Driving Value Through Category Managementmanagement through SAP Ariba Supplier management Reverse...
Transcript of Driving Value Through Category Managementmanagement through SAP Ariba Supplier management Reverse...
Driving Value Through Category Management
1
Pre - 2015
Tasnee Procurement has evolved over a period of time to reach to
excellence and sustainability
2
2015
▪ Tactical Procurement▪ Contract administration▪ Price based supplier
selection
▪ Category management▪ Spend visibility▪ Contract management▪ Buying consortia▪ Track & trace tool▪ Org. effectiveness
- Business Partner- Center of
Excellence (CoE)- Sourcing
committees
▪ Contract life cycle management through SAP Ariba
▪ Supplier management▪ Reverse auctions▪ Local content▪ Value based supplier selection▪ Supply risk management (BCP)▪ Digitalization
2018 & beyond
▪ Diagnosed & baselined current processes & spend
▪ Designed target state processes
▪ Analyzed current contracts
▪ Profiled current and potential suppliers
▪ Identified quick wins
▪ Further engaged users and suppliers to develop and refine improvement ideas
▪ Created category based organizational structure across levels to maximize value creation & sustainability
▪ Redefined & streamlined roles and responsibilities
▪ Prioritized categories based on their potential and ease of implementation
▪ Built category strategies
▪ Developed & introduced BUYER approach
▪ Developed savings tracking methodology
▪ Introduced procurement levers (should cost, demand mgmt. etc.)
▪ Implemented quick wins
3
Diagnosis Prioritization &Alignment
Implementation Change Management
▪ Developed training programs
▪ Report realized savings (P&L)
▪ Monitored execution performance and ensure optimization
▪ Corrective actions in case of under-performance
▪ Updated policy & procedures
We followed a structured project management methodology for
Category Management implementation
We analyzed ~200k PO lines, from multiple sources and developed
spend visibility through Spend Cube
4
Cristal KSA
Tasnee spend
baseline
categorization
(L1 to L4)
Downstream3
Cristal International
At region level detail
TPC
At BU level detail
At BU level detail
Spend baseline
▪ Raw spend data collected across different systems, +10
different parties and 5 continents
▪ Sanity checks conducted rigorously and findings
compared with information in different sources
▪ Spend baseline with different components determined
Aggregation and categorization
▪ Data aggregation/standardization conducted (>200k line
items standardized)
▪ Standardized and aggregated data categorized from L1 to
L4 levels
Finance Dept’s1 Procurement Dept’s2
Tasnee 2014 spend baseline
Procurement spend
Clean-up and stress test of raw data
Additional raw material and chemicals spend
Other costs
Category execution strategies were prioritized based on annual spend
& ease of implementation
5
3.0
1,755
2.90.4 2.5
110
1,765
2.20.7 3.20.6 4.50.3 3.42.0 3.32.62.10.8 2.30.5 3.12.82.72.4
1,760
4.2
35
30
4.03.93.8
10
4.8
60
4.43.73.63.5 4.74.3
15
4.1 5.0
0
4.6
5
25
20
4.9
75
50
40
90
80
65
45
85
55
105
70
0.9
Road
Processing Equipment And Spares
Additives
Filtration
Power Transmission & Bearing (Ptb)
Hvac
Electronics And InstrumentationWater Treatment Chemicals
Construction And Installation
Resins
Pipes, Valves & Fittings
Industrial And Calibration Gases
Hardware & Fasteners
Material Handling Supplies
Process Chemicals
Electrical
Industrial Supplies
Building Supplies
Engineering And Design Services
Pumps & Pump Kits
Material Handling
Laboratory Equipment & Supplies
Annual spend2014 SAR Mn
Packaging Supplies
Water
3Rd Party Logistics (3Pl)
Fabrication
Warehousing
Waste Management
Maintenance Services
Equipment Rental
Hr Services
Other Professional Services
Equipment Maintenance And Repair
Office Supplies
Pallets
It Software
Building Repair And Construction
Safety Supplies
Refractories
Consulting
Facility services
Compensation Or Benefits
It Services
Freight Forwarding
Customs Brokerage Service
It Hardware
Low Medium High
Wave 4-5, long tailWave 2-3Pilot – Wave 1
Ease of capture1
Re-designed our organization around Category Management for
maximum operational performance & value creation
Business Partner
– Ti
Business Partner
– Petchem
Business Partner
– DS
Projects
Industrial
Business
APAC
South America
North America
Europe
Analysis and
KPIs
Policies and
Procedures
Supplier
Performance
Management
Central
Procurement
KSA
Procurement
Raw materials &
Packaging
Services &
Projects
International
Procurement
Center of
Excellence
Transactions
Class C
Class A
Class B
MRO +
Consumables
Chemical
Permit
Custom
Clearance
Freight
forwarding
Exemptions
Inbound logistics
6
▪ Implement and Track contract progress, compliance, and financial results
▪ Take corrective actions in case of under-performance
▪ Manage supplier performance
▪ Identify future value improvement potential
▪ Finalize implementation plans
▪ Design and float RFP / Conduct sourcing event
▪ Execute process improvement ideas
▪ Negotiate with current and potential suppliers
▪ Finalize contract with legal
▪ Develop KPI metrics and build into contracts
▪ Sign contract
▪ Select focus areas based on preliminary hypotheses
▪ Develop work-plans
▪ Develop and quantify improvement ideas, using analytics and creativity methods
▪ Further engage users and conduct idea generation workshop
▪ Evaluate and prioritize improvement ideas
– Assess opportunities and risks
– Quantify financial impact
▪ Develop new category/supplier strategy
▪ Finalize scope and specifications
▪ Develop implementation plans to execute category strategy
▪ Drive approval process
▪ Build baseline– Build spend database – Understand future
demand (volume and needs)
– Analyze current contracts
– Identify key stakeholders
– Develop cost break downs
– Assess TCO
▪ Understand supply markets
– Understand market dynamics
– Profile current and potential suppliers
▪ Engage legal team
▪ Define objectives and preliminary scope of work
▪ Define governance structure
▪ Identify cross-functional team and hold kickoff
▪ Agree on timeline and next steps
▪ Assign category board
Execute ReviewYield measures
Understand
Build Baseline
Create category strategy
Managecontracts
Manage contracts & category
performance
Understandsupply
markets
Implement strategy internally
Negotiate with suppliers
Set up team &governance
Selectfocusareas
Identify potential and develop ideas
Syndicate and refine measures
Engagestake-
holders
Build
BUYER approach has helped us in realizing the value of Category
Management
7
Realizing a measure takes 5-stage¹ approval process to ensure
sustainability and P&L reflection
Implement-ation Level
▪ Initiatives identified and described, incl. rough estimation of run-rate EBIT potential
▪ Measure fully evaluated and ready for approval
▪ Measureendorsed by all relevant stakeholders
▪ Measure operationally implementedand successconfirmed by line management
▪ Financial realization of impactagainst baseline of 2014 confirmed by finance
▪ PMO Member
▪ Line responsible
▪ Or TEP Steering Committee
▪ Business Owner
▪ CFO▪ Workstream Leader
Description
Responsible
IL5
Target
IL2IL1 IL3 IL4
1 Improvement value on the diagnostic baseline year of 2014
Measure
Identified
Measure
Evaluated
Measure
Approved
Measure
Implemented1
Measure
Realized
IL6
Measure Banked
▪ Financial realization of impactin actual P&L –Current margin and volume confirmed by finance
8
The value realization roadmap had 3 horizons towards sustainable
operational excellence and impact
Timeline
Key
activities
Target
Impact
(IL4)
Create basic transparency,
design the journey,
prioritize quick wins and pilot
first categories
Implementation
and impact capturing while
upgrading procurement
processes
Sustainability and
continuous improvement
~3 months ~ 11-12 months
▪ Implement Pilot Wave of
category management
▪ Design target state processes
and KPIs
▪ Implement quick wins
▪ Implement Wave 1 and 2 of
category management
▪ Harmonize processes across
entities
▪ Commence system
integration
25-50 155-310 30-40
▪ Complete implementation of
processes / remaining Waves
of category management
▪ Monitor performance and
ensure optimization
25-50 180-360 ~210-~400
Per Wave
Cumulative
3 months and beyond
9
Appendix
10
We diagnosed multiple high spend categories & came up with our
recommendations to increase savings & sustainability
Spares Inventory
Optimization
▪ ~ 15% potential duplicates identified▪ Multiple items are kept in same bin location▪ Identified opportunities to reduce inventory carrying
cost by ~ 15-20 % YoY▪ Opportunity to reduce max. stock level by optimizing
safety stock, re-order point & delivery time by 10-12%▪ Shelf life items are kept outside temperature
controlled area▪ Non-moving stock value and count is growing YoY
What we foundWorkstream
▪ Conduct data cleansing & eliminate duplicates▪ Link cleansed data with eBOM▪ Optimize data governance solution for keeping the data
clean and green▪ Improve warehouse utilization and decrease cost of
operations▪ Inventory Strategy optimization for slow moving, non-
moving items against criticality A and B
What do we need to do
Logistics and
Freight
Raw Material and
Packaging Cost
Optimization
Contracts
▪ Improper utilization of contracts▪ Price optimization opportunity▪ Manpower qualification issues▪ Planning issues
▪ Reduce price through supplier negotiations, buy or rent option
▪ Optimize and ensure proper contract utilization▪ Work with end users to create manpower
qualification criteria▪ Optimization through proper planning
▪ Successful test trials were conducted for FFS bags in HDPE, however they were un-successful in LDPE
▪ Supplier not aligned with the trial process for FFS bags
▪ Carbon Black MB is under study with technical team with 80% completion
▪ Standardize & optimize packaging specifications▪ Conduct trails & identify alternate suppliers for
identified RM▪ Keep Carbon Black MB project with technical team
▪ Baselining gaps▪ No economy of scale due to fragmented Spend▪ Dynamic Fluctuating Market/Prices▪ Container/Equipment shortage
▪ Develop total Cost of Ownership (TCO) approach▪ Scope consolidation▪ Identify cost Levers & contract compliance▪ Understand capability matrix of service providers
11
Total
Spares InventoryOptimization
Logistics & Freight
RM & Packaging
Cost Optimization
Contracts
450
906
269
123
64
40 - 60+
25 - 30
10 - 15
5 - 10
80 – 110 +
Minimize inventory without compromising on reliability & eliminate obsolete stocks, standardization & increase spares availability based on asset integrity
Minimize cost & supply risk for logistics through benchmarking & identifying new solution and alternate suppliers
Develop sustainable raw material supply & reduce risk through reviewing TCO for RM materials & identify cost reduction opportunities
Optimize and ensure proper utilization by reviewing ARCs and evaluating the effectiveness and utilization of current contracts
Workstream Description Spend Savings
A detailed spend analysis was conducted on selected categories
for implementation prioritization
Category Expected Saving¹
13
12
Progress Next Steps
Lo
gis
tic
s a
nd
Fre
igh
t
Ocean Freight
Integrated
Supply Chain
Inbound FFD
Total
1
2
28
Spend¹
Strategic Storage
Movement
121
127
13
9
270
Current Status
The implementation progress was monitored in close co-ordination
with category management team (1/4)
1. In SAR M
▪ ITP signed with all shipping
lines
▪ 2 years contract renewal
under Progress. Awaited
FFD’s confirmation
▪ Contract signed with all FFD
except JAS
▪ Obtaining management
approval on the award
recommendation
• Savings under Monitoring and
reporting on Monthly basis
• Contract renewal - Executive
Summary preparation is in
progress
• Savings to be monitored and
reported on Monthly/quarterly
basis
• Contract execution and
monitoring saving
12
The implementation progress was monitored in close co-ordination
with category management team (2/4)
Category Expected Saving¹
7
1
Progress Next Steps
RM
& P
ac
ka
gin
g C
os
t O
pti
miz
ati
on
Lower thickness
for FFs bags
Total
1
1.3
12.6
Spend¹
72
6
123
Current Status
▪ Samples have been
approved & now we are
awaiting customer
feedback
▪ Under feasibility study
▪ Prepare for the plant trail
and procure trial quantity
▪ New Preblen-A recipe is
approved
▪ Successfully conducted
trial for Carbon Black with
small quantities
▪ Initiate the bidding
process for the lower
thickness and glue less
FFS bags
▪ Share the findings with
the broader team
▪ Conduct plant trails for
LDPE
▪ Initiate the bidding
process
▪ Re examine the
process with bulk
quantities
Glue-less FFs
bags
PAL²
Concentrated Peroxides in LDPE
New Preblen-A recipe in HDPE
Carbon Black in Bulk – HDPE
1
1.3
6
5
34
1. In SAR M
2. PAL (Propionaldehyde), is a byproduct from oxidation of catalyst. Idea here is to examine the possibility of making commercial grade PAL to be used for LDPE plant 13
The implementation progress was monitored in close co-ordination
with category management team (3/4)
Category Expected Saving¹
1
1
Progress Next Steps
Co
ntr
ac
ts
Fabrication
Total
1
1
7
Spend¹
22
16
5
4
64
Current Status
▪ Obtained welding machine &
crew prices from contractors
▪ New rates were received and
compared for manpower
services
▪ Signed NDAs with third party
crane contractors
▪ Evaluated the manpower
utilization in HVAC category
▪ Negotiated the prices with
current contractors & invited 3rd
party contractor to explore
other methods of Hydrojeting
to achieve cost savings
▪ Obtained most purchased
MRO items list from contractor
and shared with MRO team
• Compare buy versus hire
scenarios in welding machines
• Award Manpower contract to 3
contractors. Potential savings is
obtained if only lowest bidder is
awarded
• Conduct third party site survey for
Crane usage optimization
• Negotiate with contractor and end
user for 8hr. daily usage v/s
existing 10 hrs. usage
• Waiting for third party proposal for
Hydrojeting services for
optimization / potential cost
savings
• Awaiting MRO recommendations
for the most shared item list for
street buying
Manpower
Crane
HVAC
Hydro jetting &
Hydrokinetic
Street Buying
13
4
2
1
1. In SAR M 14
Category Expected Saving¹ Progress Next StepsSpend¹ Current Status
Sp
are
s In
ve
nto
ry O
pti
miz
ati
on
• Assessment of project is
completed (Phase 1)
• Consultant submitted the
technical and commercial
proposal for review
• Phase 2, technical &
commercial evaluated &
finalized
• Negotiate further
discount
• Alignment and
approval from
management on
Phase 2
execution
The implementation progress was monitored in close co-ordination
with category management team (4/4)
~ 45
1. In SAR M
Total Inventory
Value
Total Yearly
Spend
> 500
~ 200
15
Thank You
16