ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe...

8
International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014 2135 ISSN: 2278 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR THIN FILMS G. Sudhakar 1 ,S. Lakshmi Rangaiah 2 , N. Lalitha Kumari 3 1. Lecturer, Department of Physics, Govt. Degree College for men, Kurnool. 2,3. Lecturer, Department of Physics, Silver jubilee Govt. College (A), Kurnool Abstract: ZnTe is an II-VI compound semiconductor with a direct band gap of 2.26 eV at room temperature. It exhibits low electron affinity (3.53 eV). It crystallizes in Zinc blends structure with lattice constant of 6.1037 A 0 and melting point of 1295 0 C. Thin films of ZnTe were prepared by thermal evaporation technique. XRD studies are used to characterize the structure of semi conductor thin films and to confirm the compound formation and unit cell parameters, crystallite site etc. SEM photos reveal the microstructure of the thin films, and are widely used for the estimation of grain size, gain boundaries, stress, strain, dislocation density etc. The effect of substrate on the structure of these films is clearly seen from the XRD data. The Optical absorption measurements yielded a band gap of 2.21 eV for undoped ZnTe. Bandgap shrinkage was also observed for the Cd-doped films. The dark resistivity of the as-deposited ZnTe decreased by more than three orders of magnitude as the Cd concentration was increased from 4 to 8 at.% and decreased to less than 1 ohm-cm after annealing at 260°C. For films doped with 6-7 at.% Cd, an increase of resistivity was also observed during annealing at 150-200°C. The hole mobility was of the order of 0.1 to 1.0 cm 2 /V.s in pure and annealed ZnTe thin films. ZnTe is potentially low cost, environmentally stable, low resistance and easily manufacturability back contact semiconducting material. It has very potential applications in solid state devices such as solar cell, Photo- detectors, light emitting diodes, Photo- electrochemical solar cells, optoelectronic devices, high efficiency multi-junction solar cells, terahertz (THz) devices and switching devices. The detailed information is presented in the paper. Key words: Stiochiometric, substrate, Vacuum coating, binary and ternary compounds, Pyrex glass, semiconductor, thermal evaporation etc., Introduction: Several have been reported in literature. Among all methods of preparation of ZnTe material, the most convenient method is fusion of appropriate amount of constituent elements. This is well known and common technique to produce highly pure binary and ternary compound semiconductors 1 . Preparation of Material: The stiochiometric ZnTe material is prepared with High purity 5 N grade elemental Zinc and Tellurium powders. 3.4gm of Zinc and 6.681 gm of Tellurium are weighed with electronic balance of Afcoset EK model 120-G, the weighed elements are transferred to the agate mortar. Mixed thoroughly till uniform powder is obtained. This powder is used for preparing thin films. Preparation of Thin Films: a) Preparation of films: The Zinc Telluride films have been prepared by the method of Thermal evaporation under high vacuum conditions. The conductivity of the films is obtained by depositing at different

Transcript of ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe...

Page 1: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2135 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd

SEMICONDUCTOR THIN FILMS

G. Sudhakar1,S. Lakshmi Rangaiah2, N. Lalitha Kumari3

1. Lecturer, Department of Physics, Govt. Degree College for men, Kurnool.

2,3. Lecturer, Department of Physics, Silver jubilee Govt. College (A), Kurnool

Abstract:

ZnTe is an II-VI compound semiconductor with a direct band gap of 2.26 eV at room temperature. It exhibits low electron affinity (3.53 eV). It crystallizes in Zinc blends structure with lattice constant of 6.1037 A0 and melting point of 12950C. Thin films of ZnTe were prepared by thermal evaporation technique. XRD studies are used to characterize the structure of semi conductor thin films and to confirm the compound formation and unit cell parameters, crystallite site etc. SEM photos reveal the microstructure of the thin films, and are widely used for the estimation of grain size, gain boundaries, stress, strain, dislocation density etc. The effect of substrate on the structure of these films is clearly seen from the XRD data. The Optical absorption measurements yielded a band gap of 2.21 eV for undoped ZnTe. Bandgap shrinkage was also observed for the Cd-doped films. The dark resistivity of the as-deposited ZnTe decreased by more than three orders of magnitude as the Cd concentration was increased from 4 to 8 at.% and decreased to less than 1 ohm-cm after annealing at 260°C. For films doped with 6-7 at.% Cd, an increase of resistivity was also observed during annealing at 150-200°C. The hole mobility was of the order of 0.1 to 1.0 cm2/V.s in pure and annealed ZnTe thin films. ZnTe is potentially low cost, environmentally stable, low resistance and easily manufacturability back contact semiconducting material. It has very potential applications in solid state devices such as solar cell, Photo-detectors, light emitting diodes, Photo- electrochemical solar cells, optoelectronic devices, high efficiency multi-junction solar cells, terahertz (THz) devices and switching

devices. The detailed information is presented in the paper. Key words: Stiochiometric, substrate, Vacuum coating, binary and ternary compounds, Pyrex glass, semiconductor, thermal evaporation etc.,

Introduction:

Several have been reported in literature. Among all methods of preparation of ZnTe material, the most convenient method is fusion of appropriate amount of constituent elements. This is well known and common technique to produce highly pure binary and ternary compound semiconductors1.

Preparation of Material:

The stiochiometric ZnTe material is prepared with High purity 5 N grade elemental Zinc and Tellurium powders. 3.4gm of Zinc and 6.681 gm of Tellurium are weighed with electronic balance of Afcoset EK model 120-G, the weighed elements are transferred to the agate mortar. Mixed thoroughly till uniform powder is obtained. This powder is used for preparing thin films.

Preparation of Thin Films:

a) Preparation of films:

The Zinc Telluride films have been prepared by the method of Thermal evaporation under high vacuum conditions. The conductivity of the films is obtained by depositing at different

Page 2: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2136 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

substrate temperatures and on various types of substrates. b) Vacuum Coating :

The evaporation of Zinc Telluride was carried out in a Vacuum coating unit model 12A4 DM (Hind Hivac Company, Bangalore, India). The unit essentially consists of a cylindrical Pyrex glass or metallic bell jar mounted on a base plate. The sample is evacuated by an oil diffusion(500 Lit/Sec) pump backed by a two stage rotary pump (200 Lit/Sec). The unit was also filled with thermal evaporation unit. Pressure in the chamber is measured by Pirani and Penning gauges maintained approximately at 1x10–5 m bar, before the commencement of evaporation. c) Substrate Cleaning:

The qualities of the films such as adherence to the substrate, uniformity of deposit depend on the cleanliness of the support surface2,3. The Pyrex glass slides were selected and are cleaned as follows : 1. The slides were kept in liquid soap water for few hours to remove all greasy materials. 2. The slides were kept in hot chromic acid for about 30 minutes to ensure the surface free from any foreign material. 3. The slides were washed with distilled water. 4. The slides were then cleaned ultrasonically in a detergent solution. 5. These slides were again washed with distilled water and finally kept in pure solvent like trichloroethylene. 6. The slides were dried under an IR lamp or hot air blower before mounting them in the vacuum chamber of the coating unit. Freshly cleaned mica can also be used as a substrate material. d) Substrate Heating:

The substrates were placed on a metallic substrate holder having holes of required dimensions and were closed by circular box type heater made of nichrome wire. The substrates as well as the holder were heated by radiation of heat. The substrate temperature is measured with a copper constantan thermocouple fixed on the substrate holder near the substrate, thus giving the temperature

of the deposition side of the substrate. The substrate temperature was controlled by variacs and the variation was ± 1K indicated in temperature indicator (DTC 1142). e) Estimation of film thickness:

The thickness of the films was estimated using digital thickness monitor (DTM) model DTM – 101 supplied by Hind Hivac Company, Bangalore. The monitor display consists of a 4-digit thickness display, a 3- digit rate display. The thickness set point establishes the film thickness at which the shutter closes. Depressing the START button zeros the thickness display and opens the shutter. The shutter is then automatically closed when the thickness set point. The shutter can also be closed manually by depressing the STOP button. In this way complete manual control of the shutter, as may be required for servicing the source, is available through use of the START & STOP button. This eliminates the possibility of leaving such a switch in the open or close position when it should be in the auto position4. f) Electrical contacts:

Suitable contacts to the specimen are the basic requirements for carrying out the physical property measurements of these films5,6. In the present investigation silver paint (air– drying) has been used. This type of contact is widely used in thin films work where high resistances are involved because of its strength and stability and it needs no baking7,8,16. g) Deposition of ZnTe films:

The evaporation sources were a trough type tantalum boat provided with suitable electrical contacts in the evaporation chamber through which the current could be varied. The source material ZnTe fine powder was kept in the sample chamber thermal evaporation arrangement. Some trial depositions were carried out to attain the desired rate of evaporation which could be obtained by the ratio of the film thickness to evaporation time and is kept constant as far as possible. The clean substrates of proper sizes were suitably mounted inside the vacuum chamber or metallic substrate holder, at a distance of 16 cm

Page 3: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2137 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

from the vapor source for getting uniform films. Current is passed through tantalum boat till it becomes red hot, after attaining a constant vacuum of the order of 1 x 10–5 mbar. The ZnTe powder kept in the thermal evaporated arrangement made to red hot boat so that it got evaporated all of a sudden and got evaporated on the substrates. The rate of evaporation, substrate temperature, order of vacuum, distance between the substrate and the source9, obliquity (i.e., the angle of incidence of the vapor stream with the substrate surface) etc., are the controlling parameters of the film properties. They were kept constant in all cases. To eliminate the effect of random factors, a series of samples were prepared under identical conditions. By putting suitable marks below the substrate during deposition, films of desired pattern or shape were obtained.

STRUCTURAL CHARACTERIZATION:

Several methods are available to characterize the structure of semi conductor thin films. XRD, SEM, TEM, STM etc., are some of the widely used methods for structural characterization3,10,13. XRD studies confirm the compound formation and unit cell parameters, crystallite site11,15 etc.,. SEM photos reveal the microstructure of the thin films, and are widely used for the estimation of grain size, gain boundaries, stress, strain, dislocation density12 etc. In the present study, XRD studies were carried for the determination of the structure of Zinc Telluride thin films. The effect of substrate on the structure of these films is clearly seen from the XRD data.

In the present investigation Philips Analytical X-ray diffractometer model PW 3710 unit filled with a wide range goniometer and a Geiger-Muller Counter is used. The O/P of the GM counter is interfered with a PC and PC-APD diffraction software is used to record the intensity and to calculate the d-parameter for Bragg reflections. The source of the X-ray radiations is a X-ray tube having copper target with balanced nickel filter. The tube is operated at 40KV and the tube current was maintained at 25 mA. Both the voltage and current were

stabilized (1). The divergence of the X-ray beam was limited to 20 – 30 in vertical direction and 10 in the horizontal direction. The substrates coated with the films were placed in position and the diffraction profiles were recorded at scanning speeds of 20 per minute. X-ray line Broadening measurement of Crystallite size: Several factors contributing to the broadening of the line are :

a. Inhomogeneous strain b. Mean dimension of the diffraction

crystallites in a direction normal to the reflecting planes.

c. Faulting in the stacking of the layers d. Spectral broadening and instrumental

factors. Considering that the broadening of the X-ray line is due to crystallites only and all other causes of broadening are negligible, the crystallite dimension is by the Scherrer’s formula

D(h,k,l) = k/Cos Where D(h,k,l) is the average crystallite dimension perpendicular to the reflecting

planes, the wavelength of the incident radiation, k is a constant depending on the shape of particles whose value is of the order of unity, β is the integral breadth of the reflections corrected for instrumental broadening and θ is the Bragg angle14. Apart from the crystalline size, the imperfection of the crystallites such as Lattice strain, dislocations and stacking faults are also known to contribute to the broadening of the X-ray line2,15. But in the present study only crystallite size and lattice parameter were estimated from XRD data. Structure determination by X-ray diffraction:

The prepared material was analyzed by X-ray diffraction and was found to have zinc Blend structure with lattice constant a= 6.071A0. The present value of a is compatible with the published data (1). Figure 1 depicts the

X-ray diffraction pattern of vacuum deposited ZnTe thin films at substrate temperature 90

oC.

Figure 2(a,b,c) gives the XRD spectra of typical

Page 4: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2138 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

ZnTe layers deposited on glass of different

thickness.

Figure 3( d1,d2,d3,d4,d5 and d6) give the X-ray diffract grams for ZnTe films deposited on glass and mica at substrate temperature of 300K, 363K, and 453K and cadium doped films. The higher the substrate temperature, the peak intensity increases and number of peaks also get enhanced. It indicates that grain size increases with substrate temperature and forming single phase ZnTe compound thin films. Cd doped ZnTe have sharp peaks and intensity increases indicating that Cd has inter-diffused with in ZnTe thin films. The X-ray reflections, d values, Intensity of ZnTe films deposited on glass and mica substrates are also studied. It is observed that the films are amorphous and polycrystalline deposited on glass and mica substrates respectively. Figure 4 gives the variation of particle size and (111) oriented films at different substrate temperatures (OC) of zinc telluride thin films. The vertical line

indicates the position of the annealed bulk

sample. Particle size is estimated from diffraction data of ZnTe for glass and mica at 200 and 450 A0 respectively. It is observed that the particle size increases with increase in thickness of ZnTe films. It is found that films deposited on mica show higher particle size compared to films on glass substrates. It is found that the particle size increase up to 398K. Films deposited at 453 K on glass shows the polycrystalline nature. It is concluded that above 453 K, films deposited on glass substrate are found to be polycrystalline, where as similar effect is not observed in case of mica substrate deposited films. The Diffraction pattern is more sharp and found to be epitaxy nature and have highest particle size of 250 nm. Films of ZnTe deposited at 453K on glass substrate are found to be polycrystalline. At this temperature re-evaporation phenomenon will take place in case of glass substrate deposited films.

Figure 1: X-ray diffraction pattern of ZnTe thin films at substrate temperature 90oC.

Figure 2(a,b,c): XRD spectra of typical ZnTe layers deposited on glass of different thickness.

Page 5: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2139 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

Figure 3(d1,d2, d3 ,d4,d5,d6): XRD of ZnTe doped

with Cd of different concentration. .

Figure 3(d1,d2, d3 ,d4,d5,d6): XRD of ZnTe doped with Cd of different concentration.

Figure. 4: X-ray diffraction profile showing the

peak shift and line broadening a) 30oC, b) 50

oC,

c) 70oC, d) 90

oC.

Figure 5: SEM of typical ZnTe samples

deposited on glass.

Figure 5 depicts the SEM of typical ZnTe

samples deposited on glass. Figure 6 shows the

SEM of ZnTe thin films deposited on the

substrate with different Cd dopants. They reveal

the microstructure of the thin films, and are

widely used for the estimation of grain size, gain

boundaries.

Electrical Conductivity: Figure-7 plots between logarithm of

conductivity and inverse of temperature for the

films presents the experimental observation of

conductivity variation with temperature for

some of the typical ZnTe films deposited on

Page 6: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2140 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

glass substrates of 2000 A0 thickness at room

temperature.

Figure 6: SEM of ZnTe thin films deposited on

the substrate with different Cd dopants.

Figures-7 depict the experimental observation of conductivity variation with temperature for these films of 2000 A0 at 373 K substrate temperatures. It is found that the activation decreases with increasing thickness, while the conductivity decreases with increase in substrate temperature. The activation energy decreases with increase in substrate temperature and the conductivity increases with thickness and substrate temperature, it is due increase in grain size in the films and reduce its defect density in the films.. It is observed that there is a phase transition from cubic to new phase at around 413K. We conclude that the electric conductivity dependent on particle size, number of carriers present and its mobility of carriers.

Optical Properties:

The Optical absorption with photon

energy was plotted in figure 8a and 8b for two

different wavelengths at 1064nm and 532 nm

Substrate absorption is corrected by introducing

an uncoated SnO2 glass substrate in the reference

beam. The transmittance (T), is converted into

optical density (OD) according to the relation

optical density (OD) = log10 (1/T). It is here

observed that the absorption coefficient (α) rises

sharply owing to the band-to-band transitions

and levels off later. An analysis of the absorption

spectrum in the region 1.5 eV < hν < 3.5 eV

indicate that α follows the relation absorption

coefficient (α) = A/hν (hν − Eg) −1/2 where A is a

constant (slope) and Eg is the energy gap. The

Optical absorption measurements yielded a

band gap of 2.21 eV for undoped ZnTe. Band

gap shrinkage is also observed for the Cd-doped

films. The dark resistivity of the as-deposited

ZnTe decreased by more than three orders of

magnitude as the Cd concentration increases

from 4 to 8 at.% and decreased to less than 1

ohm-cm after annealing at 260°C. For films

doped with 6-7 at.% Cd, an increase of

resistivity is also observed during annealing at

150-200°C. The hole mobility is of the order of

0.1 to 1.0 cm2/V.s in pure and annealed ZnTe

thin films. From the calculated values of the

absorption coefficients a plot of (αhν2) against hν

is drawn for various temperatures as shown in

figure-9 and the linear portion of the graph is

extrapolated to the energy axis shown in figure-

8. The intersection point gives the direct band

gap of the material and is found to be 2.26 eV. It

is found that the band gap value of the samples is

in good agreement with the reported value for

the electrodeposited ZnTe thin films. Figure-10

shows the variation of refractive index ‘n’ and

extinction constant ‘K’ as a function of the

wavelength in the range 400–1200 nm. It can be

Page 7: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2141 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

seen from the plot that ZnTe films show good

absorption in the visible region. The optical

constants (n and k) at wavelength 600 nm are

estimated to be 3.25 and 0.2 respectively.

Conclusions : Films of ZnTe deposited by vacuum evaporation of stoichiometric compound on glass and mica substrate with different thickness and substrate temperatures. The different substrate temperature deposited ZnTe thin films of XRD of (111) oriented peaks were

Figure-8a and 8b: Optical absorption coefficient Vs Photon energy of ZnTe two different laser irradiated thin films.

Figure-9: (αhν)2 versus hν plot for ZnTe thin films deposited at (a)300C, (b)500C, (c)700C and(d) 90 ◦ C of various substrate temperatures.

Figure-10: Variation of n and k with wavelength

for a typical ZnTe film deposited at 900C.

compared and more crystalline nature is observed for 900 C films. This gives higher particle size and low defect density in such films. XRD studies Cd doped films revealed the change of peak intensity and position. It concluded that Cd have substutional positions in ZnTe lattices. Effect of thickness and substrate temperature studies revealed that conductivity is increasing with thickness and substrate temperature. The activation energy is decreasing with increase of substrate temperature. The optical absorption coefficient, refractive index, extinction coefficient and forbidden band gap of ZnTe film were studied, where the refractive index, extinction coefficients increases with wavelength. It is observed to have a sharp direct band gap of 2.42 eV. The absorption coefficient is found to be 10 5 Cm -1 for 532 nm laser irradiated thin films. ZnTe films show good absorption in the

visible region. These films have very wide

potential applications in optoelectronics and solar cells. The Nano structured ZnTe with dopent may have still wider industrial, scientific and technological applications.

References: 1. K.N. Sharma and K.Barua, Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 12 (1979) 17-29.

2. V.Damodardas and D.Karunakaran, Journal of Physics and Chemistry Solids 46 (1985) 551-558.

Page 8: ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe …ijsetr.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/IJSETR-VOL-3-ISSUE-8-2135... · ELECTRICAL AND OPTICAL PROPERTIES OF ZnTe DOPED WITH Cd SEMICONDUCTOR

International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology Research (IJSETR), Volume 3, Issue 8, August 2014

2142 ISSN: 2278 – 7798 All Rights Reserved © 2014 IJSETR

3. L.L. Kazmerski, M.S. Ayyagani, F.F. White and G.A. Sanborn., Journal of vaccum science technology 13 139 (1976). 4. T.Ohtani, Y. Tachibana, J.Ogura,T.Miyake, Y.Okade, Y.Yokata.Journal of Alloys and Compounds 279 (1998) 136-141 5. K.C. Sharma, R.P. Sharma and J.C. Garg Indian Journal of pure and applied physics 28 (1990) 590-595 6.A.Pistone, A.S.Arico, P.L.Antonucci, D.Silvestro, V.Antonucci, Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 53 (1998) 255 -267 7. V.S.John , T.Mahalingam, Jinn P.Chu, Solid-State Electronics 49 (2005) 3-7 8.Akram K.S.Aqili, sghari Maqsood, Zulfiqar Ali Applied Surface Science 191 (2002) 280-285 9. P.Petkov, T.Petkova, V.Vassilev, V.Vachkov Materials Letters 56 (2002) 9-13

10. T.R.Yang, C.C.Lu,Physics B 284 – 288 (2000) 1187-1188 12.S.I.Radaustan, O.V.Kulikova and O.G.Maksimova, Solar Energy Materials 20 (1990) 37-41 13. Daniel Franta, Ivan Ohlida, Petr Klapetek, Alberto Montaigne-Ramil, Alberta Bonanni, David Stifter, Helmut Sitter,thin Solid Films 468 (2004) 193-202 14. B.Spath, J.Fritsche, F.Sauberlich, A.Klein, W.Jaegermann,Thin Solid Films 480-481(2005) 204-207 15.A.Erlacher, M.Ambrico, G.Perna, L.Schiavulli, T.Ligonzo, H.Jaeger, B.Ullrich,Applied Surface Science 248 (2005) 402-405 16.R.Sarma, N.Mazumdar and H.L.Das,Bulletin of Material Science 29 (2006) 15-16 17.R.Amutha, A.Subbarayan, and R.Sathyamoorthy,Crystal Reseach Technology 41 (2006) 1174-1179 18.Artur Erlacher, Alejandra R. Lukaszew, Herbert Jaeger, Bruno Ullrich,Surface Science 600 (2006) 3762-3765