Financial Services Benchmark Report Final...
Transcript of Financial Services Benchmark Report Final...
FOREWORD
The BountyJobs mission is to help employers and agencies collaborate more effectively. We recognize that going out to search is only one piece of a company’s multi-faceted talent acquisition strategy. Because it is an expensive piece, talent acquisition leaders have to make critical decisions about when and how to send jobs out to search. We host the world’s largest marketplace for employer and agency collaboration, giving us the data to benchmark salaries, fees, and performance. We think this data is a necessary tool for teams working to make the most of their third party agency investment.
01 FOREWORD & EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2016, we shifted our annual report to focus more on data, and less on analysis. With that shift, there was a high demand for more vertical-specific data. Talent Acquisition leaders wanted to see how their company’s recruitment metrics stacked up against industry benchmarks.
In these quarterly reports, we’re focusing on the four most active industries in the BountyJobs marketplace. Financial Services is the third in our series; following our previous reports on Pharmaceutical and Biotechnology, as well as Information Technology. In addition to the more traditional banking and finance roles, this report also includes roles in a wide variety of job categories, including IT and Marketing.
— The BountyJobs Team
The Dataset
This report is focused on the 2016 activity of the Financial Services companies in the BountyJobs marketplace. From aggregate activity by employers to the geographic disbursement of jobs across the country, this section gives a picture of the data we used to curate this report.
Financial Services represents an industry as well as a job category with a variety of roles within different industry sub-categories. Because of this, we expanded how we normally look at data for vertical-specific reports to look at all of the roles that fall into Financial Services-related job categories.
In addition to sharing vertical-specific data, we’ve interjected some general market data for comparison. That way, you can see how your agency recruitment metrics stack up against those of other Financial Services companies, as well as the market as a whole. You’ll see that this industry tends to differ from the general market. This is useful information if you’re recruiting candidates from other industries—or if you’re new to recruiting for Financial Services companies.
56%COMMERCIAL BANKING
Financial Services sub-industry with the highest number of job
postings in 2016.
INTERNAL AUDITORFinancial Services job category
with the highest number of job postings in 2016.
13%
03 THE DATASET: AT A GLANCE
Average # of jobs posted in 2016 by Financial Services Employers.
37 Jobs 118 Jobs
Average # of jobs posted in 2016 by our 10 most active
Financial Services employers.
Highest # of jobs posted by a single Financial
Services employer in 2016.
417 Jobs
JOB POSTINGS: PUBLIC v. PRIVATE
BOUNTYJOBS FINANCIAL SERVICES JOB ACTIVITY
Market
FinancialServices
How do our employers determine the visibility of their Financial Services jobs?
PUBLICPublic jobs are posted and visible to our marketplace
of 10K+ agencies
PRIVATEPrivate jobs are posted
privately, visible to vendors by invitation only
35%
65%70%
30%BountyJobs accommodates employers that want to manage their existing preferred vendors, as well as those who wish to connect to new agencies.
Financial Services companies use their preferred vendors nearly two-thirds of the time, while posting their roles to the marketplace one-third of the time.
04 THE DATASET: AT A GLANCE
BY THE CALENDARWhat time of year do Financial Services employers go to external search? How does that compare to the market in general?
Market FinancialServices
Financial Services companies have an atypical hiring pattern that spikes in the summer and declines sharply in December. While hiring slows for many organizations near the end of the year, the steeper decline in the Financial Services industry may be related to books closing at the end of Q4.
BY KEYWORDWhich words appear most in Financial Services job titles?
05 THE DATASET: AT A GLANCE
BY SENIORITY LEVEL What is the breakdown of Financial Services jobs sent to search by seniority level?
NON-MANAGERIAL
68% 16%
MANAGER
7%
DIRECTOR
9%
VP OR C-SUITE
BY GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTIONWhere are Financial Services jobs geographically located?
The majority of Financial Services jobs sent to search are non-managerial positions. Employers in this industry tend to look for highly specialized candidates for roles such as Auditors, Software Engineers, and Analysts.
31% of Financial Service jobs
posted in the BountyJobs Marketplace in 2016 were
located in Texas.
Texas had the biggest concentration of Financial Services jobs, in addition to the more traditional New York area and tech-heavy California.
HIGHEST CONCENTRATION
06 THE DATASET: AT A GLANCE
BY SUB-INDUSTRYWhat is the breakdown of Financial Services jobs by sub-industry?
BY JOB CATEGORYWhat is the breakdown of Financial Services jobs by job category?
56%
22%
22%
COMMERCIAL BANKING
MORTGAGE
OTHER• Securities• Credit Card Services• Investment Banking• Investment Management• General Financial Services
FINANCE & ACCOUNTING45% INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY34%
SALES & MARKETING
ENGINEERING LEGAL
12% 2.3% 1.4%
Salaries & Fees
Jobs in the Financial Services industry have largely been declining over recent years. Technology and consumer preference has been replacing the need for many types of positions. For example, the use of automatic teller machines (ATMs) and online banking has eliminated many bank teller jobs.
Despite these job cutbacks, competition for skilled talent is still high. The skill gap for more analytical and technical roles is likely what’s keeping average industry salaries higher than the rest of the job market.
It’s important to note that Financial Services industry salaries have not followed any sort of predictable pattern over the past seven years. Perhaps this industry is more affected by political events and corresponding fluctuations in the economy.
For instance, Brexit in 2016 caused a significant drop in the stock market and is said to be responsible for a decrease in job opportunities in the financial sector. It’s entirely possible that this event—and the anticipation of it—caused an ‘employer’s market’ rather than a ‘candidate’s market’ by increasing the available workforce, causing salaries to drop in 2016.
08 SALARIES & FEES: YEAR-OVER-YEAR TRENDS
Financial Services salaries have remained higher than market averages, but the gap became a little narrower in 2016. We also see that agency fees have hovered around 22 percent in recent years, but came down closer to 21 percent in 2016. While agency fees have historically been higher than market averages, they are now about equal.
YEAR-OVER-YEAR SALARY AVERAGES
MarketFinancialServices
YEAR-OVER-YEAR FEE AVERAGES
Adjusted for Inflation
SALARIES BY BANDWhat was the distribution of salaries for Financial Services jobs?
09 SALARIES: LAST 12 MONTHS
| >50K
5%
| $50K – $100K
33%
| $150K – $200K
11%
| $200K – $250K
1%
| >$250K
<1%
SALARIES BY SENIORITY LEVELWhat were salary averages for Financial Services jobs by seniority level?
• Sr. Auditor, Credit Risk• Lead Software
Engineer
$101,174Non-Managerial
• Technology Risk Manager
• Sr. Project Manager, Mortgage
$122,884Manager
• Director, Accounting Policy
• Managing Director, Wealth Markets
$170,560Director
• VP, Wealth Management
• Chief Credit Officer
$109,219VP or C-Suite
$109,862AVERAGE SALARY OFFERED $320,000
HIGHEST SALARY OFFERED
| $100K – $150K
49%
POSTING VOLUME BY FEE CLASSIFICATIONWhat was the distribution of jobs posted relative to fees? How does that compare to the market in general?
10 FEES: LAST 12 MONTHS
FEES BY SENIORITY LEVELWhat were fee averages for Financial Services jobs by seniority level?
22%Non-Managerial
22%Manager
22%Director
22%VP or C-Suite
DISCOUNT MARKET PREMIUMBelow 20% Between 20- 25% Over 25%
Financial Services
Market 12% 32%55%
8% 87% 5%
Placement fees for Financial Services roles generally fall within 20 to 25 percent of the candidate’s first year
salary, which is a significant difference from general market usage. Fees also rarely fall below 20 percent or exceed 25
percent for these roles.
Performance
Once you’ve determined salaries and fees, when can you reasonably expect to see resumes, interview candidates, and hire your new employee? Comparing your company’s data against industry benchmarks can be useful to help you measure your agency performance and identify areas for improvement. If, for instance, your first interviews take longer than the industry average, consider running an intake session to become better aligned with your agencies.
Keep in mind, however, that benchmarks are averages for jobs with wide ranging characteristics. There are a variety of factors that affect search activities and performance metrics. Some factors may be out of your control, such as a scarcity of talent in your area. Beyond that, every company’s hiring process is unique, and your performance metrics should reflect that.
12 PERFORMANCE
BOUNTYJOBS RECRUITMENT TIMELINE
FIRST AGENCY INTRODUCTION
Median amount of time it takes for an agency to
raise their hand to engage on a Financial
Services role.
FIRST AGENCY ENGAGEMENT
Average number of days until an approved
agency begins their search for a Financial
Services role.
FIRST RESUMES RECEIVED
Average number of days for an actively engaged
agency to begin submitting candidates for a Financial Services
role.
FIRST INTERVIEWS CONDUCTED
Average number of days to set up first interviews for a Financial Services
role.
3 days 7 days 27 days9 min
AGENCY PERFORMANCE STATISTICS
Average # of candidates submitted per Financial Services position
Average number of agencies invited on a private Financial Services position
14 Candidates
10 Agencies
8 Agencies
Average number of agencies invited on a public Financial Services position
How does agency performance and engagement compare from the
market to Financial Services?
Market Average: 2.5
Market Average: 8.7Market Average: 11.75
Financial Services roles typically command a higher number of agencies working on open roles. As well, the number of agencies directly invited to work on private roles far outnumbers the Market Average. This is due in part to the confidential nature of these roles.
13 PERFORMANCE: TIME TO FILL
TIME TO FILL
A variety of factors affect time to fill (TTF), including title, salary, seniority level, and scarcity of talent in a particular role. For example, time to fill increases by 15% for roles with C-suite, VP or Director in the job title, and 41% for roles with salaries of $150,000 or higher.
We’ve selected a sample of actual Financial Services jobs filled on BountyJobs in 2016.
PRINCIPAL QUANTITATIVE
ANALYST
Salary: $126KTTF: 64 Days
MANAGING DIRECTOR,
TRANSACTION BANKING
Salary: $300KTTF: 51 Days
MANAGING DIRECTOR,
INTERNAL AUDITS
Salary: $225KTTF: 113 Days
TRADE ANALYTICS MODEL
DEVELOPMENT LEAD
Salary: $158KTTF: 97 Days
DIRECTOR, APPLICATIONS
ANALYST
Salary: $190KTTF: 65 Days
VICE PRESIDENT, WEALTH
MANAGEMENT
Salary: $118KTTF: 40 Days
14 PERFORMANCE: BEST PRACTICES
BOUNTYJOBS FINANCIAL SERVICES RECOMMENDATIONS
Focus on Fees:
While most placement fees fall into the 21%-22% range, you can utilize premium fees to stand out to the best agencies for your critical, time-sensitive roles.
Create Strong Offers:
Average Financial Services salaries dropped last year, so you can attract the best talent to your organization with strong offers –including salary & benefits.
Reach New Talent Pools:
Use one tried-and-true specialist agency, one new agency, and one generalist agency on each search.
Consider Offering Relocation:
Many Financial Services employees may face job instability due to Brexit. Entice them with your opportunity by helping them relocate.
1 2
3 4
Financial Services is a highly competitive industry and specialized labor is in high demand. Below are 4 best practices to increase the effectiveness of employer/agency collaboration.
BOUNTYJOBS RETAINED SEARCH: All Your Direct-Hire Placements Under One Roof
BountyJobs takes the pain out of managing retained search engagements by allowing you to track and manage all your direct hire placements in one location. We’ve added retained-only features to keep those critical job searches moving smoothly - including automatic, milestone triggered progress.
Looking for more information about BountyJobs or the datacontained in our Marketplace? Please contact us via email [email protected] or phone at 212-660-3960.
BOUNTYJOBS HEADQUARTERS1114 Lost Creek Blvd, Suite 420
Austin, TX 78746
w w w . b o u n t y j o b s . c o m
CONTACT US: