Fishermans Bend - Documents List v9...89 “ Background report - Energy of Things, Governance and...

Document List

Fishermans Bend Planning Review Panel - Version 9, 23 April 2018

278 Date Description Presented by

1 28/10/17 Example notice – Consultation and briefing

sessions, the Age Newspaper

(from the Age)

2 10/11/17 Agenda – Public Briefing Ms Mitchell, Chair, Planning

Review Panel (Chair)

3 “ Chair Notes – Public Briefing “

4 “ Presentation – Fishermans Bend Draft

Framework Plan

Mr Ward, Fishermans Bend

Taskforce (Taskforce)

5 “ Presentation – Draft Planning Controls,

Planning Scheme Amendment GC81

Ms Tapper, DELWP

6 “ Presentation – Fishermans Bend Urban

Design Strategy, September 2017

Ms Hodyl, Fishermans Bend

Taskforce

7 “ Presentation – Integrated Transport Plan Mr Giles, Fishermans Bend

Taskforce

8 24/10/17 Agenda – Public Briefing Mr Townsend, Deputy Chair,

Planning Review Panel (Deputy

Chair)

9 “ Chair Notes – Public Briefing “

10 “ Presentation - Public Open Space Strategy Mr Ward, Taskforce

11 “ Presentation – Draft Community

Infrastructure Plan, November 2017

Ms Hajjari, Taskforce

12 “ Presentation – Background Reports, 13

November 2017

Ms Banks, Taskforce

13 28/11/17 Agenda – Site Visit Ms Goodall, Taskforce

14 “ Site Visit Map “

15 “ Planning Permits Activity and Planning

Permit Application Map

“

16 14/11/17 Notification Letter – sent to submitters Ms Mitchell, Chair

17 18/12/17 Letter – Letter to Chair referring Ministerial

Advisory Committee (MAC) Report

Minister for Planning

18 “ Report – Fishermans Bend MAC Report to

the Minister for Planning on Draft

Fishermans Bend Framework

“

19 19/12/17 Submission

a) Tabling Letter, Ms Choi

b) Directions sought, Mr Morris QC

c) Affidavit of Ms Brezzi

Ms Choi, Norton Rose Fulbright

Document List | Fishermans Bend Planning Review Panel

20 20/12/17 Preliminary key issues Mr Townsend, Deputy Chair

21 “ GC50 - Reasons for Intervention Mr Morris of Counsel

22 “ Administration Law Act 1987 Mr Canavan of Counsel

23 “ Submission – Minister for Planning Mr Tobin, Harwood Andrews

24 28/12/17 Directions Letter – Review Panel Ms Mitchell, Chair

25 18/01/18 Directions (Version 2) – Review Panel Ms Harwood, Planning Panels

Victoria

26 19/01/18 Correspondence – Adjournment request Ms Morris, Harwood Andrews

27 22/01/18 Correspondence – Proposed second

Directions Hearing date

Ms Morris, Harwood Andrews

28 23/01/18 Correspondence – Response to

Adjournment request

Mr Townsend, Deputy Chair

29 25/01/18 Correspondence – Further Adjournment

request and proposed stage 1 hearing

outline


30 29/01/18 Correspondence – Response to further

adjournment request

Ms Mitchell, Chair

31 31/01/18 Correspondence – Second Directions

Hearing

Mr Moylan, Planning and

Property Partners

32 31/01/18 Correspondence – Second Directions

Hearing

Ms Robinson, Rigby Cooke

Lawyers

33 02/02/18 Affidavit of Ms Morris Ms Brennan of Counsel for


34 “ Submission – Minister for Planning in

support of adjournment request

“

35 5/02/18 Directions and summary timetable Ms Mitchell, Chair

36 6/02/18 Correspondence – Late circulation of

Direction 11


37 7/02/18 Correspondence – Response to Direction 11

and attached list of documents

“

38 9/02/18 a) Hearing Timetable, Reasons for

Decision and revised Distribution

List

b) Additional direction (12/02/18)

Ms Mitchell, Chair

39 13/02/18 Presentation – Draft Framework Plan Mr Ward, Taskforce

40 “ Presentation – Background Reports Ms Banks, Taskforce

41 “ Presentation – Urban Design Strategy Ms Hodyl, Taskforce

42 “ Presentation – Draft Planning Controls Mr Hensen, DELWP


43 “ Presentation – Integrated Transport Plan Mr Lolas, DEDJTR

44 “ Presentation – Draft Community

Infrastructure Plan

Ms Hajjari, Fishermans Bend

Taskforce

45 “ Presentation – Public Open Space Strategy “

46 “ Agenda – Public Briefing Ms Mitchell, Chair

47 13/02/18 Correspondence re Site Tour

a) Site Tour cover letter

b) Site Tour Agenda

c) Site Tour pick up and drop off

location map

d) Site Tour route map: Part 1 and

Part 2

e) Site Tour list of sites nominated by

submitters


48 14/02/18 Planning and Property Partners - Site visit

booklet

Mr Wren of Counsel for

Planning and Property Partners

49 19/02/18 Submission – Part A

a) Harwood Andrews cover letter

b) Part A response

c) Permit activity map (Appendix E to

submission)

d) Submission spreadsheet (Appendix

F to submission)

e) Amended documentation

(Appendix G to submission, 10 files)


50 19/02/18 3D Modelling Conclave Statement

a) Letter to Panel and parties

b) Joint Conclave Statement

“

51 26/2/18 Economics evidence – Mr Szafraniec “

52 26/2/18 Planning evidence – Mr Glossop “

53 26/2/18 Urban design evidence – Mr Hodyl “

54 27/02/18 Correspondence – Permit call-ins “

55 28/02/18 Urban design evidence – Professor Bates “

56 “ Revised Directions and Distribution List

Ms Mitchell, Chair

57 01/03/18 Presentation - MAC Ms Meredith Sussex AM,

Fishermans Bend Ministerial

Advisory Committee

58 “ Submission – Ms Halliday Ms Halliday, Fishermans Bend


MAC

59 “ Powerpoint – St Kilda Cycling Club

Ms Jackson, St Kilda Cycling

Club

60 “ Submission – MWRRG

a) Submission

b) Metro Plan extract

c) Planning Scheme reference

Ms Lee, MWRRG

61 02/03/18 Presentation slides – Architects Institute of

Australia

Ms White, Architects Institute

of Australia

62 “ Submission – Oral presentation and

summary report

Ms Foxworthy, Affordable

Housing Industry Group

63 “ Submission Mr and Ms Sutherland, YCAC

64 “ Submission

Mr Riordan, Tract Consultants

65 “ Correspondence – regarding population

estimates

Mr Naughton, Planning and

Property Partners

66 06/03/18 a) Review Panel Day 1 provisions

cover letter and contents

b) Melbourne MSS – Day 1 version

c) Port Phillip MSS – Day 1 version

d) Combined LPP – Day 1 version

e) Combined CCZ – Day 1 version

f) Combined DDO – Day 1 version

g) Port Phillip DPO – Day 1 version

h) Combined PO – Day 1 version

i) How to calculate FAU – Day 1

version

Ms Mitchell, Chair

67 05/03/18 Correspondence – regarding late circulation

of EWS


68 “ Development viability evidence – Mr

Macintosh

“

69 “ Strategic transport, framework peer review

evidence – Mr Fooks

“

70 “ Strategic Transport – Integrated Transport

Plan review evidence – Mr Kiriakidis

“

71 06/03/18 Addenda 1 to urban design evidence of Ms “


Hodyl

72 07/03/18 Public Infrastructure evidence – Mr Shipp Ms Ryan, City of Melbourne

73 “ Planning evidence - Mr Milner “

74 “ ESD evidence – Mr Williamson (Joint

evidence between CoM and CoPP)

75 “ Open space evidence – Ms Thompson Ms Morris, Harwood Andrews

76 08/03/18 a) Infrastructure funding and delivery

evidence - Mr Shipp

b) Mesh report on Funding and

Financing infrastructure

Ms Bird, Maddocks

77 “ a) Social and affordable housing

evidence - Dr Spiller

b) Footnote 8

“

78 “ a) Flooding and Drainage evidence –

Mr Patterson (joint evidence

between CoM and CoPP)

b) Annexure 4 – Integrated and

Innovative Water Management

Report (Ramboll)

c) Annexure 7 – Melbourne Water

Baseline Drainage Options Plan

(GHD)

“

79 09/03/18 Correspondence – Confirmation of order of

experts


80 “ Correspondence – Request for Direction to

release ten transport background

documents


81 “ Direction 23 – release of documents Ms Mitchell, Chair

82 “ Submission – Report of Ms Peason on built

form testing and capacity modelling

Ms Ryan, City of Melbourne

83 “ Addenda 2 to urban design evidence of Ms

Hodyl


84 13/03/18 Correspondence – Confirmation of release

of transport documents

“

85 “ Correspondence – Request for access to

DELWP draft amendment mapping files


86 “ Submission – Fishermans Bend Economic

and Transport Infrastructure Study , PWC

Mr Montebello, Maddocks

87 “ Correspondence – Request for access to

Development Contributions documents


Property Partners


88 “ Background Document – Fishermans Bend

Public Space Strategy, 2017

Ms Goodall, Taskforce

89 “ Background report - Energy of Things,

Governance and the Smart City

“

90 “ Addenda 3 to evidence statement of Ms

Hodyl


91 “ Addenda 1 to evidence statement of Prof

Bates

“

92 14/03/18 Addenda 4 to evidence statement of Ms

Hodyl

“

93 “ Submission call in on existing permit

applications

Ms Brennan

94 “ Part B Submission – Minister for Planning

“

95 “ Evidence Powerpoint presentation

– Urban Design

Ms Hodyl, Fishermans Bend

Taskforce

96 15/03/18 Evidence from Homes for Victorians Mr O’Farrell, Counsel Assisting

97 “ Extract from Homes Population &

Demographic Report Sept 2016, Pages 4, 11

- 13

Ms Forsyth

98 16/03/18 Response to submissions – Minister for

Planning

Ms Brennan

99 “ Options for Open Space

a) Table describing private land

affected

b) Map locating open space sites

c) Worked example of 5 land

provision scenarios

“

100 “ Interim Development Contributions “

101 “ Taskforce response to Expert Witness

Recommendations

“

102 “ Correspondence from Mr Kiriakidis

regarding documents relied upon

“

103 “ Marked up version of DDO Mr Glossop, Glossop Town

Planning

104 “ Marked up version of CCZ “


105 19/03/18 PowerPoint presentation: Economic

evidence statement

Mr Szafreniec, SGS Consultants

106 “ Macro Plan Dimasi Feasibility Analysis Mr Wren

107 “ PowerPoint presentation Public Open Space

Evidence

Ms Brennan

108 “ Open Space Adjusted Layout plans “

109 20/03/18 Submission – City of Port Phillip and

attachments

a) Stage 1 Submission

b) Consolidated list of requested

changes

c) Marked up CCZ

d) Marked up LPP

e) Preferred locations of Community

Hubs


110 “ Summary of evidence – Mr Shipp Mr Shipp, Urban Enterprise

111 “ Extract from Fishermans Bend Integrated

Transport Plan

Ms Forsyth

112 “ School provision review for Docklands -

Stage 1


113 “ School provision review for Docklands -

Stage 2

“

114 21/03/2018 Submission relating to email sent on 15

March 2018

Ms Brennan

115 “ PowerPoint presentation on Integrated

Water Management Solutions

Mr Patterson of Ramboll Group

116 “ In Our Backyard: Growing Affordable

Housing in Port Phillip 2015-2025

Ms Brennan

117 “ Plan Melbourne Directions 2.3 Mr Tweedie of Counsel for

Norton Rose Fulbright

118 “ Extracts from Fishermans Bend Framework “


119 “ AmGC81: Social and Affordable Housing

Summary & Evidence

Dr Spiller, SGS Economics

120 “ Written submission, Melbourne City Council “

121 22/03/18 Slide presentation - Planning Mr Milner, 10 Consulting Group

122 “ Slide presentation, Professor Prof Adams Professor Adams, City of

Melbourne

123 “ Map Book Ms Foley, Minister for Planning

124

“ Attachments and CoM submission

Places for People

Ms Forsyth

125 “ Extracts from the Housing Affordability Act “

126 26/03/18 Written submission

OC 339 – 343 Plummer street, Port

Melbourne

Mr Mohan, Planning and

Property Partners

127 “ PowerPoint

OC 339 – 343 Plummer street, Port

Melbourne

“

128 “ Written Submission Mr Ashkanasy

129 “ Plan of ownership in Lorimer Precinct Ms Forsyth

130 “ Extracts of West Melbourne Structure Plan “

131 “ Extract from Victoria’s 30 Year

Infrastructure Strategy (2016)

Infrastructure Victoria

“

132 “ VCAT Caydon Cremorne No.1 Development

Pty Ltd v Yarra CC P1969/2015

“

133 “ Homes for People, City of Melbourne “

134 27/03/18 Written Submission Bellamia Nominees

and DCLC Investment

Mr Pagliaro, Urbis

135 “ PowerPoint Presentation Bellamia

Nominees

“

136 “ Submission relating to email sent on 15

March 2018

Mr Wren


137 “ Submission relating to email sent on 15

March 2018

Mr Canavan

138 &

138A

“ Update to Document 99 adjusted for Ms

Thompson recommendations

a. accompanying plan

Ms Brennan

139 “ PowerPoint presentation of Mr Fooks

Evidence Statement

Mr Fooks, GTA Consultants

140 26/3/18 Urban Design evidence – Mr McPherson Ms Eastaugh, Maddocks

141 “ Open space evidence – Mr de Keijzer Ms Ryan, City of Melbourne

142 28/3/18 Submission relating to email sent on 15

March 2018

Mr O’Farrell, Counsel Assisting

143 “ Letter from Norton Rose requesting

information on existing permits and

applications


144 “ Submission on extension of existing permits Mr Wren

145 “ Report from Phillip Boyle & Associates - car

share provision


146 “ PowerPoint presentation Prof Bates, LAB Architecture

Studio

147 “ PowerPoint presentation

Mr Kiriakidis, GTA Consultants

148 “ Extract from second container

Port Advice Evidence Base Fig 15

Ms Forsyth

149 “ Extract from Charter Keck Cramer/GTA

Precinct Car Parks rep Opportunities

“

150 “ Plan of subdivision – 874-86 Lorimer and

Aerial Photo

Mr Wren

151 29/03/18 Supplementary information notes (folder) Ms Brennan

152 “ Lorimer Street lake pattern plans Ms Forsyth

153 “ Extract from Jacobs report

FB Freight Corridor Advisory Services, Sept

2016

“

154 “ Addenda 5 to evidence statement of Ms Ms Brennan


Hodyl

155 “ Opinion of Mr Batt QC and Ms Foley re

Draft Amendment GC81

“

156 (A & B) “ A: Addenda 5 to evidence statement of Ms

Hodyl

B: Minister for Planning revised maps for

CCZ DDO and MSS - 290318

“

157 “ Letter from Mr Mackintosh - response to

Panel request for further info

“

158 “ Letter from Mr Szafraniec - response to

Panel request for further info

“

159 “ Modelling images of permits granted and

permits applications in Montague,

Sandridge and Wirraway

“

160 “ Request for ruling Ms Choi, Norton Rose Fulbright

161 “ Evidence Statement of Mr Turnbull on

traffic (s147)

Mr Katz, Conwall Stodart

162 “ a. Tabling letter

b. Evidence Statement of Mr Rodgers

on planning (s220)

c. Evidence Statement of Ms Dunstan

on traffic (s220)

Mr Wiseman, Clayton Utz

163 “ Correspondence regarding late circulation

of evidence

Mr Ponte, Ponte Lawyers


of evidence

Mr Passarella, Mills Oakley

165 “ a. Tabling Letter

b. Mr Sheppard evidence statement

on urban design (relied upon by

Planning and Property Partners and

Russell Kennedy

c. Mr Shimmin evidence statement on

economics

d. Ms Dunstan evidence statement on

traffic

e. Mr Biacsi evidence statement on

planning


166 “ Correspondence tabling urban design

evidence


Property Partners



of evidence

Ms Anderson, Rigby Cooke

Lawyers


b. Dr Eaddy evidence statement

Ms Colsell, Russell Kennedy

169 “ Further Submission – response to matters

taken on notice


of Australia

170 “ Further Submission Ms Qian, Green Building

Council

171 04/04/18 Correspondence – re request for ruling Ms Morris, Harwood Andrews

172 “ Letter and extracts of CoPP Planning

Committee Minutes of 28 March 2018

Ms Eastaugh, Maddocks

173 05/04/18 a. Tabling letter

b. Mr Negri evidence statement

Mr Memmolo, Ponte Lawyers

174 06/04/18 Revised Timetable (Version 3) Ms Harwood, Planning Panels

Victoria

175 “ Evidence Statement Mr Barnes Mr Upton, Cornwall Stodart


of evidence

Mr Passarella, Mills Oakley


b. Evidence of Mr Sheppard on

Wirraway

c. Evidence of Mr Sheppard on

Lorimer

d. Evidence of Mr Sheppard on

Sandridge

e. Evidence of Mr Sheppard on

Montague

f. Evidence of Mr McGurn

g. Evidence of Ms Dunstan

h. Evidence of Ms Heggen for

Citipower

i. Evidence of Ms Heggen for

Goodman

Mr Ng, Norton Rose Fulbright

178

“ Tabling letter of Mr Sheppard’s evidence Mr Moylan, Planning and

Property Partners

179 “ Tabling letter of Mr Sheppard and Mr

McGurn’s evidence

Ms Colsell, Russell Kennedy

180 9/04/18 DELWP Email sent on 15 March 2018 Ms Mitchell, Chair

181 - - -


182 “ Submission and attachments from City of

Port Phillip

Mr Montebllo, Maddocks

183 Urban Design Report April 2018, CoPP “

184 “ Powerpoint presentation of Mr McPherson “

185 “ Lorimer Plan – Recommended approach Mr Wren

186 “ Diagrams demonstrating transfer of

commercial development rights


187 “ Letters to landowners impacted by

proposed changes to land impacted by

open space

Ms Foley

188 “ a. Tabling letter for Spec Property

Development (s202)

b. Evidence of Ms Bell

c. Evidence of Ms Dunstan

d. Evidence of Mr Czarny

Ms Tarasenko, Minter Ellison

189 “ Addenda to Mr de Keijzer’s evidence

Ms Ryan, City of Melbourne

190 10/04/18 PowerPoint of Mr de Keijzer evidence

Ms Forsyth

191 “ Attachment to CoM submission

Ms Forsyth

192 “ Written Submission, City of Melbourne Ms Forsyth

193 “ Track change version of Parking Overlay

(A & B)

Ms Forsyth

194 “ Mr Walsh Evidence Mr Passarella, Mills Oakley

195 11/04/18 Mr Barnes Evidence

Mr Robinson, Rigby Cooke

196 “ FBURA Retail Assessment Attachments A &

B

Ms Foley

197 “ Fishermans Bend Review of sustainability

strategy

“

198 “ Fishermans Bend Net Zero Emissions

strategy, Point Advisory

“

199 “ Fishermans Bend Climate Readiness

Accommodation Strategy

“


200 “ Clarification of matters from Mr McPherson Ms Eastaugh, Maddocks

201 “ Review Panel – Statement of Reasons Ms Mitchell, Chair

202 “ PowerPoint Presentation Ms Dunstan, Traffix Group

203 “ Infrastructure Victoria 30 year strategy

extract

Ms Foley

204 “ Addendum to evidence of Mr Sheppard Mr Canavan

205 “ PowerPoint Presentation “

206 “ NRF letter of instructions to Mr Sheppard Mr Canavan

207 “ Russell Kennedy letter of instructions to Mr

Sheppard

“

208 “ The effect of zoning on house prices

discussion paper, Reserve Bank of Australia

“

209 “ Evidence of Mr Song Mr Passarella, Mills Oakley

210 12/04/18 Extract of Mr Sheppard’s evidence to

Melbourne C270

Ms Brennan

211 “ Extract of Montague Structure Plan “

212 “ Extract from Future Cities Report “

213 “ Extract from Infrastructure Australia

website

“

214 “ Extract from Essentials of Urban Design by

Mark Sheppard

“

215 “ Case Study comparative table prepared by

Ms Hodyl

“

216 “ Examples of recent developments in central

city and suburbs

“

217 “ Extract of Planning Permits Data Review

Report (2010 – 2015)

“

218 “ Planning Practice Note 59 Mr Montebello, Maddocks

219 “ Extract Better Apartments draft design

standards

Ms Forsyth

220 “ Better Apartments Consultation Report

extract

“

221 13/04/18 Addendum 2 to Mr Sheppard’s Evidence

Report

Ms Sharp of Counsel for Norton

Rose Fulbright


222 “ PowerPoint of Mr Shimmin Evidence “

223 “ Corrections to Mr Shimmin’s Evidence

Statement

“

224 “ Extract from Plan Melbourne Mr Watters of Counsel for


225 “ Extract from Global Liveability Report 2017 “

226 “ Extract from State Planning Policy

Framework


227 “ Clause 4 Buildings and Walks draft

proposed change

Ms Foley

228 “ Copy of Report by Mr Biacsi for 11-31

Montague Street in Supreme court

proceedings 2017

“

229 “ Addendum to Mr Sheppard's Lorimer

evidence

Ms Sharp

230 “ Lorimer 3D massing and shadow study “

231 16/04/18 Submission by APA Group Ms Bannister, Hall and Wilcox

232 “ Submission by Ms Wagenhoff Ms Wagenhoff

233 “ Submission by Community Alliance of Port

Phillip – Ms Small, Ms Byrne & Ms Forbath

Ms Small

234 “ PowerPoint presentation by South Port

Urban Responsible Renewal (SPURR)

Mr Groves

235 “ SPURR – Presentation speaking notes “

236 “ Correspondence seeking Panel Direction Mr Moylan


237 17/04/18 Fishermans Bend – Net Zero Carbon

Strategy, Point Advisory

Ms Brennan

238 “ Submission by Port of Melbourne

Operations

Mr Vorcheimer, HWL Ebsworth

239 “ Melbourne Airport Environs Overlay “

240 “ PowerPoint of EPA submission Ms Davies

241 “ EPA proposed amendments to planning

controls A – D

“

242 “ Submission by Fishermans Bend Network Ms Stone

243 “ Submission by Father Bob Maguire

Foundation

Ms Rosen

244 “ a. Further Review Panel Directions 24

and 25

b. Revised Hearing Timetable (Version

4)

Ms Mitchell, Chair

245 18/04/18 Fishermans Bend Current Development

Activity

Ms Brennan

246 “ Timelines for providing corrected / updated

planning scheme maps and draft controls

“

247 “ Section 46 Evidence Act 1995 Mr O’Farrell, Counsel Assisting

248 “ Further submission from Property Council

of Australia

Mr Crawford, Property Council

of Australia

249 “ Further submission from Bellamia

Nominees and PCLC Investment

Mr Weinmann, Bellamia

Nominews P/L and PCLC

Investment

250 “ a. Norton Rose Fulbright letter of

instruction to Mr Biacsi

b. Russell Kennedy letter of

instruction to Mr Biacsi

c. List of documents referred to by Mr



Biacsi

d. List of properties in FBURA with

which Mr Biacsi has had

involvement

251 19/04/18 Correspondence in response to the request

to recall witnesses


252 “ Submission on matters for consideration by

the Review Panel, Landowners Group

Mr Tweedie

253 “ Outline of submissions, Landowners Group “

254 “ Memorandum of Advice, re amendment

C270 to Melbourne Planning Scheme, Mr

Morris QC

“

255 “ Equity Trustees Executors and Agency Co

Ltd and ORS V Melbourne and Metropolitan

Board of Works [1993] 81 LGERA 86

“

256 “ Meriton Apartments Pty Ltd v Minister for

Urban Affairs and Planning [2000]

NSWLEC20

“

257 “ Seventh Columbo Pty Ltd v Melbourne City

Council [1998] VSC 7

“

258 “ Mainline Investments V City of Whittlesea

[2005] VCAT 1917

“

259 20/04/18 Further submission – response to matters

taken on notice (version 2)


of Australia (Victorian Chapter)

260 “ List of property owners and occupants

notified of proposed open space

recommendations within the City of

Melbourne

Ms Brennan

261 “ List of property owners and occupants

notified of proposed open space

recommendations within the City of Port

Phillip

“

262 “ Revised Hearing Timetable (Version 5) Ms Harwood, Planning Panels

Victoria

Fishermans Bend - Documents List v9...89 “ Background report - Energy of Things, Governance and...

Documents

Transcript of Fishermans Bend - Documents List v9...89 “ Background report - Energy of Things, Governance and...