ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the...

50
A product of WRI Ross Center for Sustainable Cities RAJEEV G MALAGI, SENIOR PROJECT ASSOCIATE, WRI INDIA ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT A tool for community engagement to decision making

Transcript of ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the...

Page 1: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

A product of WRI Ross Center for Sustainable Cities

RAJEEV G MALAGI, SENIOR PROJECT ASSOCIATE, WRI INDIA

ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSITA tool for community engagement to decision making

Page 2: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SURESH - BENGALURU

I prefer riding for 40 min to office than taking the metro for 15 min. I don’t like ‘bargaining’ my auto ride from my house to metro.

Page 3: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

LEELA BEN - AHMEDABAD

As much as I love taking the ‘BRT bus’, I struggle to reach home every day as I have to walk through dark isolated roads in the night.

Page 4: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

BABU LAAL - DELHI

Its really tough to get customers because of e-rickshaws, autos and bikes. So we have to set higher fares to earn minimum money on a daily basis.

Page 5: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

WHAT ARE WE MISSING?

Page 6: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

NEED FOR SAFE ACCESS• Cities are investing millions of dollars in creating mass transit

• Often unable to achieve their full potential due the poor first and last mile connectivity leading to unsafe access to transit systems.

• This has led to the inefficient use of transit systems and unsafe conditions in station areas

• Hence a safer and seamless access needs to be provided in cities to discourage private transport and encourage public transport.

Page 7: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

NEED FOR SAFE ACCESS

• These should not just be infrastructural but also an experiential approach

Page 8: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT

Page 9: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

FLOW OF PRESENTATION1. PART 1 - TOD recap

– What is Transit Oriented Development– A livable station area– Main streaming TOD– SAM as public engagement tool

2. PART 2 - Safe Access to Mass Transit– What is safe access – Principles of Safe Access– Need for tool

3. PART 3 – A reality check – Applications– Implications

4. Conclusion

Page 10: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENTTransit Oriented Development, involves creating concentrated nodes of moderate-to-high density developments supporting a balanced mix of land uses around transit stations.

TOD

ZO

NES

MM M

Station area

Page 11: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

OUR APPROACH TO TOD

Page 12: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
There are three crucial factors to facilitate TOD implementation in Indian cities i.e. Design, Regulatory framework and Funding/Financing.
Page 13: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

DESIGN INTERVENTIONS

Walking & bicycling (complete Streets)

Public Transport(Integrated Transport)

Active edges (Enhanced Safety and Security)

Environmental & Cultural Landscapes

Public Spaces(Enhanced public realm)

Travel Demand Management

(Parking Management)

Mixed Use & Density(Compact Development)

Page 14: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

DEMONSTRATION PROJECTS

NAVANAGAR TOD PROJECT

Page 15: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

FINANCING

Page 16: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

CAPACITY BUILDING

DESIGN REGULATORY FRAMWORK FINANCE

Presenter
Presentation Notes
To tie the three crucial factors, it is also critical that we keep building capacities of all the stakeholders.
Page 17: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Transit Oriented Development

(TOD)

Regulatory framework and

financing

Safe Access to Mass Transit

Station Access & Mobility Program

(STAMP)

Multi-Modal Integration

(MMI)

Neighborhood Improvement Program (NIP)

MAINSTREAMING TOD

Page 18: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAM AS A PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT TOOL• There is a need to make

TOD as an inclusive process

• Need for a ‘people centric approach’

• Hence a participative public consultation process becomes very critical

Page 19: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT

Page 20: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

WHAT IS SAFE ACCESS • Creating safe conditions for

pedestrians and cyclists• Prioritize walkability in

station areas

Page 21: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Image Source: Meena Kadri/ flickr

A station area is a place of connectivity where different modes of transportation come together seamlessly and where work, live, shop and play can happen simultaneously.

A STATION AREA

Page 22: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Image Source: EMBARQ India

A PEOPLE CENTRIC APPROACH

PRINCIPLES OF SAFE ACCESS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementation, maintenance and evaluation of station areas in four broad stages The Manual emphasises NMT safety and infrastructure, women’s security and universal accessibility. This Manual recognizes the role of existing providers such as street vendors, informal bicycle renting systems etc. and the use of streets as public spaces in Indian cities. Additionally the Manual also suggests strategies to create integrated public transit options and methods to manage the movement of motorized modes within station areas. The Manual suggests key takeaways for planning, institutional structures and financing mechanisms to facilitate timely implementation of station accessibility plans. And finally the Manual embeds evaluation as a critical aspect of station accessibility planning, implementation and maintenance.
Page 23: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

PEDESTRIAN & CYCLING PRIORITY

• Interconnected

neighbourhoods & city

networks

• Safe and comfortable

pedestrian & cycling

infrastructure and

services

Page 24: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ENHANCED PUBLIC REALM• Imageable public area• Streets as public spaces• Signages

Page 25: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

FEEDER INTEGRATION

• Access to IPT

• Seamless integration of

various modes including

information systems

• Bus priority measures

Page 26: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

PARKING MANAGEMENT

• Regulate parking

• PBS

• Prioritize feeder bus

services

• Shared Parking

• Parking Management

Plan

Page 27: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ENHANCED SAFETY AND SECURITY

• Road Geometrics

• Traffic calming, pedestrian &

NMT movements

• Safe streets and amenities

Page 28: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

WHAT IS SAFE ACCESS WORKSHOP • A platform to ideate and co-create last-mile connectivity

solutions around mass transit stations.

• Aim - To educate the participants regarding the need for safe access to the mass transit systems like BRT and Metro and to Derive actionable strategies

Page 29: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

OBJECTIVES• Inculcate awareness about the importance of safe and

equitable access;

• Derive implementable solutions, while negotiating the complexities involved in their adoption;

• Prioritizing through community inputs to help voice people’s opinions;

Page 30: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

THE INTERACTIVE EXERCISE

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 31: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

INTERACTIVE BOARD

Page 32: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Moderator

Govt. Authority Grandfathe

r

Woman on wheelchair Teenager

on cycleCar owner

Private developer

citizen roles

GROUP : Require at least 5 members in a groupROLE PLAY

Presenter
Presentation Notes
1 govt role and 1 pvt role must be assigned per table Any 3 of the public roles can be randomly assigned to the other 3 members at the table
Page 33: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ROLE PLAY CARDS

Page 34: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

• A strategy is designated for the table• There are two sub-items per strategy

THE INTERACTIVE BOARD

Page 35: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Step 1 Choose 2 of 6 strategies ‘individually’ based on your role • 1st from Option a,b,c and

• 2nd from option d,e,f

THE INTERACTIVE BOARD

Page 36: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Step 2 Choose 2 of 6 strategies ‘collectively’ based on common consensus • 1st from Option a,b,c and

• 2nd from option d,e,f

THE INTERACTIVE BOARD

Page 37: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAM APPLICATIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

Page 38: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAM ACROSS VARIOUS PLATFORMS

10+WORKSHOPS IN INDIA

2 INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOPS -AFRICA & TAIWAN

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 39: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ENGAGEMENT WITH PEOPLE ON GROUND - KOCHI

Engagement with local communities for 2 station areas

Page 40: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

INFORMING POLICIES

KOCHI Signage & safe access audit

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 41: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ENTREPREUNEUR ENGAGEMENT

STAMP Station Access & Mobility Program

Page 42: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

ENTREPREUNEUR & CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT

STAMP Station Access & Mobility Program

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 43: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SMART CITY ENGAGEMENTS - DAVANAGERE

Kick off workshop for Area based development work

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 44: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

STAMP

NagpurTraining the trainers

BUILDING CAPACITIES

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 45: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

STAMP

Kaohsiung, Taiwan Eco mobility conference

MASTER CLASS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 46: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

STAMP

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaLUTP workshop

TRAINING THE EXPERTS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
including letting you know the nearest station, provides fare calculation, online smartcard recharge
Page 47: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SUMMARYPART 1 - TOD recap

– What is TOD– Main streaming TOD

PART 2 - Safe Access to Mass Transit– What is safe access – Principles of Safe Access– Need for tool

PART 3 – A reality check– Applications– Implications

Page 48: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

Can we start relooking into the idea of Mass transit not as individual infrastructure components but as livable spines of the

city?

Can we look at safe access around mass transit as a ‘people oriented and a collaborative approach?

IN CONCLUSION

Page 49: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

SAFE ACCESS TOOLKIT

Page 50: ENABLING SAFE ACCESS TO MASS TRANSIT · The key messages in the Manual are as follows – the Manual suggests a participatory process to tie the planning, implementatio\൮, maintenance

THANK [email protected]