Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final...
Transcript of Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final...
![Page 1: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler Engineering
Art Ragauskas, Yulin Deng
Institute of Paper Science and Technology
![Page 2: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Agenda 2020: Aggressive goals for cost reduction
R&D Focus AreasSteam and Electrical Savings Cost
Savings($/ton)Million Btu/ton Trillion Btu/ year
Pulping/ Bleaching 1 80 $37
Black Liquor Concentration 2 100 $10
Causticizing 2 100 $17
Dewatering/ Drying 2.5 250 $12
Increased Filler/ Sustainable, Cost-Effective Pigments 3.6 75 $35
Sheet Property Development 1 50 $18
![Page 3: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Our Approach: Filler Treatment Using Starch
Filler
Starch adsorbed on filler Starch coated on filler aggregate
StarchIn traditional papermaking
Our approachfiber
fiber
Coated Filler
![Page 4: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Previous Key findings• Mill trials
– Several mill trials have been done, and the longest trial is 11 days. All trials run very well and no break associated to the trials. The trials show that
– Starch coated filler does not detrimentally impact linerboard sheet strength up to filler content of 5%
– Significant gains in productivity (up to 6%) were achieved relative to typical run rates (speed increases >30 m/min on some grades)
– Reduced ~10% steam demand • Laboratory works
– The starch coated filler shows higher strength properties than traditional wet end application
– The fillers can be used for multi-grades of papers– Saving drying energy by >10%– Two modification methods (wet and spray drying) have been
developed– Our techniques can be used for both PCC and clay
![Page 5: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Objectives
• Develop a modify starch coated clay filler technology for GA SW bleached kraft, linerboard, folding carton, and newsprint.
• Incorporate 5-10 % modified filler into newsprint and 10-20% modified filler for copy paper.
• Develop a wet starch-precipitation method for onsite PCC filler modification at paper mills
• Provide papermakers a predictive relationship between modified filler content and dewatering and drying properties for GA’s newsprint and print grades (Note: The research done in FY09 focused on clay in linerboard and will be extended to other grades in FY10)
![Page 6: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Two Methods for Filler Modification with Starch Coating
Starch coated clay: spray dry method
Starch coated clay: wet precipitation method
![Page 7: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Impact of Traditional Filler in Linerboard Using unmodified Clay Filler
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Control (0) 2.5 5% Filler in board
STF
I (N
m/g
)
4.8% loss from
unfilled9.5% loss from
unfilled
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Control (0) 2.5 5% Filler in board
STF
I (N
m/g
)
4.8% loss from
unfilled9.5% loss from
unfilled
66.5
77.5
88.5
99.510
10.511
Control (0) 2.5 5% Filler in board
Rin
g C
rush
(Nm
/g) 7% loss
from unfilled 14% loss
from unfilled
66.5
77.5
88.5
99.510
10.511
Control (0) 2.5 5% Filler in board
Rin
g C
rush
(Nm
/g) 7% loss
from unfilled 14% loss
from unfilled
4 mill trials have been done by Imerys at different mills Linerboard and starch coated filler made by spray drying was used
![Page 8: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Accomplishments in FY09-10• Filler Modification methods:
– Wet Slurry Method for starch coating: Starch-clayComposite with Fatty Acid Precipitation
– Wet Slurry Method for starch coating: Starch-PCCComposite with Fatty Acid
– Wet Slurry Method Using CMC Coated PCC• Modified filler characterization
– Particle size, shear resistance, zeta potential • Paper Grades
– Linerboard– Newsprint
![Page 9: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Starch/fatty acid modified clay for linerboard application
Starch-fatty acid form a complex which can be precipitated by lowing pH
or adding Ca2+
Godet, M.C., et al., Carbohydrate Polymers, 1993. 21: p. 91.
![Page 10: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Characterization of Starch Coated Clays by Fatty Acid Precipitation Method
• The properties of the starch-modified fillers are important– What are the surface charge?– How much starch are coated and how much
will dissolve in wet water? Will that are problems?
– What is the size of precipitated filler-starch aggregates?
– Does the aggregate size shear sensitive?
![Page 11: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Starch Coating Efficiency wt. of initial starch - wt. of dissolved starchcoating efficiency % 100%
wt. of initial starch
No. Conditions Starch concentration in the water(ppm)
Coating efficiency (%)
1# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=5% 61.86 98.02 2# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=10% 59.70 98.09 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=20% 57.16 98.17 5# starch:filler=1:8, fatty acid=10% 57.71 98.15
Note: The starch dosage is 3.125g, the filler dosage is 4 times or 8 times of starch.
Conclusion: At various conditions, >98% of starch will be coated on filler surface
![Page 12: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Zeta Potential
-50-45-40-35-30-25-20-15-10-50
0 5 10 15 20 25
Fatty acid/starch ratio (%)
Zeta
Pot
entia
l (m
V)
Zeta potential of starch-fatty acid coated clay increases as the fatty acid concentration increases. The low zeta potential can improve the retention of fillers on fiber surface
Reason: the negative charges on clay surface are shield by coated starch layer.
![Page 13: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Particle sizes of the aggregates of starch modified clay under shear
The aggregate size is between 23-33 micrometers
It decreases with the shear time, but the decrease is not significant, suggesting the starch-fatty acid complex on the clay surface is strong
Agitation speed: 1000 rpm
![Page 14: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Starch-fatty acid modified fillers for improving linerboard properties
• Previous works, including mill trials, are based on the filler made from spray drying method
• Starch-fatty acid precipitation method can be applied to paper mills without significantly change their facilities
![Page 15: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Starch-fatty acid modified fillers for improving linerboard properties
Pulp Furnish: Old corrugated containerClay: Kaolin Clay (provided by Imerys)Raw Starch: B200 (Corn starch, Grain process)Cationic starch (added in wet end, for comparison)Fatty acid: Palmitic acidCationic retention aid: Percol-175Handsheet basis weight: 180g/m2
![Page 16: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
10
20
30
40
50
0 3 6 9 12
Tens
ile in
dex
(N•m
/g)
Filler content/%Tensile index vs Filler content
Cationic Starch
Modified Clay (1:4)
Modified Clay (1:1)
Bursting index vs Filler content
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
0 3 6 9 12Filler content/%
Bur
stin
g in
dex
(kPa
•m2 g
/g)
Cationic Starch
Modified Clay (1:4)
Modified Clay (1:1)
Linerboard (from OCC) properties
Modified clay 1:4 means 1 part of starch with 4 parts of clayCationic starch addition: 6 lb/ton
![Page 17: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Stiffness vs Filler content
500
1000
1500
2000
0 3 6 9 12Filler content/%
Stiff
ness
(mg)
Cationic Starch
Modified Clay (1:4)
Modified Clay (1:1)
Tearing index vs Filler content
8
10
12
14
16
0 3 6 9 12Filler content/%
Tear
ing
inde
x (m
N•m
2 /g)
Cationic Starch
Modified Clay (1:4)
Modified Clay (1:1)
Linerboard (from OCC) properties
Modified clay 1:4 means 1 part of starch with 4 parts of clayCationic starch addition: 6 lb/ton
![Page 18: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Newsprint (wet method):Effects of Different Starch Addition Methods
on Physical Properties
0.1P-1S-3F donates: 0.05 part of palmitic acid, 1 part of starch 3 parts of filler
0.1P-1S-3F donates: 0.1 part of palmitic acid, 1 parts of starch 3 parts of filler
![Page 19: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Effects of Different Starch Addition Methods on Physical Properties
![Page 20: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Effects of the Fatty Acid on Physical Properties
![Page 21: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
One concerns of using fatty acid in paper is the reduction of the friction of the
paper sheets.The handsheet was adhered on the
surface of aluminum alloy plate andput a 2 grams stainless balance weight on the top of handsheet. Slowly raise the aluminum plate up till the weight started to move. Record the angle that weight starts to move as the measured friction. The less friction force of paper, the smaller angle the weight starts to move.
Friction Comparison
Handsheet
![Page 22: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Conclusions for starch-fatty acid coated fillers
• Starch-Palmitic Acid-Clay composite is easy to make in mill.
• The sheet properties of newsprints and linerboard from OCC can be improved.
• Coated starch on filler surface is better than directly adding cationic starch to the wet end.
• There is no significant decrease in friction when filler dosage up to 20% and palmitic acid usage up to 20% of starch.
![Page 23: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Linerboard with PCC modified with CMC
• Pulp Furnish: Old corrugated container• PCC:Albarca HO (Specialty Mineral Inc,
USA)• Cationic starch• CMC (Aldrich)• Cationic retention aid: Percol-175• Handsheet basis weight: 180 g/m2
![Page 24: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
CMC and CMS Precipitation Mechanism
• CMC is anionically charged water-soluble polymer. When cationically charged polyDADMAC is added, the neutralization reaction will result in water-insoluble polymer complex that can precipitate on filler surface.
CMC structure and possible reaction between CMC and polyDADMAC
![Page 25: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Fibrous PCC Aggregates from CMC Precipitation
300 m
![Page 26: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Linerboard (OCC) made from CMC coated PCC
Bulk vs Filler content
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2
0 2 4 6 8 10Filler content/%
Bul
k (c
m3 /g
)
Original PCC
CMC+Original PCC
CMC Modified PCC
Tensile index vs Filler conten
30
40
50
60
70
0 2 4 6 8 10Filler content/%
Tens
ile in
dex
(N•
m/g
)
Original PCC
CMC+Original PCC
CMC Modified PCC
![Page 27: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Linerboard (OCC) made from CMC coated PCC
Bursting strength vs Filler content/%
300
400
500
600
700
800
0 2 4 6 8 10Filler content/%
Bur
stin
g st
reng
th (k
Pa)
Original PCC
CMC+Original PCC
CMC Modified PCC
Stiffness vs Filler content
1100
1300
1500
1700
1900
2100
0 2 4 6 8 10Filler content/%
Stiff
ness
(mg)
Original PCC
CMC+Original PCC
CMC Modified PCC
![Page 28: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Tearing resistance vs Filler content
1500
1700
1900
2100
2300
2500
0 2 4 6 8 10Filler content/%
Tear
ing
resi
stan
ce (m
N)
Original PCC
CMC+Original PCC
CMC Modified PCC
Linerboard (OCC) made from CMC coated PCC
![Page 29: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Where is the technique standing?
• Starch-fatty acid precipitation method– A US patent application based on wet slurry
method has been filed by Georgia Tech• Spray-drying method
– It is commercially available – Being developed for applications
• Several companies have been interested the technique– Developing mill specific projects– Fillers work reviewed at IPST workshops
![Page 30: Energy Saving in Papermaking Through Advanced Filler ...biorefinery.utk.edu/technical_reviews/Final Review 2010.pdf · 3# starch:filler=1:4, fatty acid=15% 58.89 98.12 4# starch:filler=1:4,](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060706/6072596ab7f86139a357a036/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Future Works
Developing a consortium on Filler-Reduced Energy Consortium
Looking at Barrier Properties