Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil...

18
Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma 1 , Cris Koutsougeras 2 , Hao Luo 2 October 6, 2016 1 Sam Houston State University 2 Southeastern Louisiana University

Transcript of Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil...

Page 1: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Efficiency of a VAWT with

Airfoil Pitch Control

Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras2, Hao Luo2

October 6, 2016

1Sam Houston State University

2Southeastern Louisiana University

Page 2: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

VAWT and HAWT

VAWT: Vertical Axis Wind Turbine

HAWT: Horizontal Axis Wind Turbine

Page 3: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages:

• Easier to install and maintain

• No need to point into the wind

• Low risk for human or birds

• Can be installed in urban area

Disadvantages:

• Stall start

• Low efficiency

• Dynamic stability: vibration and noise

• Pulsatory torque

Page 4: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

VAWT with Pitch and Camber

Controls

Page 5: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Governing Equations

Low speed laminar flow: Navier – Stokes equations

High speed turbulent flow: k - e turbulent flow model

Page 6: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Force and Torque

Force:

Torque:

Page 7: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

NACA 0012 Airfoil

Page 8: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

COMSOL CFD Model

Page 9: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Velocity Field

Page 10: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Pressure Field

Page 11: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Torque at 300 Support Arm Angle

35000

37000

39000

41000

43000

45000

47000

49000

51000

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

To

rqu

e (

N)

Attack Angle (0)

Page 12: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Effects of Wind Speed

72000

74000

76000

78000

80000

82000

84000

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

To

rqu

e (

N)

Attack Angle (0)

5m/s

10m/s

15m/s

20m/s

Page 13: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Effects of Support Arm Angle

0.0

10000.0

20000.0

30000.0

40000.0

50000.0

60000.0

70000.0

80000.0

90000.0

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

Page 14: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Effects of Support Arm Angle

0.0

10000.0

20000.0

30000.0

40000.0

50000.0

60000.0

70000.0

80000.0

90000.0

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

Page 15: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Effects of Support Arm Angle

0.0

10000.0

20000.0

30000.0

40000.0

50000.0

60000.0

70000.0

80000.0

90000.0

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

Page 16: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Conclusions

• Torque with respect to the VAWT main rotor

shaft depends on wind angle of attack and

support arm angle

• Wind speed does affect the peak torque. But the

torque increase due to higher wind speed is

insignificant

• For the NACA 0012 airfoil, the torque always

peaks out at 90 degree angle of attack at any

given support arm angle

Page 17: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Future Work

• 2D multi-blades model

• 3D model to explore airfoil edge effect

• 3D multi-blades model

• Non-symmetric airfoil other than NACA 0012

Page 18: Efficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control - comsol.de fileEfficiency of a VAWT with Airfoil Pitch Control Junkun Ma1, Cris Koutsougeras 2, Hao Luo October 6, 2016 1Sam Houston

Questions?