his work. Only 72% of the respondentsfully endorsed the idea, while 16% opted to remain neutral. !2% disagreed.
4 The suggestion that the use of Forensic Accountants in an Audit will increase the cost of the Audit
received the highest dissenters of 14% while 78% agreed with 8% offering to be neutral.
5 The suggestion that Forensic Accounting is a relatively new area of enquiry in Nigeria was
overwhelmingly endorsed by the respondents. 98% said yes while 2% opted to offer no opinion.
CONCLUSION
The following conclusions deriving from the study are made by the researcher:
1 The respondents were serious minded Accounting Academics and made meaningful contributions to
the success of this research effort.
2 The favourable disposition of Accounting Academics to Forensic Accounting has implications for both
Accounting education and Accounting Practice in Nigeria
3 This study has once again confirmed the existence of Audit expectation gap in Nigeria.
4 The skill set identified as germane for the Forensic Accountant in this study is in consonance withsimilar international researches. Analytical mind and inquisitive skill score very high on Nigerian
academics scale of preferences.
5 It appears strange that up to 12% of respondents were persuaded that the infusion of a Forensic
Accounting in an Audit will not increase the cost of the Audit.
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
28/35
6 Other qualities that a Forensic Accountant should have gleaned from the literature search include
courage, secrecy, knowledge skills in criminology and computer skills.
Recommendations:
The Following recommendations deriving from this study are made to guide practical action:
I) Tertiary institutions in Nigeria that have not introduced the teaching of Forensic Accounting
in their curricula should do so with immediate effect
II) Accounting practitioners, in the same vein, should develop Forensic Accounting mind set
and also inject Forensic Accounting techniques in carrying out Audits.
III) Governments in Nigeria should create an enabling environment for Forensic Accountants to
thrive fighting the pervasive culture of dishonesty in the country.
IV) In the same way, a whistle blowing culture in our environment should be nurtured and
allowed to blossom.V) It will be interesting if this study is replicated using a bigger sample size and a wider
coverage
REFERENCES
Abduiqaderai qarni, A. (2004).Audit expectation gap in saudi Arabia- perceptions of
auditors,preparers of Financial Statements and users. Dundee, Uk.
Anwar, N. (2008, April 20). Forensic accounting: A dynamic tool for combating corruption. The
Financial Express, 1-1. Dhaka.
Chariri, A. (2007). The Relevance of Forensic Accounting in Detecting Financial Frauds.
Journal Organisasi dan Manajem, 3(2), 81-88.
Chui, L. (2011).An experimental examination of the effects of fraud specialist and audit
mindsets on fraud risk assessments and on the development of fraud-related problem
representations. University of North Texas.
Crawford, C. J. (2010). CAN FORENSIC ACCOUNTING PROVIDE THE TOOLS TO
RESTORE CONFIDENCE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT REPORTING
PROCESS?Journal of Business and Accounting, 3(1), 125-133.
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
29/35
Crumbley, D. L. (2008). What is Forensic Accounting?Journal of Forensic Accounting,IX(1),1
Davis, C., Ramona, F., & Ogliby, S. (2009). Characteristics and Skills of the Forensic
Accountant(p. 277). US: AICPA.
DiGabriele, J. A. (2007). Fishbowl the Forensic Accountant: Are There Differences in the Views
of the Relevant Skills of a Forensic Accountant Among Practitioners, Academics and
Users of Forensic Accounting Services? Mont clair State University.
Gray, O. R., & Moussalli, S. D. (2006). Forensic Accounting and Auditing United Again: A
Historical Perspective.JOURNAL OF BUSINESS ISSUES _, 2, 15- 25.
Hayes, R. S., Schilder, A., Roger, D., & Philip, W. (1998). Principles of International Auditig.
Auditingtext.com. Retrieved August 17, 2011,
Kasum, A. S. (2009). The Relevance of Forensic Accounting to Financial Crimes in Private and
Public Sectors of Third World Economies: A Study from Nigeria. Proceedings of The 1st
International Conference on Governance Fraud Ethics and Social Responsibility, June
(pp. 1113).
Kleeyman, Y. (2006).A Course in Forensic Accounting. Pace, U.S.
Koh, H. C., & Woo, E.-S. (1998).The Expectation Gap in Auditing.Managerial Auditing
Journal, 13(3), 147-154.
Mazumder, M. (2011). Forensic AccountingAn Investigative Approach of Accounting. SSRN
Electronic Library.
McGinn, J. (2009, November 16). The global financial cost of fraud |. Finance Week. Retrieved
August 20, 2011, from http://www.financeweek.co.uk/topic/global-financial-cost-fraud
Ojo, M. (2006). Eliminating the Audit Expectations Gap: Myth or Reality? Munich Personal
RePEc Archive
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
30/35
Okoye, E. I., & Akamobi, N. (2009). The Role of Forensic Accounting in Fraud Investigation
and Litigation Support. The Nigerian Academic Forum, 17(1), 39-42.
Okoye, E. I, & Akenbor, C. O. (2009). Forensic Accounting in Developing Economies Problems
and Prospects.Advanced Research Journal, (1).
Okoye, Emma I, & Yohanna, J. (2010). An Empirical Investigation of the Relevant Skills of
Forensic Accountants in Nigeria.Journal of Knowledge Management, 1(2). Retrieved
from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1797683
Owojori, A. A., & Asaolu, T. O. (2009). The Role of Forensic Accounting in Solving the Vexed
Problem of Corporate World.European Journal of Scientific Research, 29(2), 183187.
Pirraglia, W. (2011). The Advantages of Having a Forensic Accountant Within an Organization |
eHow.com. eHOW. Retrieved August 20, 2011, from
http://www.ehow.com/list_6292827_advantages-forensic-accountant-within-
organization.html
Quffa, H. C. (2011). Financial Statement Fraud.Hanna Associates.
Salehi, M., Mansoury, A., & Azary, Z. (2009). Audit Independence and Expectation Gap:
Empirical Evidences from Iran.International Journal of Economics and Finance, 1(1),
P165.
Salehi, M., & Azary, Z. (2009). Fraud detection and audit expectation gap: Empirical evidence
from Iranian bankers.International Journal of Business and Management, 3(10), P65.
Wells, J. T. (2003). The Fraud Examiner. Sleuthing careers bring CPAs personal and
Professional Satisfaction.Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. Retrieved August
10, 2011, from http://www.acfe.com/resources/view.asp?ArticleID=35&fontsize=lg
Zia, T. A. (2010). Development, Delivery and Dynamics of a Digital Forensics Subject.Digital
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
31/35
Forensics conference (p. 175). Presented at the 8th Australian Digital Forensics
Conference, Cowan University.
Appendix
Questionnaire
Topic: Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap- The Perception of Accounting Academics
Dear Respondent,
The Research work with the above title is being undertaken by a fellow Accounting academic currently
pursuing a Doctoral programme in Accounting.
Forensic accounting has been defined as an accounting analysis that can uncover possible fraudthat is suitable for presentation in court A forensic accountant uses his knowledge ofaccounting, law, investigative auditing and criminology to uncover fraud, find evidence andpresent such evidence in court if required to. Audit expectation gap is defined as the perceptionof members of the public as to what the auditors responsibility ought to be and what the auditorsare prepared to assume as their responsibilities in accordance with their professional standards.For some time now, audit failures have been rife and many members of the public ascribe it tothe existence of the expectation gap syndrome. Consequently, the suggestion is that an averageexternal audit should have as a member of the team a forensic accountant to grapple with the
issue of fraud and thus significantly narrow the expectation gap. This study is meant to elicityour views on this important subject as efforts are made to restore the confidence of the investingpublic on the battered image of the audit function in Nigeria. I thank you for your cooperationand assure you that your views will be treated with utmost confidentiality.
Yours truly,S. C Okaro
.Instructions:
Please tick () as appropriate in the box provided and
b) Make brief comment/s where required.
Section A (PERSONAL DATA)
(1) SEX: Male ( ) Female ( )
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
32/35
(2) Age: Less than 30years ( ) 30 to less than 40 years ( ) 40 years to less than 60 years ( ) Over 60 years (
)
(3) Professional Accounting affiliation: ICAN ( ) ANAN ( ) OTHERS--- Specify
(4) Academic Position currently held--- Specify
(5) Name of your Institution
(6) Number of years experience as an Accounting Academic
SECTION B
Please tick your preference for the following statements that are intended to ascertain your views on
forensic accounting and audit expectation gap.
Statement Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
Disagree
Forensic
accounting is
a relatively
new area of
enquiry
The Forensic
accountant isdifferent from
the traditional
auditor
While
auditors
express an
opinion on
the financial
statementsbased on their
audit work,
members of
the public
believe that
they certify
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
33/35
the
statements
Members of
the public
believe thatauditors
perform a
100%
verification of
amounts in
the financial
statements
while often
auditors
obtainevidence for
such amounts
through
taking of
samples
The average
investor
expects the
auditor as amatter of his
duty to
discover all
material fraud
The auditor,
however,
believes that
his primary
duty is not
fraud
detection
The forensic
accountant
who is not
affected by
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
34/35
the
limitations of
the audit
process is in a
better
position to
discover fraud
and thus
bridge the
expectation
gap between
the auditor
and investors
The forensic
Accountantshould be
analytically
minded and
inquisitive
He/She
should be
able to
communicate
complexfinancial
transactions
in a simple
and easy to
understand
manner
He/ she must
possess a
sense of
urgency and
commitment
The use of a
forensic
Accountant in
an audit will
-
8/12/2019 Forensic Accounting and Audit Expectation Gap - The Perception of Accounting Academics
35/35
increase the
cost of the
audit
The benefits
of usingforensic
Accountants,
however,
outweigh
their costs.
The forensic
Accountant in
Nigeria is up
to a hard jobbecause of
the high rate
of dishonesty
in the country
Inculcation of
whistle
blowing
culture in
Nigeria will
help the
forensic
Accountant in
his work
Please make any general comment you think relevant on the above subject matter