Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials...

38
Fatigue, Damage and Failure of Composite Materials: Mechanisms, Fatigue Life Diagrams and Life Prediction Ramesh Talreja Department of Aerospace Engineering Department of Materials Science and Engineering Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA UTMIS Autumn Course, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1516 October 2019 Lecture 1: INTRODUCTION

Transcript of Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials...

Page 1: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Fatigue,  Damage  and  Failure  of  Composite  Materials:

Mechanisms,  Fatigue  Life  Diagrams  and  Life  Prediction

Ramesh  TalrejaDepartment  of  Aerospace  Engineering

Department  of  Materials  Science  and  EngineeringTexas  A&M  University,  College  Station,  Texas,  USA

UTMIS  Autumn  Course,  Gothenburg,  Sweden,  15-­‐16  October  2019

Lecture  1:  INTRODUCTION

Page 2: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Contents• Lightweighting,  and  the  role  of  composites• “Big  Picture”  of  cost-­‐effective  design  with  composites• Fundamentals  – Elasticity,  plasticity,  viscoelasticity,  “strength”,  fracture,  failure,  damage.• Overview  of  failure  in  unidirectional  composites  under  tension,  compression  and  shear.•Modeling  strategies:  phenomenological  vs.  mechanisms  based.

Page 3: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Lightweighting – An  engineering  design  process

Lightweighting is  the  process  of  reducing  the  weight  of  a  product,  component,  or  system  for  the  purpose  of  enhancing(1)  performance,  (2)  operational  supportability,  and  (3)  survivability.It  entails  (a) Design,  development,  and  implementation  of  lightweight  

materials,  components,  and  technologies  (b) Cost-­‐effective  manufacturing.

Page 4: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Goals  of  lightweighting

• Improved  fuel  economy of  vehicles• Higher  performance  (speed,  mobility,  maneuverability,  range,  and  payload  capacity)• Better  operational  supportability  (transportability,  durability,  repairability,  and  maintainability)• Improved  survivability  (impact  resistance,  damage  tolerance).

Page 5: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Elements  of  lightweighting design  with  composites

• Creative  fiber  architecture  (coupled  response,  multifunctionality)• Engineered  manufacturing  (effects  of  defects)• Physics-­‐based  failure  analysis  (beyond  “strength”  criteria)• Integrated  computational  materials  engineering  (ICME)

Page 6: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Integrated  Computational  Materials  Engineering  (ICME)

MaterialsInformation

Page 7: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Market  expansion  of  carbon  fibers

Source:  Toray.com

Page 8: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Continuing  expansion  of  carbon  fiber  usage

Source:  Toray.com

Page 9: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Composites  in  Commercial  Aircraft

Page 10: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Boeing  B787

Page 11: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

a)  Boeing  B787          b)  Airbus  A350

Page 12: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

The  “Big  Picture”  ofmanufacturingsensitive  design

Process'modeling,Simulation,

Tooling,'assembly,…

1.#Manufacturing

Real'initial'and'current'material'state'(RIMS'+'RCMS): Microstructure,'

Defects,'RVE

2.#Material

5.#Performance

Integrity,'Durability,Damage'tolerance

Cost/PerformanceTrade:offs#

Specification

PhysicalModeling

Multiphysics excitation(Mechanical,'thermal,'electromagnetic'etc.)

4.#Loading

Length'scale,'Shape,'Boundary'conditions

3.#Geometry • Define  Material  State  (RIMS):

-­‐ Fiber  misalignment-­‐ Fiber  waviness-­‐ Ply  waviness-­‐ Matrix  voids• Construct  RVE• Apply  ply  level  

boundary  conditions  to  RVE  surfaces

Page 13: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Manufacturing  methods  for  polymer  matrix  composites• Manual  methods  (No  process  control)-­‐ Hand  layup-­‐ Spray  layup-­‐ Manual  prepreg layup• Automated  methods  (Fiber  dominated,  limited  process  control)-­‐ Filament  winding-­‐ Fiber  and  prepreg placement  (multiple  axes  of  motion)-­‐ Pultrusion

Page 14: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

• Various  molding  methods  with  fiber  and  textile  preforms-­‐ RTM  (resin  transfer  molding)-­‐ VARTM  (vacuum-­‐assisted  RTM)-­‐ Resin  film  infusion-­‐ -­‐• ThermoformingProcess  control  varies  depending  on  the  method  and  cost

Manufacturing  methods  for  polymer  matrix  composites,  continued

Page 15: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Labor  intensive  manufacturing  process

Cairns,  et  al,  Sandia  Report,  2011

Page 16: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Manufacturing  defects:  Voids

RTM  induced  voids

Moisture  induced  voids

Page 17: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Manufacturing  defects:  Fiber  waviness  and  misalignments

Cairns,  2009

Defects  in  large  wind  turbine  blades

Page 18: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Fundamentals  of  deformation  and  failure

è Elasticityè Plasticityè Visoelasticityè Viscoplasticityè “Strength”è Fractureè Damage

Page 19: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Relevance  of  the  fundamentals  to  understanding  of  fatigue

• Fatigue  can  only  occur  if  IRREVERSIBILITY exists• Irreversibility,  which  is  manifestation  of  energy  dissipation,  causes  material  response  to  change  from  the  first  load  application  to  the  next• Accumulation  of  this  change  can  become  critical,  causing  fatigue  failure

Page 20: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Characteristics  of  deformational  response

A:  Time-­‐independent  Reversible  (Elasticity)              B:  Time-­‐dependent  Recoverable  (Viscoelasticity)C:  Time-­‐dependent  Irrecoverable  (Viscoplasticity)

At  constant  stress

t  =  timeT  =  time  to  rupture

Page 21: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Elasticity

E

σ

ε

σ

ε

Linear:  Typical  of  metalsand  ceramics

Nonlinear:  Typical  of  rubbersand  elastomers

Page 22: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Plasticityσ

εεp

Time-­‐independentpermanent  strain  on  unloading

Typical  of  polycrystalline  materials  (e.g.  metals)where  energy  dissipationin  dislocation  motiontakes  place

EE

Elasticlimit

Page 23: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Viscoelasticity

B

t

σ

ε

ε

ε0

σ0

σ =  σ0

Typical  of  polymers  in  which  internal  changes  can  be  recovered  in  time

Page 24: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Viscoplasticity

C

tT

σ

σ0σ =  σ0

ε

ε

εp

εp

Typical  of  polymers  in  which  internal  changes  are  only  partly  recovered  in  time

Page 25: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

How  about  composites?

The  deformation  behavior  described  for  homogeneous  materials  must  be  understood  as  it  applies  to  heterogeneous  materials.

Following  observations  are  useful.• Fibers  are  (linear)  elastic•Matrix  is  constrained  by  (stiff)  fibers,  and  is  therefore  generally  under  triaxial stress  state• Interfaces  exist

Page 26: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Sources  of  irreversibility  in  polymer  matrix  composites• Fiber  breakage  (dissipation  of  fracture  surface  energy)•Matrix  viscoplasticity (dissipation  as  hysteresis  energy)• Fiber/matrix  interface  failure  (dissipation  of  fracture  surface  energy)• Interlaminar cracking  in  laminates  (dissipation  of  fracture  surface  energy)

Page 27: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Fracture  and  Damage(definitions)

• Fracture:  Formation  of  surfaces  by  breakage  of  bonds  (cracks)

• Damage:  Collective  reference  to  all  energy  dissipating  events(multiple  fracture,  irrecoverable  internal  changes,  etc)

Page 28: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

“Strength”:  What  is  it  for  composites?

• Composites  do  not  fail  at  a  specific  value  of  applied  stress,  but  have  a  sequence  of  “failure  events”  depending  on  the  failure  mode.

• As  examples,  let  us  look  at  failure  of  unidirectional  composites  under  axial  tension,  axial  compression  and  in-­‐plane  shear

Page 29: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Single  fiber  failure  in  axial  tension

Fiber  failure  from  random  flaws

Weakest-­‐link  theory  (Weibull,  1939):

Probability  of  fiber  failure

σ

σ

x Largestflaw

σ0  =  minimum  fiber  strengthσc =  characteristic  fiber  strengthc =  distribution  shape  parameter

Pf =1−expσ −σ 0σ c

⎛

⎝⎜⎞

⎠⎟

c

Page 30: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Fiber  bundle  failureP

P

Sequence  of  fiber  failures:Weakest  fiber  fails  first,Surviving  fibers  share  load  equally,Next  weakest  fiber  fails  next,  etc.

Page 31: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Observed  fiber  failure  process

Aroush et  al2006

Page 32: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Final  failure  from  fiber  breakagein  a  composite  under  increasing  load

P

P P

P

Final  failure  occurs  fromunstable  growthof  a  “core”  formedby  a  cluster  ofbroken  fibers.Matrix  deformationand  failure,  andfiber/matrixdebonding,  playroles.  

Page 33: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Failure  in  axial  compression

Failure  from  kink  bandin  shear  mode

More  likelyfailure  initiationmode

• Fiber  misalignment  plays  a  major  role• Matrix  inelasticity  in  shear  governs  failureInitiation• Final  failure  governed  by  fiber  failure  

Page 34: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Failure  in  transverse  tension

Sequence  of  failure  events:  • Fiber-­‐matrix  debonding• Link-­‐up  of  debond cracks• Crack  growth,  stable,  then  unstableto  failure

Page 35: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Failure  in  transverse  compression

Gonzalez  and  Llorca,  2007Fracture  surface  shows  evidence  ofFailure  by  shear  (hackles)

Page 36: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Failure  in  “axial”  shear

Redon  (2000)

Plumtree and  Shi  (2002)

Key  features

•Multiple,  inclined  cracks  of“Sigmoidal”  shape• Cracks  connect  near  fibersurfaces  to  form  “fracture  plane”• Fracture  surface  showshackles

t

t

Page 37: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

“Strength”  and  “Residual  strength”  for  a  part  with  a  crack

Crack&Size,&a

ac

ada0

Time&in&service,&ttd tc

Kc:&fracture&toughness!: crack/part&geometry&factor

ResidualStrength,&RS

RS =Kc

λ a

(RS)0(RS)d

2a

Does  this  apply  to  composites?(Or  any  heterogeneous  solid)

Page 38: Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-1.pdf · Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials: Mechanisms,)Fatigue)Life)

Modeling  strategies:Phenomenological  vs.  mechanisms  based• Following  metal  fatigue,  many  empirical  and  semi-­‐empirical  approaches  have  been  proposed.  None  works  reliably.• Since  there  is  no  single  crack  growth,  fracture  mechanics  type  approaches  (Paris  crack  growth  laws)  are  not  applicable  except  for  delamination  (even  that  is  problematic).• Mechanisms  based  approach  is  the  only  rational  way.  It  requires  experimentation  (observations,  measurements),  simulations,  and  analysis.  

Most  of  all,  it  requires  thinking  composites,  not  metals!


Fatigue Damage Modeling C. Rakotoarisoa of Composite ... › sites › ...Issue 9 - June 0 - Fatigue Damage Modeling of Composite Structures: the ONERA Viewpoint AL09-063 During fatigue

Fatigue Damage Modeling C. Rakotoarisoa of Composite ... › sites › ...Issue 9 - June 0 - Fatigue Damage Modeling of Composite Structures: the ONERA Viewpoint AL09-063 During fatigue

DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March …

DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March …

Title: Simulation of fatigue in composite components using ... · Simulation of Fatigue in Composite Components using ANSYS nCode DesignLife Peter Heyes, HBM‐nCode

Title: Simulation of fatigue in composite components using ... · Simulation of Fatigue in Composite Components using ANSYS nCode DesignLife Peter Heyes, HBM‐nCode

7 Christian Gaier Multi Axial Fatigue Analysis With the Fe Post Processor Femfat Utmis 2010

7 Christian Gaier Multi Axial Fatigue Analysis With the Fe Post Processor Femfat Utmis 2010

NASGRO Fatigue Crack Growth Analysis Software - …utmis.org.loopiadns.com/media/2016/06/NASGRO-Joseph-W-Cardinal.pdfNASGRO® Fatigue Crack Growth Analysis Software Presented at UTMIS

NASGRO Fatigue Crack Growth Analysis Software - …utmis.org.loopiadns.com/media/2016/06/NASGRO-Joseph-W-Cardinal.pdfNASGRO® Fatigue Crack Growth Analysis Software Presented at UTMIS

Fatigue and Residual Stress Investigation of Composite ...publications.iowa.gov/16990/1/IADOT_hr74_Fatigue_Residual_Strss... · FATIGUE AND RESIDUAL STRESS INVESTIGATION OF COMPOSITE

Fatigue and Residual Stress Investigation of Composite ...publications.iowa.gov/16990/1/IADOT_hr74_Fatigue_Residual_Strss... · FATIGUE AND RESIDUAL STRESS INVESTIGATION OF COMPOSITE

Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-5.pdf · materials)(Talreja,1985) P n a Stationary microstructure Evolving microstructure

Fatigue,)Damage)and)Failure)of) Composite)Materials ...utmis.org/media/2019/10/UTMIS-Lecture-5.pdf · materials)(Talreja,1985) P n a Stationary microstructure Evolving microstructure

Fatigue Behaviour of a Thermoplastic Composite … ·  · 2017-01-23tensile fatigue behaviour of a woven glass-fibre-reinforced composite with a polyamide 6,6 matrix. ... Fatigue

Fatigue Behaviour of a Thermoplastic Composite … ·  · 2017-01-23tensile fatigue behaviour of a woven glass-fibre-reinforced composite with a polyamide 6,6 matrix. ... Fatigue

Effect of stress concentrations on fatigue of composite ...

Effect of stress concentrations on fatigue of composite ...

Predicting the Fatigue Life of Different Composite

Predicting the Fatigue Life of Different Composite

FATIGUE MODELING OF COMPOSITE OCEAN CURRENT TURBINE BLADE · FATIGUE MODELING OF COMPOSITE OCEAN CURRENT TURBINE BLADE ... Fatigue Modeling of Composite Ocean Current ... Finite Element

FATIGUE MODELING OF COMPOSITE OCEAN CURRENT TURBINE BLADE · FATIGUE MODELING OF COMPOSITE OCEAN CURRENT TURBINE BLADE ... Fatigue Modeling of Composite Ocean Current ... Finite Element

Fatigue Damage Modelling of Fibre-reinforced Composite ...€¦ · Degrieck, J. and Van Paepegem, W. (2001). Fatigue Damage Modelling of Fibre-Reinforced Composite Materials: Review.

Fatigue Damage Modelling of Fibre-reinforced Composite ...€¦ · Degrieck, J. and Van Paepegem, W. (2001). Fatigue Damage Modelling of Fibre-Reinforced Composite Materials: Review.

Fatigue Life Prediction in Composite Materials … · Fatigue Life Prediction in . Composite Materials . Predicting fatigue life in composites is challenging because even simple load

Fatigue Life Prediction in Composite Materials … · Fatigue Life Prediction in . Composite Materials . Predicting fatigue life in composites is challenging because even simple load

ICCM18 Paper Fatigue Life Assessment For Composite Materials. Oral... · aircraft fatigue-critical, ... FATIGUE LIFE ASSESSMENT FOR COMPOSITE MATERIALS Y. Nikishkov *, A. Makeev School

ICCM18 Paper Fatigue Life Assessment For Composite Materials. Oral... · aircraft fatigue-critical, ... FATIGUE LIFE ASSESSMENT FOR COMPOSITE MATERIALS Y. Nikishkov *, A. Makeev School

DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March …windpower.sandia.gov/other/973002upd0309.pdf · DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March 25, 2009 ... The database

DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March …windpower.sandia.gov/other/973002upd0309.pdf · DOE / MSU COMPOSITE MATERIAL FATIGUE DATABASE March 25, 2009 ... The database

Comportement mécanique en fatigue d’un composite sandwich ...

Comportement mécanique en fatigue d’un composite sandwich ...

FATIGUE AND DAMAGE TOLERANCE ANALYSIS OF COMPOSITE ...digitool.library.mcgill.ca/thesisfile60701.pdf · 1 .1' .. 1 fatigue and damage tolerance analysis of composite laminates - stiffness

FATIGUE AND DAMAGE TOLERANCE ANALYSIS OF COMPOSITE ...digitool.library.mcgill.ca/thesisfile60701.pdf · 1 .1' .. 1 fatigue and damage tolerance analysis of composite laminates - stiffness

The SNL/MSU/DOE Fatigue of Composite Materials Database ... 2012 fatigue of compo… · 1 The SNL/MSU/DOE Fatigue of Composite Materials Database: Recent Trends Daniel D. Samborsky

The SNL/MSU/DOE Fatigue of Composite Materials Database ... 2012 fatigue of compo… · 1 The SNL/MSU/DOE Fatigue of Composite Materials Database: Recent Trends Daniel D. Samborsky

Fatigue life prediction of z-fibre pinned composite ...

Fatigue life prediction of z-fibre pinned composite ...

Composite automobile leaf spring-Fatigue life

Composite automobile leaf spring-Fatigue life