Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

21
Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith Kaushal Shah August 5, 2008

Transcript of Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Page 1: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Financial SectorStock Presentation

Colin SmithKaushal Shah

August 5, 2008

Page 2: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Agenda

•Recap of Sector Presentation•Stock Recommendation / Portfolio

Weights•Bank of America•Merrill Lynch•Summary

Page 3: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Sector Recommendation

Underweight Financials by 50 basis points

•Sector highly correlated to the overall market

•High risks due to uncertainties – not all losses have been realized as yet

Page 4: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Sector Analysis•Current Financial Sector Weighting

(as of July 31, 2008)

SIM 12.93%S&P 500 15.34%------------------------------Underweight 2.41%

Overall: Bring the SIM Portfolio underweight by 291 basis points relative to the S&P

Page 5: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Current CompositionCompany Ticker Current Weight*

Bank of America BAC 3.31%

Berkshire Hathaway BRKA 3.51%

Goldman Sachs GS 4.44%

Merrill Lynch MER 1.67%

TOTAL 12.93%

* Weightings according to SIM-July Appraisal Report

Page 6: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

RecommendationCompany Current

WeightBuy / Sell Proposed

Weight

Bank of America 3.31% Sell – 1.81% 1.50%

Berkshire Hathaway

3.51% Hold 3.51%

Goldman Sachs 4.44% Hold 4.44%

Merrill Lynch 1.67% Buy – 1.31% 2.98%

TOTAL 12.93% 12.43%

Page 7: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Target PricesCompany Target

PriceCurrent Price*

Upside

Bank of America (BAC) 31.44 32.62 -3.62%

Berkshire Hathaway (BRKA)

113,667.00 114,500.00 -0.73%

Goldman Sachs (GS) 205.25 177.86 15.40%

Merrill Lynch (MER) 37.88 26.39 43.54%

*as of August 4, 2008

Page 8: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Bank of America (BAC): SELL•Current Weight: 3.31% •Current Price (as of close 8/4/08): $32.62•Target Price: $31.44•Downside: 3.62%•Proposed weight: 1.50%

Page 9: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Business Analysis - BAC•Founded 1874•Based in Charlotte, North Carolina•Market Capitalization : $145.26 Billion•CEO & Chairman: Kenneth D. Lewis• Industry : M0ney Center Banks•Principal Areas of Business:

▫Global Consumer and Small Business Banking

▫Global Corporate and Investment Banking▫Global Wealth and Investment Management

Page 10: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Positives - BAC•Large and diverse deposit base gives BAC

plenty of capital with which it can pursue investments

•Largest Consumer bank in U.S.•Brings diversity to SIM Financial portfolio•Top performing stock in July appraisal

report▫$206,787 gain

Page 11: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Negatives - BAC• 2nd Quarter Net Income: $3.41B

▫Down 41% y.o.y.• Exposure to irrelevant credit risk associated

with auto financiers▫Loans for leases and to dealerships▫GMAC, Chrysler Financial

• Poorly rated holdings▫Write-downs from CDOs in 08Q2: $645M▫S&P expects chargeoffs and write-downs to

continue throughout the rest of 2008• Countrywide acquisition poses a lot of risk

Page 12: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

P/B & P/E: Soon to Hit Low Points

Page 13: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Merrill Lynch (MER): BUY•Current Weight: 1.67% •Current Price (as of close 8/4/08): $26.39•Target Price: $37.88•Upside: 43.54%•Proposed weight: 2.98%

Page 14: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Year to Date

Page 15: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Business Analysis•Founded 1914•Market Capitalization : $26.5 Billion•Industry : Investment Brokerage•Principal Areas of Business :

▫Global Markets and Investment Banking 3rd Largest Investment Bank

▫Global Wealth Management Largest in the world

Page 16: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Positives•Wealth Management remains a cash cow•Has been able to raise substantial capital

despite write-downs/losses•Recently shed off $30 billion in CDO’s at

22 cents on the dollar•CEO Thain is putting his money where his

mouth is : Buys 500,000 shares for over $11 million

Page 17: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Price/Book : Ten Year Low

Page 18: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Valuation remains positive

  High Low MeanCurren

t

Target Multipl

e

 Target B,EBITDA/Share

Target Price

Price / Book 4 0.8 2.1 0.8 2.1  35.36 $74.26 Price /

EBITDA 4.7 0.3 2 0.3  2 54.49

$108.97 DCF Model           $40.38

Analyst Target           $37.88

Page 19: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Negatives•4 straight quarterly losses

▫Write downs exceeding $40 billion▫Still has $9 billion in asset backed

securities•Significant recent dilution of shares•Still tied to risk on sale of CDO’s

▫As much as another $4.5 billion•Will core assets remain safe?

▫50% stake in Blackrock

Page 20: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Recommendation•Decrease sector weight 50 bps•Stock Recommendation

▫Sell: Bank Of America (BAC) – 181 bps

▫Buy: Merrill Lynch (MER) – 131 bps

Page 21: Financial Sector Stock Presentation Colin Smith

Thank You

Questions ??