Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006...

15
Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou
  • date post

    30-Jan-2016
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    226
  • download

    0

Transcript of Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006...

Page 1: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Errors in the magnetic field vector

determination with HMI

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Juan M BorreroSteven Tomczyk

Aimee NortonJesper Schou

Page 2: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Overview

● Simulations: synthesis & inversion● Adding Solar p-modes● Adding noise● Temporal averages● HMI expected errors in B-field determination● Future work & Improvements

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 3: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Simulations: synthesis & inversion

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 4: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Adding Solar p modes

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 5: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Adding photon noise

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 6: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Temporal averages (1)

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 7: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Temporal averages (2)

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 8: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

HMI expected errors (1)

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 9: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

HMI expected errors (2)

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

download document at: http://web.hao.ucar.edu/hmi

Page 10: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Future work

● Speed of the inversion●Shown simulations: 15 pixels/min●Current: 150000 pixels/min (SVM in progress)●Goal: 1600000 pixels/min

● Non-magnetic component● These simulations are simple !

●Use more complex atmosphere for the synthesis●Compare with Stokes profiles emerging from 3D simulations

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 11: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Stokes Profiles

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 12: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

HMI Filters

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Page 13: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Solar p modes

Page 14: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Support vector machines

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

● are obtained through statistical learning (Vapnik & Chervonenkis 1968; 1974 ...)provided multiples examples of:

● there is a trade off between #sv, accuracy, speed and generality

Page 15: Errors in the magnetic field vector determination with HMI HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006 Juan M Borrero Steven Tomczyk Aimee Norton Jesper Schou.

Comparison with simulations

HMI+AIA Meeting, Monterey, Feb 14 2006

Courtesy of Alexander Voegler & Luis Bellot