Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty An ... · Early Years: Driving Quality and...
Transcript of Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty An ... · Early Years: Driving Quality and...
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty
An ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Image by Moatview Early Education Centre, Priorswood, Dublin
Learning Community Event Report
17 February 2016, Dublin Castle, Dublin, Ireland
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 2 of 24
Acknowledgements
The authors of this report are indebted to the members of the ABC Learning Community Planning Group for their
contribution to the planning and organising of this ABC Learning Community Event. The Planning Group was
supported by Early Years Mentors from across the ABC Areas in planning and co-ordinating this event. A special
thanks to Kimberly Kendall from the Centre for Effective Services for her role in organising the event and supporting
the Planning Group in preparation for the day.
The ABC Learning Community Planning Group is grateful to all contributors and attendees for taking the time to
prepare for, travel to and engage in the event. The Planning Group would also like to thank the funders of the ABC
Programme, the Department of Children and Youth Affairs and The Atlantic Philanthropies, without whom the work
would not be possible.
This report was compiled by Ciaran O’Donnell, Dr Aisling Sheehan and Dr John Bamber from the Centre for Effective Services.
Contents
Background and Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 3
Programme ....................................................................................................................................................................... 4
Welcome and Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 4
The Impact of Poverty on Children’s Outcomes in the Early Years ........................................................................... 5
Improving Quality in Early Years Settings in Areas Experiencing Disadvantage ....................................................... 6
Policy Developments to Support Early Years Practice .............................................................................................. 7
The Local Experience of Early Years Practice in the ABC Programme....................................................................... 8
Panel Discussion .............................................................................................................................................................. 11
Breakout and Closing Sessions ........................................................................................................................................ 12
Participant Feedback – Key Quotes ................................................................................................................................ 15
Appendix A: Members of ABC Learning Community Planning Group ............................................................................ 16
Appendix B: Programme ................................................................................................................................................. 17
Appendix C: Attendees.................................................................................................................................................... 18
Appendix D: Biographies of Contributors ....................................................................................................................... 21
Appendix E: Early Years Supports Across the ABC Programme Areas ............................................................................ 23
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 3 of 24
Background and Introduction
The Area Based Childhood (ABC) Programme
The Area Based Childhood (ABC) Programme is a prevention and early intervention initiative targeting investment in
effective services to improve outcomes for children and families living in areas of disadvantage. It is funded by the
Department of Children and Youth Affairs (DCYA) and the Atlantic Philanthropies, with a total investment of almost
€30 million between 2013 and 2017. The ABC Programme is being delivered in 13 areas of disadvantage in Ireland.
For further information on the ABC Programme, visit here.
The ABC Learning Community
The ABC Learning Community provides a platform for ABC areas and stakeholders in the ABC Programme to share
learning, knowledge and practice, and to support one another to deliver effective and integrated services. It aims to:
Connect individuals, agencies and organisations within and across ABC areas;
Provide a forum for information sharing, peer support and self-reflection; and
Disseminate collective learning from the ABC Programme and influence national policy and practice.
The ABC Learning Community Planning Group assists the ABC Learning Community to meet the needs of its
members. This Group includes representatives from both the ABC areas and the programme management
organisations, Pobal and the Centre for Effective Services (CES). It determines the structure of Learning Community
events around identified themes. Themes explored to date include oral language, leveraging, and quality early years
practice. The Planning Group was supported by Early Years Mentors from across the ABC areas in planning and co-
ordinating this event. For a list of all those involved in planning the event, please see Appendix A.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC early Years Practice to Policy Event
The fourth ABC Learning Community Event was held in Dublin Castle on 17th February 2016. The event was entitled
‘Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC early Years Practice to Policy Event’ and comprised
keynote speakers, a panel discussion, and afternoon workshop sessions. The full programme is outlined in Appendix
B. Overall, the day considered the need to enhance and empower the Early Years sector in Ireland, with equal
attention to quality, sustainability and development issues. There were 111 attendees, including staff and
representatives from ABC areas and a wide range of stakeholders (see Appendix C for a full list of attendees).
The presentations for the day’s proceedings can be found here.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 4 of 24
Programme
Welcome and Introduction
The event was opened by two representatives from the planning group for the event, Eleanor McClorey, CEO of
youngballymun and Laura Dagger, Early Years Mentor of the Blue Skies Initiative in Clondalkin. The speakers
welcomed participants and provided an overview of the theme of the event on driving quality and challenging
poverty in the Early Years. They outlined how the purpose of event was to explore this theme from the perspectives
of research, policy and practice and to share and discuss practice learning. Eleanor and Laura introduced the
programme and the keynote speakers (see Appendix D for speaker biographies).
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 5 of 24
The Impact of Poverty on Children’s Outcomes in the Early Years
Dr Dorothy Watson, Associate Professor, the Economic and Social Research Institute
Dr Watson highlighted the importance of the topic of child poverty and its
effects on children’s wellbeing and future outcomes. She examined the
consequences of the recent financial recession on children’s development,
drawing on data on over 17,000 families who participated in the Growing Up in
Ireland Survey (GUI). GUI is an Irish study of families with children and data has
been collected at multiple points of time since 2008.
Dr Watson defined people as ‘economically vulnerable’ (EV) if they were living in
families with low income, household joblessness and economic stress. EV
increased for families during the recession. Between 2008 and 2011, EV rose
from between 15-19% to 25%. Risk factors for EV included lone parent families, larger families, cohabiting vs.
married couples, low maternal education, and younger age of mother. Those becoming EV during the recession were
a broader group with more married couples and parents with higher levels of education. Families that were
particularly affected by the recession were working-age families at risk of job loss, home purchasers who bought at
the ‘peak’ of the boom, business starters, and households at the family formation stage.
Dr Watson examined the impact of EV on children’s socio-emotional development. She defined socio-emotional
problems as including emotional or conduct problems, hyperactivity or inattention, and problems in relationships
with peers. EV was associated with a higher risk of social-emotional problems for both boys and girls. Children were
less likely to have socio-emotional problems if their mother was in their 30s at the time of birth, if their mother was
not emotionally distressed, or if there was a good relationship between parents in couple families.
In concluding, Dr Watson highlighted the implications of the research findings. As a result of the recession, a broader
group of children are economically vulnerable in Ireland. There is a need for policy to find the optimal mix of income
support, education, training and support for employment. Child care is particularly important for lone parent
families, and interventions being implemented need to enhance protective factors for Irish families, such as mental
well-being and family relationships.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 6 of 24
Improving Quality in Early Years Settings in Areas Experiencing Disadvantage
Professor Nóirín Hayes, Visiting Professor, Trinity College Dublin
Drawing from research, practice and policy, Professor Hayes identified the role
that Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) plays in child development and
learning and explored how to improve and support quality early years services to
enhance child development. Definitions and language differ yet ECEC is
internationally recognised as the first stage of education. Professor Hayes
described quality as a ‘mercurial’ concept and presented a range of definitions.
The European Quality Framework (2014) describes the following components of
quality: Accessibility, Workforce, Curriculum, Monitoring and Governance.
The role of quality ECEC in promoting child development and reducing
inequalities was recognised by the 2015 Report of the Inter-Departmental
Working Group: Future Investment in Childcare in Ireland. It was questioned whether the broad range of
expectations of early education (economic, social, and educational) was unrealistic. Early education is not a magic
bullet and cannot function in isolation. Greater investment in services is also needed to support the development of
quality services. Investment in ECEC in Ireland is between 0.2-0.4%, whereas the OECD average is 0.8%.
Drawing from research on ECEC and child development, Professor Hayes demonstrated that children from age 2
benefit from ECEC and that the quality and duration of ECEC matters. She also outlined the most important factors
for quality, effective early years for children. Babies and young children benefit most when relationships with babies
and young children occur within stable, caring and interactive learning environments. Interactions are critical spaces
for learning and must be positive and occur on a fairly regular basis over extended periods of time. Everyday
intentional interactions and play are hugely important for healthy brain development. The quality of these early
experiences can determine how sturdy or fragile the foundations are for learning and behaviour over time.
The Effective Provision of Preschool Education (EPPE) study
identified a number of key factors in effective ECEC practices and
that a common feature of successful programmes was the quality of
staff: well trained, motivated, and clear in their purpose. Staff
investment is therefore critical. Professor Hayes outlined a number
of things currently supporting quality (see right). She also highlighted
a number of challenges including a lack of implementation strategy
for frameworks, no strategic investment in training for staff, no
career or professional structure, insufficient funding to facilitate on-
site quality supports, and increased inspection and administration.
She called upon the ABC Learning Community to harness collective
energy to share and strengthen sectoral learning.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 7 of 24
Policy Developments to Support Early Years Practice
Ms Bernie McNally, Assistant Secretary General, DCYA
Ms McNally presented on the recent and upcoming policy developments to support
early years practice in Ireland. Recent policy developments include:
• Better Outcomes Brighter Futures: The national policy framework for children
and young people 2014-2020
• The Inter-Departmental Group Report on Future Investment in Childcare
• The Inter-Departmental Group Report on Supporting Access to Early Childhood
Care and Education for Children with a Disability
A model to support access to the Free Pre-School Year for children with disabilities and
the Early Years Strategy are currently under development (information now available
here).
Ms McNally acknowledged the need to increase investment in early years and highlighted the increase of
government spending in 2015-2016 of over €85 million euro. The growth in funding expands the reach of investment
to include:
• Extending the ECCE free pre-school year into a second year, allowing children to benefit from an average of
61 weeks, up from the current 38 week entitlement
• Supports for children with disabilities
• Investments in quality, through the Learner Fund, Inspections, Síolta Activity and Audits
• 37% increase of low cost childcare places from 35,000 to 48,000
• Investment in after-school services through capitation, consultations and standards.
She also explored how current and future investment in supporting early years practice aligned with the five
components of quality identified by the European Quality Framework (2014) (see below). The presentation also
considered imminent policy shapers of early years practice in Ireland including the ABC Programme, the Quality and
Capacity Building Initiative (QCBI) currently being developed by DCYA, and the Review of the Delivering Equality of
Opportunity in our Schools (DEIS) Programme being conducted by the Department of Education and Skills. Ms
McNally acknowledged the meaningful contribution that attendees could make to informing policy development and
called upon attendees to consider developing practical recommendations that would support quality early years
practice.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 8 of 24
The Local Experience of Early Years Practice in the ABC Programme
Three practitioners presented on their work within the early years ABC Programme, representing Early Year
mentors, managers and front-line practitioners. This presentation showcased the variety of initiatives operating in
the ABC Programme, and how quality early years practice is being developed for those involved.
Ms Sharon Byrne, Early Years Mentor, Better Finglas
Ms Byrne presented on the work of Early Years Mentors across ABC areas which
includes onsite mentoring in early years settings, interagency initiatives, parenting
supports, training and development, and speech and language supports (see slide
below). In total, ABC areas are working with 144 settings, 1,235 practitioners and
6,528 children. The work of the Mentors is supported and guided by Aistear and
Síolta, our National Early Childhood Frameworks. For more details, see Appendix E.
She highlighted research evidence that tells us that the quality of early childhood
education and care has a direct impact on the developmental outcomes of children,
and this is particularly true for children experiencing disadvantage. Mentoring and
training supports for early years professionals working in disadvantaged areas can
enhance the quality of early years experiences for children in these settings. While mentoring is not a new concept,
the introduction of formal mentoring within the early years sector is a recent development. The EU report on
Competence Requirements in Early Childhood Education and Care (2011) recognises ‘continuous pedagogical
support’ as a means of improving the competence of teams working with young children.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 9 of 24
Ms Kelda Barnes, Manager, Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service Ltd., Preparing for Life
Kelda Barnes manages the Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service, known
as Jigsaw, which is the largest community childcare setting in Ireland, providing full
and part-time places for 260 children and employing 95 staff. The service receives
support from Preparing for Life in Northside Partnership. The ABC early years team
which includes a programme manager, quality mentor and speech and language
therapist, provides a professional development programme which includes
training, mentoring and on-site support. In collaboration with Preparing for Life,
Jigsaw has:
• Completed the Síolta Quality assurance process and achieved Validation
• Accessed training for all staff members to use Aistear’s planning and
assessment tools, to deliver an emergent and inquiry-based curriculum
• Availed of financial support for practitioners completing Early Childhood Education degrees
• Reviewed, adapted and improved the learning environment, indoors and out
• Created a Curriculum Statement, which is reviewed annually
• Fostered links and developed relationships with other local EY centres, staff and managers
• Improved their practice to address children’s oral language needs by participating in HanenTM training and
having access to a speech and language therapist
• Participated in leadership training and mentoring for senior staff
• Improved staff confidence and capacity.
Ms Barnes also highlighted some of the ongoing challenges in participating in these supports, including the demands
on time for staff and financial sustainability (see slide below).
The presentation ended with a short video featured on the Aistear Síolta Practice Guide website which demonstrates
the work of the service in action, focusing on facilitating children to learn new vocabulary. The video can be viewed
here.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 10 of 24
Ms Karen Barrett, Key Worker, St Margaret’s Pre-School, youngballymun
Ms Barrett is a Key Worker with St. Margaret’s Traveller Pre-School in Ballymun, an
early years service with 24 children aged between 2½-5 years and six members of
staff. She spoke about her experiences as an early years practitioner receiving a
range of professional development supports from youngballymun, including
training and mentoring in High Scope, HanenTM, infant mental health, Aistear, and
mentoring support through the Síolta Quality Assurance Programme.
Ms Barret highlighted the wider benefits such as being more integrated with other
local practitioners and organisations like schools and HSE services. She also
reported better teamwork among staff, with greater clarity of roles and
responsibilities, improved communication, and strong leadership. She and her
colleagues have developed better relationships with parents and have introduced a key worker system which has
enhanced communication with parents. The following professional and personal impacts were also highlighted:
• Child-led instead of teacher-led, leading to reduction in conflict
• More tuned into children's needs and interests
• More confident as a professional and less stress
• Enhanced engagement in observation and feedback
• Ongoing training and development
The supports have led to many improvements including in the learning environment, as demonstrated below.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 11 of 24
Panel Discussion
The panel discussion was chaired by Toby Wolfe, Policy and Research Officer with Startstrong. This session allowed the audience members to pose questions to the speakers and to share ideas in response to the previous presentations. A number of questions were asked and discussed by the panel:
How do early years supports tackle child poverty?
The impact of early years supports provided under the ABC Programme on child poverty was queried. Dr Watson
said that by adopting an area-based approach in pockets of disadvantage, other people experiencing poverty will not
be reached. She noted that the work of ABC areas are exemplars of best practice in early years settings and can be
effective in improving child development, which may have effects on poverty later in life; they cannot act as a
substitute for an anti-poverty strategy. Professor Hayes said that the work of ABC areas can have an indirect effect
on child poverty and that there is evidence that ABC areas are working with hard-to-reach families. She noted that
ECEC supports alone are insufficient and that they need to be embedded into a cohesive, supportive system.
How do early years supports challenge transgenerational issues?
The transgenerational influence of early years educaton on environmental issues was raised and it was queried
whether the national frameworks (Aistear and Síolta) could be developed to address this. Professor Hayes said that
Aistear and Síolta are very positive developments but are now perhaps due for revision and that this is something
that could be considered. Ms Byrne noted that the High Scope curriculum has a section on ecology and environment.
Could the DEIS initiative be extended to include early years settings?
The potential for the Department of Education and Skill’s DEIS initiative to be extended to include early years
settings was questioned. Ms McNally said that the current review of the DEIS initiative provides an opportunity to
put further spotight on ECEC and that the ABC programme should inform the review process. Professor Hayes noted
that there are children who do not live in disadvantaged areas that are disadvantaged, but that the idea of clusters
of targeted supports is positive. Ms Byrne added that an opportunity to have smaller ratios of staff to children in
ECEC settings, as is the case in schools under the DEIS initiative, would be a positive development.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 12 of 24
Breakout and Closing Sessions
Breakout Sessions
During the breakout sessions, small group discussions were facilitated on the following themes:
Improving Professional Standing
Policy Context
Building Capacity
Quality Representatives from five ABC areas facilitated the breakout sessions:
Catherine O’Brien, Joanne Murphy, Maria O’Dwyer, Marie Cuddihy, and Fiona Hassett. Each group discussed and
recorded key messages. The facilitators from each session then presented the key findings to all attendees in the
closing session.
Conclusion and feedback
Dr Aisling Sheehan, Project Specialist, Centre for Effective Services
Dr Sheehan concluded the Learning Community Event by inviting each of the five facilitators to the stage and
discussing the learning from each session. In doing so, the learning generated on the day was shared, with a focus on
identifying key messages around professional standing, policy, building capacity and quality. Notes from the
breakout sessions were used to supplement the key messages shared on the day and these messages are
summarised below.
Improving Professional Standing
Learning:
The morale and professional standing of early years practitioners is low and efforts towards the professionalisation
of the workforce through the introduction of minimum qualifications, the Learner Fund, and continuous professional
development (CPD) opportunities are welcomed. Professional development opportunities afforded through
initiatives such as the ABC Programme and Better Start including training, needs-based mentoring supports and the
development of peer learning fora empower the workforce to deliver better quality provision for children. Key
challenges facing services are the poor salaries and terms and conditions of staff, turnover of staff, low self-belief of
staff in their professional roles, and the lack of resources to release staff to engage in professional development
opportunities. Many staff have to engage in professional development outside of work hours and work/life balance
can be out of kilter.
Recommendations:
Introduce five mandatory and fully funded days of CPD, linked to the Aistear and Síolta frameworks
Develop a national standardised approach to training and CPD, with consistency in the following: training
content and delivery, quality standards, and self-reflective practices
Gather data on types of CPD being rolled out and share good practice to inform a national CPD approach
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 13 of 24
Roll out leadership training to build confidence and capacity and assign leadership roles to permanent staff,
e.g. communication champion
Develop a professional registration system for the early years workforce, linked to quality and recognised
CPD (and consistent pay scales down the line)
Develop consistent terminology for the sector and the professional role of early years workers
Policy Context
Learning:
Policy direction outlined in Better Outcomes, Brighter Futures and recent reports by Inter-Departmental Groups on
investing in childcare and accessing ECEC for children with a disability are positive developments. Structures to
support the implementation of joined-up working including Children and Young People’s Services Committees and
Meitheal are also welcomed. Whilst these polices and structures exist, better communication is needed on these
developments with frontline services and parents. More policy focus is also needed in early childhood and joined-up
thinking and planning is needed so that there is coherent strategic policy. Clarity is also needed on whether policy is
driven by concerns with child development or parental employment. Some developments have been fragmented,
e.g. training opportunities require services to close, but contracts with Pobal do not allow for this. In addition, the
introduction of the free pre-school year has led to a move of more qualified staff from infant and toddler rooms to
working with pre-schoolers, introducing a risk that the 0-3s cohort is neglected. Developments should be more
joined-up and driven by evidence on what supports quality practice, rather than economic factors. More policy
attention is needed for addressing resource deficits and requirements for accessing special needs services.
Recommendations:
Deliver on the forthcoming Early Years Strategy
Provide adequate resources to implement policy commitments and commit to longer-term investments to
enable the embedding of practices and future sustainability of the work
Meaningful consultation and partnerships between parents, children, practitioners and policy-makers key to
developing a supportive policy context
Building Capacity
Learning:
Learning focused on building the capacity of staff, services and boards. In relation to staff and services, it was
considered that professional development opportunities provided by the ABC Programme were valuable and
replicable in other disadvantaged communities. The experience of practitioners who have both delivered and
received mentoring supports is that it builds the confidence and self-esteem of staff, leading to a more empowered
and skilful workforce. We need to “ask more about the workforce, not ask more of them” and put the resources in
place to build their capacity and provide them with a voice. Regarding the capacity of boards, challenges highlighted
were difficulty in identifying people with the right specialisms, getting a gender balance, getting state/political
representation, particularly in rural areas, and a focus on operational rather than quality issues. A general key
learning identified was that the principles of community development needed to be married with attention to
quality, and not dilute one in favour of the other.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 14 of 24
Recommendations:
Provide training for boards to build relevant expertise and skills required and training for managers to build
their capacity to support boards
Review the title of early years workers so that it encompasses an education focus (e.g. early childhood
educator), whilst not losing the ‘care’ aspect of the role
Ensure that a focus on the 0-3s cohort is maintained and that capacity-building efforts for staff are not solely
focused on the pre-school age
Ensure capacity-building supports, such as mentoring, are accessible across the country and are provided
with consistency in approach, delivery and message
Quality
Through access to initiatives such as the ABC Programme, staff is developing expertise and skills for delivering a high
quality service for children. An important aspect of quality improvements identified was having access to and
working with speech and language therapists, who build the capacity of early years workers to support children’s
development in speech, language and communication. Access to training and supports for reflective practice and the
delivery of evidence-based programmes also enable quality improvements. Challenges, some of which have already
been highlighted, include releasing staff to engage in training and supports, lack of resources, variable quality of
training provided through the Learner Fund, and a lack of professional body to oversee training. There is also
fragmentation in structures, funding, reporting and inspection. Engaging parents can be challenging and children
most in need may not be accessing the services.
Recommendations:
Provide services with ‘core’ funding, resources and capitation
Increase investments in supports for quality improvement
Provide access to County and City Childcare Committees on a national basis
Broaden the scope of the Learner Fund to access Levels 7 and 8 qualifications
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 15 of 24
Participant Feedback – Key Quotes
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 16 of 24
Appendix A: Members of ABC Learning Community Planning Group
The ABC Learning Community Planning Group assists the ABC Learning Community to meet the needs of its
members. The Planning Group includes representatives from both ABC areas and the programme management
organisations, Pobal and CES. The Group determines the structure of Learning Community events around identified
themes.
For this event, ‘Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC early years practice to policy
event’, the Planning Group was supported by Early Years Mentors from across the ABC areas.
The members of the ABC Learning Community Planning Group are:
Bernie Laverty (Ballyfermot/Chapelizod, Family Matters)
Eleanor McClorey (Ballymun, youngballymun)
Hugh Doogan (Louth, The Genesis Programme)
Katherine Harford (Cork, Young Knocknaheeney)
Mairéad Conroy (Dublin Docklands and East Inner City)
Mary Rose Costello (Bray, Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Rebecca Moore (Finglas, Better Finglas)
Margaret Cleary (Pobal)
John Bamber (Centre for Effective Services)
Aisling Sheehan (Centre for Effective Services)
Ciaran O’Donnell (Centre for Effective Services)
The Early Years Mentors who have assisted the Planning Group in organising this event are:
Aileen Kelleher (Limerick City, Start Right)
Claire Gleeson (Louth, The Genesis Programme)
Joanne Roe (Ballymun, youngballymun)
Laura Dagger (Clondalkin, Blue Skies Initiative)
Sandra O’Neill (Darndale, Preparing for Life)
Sharon Byrne (Finglas, Better Finglas)
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 17 of 24
Appendix B: Programme
9:30am Registration, Tea/coffee
10:30am
Welcome and introduction
Eleanor McClorey, CEO, youngballymun
Laura Dagger, Early Years Mentor, Clondalkin Blue Skies Initiative
10:45am The impact of poverty on children’s outcomes in the early years
Dr Dorothy Watson, Associate Professor, The Economic and Social Research Institute
11:05am Improving quality in early years settings in areas experiencing disadvantage
Professor Nóirín Hayes, Visiting Professor, Trinity College Dublin
11:25am Break
11:40am Policy developments to support early years practice
Bernie McNally, Assistant Secretary, Department of Children and Youth Affairs
12:00pm
The local experience of early years practice in the ABC Programme
Sharon Byrne, Early Years Mentor, Better Finglas
Kelda Barnes, Manager, Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service Ltd., Preparing for Life
Karen Barrett, Key Worker, St Margaret’s Pre-School, youngballymun
12:45pm
Panel discussion
Chair: Toby Wolfe, Policy and Research Officer, Start Strong
Dr Dorothy Watson, Associate Professor, The Economic and Social Research Institute
Professor Nóirín Hayes, Visiting Professor, Trinity College Dublin
Bernie McNally, Assistant Secretary, Department of Children and Youth Affairs
Sharon Byrne, Early Years Mentor, Better Finglas
1:15pm Lunch
2:00pm Breakout sessions
Driving quality and challenging poverty - implications for practice in the ABC Programme
Breakout Session 1
Facilitator: Catherine O'Brien, Childcare and Community Services Manager, Co-operative Housing Ireland (Docklands and East Inner City)
Breakout Session 2
Facilitator: Joanne Murphy, Co-ordinator, Louth Children and Young People’s Services Committee (Louth - The Genesis Programme)
Breakout Session 3
Facilitator: Maria O’ Dwyer, Project Manager, ABC Start Right (Limerick City)
Breakout Session 4
Facilitator: Marie Cuddihy, Development Officer (North Wicklow), Wicklow County Childcare Committee, (Bray - Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Breakout Session 5
Facilitator: Fiona Hassett, Local Childcare Resource Service Co-ordinator, Family Matters (Ballyfermot/Chapelizod)
3:20pm Close and feedback
John Bamber, Project Specialist, Centre for Effective Services
4:00pm Close
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 18 of 24
Appendix C: Attendees
Name Job Title Organisation
Adrianna Anene Home Visitor Parent Child Home Programme (PCHP)
Aileen Kelleher Early Years Co-ordinator Limerick City (Start Right)
Aileen O'Donoghue CEO Archways
Aine McNamara Consultant in Public Health Medicine Health Service Executive
Aisling Gillen National Specialist Family Support Tusla Child and Family Agency
Aisling Sheehan Project Specialist Centre for Effective Services
Alice Malone Quality Assurance Co-ordinator The Genesis Programme
Amanda McGann Supervisor Ballymun East Community Centre
Andrew Dineen Doodle Den Facilitator Doddle Den
Andrew Mulkeen Regional Development Co-ordinator Early Years and Young People, Pobal
Angela Kalaitzake Centre Manager Hollyhill / Knocknaheeny Family Centre, Cork
Ann Carrol Project Manager CASPr (Community After Schools Project)
Anne Farrington Autism Therapist Autism Services, Sligo
Anne O’Brien UpTo2 Project Worker Clondalkin (Blue Skies Initiative)
Arlene Forster Director, Curriculum and Assessment National Council for Curriculum and Assessment
Ashley Lawlor Co-ordinator St Ultan’s Nursery
Assumpta O'Neill Development Officer (South and West Wicklow)
Wicklow County Childcare Committee
Audra Hubbard Childminding Development Officer Dublin City Childcare Committee
Bernie Colman Parent Support Co-ordinator Fledglings, Kiltipper
Bernie Kelly Manager Our Lady’s Nursery Ballymun
Bernie Laverty Co-ordinator Family Matters Ballyfermot (Family Matters)
Bernie McNally Assistant Secretary Department of Children and Youth Affairs
Bernie Pentony Early Years Practitioner Early Start St John’s School, Drogheda
Betsy Burdis Manager Finglas Childcare Ltd.
Bronagh McGlade Development Officer Louth County Childcare Committee
Catherine Bond National Service Co-ordinator Better Start, Pobal
Catherine O’Brien Board of Management Páistí @ No.3 Childcare, Cork
Catherine O'Brien Childcare and Community Services Manager
Co-operative Housing Ireland
Cathie Lacey Manager Ballymun East Community Centre
Cathy Steenson Childcare Co-ordinator Little Treasures
Ciaran O'Donnell Graduate Intern Centre for Effective Services
Claire Devery Childcare Manager Ozanam Childcare
Claire Dooley SPECS Early Years Quality Mentor Bray (Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Claire Gleeson Development Officer (Early Years) The Genesis Programme
Claire Hickey Project Specialist Centre for Effective Services
Clare Kelliher Senior SLT Clondalkin (Blue Skies Initiative)
Conor Rowley Principal Officer, Policy Innovation Unit Department of Children and Youth Affairs
Deirdre O’Callaghan Childcare Manager Páistí @ No.3 Childcare, Cork
Deirdre Tobin Early Years Specialist Better Start, Pobal
Dr Dorothy Watson Associate Professor The Economic and Social Research Institute
Dr Josephine Bleach Director of Early Learning Initiative Early Learning Initiative
Duana Quigley Programme Manager youngballymun
Eibhlin Walsh Speech and Language Therapist Limerick City (Start Right)
Eimear Carron Co-ordinator Longford County Childcare Committee
Eimear Collins Business Support Officer Dublin City Childcare Committee
Eleanor McClorey CEO youngballymun
Elizabeth Canavan Assistant Secretary Department of Children and Youth Affairs
Emma Byrne Mac Namee Early Years Manager Darndale (Preparing for Life)
Fiona Hassett Local Childcare Resource Service Co-ordinator
Ballyfermot (Family Matters)
Francis Chance Programme Manager - Nurture Katharine Howard Foundation
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 19 of 24
Name Job Title Organisation
Genevieve Ruiz-O'Sullivan Research Assistant, ABC Evaluation Centre for Effective Services
Gonne Barry Assistant Director Public health Nursing Health Service Executive
Grainne Fagan Quality Support Officer Dublin City Childcare Committee
Gráinne Hartin Project Leader Ronanstown Community Childcare Centre
Hazel O’Byrne Policy Officer youngballymun
Heino Schonfeld Early Years Development Manager Barnardos
Hugh Doogan Programme Manager The Genesis Programme
Jackie Austin Assistant Director of Public Health Nursing Health Service Executive
Jeanne Ryan Support worker Limerick City (Start Right)
Jenna Russell Project Leader Barnardos, Cork
Jenny Eades Beneficiary Support Specialist Early Years and Young People, Pobal
Jessica Barrett Student Early Childhood Education and Care, IT Carlow
Joanne Murphy Co-ordinator Louth Children and Young People's Services Committee
Joanne Roe Early Years Quality Co-ordinator youngballymun
John Bamber Project Specialist Centre for Effective Services
Joyce Morris Room Assistant Padre Pio Early Start, Cork
Judith Brady Principal Officer Department of Public Expenditure and Reform
Julie McNamara CEO Kildare County Childcare Committee
June Hamill Centre Manager Before 5 Centre, Cork
Kaite Bartrand Childcare Manager CASPr (Community After Schools Project)
Karen Barrett Key Worker St Margaret's Pre-School
Karen Weafer Project Leader Fledglings City Quay
Kate Hayes Senior Speech and Language Therapist Limerick City (Start Right)
Katherine Harford Manager Young Knocknaheeny
Kelda Barnes Manager Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service Ltd.
Kimberley Kendall Project Support Centre for Effective Services
Laura Costelloe Lecturer National College of Ireland
Laura Dagger Early Years Mentor Clondalkin (Blue Skies Initiative)
Laura Fernandez Garcia Manager Stepping Stones Crèche, Drogheda
Laura Smullen Early Years Specialist Better Start, Pobal
Lesley Strahan Manager Lourdes Youth and Community Services
Lisa Kearns Manager Marian Pre-school, Bray
Lisa McMahon Manager Moatview Early Education Centre
Lisa O’Brien Crèche Leader Hollyhill / Knocknaheeny Family Centre, Cork
Liz Cronin Engagement and Support Worker Clondalkin (Blue Skies Initiative)
Lorraine Doherty Project Co-ordinator Clondalkin (Blue Skies Initiative)
Lorraine Kavanagh Social Policy and Public Service Reform Department of the Taoiseach
Louise Mc Guirk Farrell Manager Doras Bui Childcare
Lucy Connolly Early Years Mentor Young Knocknaheeny
Mairéad Conroy Early Years Mentor Early Learning Initiative
Maresa Duignan Early Year Policy Unit Department of Education and Skills
Margaret Cleary Regional Development Co-ordinator Early Years and Young People, Pobal
Marguerite Buckley Room Assistant Padre Pio Early Start, Cork
Maria Hayes Principal Social Worker Tusla, the Child and Family Agency
Maria O'Dwyer Project Manager Limerick City (Start Right)
Marianne Healy Director Public Health Nursing Health Service Executive
Marie Cuddihy Development Officer (North Wicklow) Wicklow County Childcare Committee
Marie Kennedy SPECS Support and Development worker Bray (Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Marion Byrne 0-2 Co-ordinator Early Learning Initiative
Mark Shinnick Principal Holy Child Preschool, Rutland St
Mary Barry Childcare Manager Before 5 Centre, Cork
Mary Dolan Development Officer Tallaght West Childhood Development Initiative Ltd (TWCDI)
Mary Reilly Manager Marian Pre-school, Bray
Mary Rose Costello SPECS Co-ordinator Bray (Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Melissa Murtagh Speech and Language Therapist Limerick City (Start Right)
Michèle Relihan Manager Dún Laoghaire/Rathdown County Childcare Committee
Michelle O'Doherty Manager Childworld Crèche
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 20 of 24
Name Job Title Organisation
Miriam Farrell Assistant Manager Fledglings, St.Mary's, City Quay
Nicola Miller Early Years Educator Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service (Jigsaw)
Noel Kelly Programme Manager Darndale (Preparing for Life)
Noirin Coghlan Manager Poppintree Early Education Centre
Petra Hanlon Administrator Grangegorman (Vision Beyond Poverty)
Professor Nóirín Hayes Visiting Professor Trinity College Dublin
Rachel Ivie Early Years Educator Doras Bui Childcare
Regina Clarke Home School Liaison Officer Early Start St John’s School, Drogheda
Sandra Collins Early Years Specialist Better Start, Pobal
Sandra O'Neill Early Years Mentor Darndale (Preparing for Life)
Sarah Davis Preparing for Life Better Finglas
Sharon Byrne Early Years Mentor Better Finglas
Sharon Doran Manager St John’s Preschool
Síle Hassett Childcare Manager Deansrath Family Centre
Sinead Crowley Team Leader Sligo Social Service Council Ltd
Sinead Elliffe Classroom Teacher Padre Pio Early Start, Cork
Siobhan Duffy Manager Lios na Nóg Crèche, Dundalk
Siobhan Greene Assistant Director Barnardos
Siobhan Keegan National Service Co-ordinator Better Start, Pobal
Stefanie Dawick Doodle Den Facilitator Doodle Den
Stella Owens Project Specialist Centre for Effective Services
Sue Menton Care Manager St Ultan’s
Suzanne Hesnan Crèche Manager Familibase
Teresa Grant Manager Fundayz Community Childcare Centre, Bray
Teresa Heeney CEO Early Childhood Ireland
Toby Wolfe Policy and Research Officer Start Strong
Tracey Beaufong Student Early Childhood Education and Care, IT Carlow
Triona Rooney Speech and Language Therapist Darndale (Preparing for Life)
Úna Caffrey Child Protection & Information Officer Fingal County Childcare Committee
Wendy Hoey Early Years Practitioner Lios na Nóg Crèche, Dundalk
Wendy Walsh Manager St. Margaret's Pre-School
Yuk-kuen Cheung Early Years Educator Moatview Early Education Centre
Yvonne Galvin Manager King’s Island Crèche
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 21 of 24
Appendix D: Biographies of Contributors
Dr Dorothy Watson, Associate Professor, The Economic and Social Research Institute
Dorothy Watson is an Associate Research Professor at the Economic and Social Research Institute. She received a
Bachelor's degree in Social Science from University College Cork; and her MSc and PhD (both in sociology) from the
University of Wisconsin, Madison. She was a Research Fellow of the ESRI from 1983 to 1986. Her areas of interest
are Social Inclusion, Equality, Quality of Life, Values and Belief Systems and Survey Methodology. As well as
managing several large-scale national surveys (including the ECHP in Ireland and SLÁN 2007), she has worked with
international colleagues on a number of projects, including the ESeC consortium to develop and validate a European
measure of social class and the EQUALSOC network. She is joint co-ordinator of the programme of research on Social
Inclusion and Equality. Her current research projects include work on the measurement of poverty in an Irish and
international context, mental health disability, childhood economic vulnerability and welfare regimes and quality of
life in Europe.
Professor Nóirín Hayes, Visiting Professor, Trinity College Dublin
Professor Nóirín Hayes is a developmental psychologist. She is Visiting Professor at the School of Education, Trinity
College Dublin and maintains her affiliation to the Dublin Institute of Technology, through the Centre for Social and
Educational Research. Her specialist field is child development and learning, with particular interest in early
childhood development, educational wellbeing, pedagogy, and children's rights. She has an active research portfolio
working with postgraduate students and researchers and is convener of the Researching Early Childhood Education
Collaborative [www.ealignment.ie]. She is the author of a number of books, reports and research articles on practice
and policy and her most recent book is Early Years Practice: Getting It Right from the Start (Gill and Macmillan,
2013). She has served on a number of government working groups, commissions and advisory groups including the
National Early Years Strategy Expert Advisory Group. Professor Hayes is a founder member of the Children’s Rights
Alliance, a past member of the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment and a board member Start Strong
and. She is a patron and past Chair of OMEP (World Organisation for Early Education) Ireland.
Ms Bernie McNally, Assistant Secretary General, Department of Children and Youth Affairs
Bernie McNally joined the Dept of Children and Youth Affairs in April 2015 as Assistant Secretary General. She has
lead responsibility for Early Years Care and Education, Youth Affairs, and Research and Participation. Prior to this she
was Director General of the Office of the Ombudsman (incorporating the Office of the Information Commissioner
and the Secretariat to the Standards in Public Office Commission (SIPOC) and the Commission for Public Service
Appointments). In her earlier career, Bernie worked as an Occupational Therapist in Ireland, the UK and the USA and
was later a Director of Therapy and Social Work services in St. James's Hospital, Dublin. Bernie was employed as an
Advisor on Therapy services in the Department of Health and Children from 2004 to 2008. She gained her BSc and
MSc from Trinity College Dublin and completed a graduate Leadership Program with the University of Limerick and
the Office for Health Management.
Ms Sharon Byrne, Early Years Mentor, Better Finglas
Sharon Byrne is an early years mentor with the Better Finglas ABC Programme. For almost 20 years Sharon managed
early years’ settings in the community sector and is also an experienced High Scope practitioner. She is a qualified
trainer and has delivered early years and parenting training. Sharon holds a degree in Early Childhood Care and
Education and is currently completing a Masters in Child, Family and Community Studies.
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 22 of 24
Ms Kelda Barnes, Manager, Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service Ltd., Preparing for Life
Kelda Barnes has been the manager of Darndale Belcamp Integrated Childcare Service since March 2002. Kelda’s
background is in the disability, childcare and community sectors, where she has worked for numerous organisations
in the US and here in Ireland. Previously she has held positions in the Daughters of Charity, St. Michael’s House and
with private childcare providers. Kelda holds a degree in Social Science and a post-graduate diploma in Nursery
Management, both from University College Dublin.
Ms Karen Barrett, Key Worker, St Margaret’s Pre-School, youngballymun
Karen Barrett works as an Early Years Educator in St. Margaret’s Traveller Pre-School in Ballymun. She has been
working in the Early Years sector for the past eight years and her experience is largely in community based childcare
settings. Karen is a proud Mother of two young children. She has completed her FETAC Level 5 & Level 6 Childcare
training. Karen has worked in her current position since 2011 and has been receiving mentoring, training and
coaching supports from youngballymun since then. Through engagement with the Learning Years programme Karen
has completed a range of training including Pre-School High Scope, Health and Safety, HANEN, Child Protection,
Primary Food Hygiene, Aistear and has just begun training in the High Scope Infant & Toddler curriculum. Karen is
very proud of being part of the St. Margaret’s team who successfully completed the formal Síolta Quality Assurance
Process (QAP) in 2015 and the Pre-School has been validated as providing ‘extensive evidence of quality’.
Mr Toby Wolfe, Policy and Research Officer, Start Strong
Toby Wolfe is the Policy and Research Officer at Start Strong, a national advocacy organisation campaigning for
children’s early care and education. He was a member of the Expert Advisory Group on Ireland’s National Early Years
Strategy and also the Co-Chair of Eurochild’s thematic working group on early years education. Prior to joining Start
Strong in 2009, he worked at Pobal. His background is in economics and social policy analysis.
Breakout Session Facilitators
Catherine O’Brien, Childcare and Community Services Manager, Co-operative Housing Ireland (Docklands
and East Inner City Dublin)
Joanne Murphy, Co-ordinator, Louth Children and Young People’s Service Committee (Louth – The Genesis
Programme)
Maria O’Dwyer, Project Manager, ABC Start Right (Limerick City)
Marie Cuddihy, Development Officer for North Wicklow, Wicklow County Childcare Committee, (Bray –
Supporting Parents and Early Childhood Services)
Fiona Hassett, Local Childcare Resource Service Co-ordinator, Family Matters (Ballyfermot/Chapelizod)
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 23 of 24
Appendix E: Early Years Supports Across the ABC Programme Areas
Project Name Geographical
Area Programme Contact Details
Better Finglas 01-864-2941 www.betterfinglas.org
Finglas, Dublin
Onsite mentoring in early years settings using the Aistear Siolta Practice Guide
High Scope curriculum training
Transitions from preschool to primary school programme
The facilitation of referral pathways for children attending early years settings
Sharon Byrne Early Years Mentor [email protected] 086-466-5112
Blue Skies Initiative 01-456-8734 www.blueskiesinitiative.ie
Clondalkin, Dublin
Professional development for early years practitioners to use Aistear/Síolta Self-Audit Tools
ECERS Assessments, feedback and action planning
HighScope Curriculum Training
Training and mentoring for practitioners in Incredible Years Dina Classroom and Small Group programme
Incredible Years Basic Parenting Facilitator Training
Parental support in Early Years services
Early Years Transitions programme
On Site Mentoring and Coaching
Speech and Language Therapy Model
Universal oral language supports
Laura Dagger Early Years Mentor [email protected] 087-962-5774
CDI Tallaght 01-494-0030 www.twcdi.ie
Tallaght, Dublin Parental support in Early Years services
Speech and Language Therapy Model
Mary Dolan [email protected] 01-494-0030
Michelle Quinn [email protected] 085-801-5069
Early Learning Initiative In NCI 1850-221-721 www.ncirl.ie/ELI
Dublin Docklands
ABC 0-2 Years Programme Marion Byrne [email protected]
Supporting quality improvement in early years settings through the implementation of Aistear and Síolta.
Early Years Numeracy Programme
Mairead Conroy Early Years Coordinator [email protected]
Parent Child Home Programme Beth Fagan [email protected]
Doodle Den
Zoom Ahead with Books
Restorative Practice
Emma Wheatley [email protected]
Family Matters Ballyfermot and Chaplelizod Partnership 01-623-8088
Ballyfermot, Dublin
Oral Language Programmes to Early Years and Primary Schools
1:1 Speech and Language Intervention – Targeted
Chatter Matters Programme
Upskilling, Coaching and Mentoring Early Years Practitioners and Primary Schools in Oral Language Strategies
Elklan Training
Roisin Cotter Senior SLT [email protected]
Caitriona O’Mahony Senior SLT [email protected]
ABC Grangegorman 01-402-7628 www.dit.ie
Grangegorman (DIT), Dublin 7
Incredible Years Small Group Dina Programme in ECCE settings
Professional development for early years practitioners to use Aistear/Siolta self-audit tools
Professional development for early years practitioners
Petra Hanlon Administrator [email protected] 01-402-7628
Preparing for Life 01-877-1509 www.preparingforlife.ie
Dublin 5 and 17
Strengthening Foundations of Learning
Training and on-site mentoring for early years practitioners, to enhance the quality of early learning experiences and improve outcomes for children
Language development using Hanen’s Learning Language and Loving It, linked with Aistear
Oral language programme, linked with Aistear
Accredited leadership training for managers and senior practitioners
Curriculum support and development using Aistear, the Early Childhood Curriculum Framework
Transition to school programme
Sandra O’Neill Early Years Quality Mentor [email protected]
Triona Rooney Speech and Language Therapist [email protected]
Emma Byrne Mac Namee Early Years Programme Manager [email protected]
Early Years: Driving Quality and Challenging Poverty, an ABC Early Years Practice to Policy Event
Page 24 of 24
Project Name Geographical
Area Programme Contact Details
SPECS (Bray) www.specsbray.com 01-211-6481
Bray, Co. Wicklow
Early Years Quality Mentoring programme
Training using the Aistear Síolta Practice guide
Transition from preschool to school programme
Claire Dooley Early Years Mentor [email protected]
ABC Start Right www.paulpartnership.ie
Limerick
Incredible Years Classroom Dina Programme in Preschools
Quality Early Years
Transition programme
Aileen Kelleher Early Years Coordinator [email protected] 087-439-0800
Little Voices Oral Language Programme
Kate Hayes Oral Language Coordinator ABC Start Right [email protected] 087-439-0802
Community Wraparound
Marie Boyle & Brenda Mellett Community Wraparound Co-ordinators [email protected] [email protected] 087-439-0804
The Genesis Programme 041-984-3333 www.genesislouth.ie
Louth (Drogheda & Dundalk)
Incredible Years Training for Classroom Dina Programme in Early Years settings
Incredible Beginnings training programme for Early Years professionals
Professional development for early years practitioners to use Aistear/Síolta Self-Audit Tools alongside the Incredible Beginnings programme
Onsite support to Incredible Years Group Leaders
Peer coach support to Incredible Years group leaders to ensure programme fidelity
Development of resources linking the Incredible Years programmes to the Aistear/Siolta Frameworks
Claire Gleeson Development Officer (Early Years Programmes) [email protected] 083-152-9792
Youngballymun 01-883-2176 www.youngballymun.org
Ballymun, Dublin
Learning Years Support Service providing Integrated and tailored training; coaching; mentoring and quality development service for early years centres to support implementation of National Quality and Curriculum frameworks Síolta and Aistear and implementation of High Scope Infant/Toddler and Pre-School Curriculum
Joanne Roe Early Years Quality co-ordinator [email protected] 087-657-6641
Young Knocknaheeny www.youngknocknaheeny.ie
Knocknaheeny, Hollyhill, Gurranabraher, Churchfield, Cork
A Community of Early Years settings driving an ongoing evidence informed quality improvement strategy
Beginning and ending with ECERS and ITERS
Pre and Post Preschool year Santa Barbara School Readiness scale
Highscope curriculum training
On Site specialist mentoring
Aistear Implementation Framework
Enhancement of Oral Language skills and language rich environments
Environmental enhancement equipment
Transition supports in and out of settings for children and parents
Promotion of Early Years Increased Parental Engagement
Centre Co-ordinators peer Group
Young Knocknaheeny Early Years Implementation Group
Professional supervision to mentor
Co-ordination with other key Young Knocknaheeny strands
Katherine Harford Programme Manager Young Knocknaheeny
Jenna Russell Early Years Centres Co-ordinator Young Knocknaheeny
Lucy Connelly Early Years Mentor [email protected]