Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf ·...

48
Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planets Daniel Dale Physics & Astronomy University of Wyoming Image credit: NASA

Transcript of Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf ·...

Page 1: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planets

Daniel DalePhysics & AstronomyUniversity of Wyoming

Image credit: NASA

Page 2: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Outline

The Kepler missionTargetTechniqueResults

Page 3: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Outline

The Kepler missionTargetTechniqueResults

1571-1630

Page 4: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

What fraction of stars in our galaxy harbor potentially habitable, Earth-size planets?

Page 5: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The “habitable zone”

Image: NASA

Page 6: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The “habitable zone”

Image: NASA

Page 7: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The Drake EquationN = R* · f

p · n

e · f

l · f

i · f

c · L

Where:

• N = # civilizations in Galaxy w/detectable electromagnetic emissions

• R* = Rate of star formation suitable for the development of intelligent life

• fp = Fraction of those stars with planetary systems

• ne = Number of planets, per solar system, with environment suitable for life

• fl = Fraction of suitable planets on which life actually appears

• fi = Fraction of life-bearing planets on which intelligent life emerges

• fc = Fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space

• L = Length of time such civilizations release detectable signals into space

Page 8: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler launch06 March 2009

Cape CanaveralDelta II rocket0.95 m mirror

Page 9: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Outline

The Kepler missionTargetTechniqueResults

Page 10: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Where does Kepler search?

Image: NASA

Page 11: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Where does Kepler search?

Page 12: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Where does Kepler search?

Image: NASA

Page 13: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Outline

The Kepler missionTargetTechniqueResults

Page 14: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Radial velocityPulsar timingDirect imagingGravitational microlensingTransitPolarimetryAstrometry

Page 15: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Radial velocity

Image: European Southern Observatory

Page 16: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Radial velocity

Preferentially detectslarge, close-in planets

Only provides lowerlimit to mass

Image: European Southern Observatory

Page 17: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Pulsar timingquite rare & inhospitable1991 blooper

Images: Alex Wolszczan (Penn St.)

Page 18: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Direct imaging

Prefers infrared-bright planetsfar from faint stars

Image: European Southern Observatory

Page 19: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Gravitational microlensing

Best for orbits that are 1-10 AUNot repeatable

Image: Malyszkz

Page 20: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

How does Kepler search?Transit photometry

Image: NASA

150,000 stars observedPlanets may occult their parent star

Page 21: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The first recorded transit of Venus

Image credit: Ford Madox Brown, mural at Manchester Town Hall

Page 22: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N
Page 23: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N
Page 24: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

How does Kepler search?Transit photometry

Image: NASA

Kepler provides planetary “candidates”Ideally confirmed by another technique

10% false positives:Tightly bound or dim binary star companionStellar pulsationsPeriodic instrumental glitches

Page 25: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Exoplanet Detection Methods

Year

# D

etec

ted

Image: wikipedia

Page 26: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Image credit: NASA

Page 27: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Outline

The Kepler missionTargetTechniqueResults

Page 28: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Transiting planets pre-KeplerS

ize

Re

lati

ve

to

Ea

rth

Orbital period (days)Image: NASA

Page 29: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

2929

Candidates as of June 2010

Jun 2010

Orbital period (days)

Siz

e R

ela

tiv

e t

o E

art

h

Image: NASA

Page 30: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

30

Candidates as of Feb 2011Jun 2010 Feb 2011

Siz

e R

ela

tive

to

Ea

rth

Orbital period (days)Image: NASA

Page 31: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

31

Candidates as of Dec 2011Jun 2010 Feb 2011 Dec 2011

Siz

e R

ela

tive

to

Ea

rth

Orbital period (days)Image: NASA

Page 32: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Candidates as of Jan 2014S

ize

Rel

ati

ve

to E

art

h

Orbital period (days)Image: NASA

Page 33: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Image credit: NASA/W Stenzel

Page 34: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler's habitable zone planets

Page 35: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler 62system

Page 36: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Image credit: NASA Ames/JPL-Caltech

Page 37: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler's smallest habitable zone planet

Image credit: NASA Ames/JPL-Caltech/Tim Pyle

Kepler 62f1200 lyr away (Lyra)40% larger than Earth267 day orbit

Page 38: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

22% of Sun-like stars harborEarth-size planets orbitingin their habitable zones (Petigura et al. 2013)

Image: NASA

Page 39: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Extrapolate the result to the entire Milky Way: 40 billion habitable Earth-size planets (Petigura et al. 2013)

Image: NASA

Page 40: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Transit and DopplerMeasurements Yield Density

+10b Size

MassVolume

= 8.8 g/cm3

Density

Image: NASA

Page 41: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Image: NASA

Page 42: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The Drake EquationN = R* · f

p · n

e · f

l · f

i · f

c · L

Where:

• N = # civilizations in Galaxy w/detectable electromagnetic emissions

• R* = Rate of star formation suitable for the development of intelligent life

• fp = Fraction of those stars with planetary systems

• ne = Number of planets, per solar system, with environment suitable for life

• fl = Fraction of suitable planets on which life actually appears

• fi = Fraction of life-bearing planets on which intelligent life emerges

• fc = Fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space

• L = Length of time such civilizations release detectable signals into space

Page 43: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The Drake EquationN ~ 10 · 1 · 0.2 · ? · ? · ? · ?

Where:

• N = # civilizations in Galaxy w/detectable electromagnetic emissions

• R* = Rate of star formation suitable for the development of intelligent life

• fp = Fraction of those stars with planetary systems

• ne = Number of planets, per solar system, with environment suitable for life

• fl = Fraction of suitable planets on which life actually appears

• fi = Fraction of life-bearing planets on which intelligent life emerges

• fc = Fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space

• L = Length of time such civilizations release detectable signals into space

Page 44: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

The Drake Equation

Progressing from left to right, the equation is increasingly uncertain.

Many consider this equation to simply be conceptual, something to start a conversation on how to approach a search for life.

Fermi Paradox: Where are they?

Page 45: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler Exoplanets By the NumbersCandidates: 4234 July 2014 (3845 April 2014)

Confirmed: 978 July 2014 (961 April 2014)

Estimated Galaxy Total: 40 billion

22% of Sun-like stars harbor Earth-size, habitable planets

Nearest: Alpha Centauri Bb at 4 lyr

Least massive: 2 lunar masses

Most massive: 29 Jupiter masses

Orbital periods: few hours to thousands of years

Page 46: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Thank You

Page 47: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Kepler's FutureKepler experienced 2 reaction wheel failures (July '12; May '13)

No longer can point with the requisite accuracy

It is now carrying out its “K2” mission

Relies on pressure from sunlight to serve as the “third wheel”and to balance the 'scope

Page 48: Earth 2.0: NASA's Search for Earth-size Planetsphysics.uwyo.edu/~aschwortz/LASSI/files/DDale.pdf · The Drake Equation N = R* · f p · n e · f l · f i · f c · L Where: • N

Image credit: NASA/W. Stenzel