HAL Id: hal-00745617https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00745617

Submitted on 26 Oct 2012

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

Eliciting personal network data in web surveys throughparticipant-generated sociogramsPaola Tubaro, Antonio Casilli, Lise Mounier

To cite this version:Paola Tubaro, Antonio Casilli, Lise Mounier. Eliciting personal network data in web surveys throughparticipant-generated sociograms. Préprint de l’article accepté pour publication dans Field Methods,vol. 26, n. 2, 2014. 2012. <hal-00745617>

! "!

!"#$%&'()*'(+$,-..-'(/*(/*(0(1*(2&"3-4%(56789:(;.-<-=-3>(?4%,&3$.(34=@&%A(B$=$(-3(@4#(,"%C4D,(=E%&">E(

?$%=-<-?$3=F>434%$=4B(,&<-&>%$G,*(#$%&'!(%)*+','(6H(56:(5$<<4?=4B(I&%(?"#.-<$=-&3:(

(

!"#$#%#&'( )*+,-&."( &*%/-+0( 1.%.( #&( /*2( ,3+4*5,(

%6+-3'6().+%#$#).&%7'*&*+.%*1(,-$#-'+.8,(

!

!

-.+&.!/01.2+3!45$6%2,$)7!+8!92%%5:$;*3!<+5'+5!.5'!=>?@A=(B3!-.2$,!

C5)+5$+!CD!=.,$&&$3!/%&%;+E-.2$,/%;*!.5'!=F(AGGC=!FBF@@3!-.2$,!

<$,%!(+05$%23!=>?@A=(B3!-.2$,!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&'(%!

!E4( ?$?4%( ?%4,43=,( $( G4=E&B( =&( 4.-<-=( ?4%,&3$.( 34=@&%A( B$=$( -3( J3=4%34=( ,"%C4D,'( 4K?.&-=-3>( =E4(

%43&@34B($??4$.(&I(34=@&%A(C-,"$.-L$=-&3,(=&(%4B"<4(%4,?&3B43=(#"%B43($3B(%-,A(&I(B%&?F&"=*(J=(-,($(

?$%=-<-?$3=F>434%$=4B( <&G?"=4%F#$,4B( ,&<-&>%$G'( $3( -3=4%$<=-C4( >%$?E-<$.( -3=4%I$<4( 43$#.-3>(

?$%=-<-?$3=,(=&(B%$@(=E4-%(&@3(?4%,&3$.(34=@&%A,(@-=E(,-G?.4($3B(-3="-=-C4(=&&.,*(J3($(,="BD(&I(",4%,(

&I( @4#,-=4,( &3( 4$=-3>( B-,&%B4%,'( @4( E$C4( 4G#4BB4B( =E4( ,&<-&>%$G( @-=E-3( $( =@&F,=4?( $??%&$<E(

$-G-3>( =&( I-%,=( 4.-<-=( =E4( #%&$B( 4>&( 34=@&%A( &I( $3( -3B-C-B"$.'( $3B( =E43( =&( 4K=%$<=( ,"#,4=,( &I( -,,"4F

,?4<-I-<(,"??&%=(=-4,*(M4(I-3B(=E-,(=&(#4($(?%&G-,-3>(=&&.(=&(I$<-.-=$=4(,"%C4D(4K?4%-43<4($3B($B$?=$#.4(

=&($(@-B4%(%$3>4(&I(34=@&%A(,="B-4,*(

!

)*+,-&.$!

@+;$.&!5%):+2H,3!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,3!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2,3!5%):+2H!6$,0.&$K.)$+5,3!G5)%25%)!,026%7,D!

!

!

! L!

!

!

!

!

!

!

/0%&-.1(%2-0!

!

M%,I$)%!)*%!J2+:$5J!I+I0&.2$)7!+8!:%1A1.,%'!,026%7,3! )*%2%! $,! &$E$)%'!%NI%2$%5;%! $5!0,$5J!)*%E!)+!

;+&&%;)!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!'.).3!:*$;*!%5.1&%!)+!'%,;2$1%!)*%!&+;.&!,+;$.&!%56$2+5E%5)!+8!.!,.EI&%!+8!

8+;.&!.;)+2,!O$5!;+5)2.,)!)+!P:*+&%P!5%):+2H!,)0'$%,!)*.)!8+;0,!+5!)*%!,)20;)02%!+8!,+E%!:%&&A'%8$5%'!

,+;$.&!J2+0I!,0;*!.,!.!,;*++&!+2!.!:+2HI&.;%QD!/*%!)%;*5$R0%,!)2.'$)$+5.&&7!0,%'!$5!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!

,026%7,!;+E1$5%!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!R0%,)$+5,3!.$E$5J!)+!%&$;$)!)*%!5.E%,!+8!)*+,%!I%2,+5,!OS.&)%2,TQ!)+!

:*+E!)*%!2%,I+5'%5)!OS%J+TQ!*.,!)$%,3!.5'!5.E%!$5)%2I2%)%2,3!:*$;*!I02I+2)!)+!;*.2.;)%2$K%!)*%,%!

.&)%2,!$5!)%2E,!+8!)*%$2!)$%,!)+!+5%!.5+)*%2!O$8!.57Q3!.5'!+)*%2!.))2$10)%,!,0;*!.,!J%5'%23!.J%3!)7I%!+8!

2%&.)$+5,*$I!+2!82%R0%5;7!+8!;+5).;)!:$)*!%J+D!/*%!8%:!%N.EI&%,!+8!0,%!+8!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!.5'!5.E%!

$5)%2I2%)%2! R0%,)$+5,! $5! :%1! ,026%7,! $5;&0'%!(.2$5! OLUUVQ3! <+K.2!(.582%'.3! W%*+6.2! .5'! B&%1%;!

OLUUVQ3!=+2+E$5.!.5'!=+%5'%2,!OLUUXQ3!W%*+6.23!<+K.2!(.582%'.3!Y+2%5!.5'!B&%1%;!OLUUZQD!

>.E%!J%5%2.)$5J!R0%,)$+5,!)%5'!)+!1%!).N$5J!8+2!2%,I+5'%5),3!%,I%;$.&&7!:*%5!)*%!,$K%!+8!$5'$6$'0.&!

5%):+2H,! $,! &.2J%3! .5'! :%1! ,026%7,! %N.;%21.)%! )*$,! I2+1&%E! .,! )*%7! .2%! 5+)! .'E$5$,)%2%'! 17! .5!

$5)%26$%:%2D!C,!*$J*&$J*)%'!$5!W%*+6.2!%)!.&D!OLUUZQ3!2%,I+5'%5),!2%;%$6%!5+!.''$)$+5.&!*%&I!1%,$'%,!

)*%!$5,)20;)$+5,!;+5).$5%'!$5!)*%!R0%,)$+55.$2%3!5+!8%%'1.;H!$5!;.,%!+8!.!E$,05'%2,).5'$5J3!.5'!E.7!

1%! &%8)!:$)*! &$))&%!E+)$6.)$+5! )+! ;+EI&%)%! )*%! ,026%7D!/%;*5$;.&! $,,0%,! O;+EI.)$1$&$)7!:$)*!'$88%2%5)!

12+:,%2,3! ,%))$5J,3! .5'! 6%2,$+5,Q! E.7! .2$,%[! .5'! 82.E$5J! %88%;),! OJ2.I*$;,3! ;+&+2,3! .5'! )*%!

$5)%2):$5$5J! +8! 6$,0.&! .5'! )%N)0.&! %&%E%5),Q! .88%;)! )*%! R0.&$)7! +8! 2%,I+5,%,! O=+0I%23! =+52.'! .5'!

/+02.5J%.0!LUU\[!#$%&'$5J3!<%%!.5'!]&.5H!LUUZQD!/*%!R0.&$)7!+8!5%):+2H!'.).!;+&&%;)%'!+5&$5%!E.7!

1%!&+:%2!'0%!)+!2%,I+5'%5),!.5,:%2$5J!$5!.!)$E%A,.6$5J!E.55%2!O(.)K.)!.5'!@5$^'%2,!LU"UQD!_6%2.&&3!

+5&$5%!'.).!.2%!&%,,!2%&$.1&%!.5'!E+2%!'%I%5'%5)!+8!0,.1$&$)7!$,,0%,D!

F6%5!,+3!,026%7!E%)*+'+&+J$,),!*.6%!&+5J!%EI*.,$K%'!)*%!0,%80&5%,,!.5'!I+)%5)$.&!$EI.;)!+8!6$,0.&!

;&0%,! $5!:%1! ,026%7,3! ^0,)! .,! .02.&! ;&0%,!:%2%! ;20;$.&! $5!I*+5%! ,026%7,! OM$&&E.5!.5'!@E7)*!LUU\QD!

@)2.)%J$;! 0,%! +8! 6$,0.&$K.)$+5,! )+! $EI2+6%! ,026%7! %NI%2$%5;%! .5'! `! $5'$2%;)&7! `! )+! %5*.5;%! '.).!

R0.&$)7! $,!.&&! )*%!E+2%! &$H%&7!)+!,0;;%%'! $5!5%):+2H!,)0'$%,3!.,!)*%!2%;%5)!,I%;).;0&.2!2$,%!+8!+5&$5%!

,+;$.&!E%'$.!*.,!8.E$&$.2$K%'!&.2J%!.0'$%5;%,!:$)*!5%):+2H!J2.I*!,)20;)02%,D!!!!!!

/*$,! I.I%2! I2+I+,%,! .! 6$,0.&! ,+&0)$+5! )+! %E1%'! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,! .5'! $5)%2I2%)%2,! :$)*$5! .! :%1!

,026%73! $5! .5! %88+2)! )+!E$5$E$K%! 2%,I+5'%5)! 102'%5! :*$&%!E.N$E$K$5J! )*%! .E+05)! .5'! R0.&$)7! +8!

$58+2E.)$+5!2%)2$%6%'D! G)! $,!1.,%'!+5!)*%!0,%!+8!.!I&.780&3!0,%2A82$%5'&7!J2.I*$;.&! $5)%28.;%!.&&+:$5J!

I.2)$;$I.5),!)+!'2.:!)*%$2!5%):+2H,!+5&$5%D!_02!,+&0)$+5!*.,!I+)%5)$.&!)+!2%'0;%!2%,I+5'%5)!102'%5!

$5!):+!:.7,D!#$2,)3!$)!2%'0;%,!)*%!)$E%!5%%'%'!)+!;+EI&%)%!.!,026%7!.,!I.2)$;$I.5),!'+!5+)!*.6%!)+!&$,)!

! a!

)*%! 5.E%,! .5'! .))2$10)%,! +8! .&)%2,3! 1%8+2%! +1).$5$5J! .! 6$,0.&! 2%I2%,%5).)$+5b! )*%7! ;.5! '2.:! )*%$2!

5%):+2H,!'$2%;)&7!+5!)*%!J2.I*$;.&! $5)%28.;%3!:$)*+0)!*.6$5J!)+!:.$)! 8+2!.!,01,%R0%5)!2%5'%2$5J!+8!

)*%!$E.J%!)*2+0J*!,+E%!+I)$E$K$5J!&.7+0)!.&J+2$)*ED!@%;+5'3!)*%!J2.I*$;.&!)++&!+88%2,!.5!$EE%'$.)%!

2%:.2'!)+!I.2)$;$I.5),!)*2+0J*!.!J&+1.&!6$%:!+8!)*%$2!5%):+2H,D!!!

/*$,!I.I%2!+0)&$5%,!+02!$EI&%E%5).)$+5!+8!,0;*!.!,+&0)$+5!$5!.!,I%;$8$;!I2+^%;)!+5!)*%!,+;$.&!5%):+2H,!

+8!0,%2,!+8!:%1,$)%,!+5!%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2,D!@+E%)$E%,!'%I2%;$.)$6%&7!2%8%22%'!)+!.,!PI2+A.5.P3!)*$,!$,!.!

6%27!I.2)$;0&.2!I+I0&.)$+5!:*$;*!*.'!5%6%2!1%%5!,7,)%E.)$;.&&7!,026%7%'!1%8+2%3!.&)*+0J*!.;;+05),!

+8!$),!%N$,)%5;%!;.5!1%!)2.;%'!1.;H!)+!)*%!%.2&7!LUUU,!O=.,$&&$3!/01.2+!.5'!C2.7.!LU"LQD!G),!E%E1%2,!

.2%! *%.67! G5)%25%)! 0,%2,! :$)*! .! *$J*! '%J2%%! +8! ;+EI0)%2! &$)%2.;73! .! E.^+2! 2%.,+5! )+! 0,%! .! :%1!

,026%7[!*+:%6%23!)*%!*%.&)*!2$,H,!.5'!)*%!,)$JE.!$56+&6%'!E.H%!)*%E!.!,%5,$)$6%!.5'!.&E+,)!*$''%5!

J2+0ID!/*%2%8+2%3!,+E%!.,I%;),!+8!+02!%EI$2$;.&!.II2+.;*!,0;*!.,!)*%!2%;20$)E%5)!,)2.)%J73!E.7!1%!

05,0$).1&%! 8+2! +)*%2! ,)0'$%,[! 7%)! :%! 1%&$%6%! )*.)! +02! J2.I*$;.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2! ;.5! 1%! %.,$&7!

J%5%2.&$K%'! .5'! )*.)! +02! %NI%2$%5;%! E.7! I2+6$'%! 6.&0.1&%! $5,$J*)! .5'! $5,I$2.)$+5! )+! +)*%2!

2%,%.2;*%2,! :*+! ,)0'7! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,! $5! 6.2$+0,! ,%))$5J,D! C;;+2'$5J&73! )*$,! I.I%2! 8+;0,%,!

%N;&0,$6%&7!+5!)*+,%!.,I%;),!)*.)!.2%!+8!J%5%2.&!E%)*+'+&+J$;.&!$5)%2%,)3!2.)*%2!)*.5!+5!,I%;$8$;$)$%,!

+8!+02!+:5!).2J%)!I+I0&.)$+5D!

G5!:*.)! 8+&&+:,3!:%! 2%6$%:!%,,%5)$.&! )*%+2%)$;.&!%&%E%5),!.5'!I2%,%5)!+02! ,)0'7D!c%! )*%5!+0)&$5%!

+02!J2.I*$;.&!,+&0)$+5!.5'!*+:!:%!*.6%!10$&)!$)!$5)+!+02!:%1!,026%7D!#$5.&&73!:%!'$,;0,,!)*%!&%,,+5,!

&%.25%'!82+E!+02!%NI%2$%5;%!.5'!+0)&$5%!I+,,$1&%!80)02%!'%6%&+IE%5),D!!

!

34*-&*%2('5!6&'7*,-&89!'!%,-:$%';*<!(-0%*=%!#'$*.!'>>&-'(4!

@$5;%!)*%!I$+5%%2$5J!:+2H!+8!<.0E.55!O"d\aQ3!c%&&E.5!O"d\dQ3!.5'!#$,;*%2!O"dZLQ3!)*%!0,%!+8!5.E%!

J%5%2.)+2,! )+! ;+&&%;)! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H! '.).! *.,! ,I2%.'!:$'%&7! .5'! ,%6%2.&! .&)%25.)$6%! 6%2,$+5,! *.6%!

1%%5!I2+I+,%'!.5'!)%,)%'D!G)!:+0&'!1%!+0),$'%!)*%!,;+I%!+8!)*$,!I.I%2!)+!2%)2.;%!)*$,!*$,)+273!+2!)*%!

E%)*+'+&+J$;.&! '$,;0,,$+5,! )*.)! *.6%! .;;+EI.5$%'! $)[! )*%! $5)%2%,)%'! 2%.'%2!E.7! 2%8%2! )+! #%22.5'!

.5'!'%!#%'%2$;+!'%!&.!?0.!OLUUXQ!.5'!,I%;$.&!$,,0%,!+8!N-4.B(24=E&B,!.5'!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!Oc%&&E.5!

LUU\.3! LUU\1QD! B%2%3! :%! ,$EI&7! .$E! )+! 12$%8&7! 2%6$%:! ,+E%! .,I%;),! )*.)! .2%! 2%&%6.5)! 8+2!

$EI&%E%5).)$+5!+8!)*$,!E%)*+'+&+J7!$5!:%1!,026%7,3!.5'!'$,;0,,!)*%!;*+$;%,!)*.)!:%!*.6%!E.'%D!

/*%2%!$,!.!J%5%2.&!;+5,%5,0,!)*.)!.57!%88+2)!)+!2%;+5,)$)0)%!)*%!%N*.0,)$6%!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!+8!.5!

$5'$6$'0.&!:+0&'!1%!$&&0,+27D!G5!I.2)3!)*$,!$,!'0%!)+!)*%!,*%%2!,$K%!+8!,0;*!5%):+2H,!.5'!)*%!'%8$5$)$+5!

.5'!E%.,02%! +8! )$%,! O]%25.2'3! e+*5,%53! Y$&&:+2)*3!(;=.2)73! @*%&&%7! .5'! ?+1$5,+5! "ddU[! Y$&&:+2)*3!

e+*5,%53!]%25.2'3!@*%&&%7!.5'!(;=.2)7!"ddUQ[!$5!I.2)3!)*$,!$,!.&,+!.5!%88%;)!+8!2%;+&&%;)$+5!1$.,%,!.5'!

+)*%2! ;+J5$)$6%! &$E$).)$+5,! )*.)! E.7! .88%;)! 2%,I+5,%,! O(;=.2)73! Y$&&:+2)*! .5'! ?%55%&! LUU\QD!

/*%2%8+2%3! .! ;+EE+5&7! .'+I)%'! .II2+.;*! $,! )+! $'%5)$87! .! 2%,)2$;)%'! ,01,%)3! :*+,%! '%8$5$)$+5!

'%I%5',!+5!)*%!2%,%.2;*!R0%,)$+5,D!

_5%! +I)$+5! $,! )+! .&&+:! 82%%! 2%;.&&! :$)*$5! '%8$5%'! ,;+I%! ;+5'$)$+5,! Oc%&&E.5! "d\dQD! c$)*$5! )*$,!

.II2+.;*3!)*%!,%)!+8!2%&%6.5)!.&)%2,!E.7!1%!2%,)2$;)%'!)+!)*+,%!:$)*!:*+E!)*%2%!*.6%!1%%5!;+5).;),!

+6%2!.!J$6%5! )$E%!I%2$+'3! 8+2!%N.EI&%! )*%! &.,)!'.73!:%%H3!E+5)*3!+2!7%.2! O($&.2'+!"dZZb!LdQD!/*$,!

I2+6$'%,!.!;&%.2!2%8%2%5;%!)$E%82.E%!8+2!2%,I+5'%5),3!%6%5!)*+0J*!)*%!I%2$+'!+8!)$E%!;*+,%5!E.7!

5+)! 1%! S)7I$;.&T3! .5'! %6%5! )*+0J*! )*%! 2%;%5)! +;;022%5;%! +2! 82%R0%5;7! +8! $5)%2.;)$+5,! E.7! 1%!

! V!

05;+22%&.)%'!:$)*!R0.&$)7!+2! $EI+2).5;%!+8! )*%!2%&.)$+5,*$I!.,!,%%5!17! )*%!2%,I+5'%5)! O(.2$5!.5'!

B.EI)+5!LUU\b!"XXA"X\[!]$'.2)!.5'!=*.21+55%.0!LU""b!L\"AL\LQD!W.2$.5),!)*.)!2%'0;%!)*%!$EI.;)!

+8!2.2%!%6%5),!0,%!'$.2$%,!+6%2!.!;%2).$5!I%2$+'!+8!)$E%!O#0!LUU\Q!+2!I*+5%!5+)%1++H!'.).!O<+5H$&.!

LUUVQD! C&)%25.)$6%&73! )*%! ,;+I%! ;+5'$)$+5,! E.7! 2%,)2$;)! ;*+$;%! +8! .&)%2,! )+! )*%! ff;+2%T! I%2,+5.&!

5%):+2H,! O(.2,'%5! "dZ\Q3! )*%! I%2,+5,!:*+! .2%! +8! J2%.)%,)! $EI+2).5;%! )+! 2%,I+5'%5),! Oc%&&E.5!

"d\dQ! +2! )*+,%! :$)*! :*+E! )*%7! 8%%&! I.2)$;0&.2&7! ;&+,%D! /*$,! $,! .! ;+EE+5&7! .'+I)%'! .II2+.;*3!

%,I%;$.&&7!$5!,026%7,!$5!:*$;*!8+2!)$E%!;+5,)2.$5),!+2!+)*%2!2%.,+5,3!+5&7!+5%!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!;.5!1%!

$EI&%E%5)%'!.5'!)*%!2%,%.2;*%2!;.5!1%!;+5)%5)!:$)*!,)2+5J!)$%,D!C!:%&&AH5+:5!%N.EI&%!$,!)*%!5.E%!

J%5%2.)+2! 0,%'! $5! )*%! CE%2$;.5! 9%5%2.&! @+;$.&! @026%7! O9@@Q3! .,H$5J! I%+I&%! )+! 5.E%! )*+,%! :$)*!

:*+E!)*%7!S'$,;0,,! $EI+2).5)!I%2,+5.&!E.))%2,T! O]02)!"dZVQD!/*$,!;2$)%2$+5!;.5!1%!;+E1$5%'!:$)*!

)*%! 8+2E%2!+5%! O$5! )*%!9@@3! )*%! )$E%!*+2$K+5! $,! &$E$)%'! )+! )*%! &.,)! ,$N!E+5)*,Q3!.5'!:$)*!.5!0II%2!

&$E$)!)+!)*%!)+).&!50E1%2!+8!.&)%2,!)+!1%!$5;&0'%'!O8$6%!$5!)*%!9@@QD!/*+0J*!:$'%&7!0,%'3!)*$,!.II2+.;*!

&%.6%,! +0)! :%.H! )$%,! .5'! .! 50E1%2! +8! +)*%2! .&)%2,! :*+3! $5! 8.;)3!E.7! I2+6%! ;20;$.&! $5! $58&0%5;$5J!

1%*.6$+2,!+2!$5!I2+6$'$5J!,0II+2)!$5!I.2)$;0&.2!;$2;0E,).5;%,!O(.2$5!.5'!B.EI)+5!LUU\b!"XZQD!

C!'$88%2%5)!+I)$+5!$,!)+!.,H!R0%,)$+5,!)*.)!'%8$5%!.!2.5J%!+8!I+)%5)$.&!+2!.;)0.&&7!,0II+2)$6%!.&)%2,3!.,!

:.,! 8$2,)! .))%EI)%'! 17! ].22%2.! O"dZUQ3! #$,;*%2! O"dZLQ! .5'! E+2%! 2%;%5)&7! 92+,,%))$! OLUU\QD! #+2!

%N.EI&%3!2%,I+5'%5),!E$J*)!*.6%!)+!5.E%!:*+!*.,!2%;%5)&7!*%&I%'!)*%E!O+2!:+0&'!*%&I!)*%EQ!:$)*!

).,H,!.2+05'!)*%!*+E%[!82+E!:*+E!)*%7!;+0&'!1+22+:!,+E%!,E.&&!)*$5J!&$H%!.!)++&!+2!.!;0I!+8!,0J.2[!

:*+E! )*%7!:+0&'! ,%%H! +0)! 8+2! *%&I! $8! )*%7! 5%%'%'! )+! 1+22+:! .! &.2J%! ,0E! +8!E+5%7! O(.2$5! .5'!

B.EI)+5!LUU\b!"\"QD!/7I$;.&&73!%.;*!+8!)*%,%!R0%,)$+5,!%&$;$),!'$88%2%5)!.5,:%2,3!)*%2%17!,0JJ%,)$5J!

)*.)! I%+I&%! ;.5! +1).$5! ,0II+2)! 82+E! '$88%2%5)! ,01,%),! +8! )*%$2! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H,! '%I%5'$5J! +5! )*%!

$,,0%!.)!,).H%D!/*$,!.II2+.;*! $,! )*%2%8+2%!0,%80&! )+!+1).$5! $58+2E.)$+5!+5!)*%!,0II+2)!5%):+2H,!+8!

$5'$6$'0.&,3!10)!'+%,!5+)!I2+6$'%!.!;+EI&%)%!I$;)02%!+8!)*%$2!,+;$.1$&$)7!E+2%!J%5%2.&&7D!

C! ):+A,)%I! ;+E1$5.)$+5! +8! )*%,%! ):+! .II2+.;*%,! $,! '%,;2$1%'! $5! ]$'.2)! .5'! =*.21+55%.0! OLU""QD!

/*%! 8$2,)! ,).J%! .$E,! )+! 2%;+5,)$)0)%! )*%! 12+.'%,)! 5%):+2H! I+,,$1&%3! )+! +1).$5! )*%!E+,)! ;+EI&%)%!

$E.J%! +8! )*%! 2%,I+5'%5)g,! ,+;$.&! ,022+05'$5J,[! )+! .;*$%6%! )*$,3! ]$'.2)! 0,%,! .! 82%%! 2%;.&&! 5.E%!

J%5%2.)+2!$5!:*$;*!2%,I+5'%5),!5.E%!.&)%2,!)*%7!E%%)!$5!6.2$+0,!,+;$.&!;+5)%N),D!C,!.&2%.'7!,*+:5!

$5!(.2$5!OLUUVQ3! 2%8%2%5;%!)+!;+5)%N),!:+2H,!.,!.!E%E+27!.$'3! $5!)*.)! $5'$6$'0.&,!)%5'!)+!E%5)$+5!

.&)%2,!17!.,,+;$.)$+53!;&0,)%2$5J!)*%!5.E%,!+8!)*+,%!:*+!1%&+5J!)+!)*%!,.E%!J2+0I!+2!I.2)$;$I.)%!$5!

)*%!,.E%!;+EE+5!.;)$6$)$%,D!/*%2%8+2%3!.!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!2%8%22$5J!)+!;+5)%N),!+8!$5)%2.;)$+5!2%,0&),!

$5!E+2%!.;;02.)%!%,)$E.)%,!+8! )*%! ,$K%!.5'!I2+I%2)$%,!+8!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,D!]$'.2)h,! ,%;+5'!,).J%!

.$E,!)+!$,+&.)%3!82+E!)*%,%!12+.'!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,3!)*%!,01,%),!+8!.&)%2,!:*+!I2+6$'%!,I%;$8$;!*%&I!

+2!,0II+2)!$5!I.2)$;0&.2!E.))%2,!`8+2!%N.EI&%3!:*+!*.6%!*%&I%'!$5!^+1!,%.2;*D!/*%,%!&$,),!+8!5.E%,!

.2%!J%5%2.)%'!82+E!)*%!+5%!;+E$5J!82+E!)*%!8$2,)!,).J%!+8!)*%!;+5)%N)0.&!5%):+2Hb!I.2)$;$I.5),!;.5!

2%8%2! )+! $)! .5'! .2%! .&,+! .&&+:%'! )+! .''! 5%:! 5.E%,D! c$)*! 2%,I%;)! )+! +)*%2! E%)*+',! 8+2! %&$;$)$5J!

,0II+2)!5%):+2H,3! )*$,!+5%!*.,! )*%!.'6.5).J%!+8!1%$5J!SE+2%!,7,)%E.)$;!.5'!E+2%! &$H%&7! )+!.,,$,)!

)*%! E%E+27! .,! $)! 2%.;*%,! .! ;+EI.2.)$6%&7! 12+.'%2! .22.7! +8! 8$%&',! .5'! )$E%! ,I.5,T! O]$'.2)! .5'!

=*.21+55%.0!LU""b!L\dQD!!

/*%2%! *.6%! 1%%5! 2.2%3! )*+0J*! ,0;;%,,80&3! .))%EI),! )+! $5;&0'%! 5%):+2H! 6$,0.&$K.)$+5,! $5! '.).!

;+&&%;)$+5D!B+J.53!=.22.,;+!.5'!c%&&E.5!OLUU\Q!2%I+2)!)*.)!)*%$2!0,%!+8!6$,0.&!,+;$+J2.E,!1%5%8$)%'!

)*%$2! 2%,I+5'%5),! 17! I2+6$'$5J! )*%E!:$)*! .!E+2%! *+&$,)$;! .5'! '%).$&%'! 6$%:!+8! )*%$2! 2%&.)$+5,*$I,!

)*.5! )2.'$)$+5.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,D!(;=.2)73!(+&$5.3! CJ0$&.2! .5'! ?+).! OLUU\Q! ,*+:! )*%! $5)%2%,)! +8!

;+EI.2$5J!)*%!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!.,!$5$)$.&&7!'2.:5!17!)*%!I.2)$;$I.5)3!:$)*!)*%!J2.I*!+1).$5%'!17!)*%!

! i!

2%,%.2;*%2! .II&7$5J! &.7+0)! +I)$E$K.)$+5! .&J+2$)*E,D! c*$&%! )*%,%! ):+! ,)0'$%,! :%2%! $5)%26$%:%2A

.,,$,)%'3!I.I%2A.5'AI%5;$&!+5%,3!)*%2%!$,!.&,+!,+E%!%NI%2$%5;%!$5!0,$5J!5%):+2H!6$,0.&$K.)$+5!)++&,!$5!

,%&8A.'E$5$,)%2%'! ;+EI0)%2A1.,%'! ,026%7,D! @+8):.2%! )++&,! ,0;*! .,! FJ+>%)! .5'! =AGY>_c! 2%R0$2%!

I.2)$;$I.5),!)+!&$,)!.&)%2,3!)*%$2!.))2$10)%,3!.5'!)*%$2!)$%,!)+!+5%!.5+)*%23!.5'!)*%5!.II&7!.5!+I)$E$K$5J!

.&J+2$)*E! )+! 2%5'%2! )*%! 5%):+2H! J2.I*! $5! R0.,$A2%.&! )$E%D! /*$,! .II2+.;*! *.,! )*%! .'6.5).J%! +8!

I2+6$'$5J!R0$;H!8%%'1.;H!)+!I.2)$;$I.5),!17!,*+:$5J!)*%E!)*%!,*.I%!.5'!,)20;)02%!+8!)*%$2!5%):+2H,!

.5'! I2+EI)$5J! )*%E! )+! E.H%! .'^0,)E%5),! 05)$&! )*%7! 8$5'! )*%! 2%,0&)! ,.)$,8.;)+27D! (;=.2)7! .5'!

9+6$5'.2.E.50^.E! OLUUiQ! ;&%.2&7! %NI&.$5!:*7! 2%,I+5'%5)! 102'%5! '%;&$5%,b! 2%&.)$6%! )+! )2.'$)$+5.&!

,)0'$%,! $5! :*$;*! 2%,I+5'%5),! .2%! 8+2;%'! )+! %6.&0.)%! %.;*! .&)%2! I.$2! .5'! $5'$;.)%! :*%)*%2! +2! 5+)!

)*%2%! $,! .! )$%3! J2.I*$;.&! $5)%28.;%,! .&&+:! '2.:$5J! )$%,! +5&7! :*%2%! )*%7! %N$,)3! )*%2%17! ,I.2$5J!

2%,I+5'%5),! )*%! ).,H! +8! %6.&0.)$5J! .&&! 50&&! )$%,D! B+:%6%23! 6$,0.&! E%)*+',! E.7! .&,+! $5'0;%!

05E+)$6.)%'!2%,I+5'%5),!)+!5%J&%;)!)$%,!)*.)!.2%!5+)!50&&3!)*%2%17!&+:%2$5J!'.).!R0.&$)7D!!!

_02!E%)*+'+&+J$;.&! ,+&0)$+5! ;+E1$5%,! )*%! ;+EI2%*%5,$6%5%,,! +8! ]$'.2)! .5'! =*.21+55%.0h,! ):+A

,).J%!.II2+.;*!:$)*!.!102'%5A2%'0;$5J!J2.I*$;.&!)++&D!_02!.II2+.;*!)+!6$,0.&$K.)$+5!!$EI&%E%5),!$5!

.! ;+EI0)%2A1.,%'! J2.I*$;.&! $5)%28.;%! ,+E%! +8! )*%! &%,,+5,! &%.25%'! 82+E! ,)0'$%,! )*.)! 0,%'! +88&$5%!

6$,0.&$K.)$+53! 5+).1&7!B+J.5! %)! .&D! OLUU\QD! G)! '$88%2,! 82+E! %N$,)$5J! ,+8):.2%! ,+&0)$+5,! $5! )*.)! $)! &%),!

2%,I+5'%5),!'2.:!)*%$2!,+;$.&!5%):+2H!.,!)*%7!,%%!$)3!:$)*+0)!$EI+,$5J!.57!I2%A'%8$5%'!&.7+0)D!@)$&&3!

$)! 2%)2$%6%,! )*%! 05'%2&7$5J! '.).! $5! %'J%! &$,)! 8+2E3! ,+! )*.)! 2%,%.2;*%2,! ;.5! ,01,%R0%5)&7! ;+EI.2%!

)*%E!:$)*! 2%,I+5'%5),h!+:5!'2.:$5J,3! )*%2%17!+1).$5$5J! 2$;*! $58+2E.)$+5!+5!1+)*! )*%!.;)0.&!.5'!

I%2;%$6%'!,+;$.&!,022+05'$5J,!+8!2%,I+5'%5),!.,!$5!(;=.2)73!(+&$5.!%)!.&D!OLUU\QD!!

!

34*!$%1.+!

M.).! 8+2! )*$,! 2%,%.2;*! *.6%! 1%%5! ;+&&%;)%'! .,! I.2)! +8! )*%! I2+^%;)! SC5.AE$.! @+;$.1$&$)7b! .5!

_5&$5%j_88&$5%! @+;$.&!>%):+2H,!CII2+.;*! )+! F.)$5J!M$,+2'%2,T! OC>C(GCQD! /*%! ,)0'7! .''2%,,%,! )*%!

;+5)2+6%2,$.&!:%1,$)%,3!1&+J,!.5'!+5&$5%!8+20E,!+8!I%2,+5,!:$)*!.5+2%N$.!5%26+,.3!10&$E$.!5%26+,.!

OS.5.T!.5'!SE$.T!$5!:%1!I.2&.5;%Q!.5'!+)*%2!%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2,D!(%'$.!5.22.)$6%,!%EI*.,$K%!)*%!;&.$E!

+8!,+E%!+8!)*%E!)*.)!.5+2%N$.! $,!.! &$8%,)7&%!;*+$;%!2.)*%2!)*.5!.!'$,%.,%3!.5'!)*%!'.5J%2!)*.)!)*%7!

E$J*)! ;+5)2$10)%! )+! ,I2%.'$5J!.5'!E.$5)%5$5J!05*%.&)*7!%.)$5J!I2.;)$;%,D! k%)! )*%,%!:%1,$)%,! .&,+!

I2+6$'%! 0,%2,! :$)*! %E+)$+5.&! .5'! I2.;)$;.&! ,0II+2)3! .5'! E.7! E$)$J.)%! )*%! ,%5,%! +8! $,+&.)$+5!

)2.'$)$+5.&&7! %NI%2$%5;%'! 17! %.)$5J! '$,+2'%2! ,088%2%2,D! /*2+0J*! .! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H! ,)0'73!:%! .$E! )+!

,*%'! &$J*)! +5)+! )*%! ;+5,%R0%5;%,! +8! 0,$5J! )*%,%! +5&$5%! ;+EE05$;.)$+5! )++&,! .5'! )+! '%6$,%!

$55+6.)$6%!,+&0)$+5,!8+2!*%.&)*!I+&$;7!.5'!$58+2E.)$+5!;.EI.$J5,D!

]%;.0,%! I+)%5)$.&! 2%,I+5'%5),! .2%! 17! '%8$5$)$+5! G5)%25%)! 0,%2,3!:$)*! .!E%'$0EA)+A*$J*! '%J2%%! +8!

;+EI0)%2!&$)%2.;7!%,I%;$.&&7!8+2!)*+,%!.E+5J!)*%E!:*+!.2%!.0)*+2,!+2!.'E$5$,)2.)+2,!+8!1&+J,!.5'!

8+20E,3!.!:%1!,026%7!.II%.2,!.,!.!E+,)!,0$).1&%!)++&D!_02!I.2)$;$I.5)AJ%5%2.)%'!,+;$+J2.E!'2.:$5J!

)++&!.$E,! )+! 8.;$&$).)%! 2%,I+5'%5),h! ).,H3! $5! )*%! 82.E%:+2H!+8! )*%! ):+A,).J%!E%)*+'!+8!]$'.2)!.5'!

=*.21+55%.0!OLU""Q!:*$;*!2%)2$%6%,!12+.'!,%),!+8!,+;$.&!2%&.)$+5,*$I,!8$2,)3!.5'!)*%!,E.&&%2!,01,%),!

+8!)*+,%!:*+!I2+6$'%!*%.&)*A2%&.)%'!,0II+2)!.8)%2:.2'D!_02!6.2$.5)!O:*$;*!$,!'0%!)+!+02!,01,).5)$6%!

2%,%.2;*!R0%,)$+5,!.5'!E.7!1%!05,0$).1&%!8+2!%N)%5,$+5!)+!+)*%2!,)0'$%,Q!$,!)*.)!:%!'%8$5%!=@&!,%),!

+8! 12+.'! 2%&.)$+5,*$I,! $5,)%.'! +8! +5%3! )*+,%! 8.;%A)+A8.;%! .5'! )*+,%! :$)*! :*+E! $5)%2.;)$+5,! .2%!

I2$E.2$&7!;+EI0)%2AE%'$.)%'D!

! X!

/*%! ,)0'7! :.,! ;+5'0;)%'! $5! )*%! #2%5;*! .5.AE$.! +5&$5%! ;+EE05$)7! $5! (.2;*A@%I)%E1%2! LU""3!

+1).$5$5J!"aX!2%,I+5,%,[!.5'!$5!)*%!]2$)$,*!+5%!$5!>+6%E1%2!LU""!A!(.7!LU"L3!:$)*!"VZ!2%,I+5,%,D!!

G5! 8+&&+:A0I!I*+5%! $5)%26$%:,3!:%!.,H%'!.!,01A,.EI&%!+8!LL!#2%5;*!.5'!"i!]2$)$,*! 2%,I+5'%5),! )+!

;+EE%5)!+5!)*%$2!,+;$+J2.E,3!)+!J.$5!'%%I%23!R0.&$).)$6%!$5,$J*)!$5)+!)*%$2!2%&.)$+5,*$I,D!

!

!

"#$%&''!()%*+)*%$!,-!).$!,/'0/$!(*%#$1!!

]%;.0,%!*%.&)*!2$,H,!.5'!I+)%5)$.&!,+;$.&!,)$JE.!E.H%!+02!).2J%)!I+I0&.)$+5!,%5,$)$6%!.5'!'$88$;0&)!)+!

2%.;*3!:%!*.6%!2%&$%'!+5!I02I+,$6%!2.)*%2!)*.5!2%I2%,%5).)$6%!,.EI&$5JD!C!I2%&$E$5.27!%NI&+2.)$+5!+8!

2%&%6.5)! :%1,$)%,3! 8+20E,! .5'! 1&+J,! *.,! %5.1&%'! 0,! )*2+0J*! ,5+:1.&&$5J! )+! $'%5)$87! .! ,%)! +8!

I+)%5)$.&! 2%,I+5'%5),D! /*%53! 2%,%.2;*! .,,$,).5),! +8! .5! .J%! ;&+,%2! )+! )*.)! +8! )*%! ).2J%)! I+I0&.)$+5!

*.6%! $56$)%'!I.2)$;$I.)$+5!.5'!.;;+EI.5$%'! 2%,I+5'%5),3!:$)*! .! &.5J0.J%!.5'! ,)7&%! )*.)! ;+0&'!1%!

05'%2,)++'! .5'! .II2%;$.)%'! 17! )*%ED! ?%;20$)E%5)! ,)2.)%J7! $,! ,I%;$8$;! )+! )*%! ,01,).5)$6%! $,,0%,!

.''2%,,%'! *%2%3! )*+0J*3! .5'! :%! 1%&$%6%! +02! J2.I*$;.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2! E%)*+'! ;.5! 1%! ,.8%&7!

2%I&$;.)%'!$5!,)0'$%,!)*.)!.'+I)!'$88%2%5)!,.EI&$5J!.II2+.;*%,D!!

/*%!*+E%!I.J%!+8!)*%!+5&$5%!,026%7!12$%8&7!$&&0,)2.)%,!+02!2%,%.2;*!I2+^%;)!.5'!$56$)%,!I.2)$;$I.)$+5D!

C! I.J%! SC1+0)T! I2+6$'%,! 1.;HJ2+05'! $58+2E.)$+53! :*$&%! S-.2)$;$I.)%T! +I%5,! )*%! .;)0.&!

R0%,)$+55.$2%!$5)%28.;%D!?%,I+5'%5),!;.5!.;;%,,!$)!.8)%2!)*%7!;+58$2E!$58+2E%'!;+5,%5)!.5'!.J%3!$5!

&$5%! :$)*! %)*$;.&! 2%R0$2%E%5),D! /*%7! )*%5! 6$%:! .! ,%)! +8! ,%6%5! ).1,D! #+02! +8! )*%,%! ).1,! I+$5)! )+!

,).5'.2'!E0&)$I&%A;*+$;%!+5&$5%!R0%,)$+55.$2%!,%;)$+5,!.1+0)3!2%,I%;)$6%&7b!1.,$;!,+;$+A'%E+J2.I*$;!

$58+2E.)$+5[! ,+;$+A%;+5+E$;! ,).)0,[! I2.;)$;%,! 2%&.)%'! )+!0,%!+8! )*%! G5)%25%)! .5'! ,+;$.&A5%):+2H$5J!

:%1,$)%,[!*%.&)*3!50)2$)$+53!1+'7! $E.J%3!.5'!%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2!%NI%2$%5;%D!C&&!R0%,)$+5,!.2%!I+,%'! $5!

)*%!8$2,)!I%2,+5!O8+2!%N.EI&%3!S/*%!*$J*%,)!R0.&$8$;.)$+5!G!*.6%!$,TQD!/*%!E.^+2$)7!+8!)*%!R0%,)$+5,!.2%!

;&+,%'!.5'!$5!E+,)!;.,%,3!.&&!I+,,$1&%!.5,:%2,!.2%!$'%5)$8$%'!,+!)*.)!)*%!2%,I+5'%5)!+5&7!*.,!)+!)$;H!

)*%! 1+N! ;+22%,I+5'$5J! )+! +5%! +8! )*%E! O+2! E+2%! :*%5! 2%&%6.5)QD! /*$,! .II2+.;*! .$E,! )+! 2%'0;%!

+6%2.&&!2%,I+5'%5)!102'%5!.5'!.&&+:!E+2%!)$E%!)+!;+EI&%)%!)*%!5%):+2H!'2.:$5J!).1,!O,%%!1%&+:QD!

c%! *.6%! $5;&0'%'! .E+5J! ;+5)2+&,! ):+! R0%,)$+5,! )+! J.0J%! )*%! ,$K%! +8! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,! 12+.'&7!

$5)%2I2%)%'3! .5'! ):+! 8+2! )*%! .6.$&.1$&$)7! +8! ,+;$.&! ,0II+2)! )*2+0J*! 5%):+2H! )$%,3! .,! I%2;%$6%'! 17!

2%,I+5'%5),! )*%E,%&6%,D! /*%! R0%,)$+5,! +5! 12+.'! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,! .,H! I.2)$;$I.5),! )+! I2+6$'%! .!

J&+1.&!%,)$E.)%!+8!)*%!50E1%2!+8!I%2,+5,!1%&+5J$5J!)+!,%6%2.&!2%&.)$+5.&!;.)%J+2$%,!`!I%+I&%!:*+E!

)*%7!S).&H!)+3!.5'!$5)%2.;)!:$)*T3!2%,I%;)$6%&7!$5!)*%!:+2HI&.;%3!,;*++&3!8.E$&73!&%$,02%!;%5)2%3!.5'!+5!

)*%!G5)%25%)3!$5!8+20E,!.5'!'$,;0,,$+5!J2+0I,3!1&+J,3!%E.$&3!(@>3!,+;$.&!5%):+2H,!O#.;%1++H3!<.,)D8E!

%);DQD! /*%! R0%,)$+5,! +5! ,0II+2)! .,H! 2%,I+5'%5),! .! J&+1.&! %,)$E.)%! +8! *+:!E.57! I%+I&%! )*%7! ;.5!

S).&H! )+3! .5'! ,%%H! .'6$;%! 82+ET! $5! ;.,%! )*%7! *.6%3! 2%,I%;)$6%&73! .! ,E.&&! I%2,+5.&! ;+5;%25! .5'! .!

,%2$+0,! $,,0%D! @0;*! R0%,)$+5,! .2%! ;&.,,$;.&&7! 0,%'! )+! 8$5%A)05%! %,)$E.)%,! +8! )*%! ,$K%! +8! I%2,+5.&!

.;R0.$5).5;%,! 5%):+2H,! .5'! )+! ;*%;H! )*%! 2%&$.1$&$)7! +8! 2%,I+5,%,! )+! '$88%2%5)! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,!

O]%25.2'!%)!.&D!"ddUQD!G5!,+;$.&!,0II+2)!,)0'$%,3!J&+1.&!%,)$E.)%,!+8!5%):+2H!,$K%!*.6%!)*%!.''$)$+5.&!

.'6.5).J%!+8!I2+6$'$5J!.5! $5'$;.)+2!+8!*+:!;+55%;)%'!I%+I&%! 8%%&! .5'!*+:!E0;*! )*%7! )*$5H! )*%7!

;.5!2%&7!+5!+)*%2,D!!!!

! \!

?'7*!;*0*&'%-&$!

2&%)0+03&/)4&05$5!(,+0,6%&7!5%&80/6!),,'!),!$'0+0)!9%,&5!3$%(,/&'!/$)8,%:(!

/:+!+8! )*%!,026%7! ).1,! $5;&0'%!2%.&A)$E%!6$,0.&$K.)$+5!)++&,! )+!%&$;$)!I.2)$;$I.5),g!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!

)$%,D!/*%,%!,+;$+J2.E,!.2%!.;)0.&&7!):+!J2.I*$;.&!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2,!`!+5%!8+2!+88&$5%!)$%,!:$)*!8.E$&7!

E%E1%2,3!82$%5',3!,;*++&E.)%,3!;+&&%.J0%,!.5'!)*%!&$H%3!.5'!)*%!+)*%2!8+2!+5&$5%!)$%,3!'%8$5%'!.,!)*%!

.&)%2,!:$)*!:*+E!$5)%2.;)$+5,!+;;02!,+&%&7!+2!I2$E.2$&7!)*2+0J*!:%1A1.,%'!,%26$;%,D!/*%!):+!)++&,3!

.6.$&.1&%!$5!F5J&$,*!.5'!$5!#2%5;*3!.2%!)%;*5$;.&&7!.5'!6$,0.&&7!$'%5)$;.&3!.5'!)*%!,)20;)02%!.5'!,;+I%!

+8!R0%,)$+5,!*.6%!1%%5!H%I)!,$E$&.2!)+!%5,02%!;+EI.2.1$&$)7D!/*%!+5&7!'$88%2%5;%,!1%):%%5!)*%E!.2%!

$5!)*%!:+2'$5J!+8!*%.'$5J,3!$5,)20;)$+5,!.5'!%N.EI&%,3!)+!'$,)$5J0$,*!1%):%%5!)*%!+88&$5%!.5'!+5&$5%!

E+'%,!+8!$5)%2.;)$+5D!-.2)$;$I.5),!8$2,)!;+EI&%)%!)*%!,+;$+J2.E!8+2!)*%$2!+88&$5%!.;R0.$5).5;%,3!)*%5!

)*%!+5&$5%!+5%[!)*%7!E.7!$5;&0'%!$5!)*%!&.))%2!.&)%2,!.&2%.'7!8%.)02%'!$5!)*%!8+2E%2D!

CI.2)! 82+E! )*%! +88&$5%j+5&$5%! '$,)$5;)$+53! )*%! ):+! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,! *.6%! 1%%5! H%I)! '%&$1%2.)%&7!

12+.'3! )+! %&$;$)! .! E.N$E0E! 50E1%2! +8! 5+E$5.)$+5,! +8! I%+I&%! :$)*! :*+E! 2%,I+5'%5),! 8%%&!

;+55%;)%'b!$5'%%'!2%,I+5'%5),!.2%!,$EI&7!.,H%'!)+!$5;&0'%!I%2,+5,!)*%7!S).&H%'!)+!OE+2%!)*.5!^0,)!

,.7$5J! *%&&+Q! .5'j+2! $5)%2.;)%'! :$)*TD! /*$,! 82%%! 2%;.&&! .II2+.;*! $,! .;;+EI.5$%'! 17! .! 2%8%2%5;%!

)$E%82.E%! OS$5! )*%! &.,)! ,$N!E+5)*,T3! .,! $5! )*%!9@@!.5'!+)*%2! ,)0'$%,QD!C,!]$'.2)! .5'!=*.21+55%.0!

OLU""Q3!:%!2%8%2!)+!'$88%2%5)!,+;$.&!;+5)%N),!+8!$5)%2.;)$+5!)+!%&$;$)!2%,I+5,%,3!1+)*!1%;.0,%!;+5)%N),!

.2%!,+;$+&+J$;.&&7!2%&%6.5)!.5'!1%;.0,%!2%;.&&!17!.,,+;$.)$+5!E.7!.;)!.,!.!E%E+27A.$'D!B+:%6%23!)*%!

2$,H! )*.)! .! &+5J! ,026%7!E.7!:%.H%5!E+)$6.)$+5! .5'! 2.$,%! '2+IA+0)! .'6$,%,! .J.$5,)! .,H$5J! .! 5.E%!

J%5%2.)+2!R0%,)$+5!8+2!%.;*!I+,,$1&%!;+5)%N)D!/*0,3!:%!*.6%!+5&7!I2+6$'%'!%N.EI&%,!$5!)*%!J%5%2.&!

$5,)20;)$+5,3!$5;&0'$5J3!$5!)*%!;.,%!+8!+88&$5%!)$%,3!,;*++&3!:+2HI&.;%3!8.E$&73!.5'!&%$,02%!;%5)2%[!.5'!$5!

)*%! ;.,%! +8! +5&$5%! )$%,3! S'$,;0,,$+5! 8+20E,3! 1&+J,3! %E.$&3! (@>3! .5'! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H,! O#.;%1++H3!

<.,)D8E!%);DQDP!

4I+5! .;;%,,$5J! )*%! 5%):+2H! 6$,0.&$K.)$+5! ).1,3! I.2)$;$I.5),! .2%! 8$2,)! I2%,%5)%'! :$)*! .! I+IA0I!

:$5'+:!:$)*!$5,)20;)$+5,3!$5;&0'$5J!)*%!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!R0%,)$+5!$),%&8D!/*$,!I.2)!*.,!1%%5!H%I)!)+!.!

E$5$E0E!1%;.0,%!+8!)*%!:%&&AH5+:5!)%5'%5;7!+8!G5)%25%)!0,%2,!)+!,;.5!)%N),!+5!,;2%%5!2.)*%2!)*.5!

;.2%80&&7! 2%.'! )*%ED! -.2)$;$I.5),! )*%5! 6$%:! )*%! .;)0.&! 6$,0.&$K.)$+5! )++&! O8$J02%! "QD! /*%! ,;2%%5!

'$,I&.7,! .! ).2J%)! .)! )*%! ;%5)2%! +8! :*$;*! $,! .! :*$)%! '+)! 2%I2%,%5)$5J! %J+! $),%&8[! )*2%%! ;+5;%5)2$;!

;$2;&%,3!+8!,&$J*)&7!'$88%2%5)!,*.'%,!+8!;+&+23!.2%!I&.;%'!.2+05'!$)D!/*%7!2%I2%,%5)!'$88%2%5)!'%J2%%,!+8!

;&+,%5%,,3!,+!)*.)!2%,I+5'%5),!;.5!I&.;%!)*%!;&+,%,)!.&)%2,!$5!)*%!$55%2!;$2;&%!.5'!)*%!&%,,!;&+,%!+5%,!

$5! )*%! +0)%2! ;$2;&%,D! /*%! ;+5;%5)2$;A;$2;&%!E%).I*+2! *.,! .&2%.'7! 1%%5! ,0;;%,,80&&7! 0,%'! $5! ,%6%2.&!

,)0'$%,3! .E+5J! )*%E! B+J.5! %)! .&D! OLUU\Q3! :*+,%! 2%,I+5'%5),! 8+05'! )*$,! ,)20;)02%! .5'! 5%,)$5J!

,)2.$J*)8+2:.2'!.5'!E+2%!.II%.&$5J!)*.5!)2.'$)$+5.&!:.7,!)+!'$,)$5J0$,*!'%J2%%,!+8!;&+,%5%,,D!!

!

! Z!

!

@2;1&*!A9!"!;&'>4!'$!('0!#*!6255*.!20!#+!'!>'&%2(2>'0%!B6&-7!'!%*$%CD!E51*!.-%$!&*>&*$*0%!'5%*&$!'0.!('0!#*!7-&*!

-&!5*$$!(5-$*!%-!*;-D!34*&*!('0!#*!%2*$!'0.!;&-1>$D!

!

/*%!10))+5,!+5!)*%!2$J*)!,$'%!.&&+:!I.2)$;$I.5),!)+!%5)%2!.&)%2,!.5'!.22.5J%!)*%E!+5!)*%!).2J%)D!/*%!

0II%2A2$J*)!PlP!10))+5!$,!)+!$5;&0'%!.!5%:!I%2,+5D!c*%5!;&$;H$5J!+5!$)3!.!5%:!5+'%!$5!8+2E!+8!.!1&0%!

;$2;&%!.II%.2,3!.5'! )*%!I.2)$;$I.5)! $,!I2%,%5)%'!:$)*!.!:$5'+:!)*.)!.,H,!1.,$;! $58+2E.)$+5!+5! )*$,!

.&)%2b! 5.E%! O)+! 1%! $5,%2)%'!E.50.&&7Q3! J%5'%2! O)+! ;*++,%! 82+E! .!E%50Q3! .5'! )7I%! +8! 2%&.)$+5,*$I!

O.&,+! )+! ;*++,%! 82+E! .! E%503! $5;&0'$5J! 1+782$%5'jJ$2&82$%5'3! I.2)5%23! 82$%5'3! 8.E$&7! E%E1%23!

,;*++&E.)%3!:+2H!;+&&%.J0%3!)0)+23!*%.&)*!I2+8%,,$+5.&3!+)*%2QD!G5'$;.)$+5!+8!)*%!)7I%!+8!)$%!$,!E%.5)!

)+!2%$58+2;%!)*%!2%8%2%5;%!)+!;+5)%N),!I2+6$'%'!$5!J%5%2.&!$5,)20;)$+5,D!/*%!.II&%)!I&.;%,!%.;*!5%:!

.&)%23!17!'%8.0&)3!.)!)*%!;%5)%2!1+))+E!+8!)*%!,;2%%53!.5'!)*%!I.2)$;$I.5)!;.5!E+6%!$)!17!,$EI&%!'2.JD!

W%21.&3! $5!.''$)$+5!)+! ^0,)!I+,$)$+5.&3! $5'$;.)$+5,!+8!'%J2%%!+8!;&+,%5%,,!.II%.2!:*%5!)*%!E+0,%! $,!

*%&'!+6%2! )*%!.&)%2!5+'%b! S:%!.2%! ,+E%:*.)! ;&+,%T3! S:%!.2%! ;&+,%T3! S:%!.2%! 6%27! ;&+,%T3! S:%!.2%!

%E+)$+5.&&7!$5)$E.)%TD!

/*%!+)*%2!10))+5,!;.5!1%!0,%'!)+3!2%,I%;)$6%&73!E+6%!.&)%2,!.2+05'3!'2.:!)$%,!1%):%%5!):+!.&)%2,3!

J2+0I!,%6%2.&!.&)%2,! )+J%)*%23!.5'!'%&%)%!.&)%2,3! )$%,!+2!J2+0I,D!C!,*+2)!'%,;2$I)$+5!+8!%.;*!10))+5!

.II%.2,! +5!E+0,%A+6%2D! /*%2%! $,! 5+! &$E$)! )+! )*%! )+).&! 50E1%2! +8! .&)%2,! )*.)! ;.5! 1%! %5)%2%'3! .5'!

I.2)$;$I.5),!.2%!82%%!)+!E+6%!.5'!2%A.22.5J%!5+'%,3!)$%,3!.5'!J2+0I,!.,!E.57!)$E%,!.,!)*%7!,%%!8$)D!G5!

I.,,$5J3! 5+)$;%! )*.)! .! J2+0I! $5! +02! $EI&%E%5).)$+5! E.7! +2! E.7! 5+)! ;+22%,I+5'! )+! .! 5%):+2H!

! d!

;+EI+5%5)!,)2$;)&7!,I%.H$5Jb!$)!2.)*%2!2%I2%,%5),!.!;+5)%N)!+8!$5)%2.;)$+53!:*+,%!'%8$5$)$+5!$,!&%8)!)+!

)*%!2%,I+5'%5)D!/*0,3!:%!.&&+:!J2+0I,!)+!+6%2&.I!.5'!)$%,!:$)*$5!+2!1%):%%5!J2+0I,!)+!1%!'2.:5D!

#$J02%!"! $,! 82+E!.! )%,)!.5'! $&&0,)2.)%,!.!I+,,$1&%!+0);+E%D!c*%5!I.2)$;$I.5),!;&$;H! )*%!10))+5!SGgE!

'+5%T! OP/%2E$5mP! $5! )*%!#2%5;*!6%2,$+5Q3! )*%!,7,)%E!2%;+2',! )*%$2!.5,:%2,!.5'!E+6%,! )+! )*%!5%N)!

,;2%%5D!/*%!$58+2E.)$+5!2%)2$%6%'!$5;&0'%,!.&)%2,g!5.E%,3!J%5'%23!)7I%!+8!2%&.)$+5,*$I!)+!%J+3!'%J2%%!

+8!;&+,%5%,,!)+!%J+3!)$%,!1%):%%5!.&)%2,!.5'!J2+0I!;+EI+,$)$+53!.5'!$,!,.6%'!$5!)*2%%!8+2E.),b!DNE&!

O,+02;%!8$&%Q3!D;,6!O8+2!0,%!:$)*!,).5'.2'!'.).!.5.&7,$,!,+8):.2%Q!.5'!D^I%J!O.!,;2%%5,*+)!+8!)*%!$E.J%!

'2.:5!17!)*%!I.2)$;$I.5)QD!

!

;.$!(*33,%)!/$)8,%:<!&!(+$/&%0,!&33%,&+.!

/*%!&.,)!).1!+8!)*%!+5&$5%!,026%7!.$E,!)+!%N)2.;)3!82+E!)*%,%!J%5%2.&!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,3!)*%!5.E%,!

+8! .&)%2,! )*.)!I2+6$'%!.'6$;%!.5'! ,0II+2)D!c%!I2%,%5)! 2%,I+5'%5),!:$)*! )*%! 80&&! &$,)!+8! .&)%2,! )*%7!

*.6%!I2%6$+0,&7!%5)%2%'3!.,H$5J!)*%E!)+!;*++,%!)*+,%!.E+5J!)*%,%!.&)%2,!:*+E!)*%7!:+0&'!,%%H!8+2!

*%.&)*A2%&.)%'!,0II+2)[!$8!)*%7!)*$5H!+8!,+E%+5%!%&,%!.)!)*$,!,).J%3!)*%7!.2%!.&&+:%'!)+!%5)%2!+5%!+2!

E+2%!5%:!5.E%,3!:$)*!$5'$;.)$+5!+8!J%5'%2!.5'!)7I%!+8!2%&.)$+5,*$I!.,!1%8+2%!O10)!5+)!+8!)*%$2!)$%,!

)+! +)*%2! .&)%2,QD! >+)$;%! )*.)! )*%! &$,)! 2%,I+5'%5),! ;*++,%! 82+E! $5;&0'%,! .&)%2,! E%5)$+5%'! 1+)*! $5!

+88&$5%!.5'!+5&$5%!5%):+2H,3!)*%2%17!I2+6$'$5J!$58+2E.)$+5!+5!*+:!E0;*!,0II+2)!;+E%,!82+E!+5&$5%!

;+55%;)$+5,3!2%&.)$6%!)+!8.;%A)+A8.;%!,+;$.1$&$)7D!

M$88%2%5)!,01,%),!+8!.!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!E.7!1%!E+1$&$K%'!8+2!'$88%2%5)!)7I%,!+8!,0II+2)[!$5!)*%!;.,%!

+8!%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2,3!+5%!E.7!'$,)$5J0$,*!1%):%%5!E$5+23!'.$&7A&$8%!.$&E%5),!.5'!,%6%2%!'$,)021.5;%,D!

/+!H%%I!)*%!,026%7!,*+2)3!:%!'+!5+)!.,H!2%,I+5'%5),!)+!5.E%!:*+E!)*%7!:+0&'!;+5,0&)!$5!'$88%2%5)!

I+,,$1&%!E.))%2,D!?.)*%23!:%!.,,$J5!)*%E!2.5'+E&7!)+!):+!J2+0I,3!:$)*!.!'$88%2%5)!,;%5.2$+!8+2!%.;*D!

_5%!$,!8.;%'!:$)*!.!2%&.)$6%&7!E05'.5%!$,,0%3!)*%!+)*%2!:$)*!.!E+2%!;2$)$;.&!,$)0.)$+5!O,%%!CII%5'$NQD!

C&)*+0J*!2.5'+E!.,,$J5E%5)!)+!'$88%2%5)!,;%5.2$+,!'+%,!5+)!.&&+:!;+EI.2$5J!)*%!%N)%5)!)+!:*$;*!

)*%!,.E%!$5'$6$'0.&!E.7!.;)$6.)%!'$88%2%5)!)7I%,!+8!)$%,!$5!;2$)$;.&!.5'!$5!5+5A;2$)$;.&!,$)0.)$+5,3!$)!;.5!

2%6%.&!E+2%!J%5%2.&!)2%5',!.E+5J!)*%!I+I0&.)$+5!+1,%26%'D!@I%;$8$;.&&73!:%!%NI%;)!E+2%!,)2+5J!)$%,!!

O;&+,%2!.&)%2,Q! )+!1%!E+1$&$K%'! $5!;.,%!+8!.!,%2$+0,!I2+1&%E!)*.5! $5!;.,%!+8!.!'.$&7A&$8%! $,,0%D! G5!+02!

,)0'73!:%!.&,+!.$E!)+!'%)%;)!:*%)*%2!)*%2%! $,!.57!)%5'%5;7!8+2!,0II+2)!5%):+2H,!)+!1%!,01,%),!+8!

)*%! +88&$5%! 2.)*%2! )*.5! +5&$5%! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,3! .5'! :*%)*%2! .57! ,0;*! )%5'%5;$%,! %N*$1$)!

;+22%&.)$+5!:$)*!+)*%2!6.2$.1&%,!,0;*!.,!)7I%!+8!'$,+2'%2D!?.5'+E!.,,$J5E%5)!$,!E%.5)!)+!%&$E$5.)%!

.57!,%&%;)$+5!%88%;),!.5'!%5,02%!)*.)!;+EI.2$,+5,!.2%!'+5%!:$)*!.&&!+)*%2!)*$5J,!%R0.&D!

F*$(&2>%2-0!-6!&*$15%$!

-2%'$;).1&7! J$6%5! )*%! :%&&AH5+:5! J%5'%2! 1$.,! +8! %.)$5J! '$,+2'%2,3! .5! +6%2:*%&E$5J! E.^+2$)7! +8!

2%,I+5'%5),!.2%!:+E%5D!/*%7!.2%!LL!7%.2,!+&'!+5!.6%2.J%!.5'!.1+0)!Lja!+8!)*%E!.2%!,)0'%5),D!C,!

%NI%;)%'3!E+,)!+8!)*%E!.2%!*%.67!G5)%25%)!0,%2,3!:$)*!XUn!1%$5J!;+55%;)%'!E+2%!)*.5!"i!*+02,!.!

:%%HD! C1+0)! dUn! 2%I+2)! ,+E%! %.)$5J! '$,+2'%2D! /*+,%! .E+5J! )*%E! :*+! :%2%! .&,+! $5)%26$%:%'!

$5'$;.)%!)*.)!$)!)++H!LUAaU!E$50)%,!)+!;+EI&%)%!)*%!+5&$5%!,026%7D!

!

! "U!

!

@2;1&*!G9!'!$'7>5*!-6!;&'>42('5!>*&$-0'5!0*%,-&8$!'$!.&',0!#+!&*$>-0.*0%$D!

!

/*%!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,!+8!+02!2%,I+5'%5),!O.!,01,%)!+8!:*$;*!$,!2%I2%,%5)%'!$5!#$J02%!LQ!.2%!,E.&&$,*3!

:$)*!.5!+88&$5%!.6%2.J%!,$K%!+8!""Di!8+2!#2.5;%!.5'!dDX!8+2!)*%!4Y3!.5'!.5!+5&$5%!.6%2.J%!+8!\Da!8+2!

#2.5;%!.5'!XDL!8+2!)*%!4Y[!Zn!+8!.&&!.&)%2,!.2%!5.E%'!1+)*!+88&$5%!.5'!+5&$5%D!/*%!,$K%!+8!I%2,+5.&!

5%):+2H,! %&$;$)%'! :$)*! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,! $,! ,)2+5J&7! '%I%5'%5)! +5! )*%! ,I%;$8$;! R0%,)$+5! .,H%'!

O]%25.2'!%)!.&D!"ddUQ3!.5'!+02! 8+;0,!+5!2%&.)$+5,*$I,! )*.)!.2%!PE+2%! )*.5! ^0,)! ,.7$5J!*.&&+P!+6%2!.!

'%&$E$)%'!)$E%!I%2$+'!)%5',! )+! 2%,)2$;)!;*+$;%! )+!,$J5$8$;.5)!.&)%2,D!/*0,3!;+EI.2$5J! )*%!,$K%!+8!+02!

5%):+2H,!)+!)*%!,$K%!+8!5%):+2H,!%&$;$)%'!:$)*!,$E$&.2!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2,3!.,!,0EE.2$K%'!$5!]%25.2'!%)!

.&D! O"ddUb!"ZZQ!.5'! $5!]$'.2)!.5'!=*.21+55%.0! OLU""b!LZ"Q3! $5'$;.)%,! )*.)! )*%7!.2%!12+.'&7! $5! &$5%3!

.&)*+0J*! )*%,%!I2%6$+0,!,)0'$%,!'$'!5+)!'$,)$5J0$,*!1%):%%5!+5&$5%!.5'!+88&$5%! )$%,D! G)! 8+&&+:,! )*.)!

2%&.)$6%! )+! $5)%26$%:%2A.,,$,)%'!E%)*+',3!+02! ,%&8A.'E$5$,)%2%'! $5,)20E%5)!'+%,!5+)! ,7,)%E.)$;.&&7!

$5'0;%!05'%22%I+2)$5J!+8!.&)%2,D!

G)!E.7!,%%E!,02I2$,$5J3!)*+0J*3!)*.)!+02!J2.I*$;.&&7!'2.:5!+5&$5%!5%):+2H,!.2%!,E.&&%2!)*.5!+88&$5%!

+5%,3! :*$&%! 2%,I+5'%5),h! J&+1.&! %,)$E.)%,! +8! 5%):+2H! ,$K%! .2%! *$J*%2! 8+2! +5&$5%! )*.5! 8+2! +88&$5%!

5%):+2H,D!G5,$J*)!82+E!$5)%26$%:,!,0JJ%,),!)*.)!)*$,!$,!'0%!)+!,+E%!2%,I+5'%5),!;+05)$5J!.&&!+8!)*%$2!

+5&$5%! ;+5).;),! $5! )*%$2! J&+1.&! %,)$E.)%3! 10)! )*%5! $5)%2I2%)$5J! )*%! ,%;+5'! O+5&$5%Q! J2.I*$;.&! 5.E%!

J%5%2.)+2!+5&7!.,!.!?%&G?=!`.! 2%R0%,)! )+! )*$5H!.J.$5!.1+0)! )*%$2! 2%&.)$+5,*$I,!:$)*! 8+;0,!+5!)*%$2!

;+EI0)%2AE%'$.)%'! ,+;$.&! ;+5)%N),! +8! $5)%2.;)$+5D! C,! .! 2%,0&)3! )*%7! *.6%! 5.E%'! .&)%2,! )*%7!E%%)!

E+,)&7! +5! )*%!c%13! &%.6$5J! +0)! +88&$5%! ;+5).;),! :$)*! :*+E! )*%7! *.6%!E$5$E.&3! )*+0J*! 5+)! 50&&3!

;+EI0)%2AE%'$.)%'!$5)%2.;)$+5,!O8+2!%N.EI&%3!,;*++&E.)%,!:*+!.2%!.&,+!#.;%1++H!82$%5',3!10)!:$)*!

:*+E!;+EE05$;.)$+5!+;;02,!E.$5&7!.)!,;*++&QD!

! ""!

C,!%NI%;)%'! 82+E!,026%7!'%,$J53! ,0II+2)!5%):+2H,!%&$;$)%'! )*2+0J*!,;%5.2$+!R0%,)$+5,!.2%!,E.&&%2!

)*.5!12+.'%2!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,b!8+2!E.^+2!*%.&)*!I2+1&%E,3!aDd!.5'!aD\!2%,I%;)$6%&7!8+2!#2.5;%!.5'!

4Y3! :*$&%! )*%! ;+22%,I+5'$5J! .6%2.J%,! 8+2! E$5+2! $,,0%,! .2%! LDd! .5'! aDLD! G5)%2%,)$5J&7! %5+0J*3!

2%,I+5'%5),h!J&+1.&!%,)$E.)%,!+8!)*%!,$K%!+8!)*%$2!+88&$5%!.5'!+5&$5%!5%):+2H,!%N;%%'%'!)*%!50E1%2!

+8! .&)%2,! %&$;$)%'! )*2+0J*! )*%! ):+! J2.I*$;.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,3!:*$&%! %,)$E.)%,! +8! )*%! ,$K%! +8! )*%$2!

,0II+2)!5%):+2H,!8+2!1+)*!E.^+2!.5'!E$5+2!$,,0%,!:%2%!+6%2.&&!;+5,$,)%5)!:$)*!)*%!50E1%2!+8!.&)%2,!

)*.)!:%2%!E%5)$+5%'!$5!)*%!,;%5.2$+!R0%,)$+5,D!-%+I&%!,%%E!1%))%2!.)!.,,%,,$5J!)*%!%N)%5)!)+!:*$;*!

)*%7! ;.5! 2%&7!+5!+)*%2,! 8+2! ,0II+2)3! )*.5! )*%$2! ,+;$.1$&$)7!E+2%!J%5%2.&&73! .! 8$5'$5J! )*.)! $)!E.7!1%!

$5)%2%,)$5J!)+!;2+,,A;*%;H!$5!,)0'$%,!:$)*!'$88%2%5)!I+I0&.)$+5,D!

/*%!'%5,$)$%,!+8!+02!5%):+2H,!.2%!&+:3!:$)*!.5!.6%2.J%!+8!UDLU!+88&$5%!.5'!UDLi!+5&$5%[!.5'!)*%2%!.2%!

.1+0)!LAa!;&$R0%,!I%2!5%):+2HD!c*$&%!)*$,!E.7!,0JJ%,)!05'%22%I+2)$5J!+8!,)20;)02.&! $58+2E.)$+5!.,!

'$,;0,,%'! $5!(;=.2)7! .5'!9+6$5'.2.E.50^.E! OLUUiQ3! +02! 2%,I+5'%5),! *.6%! .&,+! %N)%5,$6%&7! 0,%'!

)*%!J2+0I$5J!10))+5!+8! )*%!J2.I*$;.&! $5)%28.;%! O,)20;)02.&&7!E%.5$5J80&!10)!5+)! $5;&0'%'! $5!'%5,$)7!

.5'! ;&$R0%A;+05)! ;.&;0&.)$+5,Q! )+! 105'&%! )+J%)*%2! .&)%2,!:*+! ,*.2%! .! J$6%5! ;+5)%N)! +8! $5)%2.;)$+5b!

.1+0)!VUn!+8!.&)%2,!:%2%!$5;&0'%'!$5!,0;*!J2+0I,D!o0.&$).)$6%!$5)%26$%:,!$5'$;.)%!)*.)!2%,I+5'%5),!

05'%2,)++'!6%27!:%&&!)*%!E%.5$5J!+8!J2+0I,3!I2%;$,%&7!2%;+&&%;)$5J!:*$;*!;+5)%N)!O%DJD!,;*++&!;&.,,Q!.!

J2+0I! 2%I2%,%5)%'D! /*$,! ,0JJ%,),! )*.)! )*%! J2+0I$5J! )++&! *.,! 802)*%2! 8.;$&$).)%'! )*%! ).,H! +8!

2%,I+5'%5),!17!I2+6$'$5J!.!R0$;H%2!.5'!%.,7A)+AE%E+2$K%!:.7!)+!2%I+2)!,)20;)02.&!$58+2E.)$+5!)*.5!

'2.:$5J!$5'$6$'0.&!)$%,!1%):%%5!.&&!.&)%2,3!:*%5!.&)%2,!,*.2%!,+E%!;+5)%N)!+8!$5)%2.;)$+5D!/*0,3!)*$,!

,+&0)$+5!E.7!1%!:+2)*!2%A0,$5J!$5!+)*%2!,)0'$%,!)+!;+05)%2!2$,H,!+8!)$%!05'%22%I+2)$5JD!!

/*%!5+)$+5!+8!;&+,%5%,,!$EI&$;$)!$5!+02!;+5;%5)2$;A;$2;&%,!.II2+.;*!I2+6$'%,!.5+)*%2!$EI+2).5)!;&0%!

.,!)+!)*%!0,%80&5%,,!+8!)*%!E%)*+'D!_6%2.&&3!$5)$E.)%!.5'!6%27!;&+,%!.&)%2,!.2%!E+2%!82%R0%5)&7!8+05'!

+88&$5%3!:*$&%!;&+,%!.5'!,+E%:*.)!;&+,%!+5%,!.2%!E+2%!+8)%5!+5&$5%D!/*$,!+0);+E%!$,!;+5,$,)%5)!:$)*!

$5,$J*)!82+E!G5)%25%)!2%,%.2;*!)*.)!:%.H!)$%,!O).H$5J!)*$,!5+)$+5!)+!12+.'&7!$5'$;.)%!2%&.)$+5,*$I,!)*.)!

.2%! &%,,! 82%R0%5)&7!.;)$6.)%'3!+2!.2%!%E+)$+5.&&7! &%,,! $5)%5,%Q!.2%!I2%6.&%5)!+5! )*%!,+;$.&!:%1!.5'!

)*.)!+5%!%88%;)!+8!)*%!2$,%!+8!,+;$.&!E%'$.!*.,!1%%5!I2%;$,%&7!)+!$5;2%.,%!)*%!50E1%2!+8!:%.H!)$%,!+8!

$5'$6$'0.&,! OF&&$,+53! @)%$58$%&'!.5'! <.EI%!LUU\QD!c%!.&,+! 8$5'3! .,!%NI%;)%'3! )*.)! $5)$E.)%!.5'!6%27!

;&+,%!.&)%2,!.2%!E+2%!50E%2+0,!OLja!+8!.&&!.&)%2,Q! $5!,0II+2)!5%):+2H,!8+2!,%2$+0,!$,,0%,3!:*$&%!)*$,!

)%5'%5;7!$,!,&$J*)&7!:%.H%2!$5!E$5+2!$,,0%!5%):+2H,3!%,I%;$.&&7!$5!)*%!4Y!,.EI&%D!/*%,%!8$5'$5J,3!.5'!

8%%'1.;H! 82+E! $5)%26$%:%%,3! ,0JJ%,)! )*.)! 2%,I+5'%5),! ;&%.2&7! 05'%2,)++'! )*%! '$88%2%5;%,! )*.)!

;+5;%5)2$;!;$2;&%,!2%I2%,%5)3!.5'!E.'%!.;)$6%!0,%!+8!)*%ED!!

!

H-0(51$2-0!

c%!*.6%!I2%,%5)%'!.!I.2)$;$I.5)AJ%5%2.)%'!:%1A1.,%'!,+;$+J2.E3!.5!$5)%2.;)$6%!J2.I*$;.&!$5)%28.;%!

%5.1&$5J!I.2)$;$I.5),!)+!'2.:!)*%$2!+:5!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,!:$)*!,$EI&%!.5'!$5)0$)$6%!)++&,D!c2$))%5!

$5,)20;)$+5,!.2%!E$5$E.&!.5'!)*%!6$,0.&!,)20;)02%!$,!.,!,%&8A%NI&.5.)+27!.,!I+,,$1&%D!!c*$&%!'2.:$5J!+5!

I2%6$+0,!%NI%2$%5;%,!+8!0,$5J!J2.I*,! $5! 8$%&':+2H3!+02!.II2+.;*! $,! $55+6.)$6%! $5! )*.)! $)! $,! )*%! 8$2,)!

)$E%!I.2)$;$I.5),!)+!.!:%1!,026%7!;.5!'2.:!)*%$2!+:5!,+;$+J2.E!+5&$5%3!:$)*+0)!8$2,)!%5)%2$5J!&$,),!+8!

.&)%2,g!5.E%,3!.))2$10)%,3!.5'!)$%,!)+!+5%!.5+)*%2D!c%!*.6%!$5)%J2.)%'!+02!J2.I*$;.&!$5)%28.;%!:$)*$5!

.!):+A,)%I!.II2+.;*!.$E$5J!)+!8$2,)!%&$;$)!,+;$.&!)$%,!$5!J%5%2.&3!.5'!)*%5!)+!%N)2.;)!,01,%),!+8!$,,0%A

,I%;$8$;!,0II+2)!)$%,!.,!$5!]$'.2)!.5'!=*.21+55%.0!OLU""QD!!

! "L!

_02! :+2H! ;+58$2E,! )*.)! )*%! 6$,0.&! 5.)02%! +8! )*%! I2+;%'02%! $,! J%5%2.&&7! :%&;+E%'3! .5'! %.,$&7!

05'%2,)++'3! 17! 2%,I+5'%5),D! /*%! ,026%7! '%,$J5! $),%&8! :.,! ;+EI&%N! `).2J%)$5J! .! '$88$;0&)A)+A2%.;*!

I+I0&.)$+5!.5'!$5;&0'$5J!5+)!+5%3!10)!):+!J2.I*$;.&!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2,D!>%6%2)*%&%,,3!2%,0&),!$5'$;.)%!

)*.)!)*%!J2.I*$;.&!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!*.,!1%%5!05'%2,)++'!17!.&&3!:$)*!8%:!,$J5,!+8!2%E.$5$5J!102'%5D!

/*%!,*%%2!50E1%2!+8! 2%,I+5,%,!+1).$5%'! 82+E!.!I+I0&.)$+5! )*.)! $,!*$J*&7! ,%5,$)$6%!.5'!*.'!5%6%2!

1%%5!,026%7%'!1%8+2%3!,$J5.&,!I+)%5)$.&!)+!J%5%2.&$K%!)*$,!E%)*+'!)+!+)*%2!'.).!;+&&%;)$+5!I2+^%;),D!

c%!%NI%;)!$)!)+!1%!I.2)$;0&.2&7!0,%80&!$5!+)*%2!,)0'$%,!+8!G5)%25%)!;+EE05$)$%,3!:*%2%!)*%!;+EI0)%2!

&$)%2.;7!+8!)*%!).2J%)%'!I+I0&.)$+5!;.5!1%!).H%5!8+2!J2.5)%'D!_02!%NI%2$%5;%!,*+:,!)*.)!$)!$,!,0$).1&%!

8+2!*$''%5!+2! ,%5,$)$6%!I+I0&.)$+5,! 8+2!:*+E!.!:%1!,026%7!*.,! )*%!'$,)$5;)$6%!.'6.5).J%!+8!1%$5J!

&%,,! $5)20,$6%! )*.5! 8.;%A)+A8.;%! +2! I*+5%! R0%,)$+55.$2%,D! -+)%5)$.&! 80)02%! .II&$;.)$+5,! $5;&0'%!

$58+2E.)$+5! 2%I+,$)+2$%,!.5'!'$,;0,,$+5!J2+0I,!+5!.57)*$5J! &$H%! ,%&8A*.2E3! $58%;)$+0,!.5'!6%5%2%.&!

'$,%.,%,3!+2!;*2+5$;!;+5'$)$+5,D!!

c%! *.6%! 0,%'! +02! J2.I*$;.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2! $5! .! E$N%'AE%)*+'! 82.E%:+2H3! :$)*! +5&$5%!

R0%,)$+55.$2%,!8+2!.&&!I.2)$;$I.5),!.5'!$5A'%I)*!$5)%26$%:,!8+2!.!,01A,.EI&%!+8!)*%ED!/*%!R0.&$).)$6%!

I.2)!+8!)*%!,)0'7!*.,!I2+6$'%'!.''$)$+5.&!$5,$J*)!17!&%))$5J!2%,I+5'%5),!P)%&&!)*%!,)+27P!+8!)*%!.&)%2,!

)*%7! *.'! '2.:5! +5! )*%! ,+;$+J2.ED! /*$,! ,+&0)$+5! $,! $5! &$5%! :$)*! +02! ;*+$;%! +8! ).2J%)$5J! .! ,I%;$.&!

;+EE05$)73! 2%R0$2$5J! I02I+,$6%! ,.EI&$5J[! 7%)! :%! 1%&$%6%! )*.)! $5! I2$5;$I&%3! +02! J2.I*$;.&! ,+&0)$+5!

;+0&'!8$)!:$)*!1+)*!R0.5)$).)$6%!.5'!E$N%'!E%)*+',3!,01^%;)!)+!I2+I%2!.'.I).)$+5!)+!)*%!;+5)%N)!.5'!

.$E,!+8!%.;*!,)0'7D!!

/*%!E.^+2!&$E$).)$+5!+8!+02!;+5)2$10)$+5!$,!)*.)!$,!'+%,!5+)!,7,)%E.)$;.&&7!;+EI.2%!+02!J2.I*$;.&!)++&!

:$)*!.&)%25.)$6%,3! ,0;*!.,! 8.;%A)+A8.;%!+2!I*+5%!E+'%,!+8!%5R0$273! $5! )%2E,!+8!05$)! 2%,I+5,%! 2.)%3!

6.&$'$)73! 2%&$.1$&$)73!'.).!R0.&$)73! .5'! $)%E!5+5A2%,I+5,%D!]%;.0,%!:%! ).2J%)%'!.! ,I%;$.&!I+I0&.)$+5!

.5'! 0,%'! I02I+,$6%! ,.EI&$5J3! :%! ;.55+)! I2+6$'%! .57! J%5%2.&$K.1&%! %6$'%5;%! .,! )+! :*%)*%2! +02!

,+&0)$+5!:+0&'! 1%! 1%))%2! )*.53! +2! %R0$6.&%5)! )+3!E+2%! )2.'$)$+5.&! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2! R0%,)$+5,D!c%!

,$EI&7! %52$;*! )*%! I+)%5)$.&! ,I%;)20E! +8! E%.5,! .6.$&.1&%! )+! 8$5'! )*%! :%1! 8+2E.)! )*.)! :+0&'! 1%!

%R0$6.&%5)! )+! %,).1&$,*%'! 5.E%! J%5%2.)+2,3! .5'! &%.6%! )*%! R0%,)$+5! +8! ;+EI.2$,+5! )+! 80)02%!

2%,%.2;*D!@)0'$%,!:$)*!.!,$EI&%2!'%,$J5!O8+2!%N.EI&%!:$)*!+5&7!+5%!5.E%!J%5%2.)+23!+2!'$2%;)%'!.)!

E+2%! ,).5'.2'! I+I0&.)$+5,Q3! :+0&'! 1%! I.2)$;0&.2&7! :%&&! ,0$)%'! )+! I2+6$'%! 802)*%2! $5,$J*)! $5)+! )*%!

J%5%2.&!;.I.;$)7!+8!J2.I*$;.&!,+&0)$+5,!)+!$EI2+6%!:%1!,026%7,!$5!,+;$.&!5%):+2H!.5.&7,$,D!

!

! "a!

">>*0.2=!

!

9&+1.&!%,)$E.)%,!+8!5%):+2H!,$K%b!

/+'.73!G!*.6%!DDD!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!).&H!)+!.5'!j+2!$5)%2.;)!:$)*!$5!E7!,;*++&3!:+2HI&.;%3!8.E$&73!&%$,02%!

;%5)2%3!%);DQD!

/+'.73!G!*.6%!DDD!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!).&H!)+!.5'!j+2!$5)%2.;)!:$)*!+5!)*%!G5)%25%)3!8+20E,!.5'!'$,;0,,$+5!

J2+0I,3!1&+J,3!%E.$&3!(@>3!,+;$.&!5%):+2H,!O#.;%1++H3!<.,)D8E!%);DQD!

G8!G!*.6%!.!,E.&&!I%2,+5.&!;+5;%253!G!*.6%!DDD!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!;.5!).&H!)+3!.5'!,%%H!.'6$;%!82+ED!

G8!G!*.6%!.!,%2$+0,!$,,0%3!G!*.6%!DDD!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!;.5!).&H!)+3!.5'!,%%H!.'6$;%!82+ED!

!

>.E%!J%5%2.)+2!`+88&$5%!,+;$.&!5%):+2Hb!

G!.E!5+:!J+$5J!)+!'2.:!E7!5%):+2H!+8!;+5).;),D!

/*%,%!.2%!I%+I&%!:*+E!G!*.6%!).&H%'!)+!OE+2%!)*.5!^0,)!,.7$5J!*%&&+Q!.5'j+2! $5)%2.;)%'!:$)*! $5!)*%!

&.,)!,$N!E+5)*,3!.5'!:*+E!G!$5)%2.;)!:$)*3!8+2!%N.EI&%3!.)!,;*++&3!$5!)*%!:+2HI&.;%3!:$)*!E7!8.E$&73!+2!

.)!E7!&%$,02%!;%5)2%3!%);D!

G! .E!)*%!'+)!.)! )*%!;%5)2%!+8! )*%! ).2J%)D! G! ,*.&&!I&.;%! )*%!+)*%2,! O1&0%!'+),Q!.2+05'!E%3!:$)*! )*+,%!

;&+,%,)!)+!E%!)+:.2',!)*%!;%5)2%!.5'!)*%!+)*%2,!802)*%2!.:.7D!

G!;.5!;.&&!)*%E!17!)*%$2!8$2,)!5.E%3!&.,)!5.E%3!$5$)$.&,!%);D!`!I2+6$'%'!G!;.5!2%;+J5$K%!)*%E!&.)%2D!G8!):+!

I%2,+5,!,*.2%!)*%!,.E%!5.E%3!G!;.5!'$,)$5J0$,*!)*%E!17!.''$5J!.!50E1%2!+2!.!&%))%2D!

!

>.E%!J%5%2.)+2!`+5&$5%!,+;$.&!5%):+2Hb!

G! .E! 5+:! J+$5J! )+! 5.E%! E7! G5)%25%)! ;+5).;),D! /*%,%! .2%! I%+I&%! :*+E! G! *.6%! ).&H%'! )+! .5'j+2!

$5)%2.;)%'!:$)*!$5!)*%!&.,)!,$N!E+5)*,3!.5'!:*+E!G!$5)%2.;)!:$)*3!8+2!%N.EI&%3!+5!'$,;0,,$+5!8+20E,3!

1&+J,3! %E.$&3!(@>3! .5'! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H,! O#.;%1++H3! <.,)D8E! %);DQD! G! ;.5! 5.E%! )*%! ,.E%! I%2,+5,! .,!

1%8+2%3!.5'!j!+2!+)*%2,D!

G! .E!)*%!'+)!.)! )*%!;%5)2%!+8! )*%! ).2J%)D! G! ,*.&&!I&.;%! )*%!+)*%2,! O1&0%!'+),Q!.2+05'!E%3!:$)*! )*+,%!

;&+,%,)!)+!E%!)+:.2',!)*%!;%5)2%!.5'!)*%!+)*%2,!802)*%2!.:.7D!

G! ,*.&&! 2%A0,%! )*%! ,.E%! 5.E%! 8+2! )*%! I%2,+5,! G! *.6%! .&2%.'7!E%5)$+5%'! 1%8+2%D! G! ;.5! ;.&&! .&&! +)*%2!

I%2,+5,!17!)*%$2!8$2,)!5.E%3!&.,)!5.E%3!$5$)$.&,!%);D!`!I2+6$'%'!G!;.5!2%;+J5$K%!)*%E!&.)%2D!

!

>.E%!J%5%2.)+2!`,0II+2)!5%):+2H,b!

OG$..(<&3<4%3Q(c*.)! 8+&&+:,! $,! )*%! &$,)!+8!.&&!I%2,+5,! G!*.6%!5.E%'!.,!E7!;+5).;),3!1+)*!+5&$5%!.5'!

+88&$5%D! <%)g,! 5+:! $E.J$5%! .! ,E.&&! ;+5;%25b! G! *.6%! 2%;%5)&7! 5+)$;%'! ,01,).5)$.&! *.$2! &+,,! .5'! G! .E!

&++H$5J!8+2!.!)2%.)E%5)D!G5!)*$,!&$,)3!.2%!)*%2%!.57!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!;+0&'!).&H!)+3!.5'!:*+!;+0&'!.'6$,%!

E%p!G8!)*%2%!.2%!.57!+)*%2!I%2,+5,!G!:+0&'!&$H%!)+!).&H!)+3!10)!:*+!.2%!5+)!$5!)*%!&$,)3!G!;.5!.''!)*%$2!

5.E%,!1%&+:D!

O4%-&",( -,,"4Q(c*.)! 8+&&+:,! $,! )*%! &$,)! +8! .&&! I%2,+5,! G! *.6%!5.E%'!.,!E7! ;+5).;),3! 1+)*!+5&$5%! .5'!

+88&$5%D! <%)g,!5+:! $E.J$5%! )*.)! G! .E!05:%&&!.5'!E7!'+;)+23!:*+! $,!:+22$%'3! $,! ;+5,$'%2$5J! $5I.)$%5)!

*+,I$).&!)2%.)E%5)D!G5!)*$,!&$,)3!.2%!)*%2%!.57!I%2,+5,!:*+E!G!;+0&'!).&H!)+3!.5'!:*+!;+0&'!.'6$,%!E%p!

G8!)*%2%!.2%!.57!+)*%2!I%2,+5,!G!:+0&'!&$H%!)+!).&H!)+3!10)!:*+!.2%!5+)!$5!)*%!&$,)3!G!;.5!.''!)*%$2!5.E%,!

1%&+:D! !

!

! "V!

!

I*6*&*0(*$!

].22%2.3!(D! "dZUD! C!E%)*+'! 8+2! )*%! .,,%,,E%5)! +8! ,+;$.&! ,0II+2)! 5%):+2H,! $5! ;+EE05$)7! ,026%7!

2%,%.2;**(+&334<=-&3,!ab!ZA"aD!

]%25.2'3! ?DBD3! FD=D! e+*5,%53! -DMD! Y$&&:+2)*3! =D! (;=.2)73! 9DCD! @*%&&%7! .5'! @D! ?+1$5,+5D! "ddUD!

=+EI.2$5J!8+02!'$88%2%5)!E%)*+',!8+2!E%.,02$5J!I%2,+5.&!,+;$.&!5%):+2H,D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!"Lb!"\dA

L"iD!

]$'.2)3! =D3! .5'! eD! =*.21+55%.0D! LU""D! B+:! )+! J%5%2.)%! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,b! $,,0%,! .5'! )++&,! 8+2! .!

,+;$+&+J$;.&!I%2,I%;)$6%D!N-4.B(24=E&B,!Lab!LXXqLZXD!

]02)3!?D!"dZVD!>%):+2H!$)%E,!.5'!)*%!J%5%2.&!,+;$.&!,026%7D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!Xb!Lda`aadD!

=.,$&&$3!CDCD3!-D!/01.2+3!.5'!-D!C2.7.D!LU"LD!/%5!7%.2,!+8!C5.D!<%,,+5,!82+E!.!)2.5,'$,;$I&$5.27!1+'7!+8!

&$)%2.)02%!+5!+5&$5%!I2+A%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2!:%1,$)%,D!O&<-$.(O<-43<4(J3I&%G$=-&3!i"b!"L"A"adD!

=+2+E$5.3!<D3!.5'!9D!=+%5'%2,D!LUUXD!?%&$.1$&$)7!.5'!6.&$'$)7!+8!%J+;%5)%2%'!5%):+2H!'.).!;+&&%;)%'!

6$.!:%1D!C!E%).A.5.&7,$,!+8!E0&)$&%6%&!E0&)$)2.$)!E0&)$E%)*+'!,)0'$%,D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!LZb!LUdqLa"D!

=+0I%23!(D-D3! #D9D!=+52.'3! .5'!?D! /+02.5J%.0D!LUU\D!W$,0.&! ;+5)%N)!%88%;),! $5!:%1! ,026%7,D!)"#.-<(

R?-3-&3(S"$%=4%.D!\"b!XLa`XaVD!

M$&&E.53!MDCD!.5'!eDMD!@E7)*D!LUU\D!M%,$J5!%88%;),!$5!)*%!)2.5,$)$+5!)+!:%1A1.,%'!,026%7,D!/G4%-<$3(

T&"%3$.(&I()%4C43=-C4(24B-<-34!aLb!dUAdXD!

F&&$,+53!>D3!=D!@)%$58$%&'3!.5'!=D!<.EI%D!LUU\D!/*%!1%5%8$),!+8!#.;%1++H!P82$%5',bP!@+;$.&!;.I$).&!.5'!

;+&&%J%!,)0'%5),h!0,%!+8!+5&$5%!,+;$.&!5%):+2H!,$)%,D!T&"%3$.(&I(+&G?"=4%F24B-$=4B(+&GG"3-<$=-&33!

"Lb!"D!*))Ibjj^;E;D$5'$.5.D%'0j6+&"Lj$,,0%Vj%&&$,+5D*)E&!!

#%22.5'3! CD3! .5'! CD! '%! #%'%2$;+! '%! &.! ?0.D! LUUXD! (%)*+',! +8! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H,! .5.&7,$,D! G5!

U4G&>%$?EDQ($3$.D,-,($3B(,D3=E4,-,3!!%'D!9D!=.,%&&$3!eD!W.&&$53!9D!c05,;*3!6+&!GW3!\ViA\XVD!CE,)%2'.E3!

F&,%6$%2D!

#$%&'$5J3! >D3! ?D(D! <%%3! .5'! 9D! ]&.5HD! LUUZD! !E4( O/V;( W$3B#&&A( &I( R3.-34( X4,4$%<E( 24=E&B,D!

/*+0,.5'!_.H,3!=Cb!@.J%D!

#$,;*%23!=D!"dZLD!!&(U@4..(/G&3>(N%-43B,D!=*$;.J+b!45$6%2,$)7!+8!=*$;.J+!-2%,,D!

#03!kD!LUU\D!=+5).;)!'$.2$%,b!]0$&'$5J!.2;*$6%,!+8!.;)0.&!.5'!;+EI2%*%5,$6%!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,D!N-4.B(

24=E&B,!"db!"dVAL"\D!

92+,,%))$3!(D!LUU\D!C2%!#2%5;*!5%):+2H,!'$88%2%5)p!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!Ldb!ad"AVUVD!

B+J.53! ]D3! eDCD! =.22.,;+3! .5'! ]D! c%&&E.5D! LUU\D! W$,0.&$K$5J! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,b! :+2H$5J! :$)*!

I.2)$;$I.5)A.$'%'!,+;$+J2.E,D!N-4.B(24=E&B,!"db!""Xq"VVD!

Y$&&:+2)*3! -D3! FD! e+*5,%53! BD?D! ]%25.2'3! 9D! @*%&&%73! .5'! =D! (;=.2)7D! "ddUD! F,)$E.)$5J! )*%! ,$K%! +8!

I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,("Lb!LZdqa"LD!

! "i!

<.0E.553!FD!_D!"d\aD!Y&3B,(&I()."%$.-,GQ(!E4(N&%G,($3B(O"#,=$3<4(&I(Z%#$3(O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,D!>%:!

k+2Hb!e+*5!c$&%7D(

<+5H$&.3!(D!LUUVD!-*+5%!5+)%1++H,!.,!'.).!+5!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H,D!+&334<=-&3,!LXb!iaAX"D!

<+K.2!(.582%'.3!YD3!WD!W%*+6.23! .5'!WD!B&%1%;D!LUUVD!=+&&%;)$5J!%J+A;%5)2%'!5%):+2H!'.).! 6$.! )*%!

:%1D!24=&B&.&[A-(LC4LA-!"b!LdiqaL"D!

(.2$53!CD!LUUVD!C2%!2%,I+5'%5)!E+2%!&$H%&7!)+!&$,)!.&)%2,!:$)*!;%2).$5!;*.2.;)%2$,)$;,p!GEI&$;.)$+5,!8+2!

5.E%!J%5%2.)+2!'.).D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!LX!b!LZdqaU\D!

(.2$53!CD3!.5'!YD>D!B.EI)+5D!LUU\D!@$EI&$87$5J!)*%!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2b!.&)%25.)$6%,!

)+!)2.'$)$+5.&!E0&)$I&%!.5'!,$5J&%!5.E%!J%5%2.)+2,D!N-4.B(24=E&B,!"db!"Xa`"daD!

(.2,'%53!-DWD!"dZ\D!=+2%!'$,;0,,$+5!5%):+2H,!+8!CE%2$;.5,D!/G4%-<$3(O&<-&.&>-<$.(X4C-4@!iLb!"LL`

a"D!

(.)K.)3!4D!.5'!=D!@5$^'%2,D!LU"UD!M+%,!)*%!+5&$5%!;+&&%;)$+5!+8!%J+A;%5)2%'!5%):+2H!'.).!2%'0;%!'.).!

R0.&$)7p!C5!%NI%2$E%5).&!;+EI.2$,+5D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!aLb!"UiA"""D!!

(;=.2)73! =D3! .5'! @D! 9+6$5'.2.E.50^.ED! LUUiD! C! E+'$8$%'! %&$;$).)$+5! +8! I%2,+5.&! 5%):+2H,! 0,$5J!

'75.E$;!6$,0.&$K.)$+5D!+&334<=-&3,!LXb!X"qXdD!

(;=.2)73!=D3!-DMD!Y$&&:+2)*3!.5'!eD!?%55%&&D!LUU\D!GEI.;)!+8!E%)*+',!8+2!2%'0;$5J!2%,I+5'%5)!102'%5!

+5!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!,)20;)02.&!E%.,02%,D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!Ldb!aUUAa"iD!

(;=.2)73!=D3!eD<D!(+&$5.3!=D!CJ0$&.23!.5'!<D!?+).D!LUU\D!C!;+EI.2$,+5!+8!,+;$.&!5%):+2H!E.II$5J!.5'!

I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!6$,0.&$K.)$+5D!N-4.B(24=E&B,!"db!"Viq"XLD!

($&.2'+3!?D(D!O%'QD!"dZZD!N$G-.-4,($3B(O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,D!>%:1027!-.2H3!=Cb!@.J%D!

W%*+6.23! WD3! YD! <+K.2! (.582%'.3! 9D! Y+2%53! .5'! WD! B&%1%;D! LUUZD! (%.,02$5J! %J+A;%5)%2%'! ,+;$.&!

5%):+2H,!+5!)*%!:%1b!R0%,)$+55.$2%!'%,$J5!$,,0%,D!O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,!aUb!L"aqLLLD!!

c%&&E.53! ]D! "d\dD! /*%! ;+EE05$)7! R0%,)$+5b! )*%! $5)$E.)%! 5%):+2H,! +8! F.,)! k+2H%2,D! /G4%-<$3(

T&"%3$.(&I(O&<-&.&>D(ZVb!"LU"`aaD!

c%&&E.53!]D3!CD!o0.5AB..,%3!eD!c$))%3!.5'!YD>D!B.EI)+5!LUU"D!M+%,!)*%!G5)%25%)!$5;2%.,%3!'%;2%.,%!

+2! ,0II&%E%5)! ,+;$.&! ;.I$).&p! @+;$.&! 5%):+2H,3! I.2)$;$I.)$+5! .5'! ;+EE05$)7! ;+EE$)E%5)D! !E4!

/G4%-<$3(Y4E$C-&%$.(O<-43=-,=!Vib!VaX`XiD!

c%&&E.53!]D!LUU\.D!=*.&&%5J%,!$5!;+&&%;)$5J!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!'.).b!/*%!5.)02%!+8!I%2,+5.&!5%):+2H!

.5.&7,$,D!N-4.B(24=E&B,!"db!"""A""iD!

c%&&E.53! ]D! LUU\1D! /*%! 5%):+2H! $,! I%2,+5.&b! G5)2+'0;)$+5! )+! .! ,I%;$.&! $,,0%! +8! O&<-$.( P4=@&%A,*(

O&<-$.(P4=@&%A,(Ldb!aVdAaiXD!

! "X!

!

"(80-,5*.;*7*0%$!

/*$,! .2)$;&%! $,! I.2)! +8! )*%! 2%,%.2;*! I2+^%;)! fC5.A($.! @+;$.1$&$)7b! .5! _5&$5%j+88&$5%! ,+;$.&! 5%):+2H,!

.II2+.;*!)+!%.)$5J!'$,+2'%2,g!OC5.E$.Q3!,0II+2)%'!17!)*%!#2%5;*!CJ%5;%!>.)$+5.&%!'%!&.!?%;*%2;*%3!

C>?!OJ2.5)!50E1%2!C>?AUdAC<GCAUU"QD!CII2+6.&,!*.6%!1%%5!+1).$5%'!82+E!+&GG-,,-&3(P$=-&3$.(B4(

.\J3I&%G$=-]"4(4=(B4,(1-#4%=^,!O=>G<Q!.5'!)*%!?%,%.2;*!F)*$;,!=+EE$))%%!+8!F;+&%!'%,!B.0)%,!F)0'%,!

%5!@;$%5;%,!@+;$.&%,3!-.2$,D!

/*%!:%1A1.,%'!.II&$;.)$+5!*.,!1%%5!'%6%&+I%'! $5!;+&&.1+2.)$+5!:$)*!F2.5+,3!-.2$,3!.5'!)*%!,+02;%!

;+'%! ;.5! 1%! .;;%,,%'! .)b! *))Ibjj:::D.5.E$.D82j,+02;%j;$1&%j,+02;%DK$ID! C5.E$.! FJ+;%5)%2%'!

>%):+2H! #&.,*! CII&$;.)$+5! 8+2! C5.E$.! C>?! $,!

&$;%5,%'! 05'%2! .! =2%.)$6%! =+EE+5,! C))2$10)$+5! `! >+5! =+EE%2;$.&! aDU!

45I+2)%'!<$;%5,%!*))Ibjj;2%.)$6%;+EE+5,D+2Jj&$;%5,%,j17A5;jaDUjD!

c%! .;H5+:&%'J%! )*%! $EI+2).5)! ;+5)2$10)$+5,! )+! )*%! 8$%&':+2H! +8! )*%! C>C(GC! I2+^%;)! )%.E!

E%E1%2,!.5'!2%,%.2;*!.,,$,).5),[!.5'!:%!)*.5H!]%.)!.5'!M+;)$,,$E+D82!8+2!.'6%2)$,$5J!+02!,)0'7!+5!

)*%$2! :%1,$)%,D! c%! .2%! J2.)%80&! )+! C&%N$,! #%22.5'3! ]%25$%! B+J.53! /+E! CD]D! @5$^'%2,3! .5'! )*2%%!

.5+57E+0,!2%8%2%%,!+8!N-4.B(24=E&B,!8+2!6.&0.1&%!;+EE%5),!.5'!,0JJ%,)$+5,!+5!I2%&$E$5.27!'2.8),!

+8!)*$,!I.I%2D!

!