Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in...
Transcript of Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in...
![Page 1: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems
S. Gurvitz
Weizmann Institute and NCTS
Outline:
1. Single-electron approach to electron transport.
2. Quantum rate equations.
3. Decoherence and measurement.
1
![Page 2: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
LECTURE 1
Single-electron approach to electron transport.
2
![Page 3: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Nonequilibrium transport in mesoscopic systems
E1E0
E0 E1
2E
2E
Two−dimensional electron gas
Iµµ
L
R
AlGaAs
GaAs
E
Double−dot (qubit)
Emitter
I
Quantum dot (resonant tunneling)
Collector
electrodes
3
![Page 4: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Electron motion in the double-dot (double-well).
Electrostatic qubit
E1 2EΩ 0
Schematical representation
Tunneling Hamiltonian: HQ = E1a†1a1 + E2a
†2a2 + Ω0(a
†2a1 + a†1a2)
All parameters in the tunneling Hamiltonian (E1,2 and Ω0) are re-
lated to the double-well potential in the configuration space: J. Bardeen,
PRL 6, 57 (1961), S.G. et al, PRA 69, 042705 (2004).
4
![Page 5: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
V(x)=U (x)+U (x)1 2
E1
V(x)
xx0
E2
E1
U (x)1
x0
E2
Φ2(x)
U (x)2
xx0
Φ1(x)
x
HQ = E1a†1a1 + E2a
†2a2 + Ω0(a
†2a1 + a†1a2)
Ω0 = −√
2|E|m
Φ1(x0)Φ2(x0)
The coupling Ω0 is real, but it can be of a positive or negative sign.
5
![Page 6: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Electrostatic qubit
E1 2EΩ 0
Schematical representation
Electron wave function: |Ψ(t)〉 =[b1(t)a
†1 + b2(t)a
†2
]|0〉.
The Schrodinger equation: i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = HQ|Ψ(t)〉.ib1(t) = E1b1(t) + Ω0b2(t)
ib2(t) = E2b2(t) + Ω0b1(t)
The initial condition: b1(0) = 1, b2(0) = 0. The probability of finding
the electron in the second dot is |b2(t)|2 = Ω20/ω
2[1 − cos2(ωt)], where
ω =√
Ω20 + ε2 is the Rabi frequency and ε = E1 − E2. Therefore
|b2(t)|2 ¿ 1 for ε À Ω0.
6
![Page 7: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
1
t
ε=0
ε>>Ω
2 |b (t)| 2
0
N -coupled wells
Ω1 Ω2 ΩN−1
E E EE1 23 N
The probability of finding the electron in the last well for |Ei−Ei+1| À |Ωi|:
|bN(t)|2 ∼ Ω21
ε21
Ω22
ε22
· · · Ω2N−1
ε2N−1
∼(
Ω
ε
)2N
∼ e−N/N0
where N0 is the localization length (Anderson localization).
7
![Page 8: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Decay to continuum
0E Ωr
rE
Tunneling Hamiltonian:H = E0a†0a0 +
∑r Era
†rar +
∑r Ωr(a
†ra0 + a†0ar).
The wave function: |Ψ(t)〉 = [b0(t)a†0 +
∑r br(t)a
†r|0〉.
The Schrodinger equation: i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = H|Ψ(t)〉:ib0(t) = E0b0(t) +
∑r
Ωrbr(t)
ibr(t) = Erbr(t) + Ωrb0(t)
Initial conditions: b0(0) = 1 and br(0) = 0. The Laplace transform:
b(E) =∫∞0 b(t) exp(iEt)dt.
8
![Page 9: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
0E Ωr
rE
(E − E0)b0(E)−∑r
Ωrbr(E) = i
(E − Er)br(E)− Ωrb0(E) = 0
Substituting br(E) from the second equation to the first one,[E − E0 −
∑r
Ω2r
E − Er
]b0(E) = i
Replace sum over r by an integral:∑
r →∫
ρR(Er)dEr, where
ρR = dr/dEr is the density of states. We assume: Ω(Er)=const and
ρR(Er)=const. Then
∑r
Ω2r
E − Er
→∞∫
−∞
Ω2(Er)ρR
E − Er + iδdEr = −iπΩ2
RρR = −iΓR
2
Therefore b0(E) = iE − E0 + iΓR/2
9
![Page 10: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The inverse Laplace transform:
b0(t) =
∞+iδ∫
−∞+iδ
e−iEt
E − E0 + iΓR/2
(dE
2πi
)E
R
2Γ
0E −i
The probability of finding the electron inside the dot |b0(t)|2 = e−ΓRt.
The origin of the irreversibility.
|b (t)|02
t
1Finite reservoir
|b (t)|02
t
1Infinite reservoir
For infinite reservoirs the time of return increases to infinity.
10
![Page 11: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Resonant tunneling (Single Electron Transistor).
El
E rl
LµEr0E
Ω ΩµR
l
Tunneling Hamiltonian:
Hset =∑
l
Ela†l al+
∑r
Era†rar+E0a
†0a0+
(∑
l
Ωla†l a0 +
∑r
Ωra†ra0 + H.c.
)
Single-electron approach: The entire system is occupied by a one electron,
which is initially at the level El in the left reservoir. The wave function:
|Ψ(t)〉 =
[∑
l
bl(t)a†l + b0(t)a
†0 +
∑r
br(t)a†r
]|0〉
The initial condition: bl(0) = δll, b0(0) = br(0) = 0.
11
![Page 12: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
El
E rl
LµEr0E
Ω ΩµR
l
The Laplace transform: |Ψ(E)〉 =∫∞0 |Ψ(t)〉 exp(iEt)dt. Then the
time-dependent Schrodinger equation, i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = Hset|Ψ(t)〉 reads:
(E − El)bl(E)− Ωlb0(E) = iδll⇐= the initial condition
(E − E0)b0(E)−∑
l
Ωlbl(E)−∑
r
Ωr br(E) = 0
(E − Er)br(E)− Ωr b0(E) = 0
Substituting bl(E) and br(E) from the 1-st and the 3-d equations to the 2-d one:(
E − E0 −∑
l
Ω2l
E − El−
∑r
Ω2r
E − Er
)b0(E) =
iΩl
E − El
Replacing sums by integrals we find: b0(E) = 1
E −E0 + iΓL + ΓR
2
iΩlE − El
12
![Page 13: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
El
E rl
LµEr0E
Ω ΩµR
l
The amplitude of finding the electron inside the dot (the inverse Laplace transform)
b0(t) =
∞∫
−∞b0(E)
dE
2πi=
Ωl
El − E0 + iΓ/2
(eiElt − e−iE0t−(Γ/2)t
)
where Γ = ΓL + ΓR is the total width of the level E0. The probability of findingthe electron inside the right reservoir (collector):
P(l)R (t) =
∑r
|br(t)|2 =∑
r
∫br(E)b∗r(E
′)ei(E′−E)tdEdE′/(2π)2
The average current:
I(l)R (t) = dP
(l)R (t)/dt =
∑r
∫i(E′ − E)br(E)b∗r(E
′)ei(E′−E)tdEdE′/(2π)2
where br(E) = [Ωr/(E−Er)]b0(E). Finally the average current: I(l)R (t) = ΓR|b0(t)|2.
13
![Page 14: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
El
E rl
LµEr0E
Ω ΩµR
l
The total current in the collector is a non-coherent sum over all occupied electronstates (El) of the emitter: IR(t) =
∑l I
(l)R (t). Replacing sum over (l) by an integral:
IR(t) =
µL∫
µR
ΓR|b0(t)|2ρLdEl
In the steady-state limit (t → ∞) we find b0(t) → Ωl
(El−E0+iΓ/2)e−iElt.
Then the stationary current, I = I(t →∞)
I =
µL∫
µR
ΓLΓR
(El − E0)2 + Γ2/4
(dEl
2π
)=
µL∫
µR
T (E)dE⇐= The Landauer formula
Here T (E) is the penetration coefficient. For infinite bias (µL−µr À Γ)
the steady-state current I = ΓLΓR
ΓL+ΓR.
14
![Page 15: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
LECTURE 2
Quantum rate equations.
15
![Page 16: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
The main drawback of the single-electron approach: non-interacting electrons.
Quantum rate equations (an intuitive approach).
µR
Lµ
LΓ RΓ
LΓ RΓ
µR
(1)
n
(0)
Lµ
n
n is a number of electrons in collector.
σ(n)00 (t) = −ΓLσ
(n)00 (t)︸ ︷︷ ︸
loss term
+ΓRσ(n−1)11 (t)︸ ︷︷ ︸
gain term
σ(n)11 (t) = −ΓRσ
(n)11 (t) + ΓLσ
(n)00 (t)
The accumulated charge: Q(t) =∑
n
n[σ(n)00 (t) + σ
(n)11 (t)].
The current: I(t) = Q(t) =∑
n
n[σ(n)00 (t) + σ
(n)11 (t)] = ΓR
∑n
n[σ(n−1)11 (t)− σ
(n)11 (t)]
= ΓR
∑n
σ(n)11 (t) = ΓRσ11(t) ⇐= the total probability of finding the dot occupied.
In the steady-state limit: σ11(t →∞) = ΓL
ΓL+ΓR. The current: I(t →∞) = ΓLΓR
ΓL+ΓR.
The same result as in the single-electron approach for infinite bias (µL−µR À ΓL,R).
16
![Page 17: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Non-interacting electrons
Lµ
µRLΓ LΓ
LΓ LΓ
RΓ
RΓ
RΓ
RΓ
(2)
(1 )(0)
(1 )
n
nn
nσ
(n)00 = −2ΓLσ
(n)00 + ΓR(σ(n−1)
11↑ + σ(n−1)11↓ )
σ(n)11↑ = −(ΓL + ΓR)σ(n)
11↑ + ΓLσ(n)00 + ΓRσ
(n−1)22
σ(n)11↓ = −(ΓL + ΓR)σ(n)
11↓ + ΓLσ(n)00 + ΓRσ
(n−1)22
σ(n)22 = −2ΓRσ
(n)22 + ΓL(σ(n)
11↑ + σ(n)11↓)
The steady-state current: I = 2ΓLΓR/(ΓL + ΓR)
Coulomb blockade (σ22 = 0)
Lµ
µRLΓ
LΓ
LΓRΓ RΓ
RΓ
(1 )
(0) (1 )
n
nn
σ(n)00 = −2ΓLσ
(n)00 + ΓR(σ(n−1)
11↑ + σ(n−1)11↓ )
σ(n)11↑ = −ΓRσ
(n)11↑ + ΓLσ
(n)00
σ(n)11↓ = −ΓRσ
(n)11↓ + ΓLσ
(n)00
The steady-state current: I = 2ΓLΓR/(2ΓL +ΓR)
17
![Page 18: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Application of rate equations to qubit measurements
Point-contact as a detector: S.G., Phys. Rev. B 56, 15 215 (1997).J.M. Elzerman, R. Hanson, J.S. Greidanus, L.H.W. van Beveren, S. De Franceschi,L.M.K. Vandersypen, S. Tarucha, L.P. Kouwenhoven, Physica E 25, 135 (2004).
Ω
Ω
Schematic representationPOINT−CONTACT DETECTOR
µR
0
E1
E1
I1 I2
I1µR
0
E2
µL I2E2
E E1 2
µL
18
![Page 19: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
m
M.H. Devoret and R.J. Schoelkopf, Nature 406, 1039 (2000).T. Hayashi, T. Fujisawa, H.D. Cheong, Y.H. Jeong, Y. Hirayama, Phys. Rev. Lett.91, 226804 (2003).J. Gorman, D.G. Hasko, D.A. Williams, Phys. Rev. Lett., 95, 090502 (2005).S.A. Gurvitz and G.P. Berman, Phys. Rev. B72, 073303 (2005).
19
![Page 20: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Qubit measurements with a double−dot detector
QUBIT
DETECTOR DETECTOR
QUBIT
L
ΩE
µ
2
Lµ
µRµ R
E
E
1
2
EΩ
1
0E0E I 0E +U
I=00E
R. Brenner, T.M. Buehler, and D.J. Reily, J. Appl. Phys. 97, 034501 (2005).T.Gilad and S.G., Phys. Rev. Lett., 97, 116806 (2006).HuJun Jiao, Xin-Qi Li, and JunYan Luo, Phys. Rev. B75, 155333 (2007).
20
![Page 21: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Qubit measurements with the point-contact detector
2II1n n
Ωlr lr
Ω’E l E r E l E r
ΩE E
1 2
0ΩE E
1 2
0
The density matrix for an entire system, σ(n)ij (t). The Bloch-type rate equations:
σ(n)11 = −D1σ
(n)11 + D1σ
(n−1)11 + iΩ0(σ
(n)12 − σ
(n)21 )
σ(n)22 = −D2σ
(n)22 + D2σ
(n−1)22 + iΩ0(σ
(n)21 − σ
(n)12 )
σ(n)12 = i(E2 − E1)σ
(n)12 + iΩ0(σ
(n)11 − σ
(n)22 )− D1 + D2
2σ
(n)12 +
√D1D2σ
(n−1)12 ,
where D1,2 = I1,2/e. Tracing over the detector states n we find
σ11 = iΩ0(σ12 − σ21)
σ22 = iΩ0(σ21 − σ12)
σ12 = i(E2 − E1)σ12 + iΩ0(σ11 − σ22)− (Γd/2)σ12,
where σij(t) =∑
nσ
(n)ij (t) and Γd = (
√I1/e−
√I2/e)2 is the decoherence rate.
21
![Page 22: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Detector current
2II1n n
Ωlr lr
Ω’E l E r E l E r
ΩE E
1 2
0ΩE E
1 2
0
The density matrix for an entire system, σ(n)ij (t). The Bloch-type rate equations:
σ(n)11 = −D1σ
(n)11 + D1σ
(n−1)11 + iΩ0(σ
(n)12 − σ
(n)21 )
σ(n)22 = −D2σ
(n)22 + D2σ
(n−1)22 + iΩ0(σ
(n)21 − σ
(n)12 )
σ(n)12 = i(E2 − E1)σ
(n)12 + iΩ0(σ
(n)11 − σ
(n)22 )− D1 + D2
2σ
(n)12 +
√D1D2σ
(n−1)12 ,
Tracing the qubit states in the density matrix σ(n)ij we obtain the probability of finding n
electrons in the collectror by time t:
Pn(t) = σ(n)11 (t) + σ
(n)22 (t)
The (ensemble) average current is:
< I(t) >= e∑
nPn(t) = (I1 − I2)σ11(t) + I2
22
![Page 23: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Quantum-mechanical derivation of rate equations for quantum transport
S.G. and Ya. Prager,
PRB 53, 15 932 (1996);
S.G., PRB 56, 15 215 (1997);
PRB 57, 6602 (1998);
S.G. and Mozyrsky, PRB in press,
arXiv:0704.0194
Resonant tunneling through the SET.
LµEl
Er1EΩ Ω
µRl r
Tunneling Hamiltonian:
Hset =∑
l
Ela†l al +
∑r
Era†rar + E1a
†1a1 +
∑
l,r
(Ωla†l a1 + Ωra
†ra1 + H.c.)
The wave function:
|Ψ(t)〉 =
b0(t) +
∑
l
b1l(t)a†1al +
∑
l,r
brl(t)a†ral +∑
l<l′,r
b1rll′(t)a†1a†ralal′ + · · ·
|0〉.
At t = 0 all the levels in the left (right) reservoirs are occupied up to the Fermienergies µL and µR, i.e. b0(0) = 1 and all other bα(0) = 0. The amplitudes b(t) areobtained from the Schrodinger equation i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = Hset|Ψ(t)〉.
23
![Page 24: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
µE1
lΩµL
R
lrb1lb
ElEr
R
L
µE1
l
µEl
Ω rErΩrΩ
The probability of finding the dot occupied:
σ11(t) =∑
l
|b1l(t)|2
︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(0)11 (t)
+∑
l<l′,r
|b1ll′r(t)|2
︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(1)11 (t)
+∑
l<l′<l′′,r<r′|b1ll′l′′rr′(t)|2
︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(2)11 (t)
+ · · · =∞∑
n=0
σ(n)11 (t) ,
The probability of finding the dot unoccupied:
σ00(t) = |b0(t)|2︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(0)00 (t)
+∑l,r
|blr(t)|2
︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(1)00 (t)
+∑
l<l′,r<r′|bll′rr′(t)|2
︸ ︷︷ ︸σ(2)00 (t)
+ · · · =∞∑
n=0
σ(n)00 (t) .
Rate equations:
σ(n)00 (t) = −ΓLσ
(n)00 (t) + ΓRσ
(n−1)11 (t)
σ(n)11 (t) = ΓLσ
(n)00 (t)− ΓRσ
(n)11 (t) ,
Derivation24
![Page 25: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
LµEl
Er1EΩ Ω
µRl r
The wave function:
|Ψ(t)〉 =
[b0(t) +
∑l
b1l(t)a†1al +
∑l,r
brl(t)a†ral +
∑l<l′,r
b1rll′(t)a†1a†ralal′ + · · ·
]|0〉.
Substituting |Ψ(t)〉 into the Schrodinger equation i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = Hset|Ψ(t)〉 we obtain,
ib0(t) =∑
l
Ωlb1l(t)
ib1l(t) = (E1 − El)b1l(t) + Ωlb0(t) +∑
r
Ωrblr(t)
iblr(t) = (Er − El)blr(t) + Ωrb1l(t) +∑
l′Ωl′b1ll′r(t)
· · · · · · · · ·
The Laplace transform: b(E) =∫∞0
eiEtb(t)dt.
25
![Page 26: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
LµEl
Er1EΩ Ω
µRl r
Eb0(E)−∑
l
Ωlb1l(E) = i
(E + El − E1)b1l(E)− Ωlb0(E)−∑
r
Ωr blr(E) = 0
(E + El − Er)blr(E)− Ωr b1l(E)−∑
l′Ωl′ b1ll′r(E) = 0
· · · · · · · · ·
Replace the amplitude b in each of the sums∑
Ωb by an expression obtained fromthe subsequent equation. For example:
[E −
∑
l
Ω2l
E + El − E1
]b0(E)−
∑
l,r
ΩlΩr
E + El − E1blr(E) = i.
Replace the sums over l and r by integrals:∑
l →∫
ρL(El) dEl , where ρL(El) isthe density of states. Then the first sum becomes an integral
S1 =∫ µL
−Λ
ρL(El)dElΩ2
L(El)E + El − E1
26
![Page 27: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
S1 =∫ µL
−Λ
ρL(El)dElΩ2
L(El)E + El − E1
In the limit of high bias, µL = Λ →∞:
S1 = −iπΩ2L(Ei − E)ρL(E1 − E) = −i
ΓL
2,
El
E −E−i ε1
We assumed weak energy dependence of ρL and ΩL.The equation for the amplitude b0(E) becomes
[E − i
ΓL
2
]b0(E)−
∑
l,r
ΩlΩr
E + El − E1blr(E) = i.
The second term (“cross” term):∫ Λ
µR
ρR(Er)dEr
∫ µL
−Λ
ρL(El)dElΩL(El)ΩR(Er)blr(E, El, Er)
E + El − E1=⇒ 0 for Λ →∞
All singularities of the amplitude blr(E, El, Er) in the El variable are below the real axis.
27
![Page 28: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Indeed, iterating the Scrodinger equation we find
blr(E, El, Er) =Ωr b1l
E + El − Er+
∑l′
Ωl′ b1ll′rE + El − Er
=ΩlΩr b0(E)
(E + El − Er)(E + El − E1)+ · · ·
Therefore all “cross” terms vanish in the large bias
limit, Λ →∞.
El
E −E−i εrE −E−i ε 1
Finally the Schrodinger equation is transformed in the large bias limit to the following set
of equation:
(E + iΓL/2)b0(E) = i
(E + El − E1 + iΓR/2)b1l(E)− Ωlb0(E) = 0
(E + El − Er + iΓL/2)blr(E)− Ωr b1l(E) = 0
· · · · · · · · ·
Using the inverse Laplace transform we reduce the Schrodinger equation to the rate
equations:
σ(n)00 (t) = −ΓLσ
(n)00 (t) + ΓRσ
(n−1)11 (t)
σ(n)11 (t) = ΓLσ
(n)00 (t)− ΓRσ
(n)11 (t) .
28
![Page 29: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
LECTURE 3
Decoherence and relaxation processes in open systems
generated by fluctuating environment.
Outline:
1. Decoherence and Relaxation of the two-state system (qubit) due to
interaction with the environment.
2. Quantum mechanical model of random force acting on the qubit.
3. Relation of the decoherence and relaxation rates to the fluctuation
spectrum of the environment.
4. Decoherence and measurement.
1
![Page 30: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Phenomenological treatment of the environment.
(Bloch equations).
Dynamic of a two-state (spin 1/2) system.
i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = H|Ψ(t)〉, where H = εσz+Ωσx, and |Ψ(t)〉 =
b1(t)
b2(t)
Two-state system can be represented by an electrostatic qubit.
ElectrodesSchematic representation
- e(2)
e
(1)(1) (2)
W
Here |b1(2)(t)|2 is a probability of finding the electron in the first (second) dot.
2
![Page 31: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
ElectrodesSchematic representation
- e(2)
e
(1)(1) (2)
W
For the initial condition: b1(0) = 1, b2(0) = 0.
|b2(t)|2 =Ω2
Ω2 + ε2(1− cos2 ωRt), where ωR =
√Ω2 + ε2.
The density matrix: σ11(t) = |b1(t)|2, σ22(t) = |b2(t)|2, σ12(t) = b1(t)b∗2(t).
The Schrodinger equation i|Ψ(t)〉 = H|Ψ(t)〉 is transformed to
σ11 = iΩ(σ12 − σ21)
σ22 = iΩ(σ21 − σ12)
σ12 = −2i ε σ12 + iΩ(σ11 − σ22)
3
![Page 32: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Decoherence due to interaction with the environment
(2)(1)
e- eW
σ11 = iΩ(σ12 − σ21)
σ22 = iΩ(σ21 − σ12)
σ12 = −2i ε σ12 + iΩ(σ11 − σ22)− (Γd/2)σ12,
where Γd is the decoherence rate. The density-matrix becomes the
statistical mixture for any ε. (Qubit loses the energy for ε > 0).
σ(t) =
σ11(t) σ12(t)
σ21(t) σ22(t)
t→∞−→
1/2 0
0 1/2
4
![Page 33: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Relaxation (phonon emission)
+ W
E0
EE − =2−
W E+− gE
σ−−(t) = −Γrσ−−(t)
σ+−(t) = i(E− − E+)σ+−(t)− Γr
2σ+−(t) ,
where Γr is the relaxation rate. The qubit appears in a pure (ground) state.
σ(t) =
σ11(t) σ12(t)
σ21(t) σ22(t)
t→∞−→
1/2 1/2
1/2 1/2
5
![Page 34: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Combined effect of decoherence and relaxation on the qubit behavior.
The qubit density matrix can be represented as σ(t) = (1 + τ · S(t))/2, whereτ = τx,y,z are the Pauli matrices and S(t) = Sx,y,z(t) is the “polarization” vector.
Sz = −Γr
2Sz − 2ΩSy
Sy = 2Ω Sz − Γd + Γr
2Sy
Sx = −Γd + 2Γr
2(Sx − Sx)
where Sx = Sx(t →∞) = 2Γr/(Γd+2Γr).
⇐= Bloch NMR equations forT−1
1 = (Γd + 2Γr)/2 andT−1
2 = (Γd + Γr)/2.
“Classical” origin of decoherence and relaxation of the qubit:
Random fluctuations of qubit parameters (or magnetic field for spin).
How relaxation and decoherence are related to the fluctuations spectrum?
Quantum mechanical models of the environment.
6
![Page 35: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Dynamical quantum mechanical model for fluctuations of qubit parameters
with the controllable fluctuations spectrum.
Electrostatic Qubit
Single Electron Transistor (Environment)
(W)Fluctuation of coupling
W
Fluctuation of energy
e
-e
(e)
I I
7
![Page 36: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Fluctuation of coupling (Rabi frequency) between qubit states
(2)(2)(1) (1)
E0
- e- e
lE rWµL ErµR
W WQUBIT
SET
e e’
lWE0
H = HQ + HSET + Hint HQ = ε(a†1a1 − a†2a2) + Ω(a†1a2 + a†2a1)
HSET =∑
l Elc†l cl +
∑r Erc
†rcr + E0c
†0c0 +
∑l,r(Ωlc
†l c0 + Ωrc
†rc0 + H.c.)
Hint = δΩ c†0c0(a†1a2 + a†2a1), where δΩ = Ω′ − Ω.
For large bias voltage the Schrodinger equation i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 = H|Ψ(t)〉 is
reduced to rate equations for the density matrix, σjj′(t).
8
![Page 37: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Quantum rate equations (S.G. and Ya. Prager, PRB 53, 15 932 (1996),
S.G., PRB 56, 15 215 (1997); PRB 57, 6602 (1998); S.G. and Mozyrsky, arXiv:0704.0194
σaa = −ΓLσaa + ΓRσbb + iΩ(σac − σca),
σbb = −ΓRσbb + ΓLσaa + iΩ′(σbd − σdb),
σcc = −ΓLσcc + ΓRσdd + iΩ(σca − σac),
σdd = −ΓRσdd + ΓLσcc + iΩ′(σdb − σbd),
σac = −2iεσac + iΩ(σaa − σcc)− ΓLσac + ΓRσbd,
σbd = −2iεσbd + iΩ′(σbb − σdd)− ΓRσbd + ΓLσac.
(2)(2)(2) (1)(1) (1)(2)
(d)(c)(b)(a)
QUBIT
SET
The available discrete states of the entire system
(1)
GR GRE0
L
W W W W’ ’
GR GRGLG LGLG
9
![Page 38: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
(2)(2)(2) (1)(1) (1)(2)
(d)(c)(b)(a)
QUBIT
SET
(1)
GR GRE0
L
W W W W’ ’
GR GRGLG LGLG
Tracing the SET variables we obtain the reduced density matrix of the qubit:
σ11(t) = σaa(t) + σbb(t), σ22(t) = σcc(t) + σdd(t), σ12(t) = σac(t) + σbd(t)
The qubit’s density matrix becomes the mixture for any qubit-SET coupling
(δΩ = Ω′ − Ω)
σ(t)t→∞−→
1/2 0
0 1/2
Therefore there is no relaxation of the qubit, but only decoherence.
10
![Page 39: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
(2)(2)(2) (1)(1) (1)(2)
(d)(c)(b)(a)
QUBIT
SET
(1)
GR GRE0
L
W W W W’ ’
GR GRGLG LGLG
The fluctuation spectrum of Ω is given by the SET charge correlator:
SQ(ω) =∫ ∞
−∞〈δQ(0)δQ(t)〉eiωtdt
The correlator can be evaluated via P1(t) = σbb(t) + σdd(t), which is a
probability of finding the SET occupied. One find:
SQ(ω) =2ΓLΓR
Γ(ω2 + Γ2)
where Γ = ΓL + ΓR. The fluctuation spectrum is not affected by the qubit.
11
![Page 40: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Comparison with Bloch equations.
σ11 = iΩ(σ12 − σ21)
σ22 = iΩ(σ21 − σ12)
σ12 = −2i ε σ12 + iΩ(σ11 − σ22)− (Γd/2)σ12
Damping oscillations with the Rabi frequency: ωR =√
Ω2 + ε2.
In weak coupling limit (small fluctuations of the Rabi frequency) δωR ¿ Γ
the qubit behavior obtained from the rate equations for the entire system
coincides with that obtained from the Bloch equations with the decoherence
rate
Γd = 2 (δωR)2 SQ(0)
There is no relation between Γd and S(ω) in a strong coupling limit,
δωR À Γ ∼ S−1Q (0)
12
![Page 41: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
The probability of finding the electron in the first dot if the qubit for
ε = 2Ω, ΓL = Ω, ΓR = 2Ω and δΩ = 0.5Ω. The solid line is the exact
result (rate equations), whereas the dashed line is obtained from the
Bloch-type rate equations.
10 20 30 40 50tW
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
(a) (b)
10 20 30 40 50tW
-0.4-0.2
00.20.40.60.81 t
t
t
Re 12
Im 1211 s ( )
s ( )
s ( )
13
![Page 42: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Fluctuation of the qubit’s energy levels
(2) (1)(1) (2)
lE
E0 ErµR
W We e+U
QUBIT
SETµL
ee- -
rWlW
H = HQ + HSET + Hint HQ = ε(a†1a1 − a†2a2) + Ω(a†1a2 + a†2a1)
HSET =∑
l Elc†l cl +
∑r Erc
†rcr + E0c
†0c0 +
∑l,r(Ωlc
†l c0 + Ωrc
†rc0 + H.c.)
Hint = U c†0c0a†1a1, where U is Coulomb energy.
For the large bias voltage, µL − µR, the Schrodinger equation, i∂t|Ψ(t)〉 =
H|Ψ(t)〉, is reduced to rate equations for the density matrix, σjj′(t),
describing the qubit and the SET at once.
14
![Page 43: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
The available discrete states of the entire system
−−−
’’’’
(b)(a) (d)(c)
−W We ee+U e+U
e e e e
GR
WW
GL GR GL GRRGLGLG
The tunneling widths are energy independent: Γ′L,R = ΓL,R. The charge
correlator is not affected by the qubit, SQ(ω) = 2ΓLΓR/[Γ(ω2 + Γ2)].
There is no relaxation of the qubit, Γr = 0. In a weak coupling limit,
U ¿ (Ω2 + ΓΩ)1/2, the decoherence rate
Γd = U2 SQ(ωR)
There is no relation between Γd and S(ω) in a strong coupling limit,
U À (Ω2 + ΓΩ)1/2. The qubit is localized in the limit U/Ω →∞.
15
![Page 44: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
The tunneling widths are energy dependent: Γ′L,R 6= ΓL,R (back-action):
Weak coupling, ∆Γ ∝ U .
(2)(2) (1)(1)(1)(1) (2)
−−−−
’’’’
(2)W
e ee+U e+U
e e e e
GR
WW
GL GR GL GRRGLGL
W
G
The qubit’s density matrix does not turn to the mixture in the steady-state:
σ(t)t→∞−→
1/2− αU βU
βU 1/2 + αU
Relaxation takes place, Γr 6= 0. The charge correlator is affected by the
qubit (the back action). From a comparison with Bloch equations we find:
Γd + 2Γr = U2 SQ(ωR)
16
![Page 45: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Decoherence and measurement.
(2)(2) (1)(1)(1)(1) (2)
−−−−
(2)W We ee+U e+U
e e e e
GR
WW
GL GR G GRRGLGLGL
The Coulomb interaction U À ΓL,R, but U ¿ Ω (small qubit’s distortion).
20 40 60 80 100tW0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
t11s ( )Decoherence rate Γd in the
case of “measurement” ex-
ceeds by order of magnitude
the decoherence from fluctu-
ations of the qubit’s levels.
17
![Page 46: Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic ......Electronic transport and measurements in mesoscopic systems S. Gurvitz Weizmann Institute and NCTS Outline: 1. Single-electron](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042811/5fa464f3ce2c386f4c424cff/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Summary
• Random fluctuations of the qubit parameters due to interaction with
the environment can be described by simple quantum rate equations.
• In the absence of back-action on the fluctuating environment (”pure
environment”) no relaxation of the qubit takes place.
• In the presence of back-action (“measurement regime”) relaxation of
the qubit takes place, in general.
• In weak coupling limit the decorerence (relaxation) rate is given by the
fluctuation spectrum of the environment.
• No relation between the decoherence (relaxation) rate is found in strong
coupling limit. The qubit is localized.
• The method is mostly suitable for multi-qubit systems. How the
decoherence rate scales with number of coupled qubits?
18