Effects of Crop Diversity Farm Income -...

1
© V. Floris, May 2013, Syan, BF REFERENCES © CIRAD, October 2015, Global Food Security, Ithaca (New York) 1 J. E. Arsenault, L. Nikiema, P. Allemand, K. A. Ayassou, H. Lanou, M. Moursi, F. De Moura and Y. Martin-Prevel (2014). Seasonal differences in food and nutrient intakes among young children and their mothers in rural Burkina Faso. Journal of Nutritional Science, 3, e55 2 E. Masset, L. Haddad, A. Cornelius, J. Isaza-Castro (2012). Effectiveness of agricultural interventions that aim to improve nutritional status of children: systematic review. British Medical Journal, 337 (7676) pp. 979-983 3 Berti P. R., Krasevec J., FitzGerald S., 2004. A review of the effectiveness of agriculture interventions in improving nutrition outcomes. Public Health Nutrition, 7 (5) pp. 599-609. 4 Introducing the Minimum Dietary Diversity – Women (MDD-W) Global Dietary Diversity Indicator for Women. FANTA, Washington, DC, July 2014. http://www.fantaproject.org/monitoring-and-evaluation/minimum-dietary-diversity-women-indicator-mddw. > CONCLUSION CONCLUSION www.cirad.fr LOURME RUIZ Alissia 1 DURY Sandrine 1 MARTIN-PRÉVEL Yves 2 1 Cirad, UMR Moisa, 2 IRD, UMR Nutripass Monptellier Let’s watch the trailer of the documentary film below We surveyed 580 farm households representative of the region, 3 times (2013/14) Within the same family farms in the Hauts-Bassins region (Western Burkina Faso), we collected data on food consumption, farm characteristics, and production outcomes (harvested quantities and sales amount, designed here as “ farm income”). We computed Simpson’s Index, as marker of both richness and evenness of crop diversity. From a qualitative 24-h recall, we computed the Minimum Dietary Diversity index for Women (MDD-W) which comprises 10 food groups; the threshold of 5 food groups consumed identifies women who are more likely to cover their micronutrient needs 4 . On this MDD-W , we regressed crop diversity, farm income, demographic and socio-cultural variables. Relatively high agricultural production AND low dietary diversity were observed in Western Burkina Faso 1 . While food security policies mainly recommended boosting agricultural production, recent literature reviews showed ambiguous effects of higher production on overall diet of members in farm households 2, 3 . In order to clarify these confusing results, we investigated more accurately which farms characteristics improve the dietary diversity of women (as indicator of nutritional quality of food), with a focus on crop diversity and socio-economic characteristics of women in family farms. The mean number of food groups consumed by women was low: 3.43 (SD: 1.35) and 80% of women didn’t reach the threshold of 5 food groups consumed out of 10. Unexpectedly, the dietary diversity remains stable across seasons (see Graph1). According to seasons, women consumed more vitamin A-rich fruits during the mango period (dry season) and more vegetables when it’s raining during lean and post-harvest seasons (see Graph 2). Women who had a higher dietary diversity score more often ate eggs, nuts or flesh foods. Crop diversity and farm income had very slight effects on dietary diversity During the dry season, women’s dietary diversity was strongly and positively associated with farm income per capita, but not with the Simpson’s Index. During the lean season, women’s dietary diversity was not associated with any of the variables related to farm characteristics or agricultural production. Moreover, variables concerning women’s wealth and empowerment were significantly associated with women’s dietary diversity across seasons, while characteristics of the farm head were not. On-farm crop diversity is not related to dietary diversity of women. Farm Income has a seasonal effect. Women’s dietary diversity depends primarily on their own social and economic status. © V. Floris, May 2013, Syan, BF Women are in charge of food purchasing, meal preparation, and feeding practices. Most them (95%) ate (staple dish made from cereal) with a sauce, that gives the diversity of the meal - or not. Effects of Crop Diversity and Farm Income on Dietary Diversity of Women in Family Farms Here, the documentary film is available on Cirad Vimeo Graph1: Dietary Diversity of Women across seasons 0 2 4 6 8 Dry season Lean season Post-harvest The man, family and farm head, manages farm activities and outcomes. He decides the allocation of outputs and incomes. Despite their involvement in farm labor, women have less power in farm and budget decisions. Across seasons women’s dietary diversity didn’t vary, but food groups consumed did Graph2: Share of food groups in the MDD-W across season 0 20 40 60 80 100 dry season lean season post-harvest Starchy staple foods Beans & peas Nuts & seeds Dairy Flesh foods Eggs Vit. A-rich leafy veg. Vit. A-rich veg. & fruits Vegetables Fruits

Transcript of Effects of Crop Diversity Farm Income -...

Page 1: Effects of Crop Diversity Farm Income - Ciradagents.cirad.fr/pjjimg/sandrine.dury@cirad.fr/2015... · Graph1: Dietary Diversity of Women across seasons 0 2 4 6 8 Dry season Lean season

© V

. Flo

ris,

May

20

13

, Sya

n, B

F

REFERENCES

© C

IRA

D,

Octo

ber

20

15,

Glo

bal F

ood S

ecurity

, It

haca (

New

York

)

1 J. E. Arsenault, L. Nikiema, P. Allemand, K. A. Ayassou, H. Lanou, M. Moursi, F. De Moura and Y. Martin-Prevel (2014). Seasonal differences in food and nutrient intakes among young children and their mothers in rural Burkina Faso. Journal of Nutritional Science, 3, e55 2 E. Masset, L. Haddad, A. Cornelius, J. Isaza-Castro (2012). Effectiveness of agricultural interventions that aim to improve nutritional status of children: systematic review. British Medical Journal, 337 (7676) pp. 979-983 3 Berti P. R., Krasevec J., FitzGerald S., 2004. A review of the effectiveness of agriculture interventions in improving nutrition outcomes. Public Health Nutrition, 7 (5) pp. 599-609. 4 Introducing the Minimum Dietary Diversity – Women (MDD-W) Global Dietary Diversity Indicator for Women. FANTA, Washington, DC, July 2014. http://www.fantaproject.org/monitoring-and-evaluation/minimum-dietary-diversity-women-indicator-mddw.

> CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

www.cirad.fr

LOURME RUIZ Alissia1

DURY Sandrine1

MARTIN-PRÉVEL Yves2

1 Cirad, UMR Moisa, 2 IRD, UMR Nutripass

Monptellier

Let’s watch the trailer of the documentary film below

We surveyed 580 farm households representative of the region, 3 times (2013/14)

Within the same family farms in the Hauts-Bassins region (Western Burkina Faso), we collected data on food consumption, farm characteristics, and production outcomes (harvested quantities and sales amount, designed here as “ farm income”). We computed Simpson’s Index, as marker of both richness and evenness of crop diversity. From a qualitative 24-h recall, we computed the Minimum Dietary Diversity index for Women (MDD-W) which comprises 10 food groups; the threshold of 5 food groups consumed identifies women who are more likely to cover their micronutrient needs 4. On this MDD-W, we regressed crop diversity, farm income, demographic and socio-cultural variables.

Relatively high agricultural production AND low dietary diversity

were observed in Western Burkina Faso1. While food security policies mainly recommended boosting agricultural production, recent literature reviews showed ambiguous effects of higher production on overall diet of members in farm households 2, 3.

In order to clarify these confusing results, we investigated more accurately which farms characteristics improve the dietary diversity of women (as indicator of nutritional quality of food), with a focus on crop diversity and socio-economic characteristics of women in family farms.

The mean number of food groups consumed by women was low: 3.43 (SD: 1.35) and 80% of women didn’t reach the threshold of 5 food groups consumed out of 10. Unexpectedly, the dietary diversity remains stable across seasons (see Graph1). According to seasons, women consumed more vitamin A-rich fruits during the mango period (dry season) and more vegetables when it’s raining during lean and post-harvest seasons (see Graph 2). Women who had a higher dietary diversity score more often ate eggs, nuts or flesh foods.

Crop diversity and farm income had very slight effects on dietary diversity

During the dry season, women’s dietary diversity was strongly and positively associated with farm income per capita, but not with the Simpson’s Index. During the lean season, women’s dietary diversity was not associated with any of the variables related to farm characteristics or agricultural production. Moreover, variables concerning women’s wealth and empowerment were significantly associated with women’s dietary diversity across seasons, while characteristics of the farm head were not.

On-farm crop diversity is not related to dietary diversity of women.

Farm Income has a seasonal effect.

Women’s dietary diversity depends primarily on their own social and economic status.

© V

. Flo

ris,

May

20

13

, Sya

n, B

F

Women are in charge of food purchasing, meal preparation, and feeding practices. Most them (95%) ate tô (staple dish made from cereal) with a sauce, that gives the diversity of the meal - or not.

Effects of Crop Diversity and Farm Income on Dietary Diversity of Women in Family Farms

Here, the documentary film is available on Cirad Vimeo

Graph1: Dietary Diversity of Women across seasons

02

46

8

Dry season Lean season Post-harvest

The man, family and farm head, manages farm activities and outcomes. He decides the allocation of outputs and incomes. Despite their involvement in farm labor, women have less power in farm and budget decisions.

Across seasons women’s dietary diversity didn’t vary, but food groups consumed did

Graph2: Share of food groups in the MDD-W across season

02

04

06

08

01

00

Su

m o

f fo

od

gro

ups e

ate

n (

24

h-r

ecall)

dry season lean season post-harvest

Starchy staple foods Beans & peas

Nuts & seeds Dairy

Flesh foods Eggs

Vit. A-rich leafy veg. Vit. A-rich veg. & fruits

Vegetables Fruits