7/31/2019 FOREN VITAL Accident Investigations - NTSB - National Transportation Safety Boa

1/5

Nibo 5 Hllkmoe} Keto|}kch}kie| 5 Qowiq}|

N HVHQMI_\ B H]OQKH@\HLLKMOE] AQKODQo`oh|o id nhvhqmiu| bh}oqkh`| dqib lhqci }hejBkmm`o}ise, Inki,Hucu|} 11, 177

7/31/2019 FOREN VITAL Accident Investigations - NTSB - National Transportation Safety Boa

2/5

Bkmso|} ]hejSiqj|, Kel%, nhm mieo }no `h|} MI]"qoxukqom }o|}| < ie }no lhqci }hej6 h n{mqi|}h}kl }o|} hem h bhceo}kl whq}kl`o ke|wol}kie ke Bhqln 1771 hem h tk|uh` ke|wol}kie keBhqln 177

7/31/2019 FOREN VITAL Accident Investigations - NTSB - National Transportation Safety Boa

3/5

H wi|}hllkmoe} o~hbkeh}kie qotoh`om h 84"keln `iec }nqiucn"sh`` lqhlj eo~} }i }no qhmkh` so`m ke }no dqie} nohm h} }no 8 i#l`ilj wi|k}kie% .\oo dkcuqo 7+ qoxukqo }nh} hen{mqiu| hbbiekh }qhe|wiq}om a{ nkcnsh{ ao keok}noq MI] |wolkdklh}kie BL"7+ hen{mqiu| hbbiekh k| l`h||kdkom hem qocu`h}om diq mibo|}kl |nkwboe}| h| h eied`hbbha`o ch|% Wqo||uqo

to||o`| kel`umkec lhqci }hej| lie}hkekec hen{mqiu| hbbiekh bu|} ao bhqjom !Kenh`h}kie Nhvhqm%! H`|i }no |nkwwkec whwoq| diq }ni|o whljhco| bu|} lie}hke}no siqm| !Kenh`h}kie Nhvhqm! ke h||ilkh}kie sk}n }no |nkwwkec mo|lqkw}kie%

Hen{mqiu| hbbiekh k| }qhewiq}om h| h `kxuudkom libwqo||om ch| ke wqo||uqo to||o`| .}hej lhq| lhqci }hej| hem l{`kemoq|+% Kd k} k| qo`oh|om dqib}no wqo||uqo to||o` hen{mqiu| hbbiekh sk`` kbbomkh}o`{ qo}uqe }i h ch|oiu| |}h}o hem o~whem qhwkm`{

Hen{mqiu| hbbiekh k| h a{wqimul} id }no wqilo|| id lietoq}kec lih` ke}i lijo snkln k| u|om h| h duo` ke a`h|} duqehlo| }i wqimulo |}oo`%

moe} Keto|}kch}kie| " E]\A " Eh}kieh` ]qhe|wiq}h}kie \hdo}{ Aihqm n}}w6))sss%e}|a%cit)keto|}kch}kie|)du``}o~})NVA7=78%n}

? 17)87)1781 361<

7/31/2019 FOREN VITAL Accident Investigations - NTSB - National Transportation Safety Boa

4/5

\nkwwoq Kediqbh}kieHJ \}oo` k| h |}oo` wqimul}kie dhlk`k}{ ke Bkmm`o}ise Inki% HJ \}oo` wqimulo| k}| ise lijo hem |}iqo| }no qo|u`}kec hen{mqiu| hbbiekh ke|}h}kiehq{ }hej|%

HJ \}oo` |o``| haiu} |k~ lhqci }hej `ihm| id hen{mqiu| hbbiekh h bie}n }i _ekthq _\H Kel% ._ekthq+ ke Lkelkeeh}k Inki% Hlliqmkec }i HJ \}oo`#| qoliqm|}no hllkmoe} lhqci }hej sh| }no ie`{ ieo ke snkln HJ \}oo`#| hen{mqiu| hbbiekh nhm aooe }qhe|wiq}om ke }no wh|} {ohq% 88

HJ \}oo`#| `haiqh}iq{ |nkd} bhehcoq heh`{vo| ohln lhqci }hej `ihm id hen{mqiu| hbbiekh diq bik|}uqo% No |}h}om }nh} }no hen{mqiu| hbbiekh h`bi|} h`sh{|lie}hke| `o|| }nhe 7%1 woqloe} sh}oq% HJ \}oo`#| qoliqm| |nis }nh} }no hen{mqiu| hbbiekh `ihmom ke }no hllkmoe} lhqci }hej muqkec }no = bie}n| wqolomkec }nohllkmoe} }{wklh``{ lie}hkeom `o|| }nhe 7%8 woqloe} sh}oq%

HJ \}oo` coeoqh}o| }no |nkwwkec whwoq| diq }no lhqci }hej| `ihmom h} }no Bkmm`o}ise w`he}% ]no |nkwwkec whwoq| diq }no 81 bie}n| aodiqo }no hllkmoe} mkm ei}kel`umo }no siqm| !EI] DIQ X hem ] ]HEJ\%!

HJ \}oo`#| xuh`k}{ |}hemhqm iwoqh}kec wqhl}klo ,78"78=8"71 diq `ihmkec }qulj| hem }hej lhq| sk}n hen{mqiu| hbbiekh ke u|o h} }no }kbo id }no hllkmoe} mkm ei}qoxukqo `ihmoq| }i toqkd{ aodiqo `ihmkec }nh} }no qoloktkec lhqci }hej sh| hwwqiwqkh}o diq hen{mqiu| hbbiekh }nh} sh| `o|| }nhe 7%1 woqloe} sh}oq% ]no wqhl}klomkm ei} }o`` }no `ihmoq snh} }i mi kd }no lhqci }hej sh| bhqjom !X]%!

Ie \ow}obaoq 88 177< HJ \}oo` qotk|om }no xuh`k}{ |}hemhqm iwoqh}kec wqhl}klo snkln eis |h{|6

Aodiqo `ihmkec lnolj |wolkdklh}kie w`h}o `ilh}om ie |kmo id }hejoq, bu|} ao `hao`om EX]% Kd `hao`om X], iq nh| ei `hao`, MI EI] @IHM%Lie}hl} \nkd} Bhehcoq% H`` HJ \}oo` obw`i{oo| keti`tom ke `ihmkec hen{mqiu| hbbiekh ke}i lhqci }hej| hqo wqo|oe}`{ aokec }qhkeom ke }no qotk|om xuh`k}{ |}hemhqm iwoqh}kec wqhl}klo%

Hmmk}kieh``{ HJ \}oo`#| |nkwwkec whwoq| diq hen{mqiu| hbbiekh eis lie}hke }no siqm| !EI] DIQ X hem ] ]HEJ\%!

Lhqqkoq Kediqbh}kie

]no lhqci }hej |obk}qhk`oq keti`tom ke }no hllkmoe} sh| iwoqh}om a{ Wqiwheo ]qhe|wiq} Ke}oqeh}kieh` .W]K+88 }no Niu|}ie"ah|om mktk|kie id Hboqkch|% 81 W]Knhem`o| }no |obk}qhk`oq mo`ktoq{ |oqtklo id `kxuodkom wo}qi`oub ch| .@WC+ }i }no Hboqkch| mk|}qkau}kie |k}o|% W]K h`|i }qhe|wiq}| | obk}qhk`oq `ihm| id @WC hemhen{mqiu| hbbiekh diq i}noq lu|}iboq| |uln h| _ekthq snkln nhm nkqom W]K }i nhu` hen{mqiu| hbbiekh dqib HJ \}oo`% W]K k| }no ie`{ mktk|kie id Hboqkch|}nh} }qhe|wiq}| hen{mqiu| hbbiekh% Haiu} 8 woqloe} id W]K#| au|keo|| keti`to| }qhe|wiq}kec hen{mqiu| hbbiekh% W]K obw`i{| 818 libwhe{ mqktoq| hem 8=?iseoq"iwoqh}iq mqktoq|% .]no mqktoq keti`tom ke }no hllkmoe} sh| he iseoq"iwoqh}iq id nk| ise }qhl}iq%+ W]K nh|

7/31/2019 FOREN VITAL Accident Investigations - NTSB - National Transportation Safety Boa

5/5

Wqo|| Qo`oh|o|

\woolno|)]o|}kbie{

Mh}hah|o|

Hllkmoe} Miljo}|

]qhkekec Loe}oq

\hdo}{ Qolibboemh}kie|\}qh}ockl W`he, Woqdiqbhelo $ Hlliue}hak k}{ Qowiq}| $ BiqoBomkh Qo|iuqlo|

Qowiq} he Hllkmoe}

\uabk} h ]LH\ Ei}kdklh}kie

Iqchekvh}kie

Hlqi|| }no Aihqm

Iddklo @ilh}kie|

Keto|}kch}kto Wqilo||

Mkqol}kie| }i Liedoqoelo Loe}oq

Aihqm Bobaoq|

Lie}hl} _|

Obw i{boe}

Soa Wi`klko| $ Ei}klo|

\k}o Bhw

C i||hq{ id ]oqb|

Iqc Lnhq}

DHX|

DIKH

Ei Dohq

Wqkthl{ \}h}oboe}

Iwoe%cit

Hllkmoe} Hekbh}kie|

Hllkmoe} Qowiq}| Heeuh` Qotkos id Hkqlqhd} Hllkmoe} Mh}h

1 Xuoelnkec hem }obwoqkec k| h noh} }qoh}boe} ke}oemom }i kbwqito }no lnhqhl}oqk|}kl| id |}oo`, kel`umkec kelqoh|kec }no {ko`m |}qoec}n% [ko`m |}qoec}n k| }no |}qo||h} snkln h bh}oqkh` |}hq}| }i woqbheoe}`{ modiqb%

< ]k}`o =; LDQ |ol}kie 8>7%=73 qoxukqo| BL %

4 H`` woqloe}hco| id sh}oq ke hen{mqiu| hbbiekh }nh} hqo qodoqqom }i ke }nk| whwoq hqo lh`lu`h}om a{ sokcn}%

3 ]k}`o =; LDQ |ol}kie 831%.l+%

> ]k}`o =; LDQ |ol}kie 831%17