Electronic Structure of Correlated Materials : a DMFT Perspective Gabriel Kotliar Physics Department...
-
date post
20-Dec-2015 -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
1
Transcript of Electronic Structure of Correlated Materials : a DMFT Perspective Gabriel Kotliar Physics Department...
Electronic Structure of Correlated Materials : a DMFT Perspective
Gabriel Kotliar
Physics Department and
Center for Materials Theory
Rutgers University
In Realistic Theories , GRC on Correlated Electrons.
June 29-July 3rd 2002
Supported by the NSF DMR 0096462
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Outline
Introduction Basic ideas of Dynamical Mean Field Theory and
its extensions. Qualitative successes of DMFT. Realistic implementation of DMFT. Illustrations: NiO (with S. Savrasov) Fe and Ni (with Lichtenstein and Katsnelson) Outlook.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Weakly correlated electrons:band theory. Simple conceptual picture of the ground
state, excitation spectra, transport properties of many systems (simple metals, semiconductors,….).
A methods for performing quantitative calculations. (Density functional theory, in various approximations).
Success story : Density Functional Linear Success story : Density Functional Linear ResponseResponse
Tremendous progress in ab initio modelling of lattice dynamics& electron-phonon interactions has been achieved(Review: Baroni et.al, Rev. Mod. Phys, 73, 515, 2001)
(Savrasov, PRB 1996)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Limitations of LDA
LDA spectra can be taken a starting point for perturbative (eg. GW ) calculations of excitation spectra and transport.
THIS DOES NOT WORK for strongly correlated systems, eg oxides containing 3d, 4f, 5f elements. CHARACTER OF THE EXCITATION SPECTRA is not captured by LDA.
LDA does not have good predicted power for ground state properties in this system either.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Localization vs Delocalization Strong Correlation Problem
•A large number of compounds with electrons in partially filled shells, are not close to the well understood limits (localized or itinerant). Non perturbative problem.•These systems display anomalous behavior (departure from the standard model of solids). Standard approaches (LDA, HF ) do not work well.•Dynamical Mean Field Theory. Treats atoms and bands. Treats QP bands and Hubbard bands. Exact in large dimensionality.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Strongly correlated electrons
Large degeneracy. Low energy scales. Many Competing forms of long range order (various
forms of charge-spin-orbital and even currents) Quasidegenerate ground states, with different
forms of magnetic order. Competition between different possible states,
frustration, phase separation. Tunability. Intricate microsctrucure. Mesoscale.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
1
10
1( ) ( )
( )n nn k nk
G i ii t i
w ww m w
-
-é ùê ú= +Sê ú- + - Sê úë ûå
DMFT Impurity cavity construction: A. Georges, G. Kotliar, PRB, (1992)]
†
0 0 0
[ ] ( )[ ( , ')] ( ')o o o oS Go c Go c U n nb b b
s st t t t ¯= +òò ò
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
0
†( )( ) ( ) ( )L n o n o n S GG i c i c iw w w=- á ñ
10 ( ) ( )n n nG i i iw w m w- = + - D
0
1 † 10 0 0 0 ( )( )[ ] ( ) [ ( ) ( ) ]n n n n S Gi G G i c i c iw w w w- -S = + á ñ
Weiss field
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
1
10
1( ) ( )
( )n nn k nk
G i ii t i
w ww m w
-
-é ùê ú= +Sê ú- + - Sê úë ûå
DMFT Impurity cavity construction
1
10
1( ) ( )
V ( )n nk nk
D i ii
w ww
-
-é ùê ú= +Pê ú- Pê úë ûå 0
1 † 10 0 ( )( )[ ] ( ) [ ( ) ( ) ]n n n n S Gi G G i c i c ia bw w w w- -S = + á ñ
†
0 0
( ) ( , ') ( ') ( , ') o o o o o oc Go c n n U n nb b
s st t t t d t t ¯ ¯+òò
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
()
1 100 0 0( )[ ] ( ) [ ( ) ( ) ]n n n n Si G D i n i n iw w w w- -P = + á ñ
,ij i j
i j
V n n
( , ')Do t t+
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
C-DMFT
C:DMFT The lattice self energy is inferred from the cluster self energy.
0 0cG G ab¾¾® c
abS ¾¾®Sij ijt tab¾¾®
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
C-DMFT: test in one dimension. (Bolech, Kancharla GK cond-mat 2002)
Gap vs U, Exact solution Lieb and Wu, Ovshinikov
Nc=2 CDMFT
vs Nc=1
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Solving the DMFT equations
G 0 G
I m p u r i t yS o l v e r
S . C .C .
•Wide variety of computational tools (QMC,ED….)Analytical Methods•Extension to ordered states. Review: A. Georges, G. Kotliar, W. Krauth and M. Rozenberg Rev. Mod. Phys. 68,13 (1996)]
G0 G
Im puritySo lver
S .C .C .
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
DMFT: Methods of Solution
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
A (non comprehensive )list of extensions of DMFT Two impurity method. [A. Georges and G. Kotliar,
A. Schiller K Ingersent ] Bethe Peirels [ A. Georges and G. Kotliar] Dynamical Cluster Approximation [M. Jarrell et.
Al. Phys. Rev. B 7475 1998] Periodic cluster [Lichtenstein and Katsnelson]. Cellular Dynamical Mean Field Theory [G. Kotliar
et.al] Extended DMFT [Sachdev and Ye, Parcollet and
Georges, H. Kajueter and G. Kotliar, Q. Si and J L Smith , R . Chitra and G. Kotliar]
Combination with lowest order Perturbation theory for the light orbitals [Savrasov Kotliar, Ping Sun]
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Insights from model DMFT studies Canonical phase diagram at integer occupation. Low temperature Ordered phases . Stability depends on details (chemistry and crystal structure)High temperature behavior around Mott endpoint, more universal regime, captured by simple models treated within DMFT. Role of magnetic frustration.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Schematic DMFT phase diagram Hubbard model (partial frustration)
M. Rozenberg G. Kotliar H. Kajueter G Thomas D. Rapkikne J Honig and P Metcalf Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 105 (1995)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Kuwamoto Honig and AppellPRB (1980)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Mott transition in pyrites: NiSe2-xSx Miyasaka and
Takagi (2000)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Mott transition in layered organic conductors S Lefebvre et al. cond-mat/0004455, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 5420 (2000)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Insights from DMFTThe Mott transition is driven by transfer of spectral weight from low to high energy as we approach the localized phaseControl parameters: doping, temperature,pressure…
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Evolution of the Spectral Function with Temperature
Anomalous transfer of spectral weight connected to the proximity to the Ising Mott endpoint (Kotliar Lange and Rozenberg Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5180 (2000)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Anomalous transfer of optical spectral weight V2O3
:M Rozenberg G. Kotliar and H. Kajuter Phys. Rev. B 54, 8452 (1996).
M. Rozenberg G. Kotliar H. Kajueter G Tahomas D. Rapkikne J Honig and P Metcalf Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 105 (1995)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Anomalous transfer of optical spectral weight, NiSeS. [Miyasaka and Takagi]
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
General Lessons
Coherence –incoherence crossover. Mott transition in one band model. Transfer of spectral weight. Coexistence of atomic like and band like
excitations at finite temperatures. Anomalous transport. Simple laws for transfer of spectral weight
around special points.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Realistic DMFT methods. Spectral functions. Finite temperatue. Excitations. Ground state properties are a byproduct of spectra. Can be computed more reliably being less sensitive
on long distance details. High temperature. NON PERTURBATIVE, using the Weiss field as a
variable one can cross the barrier where skeleton PT theory breaks down.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Combine Dynamical Mean Field Theory with Electronic structure methods. Single site DMFT made correct qualitative
predictions. Make realistic by: Incorporating all the electrons. Add realistic orbital structure. U, J. Add realistic crystal structure. Allow the atoms to move.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Two roads for ab-initio calculation of electronic structure of strongly correlated materials
Correlation Functions Total Energies etc.
Model Hamiltonian
Crystal structure +Atomic positions
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Realistic Calculationsof the Electronic Structure of Correlated materials
Combinining DMFT with state of the art electronic structure methods to construct a first principles framework to describe complex materials.
Anisimov Poteryaev Korotin Anhokin and Kotliar J. Phys. Cond. Mat. 35, 7359 (1997).
Lichtenstein and Katsenelson PRB (1998) Savrasov Kotliar and Abrahams Nature 410, 793
(2001)) Kotliar, Savrasov, in Kotliar, Savrasov, in New Theoretical New Theoretical approaches to strongly correlated systemsapproaches to strongly correlated systems , , Edited by A. Tsvelik, Kluwer Publishers, 2001)Edited by A. Tsvelik, Kluwer Publishers, 2001)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Combining LDA and DMFT
The light, SP (or SPD) electrons are extended, well described by LDA
The heavy, D (or F) electrons are localized,treat by DMFT.
LDA already contains an average interaction of the heavy electrons, subtract this out by shifting the heavy level (double counting term)
The U matrix can be estimated from first principles (Gunnarson Anisimov Hybertsen et.al) or viewed as parameters
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Density functional theory and Dynamical Mean Field Theory DFT: Static mean field, electrons in an
effective potential. Functional of the density.
DMFT: Promote the local (or a few quasilocal Greens functions or observables) to the basic quantities of the theory.
Express the free energy as a functional of those quasilocal quantities.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Spectral Density Functional : effective action construction (Fukuda, Valiev and Fernando , Chitra and Kotliar).
DFT, consider the exact free energy as a functional of an external potential. Express the free energy as a functional of the density by Legendre transformation. DFT(r)]
Introduce local orbitals, R(r-R)orbitals, and local GFG(R,R)(i ) = The exact free energy can be expressed as a functional
of the local Greens function and of the density by introducing (r),G(R,R)(i)]
A useful approximation to the exact functional can be constructed, the DMFT +LDA functional. Savrasov Kotliar and Abrahams Nature 410, 793 (2001))
Full self consistent implementation.
' ( )* ( , ')( ) ( ')R Rdr dr r G r r i r
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
LDA+DMFT-outer loop relax
G0 G
Im puritySo lver
S .C .C .
0( ) ( , , ) i
i
r T G r r i e w
w
r w+
= å
2| ( ) | ( )k xc k LMTOV H ka ac r c- Ñ + =
DMFT
U
Edc
0( , , )HHi
HH
i
n T G r r i e w
w
w+
= å
ff &
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Realistic DMFT loop
( )k LMTOt H k E® -LMTO
LL LH
HL HH
H HH
H H
é ùê ú=ê úë û
ki i Ow w®
10 niG i Ow e- = + - D
0 0
0 HH
é ùê úS =ê úSë û
0 0
0 HH
é ùê úD =ê úDë û
0
1 †0 0 ( )( )[ ] ( ) [ ( ) ( )HH n n n n S Gi G G i c i c ia bw w w w-S = + á ñ
110
1( ) ( )
( ) ( ) HH
LMTO HH
n nn k nk
G i ii O H k E i
w ww w
--é ùê ú= +Sê ú- - - Sê úë ûå
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
LDA+DMFT functional2 *log[ / 2 ( ) ( )]
( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
1 ( ) ( ')( ) ( ) ' [ ]
2 | ' |
[ ]
R R
n
n KS
KS n n
i
LDAext xc
DC
R
Tr i V r r
V r r dr Tr i G i
r rV r r dr drdr E
r r
G
a b ba
w
w c c
r w w
r rr r
- +Ñ - - S -
- S +
+ + +-
F - F
åò
ò òå
Sum of local 2PI graphs with local U matrix and local G
1[ ] ( 1)
2DC G Un nF = - ( )0( ) iab
abi
n T G i ew
w+
= å
KS ab [ ( ) G V ( ) ]LDA DMFT a br r
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Very Partial list of application of realistic DMFT to materials QP bands in ruthenides: A. Liebsch et al (PRL 2000) phase of Pu: S. Savrasov et al (Nature 2001) MIT in V2O3: K. Held et al (PRL 2001) Magnetism of Fe, Ni: A. Lichtenstein et al PRL (2001) transition in Ce: K. Held et al (PRL 2000); M. Zolfl et al
PRL (2000). 3d doped Mott insulator La1-xSrxTiO3 (Anisimov et.al
1997, Nekrasov et.al. 1999, Udovenko et.al 2002) ………………..
Failures of lda Failures of lda
NiO dielectric constant. LSDA:35.7 Exp:5.7
Lattice dynamics cannot be predicted:
• Optical G-phonon in MnO within LSDA: 3.04 THz, Experimentally: 7.86 THz (Massidda, et.al, PRL 1999)
• Bulk modulus for metallic Plutonium is one order of magnitude too large within LDA (214 GPa vs. 30 GPa) Also elastic constants are off.(Bouchet, et.al, J.Phys.C, 2001)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Functional approach allows computation of linear response.(S. Savrasov and GK 2002
Apply to NiO, canonical Mott insulator.
U= J=.9
Simple Impurity solver Hubbard 1.
Results for NiO: PhononsResults for NiO: Phonons
Solid circles – theory, open circles – exp. (Roy et.al, 1976)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
NiO U=8ev, J=1ev, Savrasov and GK (2002)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Case study Fe and Ni
Archetypical itinerant ferromagnets LSDA predicts correct low T moment Band picture holds at low T Curie behavior at high temperatures. Crossover between a real space and a
momentum space prediction.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Iron and Nickel: crossover to a real space picture at high T (Lichtenstein, Katsnelson and Kotliar Phys Rev. Lett 87, 67205 , 2001)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Photoemission Spectra and Spin Autocorrelation: Fe (U=2, J=.9ev,T/Tc=.8) (Lichtenstein, Katsenelson,Kotliar Phys Rev. Lett 87, 67205 , 2001)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Photoemission and T/Tc=.8 Spin Autocorrelation: Ni (U=3, J=.9 ev)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Iron and Nickel:magnetic properties (Lichtenstein, Katsenelson,GK PRL 01)
2
0 3( )eff
q
M
T Tc
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Ni and Fe: theory vs exp / ordered moment
Fe 2.5 ( theory) 2.2(expt) Ni .6 (theory) .6(expt)
eff high T moment
Fe 3.1 (theory) 3.12 (expt) Ni 1.5 (theory) 1.62 (expt)
Curie Temperature Tc
Fe 1900 ( theory) 1043(expt) Ni 700 (theory) 631 (expt)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Role of theory
Orient the thinking about materials. Visualization. Generate
Refine questions, ask about deviation from
DMFT.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Outlook. Many qualitative aspects of the Mott transition in
clusters need to be understood. The notions and the calculations of U’s need to be
refined a revisited. (E-DMFT). Replacing LDA part by simple low order diagrammatic scheme (local GW)
RG techniques and cluster impurity solvers. Small clusters may be needed for accurate
computations of critical temperatures. Role of long wavelength fluctuations?
Many materials to be studied, and insights to be gained.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Acknowledgements: Development of DMFT
Collaborators: V. Anisimov, C. Bolech, G. Biroli, R. Chitra, V. Dobrosavlevic, D. Fisher, A. Georges, H. Kajueter, V. Kancharla, W.Krauth, E. Lange, A. Lichtenstein, G. Moeller, Y. Motome, G. Palsson, O. Parcollet, M. Rozenberg, S. Savrasov, Q. Si, V. Udovenko ,X.Y. Zhang
Support: National Science Foundation.
.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Future Challenges
Develop user friendly interfaces, for first principles calculations of realistic DMFT, for visualization of spectra, resolved in real space, momentum space and orbital space. FAT DMFT. [Done for LDA, S. Savrasov, Material Information and DESIGN Laboratory] and for further code development.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Outlook
The Strong Correlation Problem:How to deal with a multiplicity of competing low temperature phases and infrared trajectories which diverge in the IR
Strategy: advancing our understanding scale by scale
Generalized cluster methods to capture longer range magnetic correlations
New structures in k space. Cellular DMFT
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
. ARPES measurements on NiS2-xSex
Matsuura et. Al Phys. Rev B 58 (1998) 3690. Doniaach and Watanabe Phys. Rev. B 57, 3829 (1998)
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Photoemission V2O3 Held et.al. PRL 2001
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
V2O3 LDA+DMFT Held et.al. PRL 2001
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Outlook
Extensions of DMFT implemented on model systems, carry over to more realistic framework. Better determination of Tcs…………
First principles approach: determination of the Hubbard parameters, and the double counting corrections long range coulomb interactions E-DMFT
Improvement in the treatement of multiplet effects in the impurity solvers, phonon entropies, ………
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Hubbard model
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
U/t
Doping or chemical potential
Frustration (t’/t)
T temperatureMott transition as a function of doping, pressure temperature etc.
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Limit of large lattice coordination
1~ d ij nearest neighborsijt
d
† 1~i jc c
d
†
,
1 1~ ~ (1)ij i j
j
t c c d Od d
~O(1)i i
Un n
Metzner Vollhardt, 89
1( , )
( )k
G k ii i
Muller-Hartmann 89
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Dynamical Mean Field Theory, cavity constructionA. Georges G. Kotliar 92
†
0 0 0
( )[ ( ')] ( ')eff o o o oc c U n nSb b b
s st m t t tt ¯
¶= + - D - +
¶òò ò ( )wD
†( )( ) ( )
MFo n o n SG c i c iw w D=- á ñ 1( )
1( )
( )[ ][ ]
nk
n kn
G ii
G i
ww e
w
=D - -
D
å
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Extended DMFT electron phonon
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Extended DMFT e.ph. Problem
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Mean-Field : Classical vs Quantum
Classical case Quantum case
Phys. Rev. B 45, 6497 A. Georges, G. Kotliar (1992)
†
0 0 0
( )[ ( ')] ( ')o o o oc c U n nb b b
s st m t t tt ¯
¶+ - D - +
¶òò ò
( )wD
†( )( ) ( )
MFL o n o n HG c i c iw w D=- á ñ
1( )
1( )
( )[ ][ ]
nk
n kn
G ii
G i
ww e
w
=D - -
D
å
,ij i j i
i j i
J S S h S- -å å
MF eff oH h S=-
effh
0 0 ( )MF effH hm S=á ñ
eff ij jj
h J m h= +å
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
1
10
1( ) ( )
( )n nn k nk
G i ii t i
w ww m w
-
-é ùê ú= +Sê ú- + - Sê úë ûå
DMFT Review: A. Georges, G. Kotliar, W. Krauth and M. Rozenberg Rev. Mod. Phys. 68,13 (1996)]
†
0 0 0
[ ] ( )[ ( , ')] ( ')o o o oS Go c Go c U n nb b b
s st t t t ¯= +òò ò
† †
, ,
( )( )ij ij i j j i i ii j i
t c c c c U n n
0
†( )( ) ( ) ( )L n o n o n S GG i c i c iw w w=- á ñ
10 ( ) ( )n n nG i i iw w m w- = + - D
0
1 † 10 0 ( )( )[ ] ( ) [ ( ) ( ) ]n n n n S Gi G G i c i c ia bw w w w- -S = + á ñ
Weiss field
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
X.Zhang M. Rozenberg G. Kotliar (PRL 1993)
Spectral Evolution at T=0 half filling full frustration
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Anomalous Spectral Weight Transfer: Optics
0( ) ,eff effd P J
iV
Schlesinger et.al (FeSi) PRL 71 ,1748 , (1993) B Bucher et.al. Ce2Bi4Pt3PRL 72, 522 (1994), Rozenberg et.al. PRB 54, 8452, (1996).
2
0( ) ,
ned P J
iV m
ApreciableT dependence found.
, ,H hamiltonian J electric current P polarization
, ,eff eff effH J PBelow energy
THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW JERSEY
RUTGERS
Comments on LDA+DMFT• Static limit of the LDA+DMFT functional , with = HF
reduces to LDA+U• DMFT retain correlations effects in the
absence of orbital ordering. • (for example treating the impurity model in the
Hubbard 1 approximation).• Functional formulation allows calculation of total
energies and linear response.• Gives the local spectra and the total energy
simultaneously, treating QP and H bands on the same footing.