Everything You Wanted to Know About Hospital Clinics · © Wipfli LLP 2 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Two...
Transcript of Everything You Wanted to Know About Hospital Clinics · © Wipfli LLP 2 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW Two...
© Wipfli LLP 1
Everything You Wanted to Know About Hospital Clinics
Presented bySteven Rousso, MBA, MPA
Partner
© Wipfli LLP 2© Wipfli LLP 2
PRESENTATION OVERVIEW
Two Topics• Everything you wanted to know about hospital clinics
and….• Update on the new provider based reimbursement rules− Affecting all provider based entities including clinics
© Wipfli LLP 3© Wipfli LLP 3
CLINICS?
What is a Clinic?• Is it a license category?• Can it be a physician’s office?• Does it have to deliver medical care?• Do they have to be provider based if they are part of the
hospital?• Can they hire physicians?• Are there eligibility rules?• Are there federal regulations?
© Wipfli LLP 4© Wipfli LLP 4
CLINIC MODELS
License (if applicable) Dictates Clinic Model or Model will dictate License?• Both are interrelated
MY OTHER CAR
IS A GURNEY!
© Wipfli LLP 5© Wipfli LLP 5
DESIGNATION WILL DICTATE LICENSE
Federal designations such as Rural Health Clinics (RHC’s) & Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC’s) are not licenses
RHC’s can be physician offices, community clinics or hospital based departments
FQHC’s can be community clinics, county clinics (exempt from licensure) and even hospital based clinics• (no more hospital based clinics in California, expired in
1999)
© Wipfli LLP 6© Wipfli LLP 6
CLINICS - MYTH OR FACT?
Clinics always lose money on a direct basis Clinics can be used as a community investment tool Clinics receive more reimbursement than physician
practices Clinics need additional licensed personnel Clinics have special regulations Clinics must adhere to OSHPD 3 regulations Clinics need an approval by CDPH before they can
open
© Wipfli LLP 7© Wipfli LLP 7
OBJECTIVES FOR DEVELOPING CLINICS
Objectives of Clinics• Referrals?• Defend your backyard – locals rule!• Support Specialists• McDonalds Theory?• Expansion of primary care • Expansion of service area
© Wipfli LLP 8© Wipfli LLP 8
OBJECTIVES
Allows Hospitals to assume business risk Strategy to retain physicians who may otherwise
leave the area Strategy to build larger physician organization (e.g.,
1206 (l) medical foundation Were important in ACO development
© Wipfli LLP 9© Wipfli LLP 9
WHY DEVELOP THESE?
Level the playing field with competitors Physician Recruitment (physical space) Not all your eggs in one basket Where do you want to lose less? Community needs Ability to hire physicians Community Image Loss leader? Hospital/Physician Branding Physician requests
© Wipfli LLP 10© Wipfli LLP 10
WHO DEVELOPS CLINICS?
The Usual Suspects• Physicians• Community Clinics• Public Health Dept’s• County’s• Hospital’s• Academic Medical Centers• Districts• Walmart• Even SNF’s
© Wipfli LLP 11© Wipfli LLP 11
WHAT’S SPURRED THE GROWTH?
Clinic Volume Explosion – Why?• Treatments geared toward outpatient• Easy to get in game• Physicians wanting to be employed• Technology advances• Old provider based rules!• Reimbursement− FQHC’s, RHC’s
© Wipfli LLP 12© Wipfli LLP 12
FUTURE GROWTH?
Will This Growth Continue?• ACO’s & Medical Home?• Expansion of Medi-Cal eligibility – no longer applicable??
• Continued Technology Advances• Repeal of Corporate Practice?− CAH’s are allowed to hire physicians now!
• A relatively low investment• Continual shift towards outpatient services
© Wipfli LLP 13© Wipfli LLP 13
CLINIC ALTERNATIVES
Traditional Clinic Alternatives• MSO• Friendly PC• Foundation model (l)• Physician guarantees• Free market• All have business risk and legal considerations
© Wipfli LLP 14© Wipfli LLP 14
VARIOUS CLINIC MODELS
Clinic Models:• 1206 (b) – political subdivisions, districts, counties,
government entities• 1206 (d) – outpatient departments of hospitals• 1204 (a) Primary Care - community clinics − Ability to hire physicians
• RHC’s, FQHC’s – not really models• Retail Clinics• Urgent Care Clinics
© Wipfli LLP 15© Wipfli LLP 15
MODELS, CONT
Other Clinic Models• All exempt from licensure
− Foundation Model 1206 (l) − Academic Medical Centers 1204 (g)− Student Health Centers 1204 (j) − Clinics operated less than 30 hours (h)
~ Part of 1204(a) only
Clinic Models
© Wipfli LLP 16© Wipfli LLP 16
THE FUTURE?
© Wipfli LLP 17© Wipfli LLP 17
1206(D) HOSPITAL OUTPATIENT CLINIC
California• Title 22, Article 5 of the California Code of Regulations
(“CCR”)− General Requirements− Outpatient Service Requirements− Outpatient Service Equipment and Supplies− Outpatient Service Space
A lot of words but few real requirements
© Wipfli LLP 18© Wipfli LLP 18
LICENSING OPTIONS
1206 (d) Clinic?• Hospital Outpatient Department − Part of hospital− On license - required as a supplemental service− Easy application
• No separate provider numbers• Contract with physicians• Doesn’t require a survey • Will require OSHPD 3 sign off
© Wipfli LLP 19© Wipfli LLP 19
LICENSING OPTIONS
1206 (d) Clinic?• Advantages − Split billing− Medicare recent changes− Relatively easy application− No separate board− No real staff requirements− No minimum hours or service requirements− Hospital signage− No licensing fee− Medical records and other support and ancillary services
can be provided by Hospital
© Wipfli LLP 20© Wipfli LLP 20
LICENSING OPTIONS
1206 (d) Clinic?:• Disadvantages − OSHPD 3− Lose money, always− Overhead allocation you may not want!− May be perceived as competition by medical staff− Difficult to close down once you open− JCAHO− Scope of practice issues− Deductibles and co-pays under Hospital
~ Lots of complaints!
© Wipfli LLP 21© Wipfli LLP 21
OSHPD REQUIREMENTS
Licensed Entity = OSHPD 3 required Not Licensed = no requirement for OSHPD 3
• Its that’s simple!− And an architect’s sign off!
© Wipfli LLP 22© Wipfli LLP 22
1206(D) DISTANCE REQUIREMENTS
California• CA H&S Code 1250.8• 15 miles for maximum distance hospital physical plants can
be from one another if using the same license• Exception for outpatient services• No real distance requirement in California− (for outpatient clinics only)
• How can that be? However…
© Wipfli LLP 23© Wipfli LLP 23
CLINIC DISTANCE REQUIREMENTS
Medicare Distance Requirements• Not mandatory but advised
© Wipfli LLP 24© Wipfli LLP 24
MEDICARE DISTANCE RULES
Medicare Distance Requirements• 35 mile rule – to be provider based• 8 or 9 exceptions• Medicare only• There are no Medi-Cal provider based rules other than to
say they follow Medicare
© Wipfli LLP 25© Wipfli LLP 25
1206 (B)
Why These?• Exempt from licensure• Government entity− e.g., district hospital
• Easy to get in game• Mostly used as defense• Easiest of all models• No requirements• No JCAHO, No survey!
© Wipfli LLP 26© Wipfli LLP 26
1204 (A)
Primary Care Clinics:• Title 22 – 1204 H&S Code• Full application• Survey – 300 conditions• OSHPD 3• Fire Clearance• Medicare 855• Transfer agreement
© Wipfli LLP 27© Wipfli LLP 27
PRIMARY CARE CLINICS
Advantages:• Can hire physicians – really?− Not a regulation, AG’s opinion
• Non-profit and grant eligible• Off the Hospitals books• No overhead draw• No accreditation• Intermittent clinics• Pre-cursor to FQHC
© Wipfli LLP 28© Wipfli LLP 28
PRIMARY CARE CLINICS
Disadvantages:• RN requirement• Separate license and survey• OSHPD 3• Sliding fee scale requirement• Application fee• Timing, low priority for state surveys
© Wipfli LLP 29© Wipfli LLP 29
NO SUCH THING AS A HOSPITAL SATELLITE CLINIC
Unless you have a 1204 (a) - licensed community clinic
If you have 5 outpatient clinics:• 5 lines on your license
© Wipfli LLP 30© Wipfli LLP 30
URGENT CARE CLINICS
Not really a model No federal or state regulations No license or designation Any provider can basically say they offer urgent care
services
© Wipfli LLP 31© Wipfli LLP 31
WHAT ABOUT MEDICARE?
Medicare Enrollment:• 855 A, B, R, I• Or just bill under the Hospital’s outpatient number• Will Need NPI• Separate by location• Medicare doesn’t recognize clinic licenses• Its always enrollment
© Wipfli LLP 32© Wipfli LLP 32
OTHER CLINIC MODELS
FQHC’s and RHC’s Its raining money How does $300 a visit sound?
© Wipfli LLP 33© Wipfli LLP 33
RHC = RURAL HEALTH CLINIC
Eligibility• Rural – really non-urbanized
~ Census Bureau only!• Underserved designation− HPSA, MUA
• Hospital, community clinic or physician• Why go thru this? - its called $PPS• Enhanced Medi-Cal and Medicare reimbursement – great
model for rural hospitals
© Wipfli LLP 34© Wipfli LLP 34
FQHC = FEDERALLY QUALIFIED HEALTH CENTER
Eligibility• Underserved designation− MUA, MUP
• Community Clinic Licensed − Exempt if government entity
• Why go thru this? How about $$$• Enhanced Medi-Cal and Medicare reimbursement • Not a hospital program – Sorry− Community Board (not the hospital’s board) − Can support but not own− ED diversion program
© Wipfli LLP 35© Wipfli LLP 35
1206(L)
Medical Foundation preferred:• No license• Stable practice environment (W-2)• Single bill for patients• But for some reason, hospitals are reluctant to use
“systems” foundation model due to OH expense they get hit with!
© Wipfli LLP 36© Wipfli LLP 36
HAVE YOU THOUGHT OF THESE?
Other Considerations Before You Start Your Own Clinic• Views of Medical Staff• Scope of practice considerations, e.g., medical assistants• Union issues• JCAHO• Own line item & P&L• Provider based• Overhead draw• Licensing• Build vs. affiliate • Capital
CLINIC?
© Wipfli LLP 37© Wipfli LLP 37
HAVE YOU THOUGHT OF THESE?
Other Considerations• Building standards – UBC, OSHPD III• 3 day rule for Medicare admissions for same owners• Split billing• EMTALA− on and off campus
© Wipfli LLP 38© Wipfli LLP 38
WHICH CLINIC MODEL CAN HIRE PHYSICIANS
1206 L 1204 A 1204 G 1206 B
• If county− Not 1206 d’s
• But critical access hospitals can
© Wipfli LLP 39© Wipfli LLP 39
COMPENSATION TO PHYSICIANS
Payment Models• Contractor agreement• Hourly• RVU’s• Collections• Daily• Salary• Visit• Combination plate• RHC’s, FQHC’s− No physician billing!
© Wipfli LLP 40© Wipfli LLP 40
DON’T LOOK AT THE P&L OF CLINIC
Financial results are not the benefits of the clinic You wouldn’t look at the loss of physician
guarantees? Track referrals if possible
• Two or three inpatient referrals flips the switch!
© Wipfli LLP 41© Wipfli LLP 41
WHICH CLINIC MODEL IS FOR YOU?
Depends on what you want to accomplish?• Hire physicians• Recruitment• Referrals• Prevent physicians from leaving?• Expand service area?• Political?
© Wipfli LLP 42
Provider-based Regulations
© Wipfli LLP 43© Wipfli LLP 43
PROVIDER-BASED
Provider-based is a Medicare billing status and process for physician services that are provided in a hospital outpatient department
© Wipfli LLP 44© Wipfli LLP 44
NO ONE ELSE CARES THAT THE CLINIC IS PROVIDER BASED
Other Payers• Will just pay you like a physicians office• Provider based for Medi-Cal but free-standing with
Medicare?• License versus billing
© Wipfli LLP 45© Wipfli LLP 45
BACKGROUND OF PROVIDER BASED RULES
Outpatient departments and clinics that qualify for provider based status under Medicare receive higher reimbursement than those paid to a free-standing facility− Could be 40 to 50% higher
Provider based facilities are considered extensions of the main hospital, and due to the hospital regulatory requirements, this justified the higher reimbursement
Result: Significant increase in provider based clinics• Hospitals operating provider based clinics several states
away! Result: April 2000, CMS issued requirements for provider based
departments – specific criteria to asses this status− Employees, license, signage, integration, etc
© Wipfli LLP 46© Wipfli LLP 46
BACKGROUND OF RULES
Rules clarified in 2002 and amended April 2003:• Eliminated requirement for a provider to obtain affirmative
approval from CMS as a pre-condition for billing as a provider based facility
• CMS could go back and try to recover payment from provider based facilities if it is determined that the clinic wasn’t provider based
• If approved by CMS via the attestation process, and later determined that the entity wasn’t provider based, CMS will not try to recover prior payments
© Wipfli LLP 47© Wipfli LLP 47
SHOULD WE FILE AN ATTESTATION?
An attestation is a voluntary signed statement by the provider stating they meet all required provider-based criteria
Provides written support of compliant process Educates staff on requirements And avoids prior liabilities if you are not in compliance with
the provider based rules but have been billing as such• Differs depending on whether clinic is “on or off” campus• Off campus sites must submit documentation with attestation
© Wipfli LLP 48© Wipfli LLP 48
OIGS CONCERN
OIG’s 2009 and 2010 work plan included a significant focus on hospital owned facilities claiming provider based status:• Federal requirements for hospital based designation• Ensuring place of service codes has been correctly identified
RAC Audits - strong emphasis on reviewing place of service codes – guess why?
© Wipfli LLP 49© Wipfli LLP 49
WHY THE CONCERN?
Chief benefit – entitled to APC payments under Medicare
As well as physician payments• Two bills
− UB92− CMS 1500
© Wipfli LLP 50© Wipfli LLP 50
OIG’S WORK PLAN – 3 IMPORTANT PROVISIONS Provider based status for inpatient and outpatient facilities Hospital ownership of physician practices Place of service errors
• 22 for hospital outpatient setting• 11 for office setting
© Wipfli LLP 51© Wipfli LLP 51
DISTINCTION BETWEEN ON CAMPUS AND OFF CAMPUS SITES August 2002 – CMS makes important distinctions between on-
campus and off campus sites. Definition: Physical area immediately adjacent to the providers
main building, other areas and structures that are not strictly contiguous to the main building, but are located within 250 yards of the main building.
© Wipfli LLP 52© Wipfli LLP 52
REQUIREMENTS FOR ON AND OFF CAMPUS CLINICS Licensure Ownership control Administration and Supervision Public Awareness Financial Integration Clinical Integration
− Integrated medical staff− Integrated medical records− Quality monitoring
© Wipfli LLP 53© Wipfli LLP 53
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR OFF CAMPUS CLINICS Must meet all the standards applicable to on-campus sites but
have additional requirements including: Ownership Administration and Supervision Location in immediate vicinity
− 35 mile rule comes into play− Straight line – not road miles
© Wipfli LLP 54© Wipfli LLP 54
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR BOTH ONAND OFF CAMPUS CLINICS: EMTALIA – doesn’t apply for off campus Site of service Provider agreement Non discrimination Billing of Medicare patients Facility fee to Medicare patients but not required for other payers Payment window
© Wipfli LLP 55© Wipfli LLP 55
ADDITIONAL OBLIGATIONS FOR OFF CAMPUS SITES
Informing Medicare beneficiaries• How much is patients liability?
Physician supervision• Must be present
© Wipfli LLP 56© Wipfli LLP 56
MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS
Management contracts for on campus and off campus provider based sites are permissible, however, for off campus you must meet the following criteria:• The provider, not the management company must employ all
direct patient care staff• Facility must be integrated with main provider• The management contract must be held by main provider, not
parent organization
© Wipfli LLP 57© Wipfli LLP 57
PROVIDER-BASED CLINICS - SHOULD YOU OR SHOULDN’T YOU? Evaluating Benefits vs. Costs of Converting to Provider-Based Clinic Status Financial Analysis
• Reimbursement impact• Conversion costs
Physician Relations• Employed versus contract physicians
Other Objectives• Internal politics• Community relations/perceptions• Competition• Compliance
© Wipfli LLP 58© Wipfli LLP 58
HELPFUL HINTS
Evaluate your provider-based facilities – are you billing as such? Internally audit for compliance with ALL provider-based
requirements Review on campus versus off campus requirements and
obligations Ensure billing is properly identified and using the proper
modifier(s) and POS code
© Wipfli LLP 59
Steven Rousso, MBA, MPAPartnerWipfli/HFS Health Care Practice 510 768 [email protected]
QUESTIONS
© Wipfli LLP 60
hfsconsultants.com