Comparing the TCO of Physical PCs, VDI, and Cloud-hosted ...
Enterprise Cloud System (ECS) -...
Transcript of Enterprise Cloud System (ECS) -...
Enterprise Cloud System (ECS) TCO Comparisons with Competitive Cloud Solutions Jose Castano Director, IBM System z New Workloads & Solutions
Fehmina Merchant, Ph. D. Senior Consulting Engineer, IBM Competitive Project Office
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
2
10101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110
10101010101011010101010110101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010
10110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101
10101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010
10100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101
01010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010110101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010
10101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110
10101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101
01000010101101010110101010101010110101010101101010101010110101010101010101110100101001010101010011010101101010100001010110101
01101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010
00010101101010110101010101010110101010101101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101
01011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010
10101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011
01010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101
01010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101101010101001101010110101010000101
01101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011
01010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101
01001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010
10101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010
10101011010101010110101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101
01011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010
10000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001
10101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101
01010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010110101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010
11010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011
01010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000
10101101010110101010101010110101010101101010101010110101010101010101110100101001010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010
10101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101
01101010110101010101010110101010101101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110
10101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010
10011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101
01010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101
01010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101101010101001101010110101010000101011010
10110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101000010101101010110101010101010110101010101010101010100110101011010101
00001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011010101101010100001010110101011010101010101011010101010101010101010011
01010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010101010101001101010110101010000101011010101101010101010101101010101010
Software as
a Service DevOps
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
Hybrid
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
Cloud with Linux on
System z
App Dev cloud Maximize efficiency by tapping
unutilized resources
z/OS® cloud Core business operations
enabled as cloud services
Hybrid cloud Maximum flexibility through
use of on- and off-premise
resources
Linux® on IBM System
z® cloud Highly efficient fully
virtualized infrastructure
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
0
System z: The dynamic cloud for extreme flexibility and value
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
zEnterprise redefines efficiency & economics of IT enabling new levels of business agility
3
Delivering superior service at
lower cost than legacy x86 or Public
Cloud vendors
Saved
$46 million through consolidation
Cut datacenter costs by
70%
0
50
100
150
200
250
100 200 500 1600
Number of virtual servers
Co
st p
er
virt
ua
l se
rve
r
3200
Enterprise
Linux server
Public Cloud
x86 Largest MSP in Africa leveraging System z to
bring cloud to new markets
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
IBM Enterprise Cloud System Trusted Cloud. Simply Delivered.
4
Award Winning
Hardware Design
Fully Automated Cloud
Management Suite
Standard Linux
Environment • Red Hat/SUSE
• 3000+ Applications
Trusted, 24/7
IBM Support
Hypervisor and
Virtualization
Management
Utility Pricing and MSP
Flexible Financing
Factory Integrated
Delivered in 45 Days
Production Ready in Hours
Scale up to 6000 VMs
Mainframe Availability
Proven Server Security
{ }
{ } }
{ Memory
IFLs
I/O and Network
Linux Guests
Linux Guests
Linux Guests
Virtualization Management
LPAR LPAR LPAR
Enterprise Cloud System based
on zBC12* Server
Cloud Management
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Reduce costs with a System z private cloud
5
03. Advantages of a private cloud on zEnterprise
Server configurations are based on equivalence ratios derived from IBM internal studies. Prices are in US currency and will vary by country. Public cloud case includes
costs of hardware (instances, data in/out, storage, support, free tier/reserved tier discounts), software (middleware) and labor. IBM zEnterprise® and x86 cases include
costs of hardware (system, virtualization, OS), software ( cloud mgmt, middleware), power, floor space and labor.
34% and 73% less cost
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Agenda
6
Assumptions
– TCO model
– Platforms – Enterprise Cloud System, x86 cloud, public cloud
– Workloads – Heavy I/O, medium, very light dev/test
Two TCO studies
– 398 workload case
– 48 workload case
Summary
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
TCO Model
7
More than 30 cost variables – Blade and IFL amount and costs
– Memory amount and costs
– Storage amount and costs
– PVU counts
– Cost of hypervisors
– Cost of cloud management software
– Cost of operating system
– Cost of middleware
– Cost of hypervisor maintenance
– Cost of cloud management maintenance
– Cost of operating system maintenance
– Cost of middleware maintenance
– Power consumption
– Cost of power
– Space taken
– Cost of space
– Admin rate
– Efficiency factors for labor
– Number of FTE
– Number and type of instances
– Cost of instances
– Amount of data in/out
– Cost of data in/out
– Enterprise support costs
Placed in four categories – Hardware – Software – Labor – Power and Space
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
8
Enterprise Cloud System Assumptions
Hardware costs include: ELS, storage, z/VM®, IBM Wave for z/VM and SLES
Software costs include: – WebSphere® Application Server ND (middleware)
– Cloud Management Suite for System z (SmartCloud Orchestrator, Tivoli® OMEGAMON® for z/VM and Linux, Tivoli Storage Manager EE),
– Tivoli software for z/VM (Operations Manager for z/VM, Backup and Restore for z/VM)
Labor costs included to manage both hardware and VMs
Power/floor costs included
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
9
x86 Cloud Assumptions
Hardware costs include: x86 hardware with competitor hypervisor, SLES
Software costs include: – WebSphere Application Server ND (middleware)
– SmartCloud Orchestrator
– SmartCloud Monitoring
– Tivoli Storage Manager EE
Labor costs included to manage hardware and VMs
Power/floor costs included
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
10
Public Cloud Assumptions
Each workload deployed as a separate instance
Reserved instances with heavy utilization pricing model used
Hardware costs include:
– Instances in east US region with SLES, EBS volume, data in/out, support
(enterprise), free and reserved tier discounts applied
Software costs include: WebSphere Application Server ND (middleware)
costs for instances
Labor costs included for managing instances
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
11
Workload Assumptions
Workloads run 24x7
3 types of workloads
– Heavy I/O
• Online web application driving 22 transactions per second with 1 MB I/O per transaction
– Medium
• Online web application driving 22 transactions per second with light I/O
– Very light
• Dev/test environment for web application driving a few transactions per second
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Which option costs less for delivering mixed workloads?
12
Which option provides the lowest TCO over 3 years?
Public Cloud
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
Private Cloud (x86)
398 workloads
87 medium workloads
39 heavy I/O workloads
272 very light workloads
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Platform requirements for deploying workloads with heavy I/O
13
39 heavy I/O workloads
Online banking workloads, each driving 22 transactions
per second with 1MB I/O per transaction
Server configurations derived from IBM internal studies.
39 cc2.8xlarge
reserved instances
26 IFLs
624 x86 cores
Public Cloud
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
Private Cloud (x86)
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Platform requirements for deploying medium workloads
14
87 medium workloads
87 c1.medium
reserved instances
14 IFLs
Online banking workloads, each driving 22
transactions per second with light I/O
Server configurations derived from IBM internal studies.
24 x86 cores
Public Cloud
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
Private Cloud (x86)
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Platform requirements for deploying very light workloads
15
272 m1. small
reserved instances
8 IFLs
Server configurations derived from IBM internal studies.
28 x86 cores
272 very light workloads
Dev/test workloads, each driving a few transactions
per sec
Public Cloud
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
Private Cloud (x86)
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Public Cloud
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
Private Cloud (x86)
Cloud on System z yields the lowest costs
16
$37.0M (3yr TCO)
$18.3M (3yr TCO)
$9.4M (3yr TCO)
398 reserved instances
48 IFLs
676 x86 cores
49 and 75%
less cost
Server configurations are based on equivalence ratios derived from IBM internal studies.
Prices are in US currency and will vary by country. Public cloud case includes costs of
hardware (instances, data in/out, storage, enterprise support, free tier/reserved tier
discounts), software (middleware) and labor. zEnterprise and x86 cases include costs of
hardware (system, virtualization, OS), software ( cloud mgmt, middleware), power, floor
space and labor.
398 workloads
87 medium workloads
39 heavy I/O workloads
272 very light workloads
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Enterprise Cloud System delivers lowest TCO
17
Server configurations are based on equivalence ratios derived from IBM internal studies. Prices are in US currency and will vary by country. Public cloud
case includes costs of hardware (instances, data in/out, storage, enterprise support, free tier/reserved tier discounts), sof tware (middleware) and labor.
zEnterprise and x86 cases include costs of hardware (system, virtualization, OS), software ( cloud mgmt, middleware), power, floor space and labor.
49 and 75%
less cost
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Which option costs less for delivering mixed workloads?
18
Which option provides the
lowest TCO over 3 years?
Public Cloud
Private Cloud (x86)
48 workloads
10 medium workloads
3 heavy I/O workloads
35 very light workloads
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Cloud on System z yields the lowest costs
19
$3.9M (3yr TCO)
$1.6M (3yr TCO)
Public Cloud
Private Cloud (x86)
48 reserved instances
55
x86 cores
Server configurations are based on consolidation ratios derived from IBM internal studies.
Prices are in US currency and will vary by country. Public cloud case includes costs of
hardware (instances, data in/out, storage, enterprise support, free tier/reserved tier
discounts), software (middleware) and labor. zEnterprise and x86 cases include costs of
hardware (system, virtualization, OS), software ( cloud mgmt, middleware), power, floor
space and labor.
48 workloads
10 medium workloads
3 heavy I/O workloads
35 very light workloads
$1.0M (3yr TCO)
6
IFLs
34 and 73%
less cost
Cloud on System z (Enterprise Cloud
System)
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Enterprise Cloud System delivers lowest TCO
20
Server configurations are based on equivalence ratios derived from IBM internal studies. Prices are in US currency and will vary by country. Public cloud case includes
costs of hardware (instances, data in/out, storage, enterprise support, free tier/reserved tier discounts), software (middleware) and labor. zEnterprise and x86 cases
include costs of hardware (system, virtualization, OS), software ( cloud mgmt, middleware), power, floor space and labor.
34 and 73%
less cost
20
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
21
Summary
Up to 75% lower total cost of ownership than leading public
cloud provider
Up to 49% lower total cost of ownership than x86 private cloud
Lower software (middleware) license costs from running
workloads more efficiently
Lower labor, energy and floor space at scale
21
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Q&A
#mainframe50
#mainframe
© 2014 IBM Corporation
IBM Competitive Project Office
Questions? Comments? Tell us what you think.
#mainframe