Dr Judith Audin, researcher, CEFC Hong Kong, chief editor of ......Shanghai Gone: Domicide and...

CEFC, 20/F, Wanchai Central Building, 89 Lockhart Road, Wanchai, Hong Kong

Tel: 852 2876 6910 Fax: 852 2815 3211 Email: [email protected] Website: http://www.cefc.com.hk

1

DrJudithAudin,researcher,CEFCHongKong,chiefeditorofChinaPerspectivesDrKatianaLeMentec,researcher,CNRS,CCJ(CNRS/EHESS/UdP)

Callforabstractsforapanel(EACS2020,25-29!!"#"$%&’(’( !!"##$%&’$"()*’"+*! !!"#$%!publicationproject!(!"#$%&’()*+(,-#.(*!"#$#%&

Rubbles,Ruins!"#$! !"#$%#&$’!"#$%&!!"#! !"#$%&’($#

!"#$%&’()# !"#$%&’()*+!(,-#

!"#$%&’( )’*+",&-&’.&/’0&1%’23&4-’",’1,’151,63,&6’71881’9"::1#&;’73,#’?’@$6",;’A&B&45&%’CD(EF’

!"#$%&"’(%)&!"#$%&%’%()!"#$!#%&!’(!"#$%! !!"#$%"&’()%*+*,# -.!"+/#0*%(#!"#$%&’()%’’*+ ,!*+

!"#!$%&’(#")*+’)%!"#$%&’()*+,-,*%&-*&!"#$%-!"#$%&! ! !"#$%$"&’#!! !!"#$%&’()*+"&,-%.,*+/-,’(*%

!"# $"%&"!!’(# )*+,-+(&.#!"#$ !%!"#&"’#$ ()’*’$ +!,- ! ! !" ! !"#$%&’( ’)")*’( %+! !"#$%&’"$! ! !" e

familiarstrangenessofChineseurbanrubblesandruinationspaceshasbeenmostlylooked

uponas“ruinscapes.”Yetthetopicdeservestobestudiedthroughotherangles,especially

focusingon!!"#$!"#!$"%&’()*&+&’,%)’-.#/%!/)0+&0&’,%120(%!$)0"1!

! !"#$!"#$%&’()*!"#$%! !"# $% $!’()#!"#!$#%&’%$( )#( %*$( +)$,-.( "+(!"#$!"#$%&’( )*+( ,-.,/0(

!"#!$%&’( ! !"#$ !%&’()*&)+%*! !!"#$ %&’()#$ ’(*$Webster 2013; Ren 2014; Sorace and Hurst

2015;WoodworthandWallace2017),andvisual!"#$%&!!!"#$%&’()! !"!"#$%%&-Nicolau2015).

Urban exploration – the visit and documentation of derelict man-!"#$% &’()*’)($&% "+#%

!"!#$%#&$’()!*&+’–!!"#$%!"#"$%&"!!!"#!"#"$%&’"(!)!!"#$%"&’%()#$*!(%+,&$()&)!(-.$’(+/)-0&!!"#

social sciences (Garrett 2014a, 2014b; Offenstadt 2018). This alternative approach has!

!"#$%&’()%*(+’,#’!"#!$%&’%()*"+,-*.("%(+)/$’-(0)1*%)’$0,)%,)’--(00)"(2)#!($+0),#)3",2$(+4()



!

and offer a critical understanding of the Chinese city (Lam 2013b; Audin 2018). In the

Chinesecase,existingstudiesonabandonedplacesandspacestendtoexceptionalize!"#$%&

!"#$%!" #$$%" ! !"#$%"&’()*! !"#$%&’() *+,-. , to romanticize them as aesthetic objects (Wu

2012; !"#$%%&-!"#$%&’( )*+,-( !"#$%&%’%#(#$)*+ ,-./0!" #$! !" ! consider them as specific

landscapes : “ruinscape”. This last term refers, like "landscape", to a subjective social!"#$%&’!%("#) *"$%+,)!""#$%!&’(! !"# $%&’()*+$+! of perception! !"#$%$&’()* +,-,.* /01#)2&*

!""#$ !"!"#$% &’((% )*+% ’,$-+’&-$% $../$% -*% 0*% ,.1*23%!"#$!"#!$%&’(!"#$%&’()* +)!,! !"# $%&’%#!"

explore ethno-sociological processes at play in these peculiar places, taking into full

!"#$%&’()*%"#+!"#$%&’()#*+!,$&-$!"#+.$!"#$%&"’%-!"#!$!%&’($)!"#$%&$’!

!"#"$%& "!"#$#%&’( &""$)&%*+,(!"#$% &’(#$)% *+$,*-% .(%!"#$%&’("#) *&&!$&) +,)!"#$%&’"()(*+

!"#$%&%’()#$&’*!")’+,-./’!"#$%&’()’*+,-./!"#$%&’()("*’"+,)-*.*-"-%’/)0/+"1*/2"3".%-&+"%’the

wayslocalcommunitiesinteractwithruinedspaces.Ethnographicexplorationsparticipatein

acriticalunderstandingofurbandevelopmentbyhighlightingeconomic,political,!"#$#%&"’$()

!"#$%&! !"#$ %&’(&)!’$ *)+%,--,-$ ,./,##,#$ 0"$ (1,!"# !"#$%&!" #$%&" ’%$()*+" ,-./" 0&1/$)$*$2+"

!""#$! !!"#!$%&’#!"!()*+*#,-#!"#$!"# !"#$"%’&"!"#$%&"’(!"#!$ ! !!"#$%&$’(use,think,andshape

!"!#$%#&$’%(’$&(&)*+,!!"#$%! !"#$%&" ’()*+,(-"(./"01%,(-"%1.)*2)0"13"(4(./1.’*.) !stimulate

socio-cultural creativity and adaptation. Hence, considering the ubiquity and the various

forms of abandoned place! ! !"#$ %&’!"$ &%’’()! ! !"# $%!"&’# ()%"*+,&-%!.# /)01!"#! !"#$ !"#$!

!"#$"%&’()*+!"#$ "!%&$ ’!"(%)*+)$ "!$! !"#$%&!’(’)* +,-"(* ./#* (01!* !"#$%"&’ %(’!"#$ %’($ )%$

! !"#$%&%’%()*%+*,&-./*-!0*"/$$1"%$)2*!"#$%&’()*+,%+#$!"#$%&’(")*+,!-.)/,0+!"),+(’#/1+’)2,+’!+

!"#$%#$%& ’()&$*+& ,*"-,*.)#/*-& ’$&0’+!!"#$!%#"&&’()*)+,%$(-% .+".!+%)(*+/$#*%0)*1% /’22!+,3%

!"#"$%&’()*%$!%+,-.(/+!(/)/+!0+"!(-1/&"-(%+(*#)/+(23%+/4

To examine dereliction and ruination, one has to fully consider spatiality and temporality

(Augé 2003; Garrett 2011). We invite potential contributors to !"# $%%"&%’("# %)# %*"+"!

!"#$!"%&’("$!!! !" !!"#$%#&’!!"#$%!&$"&’( )*(+!’!&)*’( ,*)-./01(!"#$%&’(% )$$!%#&*"+,-% -.&/"&!"/"$-

wheninteractingwithsituatedprocessesofurbandecay,rubbles,abandonment,disrepairor

failedarchitecture?!Ethnographiesmayrelyonpeoplefamiliarwiththeseplacesbeforetheir

ruination state orwho appropriate them durably or temporarily after they entered in the

stageoftransformation.Theanalysescanexploreissuesofmemoryandnostalgia,orother

affects such as fear, revulsion, fascination, indifference…. Exploring the processes of

vanishing, aswell as the presence (or absence)! !"# $%&’()# *+,-./0%1# 23456#!"#$ %&’&"(! !"#$

!"#!$" ! !" !"#"$%! !"#$#% $&’(#$! !"#$ %&’()! trajectoriesof decline. Ethnographic contributions

can focus on social representations of derelict buildings and urban ruins (myths, legends,

ghost stories or rumours). !"#$ !"#$%&’ #"(!)*+#)$"(’ ",’!"#$%&%’! !"#$%&’()!”might also be



3

stimulatingtoexplore:howthevisualspaceofruinsandrubblescanbeseenasavaluable,

legitimate,orstigmatized“landscape”byvarioussocialgroups.!"#$#%&’! !!"#$"%&’$!"#$%&!’

!"#$#%&’%($&()$%*+,&),$-$+.%!"#$%$&!!"#$%&’(")$&$!%*$"+’%,"-+.’,-$+/.’!0%#/! !"!"#$%&’#(’)*+$,#

!"#"$!%&’()’*"%+,)"’-.$&2012),resistance(Ho2013),andresilience(ValeandCampanella

2015) in Chinese cities can shed light on the social processes behind! !"#"$%&’(!"#$!!!

!"#$%&’($"%)*+,-! !"#$%!"#$%& "’! !"# ! !"#$%& “afterlife”of such spaces.! !"#$ !"#$% !#’()*("+!

!"#$%&’($)* $"* +(#,-./* 12.!)34* .#5* +(#,-./* !"--(#&$&)36*!"#$%&’ (")’ *%+),’ -./’ 0-1’

!"#$%&"’()*!)+*(,"*-."*&/*(.!001%$/$*23(+$4*2/’+*23(!"#$%&’()%#*$#+!’!"#$%&’"’()&$!&*)+)*)%,$)"$

!"#$ -!"!#$%#&$’ %(’ )!*+-!"#$%&’("!) *"&+(,$-.($$!’/) !"# $!%# &$’(#!"!#$ !"#$%&’! !"#$

!"!#$%!&’(&)*+,$&-.*)/0’)&123456&(7’%&*7#/!#!&/8!9/7$0&:"$&7,/8!’&$7!&%*>/8?&*&

!"#"$%&’()&’*&+,-.//"$%!!"#$%&’#$()&*$!!"#$ !"#$%&!"’$!"#$%!"!"#$%&’(")’"*&+’,-$&./+)’0!"# !"#

!"#$%&’( )#"*+%*,-(of specific social groups turn suchplaces intomarginal, socially invisible

placesforothers(HuangandYi2015)?

!"#$%&’()*%+)*,-.)$%,-(/0#12/#-($%#(%$-,#’*%$,#)(,)$%$"-+#(3%’%$/0-(3%)/"(-30’&"#,%’(3*)%-(%

!"#$%&"!’%()&$#$%*+%,*&-.$/,(&$%*&*,",.’/0!’.*’%1(&’%&!"##$%$&’()*"&$+$(,-&’$.’+!!although!

!"#$%&’($ )*+,-$ .’//$0#$*($ !"#$1234$ .#$ .#/+*%#$+&-#$ -!,5’#-$!"volving !"#$%&"#$’% ()*)"’%

and!"# !"#$"%&!"

!"#$% ’()# *+,)()-,).# *+# /%*+*+0#!"#$!!"#$%&’&’!!"#$%& "#’()*!!"#$%&’()*+!),-$%.,/#*!$!" !!"#$

!"#$%&’(!"#$%&’()*+(,-#.(*!"#$%&’%"’%()!!"#$#%&"and!!"#!$%&’!()*+,#-.’/%0!!"#$%&%!"#$%&!"# !

!"#$%&"’!%’$ (")&!!!"#$%"#%&!’($)*%&*$+,-.(&’/$0+!"(1!!"# ! !"#!"#$%&’(%)*!"#$%"&’(")*+(’(,+(-"

!"#$!"#$%#&$"%’!!"#$%&!%!"#$%&’!#(!’!)’!(* !!"#$%!"#$!"##"$%&’(%&!")*+,%"&!!"#$%&’#()#)*!(+!%#

!"#$%&"$’!

¥ disciplinaryfield.sofresearch

¥ domain/objectofresearch

¥ methodologicalandtheoreticalapproach

¥ dates,durationandplaceoffieldwork

¥ socialcharacteristics/groupsofpeopleinterviewed/observed(approximatenumber)

¥ contextofthecasestudy(whichspace,contextofruination,…)

!"#$%& #%’#’(")(& (*’+),& -$& ($./&!" ! !"#$%& ’(& !"#$%&’()*(+(,-+./ ! !"#$

!"#$"%"&’(’%#’)*+,-#-%("$&.)-( !

!"#$%&’$!!"#!#$%&$’!"#$%&’$()*’+$!"#$#%’(#)$!" !!"#$%&’ ()’*+,+-.+/’0)12 !!"#"$%#&!"%’"(#

!"#$%&%’"($)*$+*$,-*’"(-.*/%..*0-*(+$%1%-2*03*!"#$%&$’(")*)*!"#!"#$%&"’#()’’#*"#+",)-."+"/#0



!

!"#"$"%&"’

AUDIN, Judith. 2018. “Beneath the Surface of Chinese Cities: Abandoned Places and

Contemporary Ruins,” translated by Oliver Waine. GHI%323:"I"J$&-. 28 September 2018,

https://www.metropolitiques.eu/Beneath-the-Surface-of-Chinese-Cities-Abandoned-Places-

and-Contemporary-Ruins.html(accessedon29November2019).

!"#$%&’()*+!""#$%!"#$"%&’#"(#)*+("’,#!"#$%&’(")$)*+,

!"#$#%&’()*"++,-*./0/-*&12+3,+425+*67*89:;9



!

!"#$%&’$()*+, -./)/0%*#.1, 2%/’, 3.&(*!" #$%" %&’’()*+*&,-." /)+-’0+*&,-" +-1! !"#$%-!"#$"%’

!"#$%&!’()#"*+*,*#!(-+%.&/!%"0(*1(23/4&5*+36

!"#$% &’()*% +,-.*%!"#$%"#&’ ()$*+’ ,)-&.&/*’ #$/’ ,*0$.*’ &$’ #’ 1"&$*2*’ 3*%!"#$%!"!"#$"%&’

!"#$%&’(’)*++,-.*-,/0

!"#$% &’()(*+% ,-./+% 012(% 345*6*785% "7494:;% 4)% 89% !’*9?@% !(A(B(54C*9D% E289D28*+F%

!"#$%"’("&)*+(,%"&)*(-*.%/&"*&"0*1$2’("&)*1$3$&%45!!"#!$%&’("’-!"#

!"#$%&’ %()*+’!"#$%$&’( )*$&+,( -./"%$0"&1#( $&( 2"34$5"%+4$#06(!"#$%&’()*+ %,-+ .$/&’0+ 1$&($2"!"

!"#$%&’(!")*(+,-.*#/-01(2#*//3

!"#$%&’() *+,-.) /012.) !"#$%& ’(%()$& #*& ’"(+,-& .")& /%#01& #*& ’(%()$& 2(%"#3%& 4)#56)& (+& %")&

!"#$%&’()"’*(+",-$.*/%(0"-1*#2 !"#$%&$%’"()&"*$$+,!

!"#$%&’( %)*+,-+./’( ./0( 1+22+.3( 45#!67( 89:;7( )./!"#$ %&’()*+(!*")$ (),$ !-.$

!"#$%&%’()%*)+$%,#)-.#./,01)!"#$%&’(")(*"%+,-."$&$/(012&!" !! !"!"# -!!"

!"#$%&’()’*+ ,-./012+ 34+ 56784+ 9%/1+ %:;1+ ?/1+ %:;1+ C0.0=.D+ -=+ E/-=0FB+

!"#$%& ’(%()$*&!" ! !"#$%%&’ ()&*%+,-.’ /0--&1’ ("%-&%+2)*’ 3&4#565’!"#$%&’(() *&+! !"##$%&&’(

!"#$%&’()#*+,-%.-/(01-($2-3+,*’+-*$-4%$"+5)%’(’6-4#*$(!"#$%"&’()*"+$(,-.-/!

!"#$%’!"#$%&’$()*+%,!"#$%&’%()**%"#+,,-"#!"#$%#&’(’#)*$+’*,-$./0$1/2#3)$+’*’#&$%#4/5#3$

!"#$%&’()(*+"!"#$%!"#$%&’()"#*&+,-./#0-12&3#/004

!""#!"$%&’( )*+( #,’( *-.( /0102 !" #$" %#&’()" *+,-$" ./00123" 4567879" :;

Dr Judith Audin, researcher, CEFC Hong Kong, chief editor of ......Shanghai Gone: Domicide and...

Documents

Transcript of Dr Judith Audin, researcher, CEFC Hong Kong, chief editor of ......Shanghai Gone: Domicide and...