EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate...

16
EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE CARLOS EDUARDO CÁRDENAS, El Paso Attorney at Law State Bar of Texas 35 th ANNUAL ADVANCED CIVIL TRIAL COURSE 2012 San Antonio – July 25-27 Dallas – August 22-24 Houston – October 17-19 CHAPTER 27

Transcript of EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate...

Page 1: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

CARLOS EDUARDO CÁRDENAS, El Paso Attorney at Law

State Bar of Texas 35th ANNUAL

ADVANCED CIVIL TRIAL COURSE 2012 San Antonio – July 25-27

Dallas – August 22-24 Houston – October 17-19

CHAPTER 27

Page 2: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation
Page 3: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

CARLOS EDUARDO CÁRDENAS

Attorney & Counselor At Law

[email protected]

The Law Firm of Law Offices of

Carlos Eduardo Cárdenas, P.C. Joseph (Sib) Abraham, Jr.

1104 Nueces Of Counsel,

Austin, Texas 78701 717 E. San Antonio Street

(512) 478-7463 El Paso, Texas 79902

(915) 544-7860

EDUCATION

Georgetown University, B.S. in Business Administration 1977

The University of Texas , J.D. 1980

PROFESSIONAL AWARDS & CERTIFICATIONS

College of the State Bar of Texas 1985-1990

Board Certification in Administrative Law- 1989-1999

Texas Board of Legal Specialization

Martindale-Hubbell, Peer Review Rated AV 2005- Present

Founding Life Fellow- El Paso Bar Foundation 2008

American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA) 2009-Present

Pro Bono College- State Bar of Texas 2009

Recognized by the Texas Bar Journal as “Access to Justice January, 2010

Pro Bono Champion”

Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010

El Paso Lawyers for Patriots

Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation 2010

State Bar of Texas-Certificate of Appreciation 2011

Texas Lawyers for Texas Veterans

Black El Paso Democrats-Certificate of Appreciation 2011

Community Service-Equal Access to Justice

PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS & ACTIVITIES

District IX Committee on Admissions-Texas Board of Law Examiners 1990-1991

Board of Directors – El Paso Bar Association 2002-2011

President 2009-2010

El Paso Bar Association Fee Dispute Committee 2006-2010

State Bar of Texas Hispanic Issues Council 2007-2011

State Bar of Texas Local Bar Services Committee 2007-2012

Chair 2011-2012

Council of the Litigation Section-State Bar of Texas 2008-Present

Speaker, State Bar of Texas Webinar-Legislative Update on Litigation June, 2009

Speaker, Panel Discussion-State Bar of Texas- Bar Leaders Conference- July, 2010

Texas Lawyers for Texas Veterans

Speaker, Panel Discussion-State Bar of Texas-Bar Leaders Conference- July, 2010

Pro Bono Fundraising

Co-Course Director- State Bar of Texas-Litigation Update Institute 2011, 2012

Speaker, State Bar of Texas Advanced Civil Trial Course 2011, 2012

Commissioner, Texas Access to Justice Commission 2011-Present

Board of Directors-Texas Civil Rights Project 2011-Present

Revised July 5, 2012

Page 4: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation
Page 5: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACCESS TO JUSTICE COMMISSION ........................................................................................................................ 1 THE FACE OF POVERTY ........................................................................................................................................... 2 HOW IS POVERTY DEFINED? .................................................................................................................................. 3 JUSTICE GAP ................................................................................................................................................................ 3 LEGAL SERVICES PROGRAMS ................................................................................................................................. 4 PRO BONO HELP IS NEEDED .................................................................................................................................... 4 CASES TURNED DOWN .............................................................................................................................................. 5 GAPS IN CIVIL LEGAL SERVICES ............................................................................................................................ 5 LEGAL AID PROGRAMS THROUGHOUT THE STATE .......................................................................................... 6 PROVIDING LEGAL SERVICES TO THE POOR ...................................................................................................... 6 STATE BAR OF TEXAS ............................................................................................................................................... 7 AREAS IN NEED OF ASSISTANCE ........................................................................................................................... 7 HOW TO HELP ON YOUR OWN ................................................................................................................................ 8 SBOT LEGAL SERVICES SUPPORT DIVISION ....................................................................................................... 8

Page 6: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation
Page 7: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

CARLOS EDUARDO CÁRDENAS

EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE

Attorney at LawEl Paso, Texas

State Bar of Texas 35th Annual ADVANCED CIVIL TRIAL COURSEADVANCED CIVIL TRIAL COURSE

July 27, 2012 – San AntonioAugust 24, 2012 – Dallas

October 19, 2012 – Houston

orneys

ivate

 att

mak ing  a  d i f f e r en ce

pri

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

1

Page 8: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

The Face of Poverty

Did you know:y

• In Texas, more than               6 million people qualify for legal aid.

The Face of Poverty

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

2

Page 9: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

How is Poverty defined?

Legal Aid eligibilityg g y125% of Federal poverty level

$13,963 per year for a single person

$28,813 per year for a family of fourA f il f f i l th $2 401 th

A minimum wage worker earns $15,080 per year.

A family of four survives on less than $2,401 per month

• Law offices, neighborhoods,

Justice Gap

and churches

• Court houses — pro se litigants

• Natural disastersNatural disasters

• Current economic downturn 

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

3

Page 10: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

Programs funded by the        

Legal Services Programs

g yLegal Services Corporation (LSC)

Legal Aid of NorthWest Texas

Lone Star Legal Aid

Texas RioGrande Legal Aid

Pro Bono Help is Needed

There is one Texas attorney in private practice for every 392 Texansfor every 392 Texans

There is only Texas legal aid attorney for every 11,152 poor Texans

:

:

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

4

Page 11: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

Cases turned down

Met Need

Almost one‐half of all otherwise eligible cases are rejected by Legal Aid for lack of resources

Unmet Need

Need for civil legal services amongst poor Texans

Gaps in Civil Legal Services

Inadequate Resources—available resources do not meet the demand for servicesdo not meet the demand for servicesLack of money to hire an attorneyLack of funding for legal services

Funding RestrictionsType of legal services

providedpClient eligibilityResource limit

Geographic limitationsRural vs. Urban

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

5

Page 12: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

Legal aid programs throughout the state

To contact the legal aid provider in your area, visit: provider in your area, visit:

www.TexasLawHelp.org

Providing Legal Services to the Poor

• Legal Services Programs

• Private Attorneys –

Pro BonoPro Bono

• Self Help

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

6

Page 13: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

State Bar of Texas

• Aspirational standard– 50 hours a year 

• What constitutes pro bono?

– Pro bono policy

– FAQs

• Report your Pro Bono Hours

– Online: www.texasbar.com/mybarpage 

Areas in Need of Assistance

Types of Legal Aid CasesF il & D ti Vi lFamily & Domestic Violence

Immigration

Housing Law

Probate, Torts, & Incorporation

Social Security, Food Stamps, y pother gov't benefitsConsumer Protection

Education & Juvenile Rights

Health Care

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

7

Page 14: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

How to help on your own

Time CommitmentTime Commitment

2 – 50 hours

Type of work

Legal RepresentationLegal Representation

Advice and Counsel

Document Review

Mentoring

SBOT Legal Services Support Division

Support Provided for Pro Bono Attorneys, Legal Aid and ATJ infrastructure 

• Malpractice insurance  

• TexasBarCLE scholarships 

• Mentor/Mentee MCLE credit 

• Pro Bono CollegePro Bono College 

• Sign Up Fund 

• Referral Directory 

• Emeritus Attorney Program 

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

8

Page 15: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation

Hannah Silk Kapasi512.427.1859  or   800.203.2222, Ext. 1859

[email protected]

Equal Access to Justice Chapter 27

9

Page 16: EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE - TexasBarCLE · Ft. Bliss Office of the Staff Judge Advocate-Certificate of Appreciation 2010 . El Paso Lawyers for Patriots . Life Fellow- Texas Bar Foundation