The Johns Hopkins University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to ELH.

http://www.jstor.org

"For Show or Useless Property": Necrophilia and the Revenger's Tragedy

Author(s): Karin S. Coddon

Source: ELH, Vol. 61, No. 1 (Spring, 1994), pp. 71-88

Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press

Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2873432

Accessed: 08-03-2015 06:49 UTC

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/ info/about/policies/terms.jsp

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.200 on Sun, 08 Mar 2015 06:49:15 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.orghttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=jhuphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/2873432http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

!"#$%&'#(%#$%)&*+*&&%,$#,*$-.!/%0*1$#,'2+23%304%-'*%$*5*06*$7&% -$36*4.%

8.%93$20%&:%1#44#0%

!9;%;ED>CKD;AE%AL%M>NDJ%NEM%DJ>%>CAD;K%DJCABFJABD%*G;ONP>DJNE%NEM%QNKAP>NE%DCNF>MR%;%AL%DJ>%F>EC>T%LCA=%'N=G>D7NH%;EDA%#HJ>G;N7%DA%DJ>%H>CS>CBC%NEM%U;MMG>DAE?%DJ>%PAMR%AL%M>NDJ%;N%PAMR%AL%M>:%2EM>>M?%VJ;G>%FCNED;EF%DJND%DJ>NDC;KNG%H>C%ND%MA%EAD%!FA%%KACH?!%,J;G;HH>%3C;>HD;PG>%NCGR%=AM>=%*EFGNEM%NEM%"CNEK>X%LCA=%LN=;G;NCI%;DR%V;DJ%DJ>%M>NM%DA%=NKNPC>%>CAD;K;D%;E%1RC;G%-ABCE>BC7%$>S>EF>CMR%YZ[\]^?%DJ>%>CAD;K;O>M%PAMR%AL%M>NDJ%;%DJNE%N%EK>%AC%=AAMR%=>=>EDA%=AC;/%6GAC;NEN7=NC@NPG>%KDNKBGNC%NEM%=ND>C;NG%>LL;KNKR:%,>D>C%&DNGGRPCN=AS>%KACCBHD;EF%C>NG=%AL%_BNG%M>%;G;>M%PR%5;EM;K>7ED%APDCADJ>M%NEM%PR%J;CNG%HCA%EF>%NFN;E%G>KJ>CAB:`%2%=ND;K%=A=>ED/%N%%G;D>CNG;OND;AE%AL%DJ>%KAES>ED;AENG%GAS>aM>NDJ%KAEbBEKD;AE%N%4B@>% @;%%CNDJ>C%APS;AB=NG>%_BNG;DRIAC%LNGG;EF%;EDA%DJ>%D>=HD;EF%DJABFJ%NENKJCAI%E;BC%!JNS>%C>NM!%"C>BM% AC%8NDN;GG>%YDA%HNCNHJCN%8NBMC;GGNCM^?%2%VABGM%G;@>%DA%KGN;=%DJND%E>KCAHJ;G;N%;E%-J>%$>S>EF>C7MR%CS>%DA%HNCAMR%NEM%DA%;ED>CCAFND>%KAED>=I%HACNCR?%;EKC>NKD%AL%ED;L;K%>EcB;CRIH>CJNH%C>GND;S>GR%C>K>ED%HJ>EA=I%>EAE%AL%HBPG;K%M;BC7KD;S>!%@EAVG>MF>%AL%DJ>%PAMR%PR%KDNKBGNC?%M>L;NEDGR%H>CS>C%M>:%0>KCAHJ;G;N%RA@>DJ>C%EK>%NEM%MBKI%

*+'%[Z%YZdde^%]ZIff%g% Zdde%PR%-J>%QAJE

D;AET%M;%MA>HGNK>%DJ>%BECBGR%>CAD;K%PBD%;ENM%HC>KNC;I%ABG;%PAMR%PR%DJ>%KAGM%=>M;B=%AL%DJ>%ED;L;K%FNO>:h%-ABCE>BC7%!DJ>%;M>N%AL%M>NDJ!I;D%MA>NDJ%PR%C>EM>C;EF%;D%;EDA%N%M;

P>KA=>%DJ>%;E%L;KD;S>%8GB>P>NCM:%3LD>C%Q>NEE>7%NEM%>_>KBD;AE?%6;GG>S;M>EDGR%C>D;C>M%DA%J;C>%J>%HCAK>>M>M%DA%MBK>?%=BCM>C%NEM%=BD;GND>%

;EF?%DJ>%AHD;=;OND;AE%AL%;D

;E%DJ>%KA=HNER%AL%cBNCD>C>M%NEM%LGNR>M%KACHNCLBG%DA%P>JAGM:!``%3G;M>DD;?%N%G>NCE>M%2DNG;NE%$>EN;ND;%AE%NENDA=R?%C>L>CEDND;AE:!`h%2E%J;ND;%AE%BCE%>_KNSND;AE

KACH

&A%LNC%P>RAEM%DJ>%NCD;L;K;NG%%#L%NER%VA=NE7_;AE%-JND%DJ>%BHC;FJD>%P>?%-JND%E%D;=>%KB%BH%>;FJD%V;DJ%GAA@;EF%NLD>C%J>C:%

YZ:Z:ZeI`i^%

-J>%NMMC>%KDNKG>%;DGL?%;M%PR%=;AD;K%;E%ED?!%N%!GG!%AL%DJ>%M>NM%VA=NE:%.>D%DJ>%G;S;EF%6GAC;NEN%KNE%P>%KJNCNKD>C;O>M%AEGR%;E%D>C=%NCD;L;K>%NEM%ACEN=>EDND;AE%>=HGAR>M%PR%ADJ>C%GNM;>R>C>%G;@>%!DVA%J>NS>EI%HA;ED>M%M;N=AEM

>ENPG>M%DJ>%KAIAHDND;AE%AL%DJ>%KACH%;E%DJ>%HBCC%@EAVGI%>MF>^?%NGG%N%HALAC=ND;AE%?%KNEEAD%P>%DN@>E%DA%=HDBEG;FJD>E>M%NEM%NLL;C=ND;S>%>=PCNK;EF%AL%DJ>%_BNG%PAMR:%2E%J>C%M;;E7%K;L;KNGGR?%=HJNE%AL%NER%NGGB%$>M>=HD;AE%NEM%$>%$>LAC=ND;AE7%AL%;EVNCME>EKR%S;M%FC>ND>C%NE_;>DR%NPABD%M>NDJT%DJ>%HCA=;E>EK>%AL%DJ>%!LAAM%LAC%VAC==HJN%M>KA=HALNKD;AE%AL%DJ>%KACH?%;M;>SNG%4NEK>%AL%4>NDJ:h`%3%G;S;EF?%_BNG%PAMR?%+NVC>EK>%&DAE>%E?%;ED>CKABC%G;@>GR%>_HAM%DJ>=%DA%LG>NC>M%V>GG%AE%DJ>%VNR%DA%HBDC>LNKD;AE/%

8ADJ%_>M%GAEF%H>C;AM=%LAC%=AEDJNCE%VJ>E%C>GND;S>GR%V>GG?%DJ>R%ALD>E%C>M%LCA=%M;C%_%HN;ELBG%DA%DJ>=%AC%BEHG>N;C%HNCDE>CE%C>M%LCA=%N%VJAG>%C;>KAGAF;KNG%M;C

NNDJ7%>LL>KD%;C%5;EM;K>7CS>C%JAE>%VACGM!%YZ:Z:de^:%1JNCG>%'NGG>DD%JNS>%APCS>M%DJND%!5;EM;K>7R%;R%;EDA%=NME>%KC>ND>CI>FA%NEM%GAEDBNGGR?%DJ>C>%;C%N%C>NG%5;EM;K>T%J>%JNED>C>M%K>;D%DJND%J>%;%=NE%J>%HC>D>EM:%-A%HBD%AE%DJ>%CAG>%AL%5;EM;K>%NFN;E%;V%M;%'NGG>DDED>C>M%KD?%;%NERVJ>C>%;E%DJ>%HGNR:hi%8R%J;L;E;D;AE?%!DA%P>%JAE>%VACGM!I!DJ>%VACGM!%P>;EF%DJ>%C>NG=%AL%QNKAP>NE%DJ>NDC;KNG%C>HC>EDND;AE?%VJ;KJ%;E%;D%G;=;D%AL%C>HC>EDND;AE:!h[%"AC%EA%!C>NG%5;EM;K>!%;%PNENG%E%DJND%DJ>NDC;KNG%H>C%NC>%PR%M>L;E;D;AE%CAG>

;DE%NKDAC:h]%-J>%AH>E;EF%E>%KGA7C!%YZ:Z:Zhe^?%PBD%DJ>%KAGGNH%AL%PABEMNC;>DV>>E%KD%NEM%APb>KD%JNNMR%P>>E%HBD%LACDJ%NE%AL%DJ>%HGNR:%-J>%ED%DJ>NDC;KNG;OND;AE%AL%M;%DJND%DJ>%M;%;GGBEDNI%D;AE%N%=>DNHJRDNHJRC%AEGR%DJ>%NCP;DCNCR%=ND>C;NG;DR%AL%PAM;>S>E%AL%DJ>%AEE%G;S;EF%NEM%M>NM:%-JB

;M>ED;DR%NKKABED%HGNR7%>H;=AGAF;KNG%G>S>G%DJ>%HGNR%=N@>>E%;M>ED;DR%NEM%M;LL>C>EK>?%&>GL%NEM%#DJ>C?%DJ>E%DJ>%C>LB=PCNK>%AL%APb>KD;L;KND;AE%NEM%M;%NE%NENCKJR%;E%VJ;KJ%;M>ED;DR%;CKJNEF>NPG>:%'>EK>%DJ>%LAGGAV;EF%E>7CS>C%M;%CNH>%NEM%%YPR%HA;J>NC%NFN;E?%DJ>%>LL>KD%;%DCA=H>%G7A>;G?%VJ>C>;E%DJ>%>=;EF%>_NKD;DBM>%AL%=;=>C%;=;DND;AE%;DGL%%HNCAM;K%HC>K;%MBHG;KND;AE%AL%DJ>%5;EM;K>I6GAC;NENI4B@>%DC;NM%;%S>CR%NED;DJ>%E>%;C?%;E%DJND%;D%=;=;KG%DJND%JNH;=AGAF;KNG%LABEMND;AE%;DGLIDJ>R%NC>%CC;EF%DA%NEM%;ED>CNKD;EF%AEGR%V;DJ%ADJ>C%

&;=;GNCGR?%DJ>%M;7=HD%DA%HCAKBC>%J;S>E%;EK>%JNM%+B=%DV;M!%Y`:h:`^?%;E%N%P;DD>CGR%G;D>CNG%HBE%AE%DJ>%KAES>ED;AENG%*G;ONP>DJNEaQNKAP>NE%!ACFNDNI%HJAC?%G;D>CNG%EAD%DJ>%G>NKNB%C%VABGM%HCAS;M>%N%FCAD>%KDNKG>%AL%_%NEM%M>NDJ%;ED>CDV;E>M:%-JND%5;EM;K>%;CE>M%DJND%DJ>%4B@>%NEM%EAD%&HBC;A%VNM%!J>NH>M!%V;DJ%DJ>%4BKJ>_K>KD%AC%C>L>C>ED%YAES>EF>%NFN;E%4B@>^:%5;EM;K>%M%;E%DJ>%HGNR%;S>E%KDNKG>%H>C%/%;D%;%M>%DA%HC>ED%KDNKBGNCGR%DJ>%KABHG;EF%AL%DJ>%cB;K@%NEM%DJ>%M>NM?%N%M>%DJND%;=HG;KND>%PBD%DJ>%NBM;>EK>%NGG:e`%-JB%HGNR7?%NKD%h?%E>%i?%;=NC@NPG>%PADJ%LAC%;DGND;S>%HC>=NDBC;DR?%F;S>E%C>S>EF>%DCNF>MR%KAES>ED;AE

S>J>=>EK>%V;DJ%VJ;KJ%;D%HNCAM;>%F>EC>7

"AC%DJ>>g%"AC%DJ>>%MA>CGLg%3C>%GACM

C>HC>EDND;AE%AL%AS>CDGR%M>K>ED>C>M?%=;AD;KNGGR%BEC>NMNPG>%APb>KD>M?%AE%N% K>CDN;E%G>S>G?%DJ>%VJAG>%AL%-J>%$>S>EF>C7MR%;E%AS>C%DA%!

N%YCND;AENG^%=;CCAC%DA%ENDBC>?%AC%KDNKBGNC%>_H>C;>EK>%NNDJ%N%%AL%%C>L>C>ED;NG;DR?%DJ>%M>_BNG;O>M%APb>KD%AL%M;%#DJ>C%AL%DJ>%M;=PAM;>M%HCADAIJB=NE;%$>S>EF>C7MR%CI%GR%HCALL>C%M>NM%PAMR%ND;M%HCAH%AE%VJ;KJ%EAD%C>NM?%E>;DJ>C%N%PAMR%AL%HN;E%EAC%AL%HG>N?%PBD%AE>%AL%;EL;E;D>%BD;G;DR:%2E%;D%ED;O>M%PAMR?%DJ>%HGNR%KDNKBGNCGR%KAELABEM%DCNE%G>F;D;=;O>M%PAMR?%M>%NEM%M;IDJ>%S>CR%PABEMNC;>%KD%NEM%APb>KD%LAC%>NCGR%=AM>=%*BCAH>NE%>H;=AGAFR:%

2E%HA=%3=>C;KN?%VJ>E%AE>%J>NCE>M%DA%ZddZ%9BVN;D%AC%2CNc?%VJ>E%DJ>%HAG;D;KNG%;E

4NC@>C%5;%[^?%e]I][T%LAC%PGNK@%M>NDJ%>%(J;D>%YEAD>%[^?%h\Ih`T%NEM%LAC%KJBCKJ%PBC>NBKCNKR%>%3C;>%Z^?% df:%f% &>>?%LAC%>_N=HG>?%PAA@%[?%KJNHD>C%Z]%AL%UACD>%M73CDJBC:%2%N=%FCND>LBG%DA%*G;ONP>DJ%8CRNE%LAC%DJ;L>C>EK>?%NGG%N%LC>cB>ED%;ED>CKD;AE%AL%KDNKG>%NEM%M>NDJ%V;DJ%DJ>%>CAD;K%;E%U>M;>SNG%!S;CF;E%=NCDRCCE%+:%8BGGABFJ?%&>_BNG%5NC;NEK>%;E%&AK;>DR%NEM%';V%.AC@/%QAJE%(;G>R%k%&AE

h[%4>CC;MN%YEAD>%h\^?% he:%h]%8R%!JAE>L>C%EAD%AEGR%DA%DJ>%=AM>CE%M>L;E;D;AE%AL%!DCBDJLBGE>