Fast Track Collection Initiatives – A Strategy to Fund …€¦ · · 2011-09-09Fast Track...
Transcript of Fast Track Collection Initiatives – A Strategy to Fund …€¦ · · 2011-09-09Fast Track...
_experience the commitment TM
August, 2011
Fast Track Collection Initiatives –A Strategy to Fund Modernization at North Carolina’s Department of RevenueTed London, Vice President, CGI
Confidential – CGI Proprietary – August 2011
Agenda
Guiding Principles
Fast Tracked Collection Initiatives
Results
Ongoing Improvement Projects
Predictive Analytics
Collections Case Management
2
Confidential
1. Cost effective treatment streams
2. Be easy to do business with
3. Maximize data and information available about debtors
4. Effective goal setting and management reporting
Guiding Principles - 4 Keys to Success
3
Confidential
Why Implement Changes Now?
A method of funding TIMS Project− Multi-year project to update NCDOR’s computer systems
and technical infrastructure Typical Project Funding Approaches
− Appropriations Traditional method
− Fees Fees for “services” Fee assessed at point in collection process
− Benefits based funding Typically used for large IT projects
4
Confidential
The “Fast Tracked 5”
Returned Mail Automation Automated Attachment Process Write-off Review and Reversal Vendor Attachment Collection Case Management and Decision
Analytics
Over $72 Million in benefits to date (includes July, 2011)
5
Confidential
Returned Mail Automation
14,000 notices worth $20 million in potential revenue were suppressed because they were returned by the USPS with incorrect addresses
Research was manual, time consuming and expensive
Partnered with LexisNexis to secure better addresses
After automated skip tracing, all resolved cases were released for collection action
Implemented May, 2010 Gross Benefits: $5.5 Million
6
Confidential
Automated Attachment Process
NC’s Statutes (NCGS 105-242) gives NCDOR administrative authority to attach and garnish wages, bank accounts and other intangible property
In All of CY 2009, the entire Department issued 190K attachments and garnishments (A&G’s)
Between implementation in Sept 2010 and June 30, 2011, the AA Process alone issued 355K A&G’s
Priority Process
7
Confidential
Automated Attachment Process
Implemented August 2010 Stats
− Moved 1.15 Million cases (value over $1.8B) through the process
− Issued 90,727 bank garnishments− Issued 265,046 wage garnishments
Gross Benefits: $32.4 Million
9
Confidential
Write-off Review and Reversal Process
Continuous review of accounts previously deemed uncollectible and written off using AA process
Allows more aggressive write-off program Implemented October 2010
− 95,608 taxpayers reviewed− 9,341 bank garnishments− 32,531 wage garnishments
Gross Benefits: $9.4 Million
10
Confidential
Vendor Attachment Process
Joint project between NCDOR and the NC Office of State Controller− Most agencies process vendor payments using the
Controller's North Carolina Accounting System (NCAS) − Nightly process matches NCAS payments with tax debts
and offsets any payments − Additional non-NCAS agencies to be added as a part of
TIMS project Implemented November 2011 Gross Benefits: $2.6 Million
11
Confidential
Collection Assistance Fee Year over Year
13
$-
$500,000.00
$1,000,000.00
$1,500,000.00
$2,000,000.00
$2,500,000.00
$3,000,000.00
$3,500,000.00
$4,000,000.00
Fiscal Year 2001-02
Fiscal Year 2002-03
Fiscal Year 2003-04
Fiscal Year 2004-05
Fiscal Year 2005-06
Fiscal Year 2006-07
Fiscal Year 2007-08
Fiscal Year 2008-09
Fiscal Year 2009-10
Fiscal Year 2010-2011
Lessons Learned
1. Gain executive support before starting project2. Form a cohesive team (partnership) of the best
people you can find … State staff and contractor staff should be indistinguishable
3. Full involvement by sponsor with a willingness to make take risks and make quick decisions
4. Balance implementation speed with “quality” of product
− Don’t get too hung-up on “what-if’s”− Use exception reports to handle 80/20 decisions
14
Confidential
Projects In Progress
CACS-G (and total TIMS) Implementation 2010 Legislative Projects - Budget Bill (SB 897)
(Section 31.8 – Page 181)− FIRM (Financial Institutions Records Match) (in-progress
year end implementation) − E-Garnishment (pilot in-progress)− Expanded state refund offsets (in-progress)− Vendor Offset (in-progress)− Failure to Pay Penalty (completed)
15
Confidential
Decision Analytics – A Quick Primer Analyzing Information to
indentify patterns that will predict future outcomes
Translates this analysis into actionable “scores”
Uses scores to determine risk and predict behavior Expert ModelsEmpirical Models
Applies business rules based upon the scores to obtain better results
16
Confidential
Why you can’t Judge the Accounts Receivable Book by its Cover Determining strategies based upon
dollar balances is a risky business− Many key factors:
− Age of Debt(s)− Number of times in collections− Type of debt
What you need are models to predict the best collection strategy− Likelihood of voluntary payment− Estimated yield from the case− Likelihood of non-payment
17
Confidential
Using Decision Analytics to enhance collections
While a case may have a legal obligation to pay, the likelihood of payment may be low
Most organizations have more cases than staff to work them
Agencies need to determine− How long to stay in an automated
cycle
− How quickly to accelerate cases to stronger actions
− When to assign write-off18
Confidential
Collections Scoring in North Carolina(Workflow)
Development of models to determine the likelihood of self-compliance
Support for both failure-to-pay and failure-to-file Prioritization of cases based on risk of non-
compliance Workflow engine to support treatment streams Collection of data to
gauge the effectivenessof the models andtreatment Streams
19
Confidential
Collections Scoring in North Carolina(Other Collection Decisions)
Imbed risk scoring and decision analytics into various processes:− Write off identification
− Determine when the case is cost effective to pursue− Legal Action Determination
− Use risk to determine how to prioritize various actions− Payment plans
− Time to pay based on likelihood of default
20
Confidential
Collections Case Management
North Carolina decided to enhance their collections operations with a significantly enhanced collections tool (CACS®-G)− Merging of tax types into unified cases− Automated table-driven workflow− Enhanced workflow support for treatment streams− Automated involuntary collection actions− Enhanced payment agreement support− Enhanced management reporting
21
Confidential
Case creation
New case structure consolidates all tax types into a single case
CACS-G database structure allows for significant flexibility in the definition of a case− Case is the key unit of work− Multiple debt types linked to a single case
Allows creation of cases prior to delinquency to support creation of a payment plan earlier in the collection process
Decision scores for cases used to prioritize and route cases within the application
22
Confidential
Automated table-driven workflow
Goal: allow for power to create enhanced strategies, with the ease of changing rules by business users− Leverages a rule base for movement of cases− Allows workflow routing based on any case attribute− Allows for both primary and five secondary work queues
On-line table settings allow authorized business staff to adjust workflow and treatment streams without programmer support
23
Confidential
Involuntary Collection Support
Capture of bank and employer information through interfaces
Support for system initiated liens, levies and garnishments
Integrates Legal Actions with correspondence
Captures history, demographic, and debt information
Monitors for new asset sources (even after the account is written off) for new opportunities
Prioritizes levy sources24
Confidential
Payment Agreement Support
Electronic Funds Transfers (EFT) - Facilitates the initiation of an EFT associated with a payment plan− Integrates with payment plans for better monitoring − Supports the entire EFT life cycle from pre-note
processing to final and balloon payments− Supports resending failed requests
Supports self-service paymentagreements over the Internet
Uses risk score to determine validpayment plans
25
Confidential
Other capabilities
Enhanced management reporting− Inventory statistics− Collector Performance statistics− Workflow and risk model
effectiveness reports Portable Case Management
to support field user
26
Confidential
CGI Experience helping Government improve tax operations
• Integrated Tax Systems• Implemented numerous
successful tax processing systems and data warehouses for tax agencies
• Collection Enhancements• Automated collection tools• Taxes, court fines, child
support, student loans, motor vehicles
• Business process improvements
• Statistical Models• CGI has a proven process,
and is willing to be paid only out of increase in revenues
Internal Revenue Service
Grand TotalOver $1.7 Billion
Missouri$55 Million
Canada Revenue Agency
Benefits Funded Collections projects
Australian TaxOffice
Other Collections projects
Other Tax and Revenue Projects
New York City
North Carolina$72 Million
Virginia$231 Million
California$570 Million$176 Million$41 Million$37 Million
Kansas$182 Million
Hawaii$252 Million$133 Million
27
Confidential
Contact Information
28
Confidential
Charlie HelmsDirectorTax Compliance Collection DivisionNC Department of Revenue
(919) [email protected]
Ted LondonVice PresidentTax, Revenue and Collections Solutions
(916) [email protected]
ISO 9001 Certified