Final Project Dissertation - Copy
-
Upload
dateme-abam -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of Final Project Dissertation - Copy
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 1/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pagei of 54
Declaration
I hereby certify that this work is my own, except where otherwise acknowledged, and that it has
not been submitted previously for a degree at this, or any other university.
Name: Dateme Ibifubara Abam
Signature:
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 2/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pageii of 54
Acknowledgements
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to the Almighty God for life, and for the privilege he
has given me to complete this program successfully. I also express my profound appreciation to
my supervisor Dr. Mohammed Rouainia for his time, guidance, experience and knowledge
throughout this work. I¶m also thankful to Stylianos Panayides for his time, patience,
encouragement, and continual support from the start right up to the very end of this project.
My deepest appreciation is directed to my employer, Engr Mayne David-West and his associate
partner Nathaniel Frank Iboroma for funding my studies and their sacrifice towards my progress
as an Engineer. I also thank my uncle Dr T.K.S Abam, and my tutors Colin Davie, Jean Hall, and
Gaetano Elia for helping me as well in my progress as a geotechnical engineer. Finally, I will
always be indebted to my parents Sir Prof & Dame Dr (Mrs) D.P.S Abam, for their sacrifices
throughout my life. I am where I am today because of you all. Thank you so much.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 3/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pageiii of 54
Abstract
Structures built on soft clay materials over the years have been a major challenge in the
construction industry. Natural soft clays tend to have significant anisotropy of fabric
generated by plastic straining during laboratory tests. Anisotropy can influence plastic
behaviour for soft clays. A Kinematic Hardening Soil Model which accounts for structure
anisotropy and destructuration effects is implemented in the 3D commercial finite element
package PLAXIS to study the behaviour of an embankment founded on soft structured clay.
The Teven Road trial embankment constructed in Eastern Australia which was founded on
a soft soil deposit has been used as a case study in this project. Coupled analysis of excess
pore pressure dissipation and displacements have been done to study the embankment
behaviour. Long term settlement and excess pore pressure predicted from the finite
element analysis have been compared with measured data from the site. Parametric studies
have also been performed on the initial degree of structure, permeability anisotropy,
interpolation exponent, destructuration parameter to understand how they affect the model
prediction using coupled analysis.
K eywords: Anisotropy, constitutive model, embankment, initial structure, pore pressure,
settlement
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 4/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pageiv of 54
NOTATION
parameter controlling relative proportions of distortional and volumetric destructuration
stiffness interpolation parameter
Youngs Modulus
parameter controlling rate of loss of structure with damage strain
critical state stress ratio
mean effective stress
ratio of sizes of bubble and reference surface
parameter describing ratio of sizes of structure and reference surfaces
initial value of r
slope of swelling line in ln : ln p compression line
slope of normal compression line in ln : ln p compression plane
poisson¶s ratio
stiffness interpolation exponent
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 5/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pagev of 54
Table of Contents
Declaration ................................................................................................................................. i
Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................ii
Abstract .................................................................................................................................. iii
NOTATION ............................................................................................................................. iv
List of Figures ......................................................................................................................... vii
List of Tables............................................................................................................................. x
1. Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Background .................................................................................................................. 1
1.2 Project Aim .................................................................................................................. 3
1.3 Project Objectives ......................................................................................................... 3
1.4 Project Layout .............................................................................................................. 3
2. Literature Review ................................................................................................................ 5
3. Methodology ..................................................................................................................... 11
3.1 Teven Road Trial Embankment................................................................................... 11
3.2 Material parameters .................................................................................................... 12
3.3 3D Model ................................................................................................................... 14
3.4 Boundary Conditions and Model Assumptions ............................................................ 16
3.5 Calculations ................................................................................................................ 17
4. Parametric Study................................................................................................................ 18
4.1 Analysis of Embankment Behaviour on Soft Structured Clay ...................................... 18
4.2 Effect of Initial structure on the Finite Element Analysis prediction of Embankment
Behaviour .............................................................................................................................. 26
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 6/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pagevi of 54
4.3 Effect of Permeability Anisotropy on the Finite Element Analysis prediction of
Embankment Behaviour ........................................................................................................ 29
4.4 Effect of the Stiffness Interpolation Exponent on the Finite Element Analysis
Prediction of Embankment Behaviour ................................................................................... 31
4.5 Effect of the Destructuration Parameter (k) on the Finite Element Analysis Prediction of
Embankment Behaviour ........................................................................................................ 34
5. Conclusion ......................................................................................................................... 37
References ................................................................................................................................ 39
Appendix
Table A 1 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-1 .................... 42
Table A 2 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-2..................... 42
Table A 3 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC3-3..................... 42
Table A 4 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-4..................... 42
Table A 5 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point A ................. 42
Table A 6 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point B ................. 43
Table A 7 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point C ................. 43
Table A 8 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point D ................. 43
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 7/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pagevii of 54
List of Figures
Figure 1.1. Model for destructuration of clays: (a) Cam-clay model: (b) bubble (yield surface)
and outer surface in bubble model; (c) reference surface, structure surface and bubble (yield
surface) for destructuration model; (d) deviatoric section through bubble and structure surface for destructuration model. This diagram has been reproduced from Fig 1. (D. Muir Wood 2000)..... 2
Figure 1.2. Project outline ........................................................................................................... 4
Figure 2.1. Finite element mesh and soil profile for the trial embankment (M.Rouainia 2005)..... 6
Figure 2.2 Longitudinal and cross sections of the Haarajoki test embankment. Cross section
35840, where no vertical drains were applied, is analysed. (Marcin Cudny 2003) ....................... 7
Figure 2.3. Finite element discretisation of the boundary problem. (Marcin Cudny 2003) ........... 7
Figure 2.4. Plan View of Trial Embankment Design. (N.Sivakugan 2005) .................................. 8
Figure 2.5. Construction History of Trial Embankment.(N.Sivakugan 2005) ............................... 9
Figure 2.6. Location of instrumentation below trial embankment (N.Sivakugan 2005) ................ 9
Figure 3.1. Soil strata beneath a section across Teven Road trial embankment .......................... 11
Figure 3.2. Construction sequence of the Teven Road embankment .......................................... 12
Figure 3.3. Plan view of the Teven road embankment on soft soil deposit. ................................ 15
Figure 3.4. 2D plan view mesh of Teven road trial embankment on the soft soil deposit ........... 15
Figure 3.5. 3D mesh of Teven road trial embankment on the soft soil deposit ........................... 16
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 8/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pageviii of 54
Figure 4.1. 3D representation of the deformed mesh of the trial embankment at the end of
consolidation period .................................................................................................................. 20
Figure 4.2. Excess pore pressure in the soil depost at end of each phase ................................... 21
Figure 4.3 Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressures at PC2-1,
PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data........................................................................... 22
Figure 4.4 Vertical displacements of the ground surface beneath the embankment at end of each
phase ........................................................................................................................................ 23
Figure 4.5. Horizontal displacements of the ground surface beneath the embankment at the end
of each face ............................................................................................................................... 24
Figure 4.6. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlements at points A, B, C
and D with measured data ......................................................................................................... 25
Figure 4.7. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure dissipation
at PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different degrees of initial structure
................................................................................................................................................. 27
Figure 4.8. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlements at Points A, B, C
and D with measured data for different degrees of initial structure ............................................ 28
Figure 4.9. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure dissipation
at PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different degrees of permeability
anisotropy. ................................................................................................................................ 29
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 9/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Pageix of 54
Figure 4.10. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C
and D with measured data for different degrees of permeability anisotropy ............................... 30
Figure 4.11. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure
dissipation at PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different values of . . 32
Figure 4.12. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C
and D with measured data for different values of .................................................................. 33
Figure 4.13 Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C
and D with measured data for different values of destructuration parameter k ........................... 35
Figure 4.14. Comparison of FE prediction for settlement at points A, B, C and D with measured
data for different values of destructuration parameter k ............................................................. 36
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 10/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page x of 54
List of Tables
Table 3.1 Estimated Values used in the numerical analysis ....................................................... 13
Table 3.2 Coordinates for the boreholes shown in plan view of Teven road embankment .......... 14
Table 3.3 Summary of phase calculations .................................................................................. 17
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 11/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page1 of 54
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
Numerical simulations by means of the Finite Element Method have become a valuable
tool in geotechnical engineering to predict and to understand the behaviour of complex structures
and extensive research has been recently carried out in this area (Yildiz 2009). Embankments
and other construction works built on soft soil deposits have posed difficulties in
geotechnical design over the years. The behaviour of stress±strain for soft soils is very
complex as the soil response to loading the foundation is influenced by different basic
characteristics of natural soil behaviour which include creep, anisotropy and
destructuration (M. Karstunen 2006).
Low strength of the soft soil deposits limits the embankment height that may be
constructed on it with adequate safety for short term stability, and low permeability determines
large settlements that develop slowly as excess pore pressure dissipates in the soft deposit. Thus,
stability and time required for consolidation of the soft soil deposit are major considerations in
the design and construction of embankments over soft cohesive foundations (Yildiz 2009).
This project presents a numerical analysis of the ³Teven Road trial embankment´, whichwill be used as a case study in studying the behaviour of an embankment on soft clay deposit, by
comparing the excess pore pressures and settlements predicted from finite element analysis based
on laboratory results with field monitoring data from the instrumented embankment.
The Kinematic Hardening Structure Model (KHSM) developed by (Rouainia and D. Muir
Wood 2000) and implemented in the 3D commercial finite element package PLAXIS has been
used to model all the layers in the soil deposit. The KHSM is an extension of the well established
Modified Cam-Clay (MCC) model. Natural soft clays tend to have significant anisotropy of
fabric, developed during deposition and one-dimensional consolidation. During plastic
straining, as a result of the re-orientation of particles, the fabric anisotropy can change and
this inÀuences both elastic and plast ic behaviour of the material. The KHSM thus adds some
initial structure to the soft material which is lost progressively during plastic straining. The
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 12/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page2 of 54
KHSM introduces three surfaces which are the bubble surface, the structure surface and the
reference surface into the MCC model. The bubble surface moves with the current stress and
separates regions of elastic and plastic response. The structure surface stores the data about the
current anisotropy and magnitude of structure and acts as a bounding surface. This then reduces
to the reference surface as plastic straining occurs. The reference surface represents the
behaviour of the reconstituted material. All three surfaces change in size as plastic straining
occurs (D. Muir Wood 2000). Figure 1.1 shows the KHSM model for destructuration of clays.
Figure 1.1. Model for destructuration of clays: (a) Cam-clay model: (b) bubble (yield surface) and outer
surface in bubble model; (c) reference surface, structure surface and bubble (yield surface) for
destructuration model; (d) deviatoric section through bubble and structure surface for destructuration
model. This diagram has been reproduced from Fig 1. (Rouainia and D. Muir Wood 2000).
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 13/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page3 of 54
1.2 Project Aim
The aim of this project is to simulate the performance of a fully instrumented trial
highway embankment on thick soft clay deposit.
1.3 Project Ob jectives
In other to achieve the aim, the following objectives have been outlined for the project.
(i) Obtain material parameters to be used in the numerical analysis
(ii) Create a 3D finite element model of the embankment
(iii) Simulate the embankment construction on the soft soil deposit using the KHSM
constitutive model which accounts for anisotropy and destructuration effects in
finite element (FE) analysis.
(iv) Compare the settlements and excess pore pressures predicted from the FE analysis
and compare it with measured data obtained from the site.
1.4 Project Layout
This project consists of four chapters described in very brief terms below. A diagram of
the relationship between the chapters is shown in Figure 1.2. Project outline Chapter 1 gives a
background of the basic concepts, aim and objective of this project. Chapter 2 discusses related
work on this study. In Chapter 3, the geometry of the embankment and underlying soft soil
deposit is described. Following this is the soil parameters used in the numerical analysis for each
material in the soil strata of the deposit. Sequel to it is the layout and 3D model of the
embankment on the soil deposit. The boundary conditions used in the numerical analysis will
then be described, and finally the phase calculations following the construction sequence of the
embankment on site will be outlined. In Chapter 4, the embankment behaviour is analysed using
a coupled analysis of deformation and pore pressure dissipation. Parametric studies will be
conducted on the model to study the effect of effect of structure anisotropy, permeability
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 14/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page4 of 54
anisotropy, interpolation stiffness exponent, and destructuration parameter on the model
prediction of the embankment behaviour.
In Chapter 5 the conclusions drawn from the embankment behaviour, and parametric study will
be made.
Figure 1.2. Project outline
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 15/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page5 of 54
2. Literature Review
In an earlier study, (M.Rouainia 2005) investigated the influence of structure degradation
on the behaviour of embankments on soft soil. Using the fully instrumented trial embankments
which had been constructed on estuarine clay deposits on the Pacific Highway along the east
coast of Australia, the Kinematic Hardening Structure Model (KHSM) proposed by (D. Muir
Wood 2000) which is proficient in addressing the initial structure and destructuration process in
soft clays was implored to validate the settlement of the embankment by the finite element
method. The parameters which were used in the KHSM were calculated from a set of field and
laboratory data from soft soils in that region and in other to predict the consolidation behaviour
of the soft deposit, coupled analysis of excess pore pressure and displacements was used in the
finite element implementation. The left and right boundaries of the finite element mesh that was
used to describe the soils below the embankment shown in Figure 2.1 were restrained in the
horizontal directions, the bottom boundary was set to be undrained and the top boundary was set
to be free drained to zero pore pressure. As the embankment is symmetric, just half of the
embankment was simulated in the model and allowed to consolidate for 100,000 days. The
settlements at the ground surface as well as the excess pore pressures beneath the embankment
along some reference points were compared with the field measured data to access the level of
accuracy of the finite element model.
From the results, the displacements predicted by the finite element analysis using the
KHSM were very good in the overall. However, the excess pore pressures were under predicted
as a result of variable boundary in-situ conditions. It was concluded that since in soft clay
materials, the excess pore pressures and settlements are connected, using models that account for
destructuration processes were necessary to correctly study geotechnical problems with related
materials (M.Rouainia 2005).
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 16/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page6 of 54
Figure 2.1. Finite element mesh and soil profile for the trial embankment (M.Rouainia 2005)
(Marcin Cudny 2003) investigated the possibilities of a multi-laminate constitutive model
which accounts for structural anisotropy and destructuration effects with the 2D finite element
code Plaxis to simulate the behaviour of a test road embankment constructed on soft soil deposits
at Haarajoki, Finland. A spatially distributed anisotropic overconsolidation was introduced in the
multi-laminate model which combines the strength anisotropy with the characteristic mechanical
process of destructuration. The longitudinal and cross sections of the Haarajoki test embankment
are shown in Figure 2.2. The construction of the embankment was completed within 3 weeks
and was done in multi-stages of 0.5 m using a gravel fill. Excess pore pressures of about 3 to 10
kPa were measured in the deposit before the construction began. The part of the embankment
without ground improvement (cross section 35840) was analysed in the study.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 17/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page7 of 54
Figure 2.2 Longitudinal and cross sections of the Haarajoki test embankment. Cross section 35840,
where no vertical drains were applied, is analysed. (Marcin Cudny 2003)
Material parameters for the main soft soil were estimated from available laboratory test
results and previous parameter sets with only the initial values of state variables which represent
bonding and overconsolidation varying with depth. Phase calculations which followed the
construction sequence of 0.5m high multi stages for the embankment were set to consolidate for
a total period of 1920 days were computed as fully coupled static/consolidation analysis. The
finite element discretisation of the boundary problem is shown in Figure 2.3.
Figure 2.3. Finite element discretisation of the boundary problem. (Marcin Cudny 2003)
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 18/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page8 of 54
Measured and calculated vertical displacements were compared at the centre line and at
the points located 4 and 9 m from the centre line. Horizontal displacements were compared along
the vertical profile located 9 m from the centre line. From the results, the horizontal settlements
were overestimated but the vertical displacements were good. Considering an assumed simplicity
of the initial field conditions and use of average material parameters for the deep soft soil
deposit, the final accuracy of the simulations was deemed acceptable.
(N.Sivakugan 2005) presented a case history of a trial embankment that was built on soft,
organic clay in the Sunshine Coast Motorway in South East Queensland, Australia. An
assessment of the efficiency of vertical drains to reduce the time of consolidation of the clay
deposit was done by studying the settlements and pore pressure below the trial embankment on
the soft deposit with the installed vertical drains. The trial embankment constructed had
approximately 40m width and 90m length and was studied in three parts A, B and C (see Figure
2.4). Part B had no prefabricated vertical drains, while part A had prefabricated vertical drains
with triangular grid patterns spaced at 1m, and part C at 2m.
Figure 2.4. Plan View of Trial Embankment Design. (N.Sivakugan 2005)
The embankment fill was a granular material which was placed in stages with the
construction sequence shown in Figure 2.5. The left side of the embankment was instrumented
with the locations shown in Figure 2.6 to obtain relevant data.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 19/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page9 of 54
Figure 2.5. Construction History of Trial Embankment.(N.Sivakugan 2005)
Figure 2.6. Location of instrumentation below trial embankment (N.Sivakugan 2005)
The numerical analysis was performed using the finite difference program, FLAC, and
settlements predicted on the basis of a fully coupled Biot consolidation model. The bottom
boundary was considered to be rigid as the sand layer below the clay deposit was dense so that
any settlements connected with it could be ignored, while the lateral boundaries of the finite
difference mesh were positioned at 150 m from the centre of the embankment, and fixed in the
horizontal direction to minimize the effect. Both the top and bottom surfaces of the clay were
assumed as free draining, and the water table at the ground surface.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 20/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page10 of 54
From the results obtained in the numerical analysis, the settlements and pore pressures
compared well with the field measured data. Furthermore, it was observed that the horizontal and
vertical permeability values on each of the models from field measurements were smaller than
those obtained from the laboratory testing.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 21/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page11 of 54
3. Methodology
3.1 Teven Road Trial Embankment
The Teven Road trial embankment on the soft soil deposit which will be used as a case
study in this project is shown in Figure 3.1 The base of the trial embankment has a 54m width
and 84m length with a total height of 1.6m reached over a period of 69 days following a
construction sequence shown in Figure 3.2. The soil strata consist of four layers. The first is a
2m thick crust clay slightly sandy layer which is unsaturated and overconsolidated. Following
this layer is a soft estuarine clay layer about 8m thick. The third layer which is 2m thick is a
dense sand layer which is fine to medium grained and the last layer is a firm to stiff clay layer
which is 19m thick. The water level was measured as 1m below ground level. Locations of
settlement plates and piezometers are also shown in Figure 3.1.
Figure 3.1. Soil strata beneath a section across Teven Road trial embankment
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 22/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page12 of 54
Figure 3.2. Construction sequence of the Teven Road embankment
3.2 Material parameters
The model parameters for the finite element analysis have been obtained from a previous
study (Allman) which was determined from a set of field and laboratory data from soft soils in a
nearby site and listed in Tabl e 3.1. In this study, only the soft estuarine clay layer has been
modelled using the structure model in the KHSM. All other layers in the soil deposit have been
modelled with the bubble model, while the embankment is modelled with the Mohr-coulomb
model.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 23/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page13 of 54
Table 3.1 Estimated Values used in the numerical analysis
Table 3.1 cont. Estimated Values used in the numerical analysis
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 24/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page14 of 54
3.3 3D Model
The 3D model of the trial embankment on the soft soil deposit was built in such a way
that simulating the staged construction sequence of the trial embankment on site shown in
Figure 1.1 could be achieved. This was done by creating a plan view of the embankmentconstructed in stages, and inserting boreholes at the vertices to describe the soil profile
and depths as shown in Tabl e 3.1. Figure 1.1 shows the plan view of the embankment on
the deposit. The coordinates for the outer boundaries and embankment are shown in
Tabl e 3.2
Table 3.2 Coordinates for the boreholes shown in plan view of Teven road embankment
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 25/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page15 of 54
Figure 3.3. Plan view of the Teven road embankment on soft soil deposit.
Figure 3.4. 2D plan view mesh of Teven road trial embankment on the soft soil deposit
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 26/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page16 of 54
Figure 3.5. 3D mesh of Teven road trial embankment on the soft soil deposit
3.4 Boundary Conditions and Model Assumptions
The boundary conditions for the problem were such that pore water was allowed to move
across the left and right boundaries in other not to affect horizontal flow conditions, and the
displacements were fixed. The bottom boundary is set to undrained with zero displacement. At
the ground surface, displacements were not restricted and free drainage conditions applied.
Boundary effects were controlled by choosing an area such that significant influence on the
results will be avoided. The global coarseness of the mesh size for the model was set to medium
for the horizontal element distribution, and fine in the vertical element distribution in other to
ensure reasonably accurate results as computing problems hindered the use of a fine mesh
entirely. Total number of elements was 10,160. Figure 3.4 and Figure 3.5 show the 2D and 3D
mesh of the Teven road embankment on the soft soil deposit.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 27/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page17 of 54
3.5 Calculations
The calculations consisted of seven phases which was done in accordance with the
construction sequence on site earlier discussed. The entire height of 1.6m of embankment was
raised in stages, and allowed to consolidate in between stages.Tabl
e 3.3 shows a summary of the phase calculations, procedure, and phase time completion. The total consolidation time was
100,000days.
Table 3.3 Summary of phase calculations
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 28/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page18 of 54
4. Parametric Study
Coupled analysis of the dissipation of pore pressure and the displacement of the ground
surface beneath the embankment has been adopted in the finite element (FE) analysis to predict
the consolidation behaviour. Excess pore pressure ± time plots obtained from the FE analysis
were done at points PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 to analyse the dissipation of the excess
pore pressures in the soil deposit and compared with measured data. PC2-1, PC2-2 and PC2-4
are located at 3m, 5m, and 10m deep respectively from the centre of the embankment on the
ground surface, while PC3-3 is 7m deep, 15m away from the centre of the embankment as can be
seen in Chapter 3, Figure 3.1. Similarly, settlement-time plots obtained from the FE analysis
were done at points A (centre of the embankment), B (15m from the centre of the embankment),
C (toe of the embankment) and D (7m from the toe of the embankment) to study embankment
behaviour and compare the displacements of the ground level under the embankment with
measured data. These can be seen in Chapter 3, Figure 3.1.
Parametric studies have been carried out on the KHSM to understand the model
prediction of the embankment behaviour using the coupled analysis. The effect of initial degree
of structure, permeability anisotropy , destructuration parameter , and stiffness
interpolation exponent on the FE analysis prediction have been investigated and also
compared with measured data from the field.
4.1 Analysis of Embankment Behaviour on Soft Structured Clay
The 3D deformed mesh from the model prediction at the end of the phase calculations
following the construction sequence is shown in Figure 4.1 The dissipation of excess pore
pressures in the soil deposit is shown at the end of each phase in Figure 4.2 while the excess pore
pressure predicted from FE analysis are shown in appendix, Tabl e A 1± Tabl e A 4. The excess
pore pressure ± time plots from the FE analysis are compared with measured data and shown in
Figure 4.3. The measured data which was compared with the FE analysis prediction have been
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 29/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page19 of 54
obtained from a previous study by (Sheng 2006, et al ) using win-dig software and are shown in
appendix Tabl e A 9
As can be seen from Figure 4.2, the dissipation of the excess pore pressure begins and
continues at the end of each phase as the embankment is constructed. The pore pressuredissipation increases at end of each loading stage and hits its peak value at the end of
construction (phase 5). At the end of the consolidation period (phase 6), the pore pressure in the
soil deposit is completely dissipated. As can be seen from Figure 4.3, the FE analysis generally
over predicts the pore pressure dissipation apart from the FE analysis prediction at PC2-2,
although the general behaviour of the pore pressure is some-what same as that of the measured
data. This could be as a result of highly variable boundary conditions in situ. Again we notice
that a sharp peak value occurs in PC2-1, but smooth peak values in PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4.
This can partly be attributed to the value of initial degree of structure, used in the modelling
the soft clay layer. The destructuration parameter could also be another factor as low values of
slows down the rate at which structure is lost with continuing strain and hence smoothens the
peak value (Rouainia and D. Muir Wood 2000).
The vertical and lateral displacements of the ground surface predicted from FE analysis
are shown at the end of each phase in Figure 4.4 and Figure 4.5. The vertical displacements
predicted from FE analysis are shown in appendix, Tabl e A 5± Tabl e A 8 while the settlement ±
time curves from the FE analysis are compared with measured data and shown in Figure 4.6.
As can be seen from Figure 4.5, the FE analysis predicts maximum horizontal
displacements of about 91mm either side of the embankment at the end of the consolidation
period. Also notice the potential failure surfaces developed on either side of the embankment in
Figure 4.5(f). As can be seen from Figure 4.6 the FE analysis predicts about 445mm maximum
vertical displacement of the ground surface beneath the embankment occurring at the centre of
the embankment (point A) which reduces as the distance moves away from the centre. The FE
analysis also predicts heaving of the ground surface of about 12.7mm at point D. In general, the
displacements predicted from the FE analysis compares very well with the measured data
although the model accuracy reduces as we move away from the embankment.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 30/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page20 of 54
Figure 4.1. 3D representation of the deformed mesh of the trial embankment at the end of
consolidation period
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 31/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page21 of 54
Figure 4.2. Excess pore pressure in the soil depost at end of each phase
(a) end of phase 1, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(b) end of phase 2, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(c) end of phase 3, height of embankment = 1.0m, ,
(d) end of phase 4, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(e) end of phase 5, height of embankment = 1.6m, ,
(f) end of phase 6, height of embankment = 1.6m,
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 32/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page22 of 54
Figure 4.3 Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressures at PC2-1, PC2-
2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 33/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page23 of 54
Figure 4.4 Vertical displacements of the ground surface beneath the embankment at end of each phase
(a) end of phase 1, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(b) end of phase 2, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(c) end of phase 3, height of embankment = 1.0m, ,
(d) end of phase 4, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(e) end of phase 5, height of embankment = 1.6m,
,
(f) end of phase 6, height of embankment = 1.6m,
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 34/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page24 of 54
Figure 4.5. Horizontal displacements of the ground surface beneath the embankment at the end of
each face
(a) end of phase 1, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(b) end of phase 2, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(c) end of phase 3, height of embankment = 1.0m, ,
(d) end of phase 4, height of embankment = 0.5m, ,
(e) end of phase 5, height of embankment = 1.6m, ,
(f) end of phase 6, height of embankment = 1.6m,
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 35/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page25 of 54
Figure 4.6. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlements at points A, B, C and D
with measured data
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 36/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page26 of 54
4.2 Effect of Initial structure on the Finite Element Analysis prediction of Embankment
Behaviour
The effect on the prediction of the soil behaviour using FE analysis due to the amount of
structure in the KHSM was investigated. The initial structure in the soft estuarine clay layer
(layer 2) which is modelled with the structure model in the KHSM is initially removed .
Subsequently, the amount of structure in the layer is gradually increased for values of
The FE prediction of the dissipation of excess pore pressure and deformation in the
soil deposit is analysed and compared for all assumed values of as well as measured data.
These are shown in Figure 4.7 and Figure 4.8 (Data obtained from FE analysis have been put in a
CD attached to this project.)
As can be seen from Figure 4.7 and Figure 4.8 we observe that when the initial structure
is non-existent , the FE analysis greatly over predicts the excess pore pressure and
displacements beneath the embankment. However as the initial degree of structure increases, the
FE analysis prediction of the displacements and dissipation of excess pore pressure improve, and
then converge at . Further increase in the initial degree of structure gives virtually the
same FE analysis prediction at this stage. We can thus conclude that the structure surface in the
KHSM is quite large at , and thus cannot degrade significantly. Hence further increase in
the initial degree of structure will not produce different results. Furthermore, the FE analysis
prediction of vertical displacements compares well with the measured data for an initial degree
of structure,
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 37/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page27 of 54
Figure 4.7. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure dissipation at
PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different degrees of initial structure
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 38/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page28 of 54
Figure 4.8. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlements at Points A, B, C and D
with measured data for different degrees of initial structure
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 39/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page29 of 54
4.3 Effect of Permeability Anisotropy on the Finite Element Analysis prediction of
Embankment Behaviour
The effect of the permeability anisotropy on the FE analysis prediction of soft soil
behaviour under the trial embankment was investigated as its importance in the pore pressure
estimation and rate of post settlements cannot be over-emphasized. The permeability anisotropy
ratios in all the layers were varied using values of respectively. The
results shown in Figure 4.9 and Figure 4.10 display how the measured data from the field
compare with the predictions from FE analysis of the excess pore pressures and displacements of
the ground surface. (Data obtained from FE analysis have been put in a CD attached to this
project).
Figure 4.9. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure dissipation at
PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different degrees of permeability anisotropy.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 40/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page30 of 54
Figure 4.10. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C and D
with measured data for different degrees of permeability anisotropy
As can be seen from Figure 4.9 at PC2-2, we observe that as increases, the peak
values of pore pressure predicted from the FE analysis do not change much although complete
dissipation in the soil deposit is achieved at different times. This can be easily understood as a
more permeable material will consolidate faster than the less permeable ones. At points PC3-3,
and PC 2-4, the peak values predicted from FE analysis increase as reduces. Furthermore,
the FE analysis over predicts the pore pressure at PC2-1, PC3-3, and PC2-4.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 41/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page31 of 54
In Figure 4.10 at points A and B, the plot shows that the settlements predicted from the FE
analysis compares well with the measured data on site for permeability anisotropy ratio of
.
4.4 Effect of the Stiffness Interpolation Exponent on the Finite Element Analysis
Prediction of Embankment Behaviour
The effect of the stiffness interpolation exponent parameter on the FE analysis prediction
of the soft soil behaviour beneath the trial embankment was investigated. Assumed values of
were used in all the layers while the values of the destructuration strain
parameter and stiffness interpolation parameter remained fixed. The results of the prediction from FE analysis for all assumed values of were compared with measured data and
are shown in Figure 4.11 and Figure 4.12. (Data obtained from FE analysis have been put in a
CD attached to this project).
In Figure 4.11, the differences in predicted peak values for all assumed values of the
interpolation exponent are small. It is also observed that while the FE analysis predicts a
smaller peak value of excess pore pressure for a low value of than for a high one, the higher
values of consolidate faster than the lower ones. For , FE analysis predicted a peak
value of at point PC3-3 after 133.5days, and after consolidating for 1000days,
while for , the predicted peak value from FE was after 133.5days, and
after 1000days. Again, the peak values of the excess pore pressure at PC3-3, and PC2-4
appears smoother than those at PC2-1, and PC2-2
In Figure 4.12 the settlements predicted from FE analysis are almost same for all values
of after construction, but begin to change slightly as the clay consolidates after 800 years at
Point A. After this period, as reduces the settlement increases. This can be can attributed to the
fact that as controls the way in which plastic stiffness falls as the bubble yield surface
approaches the structure surface and hence the rate at which plastic strains develop, reducing the
value of increases the plastic hardening modulus and hence reduces the plastic strains and
slows the destructuration process (Rouainia and D. Muir Wood 2000).
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 42/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page32 of 54
The FE analysis still over predicts the dissipation of excess pore pressure at all the points
except at PC2-2. As can be seen from Figure 4.12, the FE analysis compares well with measured
data at points A, and B for . Further increase in gives very little difference in the
settlements predicted from FE analysis.
Figure 4.11. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for excess pore pressure dissipation at
PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-3, and PC2-4 with measured data for different values of .
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 43/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page33 of 54
Figure 4.12. Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C and D
with measured data for different values of
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 44/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page34 of 54
4.5 Effect of the Destructuration Parameter (k ) on the Finite Element Analysis Prediction
of Embankment Behaviour
The effect of the destructuration parameter on the FE analysis prediction of the soft soil
behaviour beneath the embankment was investigated. The parameters and were
maintained in all the layers while assumed values of were used in soft
estuarine clay layer which is modelled with the structure model of the KHSM. The results of the
prediction from FE analysis for all assumed values of were compared with measured data and
are shown in Figure 4.13 and Figure 4.14. (Data obtained from FE analysis have been put in a
CD attached to this project).
As can be seen from both plots, we observe that as increases, the prediction from FE
analysis doesn¶t change. This can be attributed to the fact that since the calculation type used
which was earlier mentioned in Chapter 3 is consolidation rather than plastic, it is possible that
due to long periods of consolidation, plasticity is not achieved hence there is no loss of structure
in the material.
However, in the event that the value of the parameters and which control the rate at
which plastic strains develop were able to cause enough plastic strains in the structured layer for
destructuration to occur, it is expected that increase in will lead to rapid loss of structure in the
material (Rouainia and D. Muir Wood 2000). Thus the predicted peak values for pore pressure
dissipation from FE analysis may have increased with increasing values of
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 45/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page35 of 54
Figure 4.13 Comparison of Finite Element analysis prediction for settlement at points A, B, C and D
with measured data for different values of destructuration parameter k
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 46/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page36 of 54
Figure 4.14. Comparison of FE prediction for settlement at points A, B, C and D with measured data
for different values of destructuration parameter k
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 47/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page37 of 54
5. Conclusion
The construction of embankments on soft soil deposit is a major problem in geotechnical
engineering. Low permeability, low strength and high deformations are among the characteristics
displayed by natural soft soils which make construction on this material very difficult.
The Kinematic Hardening Soil Model (KHSM) developed by (Rouainia and D. Muir
Wood 2000) has been implemented in finite element analysis and used to study the behaviour on
a trial embankment on soft structured clay. Parametric studies were also conducted on the initial
degree of structure, permeability anisotropy ratio, interpolation exponent and destructuration
parameter in the KHSM model to understand how they affect the prediction from FE analysis of
the embankment behaviour. The results from the coupled analysis of excess pore pressure and
displacements of the ground surface gave the following conclusions
(1) The settlements predicted from FE analysis is generally in good agreement with the
measured data obtained from the field. However, the excess pore pressures are generally
overestimated. This has been attributed to variable in-situ conditions.
(2) The effect of the initial degree of structure is evident on the prediction from FE analysis
of the settlements of the ground surface as an increase in the degree of structure results in
a better prediction of the settlements from FE analysis which continues until the structure
surface becomes large enough and cannot degrade further. At this point, the settlements
predicted from FE analysis is in good agreement with measured data from the field.
(3) Permeability anisotropy ratio has an effect on the maximum values of pore pressure
dissipation predicted from FE analysis. An increase in the permeability anisotropy ratio
results in lower peak values of pore pressure dissipation predicted from FE analysis. In
this study, the settlements predicted from FE analysis compares well with measured data
from the field for a permeability anisotropy ratio of 2.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 48/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page38 of 54
(4) After long periods of consolidation, the stiffness interpolation exponent affects the
predicted settlements from FE analysis as an increase in results in a reduction of the
predicted settlement at ground surface beneath the centre of the embankment. This takes
place mainly at the centre of the embankment (point A).
(5) The destructuration parameter does not affect the prediction from FE analysis as the
calculation type used in this study is consolidation as against plastic strain. Hence due to
long periods of consolidation, plasticity is not reached so there is no loss of structure in
the material.
In the overall, we can conclude from this study that using constitutive models that
account for effects of initial structure and destructuration to analyse construction on natural soft
clays is important as they improve the prediction of the behaviour of the structure on the soft soil
deposit.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 49/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page39 of 54
References
Allman, D. S. a. M. A. "Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay."
Borges, J. L. (2004). "Three-dimensional analysis of embankments on soft soils incorporatingvertical drains by finite element method." Computers and Geotechnics 31(8): 665-676.
Cudny, M. and P. A. Vermeer (2004). "On the modelling of anisotropy and destructuration of
soft clays within the multi-laminate framework." Computers and Geotechnics 31(1): 1-22.
D. Muir Wood, M. R. (2000). "A kinematic hardening constitutive model for natural clays with
loss of structure." Geotechnique 50(2): 153-164.
Jin-Chun Chai, N. M., and Shui-Long Shen (2002). "Performance of embankments with and
without reinforcement on soft subsoil." Can. Geotech. J. 39: 838-848.
M. Karstunen, C. W., H. Krenn, F. Scharinger, H. F. Schweiger (2006). "Modelling the
behaviour of an embankment on soft clay with different constitutive models." InternationalJournal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics 30(10): 953-982.
M.Rouainia, D. S. J. Z. (2005). "Influence of sturcture degradation on the behaviour of embankments on soft soil." 13th ACME Conference: University of Sheffield.
Marcin Cudny, H. P. N. (2003). "Numerical analysis of a test embankment on soft ground usingan anisotropic model with destructuration." Int. Workshop on Geotechnics of Soft Soils - Theory
and practice, Schweiger, Karstunen & Cudny (eds.).
N.Sivakugan, B. R. (2005). "Observed and predicted behaviour of clay foundation responseunder the Sunshine Motorway trial embankment." International Conference on Soil Mechanics
and Geotechnical Engineering.
Shen, S.-L., J.-C. Chai, et al. (2005). "Analysis of field performance of embankments on softclay deposit with and without PVD-improvement." Geotextiles and Geomembranes 23(6): 463-
485.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 50/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page40 of 54
Sheng, W. H. S. F. D. B. D. S. a. D. (2006). "Finite-Element Parametric Study of theConsolidation Behaviour of a Trial Embankment on Soft clay " International Journal of
Geomechanics 6(5): 328-341.
Yildiz, A. (2009). "Numerical analyses of embankments on PVD improved soft clays."Advances in Engineering Software 40(10): 1047-1055.
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 51/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page41 of 54
APPENDIX
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 52/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page42 of 54
Table A 1 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-1
Table A 1 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-1
Table A 2 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-2
Table A 2 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-2
Table A 3 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC3-3
Table A 3 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC3-3
Table A 4 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-4
Table A 4 Cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Excess Pore Pressures at PC2-4
Table A 5 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point A
Table A 5 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point A
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 53/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
August 2011 Msc. Project Dissertation Page43 of 54
Table A 6 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point B
Table A 6 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point B
Table A 7 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point C
Table A 7 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point C
Table A 8 Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point D
Table A 8 cont. Predicted Values from FE Analysis of Vertical Displacements at Point D
Table A 9 Measured data from instrumentation on site of Excess pore pressure at PC2-1, PC2-2, PC3-
3, and PC2-4
Table A 10 Measured data from instrumentation on site of vertical displacements at Points A, B, C and
D
8/4/2019 Final Project Dissertation - Copy
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/final-project-dissertation-copy 54/54
Numerical Analysis of a Trial Embankment on Soft Clay
Table A 10 cont. Measured data from instrumentation on site of vertical displacements at
Points A, B, C and D