Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS...

21
CMS PRS-μ, CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV μ’s Stefano Lacaprara [email protected] INFN and Padova University Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-μ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV μ’s – p.1/21

Transcript of Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS...

Page 1: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

PRS-µ, CMS week

CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003

Energy loss study of TeV µ’s

Stefano [email protected]

INFN and Padova University

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.1/21

Page 2: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

MotivationIncreasing interest in high pt muons,

Eg. Z ′ search,

Large room for improvements and

optimization in actual muon reconstruction,

Major concern is energy loss (brem) along

muon trajectory,

How to recognize it?

How to improve muon fit?

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.2/21

Page 3: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS ApproachesSo far a “top-bottom” approach

Look at high level reconstruction quantities (such asdi-µ invariant mass) and see the effect of differentreconstruction algorithms on it: eg Truncated MuonReconstructionEffect on 1/pt resolution and pullsLook at Kalman filter output (χ2)Found possible algorithm optimization

Try “Bottom-top” approachLook at MC to see how high pt muons behaves inCMSLook at energy deposit along muon trajectoryLook at hits multiplicity on muon chambersLook at pt, η reconstructed in Tracker and Muonsystems alone

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.3/21

Page 4: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

ToolsSample single µ, mixed charge, pt = 1 TeV , |η| < 2.5,CMSIM 133Maybe not the best sample: at high η the pµ

t is notrelevant for CMS (e.g. p ≈ 3.5 TeV ). Will try p = 1 TeVStandard geometry (with wrong Al and DT gas densityin DT system)Reconstruction with ORCA 813 (plus various bugs fix, tobe released in 820 soon)Check µ energy loss in Tracker (from IP to outermost Tklayer), Calo’s (outermost Tk – innermost Muon station),Muon (innermost – outside)Compare µ energy loss with SimHits multiplicityDitto for RecHits (layer hits)η independent study

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.4/21

Page 5: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ energy loss (fraction)hEnLossTotFrac

Entries 99044

Mean 0.03039

RMS 0.06768

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

10

210

310

410

hEnLossTotFrac

Entries 99044

Mean 0.03039

RMS 0.06768

tot

tk

calo

mu

Total muon energy loss (fraction) hEnLossMuFrac

Entries 99044

Mean 0.01336

RMS 0.04578

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

1

10

210

310

410

510

hEnLossMuFrac

Entries 99044

Mean 0.01336

RMS 0.04578

mu

sta 1->2

sta 2->3

sta 3->4

Muon muon energy loss (fraction)

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.5/21

Page 6: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ energy loss calo vs SimHit mult.

# SimHits station 10 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

frac

µ loss

E

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

210

310

410

vs. # SHs st. 1µEn. loss

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.6/21

Page 7: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ energy loss calo vs RecHit mult.

# RecHits station 10 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

frac

µ loss

E

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

210

310

410

vs. # RHs st. 1µEn. loss

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.7/21

Page 8: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ energy loss Muon vs SimHit mult.

# SHs st. 2

0 50 100 150 200

en.

loss

µFr

ac

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

st. 1->2

# SHs st. 3

0 50 100 150 2000

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

st. 2->3

# SHs st. 4

0 50 100 150 2000

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

210

310

410

st. 3->4

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.8/21

Page 9: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ energy loss Muon vs RecHit mult.

# RHs st. 2

0 50 100 150 200

en.

loss

µFr

ac

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

st. 1->2

# RHs st. 3

0 50 100 150 2000

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

st. 2->3

# RHs st. 4

0 50 100 150 2000

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

210

310

410

st. 3->4

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.9/21

Page 10: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

P µt Tk-Muon vs Calo En. loss

(pt outermost Tk st. - pt innermost Mu st.)/Gen. pt

calo (frac)µlossE

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

)/Gen

first

-Mu

last

(Tk

µPt

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

10

210

310

Pt Tk- Pt Muon vs En. loss calo

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.10/21

Page 11: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

χ2 Muon Fit vs Calo En. loss

calo (frac)µlossE

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

fit

µ^2

χ

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

10

210

310

^2 Muon Fit vs En. loss caloχ

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.11/21

Page 12: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

ηµ Tk-Muon vs Calo En. loss(η at outermost Tk station - η innermost Muon station )

calo (frac)µlossE

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

)/Gen

first

-Mu

last

(Tk

µEt

a

-0.3

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

210

310

410

Eta Tk- Eta Muon vs En. loss calo

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.12/21

Page 13: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

Conclusion and futureVery preliminary study,Preliminary conclusion: hits multiplicity is not correlatedwith energy loss! Cannot use Muon station ascalorimeter!Not correct to rely on hit multiplicity to stop fit of muontracjectory,Need to use also station with very high multiplicity in thefitFirst test (not shown here) to “clusterize hits” incrowded chambers (DT), without pattern recongitionlooks not too bad,Naïve test of pt, ∆η, chi2 Tk vs Mu not very promisingMust repeat with OSCAR (also for cross check),More appropriate sample (p = 1 TeV ?)Must check energy measured by calo’s...

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.13/21

Page 14: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS Backup

Backup slides

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.14/21

Page 15: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

∆Pt/Pt µ Muon only

-10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 100

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

µ p_t/p_t ∆

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.15/21

Page 16: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

∆Pt/Pt µ Tk only

-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 20

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

18000

20000

µ p_t/p_t ∆

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.16/21

Page 17: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

∆Pt/Pt µ Tk+Mu

-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 20

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

18000

20000

22000

µ p_t/p_t ∆

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.17/21

Page 18: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ Charge assignment Mu only

-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5

410

510

µCharge ass.

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.18/21

Page 19: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ Charge assignment Tk only

-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5

310

410

510

µCharge ass.

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.19/21

Page 20: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ Charge assignment Tk+Mu

-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5

310

410

510

µCharge ass.

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.20/21

Page 21: Energy loss study of TeV ’slacaprar/talks/PRSMU_20040608.pdf · 2004-06-08 · CMS PRS- , CMS week CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 Energy loss study of TeV ’s Stefano Lacaprara Stefano.Lacaprara@pd.infn.it

CMS

µ Charge assignment Tk+Mu Vs EnLoss Calo

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

210

310

410

En. loss (frac) CaloµCharge ass.

Stefano Lacaprara – PRS-µ, CMS week, CERN, Tuesday 8 June 2003 – Energy loss study of TeV µ’s – p.21/21