Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea...

10
Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers H olothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands KELSHAW BONHAM and EDWARD E. HELD! IN a distributional study of the black sea cu- cumbers, H olothuria atra (Jager) and H. leu- cospilota (Brandt) , at Rongelap Atoll ( Fig. 1) the beaches of most of the larger islets were surveyed during September 1959, March 1961, and September 1961. Estimates of abundance and size were made, and observations on tem- perature tolerance, predation, asexual reproduc- tion by fission, and some other ecological aspects were considered. These two species of sea cucumbers are fre- quently, although not always, found together in the intertidal area of the seaward sides of the islets at the edge of the reef-flat nearest shore. They occupy pools of water from a few centi- meters to about one shalf meter deep at low tide (Figs. 2, 3), or are occasionally entirely exposed. H. atra usually covers itself with a coating of light coral sand held in place by tube feet, al- though occasionally it is naked and black. The integument is thick and firm. This species lacks the Cuvierian organ and thus may be handled without the annoyance of adhesive threads. H. leucospilota is always naked and almost black, has a softer integument with fine protuberances giving it a prickly appearance. The intricate, microscopic calcareous deposits in the integu- ment differ markedly in the two species: in H. atra (Fig. 4A ) the "tables" are tall and there are no "buttons," while in H. leucospilota (Fig. 4B) the tables are short and squat, and there are many buttons. H. atra also occurs in deeper water in the lagoon, where it does not coat itself with sand, and to an undetermined extent on the vast areas of reef-flat between islets. At high tide the water at the seaward shores of the islets usually covers both species to a depth of 1-1 Y2 m, and they 1 University of Washington, Laboratory of Radia- tion Biology, Fisheries Cent er, Seattle 5, Washington . Manuscript received December 20, 1961. are then frequently subjected to wave action from the surf whose initial force has been broken by the outer reef. A conspicuous feature of this habitat is the churning agitation and aeration of the water. H. atra appears to main- tain its position by inhabiting depressions and holding onto the relatively smooth reef-flat by means of its tube feet. H. leucospilota usually anchors the posterior portion of its body under- neath a stable rock or in a hole in the reef floor. In the absence of other cover it may find its way under a cluster of H. atra (Fig. 3). At appro- priate times it extends its highly mobile and extensible anterior end outward for feeding. Concentrations of these two species almost always occur where large slabs of beachrock are situated on the lower edge of the sandy beach slope bordering the inner edge of the reef-flat, and where, after the recession of the tide , the sea water may be observed to issue from the sand onto the reef-flat below the slabs of rock until the next tide. Below a sandy beach without slabs of rock no such prolonged runoff is evi- dent, and the sea cucumbers usually are few or lacking. It is in the pools fed by the relatively cool water from underneath the rock slabs that H. atra and H. leucospilota thrive. Concentra- tions of sea cucumbers were occasionally seen in the absence of slab-rock, and rarely slab-rock was found with out sea cucumbers. They occupy an ecological niche almost devoid of other macroscopic organisms; occasionally small snails occur, but frequently the sea cucumbers are alone. There is no obvious food in the sand they ingest. CENSUSING OF SEA CUCUMBERS The surveying procedure consisted of observ- ing, photographing, and taking notes on the abundance of Holotburia while walking around 305

Transcript of Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea...

Page 1: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atraand H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

KELSHAW BONHAM and EDWARD E. HELD!

IN a distributional study of the black sea cu­cumbers, H olothuria atra (Jager ) and H. leu­cospilota ( Brandt) , at Rongelap Atoll ( Fig. 1)the beaches of most of the larger islets weresurveyed during September 1959, March 1961,and September 1961. Estimates of abundanceand size were made, and observations on tem­perature tolerance , predation, asexual reproduc­tion by fission, and some other ecological aspectswere considered.

These two species of sea cucumbers are fre­quently, although not always, found together inthe intertidal area of the seaward sides of theislets at the edge of the reef-flat nearest shore.They occupy pools of water from a few centi­meters to about one shalf meter deep at low tide(Figs. 2, 3), or are occasionally entirely exposed.H . atra usually covers itself with a coating oflight coral sand held in place by tube feet, al­though occasionally it is naked and black. Theintegument is thick and firm. This species lacksthe Cuvierian organ and thus may be handledwithout the annoyance of adhesive threads. H.leucospilota is always naked and almost black,has a softer integument with fine protuberancesgiving it a prickly appearance. The intricate,microscopic calcareous deposits in the integu­ment differ markedly in the two species: in H .atra (Fig. 4A ) the "tables" are tall and thereare no "buttons," while in H . leucospilota (Fig.4B) the tables are short and squat, and there aremany buttons.

H. atra also occurs in deeper water in thelagoon, where it does not coat itself with sand,and to an undetermined extent on the vast areasof reef-flat between islets. At high tide the waterat the seaward shores of the islets usually coversboth species to a depth of 1-1 Y2 m, and they

1 University of Washington, Laboratory of Radia­tion Biology, Fisheries Cent er, Seattle 5, Washington.Manu script received December 20 , 1961.

are then frequently subjected to wave actionfrom the surf whose initial force has beenbroken by the outer reef. A conspicuous featureof this habitat is the churning agitation andaeration of the water. H. atra appears to main­tain its position by inhabiting depressions andholding onto the relatively smooth reef-flat bymeans of its tube feet. H. leucospilota usuallyanchors the posterior portion of its body under­neath a stable rock or in a hole in the reef floor.In the absence of other cover it may find its wayunder a cluster of H . atra (Fig. 3). At appro­priate times it extends its highly mobile andextensible anterior end outward for feeding.

Concentrations of these two species almostalways occur where large slabs of beachrock aresituated on the lower edge of the sandy beachslope bordering the inner edge of the reef-flat,and where , after the recession of the tide , thesea water may be observed to issue from thesand onto the reef-flat below the slabs of rockuntil the next tide. Below a sandy beach withoutslabs of rock no such prolonged runoff is evi­dent, and the sea cucumbers usually are few orlacking. It is in the pools fed by the relativelycool water from underneath the rock slabs thatH . atra and H. leucospilota thrive. Concentra­tions of sea cucumbers were occasionally seenin the absence of slab-rock, and rarely slab-rockwas found with out sea cucumbers. They occupyan ecological niche almost devoid of othermacroscopic organisms; occasionally small snailsoccur, but frequently the sea cucumbers arealone. There is no obvious food in the sand theyingest.

CENSUSING OF SEA CUCUMBERS

The surveying procedure consisted of observ­ing, photographing, and taking notes on theabundance of Holotburia while walking around

305

Page 2: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

306

" ' . . ..,."~ I

PACIFIC SCIENCE, Vol. XVII, July 1963

of() rhi..' . ~ IJ

fl r.....,." ..."

:\~.:::::::..,+i' w..~ ll r r

.f . ... . ~ r

(.orr·..·..·,.:t··,·,,,·,.~

RONGELAP ATOLL

FIG. 1. Map of Rongelap Atoll showing islet names and numbers.

the periphery of 16 islets completely , and 5others partially, thus covering 67 % of the sea­ward shores of all islets 'in the atoll. The isletsare numbered clockwise on the map of RongelapAtoll shown in Figure 1 starting at the north­west extremity. Only about 2% of the inter-isletreef area and shallower lagoon bottom regionssupposedly suitable for H. atra was censused.

Distances were measured by chain on theseaward shores of four islets, Aniiru, Kabelle,Namoen, and Rongelap, while at other isletsdistances were either determined by pacing, or,in most cases, estimated. On the east rim of theatoll high-altitude vertical , and elsewhere low­altitude oblique, aerial photos were employed toaid in orientation. Photographs taken on thereef-flat or undisturbed sea cucum bers weresometimes used in the estimations of abundance.

The places of concealrnerrtrunder overhangingledges were inspected , but rocks were seldomlifted to check for specimens .

Table 1 shows the distribution of H . atra andH . leucospilota at the localities surveyed. Sectionnumbers representing 100-m units of seawardshoreline appear under the appropriate fre­quency group. The central frequency groups in­crease by a factor of 10 while smaller ranges ofnumbers delimit the extremes. Along with therange in the column headings are the means inparentheses-geometric except for the first,where the zero limit precludes use of the geo­metric mean . Geometric and arithmetic meanswere tested for agreement with totals of thelast two columns showing sums by localitiestaken directly from a previous tabulation, whichalso supplied the data for the body of Table L

Page 3: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

Sea Cucumbers at Rongelap A toll-BON H AM and HELD

TABLE I

D ISTRIB UTION OF H . atra AN D H . leucospilota ON THE SEAWARD SHORES OF ISLETS

BY IO O·M SECTION N UMB ERS

307

(The body of the table shows section num bers in which the abunda nce of sea cucumbers fell within the rangeindic ated in the column heading. Sections for each islet were num bered clockwise starting at the coun rerclock­wise extremity (lef t-hand end when facing seaward) of the seaward shore.)

et ate l OO-m s e c t i o n numb er Rema rks To ta l i nd i vidu-No Na me '" .... .... I I I I I I

leuc10spi l~ ta a I s obse rved~ '" cc Numbers of !!. a tra Number s o f li. o r e s t ima t ed

.c ., 0- 2 3- 1 0 11-10 0 1 0 1 - 100 1 - 0 - 2 3 - 10 11-100 1 OJ.- 1 0 0 1-., u ( 1 )' (1 ) •Co .. Co 5 .62 ) (3 3 .2) 100 0 30 0 0 (5 . 62 ) ( 3 3 .2) 1000 3000 H. un ll.w.=~ ~ . (3 18 ) ( 1730) (318 (1 730 ) li..ll1.12.til'" '" '"

2 Nae o 15. 19 1 - 5 1-5 0 022

3 W. Yug ui 15 0 04 pigan i-

va rcvec 15 19 1 - 4 5 6 1-4 5 6 E . shore , many 2 1 0 2 0005 Aer ik. 2 2 1 - 3 1-2 3 12 atra o n W. sho re 12 4 06 E . Yuqu i 22 1-4 2-4 1 8 ~ on E . 16 on W. 24 6 4

s ho re8 Lomu i l al 14 1 - 5 1 - 5 0 0

ce l e n 14 1- 4 1-4 lJ on13 1 3 Inner 1 2 (1 0 . 0 0 0 atra in lagoon . 1. 13 & 1. 1 5 ) 100 0 0 013 1 3 Outer 12 17 1 2 2 6 0 24 018 Re e f area 13 (700 me t e r s north o f Ani iru I. had 8 3 , 0 0 0 a tra,26 0 0 l euco .and 4 300 S t ichopus 83000 2600

1e h loranatu s )1 8 Ani iru 1 2 12 1 - 2 1 -2 200 601 9 Kabe l Le 1 0 1 1 2 2 7 3 .8.9 0 .1 .4 . (1 0) 2-1 0 0 . 1 20 0 atr a & 100 30 00 1 50 I

13 6 l euc o . in N.E . Ichanne l20 Namoe n 1 2 2 1 2 1 4~. S . s i d e 2300 1629 Mellu 1 7 1 8 2 -5 1. 15 6 - 9 . 13 10-12 . 1-2 3 3 atra , 3 l e uc o ., E 35 00 13

14, 16 - 19 . 20 . c hanne l18 . 21 22 .2 3

31 Gog an 18 1-8 3-6 1-2 . 8 ili,2.. E . c h an ne l . 3 30 327 -8 s lab r o c k a t 1 -3 & 5.

34 Kies h l - 18 1-6 1-" 600 0echi

39 Enia e t ok 8 9 2 -3 . 1 . 1 2 , 4 , 9 11 , 14 1 0 1 - 9 , 10 ,14 0 5 ~ & 1 leuco . 3600 2 45 - 8 13 .15 - 11-13 N. s i d e

2 3 15 - 2 35 3 Rong elap 5 8 - 1-2 . 3- 5 . 6 .7 .15 . 28 -30 , 1 -24 . 25 . 4 1 4 6-48. some a t r a , l ag oon 34 00 1)90

lL 8-14 . 36. 4 2 . 2 2 . 27 . 3 9 - 4 1. 26 - 4 0. 44 . 4 5 5 0-52 . side20. 16 -2 1. 45 ,5 5 . 37 . 4 3 . 4 4 . 46 . 42-43 . 49 .56 54 . 5 5 .2 1 31 - 35. 5 7 . 61. 4 7-5 2 . 8 0 5 3 . 6 7- 6 3 .66 5 7-6 2 .

3 7. 5 3. 66 ,71 54 .58 - 71. 8 3 . 72. 74 6 4 .65 .67 -69. 6 0 . 62 - 84 .88- 76 7 3 758 3- 9 2 6 5 . 70 . 92 77 -79 .

72 - 7 9 . 80-82.8 1 . 8 2 8 5 -87

54 Arbar 1 9 1 . 2 . ' 3 - 5 . 1 - 2 6 27 -2 9 73 386 - 1 2. 1 3 - 2 627 - 29

58 Tu f a 20 19 1 9 20 0 !!!.!..laqoon . 20 0mi d-is let only,se e n

6 0 Bur ak 2 0 1-12 1 - 1 2 1 !.ll:!..lag oon s i de I 60 406 1 Pok orepp 20 1 1 0 0Total sections 76 65 66 23 16 0 4 1 36 (Total 110421 632 7)

*Ar i t.hmet i c mean. Means in other co lumn s are qeome t r r c .

Page 4: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

308

Better agreement resulted from the use of geo­metric than from arithmetic means.

Analysis of the table shows that the islets hadan estimated 1.7 X 104 H. atra and 3.7 X 103

H . leucospilota. In addition, an extensi ve area(4 X 104m2 ) of shallow (4-6 rn ) lagoon bot­tom off Island 13 and Island 15 ( Fig. 1 ) wasobserved from a skiff to be populated with anestimated 104 30-cm black ( not sand-coated )H . atra lying on the light sandy portions amongthe darker predominating, staghorn corals. Theestimate for the 700 m of reef-flat north ofAniiru I., as far as a transverse ridge across thereef, was based on thr ee traverses from 3 to 6m wide: first, walking north along the middleof the reef ; then back, one-third of the way infrom the seaward edge of the reef; and finally,pacing west across the reef on a line 200 mnorth of Aniiru I., for a distance of 500 mlagoonward from the seaward reef e dge. Extra­polations of the above observations to the ent ire

FIG. 2. Inn er edge of reef-flat, Rongelap I., section29, showing Holothuria in pools. Sept . 5, 1959, 1025hr.

PACIFIC SCIENCE, Vol. XVII, July 1963

atoll suggest the following numbers of H . atraand H . leucospilota, respectively : for islet shores,2.5 X 104 and 5.5 X 103 ; for inter-islet reefs,4 X 106 and 105 ; and for shallow lagoon bot­tom areas, 5 X 105 H. atra, or a total for theent ire atoll of 4.5 X 106 atra and 1.6 X 105

leucospilota.

OTHER SPECIES OF SEA ·CUC UMBERS

Species observed other than H . atra and H.leucospilota .are mentioned in order of decreas­ing abundance. Stichopus cbloronotus, the green­ish-black prickly sea cucumber on the inter-isletreef-flat and on the sandy, shallow lagoon shorenear the north channel of Kabelle I. was mostcommon. Also on the shallow, sandy bottom,lagoonward from Kabelle L we observed in mid­September 1961, during a period of extremetides, a heavy concentration (a bout 1/ m2 ) of10 to 20-cm specimens of a light-colored A c­tinopyga sp. with small brown spots. Dead ,specimens were common on the lagoon shore ofKabelle I. The large brown A ctinopyga mauriti­ana occupied the outer edge of the reef-flat.H olothuria gyrifer, a small tan-colored sea cu­cumber with white spo ts, was common underrocks on the seaward reef and especially in thechannel north of Kabelle 1. Occasional speci­mens of Ophiodesoma spectabilis were encoun­tered under rocks.

SAN D PASSING THROUGH HOLOTHURIA

The holothurians have been called the earth­worms of the sea. The amount of sand passingthrough the gut of H olothuria is of interestbecause of the possibility of profound alterationof the ecology in those areas where sea cucum­bers are abundant. Crozier (1918 ) has estimatedthat in 1.7 sq miles of bottom in Harr ingtonSound, Bermuda, 500-1000 tons of sand passthrough Sti chopus m oebii annually ( consideringtheir average length to be 27 em and the dryweight of the contained sand to be 46 g ) . Heconcluded that the primary effect of the feedinghabits upon the environment is the moving ofsand from one place to another.

Trefz ( 1958: 14 ) timed the passage of sandthrough capti ve H . atra at about 12 hr for anaverage-sized specimen of 30 em. Assuming an

Page 5: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

Sea Cucumbers at Rongelap Atoll-BONHAM and HELD 309

FIG. 3. H. leucospilota (black) extending fromunderneath H . atra in a pool on the eastern shore ofRongelap I., Aug. 23, 1958 , 1700 hr .

average gut content of 100 g dry weight, thiswould be equi valent to 1 gram in 7.2 min.Larger specimens required more time for pass­age of sand through the gut than did smallerspecimens , according to the following relation­ship derived from her data for specimens of25-38 cm (omitting two outlying observations):

t= 5.3 + 0.233 L

where t represents time in hours for passagethrough the gut, and L is length of sea cucumberin cm.

Yarnanouti (1939 :614) weighed the gut con­tents of 65 small (5-25 cm ) H. atra and re­corded an average of 17.1 g dry weight (range,0.4-40.5 g ). Time required for passage throughthe gut of capti ve specimens averaged 4.8 hr.Thus , 1 gram would be ingested every 16.8 minon the average.

Direct observation during low, daytim e tidesof undisturbed, feeding individuals of H. atra

30 cm long in their natural habitat at RongelapAtoll showed egesrion of sand at the rate of 1g ( dry basis ) in from 5 to 10 min, agreeingwith deductions from the data of Trefz on cap­tive specimens. Assuming continuous feeding, atRongelap Atoll the estimated 5 X 106 H. atraand H. leucospilota probably ingest and egesrabout 2.4 X 108 kg of sand yearly.

It has been pointed out by Crozier ( 1918)for Stichopus m oebii, by Yamanouti (1939) forH. atra and other species, and by Trefz ( 1958)for H. atra, that there is virtually no grindingaction or reduction in size of sand particles uponpassing through the gut. Trefz has demonstratedthat even such minute and delicate calcareous .structures as the integumental "anchors andplates " of the sea cucumber, Ophiodesoma spec­tabilis, do not undergo perceptible dissolutionin the gut of H. atra, but that they appear thesame after egestion as before ingestion, ther ebynegating the idea of chemical dissolution in thegut.

In some of the scoured depressions on the 'seaward reef where very little sand is present,H . atra serves an additional function by retain­ing within and around itself much of the sandrequired in its feeding that might otherwise bewashed away.

SIZE OF SPECIMENS

The length of undisturbed H. atra in the openranged from about 2 to 60 ern, with estimatedweights of 10 to 2000 g. We have not observedsmaller ones. Frequent estimates of length dur ­ing the censusing led to the opinion that thegeometric mean length of H. atra on the isletshores is about 17 cm and of the more slenderH. leucospilota about 25 cm. In contrast to theelongate shape of the larger specimens , thesmaller specimens of H . atra were short andthick; in fact, the smallest ( 2 cm) were as thickas they were long. At the northeastern reef ofKabelle I. on September 14, 1%1, 407 speci­mens of H. atra in a single pool were individ­ually measured or estimated for length anddiameter in inches, while still undi sturbed,and were then placed in a container of waterfor volume measurement in ern" by displace­ment. The temp erature of the pool rangedfrom about 35 to 39 C during the 5 hr re-

Page 6: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

310

TABLE 2

LENGTH-FREQUENCIES OF 407 H. atra MEASUREDIN A POOL ON THE NORTHEASTERN SHORE OF

KABELLE ISLAND, SEPT. 14, 1961

LENGTH LENGTHINCHES NUMBER INCHES NUMBER

2 5 6 983 8 7 294 78 8 .14

5 159 9 810 2

quired for measuring. Both the high tempera­ture and the slight, unavoidable disturbance ofadjacent individuals when picking up specimensfor volume measurement resulted in a smallamount of contraction. After handling, the speci­mens were deposited in another part of the pool.Table 2 gives the length-frequencies. Thesemeasurements show a single major peak at about5 inches (12 .7 cm), and fail to affirm the pres­ence of other expected frequency groups .

Figure 5 is a histogram showing the volume ­frequency . As with length-frequency there isa single peak (at about 60 ern") .

From lines fitted by inspection to the scatterdiagram of Figure 6 the relationship of volume(V) to length (L) in the size range 5-15 cmwas estimated to be:

V=5.4 LO.9 4

The rather abrupt increase in slope beyond15 cm IS emphasized by the visually fittedline:

V=0.019 L3.0

A few additional measurements of specimenslonger than 25 cm suggest that this slope of3.0 continues throughout the upper size-range.

TEMPERATURE TOLERANCE

Consideration of their habitat, exposed to thesun in shallow pools at low tide, would suggesta high temperature tolerance for H. atra. On

PACIFIC SCIENCE, Vol. XVII, July 1963

partly cloudy days after at least 2 hr of con­tinuous sunshine, the temperatures of 69 poolscontaining H. atra ranged from 31.1 to 39.4 C,with mean and standard deviation of 36.19 and2.14 C. The temperatures, determined with clin­ical centigrade thermometers, of eight black seacucumbers were consistently higher than simul­taneous temperatures in the sand-coated seacucumbers alongside them (by an average of0.25 C, standard deviation 0.16 C). After moreprolonged exposure to sunlight this differentialwould be expected to increase. Shaded thermom­eters on the bottoms of the pools gave readingslower than within the sand-coated sea cucum­bers, while thermometers in direct sunlight onthe pool bottoms approximated those withinthe black sea cucumbers. Extreme differencesbetween pool- and specimen-temperatures at anyone place and time barely exceeded 1 C. Somedegree of reflective insulation from the radiationof the sun is imparted to H . atra by the coatingof light-colored sand with which it habituallycovers its body, enabling it to retain a slightlylower body temperature than it does when notsand-coated, or than does the naked, black H .leucospilota when out in the open .

.The warmest pool in which a H. leucospilotawas found was 38.4 C, but the animal was notfeeding. The usual habitat of H . leucospilota iscooler than that of H. atra because of its habitof seeking the shade,•.and protection of rocks.Water coming in over the reef at high tide hasa temperature of about 29 C. When this coolwater saturates the beach it remains cool ifoverlain by strata of slab rock, but is warmedby the sun if the sand is exposed . H. atra oc­curred in pools of higher temperature, 39.4 C.The upper limit was not determined. Crozier(1915 : 281) gives the maximum temperatureof the habitat of H . suril1amel1sis as 31.8 C andstates that muscle coagulates at 42 C. This isonly about 3 C above the highest pool tempera­tures in which H. atra has been encountered.H. atra is unusually tolerant of heat, and is al­most the only macroscopic organism living inthese warm pools at low tide on the warmestdays.

FIG . 4. Photomicrographs showing calcareous deposits in the integument. A, Tables of H . atra. B, Tablesand buttons of H. leucospilota.

Page 7: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

Sea Cucumbers at Rongelap Atoll-BONHAM and HELD 311

Page 8: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

312 PAOFIC SOENCE, Vol. XVII, July 1963

PHOTOTROPISM

TRANSVERSE FISSION

FIG. 6. Relationship of volume to length of 407H . atra at KabelIe 1., Sept. 14, 1961. Lines drawn byinspection .

H. surinamensis which he suspected of beingregenerated following either autotomy or injuryby enemies such as fishes or crabs, but statesthat there is no evidence that H olothuria hasenemies of this kind . Frizzell and Exline (1955:29) ascribe predation on intertidal sea cucum­bers to sea gulls, and note the general concur­rence among authors that predation is slight, butpropose that the apparent protective mecha­nisms of holothurians suggest predation to bemore common than is supposed.

30207 '0Length in em

I'~ ..:/

' f~'& 'j: .

;; ~ ;;, .iii~~ i! /i~:<~f:r~i~:~ ~ .' .:.;: ...

. . ~~:

".. ..' ..,'

Besides reflective insulation the sand coatingof H . atra affords concealment. This function,however, would seem to be subordinate to thatof insulation, because of the small amount ofpredation to which H. atra is apparently sub­jected, unless, of course, the converse obtains,that the small amount of predation may be dueto the concealing effect of the sand coating. Adamaged sea cucumb er has been observed onlyonce. Th is specimen, presumably pecked by .abird, occurred in an area where curlews hadbeen active. In no case has an animal been ob­served actually preying upon H. atra. Crozier( 1915 :246) observed lightly colored parts of

PREDATION

H. atra, and to an even greater extent, H.leucospilota are negatively phototropic since

_both protect themselves from strong light, H.atra by its sand coating, and H. leucospilotaby seeking shelter. They usually react to quickchanges in light intensity, as by withdrawal oftentacles when covered by a shadow during feed­ing. H. leucospilota reacts to a shadow by sud­denly contracting under the protection of therock where its posterior end is anchored, thusfrequ ently requiring a quick grasp and a firmpull in order to collect this species.

FIG . 5. Histogram showing volume-frequency of407 H. atra from a pool at KabelIe 1., Sept . 14, 1961.

() ,'="o---f=J-..L....L...L..L.LLU.1.400

Fission has been reported in holothurians byCrozier (1 915 :291 ), who found regenerationof either end of the body in about 10% of theH. surinam ensis encountered. Frizzell and Exline(1955: 15 and 27 ) state that a few forms in­cluding H olothuria parvula (Selenka ), Cucum­aria lactea, and C. planci ( Brandt) sometimes

Page 9: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

Sea Cucumbers at Rongelap Atoll-BONHAM and HELD 313

reproduce by transverse fission, and that H olo­thuria dilficilis Semper of the tropical Pacificcommonly does so.

In September 1959 in a warm pool of about37 C on the southwest shore of Burok 1. twoshort specimens of H. atra were encounteredlying end to end. The integument of the twoadjacent terminal end portions was devoid ofsand because of the absence of tube feet. Thespecimens were saved, and later examinationrevealed a calcareous oral ring in only one, in­dicating that the two individuals resulted fromtransverse fission. Another specimen in an ad­jacent pool was photographed in an advancedstage of constriction; but without disturbanceby even so slight a stimulus as a shadow it vol­untarily relaxed the constriction and resumednormal shape within a period of about 5 min.

During the September 1961 census, enoughfissioning (Fig. 7) and fissioned specimens were

FIG. 7. H. atra, about 23 em long, undergoingtransverse fission in a pool 10-em deep. Mellu I., sea­ward side near wesr end, Sept . 18, 1961, 1520 hr.

encountered to verify that fission, or asexual re­production, does commonly occur in H olothuriaatra.

The importance of fissioning as a means ofreproduction is emphasized in Figure 6 by therelative thickness of the small specimens and theconsequent reduced slope (0.9) of their logarith­mic relationship of volume to length as com­pared to the usual cubic relationship ( slope of3) for the larger specimens.

If it may be assumed that sexual reproductionwould be seasonal in nature, while fissioningwould occur at all seasons, then the lack of ap­parent age classes or frequency modes in thevolume-frequency histogram of Figure 5 is alsoconsistent with the concept of reproduction byfissioning.

SUMMARY

1. The preferred habitat for H. atra and H.leucospilota on the seaward reef-flat is describedand is linked with the presence of slabs orshelves of rock at the junction of the sandybeach with the reef-flat . On hot days runoffwater from such areas is of relatively low tem­perature (because of the insulating effect of theslabs of rock).

2. Estimates of numbers of these two seacucumbers are based upon notes and photo­graphs 'made while traversing the peripheries ofthe larger islets and some reef and lagoon areas,resulting in an estimated total of about 5 X 106

H. atra and 2 X 105 H . leucospilota.3. The passage of sand through the gut of

H. atra is at the rate at 1 g (dry weight) infrom 5 to 10 min, resulting in an estimate forthe atoll of about 2 X 108 kg of sand ingestedand egested yearly. The primary ecological roleof the sea cucumbers in this feeding action isto move the sand from one place to another.

4. Length of H. atra observed ranged from 2to 60 cm. Measurements of 407 specimens inone pool showed that for specimens up to 15cm in length, volume increased slowly withlength, while for those from 15 to 25 em , vol­ume increased almost as the cube of length. Thisis construed as evidence of reproduction byfissioning.

5. H. atra appeared healthy and feeding insmall pools with temperatures up to 38.9 C.

Page 10: Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria ... · Ecological Observations on the Sea Cucumbers Holothuria atra and H. leucospilota at Rongelap Atoll, Marshall Islands

314

The internal temperature is slightly lower inthe sand-coated than in the naked black speci­mens because of the reflection of light andheat by the coating of sand characteristic ofthis species.

6. Evidence of predation upon H. atra or H.leucospilota is practically lacking.

7. Transverse fission in H. atra has been ob­served in various stages of progress, and isconsidered to be an important means of repro­duction.

REFERENCES

CROZIER, W . J. 1915. The sensory reactions ofH olothuria surinamensis. Zool. Jb. Phys. 35:231- 297.

--- 1918. The amount of bottom materialingested by holothurians. J. Exp. Zool. 26:379-389.

PACIFIC SCIENCE, Vol. XVII, July 1963

CUENOT, 1. 1948. Anatomie, Brhologie er Sys­tematique des Echinodermes. Classe de Holo­thuries. In : P. P. Grasse, Traite de Zoologie,Anatomie, Systematique Biologie. Tome 11,Echinodermes, Stom a toe 0 r des, Procordes,Paris. Pp . 82-120.

FRIZZELL, D. 1., and HARRIET EXLINE. 1955.Monograph of fossil holothurian sclerites.Bull. Univ. Missouri School of Mines & Met­alurgy, Tech. Ser. 89: 1-204.

TREFZ, SHIRLEY M. 1958. The physiology ofdigestion of H olothuria atra Jager with spe­cial reference to its role in the ecology of coralreefs. Doctoral thesis , University of Hawaii.Pp. 1-149.

Y AMANOUTI, T. 1939. Ecological and physio­logical studies on the holothurians in thecoral reef of Palao Islands. Palao Trap. BioI.Sta, Stud. 4:603-635.