Focal mechanisms from fluid induced...

39
��������

Transcript of Focal mechanisms from fluid induced...

Page 1: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

��������������

���� �������� �� ����������������� ��������� ��

������� ����� ����������� ����������� ��� ����� ����������

�� ��������� � � ������� ����

����� ���������� ���� �����

������� ����������

�� �� ������

��������� �� �������� �� ����� �� �����

������

Page 2: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Focal mechanisms from fluidinduced seismicity

Page 3: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

The borehole site configuration

Page 4: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Stress field determination fromhydraulic testing

Page 5: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Location of induced microseismicity

Page 6: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Observed focal mechanisms

Page 7: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Joint inversion of focal mechanismsand hydraulic tests

Page 8: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Integrated inversion

Page 9: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Using induced seismic events as pressure gauges

Page 10: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Calibrating the friction law parameters- 1

Page 11: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Calibrating the friction law parameters- 2

Page 12: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Mapping the pore pressure

Page 13: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

A simple explanation

Page 14: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Identifying flow zones from spinnerlogs

Page 15: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Conclusions from le Mayet de Montagne borehole tests

• Existence of stress heterogeneity, especially whereflow occurs;

• Need to combine focal plane solutions with other data

• Induced seismicity maps high pore pressure, not highflow rate;

• All porous fracture zones may not be significant atthe pluri hectometric scale

Page 16: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Philippine Fault

Page 17: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

(Aurelio, 1992)

Philippine Fault on Leyte island

Tongonan geothermal field

Page 18: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

• GPS measurement 91-94-95• 3.5 cm/y of creeping displacement

Displacement field in the vicinity of the fault

Seismicity

(Duquesnoy, 1997)

Page 19: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

• Branches of Philippine Fault

Displacement along the fault at Tongonan

• 2.4 cm/y of creep displacement

(Duquesnoy, 1997)

Page 20: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Injection experiment (1)

Page 21: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.
Page 22: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Injection experiment (2)

Page 23: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Injection experiment (3)

Fault

Summary of the observations:• Water injected at the bottom of the well• Well head pressure: up to 9 MPa• Increase of microseismicity• Injected volume: 36 000 m3(Other wells: 327 000 m3)

Page 24: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Seismicity acquisition

• Surface network (1-30 Hz)• Feb. – Aug. 96 (Period 1) and Nov. – May 97 (Period 3): 7 stations• Oct. – Nov. 96 (Period 2) and Jun. – Jul. 97 (Period 4): 18 stations (Four 3-C)

Page 25: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Tomographic inversion (1)• Simultaneous determination of relocation and velocity model (Thurber, 1983)• P and S traveltimes, 3-D grid with linear interpolation• Iterative least squares inversion

Period 4: 292 ev. (3939 P, 1352 S)Period 2: 141 ev. (1743 P, 1394 S)

Page 26: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Induced microseismicity locations

Page 27: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Seismicity relocationsPeriod 1+3 and 2

Page 28: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Vp velocity model (1)

Before injection

After injection

Page 29: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Vp velocity model (2)-before and during injection-

Page 30: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Focal mechanisms

32 solutions 40 solutions

Period 4Period 2

Zone 4Zone 2

Page 31: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Focal mechanisms inversion-first trial by zones-

Zone 223 focal mechanisms

Solutions in 90 % confidence domainBest solution compatible with 83 % of the data

Zone 4: no solution

Page 32: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Principle of shear wave splitting• In anisotropic

materials shear wavevelocity varies withdirection leading to shear wave splitting. .

• In planar isotropy, 5 elastic constants.

• waved polarizedparallel to plane are faster.

Page 33: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Fast S- wave polarisations-Period 2 and 4 -

• Shear wave splitting• G1, G2, G4: parallel to fault• G3: orthogonal to fault

Page 34: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Stress heterogeneity in the seismicity cloud?

New data selection:• Definition of a sphere for each event with radius~rupture dimension• Successive events with intersecting spheres are excluded

Page 35: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

13 foc. Mech.

Focal mechanisms inversion-new data selection-

Solutions in 90 % confidence domainBest solution compatible with 91 % of the data

Page 36: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Inversion focal mechanisms-new selection-

Fast S- wave polarisations-east of the Central Fault (G1, G2, G4) -

Fast polarisation ~ 145 deg. σ1 and σ2 ~ 110-150 deg.

Page 37: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Observations compatibility in regional context

• Minimum principal stress orthogonal to fault• GPS data show extention orthogonal to fault ~0.6-1.8 cm/y

(Duquesnoy, 1997)

Page 38: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Extension basins along the fault

(Aurelio, 1992)

Page 39: Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity.indico.ictp.it/event/a05227/session/57/contribution/38/material/0/3.pdf · Focal mechanisms from fluid induced seismicity. Author: F.H.

Conclusions from Tongonan experiment

• Effect of interactions between events, but once independent events are selected, results are consistent with shear wave splitting conclusions

• Shear wave splitting yields consistent results

• Fault is normal to principal stress direction and therefore does not support, locally, any shear stress component