EWRT 2

Class 7

AGENDA

• Vocabulary Test #3

• Review

• Counterarguments

• Conclusions

• Rhetorical Strategies: Aphorism and Chiasmus

• In-Class Writing: Counterarguments, Conclusions, Aphorism, Chiasmus

Take 20 minutes

Use a piece of notebook paper for your

answers

Review• Characteristics of your character

• At least six different methods

• The prompt• One of five: or you have blended two or more

• Directed Summary

• Working Thesis

• Outline

• Paragraph practice: Quotations with explanations

• An analogy or two

The Counterargument

A Counterargument• Address alternative opinions your readers might have

regarding your character. • Think about instances when your character appears to

act in a way that could be perceived as contrary to your thesis. Explain why you don’t see the behavior as contrary.

• Explain behaviors that are out of the ordinary or out of line with your thesis by analyzing text to show extenuating circumstances. Consider the arguing exercises

we have done in class. How might you address your peers’ questions and comments without the obvious question/answer format?

ConclusionGotta have it!

The ConclusionYou could discuss how this

character fits into the work as a whole.

You could address how the work would be changed if your character were gone.

You could apply insights about this character to a real-world situation. Do we grow as readers from interacting with your character?

You might SUBTLY remind the reader of your central idea and thesis.

Rhetorical Strategies

Learning to recognize themLearning to write them

Aphorism• An aphorism is a

saying—a concise statement of a principle—that has been accepted as true.

• Familiar example• “A penny saved is a

penny earned”• There is no fool like

an old fool”

Aphorisms

• Such statements have important qualities:• The are pithy: they say a great

deal in a few words.• They appear to contain wisdom:

they are delivered as truth and they have the ring of other aphorisms we accept as true.

Writing Aphorisms:Method One

• There is the ‘spontaneous combustion’ method, in which the aphorism flares out fully formed at unexpected moments, sending the writer scrabbling for napkins, envelopes or any other scrap of paper on which to write it down. Stanislaw Jerzy Lec was a great practitioner of this method:

No snowflake in an avalanche ever feels responsible.

Thanks to author and journalist James Geary for the information and examples of aphorisms: http://www.jamesgeary.com/blog/how-to-write-an-aphorism/

Method Two• Then there is the ‘deliberate composition’

method as practiced by the likes of La Rochefoucauld. He would attend a swanky salon, discuss all manner of subjects, such as love and friendship, then retire for hours to his room where he would produce several sheets of prose, all of which he would eventually distill down to one or two sharp, shining sentences: In the adversity of even our best friends

we always find something not wholly displeasing.

Method Three

• And then there are the ‘accidental aphorists,’ those writers who never intend to compose aphorisms but just can’t help themselves—aphorisms occur naturally within longer stretches of text, such as essays, novels, or poems. Ralph Waldo Emerson was a classic accidental aphorist:

What is a weed? A plant whose virtues have yet to be discovered.

Rules to Consider

• Keep it short (after all, only a fool gives a speech in a burning house),

• Definitive (no ifs, ands, or buts),

• Philosophical (it should make you think), and give it a twist.

Not fancy, just thoughtful

• What is a bastard? A man whose birth right overshadows his human rights.

• Bravery conquers fear; otherwise, it is stupidity.

• If Arya cannot save herself, she cannot hope to be saved.

Give it a try: Choose a word and write a short, pointed statement expressing a truth, doctrine, or

principle. • Power

• Execution

• Death

• Betrayal

• Prostitution

• Hostage

• Bastard

• Winter

• Brave

• Fear

• Throne

• Honor

Example: Marriage

A lottery in which men stake their liberty and women their happiness. -- Madame DiRieux

One long conversation, checkered by disputes. -- Robert Louis Stevenson

Chiasmus"to mark with

an X.”

The Oxford English Dictionary (OED) defines chiasmus as, "A grammatical figure by which the order of words in one of two of parallel clauses is inverted in the other.” This may involve a repetition of the same words ("Pleasure's a sin, and sometimes sin's a pleasure" —Byron) or just a reversed parallel between two corresponding pairs of ideas.

A reversed order of the grammar in two or more clauses in a sentence will yield a chiasmus.

Consider the example of a parallel sentence:

“He knowingly led and we blindly followed”

Inverting into chiasmus:

“He knowingly led and we followed blindly”

Simple Grammatical Chiasmus

From Writing with Clarity and style: Chapter 1 by Robert A. Harris

verb adverb verb adverb

verb adverb adverb verb

Try converting these two from parallelism to

chiasmus• Parallelism: Arya trains Nymeria daily

and plays with her happily

• Parallelism: When Jon Snow arrives at the wall, he seems happy enough, but when the arms master treats him badly, he is frustrated and angry.

Here are two possibilities

• Parallelism: Arya trains Nymeria daily and plays with her happily

• Chiasmus: Arya trains Nymeria daily and happily plays with her

• Parallelism: When Jon Snow arrives at the wall, he seems happy enough, but when the arms master treats him badly, he is frustrated and angry.

• Chiasmus: When Jon Snow arrives at the wall, he seems happy enough, but he is frustrated and angry when the arms master treats him badly.

Try it!

• Write a couple of sentences using chiasmus instead of parallelism.

• Try writing new sentences.

• Look for some sentences in your writing that will lend themselves to chiasmus.

• One of the most fascinating features of chiasmus is this "marking with an X" notion. Take Mae West's signature line, "It's not the men in my life, it's the life in my men." By laying out the two clauses parallel to each other, it's possible to draw two lines connecting the key words:

It's not the men in my life

X it's the life in my men.Thanks to author and psychologist Dr. Mardy Grothe for the

information and examples of chiasmus http://www.drmardy.com/chiasmus/definition.shtml

Word Reversal Chiasmus

Home is where the great are small

X and the small are

great

One should eat to live

X not live to eat

The ABBA Method

One other interesting way to view chiastic quotes is the ABBA method. Let's go back to the Mae West quote. If you assign the letters A and B to the first appearance of the key words and A' and B' (read "A prime" and "B prime") to their second appearance, they follow what is referred to as an ABBA pattern:

A It's not the men B in my life B' it's the lifeA' in my men

Chiasmus can also be achieved by reversing more than two key words. This observation from the 18th century English writer, Charles Caleb Colton, is a good example:

"How strange it is that we of the present day are constantly praisingthat past age which our fathers abused,and as constantly abusing that present age,which our children will praise.”

Laid out schematically, it looks like this:

A How strange it is that we of the present day are constantly praising B that past age C which our fathers abused, C' and as constantly abusing B' that present age, A' which our children will praise

Word Reversal

Another good example comes from Genesis 9:6:

A Whoever sheds B the blood C of man C' by man shall B' his blood A' be shed

Phrase Reversal

• "Lust is what makes you keep wanting to do it,even when you have no desire to be with each other.Love is what makes you keep wanting to be with each other,even when you have no desire to do it."

• — Judith Viorst

More Examples

• "We do not stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing." -- Benjamin Franklin

• "The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence." -- Carl Sagan

• “All for one and one for all” --Alexandre Dumas

• "I am stuck on Band-Aid, and Band-Aid's stuck on me."(advertising jingle for Band-Aid bandages)

Letter Reversal

• "A magician is a person who pulls rabbits out of hats.An experimental psychologist is a person who pulls habits out of rats.”

• "a doe and fawn" hide from "their foe at dawn."

Sound Reversal

•"I'd rather have a bottle in front of meThan a frontal lobotomy."

— Randy Hanzlick, title of song

Reversal of Homonyms

• "Why do we drive on a parkwayand park on a driveway?” — Richard Lederer

• "Here's champagne for our real friendsand real pain for our sham friends.” — Edwardian Toast

Number Reversal

• "A lawyer starts life giving $500 worth of law for $5 and ends giving $5 worth for $500.”— Benjamin H. Brewster

• "Errol Flynn died on a 70-foot boat with a 17-year-old girl.Walter has always wanted to go that way,but he's going to settle for a 17-footer with a 70-year-old.— Betsy Maxwell Cronkite, wife of Walter Cronkite.

Review and Practice: Try to use words and phrases that link to

your character• Word Reversal: One should eat to live not live to eat

• Phrase Reversal: Lust: keep wanting to do it, no desire to be with each other: Love: keep wanting to be with each other, even when you have no desire to do it.

• Letter Reversal: Rabbits out of hats: habits out of rats

• Sound Reversal: Bottle in front of me: frontal lobotomy

• Reversal of Homonyms: Drive on a parkway: park on a driveway

• Number Reversal: 70’ boat 17 year old girl: 17’ boat 70 year old woman

Homework

• Read A Game of Thrones through page 700

• Post # 12: Counterargument

• Post #13: Conclusion

• Post #14: Examples of aphorism and chiasmus