Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана...

94
Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy As represented in an official Muscovite diploma4c emblem book, Tsarskii Tituliarnik (Царский Титулярник), of 1672: Hermitage copy. It was commissioned by the powerful boyar (бояр) Artamon Matveev, who ran the diploma4c chancery (Posol’skii Prikaz Посольский Приказ) 4ll his downfall in 1682. The Tituliarnik was updated and con4nued in use in the early C18 th . It contained [imagined?] portraits of past Tsars and Patriarchs, and [real?] portraits of foreign rulers contemporary with Tsars Aleksei Mikhailovich and Fëdor Alekseevich. Some copies of the book record it was compiled by a Moldavian diplomat in Muscovite service, Nikolai Gavriilovich Mileskii‐Spafari, and his clerk (d’iak дьяк), Peter Dolgovo. The aquarelle and gold‐leaf designs were executed by ar4st crajsmen associated with workshops in the Armoury of the Moscow Kremlin (Oruzheinnaia Palata Оружейнная Палата). Accurate records of official emblems, rulers’ official 4tles and portraits were essen4al tools for Muscovite diplomats trying to restore Muscovy’s status in Europe’s state system ajer the disasters of the Time of Troubles. hqp://www.emc.komi.com/02/08/img/003.jpg .

Transcript of Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана...

Page 1: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

EmblemoftheTsardomofMuscovyAsrepresentedinanofficialMuscovitediploma4c

emblembook,TsarskiiTituliarnik(ЦарскийТитулярник),of1672:Hermitagecopy.Itwascommissionedbythepowerfulboyar(бояр)

ArtamonMatveev,whoranthediploma4cchancery(Posol’skiiPrikazПосольскийПриказ)4llhis

downfallin1682.TheTituliarnikwasupdatedandcon4nuedinuseintheearlyC18th.Itcontained[imagined?]portraitsofpastTsarsandPatriarchs,and[real?]portraitsofforeignrulerscontemporary

withTsarsAlekseiMikhailovichandFëdorAlekseevich.SomecopiesofthebookrecorditwascompiledbyaMoldaviandiplomatinMuscovite

service,NikolaiGavriilovichMileskii‐Spafari,andhisclerk(d’iakдьяк),PeterDolgovo.Theaquarelleandgold‐leafdesignswereexecutedbyar4stcrajsmenassociatedwithworkshopsintheArmouryofthe

MoscowKremlin(OruzheinnaiaPalataОружейннаяПалата).Accuraterecordsofofficialemblems,

rulers’official4tlesandportraitswereessen4altoolsforMuscovitediplomatstryingtorestoreMuscovy’sstatusinEurope’sstatesystemajerthedisastersof

theTimeofTroubles.hqp://www.emc.komi.com/02/08/img/003.jpg.

Page 2: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVGroznyiinthemodernRussianimagina;on(1897)

ViktorMikhailovichVasnetsov(1848‐1926)

TheVasnetsovimageinfluencedSergei

Eisenstein’sfamousfilmof1943:thefilm’sposterbelow.

Page 3: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Awe‐‐Groza‐‐Гроза• AuthoroftheVarlaam[Monastery]Speech(VarlaamskaiaBesedaВарлаамскаяБеседа)writes(variouslydatedtomid‐C16th,last

decadeofC16thorfirstofC17th)ofthemonarch’shumble/humblingawe(smirennaiagrozaсмиреннаягроза)

• IvanPeresvetov(wri;ng1550s)sees‘awegrozaгроза’asa

guaranteeofjus;cethroughresolveandfirmness;kindnessruinsstates,andadmirestheviolenceofMehmedII

• a1570lelerby‘ParfeniitheHolyFool(IurodivyiЮродивий)’–possiblyapseudonymofIvanIV,oratleastsomeonewri;nginthesamewayasIvanwassupposedtohavewrilentoaPolishdiplomat,

JanRokytein1570–praisesthe‘awegrozaгроза’ofArchangelMichael:

ГрозныйисмертносныйангелAwesomeangelofdeathСтрашныйпосланецTheterriblefinalmessenger

Page 4: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

HolyFool(IurodivyiЮродивий)–theopposite

ofGroza

Icon(1584)in‘TheWordofGod’BogoiavlenskiiMonasteryin

Kremenets‐Podol’sk,Ukraine,toStSemën:barefoot,i4nerant,ojennakedand/orprophe4c,someonefeebleinmindand

bodybutnotinspirit,someone‘foolishforGod’,someone

whomweshouldhonourandfeed.

hqp://cerkva.if.ua/index.php?

id=1856&ac4on=art

Page 5: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TheHolyFool(IurodivyiЮродивий)StAndrew

Mid‐C16thicon,MoscowschoolofDionisii.

HewassaidtoamanumiqedScythianslavelivinginConstan4nopleonthecuspoftheC9thand

C10th.Theicontellsthestoryofhislifeanddeeds,star4ngcentretoplejandmovingclockwise.He’sinspiredbyStJohntheBap4stwhilepraying,buthe’stemptedbycallousyouths(bearingcrownsof

falseglory)anddemons,allofwhomheovercomeswhenChristappearstohim(topright)andhedecidestotakeontheroleofbeggarinthestreets.Hethenperformsmiraclesinthestreetsofthegreatcity:makingtheplagueonlyaffectagrave‐robber,banishingademoninguiseofanoldwomanblockingaroad,andredeeminga

monkwho’stoogreedy.Byboqomlej,hemeetsKingDavidhimselfinHaghiaSophiaandthenheseesavisionoftheVirginMaryintheChurchatBlachernae,ontheshoreoftheGoldenHornin

Constan4nople,beforehedies(toplej).

IrinaShalina’scatalogueitem73inTheGatesofMystery:TheArtofHolyRussia,Cambridge,TheLuqerworthPress,n.d,ci4ngTheRussianMuseum,StPetersburg,inventory

itemДРЖ1219.

Page 6: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

HansWeygelwoodcut(1563)

HabsburgGermanwoodcutimagesupposedlyofIvanIV,addedtoalateredi4onofSigismundvonHerberstein’smemoirofvisitstoMuscovyin1517&1526.TheimageisaGermanfancyofwhataRussianprincemightlooklike,asitaddsacircletcrown(ofthekindfavouredbyC3rdRomanemperorslike

ClaudiusIIGothicus)tothefur‐trimmedgolden‐capthenknowntobewarnbyaMuscoviteGrandPrince(HerbersteinsawandaccuratelydescribedthecapofMonomakh.)

BibliothèquedesartsdecoraBfs,Paris

(BridgemanArtLibraryUniversalImagesGroup)

hqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/slovo/ivan4.html;SergeiBogatyrev’s‘BronzeTsars’inPersonality&PlaceinRussianCulture,London,MHRA,2010,pp.54‐55.InsetcoinimageofClaudiusIIGothicus.

Page 7: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Saxon‐German‐Livonianengravedportraitof

IvanIV

Engraving(ajerWeygel)fromPaulOderborn’sLifeofIvanIV(1585)wriqeninLa4n‘IohannisBasilides.

MagniMoscoviæ,Ducisvita’.Oderbornwasfrom

Wiqenberg,upperSaxony,anddrewonLivoniansources.

ЭпохаИванаГрозного/FaithandPower:TheAge

ofIvantheTerrible,Москва,МинистерствокультурыимассовыхкоммуникацийРоссийскойФедерации,Федеральноеагентствопокультуре

икинематографии&Федеральноегосударственноеучреждениекультуры,

Государственныйистопико‐культурныймузей‐заповедник«МосковскийКремль»2007,

fron4spiece;hqp://www.nasledie‐rus.ru/img/

870000/870401s.jpg&hqp://www.mab.lt/evangeliku/images/

oderborn.jpg.

Page 8: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ImaginedPortraitofIvanIV(b.1530,reigning1547‐84)

ComposedfortheTitularnik

(Титулярник)of1672

Portrety,gerbyipechaBBol'shoigosudarstvennoiknigi1672g.

Портреты,гербыипечатиБольшойгосударственнойкниги1672г.

hqp://viva�omenko.narod.ru/lib/pictures/page_005.htmlandonlineinNewYorkPublicLibrary,imageID:1542610@hqp://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/index.cfmandЕ.С.

Овчинников,ПортретвРусскомИскусствевека:МатериалыиИсследования,Москва1955,pp.64‐78.

Page 9: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

LateC17thEffigyPortrait(ПарсунаPersona)of

IvanIVinthemannerofanicon(withoutahaloнимб)?

OneofthefirstalemptsatsecularportraitureinMuscovy,thoughitis

paintedbyicontechnique(temperaandoilonwood)anditishardly“realis;c”.Itisrecordedasagi�byTsarFëdorIIIAlekseevichin1677toaDanishenvoy,FriedrichvonGebel.Thereareclear

affini;eswiththeTituliarnikТитулярникportraitof1672.Thefirstliterarydescrip;onofIvanIVisinI.M.

Katyrëv‐Rostovskii’s‘Tes;monial(Povest’Повесть)’of1626.

NaBonalmuseet,Copenhagen:

EthnographicCollec4onhqp://www.natmus.dk/sw20374.asp

Е.С.Овчинников,ПортретвРусскомИскусствевека:МатериалыиИсследования,Москва1955,pp.62‐64

hqp://www.cartage.org.lb/en/themes/arts/pain4ng/religious‐paint/icon‐paint/introd/parsunas/parsunas.htmandhqp://nesusvet.narod.ru/ico/books/lepahin_4/img/

ioann_vasilyevich_groznyi.jpg;;LindseyHughes,“ImagesoftheElite”,ForschungenzurosteuropaischenGeschichte,56(2000).

170.

Page 10: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Lecturer’ssnapshotfromNaBonalmuseetinCopenhagen

Page 11: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Soviet‐eraCranio‐FacialReconstruc;on(1963‐65)ofthe

faceandphysiognomyofIvanIVatthe;meofhisdeath(1584)basedonhisskull

inhistombatArkhangel’skiiSobor,intheMoscowKremlin

byaSamarkand‐based(Russian‐Uzbek)sculptorandarchæologico‐anthropologist,Mikhail

MikhailovichGerasimov(1907‐70)

RussianAcademyofSciences(RAN)Ins4tuteofEthnologyandAnthropologynamedforMikhlukho‐Maklai(IEA),

Moscow.hqp://img1.liveinternet.ru/images/aqach/c/

0/34/47/34047538_IoannIV_reconstruc4on_by_Gerasimov02.jpg&

hqp://img‐fotki.yandex.ru/get/3707/irina05012009.2a/0_19001_2eb91ff6_L

Page 12: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Icon:TheBlessingoftheProtec;veVeil(Покров)ofourLady(Богородица),theMotherofGod(Богоматерь).Iconorigina;ngfromNovgorod,1550sormid‐C16th.Liketheholywhitecowl(белыйклобук),theiconhonoursanotherlegi;ma;ngrelic:aholyveilwhichsupposedlyturnedbackaSlav[ironically!]siegeofConstan;noplein860or944.ThisveilwasseenbyStAndreiIurodivyi(HolyFool)inBlachernaeChurchinConstan;noplearound1000,andthenbroughtfromConstan;noplebyKievanprinceAndreiBogoliubskiitoRus’inC12th.TheiconshowstheMuscovite‐Byzan;neidealoftheharmonyofChurchandState;theTsarisamongclergyandsaints.Theykeephimstraightandtrue.

ПокровБогородициorПокровБогоматериStateRussianMuseum,StPetersburgГосударственныйРусскойМузейhqp://www.pravoslavie.ru/jurnal/4515.htmorhqp://hramznameniya.ru/photo/?id=160detailbolomle�Tsar(IvanIV?)andTsarina(Anastasiia?)inChurch

Page 13: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ThesourceoftheHansWeygelimagesupposedlyofTsarIvanIVVasil’evichin

1563isveryprobablythis(equallyinvented?)imagefromthelate1520s

ofIvanIV’sfatherGrandPrinceVasiliiIIIIvanovich(b.r.)

composedbyErhardSchön(1491‐1542)

andpublishedbyHansGuldenmundasasetofexo4cisingimagesof

Muscovites,nowlost.(SchönalsoproducedimagesofOqomanTurks.)

ErhardSchönwasaProtestantbasedinNuremburgmakingwoodcutimagesaimedatthemeshethoughtwouldbe

popular.

MuseumBoijmansvanBeuningen,Roqerdam,TheNetherlands

(hqp://www.boijmans.nl/nl/)hqp://collec4e.boijmans.nl/en/work/MB

%202010/2%20Q%20(PK)

Page 14: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Augus;nHirschvogel(1490or1503to1553)

Re‐workedversionofHirschvogel’sengravingof

GrandPrinceVasiliiIIIIvanovich(b.1479,r.1505‐33).

ThehatandkajanbeqerresembleHeberstein’sdescrip4on,thoughhedescribedanewly‐marriedVasilii

IIIin1526asclean‐shaven.BogatyrevexplainstheimagewasfirstmadeinViennain1547foraseriesofcontemporaryrulerportraits.Hirschvogelthenwentontomake23etchingsfora1549re‐edi4onofHabsburgambassador,SigismundvonHerberstein’smemoirof

journeystoMuscovyin1517&1526(hqp://www.rechercheisidore.fr/search/resource/?

uri=ark:/12148/btv1b59053148).HirschvogeladmiredHerberstein.ThoughhewasaProtestantfrom

Nuremburg.HirschvogelalreadyhadexperienceofHabsburgSlaviccultures,havinglivedinLjubjanainSloveniabetween1536‐44.Hestartedoutasa

mathema4cianandmap‐maker,usingmethodsoftriangula4ontoproducemoreaccuratemaps.AjerhemovedtoViennain1544,hefocussedonengraving

images.

hqp://historydoc.edu.ru/aqach.asp?a_no=413;SergeiBogatyrev’s‘BronzeTsars’inPersonality&PlaceinRussian

Culture,London,MHRA,2010,pp.55‐57.

Page 15: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Muscovitediploma4cguidebook,theTsarskiiTituliarnik(ЦарскийТитулярник),of1672:ImaginedportraitsofTsarIvanIVGroznyiГрозный.

Threecopiesweremade:oneisintheRussianStateArchiveofAncientActs(РГАДАhqp://www.rusarchives.ru/federal/rgada/nsa1.shtml)inMoscow,anotherisintheSaltykov‐ShchedrinlibraryinSt

Petersburg,andthethirdisintheHermitageinStPetersburg.hqp://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ivan_grozny_frame.jpg

&hqp://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Iioan4.jpg.

Page 16: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

LateC17thicon‐like‐portrait(ParsunaПарсуна)inthe

monasteryofAleksandrovskSloboda,whereIvanIVlocatedthecapitalofhis

“Widow’sKingdom”(Oprichnina

Oпричнина)between1564and1572,andwhereheo�enretreatedtoseek

solace.

ReprintedinСергейВладимировичФомин,ПравдаопервомРусскомЦаре:

КтоиПочемуискажаетобразГосударяИоаннаБасильевича(Грозного),Москва,«РусскийИздательскийЦентр»2010.

Page 17: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Thereisafadedlate‐C16thfrescoofIvanIVandhisboyarsinthemalemonastery,fortandchurchof‘ТheAssump;onofOurLady,theHolyVirgin(СоборУспенияПресвятойБогородицыСвияжского

БогородицеУспенскогомужскогомонастыря)’,1551‐61,inSviazhsk,nearKazan’onthemiddleVolga,avitalcentrefortheconquestoftheMoslemKhanateofKazan’in1552:

reprintedinСергейВладимировичФомин,ПравдаопервомРусскомЦаре:КтоиПочемуискажаетобразГосударяИоаннаБасильевича(Грозного),Москва,«РусскийИздательскийЦентр»2010.Image

ofthechurchfromtheKazanBishopric(Eparchate)website:hqp://kazan.eparhia.ru/www/fototemple/2_84790046296.jpg&

hqp://mtdata.ru/u1/photoFA92/20987456535‐0/big.jpeg.

Page 18: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Fadedmid‐C16thfrescoofIvanIVatSviazhk,near

Kazan’

Page 19: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Icon:TheBlessingoftheProtec;veVeil(Покров)ofourLady(Богородица),theMotherofGod(Богоматерь).Iconorigina;ngfromNovgorod,1550sormid‐C16th.Liketheholywhitecowl(белыйклобук),theiconhonoursanotherlegi;ma;ngrelic:aholyveilwhichsupposedlyturnedbackaSlav[ironically!]siegeofConstan;noplein860or944.ThisveilwasseenbyStAndreiIurodivyi(HolyFool)inBlachernaeChurchinConstan;noplearound1000,andthenbroughtfromConstan;noplebyKievanprinceAndreiBogoliubskiitoRus’inC12th.TheiconshowstheMuscovite‐Byzan;neidealoftheharmonyofChurchandState;theTsarisamongclergyandsaints.Theykeephimstraightandtrue.

ПокровБогородициorПокровБогоматериStateRussianMuseum,StPetersburgГосударственныйРусскойМузей,N.H.Likhachëvcollec4on.hqp://www.pravoslavie.ru/jurnal/4515.htmorhqp://hramznameniya.ru/photo/?id=160detailbolomle�Tsar(IvanIV?)andTsarina(Anastasiia?)inChurch

Page 20: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TheTsariselectedbyGod;БогоизбранностьРусскогоЦарства

Tsar(IvanIV?)andTsarina(Anastasiia

Romanovna?)

DetailfromthePokrovBogoroditsaПокровБогородицаicon,firsthalfofC16th,nowin

StateRussianMuseum,StPetersburg,N.H.Likhachëvcollec;on.

Ontheholyday(prazdnikпраздник)ofthe‘FeastoftheVeil’,asIvanIVwassaidtohaveprayedinhistent,

thesupposedly‐impregnablecityofKazan’wasstormedandseizedin1552.

from:Вераивласть:ЭпохаИванаГрозного/FaithandPower:TheAgeofIvantheTerrible,Москва,МинистерствокультурыимассовыхкоммуникацийРоссийскойФедерации,Федеральноеагентствопо

культуреикинематографии&Федеральноегосударственноеучреждениекультуры,Государственныйисторико‐культурныймузей‐заповедник«МосковскийКремль»2007,p.22,ci4ngМ.Б.Плюханова,СюжетыисимволыМосковсогоцарства,Санкт‐

Петербург,1995,pp.29‐31.

Page 21: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

PortraitofIvanIVintheC17thOld‐Slavonicliterary

text:TheHistoryofKazan(КазанскаяИстория)

C17thtextandportraitstylesreferringbacktoC16thevents:Ivan’s

conquestofKazan,1551andMuscovy’sdestruc;onoftheMoslemKhanatesoftheGoldenHorde.Ivanisportrayedasachivalricandroman;cherointhisOld‐

Slavonictext.

hqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/

ivan4_kazanskiy.html.

Page 22: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

BlessedistheHost(i.e.Army)oftheTsaranointedbyHeavenБлагословенновоинствонебесногоЦаря

Muscovitemid‐C16thIcon,nearly2metreslong,CathedraloftheDormi4on(UspenskiiSobor’УспенскийСоборь,MoscowKremlin.

TheTsar[IvanIV?]rides[backfromaburningKazan’in1551]amidhisinfantryandheheads[nottowardsa‘ThirdRome’but]towarda‘NewJerusalem’wheretheMotherofGodawaitswiththeinfant,Christ.TheTsardoesn’twearabaqle

helmet(шлем)butratherthemonarch’s‘armouroftruth(броняверы)’.TwogreatBibletsarsprecedehimonhorseback,DavidandSolomon,assistedintherearbysaintlymonarchsofKievRus’:Vladimir,andtheholytwins,Boris&Gleb.This‘poli4cal’iconisuniqueinMuscovyandmayhaveinfluencedbyOrthodoxan4‐OqomanprecedentsinC15thandC16thBalkanchurches(OhridinMacedoniaandPetrucainRomania).hqp://www.uer.varvar.ru/uspenskiy16.htmandDaniel

RowlandessayinPicturingRussia:ExploraBonsinVisualCulture,NewHaven,CN:YaleUniversityPress,2008,ch.6&plate6.3.

Page 23: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Detailsoftheicon

Музей‐ЗаповедникМосковскогоКремля:ВераиВласть:ЭпоxаИванаГрозного(Москва2007),p.10,andDanielRowlandessayinPicturingRussia:ExploraBonsinVisualCulture,NewHaven,CN:Yale

UniversityPress,2008,ch.6&plate6.3,andillustra4on10atIvanIVand

hqp://www.ic‐xc‐nika.ru/ikons/Ioann_Vasilevich_IV_Groznyi/000.htmlandHolyMonarchsofKievRus’:StVladimir,St

BorisandStGlebhqp://www.pravenc.ru/text/159104.html.

Page 24: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

‘BlessedistheHostoftheHeavenlyTsar’:asecondcopyoftheicon,laterC16th,nowwithgreatTsarslabeled(Israelite:David&Solomon;Byzan4ne:Constan4ne&Leo;Rus’:StVladimirandBoris&Gleb):

Tret’iakovGallery,Moscow:hqp://www.nasledie‐rus.ru/img/870000/870408.jpg.

Page 25: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ImageofTsarFëdorIIvanovich(b.1557,r.1584‐98)

wearingtheCapofMonomakhandastrideacharger(asbetokensan

Orthodoxwarriorprince).HewastheretardedanddiffidentsonandimmediatesuccessorofTsarIvanIVVasil’evichwho

diedin1584.

ImagefromthesideoftheTsar‐Cannon

Tsar‐PushkaЦарь‐пушка1586castbymastergun‐founderandbell‐maker(pushechnoilitetsпушечной

литец),AndreiChokhov(ca1545to1625)totrytodeterfurther

Polish‐Lithuanianaqack.

Nowinthegrounds(neartheFrolovgate)oftheMoscowKremlin

hqp://www.nts‐lib.ru/Online/chem/br5.jpg&hqp://www.mosgid.ru/image/1286443319_788.jpg;SergeiBogatyrev’s‘BronzeTsars’inPersonality&PlaceinRussianCulture,London,MHRA,2010,pp.

54‐71.

Page 26: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Surprisinglyaccurate(?)bogey‐manimageofTsarIvanIV(wearingtheCapofMonomakhandthecollar

(barmyбармы)onKarstenMiddeldorpofLübeck’s“LionofReval(Tallinn)”cannoncastin1559inTallinn(aHansa

Bal4c‐GermantradingcityinwhatisnowEstonia)tohelpdefendthecityajertheclose‐callofaMuscovitesiegein1558‐59atthestartoftheLivonianWar(1558‐83)betweenMuscovyand

Poland‐Lithuania.ThewarbeganwellforMuscovy,butfromthe1560sitbecameadisaster;Andrei

MikhailovichKurbskii’sdefec4onin1564wasoneofthesedisasters.

ThegunisnowinTheArBlleryMuseuminStPetersburg(adjacenttothePeterandPaulFortress@

hqp://www.ar4llery‐museum.ru/en/)hqp://www.4m.lu/photo_album/estonia/the_lion.jpg;SergeiBogatyrev’s‘BronzeTsars’inPersonality&PlaceinRussian

Culture,London,MHRA,2010,pp.50‐61.

Page 27: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

PortraitofIvanIVintheC17thOld‐Slavonicliterary

text:TheHistoryofKazan(КазанскаяИстория)

C17thtextandportraitstylesreferringbacktoC16thevents:Ivan’s

conquestofKazan,1552andMuscovy’sdestruc;onoftheMoslemKhanatesoftheGoldenHorde.Ivanisportrayedasachivalricandroman;cherointhisOld‐

Slavonictext.

hqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/

ivan4_kazanskiy.html.

Page 28: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

1530:thedyingVasiliiIIIisshownblessinghis3‐year‐oldson,IvanIV

As‐yet‐uncolouredincomplete

illustra4onfromanunfinished(asatca.1600)compendiumofoldchronicleentriescompiledby

monksatMoscowandAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVandmetropolitanMakariiin1550s

&1560s:‘TheTsar’sBook(TsarstvennaiaknigaЦарственнаяКнига)’copy(calledtheNikon

Chronicle)fromLitsevoiSvodЛицевойСвод

(1560s)athqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/

manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐1.html.

Page 29: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

1530s:TheinfantIvanIVmeetstheboyars,inthecompanyofhisLithuanianmother,ElenaGlinskaia(d.

1538)

NikonchronicleUniversalImages

Group

Page 30: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Corona4onofIvanIVasTsar,1547ChroniclecommissionedbyMetropolitanMakarii:‘TheTsar’sBook(TsarstvennaiaKnigaЦарственнаяКнига)’:hqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐287.jpgandhqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐288.jpgandhqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐289.jpg.

Page 31: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

WeddingofIvanIVandAnastasiia

Romanovnain1547

ChroniclecommissionedbyMetropolitanMakarii:‘TheTsar’sBook(Tsarstvennaia

KnigaЦарственнаяКнига)’,1560s.

hqp://www.hrono.ru/biograf/ivan4ru_inst.html.

Page 32: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Crownedbygoldencoins–ascenereplicatedinEisenshtein’sfilmaboutIvantheTerrible(PartOne‐1944).

Anotherunfinisheduncoloured

scene(1560s)fromtheCorona;onofIvanIVasTsar,1547

Chroniclecommissionedby

MetropolitanMakariiinthe1560s:‘TheTsar’sBook(TsarstvennaiaKniga

ЦарственнаяКнига)’:ГосударственныеМузеиРоссии,ГосударственныйИсторическийМузей,Москва,Издательство

«Интербук‐Бизнес»,2006,p.155,item23(Отделрукописейи

старопечатныхкниг).

Page 33: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

MarriageofIvanIV&Anastasiia

Romanovna,7February1547

Nikonchronicle

Page 34: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TheTsariselectedbyGod;БогоизбранностьРусскогоЦарства

Tsar(IvanIV?)andTsarina(Anastasiia

Romanovna?)

DetailfromthePokrovBogoroditsaПокровБогородицаicon,firsthalfofC16th,nowin

StateRussianMuseum,StPetersburg.

Ontheholyday(prazdnikпраздник)ofthe‘FeastoftheVeil’,asIvanIVwassaidtohaveprayedinhistent,

thesupposedly‐impregnablecityofKazan’wasstormedandseizedin1552.

from:Вераивласть:ЭпохаИванаГрозного/FaithandPower:TheAgeofIvantheTerrible,Москва,МинистерствокультурыимассовыхкоммуникацийРоссийскойФедерации,Федеральноеагентствопо

культуреикинематографии&Федеральноегосударственноеучреждениекультуры,Государственныйисторико‐культурныймузей‐заповедник«МосковскийКремль»2007,p.22,ci4ngМ.Б.Плюханова,СюжетыисимволыМосковсогоцарства,Санкт‐

Петербург,1995,pp.29‐31.

Page 35: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Silver,Gilt,Chiselled&EnamelledCup(Кошв)belongingtoIvanIV,madeusingMoldavian

techniquesinthearmouryworkshops,

MoscowKremlin(ОружейнаяПалата,МЗ1137)hlp://www.kreml.ru/ru/exhibi;on/

Kremlin/index.php?id_4=234&from_4=2;ЭпохаИвана

Грозного/FaithandPower:TheAgeofIvantheTerrible,Москва,

МинистерствокультурыимассовыхкоммуникацийРоссийской

Федерации,Федеральноеагентствопокультуреикинематографии&Федеральноегосударственное

учреждениекультуры,Государственныйистопико‐

культурныймузей‐заповедник«МосковскийКремль»2007,pp.54‐55,

item11,

Page 36: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Small4tleanddoubleeagleonthebase:ByGraceofGod,TsarandGrandprinceIvan

Vasil’evichSovereignofallRus’Б[о]жиеюм[и]л[о]стиюц[а]ри

великийкн[я]зьиванвасильевичг[о]с[у]д[а]рьвсеярусии

Longer4tlearoundtheedge:thisandVladimirskii,Moskovskii,Novgorotskii,TsarKazanskii,TsarAstrakhanskii,Tverskii,

Iugorskii,Permskii,Viatskii,Bolgarskiietc.,SovereignandGrandPrince,SovereignofPskov,GrandPrinceofSmolensk,Novagoroda,Nizovskielands,Chenigovskii,Riazanskii,Rostovskii,Iaroslavskii,

Belozerskii,Udorskii,Obdorskii,Koldinskii,andalltheSiberianlandandNorthernLandstheVictorandSovereignofmanyothers.

Page 37: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Proformaforthe

Diploma4cRecitalsoftheTsar’s

OfficialTitles:Tituliarnikof

1672

Page 38: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Tsar/ЦарьIvanIV’sprayerthrone(molenoemesto

моленоеместо)

intheCathedraloftheDormi4on(UspenskiiSobor’УспенскийСоборь:AristotleFiorovan4,1497):theso‐

called‘Throneof[Vladimir]Monomakh’

commissionedbyMetropolitan[i.e.,Archbishop]Makariiin1551,4yearsajerIvanIV’sproclama4onas‘Tsar’in1547,6yearsbeforehisrequesttothePatriarchofConstan4noplefor

recogni4onofthe4tlein1557,and10yearsbeforethe4tle‘Tsar’was

acceptedbythePatriarchin1561.

source:И.М.Соколова,Мономахтрон:ЦарскоеместоУспенскогособораМосковскогоКремля,

Москва,ИздательствоИндрик,2001.

Page 39: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

The prayer throne Makarii had built for Ivan IV once faced opposite the ‘Church Militant’ icon in the [Patriarch’s] Cathedral of the Dormition in the Moscow Kremlin. This is the ‘Blessed is the Host of the Heavenly Tsar’ Icon we have already studied. Now the prayer throne resides in Hall 18 (Зал Ивана Грозного) of the Russian Historical Museum in Red Square, Moscow: Государственные Музеи России, Государственный Исторический Музей, Москва, Издательство «Интербук-Бизнес», 2006, p. 31; hqp://museums.artyx.ru/books/item/f00/s00/z0000000/st024.shtml.

Page 40: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

hqp://museums.artyx.ru/books/item/f00/s00/z0000000/st024.shtml

This sculptured prayer-throne (1551) Metropolitan Makarii had ordered to be built for Ivan IV was placed opposite the ‘Church Militant’ icon in the [Patriarch’s] Cathedral of the Dormition in the Moscow Kremlin. This is the ‘Blessed is the Host of the Heavenly Tsar’ Icon we have already studied. There is an irony. The crusading thematic of the throne and icon did not preclude the use of Ottoman silk-brocade fabric (kemha in Turkish) to line the interior of the prayer-throne! Nurhan Atasoy & Lâle Uluç, Impressions of Ottoman Culture in Europe, 1453-1699, Istanbul, Turkish Cultural Foundation, Armaggan, 2012, pp. 101-2, Plates 74-75.

Page 41: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

DetailfromIvanIV’sthrone(1551)inthePatriarch’s‘CathedraloftheDormi;on(UspenskiiSoborУспенскийСобор)’,MoscowKremlinsupposedlyalributed(like

theCrown)totheC12thKievanprince,VladimirMonomakh:

IvanIVleadshiscrusadingarmy.hqp://visualrian.ru/storage/PreviewWM/3107/23/310723.jpg?

1212993160

И.M.Соколова,МономахТрон,Москва,ИздательствоИндрик,‘РоссияиХристианскийВосток’series,2001.

Page 42: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ
Page 43: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ScenesontheIvanIV’s‘ThroneofMonomakh’1551

SWside•  PrincelyandBoyarCounsellorswith

GrandPrinceVladimirMonomakh[proxyforIvanIV].

•  VladimirMonomakhassembleshiscaptains(voevodyвоеводы)andchooseshiscommanderinchief(nachal’nikначальник).

•  ThearmyoftheGrandPrincesetsoutfor[TatarIslamic]Тhrace.

•  ThecaptainsoftheGrandPrincestandbeforethewallsofThrace

Westside1.  BaqleonthewallsofThraceand

takingofcap4ves2.  ThecaptainsoftheGrandPrince

seizethecityanditswealth3.  BaqleoftheGrandPrince’sarmy

withanenemyforce4.  CouncilofByzan4neTsarConstan4ne

decidingtosendenvoystoVladimirinKiev.

Southside1.  Byzan4neTsarConstan4neIXgives

totheenvoysofStVladimiralltheregaliaofhisByzan4neemperor‐ship.

2.  Journeyoftheenvoysacrossthesea.

3.  TheenvoysofByzan4umpresenttheregaliatoGrandPrinceStVladimirofKiev

4.  Metropolitan(i.e.,Archbishop)NeofritcrownsGrandPrinceStVladimirwiththeregalia,includingtheCapofMonomakh.

FrontdoorsTextofthe‘StoryofthePrincesof

Vladimir[onceKiev,nowMuscovy]Skazaniiaokniaz’iakhVladirmirskikhCказанияокнязьяхВладимирских.

Page 44: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

SWside•  PrincelyandBoyarCounsellorswithGrandPrinceVladimirMonomakh[IvanIV].•  GrandPrinceVladimirMonomakhassembleshiscaptains(voevodyвоеводы)andchooses

hiscommanderinchief(nachal’nikначальник).•  ThearmyoftheGrandPrincesetsoutfor[TatarIslamic]Тhrace.•  ThecaptainsoftheGrandPrincestandbeforethewallsofThracesource:И.М.Соколова,Мономахтрон:ЦарскоеместоУспенскогособораМосковскогоКремля,Москва,Индрик,2001

Page 45: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

source:И.М.Соколова,Мономахтрон:ЦарскоеместоУспенскогособораМосковскогоКремля,Москва,ИздательствоИндрик,2001

TsarandCounsellors

Page 46: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Corona;on(1547)Source:hqp://feb‐web.ru/feb/irl/pictures/il2‐308‐.jpgandИ.М.Соколова,Мономахтрон:ЦарскоеместоУспенскогособораМосковскогоКремля,Москва,ИздательствоИндрик,2001.

Page 47: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Anotherthronemadefromivoryinthe

MoscowKremlinArmouryMuseum

(OruzheinnaiaPalataОружeйннаяПалата)

aqributedtotheeraofIvanIV.

hqp://museums.artyx.ru/books/item/f00/s00/z0000000/

st047.shtmland

GrangerCollec4on,UniversalImagesGroup.

Page 48: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Hereisthecorona4ontext(1547)ofMetropolitanMakariifromtheLitsevoiSvod

ЛицевойСвод(1550s,1560s)alsosponsoredbyMetropolitanMakariiintheMetropolitan’sscriptoriumintheKremlin:

Ипослемноголетиймитрополитприветствовалвеликогоцаря:«Божеюмилостиюрадуйсяиздраствуй,православныйцарюИване,всеяРусисамодержавецнамноголета».Ипоклонисяцарюмитрополит.

Anda�ermanyyearshadpassed,thearchbishopgreetedthegreatTsar:‘BythegraceofGod,rejoicingandwelcoming,wesaluteyouright‐holy[Orthodox]TsarIvan,autocratofalltheRussiasformanymoreyearstocome’.AndthenthearchbishopmadeobeissancetotheTsar.

ImageinСергейВладимировичФомин,ПравдаопервомРусскомЦаре:КтоиПочемуискажаетобразГосударяИоаннаБасильевича(Грозного),Москва,«РусскийИздательскийЦентр»2010.

Page 49: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Whatseemedimportantinretrospect:GrozaГроза

Vil’no‐bornRussian‐Jewishar4st,MarkMatve'evichAntokol’skii(1843‐1902)sculpture(1870‐71)imagininganawesome(groznyi

грозный)IvanIVsi³ngontheivorythrone.Thear4st’sworkwasenthusias4callyreceivedby

AlexanderIIandacquiredforTheHermitage,andhehadthepatronageoftheTsar’sliberalsister,GrandDuchessMariiaNikolaevna.Thear4st

renouncedhisJewishstatusajerbeingchosenasa‘PerpetualHonoraryCi4zen’,andajerhiselec4ontotheImperialAcademyofArts.Thisbronzecopypicturedhere(1872)wasmadefor

TheRussianMuseumestablishedinStPetersburgbyAlexanderIII.AnothercopywassenttoLondonfortheImperialExhibi4onof1882andwasthendonatedtotheKensington

Palace.

hqps://picasaweb.google.com/110738321384102773936/DsgCyK#5583707369082039250

Page 50: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

‘KingofKings’and‘PriestKing’curtain(katapetasmaкатапетасма)madeinaMoscowKremlinworkshopandgivenbyTsarIvanIVandTsarevnaAnastasiia

Romanovnaon20November1555forthe(SerbianOrthodox)‘Churchofthe

Presenta;onoftheVirgin’atHilandar,ontheHolyMountain,akeyOrthodox

monasterycomplex(picturedinMtAthos,northGreece.

SeeIsoldeThyrêtinTheNewMuscoviteCulturalHistory,Plate3

HilandarOrthodoxChurchResearchLibraryUniversityofOhio

Page 51: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TsarIvanIVisshownsuperintendingthepain4ngoficonsinaKremlincathedral

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicle

entriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissioned

byIvanIVin1570s:LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводat

hqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐2.html.

Page 52: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

GreatWarBannerofIvanIV(Знамявеликийстяг)1560TheArchangelMichael(right)charges(RevelaBons19:11‐18).GoldembroideredandembossedonimportedChinesesilk.hqp://files.school‐collec4on.edu.ru/dlrstore/ecdf9466‐68f3‐439b‐9712‐874bdb643c76/p13_zn_305.jpgandreconstructedathqp://www.donego.ne�irms.com/Intours/Russian/tcal/Russia/flag/2.jpg.

Page 53: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

FromaC19threconstruc;on:Историческоеописаниеодеждыивооруженияроссийскихвойск[asrecordedbytheC16thd’iakIvanViskovatovИванВисковатов].

hlp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/slovo/znamya_ioann4.html

Page 54: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Reconstruc;onoftheBalleStandardofIvanIV(ВеликийСтягьИванаГрозного)

hqp://www.gerb.bel.ru/pages/russia/flag/f_ivan4_3.gif

Page 55: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

LostMurals(corona;onofIvanIV,1547?)fromtheVes;buleofthe

GoldenHall(Золотаяпалата)(paintedoverinlater1670s,demolishedin1752)MoscowKremlin,adjacenttotheFaceledPalaceandthesquareofthe[Patriarch’s}Cathedralofthe

Dormi;on(UspenskiiSoborУспенскийСобор)basedona1672descrip;onby

SemënUshakov.

Atone;me,diplomatsandboyarsmettheTsarenthronedhere,enteringviaSpasskiiGate,past

VoznesenskimonasterygoingontoCathedralsquare,thencetotheBoyars’Porch.TheGoldenPalacewasonceconnectedtotheFaceledPalace(Грановитая

Палата).

DanielRowland’‘Twocultures,OneThroneRoom’inOrthodoxRussia:BeliefandPracBceundertheTsars,eds.ValerieKivelson&RobertH.Greene,Pennsylvania

StateUniversityPress,2003,ch.2.

NewChurchThemes:1. Poli4calpowercomesfromGod.2. TheVirginMotherofGodprotectsMuscovy.3.The[Riurikid]clanoftherulerisimportant.4.GodsafeguardsthearmyofMuscovy.5.ARealmmusthavegoodorder.6.ATsarshouldbepiousandsteadfast.7.ATsartakesadvicefromcour4ers.

Page 56: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ
Page 57: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TheCrownofKazan’ShapkaKazanskaiaШапкаКазанская

Cap‐CrowntocommemoratetheCaptureof

Kazan’,1553?

SomesayitwasthecapturedTatarcrownofKazan’.Morelikely,itwasorderedbyIvanIVandmadebythe

goldsmithsoftheMuscoviteKremlin’asithasnoIslamicmo;fs.ItwasactuallymadeforEdigei,thelastKhanofKazan’,whowascapturedinKazan’in1553,heldhostageinMoscow,andrequiredtotakethenewChris;annameof

Simeon.TheCrownwassolistedasthisSimeon’sinaKremlininventoryof1646.ThestoryimpliessomethingofIvan’scompassionforhishumiliatedenemy,whohadtoconverttoChris;anity,butwhowasotherwisehonouredandwhoselifewasspared.OnesuspectsthatseveralChurchmenmightnothaveagreedwiththispolicyof

Chris;ancompassion.

MoscowKremlin’ArmouryMuseumОружeйннаяПалата,МузейМосковскогоКремля

hqp://visualrian.ru/images/item/175928оrhqp://imagesgallery.kreml.ru/image‐view.jsp?

pos=52&pageStart=49

Page 58: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

RenovatedC17thInteriorofthe‘FaceledPalaceГрaновитаяПалата’,MoscowKremlin,1490s

hqp://pics.livejournal.com/dinya_ss/pic/0004ex6s/s640x480

Page 59: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ComparableC17thmuralsfromthethroneroomoftheadjacent‘FaceledPalace(GranovitaiaPalataГрановитаиапалата),MoscowKremlin.

Page 60: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

StBasil’sMoscow,RedSquare,1555‐61

hqp://www.xenophon‐mil.org/ruscity/moscow/basildiag.htm

Page 61: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

AmodernTatarar;st,FirinatKhalikov’sreconstruc;onofC16thKazan’foranexhibi;onstagedbythe

TatarstanRepublicinMarch2005.Tatarstanisacons;tuentpartoftheRussianFedera;onhqp://history‐kazan.ru/2005/08/kar4ny‐polnye‐dostoinstva‐i‐velichiya‐duxa‐predkov/

Page 62: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TheHistoryoftheCaptureofKazan’KazanskaiaIstoriiaКазанскаяИстория

(DavidMilleracceptstheSoviet‐eradatesof1564;SergeiBogatyrevdatesittolateC16th‐earlyC17th,re‐wrilenlateC17th)ManuscriptinRussianCentralArchiveofAncientActs(TsGADA),Moscow

hqp://historydoc.edu.ru/aqach.asp?a_no=2529&hqp://historydoc.edu.ru/catalog.asp?ob_no=%2012721

Page 63: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ConquestofSiberia:cossackfightersintraining;collec;ng

tribute;execu;ngTatarcap;ves

SemënUl’ianovichRemezovofTobol’sk,Siberia

‘ShortSiberianManuscriptКраткаяСибирскаяЛетопись

KratkaiaSibirskaiaLetopis’(1690s)’

fromValerieKivelson’sCartographiesofTsarism,CornellUniversityPress,2006,p.199and

hqp://makingmaps.net/2008/10/10/map‐symbols‐gibbets‐gallows‐execu4on/andtheexhibi4onattheRussianHistoricalmuseumin2007:‘YermakandtheTakingofSiberia:hqp://www.shm.ru/ev50926.html.

Page 64: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

SemënUl’ianovichRemezovofTobol’sk,Siberia(1640s‐1720s)

Representa;on(1690s?)

of‘TheInvasionofSiberiabytheCossack

Ermak’

LibraryoftheRussianAcademyofSciences

‘ShortSiberianManuscriptКраткаяСибирскаяЛетопись

KratkaiaSibirskaiaLetopis’(1690s)’hqp://www.nkj.ru/upload/iblock/e74/

e740261¶c6995622676039613c8142.jpg

Page 65: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

SemënUl’ianovichRemezov’s

representa;onsofErmakinSiberia:

Sailingdownthe

riversandportagesbetweenrivers

LibraryoftheRussianAcademyofSciences

‘ShortSiberianManuscript

КраткаяСибирскаяЛетописьKratkaiaSibirskaiaLetopis’(1690s)’

hqp://www.barguzinmuseum.ru/exp/galkin%201.files/image004.jpg

Page 66: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

SemënUl’ianovichRemezov’sErmakinSiberia:

Sailingdowntheriversand

alacking

LibraryoftheRussianAcademyofSciences

‘ShortSiberianManuscriptКраткаяСибирскаяЛетопись

KratkaiaSibirskaiaLetopis’(1690s)’

h�p://passion‐don.org/library/img/dov_279_2.jpg

Page 67: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVisshownreceivingtributefromthenewly‐conquered

Siberianlands

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicle

entriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s:LitsevoiSvodЛицевой

Сводathqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/

manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐2.html.

Page 68: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

MuscovitePalæographyfron4spieceof

TheBookofRoyalLevels

(СтепëннаяКнига)

TheGreatMenalogion(ВеликиеЧетьиМиней)

1554

Аcompendiumof12month‐by‐monthreligiousreadings,bibletextsandsaints’lives

(hagiographies)compiledbythecirclearoundMetropolitanMakarii.

hqp://www.hs‐augsburg.de/~harsch/russica/

r_vek16.html.

Page 69: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Englishmerchant,AnthonyJenkinson’sMapoftheCaspianregionofMuscovy(1562)

hlp://m1.ikiwq.com/img/xl/dfHNhdqSmxx5JfZHoDpzLd.jpg

Page 70: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Inanothereraofreform(1856),StPetersburgar4stPavelFëdorovichPleshanov(1826‐82)imaginesthenewly‐crowned‘HolyTsar’IvanIVhardatworkin1547reformingMuscovywithoneofKurbskii’s

favouritemembersofthesupposed‘ChosenCouncil(IzbrannaiaRada

ИзбраннаяРада)’:archpriestSil’vestr(supposedauthoroftheDomostroi).ThegreatfireofMoscow,however,is

abouttosupervene.

TheRussianMuseum,StPetersburg

hqp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/7a/Pavel_Pleshanov_001.jpg/220px‐

Pavel_Pleshanov_001.jpg

Page 71: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVisshownreceivingtributefromthenewly‐conquered

Siberianlands

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicle

entriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s:LitsevoiSvodЛицевой

Сводathqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/

manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐2.html.

Page 72: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

MuscovitePalæography

fron4spieceofTheBookofRoyalGeneraBonalLevels(StepënnaiaKnigaСтепëннаяКнига),

partofTheGreatMenalogion(VelikieChet’iMinei

ВеликиеЧетьиМиней)sponsoredby

MetropolitanMakariiofNovgorodandthenofMoscow

1554

Аcompendiumof12month‐by‐monthreligiousreadings,bibletextsandsaints’lives(hagiographies)compiledbythe

circlearoundMetropolitanMakarii.hqp://www.hs‐augsburg.de/~harsch/russica/r_vek16.html.

Page 73: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

LeaffromabookofpiousreadingsandprayersforMarch

intheMoscowKremlinPatriarchalCathedraloftheDormi;onoftheVirgin

(UspenskiiSobor’УспенскийСоборь)Cathedralcopyof

TheMenalogion(МинеяЧетья).

1540s

Thisworkproducedinthe1540sinMetropolitanMakarii’scirclewhilehewastheArchpriestinNovgorod(1526‐42),i.e.beforehebecameMetropolitanofAllRus’

andmovedtoMoscow(1542‐63).

ГосударственныеМузеиРоссии,ГосударственныйИсторическийМузей,Москва,Издательство

«Интербук‐Бизнес»,2006,p.152,item20(Отделрукописейистаропечатныхкниг).

Page 74: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVistoldofthetreasonofhisBoyar,AndreiIvanovich

Kurbskii,1564

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicleentriescompiledbymonks

atAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s

LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСвод

hqp://www.hrono.ru/biograf/ivan4ru_inst.html.

Page 75: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Palæography

MuscoviteChanceryHandwri4ng

LeaffromapageofTsarIvanIV’sleqertohisrenegadeBoyar,AndreiIvanovich

Kurbskii

disputeddate,either1560sorC17th

hqp://www.hrono.ru/biograf/

ivan4ru_inst.html

Page 76: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Execu4ngBoyarsIllustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicleentriescompiledbymonksat

AlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570sLitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводathqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐groz15.jpgandhqp://history.sgu.ru/?wid=132orhqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐1.html.

Page 77: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Asearlyasthe1590s,FilippKolychëv(1507‐69)wasmovingtowardsainthood.Thisformercounsellorof

IvanIVbecameMetropolitan(i.e.,bishop)andAbbotoftheSolovetskiiMonasteryandFortintheWhiteSeainthefarnorthofEuropeanRussiain1546.LaterhemovedtoMoscowtoheadup

theologicaltrainingin1566.ManyChroniclesandKurbskii’sHistoryandCorrespondenceclaimhedaredtorebukeIvanIVfortheexcessesoftheOprichnina(Опричнина).IvanIVorderedhisexecu4oninTver’in1569bytheoprichnik

(опричник),MaliutaSkuratov.WeknowthathisremainswerebroughtbacktotheStsZosimaand

Savva4iChurchatSolovetskiiin1591.Thisexquisiteembroideredclothwasmadeinthe1590s,very

likelyinthecircleofthenewTsarina,IrinaGodunova.MetropolitanFilippwascanonizedin1652andhisremainswerebroughttoMoscow.

LiudmilaLikhacheva’scatalogueitem43inTheGatesofMystery:

TheArtofHolyRussia,Cambridge,TheLuqerworthPress,n.d,ci4ngTheRussianMuseum,StPetersburg,inventoryitemДРT308.

Page 78: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Moscow‐basedar4st,VasiliiVladimirovichPukirev

(1832‐90)imagines(1882)

asaintlyMetropolitanFilipp

admonishingTsarIvanIV(in1569?)fortheOprichninaajer

adivineserviceinthePatriarch’sCathedraloftheDormi4onoftheHolyVirgin(UspenskiiSobor)inthe

MoscowKremlin.

hqp://pics.livejournal.com/olga74ru/pic/0019r2qq/

s640x480

Page 79: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVisshownsendingoffnewenvoystoVil’no,

LithuaniancapitalofthePolish‐LithuanianCommonwealthor

Rechpospolita,towhichKurbksiihadfledin1564.

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicle

entriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s

LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводathqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/

manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐2.html.

Page 80: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

AlexandrovskSloboda:IvanIV’scapitaloftheOprichnina(Опричнина)

JacobUlfeld(1567‐1630)LegaBoMoscoviBca(1608,1627),EtchingbyI.T.deBrie@hqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐groz6.jpg

Page 81: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

JacobUlfeld(1567‐1630)

Imageoftherecep;onoftheDanishambassadorinthecourtofIvanIVwhileIvanIVwasinself‐imposedexileatAleksandrovskSlobodain1578

LegaBoMoscoviBca(1608,1627)

EtchingbyI.T.deBrie

hqp://krotov.info/acts/16/3/ulfeld1578_1.htmlhqp://krotov.info/pictures/history/48/4.JPG

Page 82: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

FeastinthePresenceofTsarIvanIVathisself‐imposedplaceofexileatAlexandrovskSlobodain1578asobservedbythere;nueofDanishenvoy,Jacob

Ulfeld(1567‐1630?)LegaBoMoscoviBca(1608,1627)EtchingbyI.T.deBriehqp://krotov.info/pictures/history/48/6.JPG

Page 83: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

RiteofKissingtheHolyCross

(Крестоцелование)1578RitualofRecep;onfortheDanishambassador,JacobUlfeld(1567‐1630?)

LegaBoMoscoviBca(1608,1627)EtchingbyI.T.deBriehqp://krotov.info/pictures/history/48/7.JPG

Page 84: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

MapofMoscowinfirsthalfof

C16th

commissionedbyHolsteinenvoyto

Muscovy,AdamOlearius(1603‐71)

Collec4onoftheNewYorkPublicLibrary

hqp://russia.nypl.org/maps2/17moscow.html

Page 85: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

BalleofOrsha,8September1514:(Catholic)Polesand(Orthodox)Lithuaniansareshowndefea;ng(Orthodox)Muscovites

NaBonalMuseumofWarsawhqp://www.ddg.art.pl/nm/:PolishpupilofLucasCranachinthe1520sor1530shqp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Baqle_of_Orsha_(1514‐09‐08).jpg

Page 86: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

TsarIvanIVisdepictedattheweddingritesof

‘Tsar’SemënBekbulatovich:strange

eventsin1575

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicleentriescompiledbymonks

atAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s:

LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводat

hqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/

16‐2.html.

Page 87: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Il’iaEfimovichRepin(1844‐1930)imagines(1885)thescenein16November1581ajerIvanIVhasstrucktheblowwhichhaskilledhisownson,theTsarevich,IvanIvanovich

StateTret’iakovGallery,Moscow@hqp://www.tretyakovgallery.ru/ru/collec4on/_show/image/_id/210.

Page 88: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

ViacheslavGrigor’evichShvarts(1838‐69)image(1861)ofIvanIVatthedeathbedofhissonhlp://ivan‐grozny.com/userfiles/image/u%20tela.jpg.

Page 89: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Detail1:DressCode:Ka�an;Poli;calCode:PeckingOrder:Adepic4onofthearrivalin1576ofthefirstdelega4onofRussiandiplomatsintheHabsburg

capital,Vienna:reign(1564‐76)ofHolyRomanEmperorMaximilianII.hqp://photofile.com.ua/photo/semkov/376977/74289635.jpg

Page 90: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVistoldofthetreasonofhisBoyar,AndreiIvanovich

Kurbskii,1564

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandold

chronicleentriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s

LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСвод

hqp://www.hrono.ru/biograf/ivan4ru_inst.html.

Page 91: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Palæography

MuscoviteChanceryHandwri4ng

LeaffromapageofTsarIvanIV’sleqertohisrenegadeBoyar,AndreiIvanovich

Kurbskii

disputeddate,either1560sorC17th

hqp://www.hrono.ru/biograf/

ivan4ru_inst.html

Page 92: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

Execu4ngBoyarsIllustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicleentriescompiledbymonksat

AlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570sLitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводathqp://history.sgu.ru/img/x1‐groz15.jpgandhqp://history.sgu.ru/?wid=132orhqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐1.html.

Page 93: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

IvanIVisshownsendingoffnewenvoystoVil’no,

LithuaniancapitalofthePolish‐LithuanianCommonwealthor

Rechpospolita,towhichKurbksiihadfledin1564.

Illustra4onfromacompendiumofbiblestories,churchhistoryandoldchronicle

entriescompiledbymonksatAlexandrovskSlobodaascommissionedbyIvanIVin1570s

LitsevoiSvodЛицевойСводathqp://www.varvar.ru/arhiv/gallery/

manuscripts_russian/lit_svod/16‐2.html.

Page 94: Emblem of the Tsardom of Muscovy - La Trobe University€¦ · Эпоха Ивана Грозного / Faith and Power: The Age ... в Русском Искусстве ... образ

BalleofOrsha,8September1514:(Catholic)Polesand(Orthodox)Lithuaniansdefea;ng(Orthodox)Muscovites

NaBonalMuseumofWarsawhqp://www.ddg.art.pl/nm/:PolishpupilofLucasCranachinthe1520sor1530shqp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Baqle_of_Orsha_(1514‐09‐08).jpg