ECHR - Governopresidenza.governo.it/CONTENZIOSO/contenzioso_europeo... · Web viewwithin three...
28
FIRST SECTION DECISION Application no. 3471/04 Graziella BORDINI against Italy and 88 other applications (see appended table) The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 27 September 2018 as a Committee composed of: Ksenija Turković, President, Pauliine Koskelo, Tim Eicke, judges, and Liv Tigerstedt, Acting Deputy Section Registrar, Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table, Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases, Having deliberated, decides as follows: FACTS AND PROCEDURE The list of applicants is set out in the appended table. The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”).
Transcript of ECHR - Governopresidenza.governo.it/CONTENZIOSO/contenzioso_europeo... · Web viewwithin three...
FIRST SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 3471/04Graziella BORDINI against Italy
and 88 other applications(see appended table)
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 27 September 2018 as a Committee composed of:
Ksenija Turković, President,Pauliine Koskelo,Tim Eicke, judges,
and Liv Tigerstedt, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates
indicated in the appended table,Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement
of the cases,Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention
concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”).
By letter of 7 January 2016, the representative of Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione, Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella (application no. 28985/04) informed the Court that the said applicants wished to withdraw their application to the Court.
As for the remainder of the applications, the Court received friendly-settlement declarations under which the applicants agreed to waive any further claims against Italy in respect of the facts giving rise to these applications, subject to an undertaking by the Government to pay them, the amounts detailed in the appended table. These amounts will be payable
2 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
within three months from the date of notification of the Court’s decision. In the event of failure to pay these amounts within the above-mentioned three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on them, from the expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.
The payment will constitute the final resolution of the cases.
THE LAW
Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
In the light of the foregoing, and in the absence of any special circumstances regarding respect for the rights guaranteed by the Convention and the Protocols thereto, the Court, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention, considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the part of application no. 28985/04 lodged by Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione, Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella.
As for the remainder of the applications, the Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the part of application no. 28985/04 introduced by Mrs Maria Serafina Ascione, Mr Gerardo Caruso and Mrs Delia Ievolella out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention;
Decides to strike the remainder of the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.
Done in English and notified in writing on 18 October 2018.
Liv Tigerstedt Ksenija TurkovićActing Deputy Registrar President
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 3
APPENDIX
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)1
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)2
1. 3471/0418/12/2003
Graziella BORDINI29/01/1943
12/07/2018 11/01/2018 1,500 250
2. 6916/0404/02/2004
Violante Amalia SMALDONE
29/03/1920
Di Gioia EnnioCusano Milanino
12/07/2018 05/03/2018 6,000 250
3. 7296/0413/02/2004
(3 applicants)
Biagio ORSILLO25/08/1931
Domenico GALASSO11/08/1960
Elvira GALASSO22/11/1962
Pagnozzi LoredanaBenevento
12/07/2018 28/02/2018 3,300 250
4. 7906/0405/02/2004
Maria Antonietta LANTELLA11/02/1968
Pagnozzi LoredanaBenevento
12/07/2018 16/02/2018 9,200 250
5. 11401/0410/03/2004
Paola RICCIARDI26/10/1963
Ferrara AlessandroBenevento
12/07/2018 03/01/2018 1,800 250
6. 11496/0410/03/2004
Carmelo FEBBRARO16/07/1929
died on 29/11/2017Heirs:
Luciano FEBBRARO12/12/1964
Mercante FEBBRARO30/04/1962
Ferrara AlessandroBenevento
12/07/2018 23/03/2018 5,100jointly to the heirs
250
4 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
Sergio FEBBRARO27/10/1968
Silvana FEBBRARO20/10/1960
Iolanda ZEOLI09/02/1931
7. 14569/0408/01/2004
Rosario VITIELLO09/09/1957
Pizzillo DomenicoBenevento
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,200 250
8. 19219/0412/04/2001
Istituto Filippo Smaldone Viscardi CatelloSalerno
12/07/2018 09/04/2018 4,300 250
9. 19240/0420/07/1999
Mario CASCIANO17/10/1967
Nardone AntonioBenevento
12/07/2018 20/04/2018 1,300 250
10. 19280/0422/07/1999
Cambianica Gian Paolo & Riboli Paolo S.N.C.
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 29/03/2018 2,000 250
11. 19693/0418/01/2001
Carlo GRIECO19/09/1960
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 27/03/2018 1,400 250
12. 22174/0416/06/2004
Gesualdi Pietro & C. S.a.s. Romano GiovanniBenevento
12/07/2018 02/01/2018 2,500 250
13. 24062/0429/03/1999
Domenico CALICCHIO06/11/1947
Domenico RUGGIERO24/04/1950
Ferrara SilvioBenevento
12/07/2018 19/02/2018 1,300 250
14. 24439/0401/06/1999
Dora VESSICHELLI30/01/1930
died on 31/12/2016Heirs:
Concetta BRUGLIERE14/07/1961
Maria Rosaria BRUGLIERE07/01/1966
Ferrara SilvioBenevento
12/07/2018 16/03/2018 6,200jointly to the heirs
250
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 5
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
15. 25793/0424/02/2001
Domenico CALICCHIO06/11/1947
Ferrara SilvioBenevento
12/07/2018 19/02/2018 1,700 250
16. 26016/0425/06/2004
Gioacchino ZOLLI11/05/1937
Pizzillo DomenicoBenevento
12/07/2018 03/01/2018 1,500 250
17. 26470/0423/06/2004
Azienda Agricola Caterina Sguera S.r.l.
Pizzillo DomenicoBenevento
12/07/2018 18/03/2018 3,300 250
18. 26741/0421/07/2004
Maria Luisa GUERRA25/01/1943
Ferrara AlessandroBenevento
12/07/2018 03/01/2018 1,100 250
19. 26760/0421/07/2004
Mario RICCIARDI04/10/1938
Ferrara AlessandroBenevento
12/07/2018 03/01/2018 3,000 250
20. 26876/0412/04/2001
Leasing Finanziaria Immobiliare S.p.a.
Viscardi CatelloSalerno
12/07/2018 03/04/2018 2,500 250
21. 28985/0409/07/2004
(61 applicants)
1. Amato AFFUSTO29/08/1941
2. Mario BOFFA17/02/1940
3. Anna BONTIEMPO28/02/1938
4. Francesco BOVIO29/06/1942
5. Giuseppe BOVIO12/06/1947
6. Anna Teresa CAGGESE18/03/1933
7. Pasquale CALANDRELLI11/05/1937
died on 06/10/2015Heirs:
Rosaria SACCOMANNO13/03/1936
Elena CALANDRELLI12/02/1966
Romano GiovanniBenevento
12/07/2018 05/02/2018 4,590per applicant and jointly
to the heirs of the following applicants:
Pasquale CALANDRELLI
died on 06/10/2015(Heirs:Rosaria
SACCOMANNO13/03/1936
Elena CALANDRELLI12/02/1966
Carmine CALANDRELLI
03/06/1962)
Ernestina CONTE29/04/1937
250
6 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
Carmine CALANDRELLI03/06/1962
8. Antonia CALANDRO29/09/1952
9. Tommaso CANCELLIERI28/01/1933
10. Rita CAPOZZI29/09/1951
11. Ugo CARLETTI24/07/1935
12. Luigi CAROPRESO02/02/1944
13. Anna CARUSO13/07/1939
14. Giuseppe CASSERO25/04/1944
15. Rita CELATO27/08/1957
16. Teresa CELATO07/02/1956
17. Antonio CITRO10/06/1947
18. Ernestina CONTE29/04/1937
died on 02/02/2013Heirs:
Massimo RUSSO21/08/1965
Angela RUSSO03/02/1963
19. Antonio DE FEO05/07/1947
died on 08/06/2010Heirs:
died on 02/02/2013(Heirs:
Massimo RUSSO21/08/1965
Angela RUSSO 03/02/1963)
Antonio DE FEO05/07/1947
died on 08/06/2010(Heirs:
Carmela Sabina GAITA19/09/1953
Anna Rita DE FEO22/03/1976)
Ugo Gallianodied on 08/12/2015
(Heirs:Anna SIMONE
09/06/1933Giuseppe GALLIANO
10/02/1959Luciana GALLIANO
07/08/1960)
Anna Maria MARCHIONE
died on 31/01/2012(Heirs:
Antonio MARCHIONE01/01/1946
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 7
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
Carmela Sabina GAITA19/09/1953
Anna Rita DE FEO22/03/1976
20. Benito DE SIMONE26/03/1939
21. Umberto FALLARINO22/02/1930
22. Giuliana FOLLO16/01/1957
23. Ugo GALLIANO20/02/1925
died on 08/12/2015Heirs:
Anna SIMONE09/06/1933
Giuseppe GALLIANO10/02/1959
Luciana GALLIANO07/08/1960
24. Cosimo IANNACE05/10/1934
25. Iolanda IANNACE21/11/1928
26. Luigi INFANTINO20/08/1934
27. Felicia LEMBO02/03/1948
28. Antonetta LEO07/02/1934
29. Annamaria LEPORE18/01/1953
30. Antonio MAIO21/06/1937
Riccardo MARCHIONE29/01/1949
Raffaele MARCHIONE17/07/1958
Anna Maria Tiziana PALUMBO11/11/1960
Cristiana Serenella PALUMBO06/12/1963
Vincenzo PALUMBO13/12/1969
Ilaria Barbara MARCHIONE
28/11/1976Barbara Ilaria
MARCHIONE24/05/1968)
Giovanni PIZZOdied on 24/05/2011
(Heirs:Anna PELLEGRINI
06/08/1956Nicoletta PIZZO
29/07/1977Antonio PIZZO
30/10/1975)Filomena Iolanda
D’ARGENIOdied on 17/10/2013
(Heirs:Vincenzo ZITANI
04/03/1970
8 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
31. Anna Maria MARCHIONE
28/08/1930died on 31/01/2012
Heirs:Antonio MARCHIONE
01/01/1946Riccardo MARCHIONE
29/01/1949Raffaele MARCHIONE
17/07/1958Anna Maria Tiziana
PALUMBO11/11/1960
Cristiana Serenella PALUMBO06/12/1963
Vincenzo PALUMBO13/12/1969
Ilaria Barbara MARCHIONE
28/11/1976Barbara Ilaria MARCHIONE
24/05/196832. Adriana MERCURIO
13/11/194733. Roberto MIELE
23/09/193534. Agostino PASTORE
21/11/194235. Antonio PASTORE
02/01/193936. Concetta PEPE
Umberto ZITANI04/03/1970
Arturo ZITANI04/04/1967)
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 9
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
22/07/193037. Vincenzo
PIETRONIGRO21/04/1939
38. Giovanni PIZZO25/07/1947
died on 24/05/2011Heirs:
Anna PELLEGRINI06/08/1956
Nicoletta PIZZO29/07/1977
Antonio PIZZO30/10/1975
39. Giuseppe RICCIARDI11/03/1928
40. Cosimo SALERNO28/09/1929
41. Felicia SANTAMARIA10/04/1931
42. Lucia SARRACINO21/06/1950
43. Vincenzo SOLLA20/05/1943
44. Clotilde VARRICCHIO22/09/1939
45. Angelina VERDINO12/03/1950
46. Antonio VERDINO10/06/1945
47. Mario VESSICHELLI06/10/1931
48. Elisabetta ZAMPELLI16/02/1933
10 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
49. Ida BORZILLO21/02/1941
50. Alessandro CORONA28/06/1965
51. Dario CORONA22/04/1976
52. Massimo CORONA12/12/1970
53. Walter CORONA04/08/1967
54. Anna Maria D’ARGENIO15/10/1950
55. Filomena Iolanda D’ARGENIO
15/10/1942died on 17/10/2013
Heirs:Vincenzo ZITANI
04/03/1970Umberto ZITANI
04/03/1970Arturo ZITANI
04/04/196756. Liliana D’ARGENIO
30/08/194857. Pasqualina D’ARGENIO
09/07/195658. Rita D’ARGENIO
29/09/195359. Assunta FORGIONE
14/08/195160. Nicoletta SANTAMARIA
17/12/197361. Virginia SANTAMARIA
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 11
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
14/08/196722. 30892/04
28/06/2000Anna ROMANO
13/02/1955Pizzillo Domenico
Benevento12/07/2018 22/02/2018 2,300 250
23. 32244/0425/01/2000
(3 applicants)
Gaetano BRANCIFORTE12/01/1939
Carmelo BRANCIFORTE15/02/1941
Emanuele BRANCIFORTE17/11/1948
Magro FrancescoAvola
12/07/2018 28/02/2018 4,600 250
24. 32256/0427/08/2004
(3 applicants)
Gioacchino GRASSI11/09/1938
Martino COLONNA02/03/1951
Carlo SCHIAVONE09/08/1941
Ventura CostantinoBari
12/07/2018 15/01/2018 7,000 250
25. 34576/0406/04/2001
Paolo REGAZZONI14/11/1972
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 09/04/2018 800 250
26. 36253/0418/01/2001
Diego PEZZOLI14/04/1970
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 09/04/2018 1,400 250
27. 38909/0421/10/2004
Domenico DI NAPOLI28/02/1950
Romano GiovanniBenevento
12/07/2018 02/01/2018 1,300 250
28. 40761/0425/02/1999
Franco UGGETTI20/08/1958
12/07/2018 02/01/2018 3,500 250
29. 40771/0404/08/2000
Ilario GIASINI10/05/1940
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 28/03/2018 3,500 250
30. 40967/0412/02/1998
Alfonso TERENZIANO09/06/1946
Sparano GiuseppeRome
12/07/2018 15/05/2018 4,400 250
31. 41088/0429/09/1998
Dora VESSICHELLI30/01/1930
died on 31/12/2016
Ferrara SilvioBenevento
12/07/2018 16/03/2018 2,500jointly to the heirs
250
12 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
Heirs:Concetta BRUGLIERE
14/07/1961Maria Rosaria BRUGLIERE
07/01/196632. 42194/04
03/07/1999Zollo Antonio S.a.a. Ferrara Silvio
Benevento12/07/2018 03/01/2018 5,500 250
33. 43039/0429/09/1999
Maria MAZZANTI03/04/1943
Cargioli PaoloLa Spezia
12/07/2018 22/02/2018 1,500 250
34. 44037/0427/06/2001
Antonio ARESU30/11/1955
12/07/2018 03/01/2018 3,000 250
35. 44243/0429/09/1998
(3 applicants)
Paola D’AMMANDO01/04/1947
Marta GREGORI03/10/1978
Patrizia GREGORI31/01/1984
Vespaziani GiovanniRieti
12/07/2018 21/02/2018 3,100 250
36. 44244/0402/07/1998
Stefano MARGIOTTA23/04/1931
Vespaziani GiovanniRieti
12/07/2018 21/02/2018 2,400 250
37. 44247/0430/07/1999
Brunello GUNNELLA18/01/1936
Vespaziani GiovanniRieti
12/07/2018 21/02/2018 3,300 250
38. 44316/0406/03/2001
Afim S.N.C. Verrilli TogoBenevento
12/07/2018 11/01/2018 3,000 250
39. 44627/0420/11/2004
Gian Patrizio CIONI24/01/1972
Zuccardi Merli LilianaRome
12/07/2018 13/02/2018 400 250
40. 44641/0417/04/2001
Giovanni GRAMAZIO23/06/1969
Nardone AntonioBenevento
12/07/2018 20/04/2018 1,200 250
41. 44656/0419/10/2000
(14 applicants)
1. Ettore DE VITO03/03/1955
2. Giancarlo ALLEGRUCCI
Failla Gregoria MariaRome
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 1. Ettore DE VITO: 2502. Giancarlo
ALLEGRUCCI: 1,200
250
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 13
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
25/02/19453. Katia CANZONIERI
15/01/19704. Antonio CAROSI
25/03/19355. Micaela DI BERTO
17/05/19686. Aldo DI MARCO
23/10/19357. Giulio FABRIANESI
07/03/19388. Maurizio FLAMIGNI
09/02/19399. Maurizio MARCHINI
10/03/195310. Antonio MERRA
30/10/194311. Ruggiero RAPONI
09/10/193612. Stefano SCHIAVO
14/08/195513. Alberto TICCONI
16/08/193914. Vincenzo TRIFILIO
14/04/1964
3. Katia CANZONIERI: 900
4. Antonio CAROSI: 800
5. Micaela DI BERTO: 650
6. Aldo DI MARCO: 700
7. Giulio FABRIANESI: 1,300
8. Maurizio FLAMIGNI: 650
9. Maurizio MARCHINI: 650
10. Antonio MERRA: 650
11. Ruggiero RAPONI: 650
12. Stefano SCHIAVO: 650
13. Alberto TICCONI: 400
14. Vincenzo TRIFILIO: 850
42. 45519/0402/12/2004
Franco PAOLETTI23/01/1951
Alfredo PALOMBA18/10/1938
Zuccardi Merli LilianaRome
12/07/2018 03/03/2018 2,000 250
43. 7972/0514/02/2005
Paolo CIAIOLA27/05/1955
Zuccardi Merli LilianaRome
12/07/2018 10/02/2018 1,600 250
44. 4750/0625/01/2006
Luciano CATENA19/12/1958
Marzocchi GiorgioMilan
12/07/2018 22/01/2018 900 250
14 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
45. 18628/0628/04/2006
Silvestro FORTUNA28/01/1936
Marchetti AlessandroRome
12/07/2018 28/12/2017 7,600 250
46. 22731/0627/05/2006
Marino MARONGIU05/06/1952
Eugenio MARONGIU15/07/1953
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 05/02/2018 2,700jointly
250
47. 27487/0627/06/2006
Piero Antonio DE BELLIS09/07/1953
Villa PaoloRome
12/07/2018 23/03/2018 5,400 250
48. 28942/0618/07/2006
Tecno industriale S.r.l. Defilippi (pr) ClaudioParma
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 6,600 250
49. 1184/0722/12/2006
Maria ABBATE02/09/1934
Di Francesco OlindoAgrigento
12/07/2018 13/02/2018 1,800 250
50. 6897/0706/02/2007
Ezio LUCCHETTI20/08/1921
died on 21/04/2016Heir:
Gabriella FRANZELLITTI30/11/1928
Lucchetti DinoLatina
12/07/2018 04/01/2018 8,400 250
51. 11797/0721/02/2007
Enrico DE MARI24/10/1939
Mocella DanielaNaples
12/07/2018 16/02/2018 1,400 250
52. 12578/0715/03/2007
Maria Concetta MIRRA27/02/1949
Romano GiovanniRome
12/07/2018 02/01/2018 1,300 250
53. 32935/0716/07/2007
Ludovico MAZZARELLA15/08/1932
Villa PaoloRome
12/07/2018 13/02/2018 5,200 250
54. 47850/0708/10/2007
Giulio PADOVANI21/11/1918
Marchetti AlessandroRome
12/07/2018 28/12/2017 6,600 250
55. 7215/0828/03/2003
Lorella BONASIA08/10/1961
Massimo POZZI22/10/1962
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 28/03/2018 700 250
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 15
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
56. 7770/0801/02/2008
Silvia TRAMONTELLI15/03/1916
Marchetti AlessandroRome
12/07/2018 28/12/2017 3,500 250
57. 10263/0808/02/2008
Cornicchia Grafiche di Leopoldo Cornicchia
Amici Michele MariaPonte S. Giovanni
12/07/2018 02/02/2018 2,500 250
58. 18880/0811/04/2008
Guglielma CESARE15/08/1949
Romano GiovanniRome
12/07/2018 02/01/2018 1,300 250
59. 23083/0802/05/2008
Olimpia DEL MASTRO20/12/1933
Francesca DEL MASTRO22/03/1923
Montinaro Luigi PaoloLecce
12/07/2018 20/03/2018 2,000 250
60. 23455/0814/05/2008
Iole BERTI22/03/1956
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,800 250
61. 23912/0808/05/2008
(3 applicants)
Claudia FEDELI07/02/1965
Loredana SARDU12/01/1963
Emilio ARIAUDO06/08/1951
Abbate Ferdinando EmilioOrte
12/07/2018 30/03/2018 1,800 250
62. 24024/0806/05/2008
Carlo ROVANI02/05/1957
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,800 250
63. 26415/0826/05/2008
Maria Piera EMANUELI31/01/1941
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,800 250
64. 26425/0826/05/2008
Daniela RATTI21/12/1963
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,800 250
65. 26433/0826/05/2008
Loredana BALDASSINI02/04/1940
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,800 250
66. 31007/0812/06/2008
Cataldo MAINENTI10/05/1947
Selezione Pac S.r.l.
Vico RenatoBergamo
12/07/2018 09/04/2018 1,500jointly
250
16 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
67. 51984/0829/09/2008
Emma BACINELLI15/03/1933
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,100 250
68. 51998/0829/09/2008
Maria TONELLI06/03/1941
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,100 250
69. 52020/0829/09/2008
Roberta MAZZI18/07/1965
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,100 250
70. 53551/0829/09/2008
Carla VEZZI27/04/1949
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,100 250
71. 53659/0829/09/2008
Sandra DI SPAGNA17/09/1957
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,100 250
72. 25702/0912/05/2009
Remo FERRAGINA15/06/1946
Vito FERRAGINA01/02/1944
Defilippi (sp) ClaudioLa Spezia
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 1,000 250
73. 41712/1020/04/2010
Giuseppina MORELLI04/02/1952
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 2,000 250
74. 50737/1002/08/2010
(3 applicants)
Massimo IACOMINI18/11/1964
Franco BOGO17/06/1968
Maria Angelica ZICARI21/04/1963
Defilippi (sp) ClaudioLa Spezia
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 4,500 250
75. 61414/1006/08/2010
Giorgio STAGNARI16/07/1967
Defilippi (sp) ClaudioLa Spezia
12/07/2018 08/01/2018 4,000 250
76. 73329/1012/11/2010
Mario SCRIVANTI17/06/1948
Frisani Pietro L.Florence
12/07/2018 24/01/2018 2,500 250
77. 23651/1112/02/2011
(7 applicants)
Francesco BIFERO18/06/1942
Filomena BATTIMELLI03/10/1949
Ferrara AlessandroBenevento
12/07/2018 29/01/2018 6,000 250
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 17
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
Antonio ARPINO02/02/1951
Ida AMICARELLI04/06/1948
Luca AMORESE01/08/1951
Teresa BARBERIO02/10/1951
Salvatore BARBATO06/04/1952
78. 43717/1107/06/2011
Paolo FRATI05/07/1961
Defilippi (sp) ClaudioLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 4,500 250
79. 46361/1118/05/2011
Giuseppe SEMERARO04/02/1949
Fiorillo ErnestoMessina
12/07/2018 16/01/2018 3,100 250
80. 7422/1213/01/2012
Antonio MARINO30/09/1957
Restuccia PatriziaLa Spezia
12/07/2018 12/01/2018 1,500 250
81. 47721/1216/06/2012
Rachele OLIVA12/04/1948
Zicarelli EnedinoSan Sosti
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 5,700 250
82. 15654/1304/01/2013
Michele DEL DUCA18/03/1927
Fiorillo ErnestoMessina
12/07/2018 26/01/2018 6,600 250
83. 8188/1431/10/2013
Giuseppe LUBELLI19/05/1949
Daniele Giandomenico
Lecce
12/07/2018 23/03/2018 3,800 250
84. 42120/1427/05/2014
Franco GIUNTA15/08/1968
Branca Maria GabriellaSavona
12/07/2018 26/04/2018 1,800 250
85. 55084/1425/07/2014
Vincenzo VITAGLIANO MOCCIA11/05/1933
Vitagliano Moccia Giovanna Antida
Naples
12/07/2018 15/02/2018 1,000 250
86. 57142/14 Lorella PALOMBO Forte Bruno 12/07/2018 19/03/2018 1,300 250
18 BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
02/08/2014 11/01/1974Fabio SARDELLITTI
25/11/1973
Sora
87. 21557/1524/04/2015
Eleonora CASTELLANI02/07/1981
Daniela Antonia CASTELLANI
06/07/1953
Meucci FrancescaPrato
12/07/2018 04/04/2018 2,100 250
88. 46512/1512/09/2015
Armando GIARDINA15/01/1938
Giardina AmilcareSyracuse
12/07/2018 05/04/2018 900 250
89. 47929/1518/09/2015
(16 applicants)
1. Rito AMBROSI26/08/1947
2. Francesco BOSO18/03/1944
3. Giovanni D’AVERSA06/03/1941
4. Crocifisso DE GIOVANNI16/04/1947
5. Manfredo DI GIULIO17/12/1941
6. Giovanni FRANCESCA25/09/1940
7. Antonio GRAZIANO22/08/1952
8. Pasquale GRAZIANO17/02/1937
9. Eugenio MEROLLA05/03/1938
10. Andrea MORICONI22/08/1934
11. Bruno NARDONE10/03/1943
12. Giovanni PESCE
Lippi AndreaRome
12/07/2018 19/02/2018 2,300 250
BORDINI v. ITALY AND OTHER APPLICATIONS DECISION 19
No. Application no.Date of
introduction
Applicant’s nameDate of birth /
demise
Representative’s name and location
Date of Government’s
declaration
Date of Applicant’s declaration
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage
per applicant unless indicated “jointly”
(in euros)
Amount awarded for costs and expenses
per application(in euros)
27/11/193613. Nando PRATI
21/07/193514. Ciro RUOCCO
04/09/195315. Antonio SELVA
20/07/193616. Filippo TRITTO
13/09/1947
1. Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.2. Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.
