Executive Summary - Home Page - BANKSETA Website · Web viewCommercial banks stressed the...
Transcript of Executive Summary - Home Page - BANKSETA Website · Web viewCommercial banks stressed the...
AGRICULTURAL FINANCE/AGRARIAN REFORM
Coach
Desray Clark
Sponsors
Andrew Makenete : Land and Agricultural Bank
Wilfred Verwey : RSM
Tashmia Ismael: GIBS
Syndicate 3
Magdeline Kekana; Mohamed Basson; Nerina Naik; Nwabisa Piki; Seth Maanda
2
Table of ContentsExecutive Summary.......................................................................................................................3
Introduction....................................................................................................................................4
Project Aim....................................................................................................................................4
Project Approach...........................................................................................................................5
Background....................................................................................................................................5
Vhembe Agricultural Co-operative:........................................................................................5
Initial Analysis – SA agriculture in context.....................................................................................7
1. Farming environmental factors and infrastructure................................................................10
Crop production risk (weather, diseases, R&D, technology)................................................10
Farming Infrastructure and logistics.....................................................................................10
Labour in the agricultural sector...........................................................................................10
Crop production risk (weather, diseases, R&D, technology)................................................11
Farming Infrastructure and logistics.....................................................................................11
Labour in the agricultural sector...........................................................................................11
Land Reform............................................................................................................................12
2. The Farmer..............................................................................................................................13
2.1 Emerging Farmers Financial Skills....................................................................................13
2.2 Borrowing...........................................................................................................................14
2.3 Benefit of co-operative structures......................................................................................16
3. Profitability of the farming enterprise=.....................................................................................17
3.1 Pricing of commodities.......................................................................................................17
3.2 Input Costs.........................................................................................................................18
4. The role of the government.....................................................................................................19
5. Recommendations...................................................................................................................20
6. Conclusion...............................................................................................................................27
REFERENCES............................................................................................................................28
List of Interviewees:.................................................................................................................28
Bibliography.............................................................................................................................28
APPENDIX 1: ABOUT THE VHEMBE REGION.........................................................................32
APPENDIX 2: GLOSSARY OF TERMS......................................................................................34
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
3
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
4
Executive SummaryAgriculture plays an important role in the economy of South Africa as it is a key
contributor to ensuring the foundation of food security, poverty alleviation and job
creation which are Government priorities. Government has implemented initiatives to
transform this sector of the economy however; transformation is still lagging behind
other sectors.
The purpose of this research is to identify a framework for supporting emerging farmers
in obtaining finance to migrate into successful commercial farmers. The framework
when implemented will make a considerable impact towards agrarian reform. The study
will analyse the effectiveness of the current support framework within South African
financial institutions and make a comparison to the models used in both Kenya and the
Netherlands.
A case study of the Vhembe co-op was undertaken to highlight some of the challenges
faced by emerging farmers in South Africa. Site visits were conducted to the Limpopo
Vhembe district, as well as the Joburg Market to establish the extent of the challenges.
The analysis included the use of various mechanisms to assist in understanding the
current landscape. These include:
1. A PESTLE analysis of the South African, Netherlands and Kenyan agricultural
sectors. This allowed us to make an informed comparison of South Africa with
other countries agricultural sectors.
2. Detailed literature review, interviews with financial institutions and relevant
stakeholders were done on the following :
a. Environmental factors and infrastructure requirements
b. The farmer’s business skills and borrowing capabilities
c. Profitability of the farming enterprise
d. The role of the Government
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
5
Finally, recommendations were proposed based on our findings, literature reviews and
gaps identified when assessing the Vhembe co-op. The recommendations were
primarily based on the four highlighted themes that impacted the value chain and
profitability of the primary co-op.
IntroductionThe birth of South Africa’s new democracy in 1994 was followed by several
transformation initiatives aimed at redressing past imbalances across a number of
sectors. There are mixed reactions about the success of these initiatives, but there is
consensus that the agricultural industry has failed to bring about meaningful
transformation. While commercial banks have a role to play in providing funding
required to push transformation, one would be naïve to ignore the role played by factors
such as government policies, the impact of implementation of reform programs, lack of
farming skills and various factors that we will explore in this document.
The positive spins-offs of addressing the agri-reform issues are among other things:
alleviation of poverty;
creation of food security;
rural development (that leads to a reduction of massive urban migration)creation
of employment; and
sustainable agri-businesses.
Gareth Ackerman (Chairman of Pick n Pay) says, “In most developing countries,
agriculture is the largest source of employment, and international agricultural
agreements are crucial to a country’s food security”, Finweek (2010, 29 July).
Project AimThe aim of the project is to research and develop a set of operational recommendations
which will support emerging farmers in accessing finance from financial institutions.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
6
Project ApproachThe group’s approach to the project was to investigate the role played by the banking
industry in providing funding to stimulate agrarian reform in South Africa, and to make
its findings and recommendations based on sustainable measures that can be
implemented in a South African environment. In conducting our research, it soon
became clear that a number of factors influence and play a role in the development of
the emerging farmers in South Africa, and that no one factor could be investigated in
isolation. The economic, agro-ecological, legislative and social factors interact and
overlap with each other and it became evident that focusing on only one factor is
unlikely to give significant impact on the outcome of our findings.
Background
Vhembe Agricultural Co-operative:The Vhembe co-operative (co-op) was chosen as our syndicate’s case study after
consulting with the Joburg market (previously known as the Johannesburg Fresh
Produce Market). They are a secondary co-op situated in a fertile part of Limpopo
province that supplies 35%- 40% of the Joburg market’s subtropical fruits and other
horticultural crops. They represent 18 primary co-ops who in turn represent
approximately 2000 Black emerging and subsistence farmers. Our visit to Vhembe and
interviews with the secondary co-op members confirmed that they were an ideal case
study for our Action Learning Project for the following reasons:
The members share a deep passion for farming and demonstrated a hunger to
succeed.
The co-op members volunteered to join, which is what the International Co-
operative Alliance (ICA) formulated in Geneva suggests as the basis of forming a
co-op.
They had received financial support from the European Union (EU) and the
Department of Local Government and Housing that was used to renovate a
medium sized pack-house.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
7
The co-op farmers have access to an estimated 1500 to 2000 hectares of land in
the area (an audit is in progress). The relatively frost-free climatic conditions of
the area are favourable to growing various agricultural produce and there exists a
good supply of water depending on which part of the district farming occurs.
SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE: FACTS AND FIGURES
- To date only 6 million hectares of land has been redistributed to Black landowners since the end of apartheid in 1994
- Of the redistributed land, 90% is no longer productive- Only 12% to 14% of SA’s land is suitable for agricultural production- Less than 1 in 20 beneficiaries have had access to any of Government’s facilities
aimed at helping finance and support emerging farmers- R254m of the 2010 land reform budget will be used to resuscitate commercial
farmers that have fallen out of production since being redistributed- There is an estimated 200 000 emerging farmers in South Africa- The number of large commercial farms dropped from 60 000 to 40 000 in the
past 14 years- ANC policy requires 30% of land to have been redistributed into Black hands by
2014- According to Rural Development and Agriculture Minister Gugile Nkwinti the year
2025 is more realistic to meeting the 30% land redistribution target.
Source: FinWeek 29 July 2010, Whitfield, B. and Lund, T.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
8
Initial Analysis – SA agriculture in contextDuring our research, we have had the opportunity to visit the Netherlands and Kenya. Below we set out an analysis of the different issues affecting agriculture or agricultural reform.
PESTLE ANALYSIS
Indicator Republic of South Africa Netherlands Kenya
Political environment
o Land reform and rural development are key government priorities.
o Emerging farmers are under tremendous financial strain.
o Disjunction between access to land, markets and crucial water resources makes sustainable production difficult and cripples many emerging farmers.
o Government a key supporter for agriculture
o A support program is in place for new entrants into the farming industry
o Legacy of the past leadership still a stumbling block for government with regards to land redistribution
o Political violence in 2008 had an impact on the economy
o A referendum is scheduled for 4 August 2010 for a new constitution
Economic environment
o The economy is again growing (though at a moderate pace) and financial conditions have improved.
o Credit extension is likely to remain at low levels over the medium term.
o The financing of emerging farmers remains a challenge.
o Agricultural commodity price indices are steadily trending upwards.
o There is a growing demand for agricultural land in Africa by developed countries.
o The Dutch flower industry as well as the cheese industry is a major contributor to the Netherlands economy
o The Netherlands acts as hub for global trade.
o The country is stable financially, relying on diverse inputs to its GDP
o Economy has migrated from being overly dependent on agriculture. Agriculture moved from 75% in the 1970s to 25% 2009 in terms of GDP contribution
o Small scale farmers contribute 65-70% of the agricultural produce
o Major crops produced are mainly for the primary ingredient in the value chain of finished goods or export
o Commercial banks mostly finance larger agri-enterprises with collateral. Collateral could be other private property.
o
Social o High levels of rural poverty are mainly addressed through social grants.
o Educated populationo Diverse population
o Dual economy (limited middle class)o A large part of the rural population
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
9
Indicator Republic of South Africa Netherlands Kenya
environment o A large part of the rural population depends on agriculture.
o Household nutrition levels and national food supply have been negatively affected by the recession.
depends on agriculture.o Remittances from urban workforce to
family structures in the rural areas
Technology environment
o Advances in agricultural technology are driven by the development of new production methods, including new plant cultivars, livestock breeds, input technologies and genetically modified products.
o Experts at logistics, both water and air (Hub and spoke)
o Research intensive environment
o Market research and data on agricultural not a government priority
o Large agri-businesses have their own research units
o Communication regarding agricultural risks information is not efficient and effective
Legal and institutional environment
o Regulatory institutions include the Departments of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, and Trade and Industry, the National Treasury and the Auditor General.
o Complementary bodies include other Development Finance Institutions, agriculture research bodies, the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research and organized agriculture.
o Banking system support of the co-operative banking model. Rabobank is the major bank for agricultural financing, rated as AAA
o Strong regulatory compliance culture - Basel commission head also comes from the Netherlands
o Large sectors such as the coffee market said to be under strain due to poor governance and corruption by the state
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
10
Indicator Republic of South Africa Netherlands Kenya
Environmental issues
o Environmental issues remain at the top of the global agenda.
o The revised King Code and Report on Governance for South Africa (King III) re-emphasize the importance of sustainability locally and globally
o Need to increase food production takes place in the context of climate change and variables such as declining water resources, biodiversity.
o Limited arable land availableo 50% of the country is below sea levelo Specializing in agricultural productions
and commodities.
o Rainfall dependent, limited irrigation for agricultural purposes
o Electricity is constrained as most power supply is from hydro-electricity
o Positive for agriculture in most regions in the country is the 2 rainfall seasons.
From the PESTLE analysis, it can be deduced that the common thread is that commercial agriculture makes a meaningful
contribution towards economic growth. The challenge of graduating emerging agricultural entrepreneurs to become
commercially sustainable is highly dependent upon a continuation of political leadership with dedicated government
agricultural support mechanisms and instruments. The African experience suggests that there is a demand for
subsistence and commercial agriculture in context of social upliftment and rural development. It is therefore important to
understand the agricultural production objectives of the farmer. The syndicate concentrated on the South African context
in their recommendations.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
11
1. Farming environmental factors and infrastructure
Literature review
Crop production risk (weather, diseases, R&D, technology)Variations in climate changes, as well as biological factors are major contributors of
production risk in the agricultural business. The major sources of production risk are
weather, pests, including insect and disease damage. Another source of risk to crops is
the use of technology to genetically modify crop production. The advancement of
technology has brought about improved mechanics aiding in the crop production
lifecycle and emerging farmers don’t have access to new advanced technology.
Farming Infrastructure and logisticsAn analysis of any country that has successfully developed its agriculture will always
identify the provision of good infrastructure as a requirement for achieving higher levels
of agricultural productivity and profitability. According to Stilwell et al. (1998),
infrastructure can be classified as either economic or hard (e.g. roads, electrification,
bridges and railways), social or soft (e.g. health and education) or institutional (e.g.
farmers, co-operatives and agricultural institutions).
The following are the primary farming infrastructure dependencies and associated risks
in South Africa:
Resources: Water and EnergyLimited water resources and high energy costs are major constraints.
Institutional Infrastructure: Research and DevelopmentCrucial in increasing agricultural productivity and competitiveness.
Institutional Infrastructure: Agricultural Support ServicesShortage in the supply and training of extension officers
Hard Infrastructure: Roads, Railways, Telecommunications, and ElectricityInfrastructure (roads, bridges, dams, etc.) has significant impact on the
efficiencies of the agricultural sector.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
12
Labour in the agricultural sectorSouth Africa's labour market has undergone transformation since 1994, with an
emphasis on strategies that eliminate the labour inequalities and improved general
working conditions. The introduction of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act in the
agricultural sector (the minimum wage for farm labourers is currently R1, 300.00) has
led to a higher demand for part time rather than permanent employees. Anecdotal
evidence has shown that South African farming skills are in high demand both locally
and internationally.
Findings:
Crop production risk (weather, diseases, R&D, technology)Crop risk caused by the factors such above can harm the profitability of farmers.
Knowledge of risk mitigating measures would greatly assist farmers, especially the
emerging farmer with little or no support services or skills. Government support to
agricultural research is channelled directly through the Agricultural Research Council
(ARC). Before 1994, South Africa had 14 separate, autonomous Departments of
Agriculture, and it is said that state funding to agriculture has declined (Vink, 2003).
Farming Infrastructure and logisticsThe availability of appropriate infrastructure such as pack houses and grading facilities
play a major role in ensuring the success of the farming supply chain.
Labour in the agricultural sectorWhile there is an abundance of unskilled labour the farming industry interviews with the
major commercial banks in South Africa have suggested that one of the key shortfalls in
farming is the apparent lack of access to technical expertise amongst emerging farmers.
Vhembe co-op
The Vhembe region is conveniently situated in a sub-tropical region of South
Africa which reduces the risk of weather related crop failure.
The completion of the pack house is only one of the ways in which the co-op is
addressing infrastructure needs. The deterioration of roads as well as the lack of
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
13
rail transport to key destinations is an impediment to the successful
transportation of produce by the co-op.
The co-op is allowed to contribute towards the development of Integrated
Development Plans for the municipality which deal with among other things
infrastructure priorities in the area.
The current labour force in the farms comprises of a combination of family
members, employed labour from local communities and immigrant workers from
the neighbouring countries (Zimbabwe and Mozambique).
Land ReformLiterature review
The success of emerging farmers is linked to the nature and speed of support given to
the beneficiary of the land reform process. Greenberg (2010), is extremely critical of the
lack of wider consultation and participation of those who are supposed to be
beneficiaries of the land reform process. The government’s intentions on land reform
are best summed in the quote from Anseeuw, W. and Mathebula, N. (2008):
“The South African government aims to put about 30 percent of the country's
agricultural land into black hands within 15 years. But the program has been painfully
slow. Moreover, where successful sales have taken place, critics complain that the
government has failed to help black farmers”.
Findings
Most Black emerging farmers in rural areas operate on communal land and this is
perceived as a risk by commercial banks. Farming is increasingly becoming an
economies of scale business. Banks believe that marginal farmers and subsistence
farmers are not easily bankable.
Vhembe co-op
In our case study the co-op consists of four land tenure systems:
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
14
communal land offered to family groups by traditional leaders,
private land,
agricultural land that has been recently transferred to Black communities
land that the government leases to farmers or is offered by traditional leaders to
farmers on a permission to occupy (PTO) basis.
In addition, state owned land under tribal jurisdiction is de jure state land and therefore
available for allocation, but de facto it is tribal land where certain rights have already
vested by users of such land through either PTO or CTO (certificate to occupy). A
common solution offered to production efficiency and access to funding is one of
“privatization” of state and tribal land. This over-simplification of the complex issue
ignores the social security value of land which consistently causes “community
disagreements” on commercial projects on such land.
2. The Farmer
2.1 Emerging Farmers Financial Skills
Findings
The understanding of a farming business’s financial position is essential for sound
business practices, maintaining effective control, managing cash flows and building
history for future references.
Farm records should be vigilantly kept as they provide the basic information required to
compile the financial statements. Some of the emerging farmers are illiterate and
therefore find difficulty in understanding business finance and the management of
finances.
There is evidence that assumptions are made by funders when preparing Income
Statement and Balance Sheet projections and that these assumptions are then forced
into retail or corporate credit models.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
15
Vhembe co-op
The Vhembe co-op faces financial management literacy challenges. The co-op avails its
members to Madzivhandila Agricultural College to assist in closing the farming and
financial management skills gap. The Department of Agriculture also assists emerging
farmers’ financial literacy through Ralman Consulting. This method of classroom training
provided proved to be ineffective.
2.2 BorrowingLiterature review
Inexperience in the risk assessment, lack of collateral, low profitability and macro
economic uncertainty makes banks view the emerging farmers as high risk consumers.
According to Rabobank, the farmers can be segmented into the following features:
Source: Rabobank Development: The Financial landscape and the Cocoa sector. Obstacles and solutions in farm financing: May 20
2010, Hans Bogaard
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
16
Findings
The below table indicates a comparison of most of the initiatives that financial
institutions that have made in supporting emerging farmers in accessing finance.
Name of institution Initiatives Objectives
Khula Enterprise
Mortgage loan
This is a financing facility which enables the emerging farmers to buy land for agricultural production purposes. Repayment term is 20 years. R 800 000 per emerging farmer
Equity Share scheme
A business arrangement in which both land reform beneficiaries and private sector partners buy equity in the form of shares in a land-based agricultural enterprise. R 600 000 per emerging farmer
ABSA
ABSA have about 22% of market share on lending to emerging farmers. Absa has recently been engaging and working with the Department of Agriculture, Department of Land Affairs and Khula Enterprise Finance to expedite the transformation process.
Standard Bank
Standard Bank in collaboration with Khula Enterprise plans to finance more land deals involving South African farmers seeking expansion opportunities across the continent to grow export crops. Standard Bank will be providing up to $100m in new lending over three years to small farmers and medium-sized agriculture enterprises in Africa. Furthermore, Standard has committed R500m for emerging farmer support.
FNB
First National Bank (FNB) and the US Agency for International Development (USAID) signed a R300m deal to boost emerging agriculture in the country.
Land Bank
As per Land Bank corporate plan, R450m has been committed for 2010/2011 to finance developing emerging farmers.
Vhembe co-op
The co-op has only reported receiving donor funds from the European Union (EU) and
the Department of Local Government and Housing (DLGH) to renovate their pack
house. No other funding from Commercial Banks was reported.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
17
2.3 Benefit of co-operative structures
Chances of successfully applying for funding from commercial banks and the viability of
agri-businesses improve when farmers are organised as a co-op.
Literature Review
Agricultural co-operatives, according to Kate Philip (2003), became a powerful lobby for
agriculture, holding a virtual monopoly in key agricultural sectors, backed by access to
finance through the Land Bank. These co-ops had firm control of the marketing boards
until the agricultural boards system was dismantled after 1994.
Co-ops have significant bargaining power and the ability to provide technical support to
their members. Philip’s paper puts the challenge faced by new co-ops very well when
he says: “Management is tough, democratic management is tougher”.
Findings
Rabobank (a AAA rated bank in Netherlands) was formed purely by a group of co-ops
and has to date a market share of 85% in banking farmers in the Netherlands.
Vhembe co-op
Each member of the Vhembe secondary co-op contributes R500 as a membership fee
to join the co-op. The members have limited management ability however they all have
a great commitment and resolve to work towards the transforming themselves from
subsistence or emerging farmers to fully fledged commercial farmers.
Each primary co-op nominates a representative who sits on the secondary co-op. The
board of directors is democratically elected and good governance is promoted. Voting
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
18
rights are based on a ‘one member one vote’ system. There is a plan to form business
units responsible for running key activities of the co-op e.g. logistics and marketing.
3. Profitability of the farming enterprise=
3.1 Pricing of commoditiesLiterature review
“SA embarked on what is now regarded to be the most extensive reforms of any nation
in the shortest time possible in the 1990’s. These included deregulation of agricultural
products, abolishing certain (most) tax concessions favouring the sector, reducing
significantly budgetary expenditure on the sector and implemented huge changes in
Land reform and trade policy for example, the replacement of direct controls over
imports by tariffs which were significantly set below the rates as per the WTO.”
(Makenete, L., 2010, p.11).
Findings
During an interview with Andrew Makenete from the Land Bank, it was highlighted that
the sweeping changes made to the agricultural policy agenda in South Africa from being
a subsidised and regulated industry to that of a totally liberalised free market sector had
consequences for all, more specifically for new entrants into this market. Further, the
speed of reform in the agricultural space was not complemented with policy reform in
other spheres of government.
Pricing can be broken down into two components namely input costs and selling price
(revenue). The selling price is key in determining the viability of what crops to plant for
the forthcoming planting season.
Selling price considerations:
Prices are determined by market forces both locally and internationally
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
19
Major players can use dumping tactics to reduce prices at certain intervals to
retard the growth of potential new entrants
Agents are used in this sector, the consequences of agents are that they offer
low prices to the farmer and resell to the market at more inflated prices
Clearing agents at the Joburg produce market is used to assist farmers in
getting the best prices possible as prices are driven by demand and supply.
Vhembe co-op
The Vhembe co-op farmers are also at the mercy of external market forces that
determine the price at which commodities are sold based on supply and demand.
3.2 Input CostsLiterature review
In his presentation to the Agricultural Industry Conference, Dr Kobus Laubscher CEO of
Grain SA (2009), illustrated the link between technology, input costs and infrastructure
to agricultural competitiveness.
He uses the example of a grain farmer and analyses the nature of input items that have
to be factored by a grain farmer. The list will be similar to a horticulture agri-business. It
has elements and can be classified into fixed, variable and marketing costs
Dr Laubscher concludes that most farmers are not even getting to a point where they
can recover their production costs based on the low global prices. This further
perpetuates consolidation of large farmers to drive better economies of scale.
Based on the 2005 Agricultural Census, 77% of farms have an income turnover of
below R1 million the implications of which is that they do not qualify for tax rebates. In a
presentation by Willemse, J. (Aug 2005) results of a study done among 700 farmers,
indicated that the most important aspect that required focus in the farming business is
input costs (a 25% weighting) followed by efficiency and management (with a 14%
weighting). As input costs rise, less farming happens resulting in a dependency on
imports, and therefore threatening food security. This leaves South Africa exposed to
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
20
world food price hikes, unemployment and a worsening poverty situation, especially in
rural areas.
Findings
All commercial banks also view input costs as an impediment to the viability of small or
emerging farmers. Commercial banks stressed the importance of planning, land
preparation and timeous disbursement of funds required for agricultural inputs.
Vhembe co-op
The Vhembe Secondary Co-op realised the importance of managing input costs and
has subsequently formed strategic partnerships with key suppliers. Some of these
suppliers are providing advice and training to members of the co-op. What still remains
a challenge is affordability of inputs, funding and access to the best knowledge and
skills.
4. The role of the governmentDealing with government is a complex matter as various ministries are tasked with the
same priorities more specifically, poverty alleviation and rural development. Two main
ministries being the Department of Agriculture Forestry and Fisheries (DOAFF) and
Department of Rural Development and Land Affairs (DRDLA) plays a pivotal role in
providing grants to assist agrarian reform however, the prevalent modus operandi in
these departments are that they operate as silos in relation to the priorities, further
compounding the problem is that within one department they are not aligned as to the
three spheres of government namely; National vs. Provincial vs. Local.
The local sphere of government is the entry point to access such funds. However their
mandate might not be aligned to provincial and/or national spheres resulting in funds
being redeployed.
5. Recommendations
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
21
The syndicate acknowledges that a blue print does not exist and that an approach of
one size fits all is not feasible. The basis of our recommendation is that agri-financing of
emerging farmers to drive agrarian reform requires a synchronisation between the
farming entities, the government, and the commercial banks.
Recommendations for the farming entities
We recommend integrated community-based farming aligned to a value-chain funding
approach delivered through a co-operative. The approach will be based on the following
key farming principles which are elaborated on in this section:
Organising communal land into one large-scale farming entity preferably
within the same geographic area.
Mobilising the key stakeholders at government, community and farming
business level to create a credible forum to deal with land, infrastructure,
development and other key issues that could affect the large-scale farming
operation.
Structuring farmers into an agricultural co-op mandated to oversee the
farming needs and operations of the member farmers.
Appointing a good management team for the large farming entity tasked to
drive professional farming
Development of appropriate training to impart farming and financial skills to
improve yields and drive profitability.
Strategic crop and market risk management through insurance products.
The above form the basis of a sustainable farming enterprise that has the potential to
lay the foundation for banks to at a high level assessment of the farmers.
In the next section of the recommendations we expand on how the factors that we have
highlighted in our findings can be addressed.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
22
Environmental factors and infrastructure:
Crop production risk:
Introduce risk mitigating crop farming techniques such as dual cropping, multiple
product lines and crop rotation
Selection of appropriate crops, preferably longer shelf life, to reduce risk
Crop-rotation based on research Crop insurance and hedging
Farming infrastructure and logistics:
Engage with different stakeholders to expedite the improvement of roads and
introduction of cheaper modes of transport appropriate for the large scale area.
Engage with the municipality as a co-op which is a stronger lobbying structure in
order to influence decision making
Syndicated approach to input costs (fertilisers, seeds, packaging, transportation)
Labour:
Lobby government for farm worker grants as an incentive to meet government’s
minimum wage requirement
Create a partnership between the farmers and labour aimed at minimising labour
costs
Concurrently to the above, the agreement could also address the dependency on
migrant labour to stimulate job creation
Land reform:
Suggestion is to not apply a blanket approach – solutions are tailored with
government and community involvement
Sustainable integrated approach to land transfers, grant funding and commercial
lending, skills development and market creation
The farmerEmerging farmer’s financial and technical skills: Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
23
The co-op should appoint qualified book-keepers to assist in proper management
of their books
Continuous improvement of technical skills by regular workshops facilitated by
the Extension Officers in the area
Development of a tailored experiential learning programme for farmers
(communicated by the farmers as their preferred method of learning),
Partnerships with successful commercial farmers to share skills and lessons
learnt
Structuring of co-ops: Co-ops should be formed from an economic perspective (rather than to be used
as “stokvels”)
A proper management structure should be put in place
Encourage the co-op to pursue the idea of forming various business units aimed
at addressing key areas in the value chain for example: a marketing business
unit, a banking business unit etc.
The ‘one member one vote’ system should be discouraged. Those with larger
farms should have more say (they stand to loose more)
Individual farmers should be encouraged to cede ownership of their respective
PTOs to the co-op to ensure that all the necessary farming processes are
adhered to achieve profitability
Profitability of the farming enterprisePricing of commodities:In order to achieve the best selling price, it is suggested that farmers should:
Form alliances with other agribusinesses in the region to facilitate the best prices
for the produce from this area.
Use third parties to enter into hedging agreements to mitigate against volatility
The Vhembe Co-op should create capacity and contract directly or indirectly with
the market or with other third parties like big super market chains stores.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
24
Contracts should preferably have a minimum price as well as the benefit of
higher prices
In order to manage the risk of price fluctuations, farmers should enter into contr
acts (off-take agreements) that have a minimum price guaranteed for the crop at
harvesting time. Further, the contracts must also factor the allowance to benefit
on the upside if the prices are high on delivery.
Input costs: Bulk buying leveraging on the economies of scale
The use of expert negotiators when buying and selling.
Role of the governmentWe recommend closer cooperation between the two relevant government departments
being: the Department of Rural Development and Land Affairs and the Department of
Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries. This will address:
Access to special sectoral grants;
Influence agricultural infrastructure development;
Technical support through extension officers.
Role of Commercial BanksThe unique nature of the challenges faced by this sector requires greater co-operation
between government, business and commercial banks. There are two main types of
funding for farming enterprises: long term funding (e.g. mortgage, asset finance) and
short-term funding (funds for seasonal planting requirements such as seeds).
Banks should continue with unconventional methods of financing, i.e. “value-
chain financing” where crops are used as collateral
Get off-take agreements which can be used as a means of collateral (this also
speaks to the “value-chain financing”)
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
25
Banks lend to the secondary co-ops, who in turn facilitate lending to individual
farmers and collect payment on their behalf as this will reduce the risk of
defaulting
Where co-ops are not in place but the farmers have off-take agreements, the
lending can be done through the food manufacturers e.g. Nestle as long as they
have the capacity to disburse the funds
Property owned by the co-op in partnership with the local authorities can be used
as collateral
Guarantee and relief funds from both government and other third parties
commercial banks, Developmental Finance Institutions (Khula, Land Bank, DBSA
and IDC), aid funding e.g. USAID to stand as security
Use a model similar to the Kenya’s Equity Bank “social pressure model” to
reduce incidence of non-payment of loans. This will require the use of community
leaders, chiefs and local priests to exert social pressure on the farmers to honour
their obligations.
Establish forums between the emerging farmer, commercial banks and
government in order to formulate and share “best practice” on funding methods
To summarise and align our recommendations to the problems identified through the
process of interviewing, literature reviews and the Vhembe case study, we have
developed a matrix, which in our opinion will aid the facilitation of the agrarian reform
agenda, more specifically the financing of agricultural projects.
The matrix gives an overview of the current impediments to possible tactical intervention
strategies as well as the key role players (indicative not exhaustive).
Issue Action Role playerEnvironmental factors and infrastructure
Crop production
risk
Group insurance
Technical support
Insurance & Reinsurance
companies
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
26
(extension officers) DOAFF
Farming
infrastructure and
logistics
Water supply
Roads
DBSA
Local Municipality
Labour in the
agricultural sector
Enhance skill set with
financial, technical and
business training
Local university and
agricultural technical
schools
DBSA
Land reform Lobby group Government
The farmer Emerging farmer’s
financial and
technical skills
Funding Collateral in the form asset
or income
Government guarantee
Land Bank, DBSA,
Commercial Banks, Khula
Enterprise
Structuring co-ops
Profitability Pricing Minimum price contracts
More agents
Input costs Bulk buying
Access to markets Branding, Contract
negotiations
GIBS, Rabobank
Recommendations for Vhembe
The syndicate decided from the onset that the project would be one that was applicable
and realistic. It is for this reason that it remains ongoing and the group has put in place
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
27
measures to address the needs of the co-op post the end of BankSeta’s IEDP
programme.
The learnings from the completion of this project will not only benefit the Vhembe
farming community, but put in place a practical model that can be duplicated in other
regions in South Africa.
The syndicate is in the process of finding workable and viable solutions for the Vhembe
co-op together with interested parties. They include:
The Gordon Institute of Business Science;
Rabobank Netherlands
The Development Bank of South Africa;
The Land and Agricultural Bank of South Africa; and
First National Bank.
Below is the draft action plan for implementation of the said solutions. At the moment,
no formal agreements are in place; however, the syndicate remains in contact and has
organised site visits with individuals from the above institutions.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
28
6. Conclusion
The solutions to agrarian reform and the financing of agricultural projects must be
integrated as they are interdependent. Addressing one or only some of the components
will put stress on the other parts in the value chain.
Transformation of the Agricultural Sector has a government and donor grant label and
does not sufficiently focus on agricultural entrepreneurship development and efficiency
of production for profitability and sustainability. Emerging agriculture is therefore
reduced to a government social responsibility by commercial banks. Under this
paradigm, the potential commercial funding profitability of emerging agriculture is not
exploited by commercial banks.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
29
REFERENCES
List of Interviewees: Mr. Davhana, Mr Muvhulawa and other the directors of the Vhembe Secondary
Co-operative
Mr. P. Mphahlele – COO of Joburg Market
Mr. L van der Merwe – Head of Agriculture FNB Commercial
Kenny Ngcobo – Manager Agric Credit at FNB Commercial
Mr. A. Makenete – Head of Strategy Land and Agriculture Bank
Mr. Jacques Taylor - Director, Agricultural Banking at Standard Bank
Mr. Dean Scoble – Global Markets, Agri Desk at Standard Bank
Mr. William Malan – Agribusiness Manager, Absa
Mr. Simon Yegon – Senior Agricultural Manager, CfC Stanbic Bank
Mr. Nico Basson – Project Manager, Development Bank of South Africa
Mr. Hans Bogaard - Head AgriBusiness. Rabobank Netherlands
Bibliography
Anseeuw, W. and Mathebula, N. (2008). South Africa's economic miracle – has the
emperor lost his clothes? Paper presented at the University of Pretoria Annual Forum,
Pretoria.28p.
Atkinson, D. Pienaar, D. Van Schalkwyk, C. du Plessis, R. and Wellman, G. (2003a)
Life on the farm: Shifting social and moral foundations of the farming community,
unpublished, (Bloemfontein, Human Sciences Research Council). Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
30
Brown, R. K. and Arnold, A.L. (1993) Managing Corporate Real Estate. Retrieved from
http:// www.openlibrary.org/authors/OL722464A/Robert_Kevin_Brown
Cousins, B. (2009) Potential and pitfalls of commercial land tenure reform: experience in
Africa and implications for South Africa, Washington DC USA, 9 – 10 March, PLAAS
University of Western Cape
Du Toit, G.S and Van Rooyen, J. H (1998).Risk management 3rd ed. Credit risk and
financial risk management. University of South Africa (UNISA) Press.
Eckert E., Hamman J.N., Lombard J.P. (1996) Perceptions of a new future: Empowering
farm workers through equity sharing. Commissioned by Development Bank of South
Africa
Gitman, L. J (2001). Managerial Finance, 9th ed, Retrieved from
http://www.librarything.com/author/gitmanlawrencej
Greenberg, S. (2010). Research Report, Status report on land and agricultural policy in
South Africa Institute for Poverty, Land and Agrarian Studies.
Harwood J, Heifner J, Coble K, Perry J, and Somwaru A. Managing Risk in Farming:
Concepts, Research, and Analysis. Market and Trade Economics Division and
Resource Economics Division, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of
Agriculture. Agricultural Economic Report No. 774.
Hawkins, R., Heemskerk, W., Booth R., Daane J., Maatman A. and Adekunle AA
(2009). Integrated Agricultural Research for Development (IAR4D). A Concept Paper for
the Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa (FARA) Sub-Saharan Africa Challenge
Programme (SSA CP). FARA, Accra, Ghana. 92pp.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
31
Laubscher, K. (2009). The influence of technology, input costs and infrastructure on
competitiveness, Paper presented at: AgriSA Agricultural Industry conference.
Makenete L. (June, 2010), Discussion paper for the Lesotho National Forum on
Agriculture and Food Security, Land and Agricultural Bank of South Africa, Pretoria.
Meyer, N.G., Breitenbach, M.C., Fenyes, T.I. and Jooste, A., (2009). Journal of
Development Perspectives Volume 3, The Economic Rationale For Agricultural
Regeneration and Rural Infrastructure Investment in South Africa.
Payne, B. (1994) Report: Farm worker housing in South Africa, (National Land
Committee.)
Philip, K. (2003). Co-operatives in South Africa: Their role in job creation and poverty
reduction, SA Foundation, Occasional paper. Retrieved from
http://www.businessleadership.org.za/documents/CooperativesInSA.pdf
Provincial Report on Education and training for Agriculture and Rural Development in
Limpopo Province by Mmbengeni M.E. and Mokoka M.S., Limpopo Department of
Agriculture. Retrieved from http://www.nda.agric.za/docs/et/Limpopo.pdf
Simbi, T.and Aliber, M. (2000). TIPS Forum 2000: Paths to Growth & Employment in
South Africa, Agricultural employment crisis in South Africa. Retrieved from
http:// www.tips.org.za/.../agricultural-employment-crisis-south-africa
The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited (2010) AGRIVIEW: Publisher: Information
Services Unit of the Agricultural Department. Retrieved from
http://www.standardbank.co.ls/SBIC/
Frontdoor_02_08/0,2454,7375713_7478475_0,00.html
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
32
Stilwell, T. and Atkinson, D. (1999). The economic rationale and modalities for rural
infrastructure development: developmental local government in rural service delivery.
DBSA, Midrand.
Taylor, J. (2010) Lending to Africa’s small holder farmers means improving efficiencies
throughout the value chain. (Standard Bank)
Van Empel, G. Nhlapo, K., Venter, J BATAT Series: Finance 6. Institutional
Arrangements and Financial Instruments for broadening access to financial services.
Retrieved from http://www.nda.agric.za/docs / Batat / batat _ series 6.htm
Vink, N. (2003). The Influence of Policy on the Roles of Agriculture in South Africa.
Taken from a report submitted to FAO on ‘Socio-Economic Analysis and Policy
Implications of the Roles of Agriculture in Developing Countries’. Department of
Agricultural Economics. University of Stellenbosch.
Whitfield, B., Lund, T. (2010, 29 July).Playing politics with food. Finweek, 18-19.
Willemse, J. (2006). Agricultural Economic Position of Agriculture in the Free State: an
overview, University of the Free State, 26 May.
APPENDIX 1: ABOUT THE VHEMBE REGION
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
33
Vhembe is situated in the Limpopo Province in the north-most part of the country that
borders Botswana and Zimbabwe.
VHEMBE AREA: SOME FACTS AND FIGURES
Population 1 240 035 (SA Stats, 2007)
Percentage of Blacks in the area 97%
Women as a % of the population 55%
People under the age of 15 37%
People living below the poverty line 65.2%
Unemployment 40% (versus national SA average of 30%)
Gini coefficient 0.64
Per capita income R11 100
Source: Global Insight: June 2006
Agriculture plays a significant role in the area and is rated as the second most important
source of employment. This contributed to our belief that success with the case study
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
34
could help alleviate poverty, create sustainable employment and benefit this poor
community.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
35
APPENDIX 2: GLOSSARY OF TERMSAgrarian transformation: Agrarian transformation is the rapid fundamental change in
the relations of land, livestock, cropping and community. It will focus on, but is not
limited to, the establishment of rural business initiatives, agro-industries, co-operatives,
cultural initiatives and vibrant local markets in rural settings, the empowerment of rural
people and communities (especially women and youth), and the revitalisation of old,
and revamping of new economic, social, and information and communication
infrastructure, public amenities and facilities in villages and small rural towns.
Secondary agricultural co-operative: A secondary co-operative is a co-operative
where the members are primary co-operatives. The purpose of a secondary co-
operative is to provide services to its members relating to the sector where they are
active. It takes at least two primary co-operatives to form a secondary co-operative.
Primary co-operatives which are involved in similar activities often come together in
secondary co-operatives.
Gini coefficient: The Gini coefficient is a measure of the inequality of a distribution, a
value of 0 expressing total equality and a value of 1 maximal inequality. It is commonly
used as a measure of inequality of income or wealth.
Emerging farmer: The emerging farmer is a term used to describe historically
disadvantage individuals that were excluded from the agricultural sector.
Value chain: A value chain is a collection of activities or interrelated sequential and
parallel functions involved in the production, manufacturing and marketing of foods.
Co-operative: A co-operative is an autonomous association of persons united
voluntarily to meet their common economic, social and cultural needs and aspirations
through a jointly-owned and democratically-controlled enterprise.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)
36
Permission to occupy (PTO): A PTO means that a person occupies an erf as if he or
she is the holder of the land tenure right in respect of that erf, but who is not formally
recorded in the register of land rights as the holder of the right in question.
Certificate to occupy (CTO): CTOs prove that, according to the law, the house or
building is in habitable condition. Generally, such a certificate is necessary to be able to
occupy the structure for everyday use, as well as to be able to sign a contract to sell the
space and close on a mortgage for the space.
Collateral security is one of the elements used by financiers in assessing emerging
farmers to access credit. As a result it is almost impossible for emerging farmers to
access credit from the primary lenders, such as commercial banks because they are
regarded as high risk and lack collateral.
Extension Officers: are individuals that provide technical support, i.e. soil testing,
fertiliser usage, crops to be planted etc.
Agri-finance - Agrarian reform: Syndicate 3 ALP project (100% draft submission)