FEDERAL JUDGE JENKINS DENIES MOTION TO DISMISS IN UTAH --BELL V COUNTRYWIDE et al RECONTRUST LACKS...

8/2/2019 FEDERAL JUDGE JENKINS DENIES MOTION TO DISMISS IN UTAH --BELL V COUNTRYWIDE et al RECONTRUST LACKS A

1/29

JCMOK

IMOWA- _.Y. KCY[WCI[ IF_W[Ndwie 4?- 7847 %7


2/29

{wuy{oo^ {f jfwoimfyo {ecy {wuy{ kook Xmdc`{cjjy dmyf wotuoy{ok modzo {f dno`k {eo ifnxmdc`{ {f7

y{d{o d iduyo fj di{cf` jfw xwfncyyfws oy{fxxom f` {eo mfd` nfkcjcid{cf` cyyuoy D{ {ed{ {cno-9

xmdc`{cjjy y{d{ok {ed{ dy {f {efyo {rf c{ony- rok mcao {eo Ifuw{y modzo {f jcmo d` dno`kok

ifnxmdc`{ d`k if`{cùo f` fuw rds [eo ifuw{ bwd`{ok modzo {f dno`k- fwkowc`b {ed{ xmdc {cjjy; ?

jcmo {eocw dno`kok ifnxmdc`{ gs Yox{ongow 4:- 7844:

Xmdc`{cjjy jcmok d` dno`kok ifnxmdc`{ f` Yox{ongow 4?- 7844- recie dyyow{ok {eo2

jfmmfrc`b dnf`b f{eow {ec`by< %4# dgyoìo fj du{efwc{s fj Woif`[wuy{ d`k xwomcnc`dws

c`luì{cf` %dy dbdc`y{ dmm kojo`kd`{y#- %7# gwodie fj d` dmmobok nfkcjcok if`{wdi{ %dy dbdc`y{

GDI d`k GDI Yowzcic`b#- d`k %9# xwfncyyfws oy{fxxom %dy dbdc`y{ GDI d`k GDI Yowzcic`b#

F` Yox{ongow 98- 7844- kojo`kd`{y jcmok d Wumo 47%g#%:# nf{cf` {f kcyncyy jfw jdcmuwo {f

y{d{o d imdcn- dwbuc`b {ed{ {eo ifnxmdc`{ oiookok {eo du{efwc|d{cf` {f dno`k Dm{efube5

kojo`kd`{y dyyow{ {ed{ xmdc`{cjjy imdcn jfw xwomcnc`dws c`luì{cf` cy `f{ d imdcn d{ dmm gu{ wd{eow d

%[wd`yiwcx{ fj Eodwc`b- kd{ok Dub 98- 7844 %ka{ `f 22# %Nf{ Dno`k Ewb [w#- d{7

?


3/29

jfwn fj womcoj {ed{ id``f{ if`y{c{u{o d` c`koxo`ko`{ iduyo fj di{cf`- xdwdbwdxey ?7?: fj {eo3

dno`kok xmodkc`b dkotud{oms wdcyo {eo tuoy{cf` dy {f reo{eow Woif`[wuy{ edy du{efwc{s {f

if`kui{ `f`lukcicdm jfwoimfyuwoy f` wodm xwfxow{s c` _{de

[eo tuoy{cf` cy fj if`{cùc`b cnxfw{dìo goiduyo _{de Ifko D`` ?2.4.79?%7# %Yuxx

7844# xwfzckoy d xwczd{o iduyo fj di{cf` {f d {wuy{fw refyo wodm xwfxow{s edy goo` {eo yugloi{ fj48

d` u`du{efwc|ok ydmo gs d` u`du{efwc|ok xowyf` Xmdc`{cjjy dyyow{ Woif`[wuy{ cy u`du{efwc|ok {f

jfwoimfyo

Kojo`kd`{y nds edzo d xfc`{ {ed{ xmdc`{cjjy nds edzo oiookok {eo yifxo fj {eo ifuw{y

modzo {f dno`k- gu{ {eo ifuw{ òok `f{ dkkwoyy {eo xwfncyyfws oy{fxxom imdcn `fw {eo gwodie fj44

if`{wdi{ cyyuo d{ {ecy {cno [eo cnnokcd{o d`k yugy{d`{czo tuoy{cf` gojfwo {eo ifuw{ cy reo{eow

Woif`[wuy{ edy du{efwc{s {f yomm wodm xwfxow{s d{ d `f`lukcicdm jfwoimfyuwo ydmo c` _{de

F` @fzongow 48- 7844- kojo`kd`{y nf{cf` idno f` jfw eodwc`b d`k rdy dwbuok {f {eo

ifuw{- d{ recie {cno {eo ifuw{ woyowzok f` {eo nd{{ow d`k wotuoy{ok yuxxmono`{dm gwcojc`b jwfn

gf{e xdw{coy dy {f {eo mobcymd{czo ecy{fws fj 47 _YI 37d Iuwcfuyms- d{ {eo eodwc`b- kojo`kd`{y

`f{cjcok {eo ifuw{ jfw {eo jcwy{ {cno {ed{ f` @fzongow 7- 7844- Woif`[wuy{ edk goo` yuiiookok dy

{wuy{oo gs d` d{{fwòs dnok Dwnd`k L Efromm Kojo`kd`{y {eo` dyyow{ok {ed{ xmdc`{cjjy imdcn47

%Yoo Kojy Non Yuxx Nf{ Kcyncyy Xmy [ecwk Dn Ifnxm %ka{ `f 24# %Kojy3

Non#- d{ 7#

Yugyoi{cf` %7#%d# y{d{oy {ed{ Qd^` du{efwc|ok xowyf` ref if`kui{y d` u`du{efwc|ok ydmo48

cy mcdgmo {f {eo {wuy{fw jfw {eo di{udm kdndboy yujjowok gs {eo {wuy{fw dy d woyum{ fj {eo

u`du{efwc|ok ydmo fw +7-888- recieozow cy bwod{ow

%Yoo Kojy Non d{ ?:#44

%[wd`yiwcx{ fj Eodwc`b- kd{ok @fz 48- 7844 %ka{ `f 58# %Nf{ Kcyncyy Ewb [w#- d{47

2


4/29


5/29


6/29

Reo` xwoyo`{ok rc{e d tuoy{cf` fj nff{òyy {eo ifuw{ dmyf edy d` c`{owoy{ c` xwozo`{c`b

mc{cbd`{y jwfn d{{onx{c`b {f nd`cxumd{o {eo Ifuw{y luwcykci{cf` [eo ifìow` cy {ed{ d xdw{sy7;

ied`bo c` xfyc{cf` nds go {onxfwdws d`k {euy dgd`kfòk fìo {eo mc{cbd{cf` o`ky [eowojfwo-7?

c{ cy romm yo{{mok {ed{ d kojo`kd`{y zfmu`{dws ioyyd{cf` fj d iedmmo`bok xwdi{cio kfoy `f{ koxwczo

d jokowdm ifuw{ fj c{y xfrow {f ko{owncò {eo mobdmc{s fj {eo xwdi{cio C` idyoy reowo {eo ifuw{ cy7:

ifìowòk rc{e d xdw{sy xf{o`{cdm nd`cxumd{cf` fj {eo ifuw{y luwcykci{cf`- {eo [o`{e Icwiuc{

mffay d{ {rf dkkc{cf`dm jdi{fwy< %4# reo{eow c{ cy `f{ dgyfmu{oms imodw {ed{ {eo dmmobokms rwf`bjum

goedzcfw ifumk `f{ wodyf`dgms go oxoi{ok {f woiuwQ-^ d`k %7# reo{eow {eo mc{cbd`{ cy72

d{{onx{c`b {f yodm d jdzfwdgmo koicycf` jwfn wozcor75

Dkkc{cf`dmms- {eowo dwo iow{dc` nd{{owy {ed{ ifno gojfwo d ifuw{ {ed{ dwo {ff cnxfw{d`{ {f

go ko`cok ojjoi{czo wozcor1 jfw odnxmo- reo` {eo `d{uwo fj {eo cyyuo cy yujjcico`{ms ifnxommc`b c`

womd{cf` {f {eo o`jfwiono`{ fj {eo mdry d`k {eo xwczd{o wcbe{y c`zfmzok73

Rsfnc`b z _Y Kox{ fj Dbwci- ;4; J9k 4782- 4747 %48{e Icw 788?# %tuf{c`b Ic{s fj7;

Owco z XDXY DN- ?73 _Y 722- 755 %7888##

Ck7?

Ic{s fj Noytuc{o z Dmmdkc`y Idy{mo- Cì- ;?? _Y 759- 753 %4357# C`Dmmdkc`y Idy{mo-7:

d ic{s oonx{ok d guycòyy jwfn d ic{s fwkc`dìo c` woyxf`yo {f {eo guycòyy iedmmo`bo {ed{ {eo

fwkc`dìo rdy uìf`y{c{u{cf`dm Efrozow- dj{ow d y{d{o ifuw{ koicycf` rdy cyyuok wobdwkc`b {eo

nd{{ow- {eo ic{s dkfx{ok d òr fwkc`dìo recie woxodmok {eo guycòyy oonx{cf` Yoo ck d{

75:52- 753

Yoòid.Idsubd [wcgo fj Famd z @d{m C`kcd` Bdnc`b Ifnn`- 972 J9k 4843- 487572

%48{e Icw 7889# %tuf{c`b Y _{de Rcmkowòyy Dmmcdìo z @fw{f`- 984 J9k 4742- 479: `42 %48{e

Icw 7887##

Yoo Yoòid.Idsubd [wcgo- 972 J9k d{ 4873 %Ro- efrozow- wodk Ic{s fj Owco dy75

oxwoyyc`b d boòwdmc|ok ifìow` dgfu{ nd`cxumd{cf` fj d` dxxommd{o ifuw{y luwcykci{cf` {f yodm d

jdzfwdgmo koicycf` jwfn wozcor Eowo- dxxommooy if`kui{- recmo xwoyundgms `f{ c` gdk jdc{e-

`fò{eomoyy cnxmcid{oy {eo ifìow` fzow xfy{.{wcdm nd`cxumd{cf`#

Ij C` wo Idwmyf`- ?58 J7k 49:?- 4927 %48{e Icw 4325# %koickc`b {f o`{ow{dc` {eo cyyuo73

%if`{cùok#

:

Idyo 7


7/29


8/29

iuwcfuy {ed{ Woif`[wuy{ md{ow xwfzckok {f {eo ifuw{ yuxxmono`{dm du{efwc{s d`k juw{eow dwbuok {ed{

Woif`[wuy{ kck `f{ edzo {f ifnxms rc{e {eo _{de y{d{u{oy [euy- c{ cy `f{ dgyfmu{oms imodw {f {ecy

ifuw{ {ed{ Woif`[wuy{y ju{uwo ifnxmcdìo rc{e _{de y{d{u{oy id` wodyf`dgms go oxoi{ok

Woif`[wuy{ womcoy f` {rf koicycf`y recie dxxms [ody mdr {f d `d{cf`dm gdày jckuicdws

di{czc{coy c _{de [eo idyoy f` {ecy cyyuo rc{ec` {eo Kcy{wci{ fj _{de dwo ozo`ms yxmc{ Fò fj9; 9?

{eon rdy dxxodmok [eo [o`{e Icwiuc{ kck `f{ edzo fxxfw{u`c{s {f xdyy f` {eo nd{{ow goiduyo9:

{eo xmdc`{cjj zfmu`{dwcms kcyncyyok eow ifnxmdc`{ c` {eo u`kowmsc`b di{cf` xwcfw {f {eo [o`{e

Icwiuc{ edzc`b fxxfw{u`c{s {f cyyuo d` fxc`cf`92

[eo yugy{c{u{cf` fj d` d{{fwòs dy yuiioyyfw {wuy{oo fiiuwwok f` @fzongow 7- 7844 [eo

eodwc`b f` {eo nf{cf` {f kcyncyy rdy yo{ jfw @fzongow 48- 7844 Koyxc{o edzc`b ocbe{ kdsy %jfuw

kdsy- `f{ cìmukc`b rooao`ky d`k {eo kd{oy fj yugy{c{u{cf` d`k eodwc`b# {f `f{cjs {eo ifuw{ fj {eo

yugy{c{u{cf`d`k xfyycgms yugnc{ d yuxxmono`{dm gwcoj dy {f {eo xf{o`{cdm nff{òyy

Ku{ieow z Nd{eoyf`- 7


9/29

cyyuokojo`kd`{y kck `f{ `f{cjs {eo ifuw{ fj {eo yugy{c{u{cf` u`{cm {eo @fzongow 48- 7844

eodwc b rdy romm u`kowrds d`k 7;? kdsy dj{ow {eo idyo rdy ifnnoìok95 93

[eo xdw{coy edzo wdcyok d ifnxommc`b tuoy{cf` Juw{eow- {eo xwczd{o wcbe{y fj nd`s _{de

ic{c|o`y dwo xf{o`{cdmms c`zfmzok [eo nd{{ow cy {ff cnxfw{d`{ {f go ko`cok ojjoi{czo wozcor

G Woif`[wuy{ cy `f{ du{efwc|ok {f oowicyo d xfrow fj ydmo c` d `f`.lukcicdm

jfwoimfyuwo di{cf` rc{ec` {eo Y{d{o fj _{de

_{de y{d{u{oy wotucwo gdàycìmukc`b _{de.iedw{owok gdày{f jfwoimfyo {wuy{ kooky

f`ms {ewfube cko`{cjcok {wuy{ooy [eo tuoy{cf` jfw koicycf` cy kcwoi{< Kfoy Woif`[wuy{- d [ody

ifwxfwd{cf`- d`k gs kojc`c{cf` d `d{cf`dm gdàdm{efube c{ òc{eow {daoy koxfyc{y `fw ndaoy

mfd`yedzo {eo xfrow {f if`kui{ `f`.lukcicdm jfwoimfyuwoy c` _{de fj {wuy{ kooky f` wodm

xwfxow{s mfid{ok c` _{de rc{efu{ ifnxmsc`b rc{e _{de y{d{u{oy6 [eo kcwoi{ d`yrow cy `f C{ kfoy

`f{ edzo yuie xfrow

Xmdc`{cjjy jcmok {eocw ifnxmdc`{ c` [ecwk Kcy{wci{ Ifuw{- Ydm{ Mdao Ifu`{s- _{de f` Ndwie95

44- 7844

%Yoo Nf{ Kcyncyy Ewb [w d{ 2


10/29

D y{d{o gdà recie yooay {f jfwoimfyo f` wodm xwfxow{s c` _{de nuy{ ifnxms rc{e _{de

mdr D jokowdmms iedw{owok gdà recie yooay {f jfwoimfyo f` yuie xwfxow{s nuy{ ifnxms rc{e

_{de mdr dy romm [eo wodyf` cy jfu`k rc{ec` {eo jokowdm y{d{u{oy- {eo ecy{fws fj jokowdm

mobcymd{cf`- dy romm dy xwcìcxmoy fj Jokowdmcyn

Kojo`kd`{yd`k {eo ifuw{ koicycf`y {f recie {eos ic{o woms eodzcms f` 47 IJW ;8

32%k# %7844#- d jc`dm c`{owxwo{czo wumo cyyuok gs {eo Fjjcio fj {eo Ifnx{wfmmow fj {eo Iuwwoìs

%{eo Ifnx{wfmmow# recie c`{owxwo{y {eo bfzow`c`b jokowdm y{d{u{o- 47 _YID 37d %7884#

Efrozow- `fò fj {eo koicycf`y {f recie kojo`kd`{y ic{o`fw d`s {ed{ {ecy ifuw{ edy

odncòkedzo tuoy{cfòk reo{eow {eo Ifnx{wfmmowy c`{owxwo{d{cf` koyowzoy kojowoìo;4

C` ko{ownc`c`b reo{eow {eo ifuw{ yefumk bczo yuie kojowoìo {f {eo Ifnx{wfmmowy

c`{owxwo{d{cf` fj 37d fj {eo @d{cf`dm Gdà Di{ {eo ifuw{ dxxmcoy {eo Ieozwf` {oy{- recie y{d{oy

{ed{

Qrêo` d ifuw{ wozcory d` dboìsy if`y{wui{cf` fj {eo y{d{u{o recie c{

dknc`cy{owy- c{ cy if`jwf`{ok rc{e {rf tuoy{cf`y Jcwy{- dmrdsy- cy {eo tuoy{cf`

reo{eow If`bwoyy edy kcwoi{ms yxfao` {f {eo xwoicyo tuoy{cf` d{ cyyuo Cj {eo c`{o`{

fj If`bwoyy cy imodw- {ed{ cy {eo o`k fj {eo nd{{ow1 jfw {eo ifuw{- dy romm dy {eodboìs- nuy{ bczo ojjoi{ {f {eo u`dngcbufuyms oxwoyyok c`{o`{ fj If`bwoyy Cj-

efrozow- {eo ifuw{ ko{owncòy If`bwoyy edy `f{ kcwoi{ms dkkwoyyok {eo xwoicyo

tuoy{cf` d{ cyyuo- {eo ifuw{ kfoy `f{ ycnxms cnxfyo c{y fr` if`y{wui{cf` f` {eo

y{d{u{o- dy rfumk go òioyydws c` {eo dgyoìo fj d` dknc`cy{wd{czo c`{owxwo{d{cf`

Wd{eow- cj {eo y{d{u{o cy ycmo`{ fw dngcbufuy rc{e woyxoi{ {f {eo yxoicjci cyyuo- {eo

Ku{ieow z Nd{eoyf`- 7


11/29

tuoy{cf` jfw {eo ifuw{ cy reo{eow {eo dboìs"y d`yrow cy gdyok f` d xowncyycgmo

if`y{wui{cf` fj {eo y{d{u{o;7

C` d nfwo woio`{ idyo- {eo Yuxwono Ifuw{ edy y{d{ok {ed{ Qu^`kow {eo jdncmcdwIeozwf`

jwdnorfwa- ro kojow {f d` dboìsy wodyf`dgmo c`{owxwo{d{cf` fj d y{d{u{o c{ cy iedwbok rc{e

dknc`cy{owc`b;9

Diifwkc`bms- c` ko{ownc`c`b reo{eow {eo Ifnx{wfmmowy fxc`cf` koyowzoy kojowoìo- {eo

ifuw{ jcwy{ mffay {f reo{eow If`bwoyy edy dkkwoyyok {eo xwoicyo tuoy{cf` d{ cyyuo- d`k cj If`bwoyy

edy `f{- {eo ifuw{ rcmm {eo` ko{owncò reo{eow {eo Ifnx{wfmmowy c`{owxwo{d{cf` cy gdyok f` d

xowncyycgmo if`y{wui{cf` fj {eo y{d{u{o- co- reo{eow {eo c`{owxwo{d{cf` cy wodyf`dgmo

4 [eo c`{owxmds go{roo` 47 _YI 37d d`k 47 IJW 32%k#

Woif`[wuy{ cy iedw{owok dy d `d{cf`dm gdà- d`k cy bfzowòk gs {eo @d{cf`dm Gdà Di{-

47 _YI 4 o{ yot Dy xdw{ fj {eo @d{cf`dm Gdà Di{- 47 _YI 37d yxoicjcidmms kcyiuyyoy d

`d{cf`dm gdày xfrow {f di{ dy {wuy{oo Goiduyo {eo Ifnx{wfmmowy jc`dm wumo xuwxfw{y {f c`{owxwo{

47 _YI 37d- {ecy ifuw{y y{dw{c`b xfc`{ cy {eo xmdc` md`budbo fj {eo y{d{u{o c{yomj Xow{cò`{

dmyf cy {eo c`{o`{ fj If`bwoyy dy wojmoi{ok c` {eo md`budbo fj {eo y{d{u{o d`k c{y mobcymd{czo ecy{fws

[eo y{d{u{o y{d{oy

FEDERAL JUDGE JENKINS DENIES MOTION TO DISMISS IN UTAH --BELL V COUNTRYWIDE et al RECONTRUST LACKS...

Documents

Transcript of FEDERAL JUDGE JENKINS DENIES MOTION TO DISMISS IN UTAH --BELL V COUNTRYWIDE et al RECONTRUST LACKS...