Final Presentation Satyam Scam
-
Upload
nitinabn28 -
Category
Documents
-
view
283 -
download
2
Transcript of Final Presentation Satyam Scam
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
1/21
Satyam Analysis...
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
2/21
Presented bySudhir Khare 28
Gulnaz Mahadik 31
Ritika Khare 32
Nitin Arvindakshan 36
Prashant Salvi 41
Nisha Singh 51
Geetanjali Ashok 20
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
3/21
Satyam Computer Services Ltd was founded in 1987 byB.Ramalinga Raju.
The company offers information technology (IT) servicesspanning various sectors, and is listed on NSE, BSE, theNew York Stock Exchange and Euronext.
Few milestones:
1987Incorporated as private limited company in 1987
1991
Recognized as a public limited company; debuts onthe Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE)
IPO oversubscribed by 17 times
1993
Satyam signs joint venture with Dun & Bradstreet for ITServices
Joint venture with GE announced
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
4/21
1999
Satyam Infoway (Sify) becomes the first IndianInternet company listed on NASDAQ
Satyam forms joint venture with TRW Inc.
Presence established in 30 countries
2007Becomes the Official IT Services Provider for the FIFAWorld Cups, 2010 (South Africa) and 2014 (Brazil)
Announces acquisition of UK-based Nitor GlobalSolutions Limited
Becomes the first Asian company to feature in theTraining Magazines list of Top 125 companies forlearning
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
5/21
Satyam Scandal.
Cooking books of accounts
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
6/21
Ramalinga Raju, chairman
None of the board members, past or present, had anyknowledge of the situation in which the company isplaced.
I INFLATED (non existent) cash and bank balance of Rs5,040 crore(as against Rs 5,361 crore) reflected in thebooks.
AN accrued interest of Rs 376 crore is non-existent.
I HAVE understated liability to the tune of Rs1,230 crorein accounts of funds arranged by me.
I HAVE over-stated debtors position of Rs 490 crore (asagainst Rs 2,651 crore reflected in the books.)
FORsept 2008, we reported Rs2,700 crore revenue andoperating margin of Rs 649 crore against actualrevenue of Rs2,112 crore and margin of Rs 61 crore.
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
7/21
Vadalamani Srinivas,CFO
I was asked specifically to not look into bank statement
AUDITORnever pointed out any deficiencies duringtheir discussions. Fixed deposits were unreal andfictitious which were managed with an understandingbetween the audit section and management.
BANK deposit were handled directly by Raju and the CFOwas specially asked for not to look into it
RAJU and his brother used to take decisions and tell usto do as instructed.
THE CFO admitted that the account were manipulated forabout seven years.
PRIORto quarterly board meetings, Ramakrishna,VP,finance,would prepare the balance sheet. I donot pay much attention to the details of that balancesheet.
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
8/21
Scenario I Forgery incThe scam team forged invoices to show collection
of revenue abroad, forged bank statement to show
inflow of money, showed transfer of money to fixed
deposits (FDs) through forged FD receipts and
reflected all this in the final accounts. The assetsand liabilities are altered Q2Q to reflect rising
income and rig share price.
CAVEAT This would require matching ofrevenue With staff strength and salary cost. Would
also require forging ofTDScertificates for incomefrom FDs.
POSSIBILITY High, as there is logic and objective.
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
9/21
Scenario II True Lies
Satyam did make money on export. Raju raised
invoices for export abroad; money did come through
the banking channels and was transferred to long
term FDs and reflected in the books. Once the FDs
were recorded in the books the deposits were
dissolved and money transferred to multiple
accounts. The books continued to reflect the FDs as
you dont need to surrendercertificate anymore.
Siphoned money was use to acquire land, property,
pay for political patronage for Maytas Infra and
Maytas properties.
CAVEAT This again require forging ofTDScertificates for accrued interest and connivance of
auditors.
POSSIBILITY Very high
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
10/21
Scenario III Hawala Inc
Raju receives political slush money abroad,
brings it as invoiced billings, shows it in his book
and transfers it to FDs to be dissolved latter.The
money transferred to multiple accounts is
siphoned to repatriate politicians money and forfunding the activities of Maytas.
CAVEAT Have to show staff strength tomatch revenues or ramp up operating margins.
Besides
co-opting auditors and forging
TDS
certificates.
POSSIBILITY Very very high, is in sync withwhispers of pressure to pay politicians and
patronage.
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
11/21
Balance sheet of Satyam computer ltd.
SOURCES OFSOURCES OF FUNDSFUNDS AS ONAS ON30.09.0830.09.08
ADJUSTEDADJUSTEDBALANCE SHEETBALANCE SHEET
ADJUSTMENTADJUSTMENTSS
1.1. Shareholders fundsShareholders fundsa. Share capitala. Share capital(share application(share applicationmoney , pending)money , pending)
b. Allotmentb. Allotment
c. Reserves andc. Reserves andsurplussurplus
134.70134.70
2.762.76
8392.238392.23
134.70134.70
2.762.76
((--)415.47)415.47
2. Loan Funds
a. secured loans
b. unsecured loans
____________________
30.49
234.80
______
8794.98
_______
30.49
1464.80
_______
1217.28
_______
1230.00
_______
1230.00
________
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
12/21
12
The Balance Sheet carries as ofSeptember, 30, 2008:
Inflated Cash and Bank balance of Rs. 5,040 Crores Accrued interest of Rs. 376 Crores which is non-existent Understated liability of Rs. 1,230 Crores Over stated debtors position ofRs. 490 crores
For the September Q2, reported a revenue of Rs. 2700 Crores and anoperating margin of Rs. 649 Crores as against the actual revenues of Rs.2,112 Crores and an actual operating margin of Rs.61 Crores ( 3%of revenues). This has resulted in artificial cash & bank balances goingup by Rs. 588 Crores in Q2 alone.
Immediate Market Reaction: Sensex stock index dropped 7.3% Satyam shares fell nearly 78%
Rajus Confession on 7th Jan09
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
13/21
13
Satyam Vs Enron Vs
Malpractices amounting worth USD 1.3 billion Masterminded by its founder-owner R Raju (CEO) and his brother SENSEX tanked 7.2 % when Raju announced of the fraud Government appointed new auditors KPMG and Deloitte Government guaranteed safety of jobs for all 53,000 employees
Accounting books were manipulated in conspiracy with its auditor ArthurAndersen NYSE tanked 0.9% when Enron filed for bankruptcy Government created Sarbanes Oxley Act US S.E.C. revoked CPA license of Arthur Andersen
Satyam
Enron
Scott Sullivan (CFO), David Myers and Buford Buddy Yates (Director ofGeneral Accounting) used fraudulent accounting methods to mask itsdeclining earnings Arthur Andersen withdrew its audit opinion for 2001 Government created Sarbanes Oxley Act
Worldco
m
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
14/21
APPLICATION OF FUNDS AS ON
30.09.08
ADJUSTED BALANCE
SHEET
ADJUSTMENT
S
1. Fixed assests
2. Investments
3. Tax
4. Current assests
a. sundry debtorsb. cash
c. accrued interest
d. Loans
LIABITIES
Net current assests
TOTAL APPLICATION OF FUNDS
1381.10
618.64
118.75
2651.365312.62
376.34
502.22
2166.05
6676.49
_______
8794.98
1381.10
618.64
118.75
490.00272.62
-
502.22
2166.05
901.21
_________
1217.28
1381.10
618.64
118.75
2161.365040
376.34
-
-
5775.21
(differenc
e)
________
7577.7
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
15/21
Where is the money???
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
16/21
1) If the company claims it has cash in its bank,auditors should checked whether the cash in bankwas available or not. Actual 321 Cr. Inflated5040 Cr.
2) Was the bank balance invested properly and-whereall was it invested MFs, Bonds, Securities etc.
3) Whether the internal control mechanisms are inplace internal audits, statuary compliance, riskmanagement.
4) Why did company have huge creditors and balanceat the same time.
?
Questions to the auditors
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
17/21
cont5) Look into why the company is not taking benefits
and negotiating the price.
6) Are the profit margin abnormal compare to industry
norms?
7) Check if there has been a quantum jump in wealth.
8) Carry out ratio analysis of the figures in the
organization, previous year & industry standards.
9) Undertake Physical verification of assets owned bythe company.
?
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
18/21
Deepak S. ParekhExecutive Chairman HDFC group
Kiran Karnikpresident of Nasscom
C. Achuthanformer presiding officer of the Securities AppellateTribunal
Tarun DasFormer president CII
T.N. Manoharan
S.B. Mainak
New board of director formation bycompany low board and Ministry ofcompany affaires
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
19/21
Spice group
Tech Mahindra
Hinduja group
L&T
GE
Bidders for Acquisition
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
20/21
Finally Satyam acquired by tech
mah
indra.
-
8/7/2019 Final Presentation Satyam Scam
21/21